Updated meta-analysis of classical fear conditioning in the anxiety disorders

Depression and Anxiety

Volumn 32, Issue 4, 2015, Pages 239-253

  Duits, Puck ^a   Cath, Danielle C ^a   Lissek, Shmuel ^b   Hox, Joop J ^a   Hamm, Alfons O ^c   Engelhard, Iris M ^a   Van Den Hout, Marcel A ^a   Baas, Joke M P ^a  

^a UTRECHT UNIVERSITY   (Netherlands)

^b UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY OF GREIFSWALD   (Germany)

Author keywords

anxiety disorders; classical fear conditioning; extinction; meta analysis

Indexed keywords

ANXIETY DISORDER; ASSOCIATION; CONDITIONED REFLEX; CONDITIONING; DISCRIMINATION LEARNING; EFFECT SIZE; FEAR CONDITIONING; GENERALIZED ANXIETY DISORDER; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS (TOPIC); OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; FEAR; META ANALYSIS; PATHOPHYSIOLOGY; PHYSIOLOGY; REINFORCEMENT;

ANXIETY DISORDERS; CONDITIONING, CLASSICAL; EXTINCTION, PSYCHOLOGICAL; FEAR; HUMANS;

EID: 84925671567     PISSN: 10914269     EISSN: 15206394     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/da.22353     Document Type: Review

References (86)

1. American Psychiatric Association. The diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders: DSM 5. Washington, DC; 2013.
2. LeDoux JE,. Coming to terms with fear. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2014; 111 (8): 2871-2878. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1400335111.
3. Lang PJ, Davis M, Öhman A,. Fear and anxiety: animal models and human cognitive psychophysiology. J Affect Disord 2000; 61 (3): 137-159.
4. Schienle A, Schäfer A, Hermann A, et al. Symptom provocation and reduction in patients suffering from spider phobia. Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 2007; 257 (8): 486-493.
5. Lissek S, Bradford DE, Alvarez RP, et al. Neural substrates of classically conditioned fear-generalization in humans: a parametric fMRI study. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci 2014; 9 (8): 1134-1142.
6. Mineka S, Oehlberg K,. The relevance of recent developments in classical conditioning to understanding the etiology and maintenance of anxiety disorders. Acta Psychol 2008; 127 (3): 567-580.
7. Bouton ME, Mineka S, Barlow DH,. A modern learning theory perspective on the etiology of panic disorder. Psychol Rev 2001; 108 (1): 4-32.
8. Pavlov IP,. Conditioned Reflexes. London: Oxford University Press; 1927.
9. Watson JB, Rayner R,. Conditioned emotional reactions. J Exp Psychol 1920; 3: 1-14.
10. Lissek S, Powers AS, McClure EB, et al. Classical fear conditioning in the anxiety disorders: a meta-analysis. Behav Res Ther 2005; 43 (11): 1391-1424.
11. Bouton ME,. Context, ambiguity, and unlearning: sources of relapse after behavioral extinction. Biol Psychiatry 2002; 52 (10): 976-986.
12. Hofmann SG,. Cognitive processes during fear acquisition and extinction in animals and humans: implications for exposure therapy of anxiety disorders. Clin Psychol Rev. 2008; 28 (2): 199-210.
13. Hettema JM, Annas P, Neale MC, Kendler KS, Fredrikson M,. A twin study of the genetics of fear conditioning. Arch Gen Psychiatry 2003; 60 (7): 702-708.
14. Lonsdorf T, Kalisch R,. A review on experimental and clinical genetic associations studies on fear conditioning, extinction and cognitive-behavioral treatment. Transl Psychiatry 2011; 1 (9):e41.
15. ∗ Orr SP, Metzger LJ, Lasko NB, et al. De novo conditioning in trauma-exposed individuals with and without posttraumatic stress disorder. J Abnorm Psychol. 2000; 109 (2): 290-298.
16. Grillon C,. Startle reactivity and anxiety disorders: aversive conditioning, context, and neurobiology. Biol Psychiatry 2002; 52 (10): 958-975.
17. Engelhard IM, de Jong PJ, van den Hout MA, van Overveld M,. Expectancy bias and the persistence of posttraumatic stress. Behav Res Ther 2009; 47 (10): 887-892.
18. Guthrie RM, Bryant RA,. Extinction learning before trauma and subsequent posttraumatic stress. Psychosom Med 2006; 68 (2): 307-311.
19. Lommen MJ, Engelhard IM, Sijbrandij M, et al. Pre-trauma individual differences in extinction learning predict posttraumatic stress. Behav Res Ther 2013; 51: 63-67.
20. Orr SP, Lasko NB, Macklin ML, et al. Predicting post-trauma stress symptoms from pre-trauma psychophysiologic reactivity, personality traits and measures of psychopathology. Biol Mood Anxiety Disord 2012; 2: 1-12.
21. ∗ Grillon C, Morgan CA,. Fear-potentiated startle conditioning to explicit and contextual cues in gulf war veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder. J Abnorm Psychol 1999; 108: 134-142.
22. ∗ Peri T, Ben-Shakhar G, Orr SP, Shalev AY,. Psychophysiologic assessment of aversive conditioning in posttraumatic stress disorder. Biol Psychiatry 2000; 47 (6): 512-519.
23. ∗ Hermann C, Ziegler S, Birbaumer N, Flor H,. Psychophysiological and subjective indicators of aversive pavlovian conditioning in generalized social phobia. Biol Psychiatry 2002; 52 (4): 328-337.
24. Otto MW, Moshier SJ, Kinner DG, et al. De novo fear conditioning across diagnostic groups in the affective disorders: evidence for learning impairments. Behav Ther 2014; 45 (5): 619-629.
25. American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders: DSM-IV-TR. Washington, DC; 2000.
26. Ramnani N, Toni I, Josephs O, et al. Learning- and expectation-related changes in the human brain during motor learning. J Neurophysiol 2000; 84 (6): 3026-3035.
27. Hedges LV, Olkin I,. Statistical Methods for Meta-Analysis. Orlando: Academic Press; 1985.
28. Lipsey MW, Wilson DB,. Practical meta-analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage; 2001.
29. Cohen J,. Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates; 1977.
30. Borenstein M, Hedges LV, Higgins JP, Rothstein HR,. Introduction to meta-analysis. Chichester, UK: Wiley; 2009.
31. Bryk AS, Raudenbush SW, Condon RT,. HLM2/3. Hierarchical Linear and Nonlinear Modeling with the HLM/2L and HLM/3L Programs. Chicago: Scientific Software International; 1994.
32. Hox JJ, De Leeuw ED,. Multilevel models for meta-analysis. In, SP Reise, N Duan, (Eds.), Multilevel Modeling. Methodological Advances, Issues, and Applications Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates; 2003, pp 90-111.
33. Kalaian HA, Raudenbush SW,. A multivariate mixed linear model for meta-analysis. Psychol Methods 1996; 1 (3): 227-235.
34. Grings WW, Schell AM, Carey CA,. Verbal control of an autonomic response in a cue reversal situation. J Exp Psychol 1973; 99 (2): 215-221.
35. Lipp OV, Mallan KM, Libera M, Tan M,. The effects of verbal instruction on affective and expectancy learning. Behav Res Ther 2010; 48 (3): 203-209.
36. McNally RJ,. Mechanisms of exposure therapy: how neuroscience can improve psychological treatments for anxiety disorders. Clin Psychol Rev 2007; 27 (6): 750-759.
37. Soares JJ, Öhman A,. Preattentive processing, preparedness and phobias: effects of instruction on conditioned electrodermal responses to masked and non-masked fear-relevant. Behav Res Ther 1993; 31 (1): 87-95.
38. ∗ Schweckendiek J, Klucken T, Merz CJ, et al. Weaving the (neuronal) web: fear learning in spider phobia. Neuroimage 2011; 54 (1): 681-688.
39. ∗ Lissek S, Rabin S, Heller RE, et al. Overgeneralization of conditioned fear as a pathogenic marker of panic disorder. Am J Psychiatry 2010; 167 (1): 47-55.
40. ∗ Lissek S, Kaczkurkin AN, Rabin S, et al. Generalized anxiety disorder is associated with overgeneralization of classically conditioned fear. Biol Psychiatry 2013; 75 (11): 909-915.
41. ∗ Jovanovic T, Norrholm SD, Blanding NQ, et al. Fear potentiation is associated with hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis function in PTSD. Psychoneuroendocrinology 2010; 35 (6): 846-857.
42. ∗ Jovanovic T, Norrholm SD, Blanding NQ, et al. Impaired fear inhibition is a biomarker of PTSD but not depression. Depress Anxiety 2010; 27 (3): 244-251.
43. ∗ Jovanovic T, Norrholm SD, Fennell JE, et al. Posttraumatic stress disorder may be associated with impaired fear inhibition: relation to symptom severity. Psychiatry Res 2009; 167 (1): 151-160.
44. ∗ Jovanovic T, Sakoman AJ, Kozarić-Kovačić D, et al. Acute stress disorder versus chronic posttraumatic stress disorder: inhibition of fear as a function of time since trauma. Depress Anxiety 2012; 30: 217-224.
45. ∗ Grillon C, Morgan CA, Davis M, Southwick SM,. Effects of experimental context and explicit threat cues on acoustic startle in Vietnam veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder. Biol Psychiatry 1998; 44 (10): 1027-1036.
46. Kopp B, Schlimm M, Hermann C,. Memory-emotional interactions as revealed by fear generalization in animal-fearful individuals. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry 2005; 36 (2): 145-166.
47. Lissek S, Pine DS, Grillon C,. The strong situation: a potential impediment to studying the psychobiology and pharmacology of anxiety disorders. Biol Psychol 2006; 72 (3): 265-270.
48. Milad MR, Wright CI, Orr SP, et al. Recall of fear extinction in humans activates the ventromedial prefrontal cortex and hippocampus in concert. Biol Psychiatry 2007; 62 (5): 446-454.
49. Kalisch R, Korenfeld E, Stephan KE, et al. Context-dependent human extinction memory is mediated by a ventromedial prefrontal and hippocampal network. J Neurosci 2006; 26 (37): 9503-9511.
50. Etkin A, Wager T,. Functional neuroimaging of anxiety: a meta-analysis of emotional processing in PTSD, social anxiety disorder, and specific phobia. Am J Psychiatry 2007; 164 (10): 1476-1488.
51. Delgado MR, Nearing KI, LeDoux JE, Phelps EA,. Neural circuitry underlying the regulation of conditioned fear and its relation to extinction. Neuron 2008; 59 (5): 829-838.
52. Morris SE, Cuthbert BN,. Research domain criteria: cognitive systems, neural circuits, and dimensions of behavior. Dialogues Clin Neurosci 2012; 14 (1): 29-37.
53. Hermans D, Craske MG, Mineka S, Lovibond PF,. Extinction in human fear conditioning. Biol Psychiatry 2006; 60 (4): 361-368.
54. ∗ Ashcroft K, Guimaraes F, Wang M, Deakin J,. Evaluation of a psychophysiological model of classical fear conditioning in anxious patients. Psychopharmacology 1991; 104 (2): 215-219.
55. ∗ Clum GA,. A correlational analysis of the relationships between personality and perceptual variables and discriminant GSR conditioning. J Clin Psychol 1969; 25: 33-35.
56. ∗ Fayu C,. Fear conditioning with normals, neurotics and schizophrenics. Acta Psychologica Taiwanica 1961; 3: 18-33.
57. ∗ Grillon C, Lissek S, Rabin S, et al. Increased anxiety during anticipation of unpredictable but not predictable aversive stimuli as a psychophysiologic marker of panic disorder. Am J Psychiatry 2008; 165 (7): 898-904.
58. ∗ Grillon C, Pine DS, Lissek S, et al. Increased anxiety during anticipation of unpredictable aversive stimuli in posttraumatic stress disorder but not in generalized anxiety disorder. Biol Psychiatry 2009; 66 (1): 47-53.
59. ∗ Halberstam JL,. Some personality correlates of conditioning, generalization, and extinction. Psychosom Med 1961; 23 (1): 67-76.
60. ∗ Howe ES,. GSR conditioning in anxiety states, normals, and chronic functional schizophrenic subjects. J Abnorm Soc Psychol 1958; 56 (2): 183-189.
61. ∗ Jovanovic T, Phifer JE, Sicking K, et al. Cortisol suppression by dexamethasone reduces exaggerated fear responses in posttraumatic stress disorder. Psychoneuroendocrinology 2011; 36 (10): 1540-1552.
62. ∗ Jovanovic T, Ely T, Fani N, et al. Reduced neural activation during an inhibition task is associated with impaired fear inhibition in a traumatized civilian sample. Cortex 2013; 49 (7): 1884-1891.
63. ∗ Kircher T, Arolt V, Jansen A, et al. Effect of cognitive-behavioral therapy on neural correlates of fear conditioning in panic disorder. Biol Psychiatry 2012; 73: 93-101.
64. ∗ Lau JYF, Lissek S, Nelson EE, et al. Fear conditioning in adolescents with anxiety disorders: results from a novel experimental paradigm. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2008; 47 (1): 94-102.
65. ∗ Liberman LC, Lipp OV, Spence SH, March S,. Evidence for retarded extinction of aversive learning in anxious children. Behav Res Ther 2006; 44 (10): 1491-1502.
66. ∗ Linnman C, Zeffiro TA, Pitman RK, Milad MR,. An fMRI study of unconditioned responses in post-traumatic stress disorder. Biol Mood Anxiety Disord 2011; 1 (8): 1-12.
67. ∗ Lissek S, Levenson J, Biggs AL, et al. Elevated fear conditioning to socially relevant unconditioned stimuli in social anxiety disorder. Am J Psychiatry 2008; 165 (1): 124-132.
68. ∗ Lissek S, Rabin SJ, McDowell DJ, et al. Impaired discriminative fear-conditioning resulting from elevated fear responding to learned safety cues among individuals with panic disorder. Behav Res Ther 2009; 47 (2): 111-118.
69. ∗ Lueken U, Straube B, Reinhardt I, et al. Altered top-down and bottom-up processing of fear conditioning in panic disorder with agoraphobia. Psychol Med 2013; 44: 381-394.
70. ∗ Milad MR, Orr SP, Lasko NB, et al. Presence and acquired origin of reduced recall for fear extinction in PTSD: results of a twin study. J Psychiatr Res 2008; 42 (7): 515-520.
71. ∗ Milad MR, Pitman RK, Ellis CB, et al. Neurobiological basis of failure to recall extinction memory in posttraumatic stress disorder. Biol Psychiatry 2009; 66 (12): 1075-1082.
72. ∗ Milad MR, Furtak SC, Greenberg JL, et al. Deficits in conditioned fear extinction in obsessive-compulsive disorder and neurobiological changes in the fear circuit. JAMA Psychiatry 2013; 70 (6): 608-618.
73. ∗ Miller MW, McKinney AE, Kanter FS, et al. Hydrocortisone suppression of the fear-potentiated startle response and posttraumatic stress disorder. Psychoneuroendocrinology 2011; 36 (7): 970-980.
74. ∗ Nanbu M, Kurayama T, Nakazawa K, et al. Impaired P50 suppression in fear extinction in obsessive compulsive disorder. Prog Neuro-Psychopharmacol Biol Psychiatry 2010; 34 (2): 317-322.
75. ∗ Norrholm SD, Jovanovic T, Olin IW, et al. Fear extinction in traumatized civilians with posttraumatic stress disorder: relation to symptom severity. Biol Psychiatry 2011; 69 (6): 556-563.
76. ∗ Norrholm SD, Jovanovic T, Smith AK, et al. Differential genetic and epigenetic regulation of catechol-O-methyltransferase is associated with impaired fear inhibition in posttraumatic stress disorder. Front Behav Neurosci 2013; 7: 1-10.
77. ∗ Pitman RK, Orr SP,. Test of the conditioning model of neurosis: differential aversive conditioning of angry and neutral facial expressions in anxiety disorder patients. J Abnorm Psychol 1986; 95 (3): 208-213.
78. ∗ Reeb-Sutherland BC, Helfinstein SM, Degnan KA, et al. Startle response in behaviorally inhibited adolescents with a lifetime occurrence of anxiety disorders. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2009; 48 (6): 610-617.
79. ∗ Sloane RB, Davidson P, Staples F, Payne R,. Experimental reward and punishment in neurosis. Compr Psychiatry 1965; 6 (6): 388-395.
80. ∗ Thayer JF, Friedman BH, Borkovec TD, et al. Phasic heart period reactions to cued threat and nonthreat stimuli in generalized anxiety disorder. Psychophysiology 2000; 37 (3): 361-368.
81. ∗ Van den Bergh O, Stegen K, Van de Woestijne, Karel P,. Learning to have psychosomatic complaints: conditioning of respiratory behavior and somatic complaints in psychosomatic patients. Psychosom Med 1997; 59 (1): 13-23.
82. ∗ Veit R, Flor H, Erb M, et al. Brain circuits involved in emotional learning in antisocial behavior and social phobia in humans. Neurosci Lett 2002; 328 (3): 233-236.
83. ∗ Vriends N, Michael T, Schindler B, Margraf J,. Associative learning in flying phobia. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry 2012; 43 (2): 838-843.
84. ∗ Waters AM, Henry J, Neumann DL,. Aversive pavlovian conditioning in childhood anxiety disorders: impaired response inhibition and resistance to extinction. J Abnorm Psychol 2009; 118 (2): 311-321.
85. ∗ Wessa M, Flor H,. Failure of extinction of fear responses in posttraumatic stress disorder: evidence from second-order conditioning. Am J Psychiatry 2007; 164 (11): 1684-1692.
86. Duits P, Cath DC, Heitland I, Baas JMP,. High anxiety symptoms are associated with impaired fear extinction: a study in patients treated for either panic disorder or social phobia and control subjects, 2014.