Using the Zelen design in randomized controlled trials: Debates and controversies

Journal of Advanced Nursing

Volumn 38, Issue 2, 2002, Pages 200-207

  Homer, Caroline S E ^a,b  

^a ST GEORGE HOSPITAL   (Australia)

^b UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY SYDNEY   (Australia)

Author keywords

Clinical research; Consent; Methodology; Midwifery; Nursing; Randomized controlled trial; Zelen research design

Indexed keywords

CLINICAL TRIAL; CONTROLLED CLINICAL TRIAL; EPIDEMIOLOGY; HUMAN; INFORMED CONSENT; INTERPERSONAL COMMUNICATION; LEGAL ASPECT; MEDICAL ETHICS; METHODOLOGY; MIDWIFE; MODEL; NEW ZEALAND; NURSE MIDWIFE; NURSING EVALUATION RESEARCH; ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT; PATIENT ADVOCACY; PATIENT SELECTION; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL; REVIEW; STANDARD; TIME;

ETHICS, NURSING; HUMANS; INFORMED CONSENT; MIDWIFERY; MODELS, NURSING; NEW ZEALAND; NURSE MIDWIVES; NURSING EVALUATION RESEARCH; PATIENT ADVOCACY; PATIENT SELECTION; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS; RESEARCH DESIGN; SELECTION BIAS; TIME FACTORS; TRUTH DISCLOSURE;

EID: 0036547005     PISSN: 03092402     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1046/j.1365-2648.2002.02164.x     Document Type: Article

References (43)

1. Acts of the UK Parliament (1998) Data Protection Act. Chapter 29. Queen's Publisher, London.
2. Allmark P. (1999) Should Zelen pre-randomised consent designs be used in some neonatal trials? Journal of Medical Ethics 25, 325-329.
3. Anbar D. (1983) The relative efficiency of Zelen's pre-randomisation design for clinical trials. Biometrics 39, 711-718.
4. Anonymous (1995) Your baby is in a trial [editorial]. Lancet 345, 805-806.
5. Bartlett R.H., Roloff D.W., Cornell R.G., Andrews A.F., Dillon O.W. & Zwischenberger S.B. (1985) Extracorporeal circulation in neonatal respiratory failure: a prospective randomised trial. Pediatrics 76, 479-487.
6. Bradley C. (1993) Designing medical and educational studies. Diabetes Care 16, 509-518.
7. Chang R.W., Falconer J. & Stullberg S.D. (1990) Prerandomization: an alternative to classic randomisation. The effects on recruitment in a controlled trial of arthroscopy for osteoarthrosis of the knee. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery 72A, 1451-1455.
8. Cherkin D.C., Deyo R.A., Street J.H., Hunt M. & Barlow W. (1996) Pitfalls of patient education: limited success of a program for back pain in primary care. Spine 21, 345-355.
9. Cogan R. & Spinnato J.A. (1988) Social support during premature labour: effects on labour and the newborn. Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics and Gynaecology 8, 209-216.
10. Day P., Sullivan E.A., Ford J. & Lancaster P. (1999) Australia's Mothers and Babies 1997. AIHW National Perinatal Statistics Unit, Sydney.
11. Dennis M. (1997) Commentary: why we didn't ask patients for their consent. British Medical Journal 314, 1077.
12. Dennis M., O'Rourke S., Slattery J., Staniforth T. & Warlow C. (1997) Evaluation of a stroke family care worker: results of a randomised controlled trial. British Medical Journal 314, 1071-1076.
13. Ellenberg S.S. (1984) Randomisation designs in comparative clinical trials. New England Journal of Medicine 310, 1404-1408.
14. Ellenberg S.S. (1992) Randomized consent designs in comparative clinical trials: an update [letter]. Statistics in Medicine 11, 131-132.
15. Fisher B., Bauer M. & Margolese R. (1985) Five year results of a randomised controlled trial comparing total mastectomy and segmental mastectomy with or without radiation in the treatment of breast cancer. New England Journal of Medicine 321, 665-673.
16. Flint C., Poulengeris P. & Grant A. (1989) The 'Know Your Midwife' scheme - a randomised trial of continuity of care by a team of midwives. Midwifery 5, 11-16.
17. Hartnoll R.L., Mitcheson M.C., Battersby A., Brown G., Ellis M. & Fleming P. (1980) Evaluation of heroin maintenance in a controlled trial. Archives of General Psychiatry 37, 877-884.
18. Hemminki E., Virta A.L., Koponen P., Malin M., Kojo-Austin H. & Tuimala R. (1990) A trial of continuous human support during labour: feasibility, interventions and mothers' satisfaction (trial A -pilot study with volunteered midwifery students). Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics and Gynaecology 11, 239-250.
19. Homer C.S.E., Davis G.K. & Brodie P. (2000) What do women feel about community-based antenatal care? Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health 24, 590-595.
20. Homer C.S.E., Davis G.K., Brodie P.M., Sheehan A., Barclay L.M., Wills J. & Chapman M.G. (2001a) Collaboration in maternity care: a randomised controlled trial comparing community-based continuity of care with standard care. British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 108, 16-22.
21. Homer C.S.E., Matha D., Jordan L.G., Wills J. & Davis G.K. (2001b) Community-based continuity of midwifery care versus standard hospital care: a cost analysis. Australian Health Review 24, 85-93.
22. Hunninghake D.B. (1987) Summary conclusions. Controlled Clinical Trials 8 (Suppl. 4), 1S-5S.
23. Hunninghake D.B., Darby CA. & Probstfield J.E. (1987) Recruitment experience in clinical trials: Literature summary and annotated bibliography. Controlled Clinical Trials 8 (Suppl. 4), 6S-30S.
24. MacVicar J., Dobbie G., Owen-Johnstone L., Jagger C., Hopkins M. & Kennedy J. (1993) Simulated home delivery in hospital: a randomised controlled trial. British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 100, 316-323.
25. Marquis B. & Huston C. (1994) Management Decision Making for Nurses, 2nd edn. Lippincott, New York.
26. Mason S. (1997) Obtaining informed consent for neonatal randomised controlled trials - 'an elaborate ritual'? Archives of Diseases in Childhood 76, F143-F145.
27. Matts J. & McHugh R. (1987) Randomization and efficiency in Zelen's single-consent design. Biometrics 43, 885-894.
28. McLean S. (1997) Commentary: no consent means not treating the patient with respect. British Medical Journal 314, 1076-1077.
29. Meren J.G. (1995) Ethics of consent for babies in randomised clinical trials [letter]. Lancet 345, 1370.
30. Moertel C.G., Childs D.S. & O'Fallon J.R. (1984) Combined 5-fluoroouracil and radiation therapy as a surgical adjuvant for poor prognosis gastric carcinoma. Journal of Clinical Oncology 2, 1247-1254.
31. NSW Government (1998) Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act. NSW State Government, Sydney, www.austlii.edu.au/au/ legis/nsw/consol_act/papipa1998464.
32. O'Rourke P.P., Crone R.K. & Vacanti J.P. (1989) Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation and conventional medical therapy in neonates with persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn: a prospective randomised study. Pediatrics 84, 957-963.
33. Schellings R., Kessels A.G.H., van Riet G. & Sturmans F. (1999) The Zelen design may be the best choice for a heroin-provision experiment. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 52, 503-507.
34. Snowden C., Elbourne D. & Garcia J. (1998) Zelen randomisation: Attitudes of parents participating in a neonatal clinical trial. Controlled Clinical Trials 20, 149-171.
35. Snowden C., Garcia J. & Elbourne D. (1997) Making sense of randomization: responses of parents of critically ill babies to random allocation of treatment in a clinical trial. Social Science and Medicine 45, 1337-1355.
36. Steiner A., Walsh B., Pickering R.M., Wiles R., Ward J. & Brooking J.I. (2001) Therapeutic nursing or blocking beds? A randomised controlled trial of a post acute immediate care unit. British Medical Journal 322, 453-460.
37. Stirrat G.M., Farndon J., Farrow S.C. & Dwyer N. (1992) The challenge of evaluating surgical procedures. Annals of the Royal College of Surgeons England 74, 84.
38. Thong Y.H. & Harth S.C. (1991) The social filter of informed consent in clinical research. Pediatrics 87, 568-569.
39. Tobias J.S. & Souhami R.L. (1993) Fully informed consent can be needlessly cruel. British Medical Journal 307, 1199-1201.
40. UK Collaborative Trial Group (1996) UK collaborative randomised trial of neonatal extra-corporal membrane oxygenation. Lancet 348, 75-82.
41. Zelen M. (1979) A new design for randomized controlled trials. New England Journal of Medicine 300, 1242-1245.
42. Zelen M. (1990) Strategy and alternative designs for clinical trials: an update. Statistics in Medicine 9, 645-656.
43. Zelen M. (1992) Randomised controlled trials [letter]. Lancet 340, 375.