The key role of extinction learning in anxiety disorders: Behavioral strategies to enhance exposure-based treatments

Current Opinion in Psychiatry

Volumn 29, Issue 1, 2016, Pages 39-47

  Pittig, Andre ^a   Van Den Berg, Linda ^a   Vervliet, Bram ^b,c  

^a DRESDEN UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY   (Germany)

^b MASSACHUSETTS GENERAL HOSPITAL   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY OF LEUVEN   (Belgium)

Author keywords

Anxiety disorders; Enhancement strategies; Exposure therapy; Fear extinction; Inhibitory learning

Indexed keywords

ANXIETY DISORDER; BEHAVIOR THERAPY; CLINICAL PRACTICE; EXTINCTION LEARNING; HUMAN; LEARNING; MEMORY; MEMORY CONSOLIDATION; REVIEW; STIMULUS RESPONSE; THREAT; ANXIETY DISORDERS; FEAR; PSYCHOLOGY; REINFORCEMENT;

ANXIETY DISORDERS; EXTINCTION, PSYCHOLOGICAL; FEAR; HUMANS; MEMORY;

EID: 84952719200     PISSN: 09517367     EISSN: 14736578     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1097/YCO.0000000000000220     Document Type: Review

References (112)

1. Hofmann SG, Smits JAJ. Cognitive-behavioral therapy for adult anxiety disorders: a meta-analysis of randomized placebo-controlled trials. J Clin Psychiatry 2008; 69: 621-632.
2. Norton PJ, Price EC. A meta-analytic review of adult cognitive-behavioral treatment outcome across the anxiety disorders. J Nerv Ment Dis 2007; 195: 521-531.
3. Butler AC, Chapman JE, Forman EM, Beck AT. The empirical status of cognitive-behavioral therapy: a review of meta-analyses. Clin Psychol Rev 2006; 26: 17-31.
4. Arch JJ, Craske MG. First-line treatment: a critical appraisal of cognitive behavioral therapy developments and alternatives. Psychiatr Clin North Am 2009; 32: 525-547.
5. Kindt M. A behavioural neuroscience perspective on the aetiology and treatment of anxiety disorders. Behav Res Ther 2014; 62: 24-36.
6. Bouton ME. Context, ambiguity, and unlearning: sources of relapse after behavioral extinction. Biol Psychiatry 2002; 52: 976-986.
7. Eisenberg M, Kobilo T, Berman DE, Dudai Y. Stability of retrieved memory: inverse correlation with trace dominance. Science 2003; 301: 1102-1104.
8. Alfei JM, Monti RIF, Molina VA, et al. Prediction error and trace dominance determine the fate of fear memories after post-training manipulations. Learn Mem 2015; 22: 385-400.
9. Haaker J, Golkar A, Hermans D, Lonsdorf TB. A review on human reinstatement studies: an overview and methodological challenges. Learn Mem 2014; 21: 424-440.
10. Vervliet B, Baeyens F, Van den Bergh O, Hermans D. Extinction, generalization, and return of fear: a critical review of renewal research in humans. Biol Psychol 2013; 92: 51-58.
11. Quirk GJ. Memory for extinction of conditioned fear is long-lasting and persists following spontaneous recovery. Learn Mem 2002; 9: 402-407.
12. Vervliet B, Craske MG, Hermans D. Fear extinction and relapse: state of the art. Annu Rev Clin Psychol 2013; 9: 215-248.
13. Craske MG, Liao B, Vervliet B. Role of inhibition in exposure therapy. J Exp Psychopathol 2012; 3: 322-345.
14. Craske MG, Kircanski K, Zelikowsky M, et al. Optimizing inhibitory learning during exposure therapy. Behav Res Ther 2008; 46: 5-27.
15. Duits P, Cath DC, Lissek S, et al. Updated meta-analysis of classical fear conditioning in the anxiety disorders. Depress Anxiety 2015; 32: 239-253.
16. Milad MR, Rosenbaum BL, Simon NM. Neuroscience of fear extinction: implications for assessment and treatment of fear-based and anxiety related disorders. Behav Res Ther 2014; 62: 17-23.
17. Otto MW, Moshier SJ, Kinner DG, et al. De novo fear conditioning across diagnostic groups in the affective disorders: evidence for learning impairments. Behav Ther 2014; 45: 619-629.
18. Garfinkel SN, Abelson JL, King AP, et al. Impaired contextual modulation of memories in PTSD: an fMRI and psychophysiological study of extinction retention and fear renewal. J Neurosci 2014; 34: 13435-13443.
19. Acheson DT, Geyer MA, Baker DG, et al. Conditioned fear and extinction learning performance and its association with psychiatric symptoms in active duty marines. Psychoneuroendocrinology 2015; 51: 495-505.
20. Fullana MA, Cardoner N, Alonso P, et al. Brain regions related to fear extinction in obsessive-compulsive disorder and its relation to exposure therapy outcome: a morphometric study. Psychol Med 2014; 44: 845-856.
21. Lommen MJJ, Engelhard IM, Sijbrandij M, et al. Pretrauma individual differences in extinction learning predict posttraumatic stress. Behav Res Ther 2013; 51: 63-67.
22. Orr SP, Lasko NB, Macklin ML, et al. Predicting posttrauma stress symptoms from pretrauma psychophysiologic reactivity, personality traits and measures of psychopathology. Biol Mood Anxiety Disord 2012; 2: 8.
23. Vervliet B, Raes F. Criteria of validity in experimental psychopathology: application to models of anxiety and depression. Psychol Med 2012; 43: 2241-2244.
24. Dunsmoor JE, Paz R. Fear generalization and anxiety: behavioral and neural mechanisms. Biol Psychiatry 2015; 78: 336-343.
25. Dymond S, Dunsmoor JE, Vervliet B, et al. Fear generalization in humans: systematic review and implications for anxiety disorder research. Behav Ther 2014; 57: 1971-1977.
26. Vervliet B, Vansteenwegen D, Eelen P. Generalization of extinguished skin conductance responding in human fear conditioning. Learn Mem 2004; 11: 555-558.
27. Vervliet B, Vansteenwegen D, Baeyens F, et al. Return of fear in a human differential conditioning paradigm caused by a stimulus change after extinction. Behav Res Ther 2005; 43: 357-371.
28. Vervliet B, Kindt M, Vansteenwegen D, Hermans D. Fear generalization in humans: impact of prior nonfearful experiences. Behav Res Ther 2010; 48: 1078-1084.
29. Vervoort E, Vervliet B, Bennett M, Baeyens F. Generalization of human fear acquisition and extinction within a novel arbitrary stimulus category. PLoS One 2014; 9: e96569.
30. Barry TJ, Griffith JW, Vervliet B, Hermans D. The role of stimulus specificity and attention in the generalization of extinction. J Exp Psychopathol 2015; doi: 10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2014.11.010. [Epub ahead of print].
31. De Kleine RA, Hendriks G-J, Smits JAJ, et al. Prescriptive variables for Dcycloserine augmentation of exposure therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder. J Psychiatr Res 2014; 48: 40-46.
32. De Kleine RA, Smits JAJ, Hendriks GJ, et al. Extinction learning as a moderator of d-cycloserine efficacy for enhancing exposure therapy in posttraumatic stress disorder. J Anxiety Disord 2015; 34: 63-67.
33. Hofmann SG. D-cycloserine for treating anxiety disorders: making good exposures better and bad exposures worse. Depress Anxiety 2014; 31: 175-177.
34. Hofmann SG, Fang A, Gutner CA. Cognitive enhancers for the treatment of anxiety disorders. Restor Neurol Neurosci 2014; 32: 183-195.
35. Hofmann SG, Otto MW, Pollack MH, Smits JA. D-cycloserine augmentation of cognitive behavioral therapy for anxiety disorders: an update. Curr Psychiatry Rep 2015; 17: 532.
36. Marin M-F, Lonak SF, Milad MR. Augmentation of evidence-based psychotherapy for PTSD with cognitive enhancers. Curr Psychiatry Rep 2015; 17: 39.
37. McGuire JF, Lewin AB, Storch EA. Enhancing exposure therapy for anxiety disorders, obsessive-compulsive disorder and posttraumatic stress disorder. Expert Rev Neurother 2014; 14: 893-910.
38. Myskiw JC, Izquierdo I, Furini CRG. Modulation of the extinction of fear learning. Brain Res Bull 2014; 105: 61-69.
39. Rodrigues H, Figueira I, Lopes A, et al. Does D-cycloserine enhance exposure therapy for anxiety disorders in humans? A meta-analysis. PLoS One 2014; 9: e93519.
40. Singewald N, Schmuckermair C, Whittle N, et al. Pharmacology of cognitive enhancers for exposure-based therapy of fear, anxiety and trauma-related disorders. Pharmacol Ther 2015; 149: 150-190.
41. Peña DF, Childs JE, Willett S, et al. Vagus nerve stimulation enhances extinction of conditioned fear and modulates plasticity in the pathway from the ventromedial prefrontal cortex to the amygdala. Front Behav Neurosci 2014; 8: 327.
42. Rodriguez-Romaguera J, Do-Monte FH, Tanimura Y, et al. Enhancement of fear extinction with deep brain stimulation: evidence for medial orbitofrontal involvement. Neuropsychopharmacology 2015; 40: 1726-1733.
43. Marin M-F, Camprodon JA, Dougherty DD, Milad MR. Device-based brain stimulation to augment fear extinction: implications for PTSD treatment and beyond. Depress Anxiety 2014; 31: 269-278.
44. Graham BM, Callaghan BL, Richardson R. Bridging the gap: lessons we have learnt from the merging of psychology and psychiatry for the optimisation of treatments for emotional disorders. Behav Res Ther 2014; 62: 3-16.
45. Deacon BJ, Kemp JJ, Dixon LJ, et al. Maximizing the efficacy of interoceptive exposure by optimizing inhibitory learning: a randomized controlled trial. Behav Res Ther 2013; 51: 588-596.
46. Lovibond PF, Mitchell CJ, Minard E, et al. Safety behaviours preserve threat beliefs: protection from extinction of human fear conditioning by an avoidance response. Behav Res Ther 2009; 47: 716-720.
47. Culver NC, Vervliet B, Craske MG. Compound extinction: using the Rescorla-Wagner model to maximize exposure therapy effects for anxiety disorders. Clin Psychol Sci 2015; 3: 335-348.
48. Culver NC. Extinction-based processes for enhancing the effectiveness of exposure therapy. University of California, Los Angeles; 2013.
49. Shiban Y, Schelhorn I, Pauli P, Muehlberger A. Effect of combined multiple contexts and multiple stimuli exposure in spider phobia: a randomized clinical trial in virtual reality. Behav Res Ther 2015; 71: 45-53.
50. Bandarian-Balooch S, Neumann DL, Boschen MJ. Exposure treatment in multiple contexts attenuates return of fear via renewal in high spider fearful individuals. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry 2015; 47: 138-144.
51. Dunsmoor JE, Ahs F, Zielinski DJ, LaBar KS. Extinction in multiple virtual reality contexts diminishes fear reinstatement in humans. Neurobiol Learn Mem 2014; 113: 157-164.
52. Niles AN, Craske MG, Lieberman MD, Hur C. Affect labeling enhances exposure effectiveness for public speaking anxiety. Behav Res Ther 2015; 68: 27-36.
53. He J, Sun H-Q, Li S-X, et al. Effect of conditioned stimulus exposure during slow wave sleep on fear memory extinction in humans. Sleep 2015; 38: 423-431.
54. Dunsmoor JE, Campese VD, Ceceli AO, et al. Novelty-facilitated extinction: providing a novel outcome in place of an expected threat diminishes recovery of defensive responses. Biol Psychiatry 2015; 78: 203-209.
55. Haesen K, Vervliet B. Beyond extinction: habituation eliminates conditioned skin conductance across contexts. Int J Psychophysiol 2014. [Epub ahead of print]
56. Culver NC, Stoyanova M, Craske MG. Clinical relevance of retrieval cues for attenuating context renewal of fear. J Anxiety Disord 2011; 25: 284-292.
57. Mystkowski JL, Craske MG, Echiverri AM, Labus JS. Mental reinstatement of context and return of fear in spider-fearful participants. Behav Ther 2006; 37: 49-60.
58. Kleim B, Wilhelm FH, Temp L, et al. Sleep enhances exposure therapy. Psychol Med 2014; 44: 1511-1519.
59. Zbozinek TD, Holmes EA, Craske MG. The effect of positive mood induction on reducing reinstatement fear: relevance for long term outcomes of exposure therapy. Behav Res Ther 2015; 71: 65-75.
60. Siette J, Reichelt AC, Westbrook RF. A bout of voluntary running enhances context conditioned fear, its extinction, and its reconsolidation. Learn Mem 2014; 21: 73-81.
61. Powers MB, Medina JL, Burns S, et al. Exercise augmentation of exposure therapy for PTSD: rationale and pilot efficacy data. Cogn Behav Ther 2015; 44: 314-327.
62. De Carvalho Myskiw J, Benetti F, Izquierdo I. Behavioral tagging of extinction learning. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2013; 110: 1071-1076.
63. Menezes J, Alves N, Borges S, et al. Facilitation of fear extinction by novelty depends on dopamine acting on D1-subtype dopamine receptors in hippocampus. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2015; 112: E1652-E1658.
64. De Carvalho Myskiw J, Furini CRG, Benetti F, Izquierdo I. Hippocampal molecular mechanisms involved in the enhancement of fear extinction caused by exposure to novelty. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2014; 111: 4572-4577.
65. Schiller D, Monfils M-H, Raio CM, et al. Preventing the return of fear in humans using reconsolidation update mechanisms. Nature 2010; 463: 49-53.
66. Soeter M, Kindt M. Dissociating response systems: erasing fear from memory. Neurobiol Learn Mem 2010; 94: 30-41.
67. Craske MG, Treanor M, Conway CC, et al. Maximizing exposure therapy: an inhibitory learning approach. Behav Res Ther 2014; 58: 10-23.
68. Pittig A, Stevens S, Vervliet B, et al. Optimierung expositionsbasierter Therapie: Ein Ansatz des inhibitorischen Lernens [Optimizing exposurebased therapy: An inhibitory learning approach]. Psychotherapeut 2015; 60: 401-418.
69. Torrents-Rodas D, Fullana MA, Vervliet B, et al. [Optimizing exposure based therapy: an inhibitory learning approach]. Rev Psicopatología y Psicol Clínica 2015; 20: 12-35.
70. Philippot P, Dethier V, Vervliet B, et al. [Optimizing exposure based therapy: an inhibitory learning approach]. Rev Francoph Clin Comport Cogn 2015. (in press).
71. Vervliet B, Depreeuw B, Craske MG. [Optimizing exposure based therapy: an inhibitory learning approach]. Gedragstherapie 2014; 47: 296-339.
72. Rief W, Glombiewski F a, Gollwitzer M, et al. Expectancies as core features of mental disorders. Curr Opin Psychiatry 2015; 28: 378-385.
73. Bouton ME. Why behavior change is difficult to sustain. Prev Med 2014; 68: 29-36.
74. Lucke S, Lachnit H, Stuettgen MC, Uengoer M. The impact of context relevance during extinction learning. Learn Behav 2014; 42: 256-269.
75. Icenhour A, Kattoor J, Benson S, et al. Neural circuitry underlying effects of context on human pain-related fear extinction in a renewal paradigm. Hum Brain Mapp 2015; 36: 3179-3193.
76. Waters AM, Potter A, Jamesion L, et al. Predictors of treatment outcomes in anxious children receiving group cognitive-behavioural therapy: pretreatment attention bias to threat and emotional variability during exposure tasks. Behav Change 2015; 32: 143-158.
77. Culver NC, Stoyanova M, Craske MG. Emotional variability and sustained arousal during exposure. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry 2012; 43: 787-793.
78. Kircanski K, Mortazavi A, Castriotta N, et al. Challenges to the traditional exposure paradigm: variability in exposure therapy for contamination fears. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry 2012; 43: 745-751.
79. Miguez G, Witnauer JE, Laborda MA, Miller RR. Trial spacing during extinction: the role of context-US associations. J Exp Psychol Behav Process 2014; 40: 81-91.
80. Burklund LJ, David Creswell J, Irwin MR, Lieberman MD. The common and distinct neural bases of affect labeling and reappraisal in healthy adults. Front Psychol 2014; 5: 1-10.
81. Roig M, Nordbrandt S, Geertsen SS, Nielsen JB. The effects of cardiovascular exercise on human memory: a review with meta-analysis. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 2013; 37: 1645-1666.
82. Lambourne K, Tomporowski P. The effect of exercise-induced arousal on cognitive task performance: a meta-regression analysis. Brain Res 2010; 1341: 12-24.
83. Meulders A, Meulders M, Vlaeyen JWS. Positive affect protects against deficient safety learning during extinction of fear of movement-related pain in healthy individuals scoring relatively high on trait anxiety. J Pain 2014; 15: 632-644.
84. Zbozinek TD, Hermans D, Prenoveau JM, et al. Postextinction conditional stimulus valence predicts reinstatement fear: relevance for long-term outcomes of exposure therapy. Cogn Emot 2015; 29: 654-667.
85. Hunter AS. Impaired extinction of fear conditioning after REM deprivation is magnified by rearing in an enriched environment. Neurobiol Learn Mem 2015; 122: 11-18.
86. Landmann N, Kuhn M, Maier J-G, et al. REM sleep and memory reorganization: potential relevance for psychiatry and psychotherapy. Neurobiol Learn Mem 2015; 122: 28-40.
87. Marshall AJ, Acheson DT, Risbrough VB, et al. Fear conditioning, safety learning, and sleep in humans. J Neurosci 2014; 34: 11754-11760.
88. Pace-Schott EF, Germain A, Milad MR. Effects of sleep on memory for conditioned fear and fear extinction. Psychol Bull 2015; 141: 835-857.
89. Spoormaker VI, Gvozdanovic GA, Sämann PG, Czisch M. Ventromedial prefrontal cortex activity and rapid eye movement sleep are associated with subsequent fear expression in human subjects. Exp Brain Res 2014; 232: 1547-1554.
90. Hauner KK, Howard JD, Zelano C, Gottfried JA. Stimulus-specific enhancement of fear extinction during slow-wave sleep. Nat Neurosci 2013; 16: 1553-1555.
91. Diekelmann S, Born J. Cueing fear memory during sleep: to extinguish or to enhance fear? Sleep 2015; 38: 337-339.
92. Nader K, Schafe GE, LeDoux JE. Fear memories require protein synthesis in the amygdala for reconsolidation after retrieval. Nature 2000; 406: 722-726.
93. Schwabe L, Nader K, Pruessner JC. Reconsolidation of human memory: brain mechanisms and clinical relevance. Biol Psychiatry 2014; 76: 274-280.
94. Lonergan MH, Olivera-Figueroa La, Pitman RK, Brunet A. Propranolol's effects on the consolidation and reconsolidation of long-term emotional memory in healthy participants: a meta-analysis. J Psychiatry Neurosci 2013; 38: 222-231.
95. Agren T. Human reconsolidation: a reactivation and update. Brain Res Bull 2014; 105: 70-82.
96. James EL, Bonsall MB, Hoppitt L, et al. Computer game play reduces intrusive memories of experimental trauma via reconsolidation: update mechanisms. Psychol Sci 2015; 26: 1201-1215.
97. Bjorkstrand J, Agren T, Frick A, et al. Disruption of memory reconsolidation erases a fear memory trace in the human amygdala: an 18-month follow-up. PLoS One 2015; 10: e0129393.
98. Sevenster D, Beckers T, Kindt M. Fear conditioning of SCR but not the startle reflex requires conscious discrimination of threat and safety. Front Behav Neurosci 2014; 8: 32.
99. Gisquet-Verrier P, Lynch JF, Cutolo P, et al. Integration of new information with active memory accounts for retrograde amnesia: a challenge to the consolidation/reconsolidation hypothesis? J Neurosci 2015; 35: 11623-11633.
100. Sevenster D, Beckers T, Kindt M. Retrieval per se is not sufficient to trigger reconsolidation of human fear memory. Neurobiol Learn Mem 2012; 97: 338-345.
101. Sevenster D, Beckers T, Kindt M. Prediction error demarcates the transition from retrieval, to reconsolidation, to new learning. Learn Mem 2014; 21: 580-584.
102. Gershman SJ, Jones CE, Norman K a, et al. Gradual extinction prevents the return of fear: implications for the discovery of state. Front Behav Neurosci 2013; 7: 164.
103. Jones BJ, Pest SM, Vargas IM, et al. Contextual reminders fail to trigger memory reconsolidation in aged rats and aged humans. Neurobiol Learn Mem 2015; 120: 7-15.
104. Wood NE, Rosasco ML, Suris AM, et al. Pharmacological blockade of memory reconsolidation in posttraumatic stress disorder: three negative psychophysiological studies. Psychiatry Res 2015; 225: 31-39.
105. Bos MGN, Beckers T, Kindt M. Noradrenergic blockade of memory reconsolidation: a failure to reduce conditioned fear responding. Front Behav Neurosci 2014; 8: 412.
106. Spring JD, Wood NE, Mueller-Pfeiffer C, et al. Prereactivation propranolol fails to reduce skin conductance reactivity to prepared fear-conditioned stimuli. Psychophysiology 2015; 52: 407-415.
107. Marks EH, Zoellner LA. Attenuating fearful memories: effect of cued extinction on intrusions. Emotion 2014; 14: 1143-1154.
108. Norcross JC, Krebs PM, Prochaska JO. Stages of change. J Clin Psychol 2011; 67: 143-154.
109. Pittig A, Schulz AR, Craske MG, Alpers GW. Acquisition of behavioral avoidance: task-irrelevant conditioned stimuli trigger costly decisions. J Abnorm Psychol 2014; 123: 314-329.
110. Pittig A, Alpers GW, Niles AN, Craske MG. Avoidant decision-making in social anxiety disorder: a laboratory task linked to in vivo anxiety and treatment outcome. Behav Res Ther 2015; 73: 96-103.
111. Levy HC, Radomsky AS. Safety behaviour enhances the acceptability of exposure. Cogn Behav Ther 2014; 43: 83-92.
112. Levy HC, Senn JM, Radomsky AS. Further support for the acceptabilityenhancing roles of safety behavior and a cognitive rationale in cognitive behavioral therapy for anxiety disorders. J Cogn Psychother 2014; 28: 303-316.