Timing and awareness of movement decisions: Does consciousness really come too late?

Frontiers in Human Neuroscience

Volumn , Issue JUL, 2013, Pages

  Guggisberg, Adrian G ^a   Mottaz, Anaïs ^a  

^a GENEVA UNIVERSITY HOSPITALS   (Switzerland)

Author keywords

Decision making; Free will; Introspection; Libet; Volition

Indexed keywords

ACTION POTENTIAL; AWARENESS; BEREITSCHAFTSPOTENTIAL; BRAIN FUNCTION; COGNITION; CONSCIOUSNESS; DECISION MAKING; FUNCTIONAL MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; HUMAN; INTROSPECTION; LATERALIZED READINESS POTENTIAL; MOTOR PERFORMANCE; MOVEMENT (PHYSIOLOGY); NERVE EXCITABILITY; OSCILLATION; PRIMARY MOTOR CORTEX; REVIEW; SUPPLEMENTARY MOTOR AREA;

EID: 84933679739     PISSN: 16625161     EISSN: 16625161     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.3389/fnhum.2013.00385     Document Type: Review

References (99)

1. Alquist, J.L., Ainsworth, S.E., and Baumeister, R.F. (2013). Determined to conform: Disbelief in free will increases conformity. J. Exp. Soc. Psychol. 49, 80-86.
2. Ball, T., Schreiber, A., Feige, B., Wagner, M., Lucking, C.H., and Kristeva-Feige, R. (1999). The role of higher-order motor areas in voluntary movement as revealed by highresolution EEG and fMRI. Neuroimage 10, 682-694.
3. Banks, W.P., and Isham, E.A. (2009). We infer rather than perceive the moment we decided to act. Psychol. Sci. 20, 17-21.
4. Banks, W.P., and Pockett, S. (2007). Benjamin Libet's Work on the Neuroscience of Free Will, in The Blackwell Companion to Consciousness, eds. M. Velmans & S. Schneider. (Oxford: Blackwell), 657-670.
5. Baumeister, R.F., Masicampo, E.J., and Dewall, C.N. (2009). Prosocial benefits of feeling free: disbelief in free will increases aggression and reduces helpfulness. Pers. Soc. Psychol. Bull. 35, 260-268.
6. Birbaumer, N., Elbert, T., Canavan, A.G., and Rockstroh, B. (1990). Slow potentials of the cerebral cortex and behavior. Physiol. Rev. 70, 1-41.
7. Bode, S., Bogler, C., and Haynes, J.D. (2013). Similar neural mechanisms for perceptual guesses and free decisions. Neuroimage 65, 456-465.
8. Bode, S., Sewell, D.K., Lilburn, S., Forte, J.D., Smith, P.L., and Stahl, J. (2012). Predicting perceptual decision biases from early brain activity. J. Neurosci. 32, 12488-12498.
9. Brass, M., and Haggard, P. (2008). The what, when, whether model of intentional action. Neuroscientist 14, 319-325.
10. Brass, M., Lynn, M.T., Demanet, J., and Rigoni, D. (2013). Imaging volition: what the brain can tell us about the will. Exp. Brain Res.
11. Brentano, F. (1874). Psychologie vom empirischen Standpunkt. Hamburg: Felix Meiner.
12. Brovelli, A., Lachaux, J.P., Kahane, P., and Boussaoud, D. (2005). High gamma frequency oscillatory activity dissociates attention from intention in the human premotor cortex. Neuroimage 28, 154-164.
13. Brunia, C.H. (1988). Movement and stimulus preceding negativity. Biol. Psychol. 26, 165-178.
14. Buzsaki, G., Anastassiou, C.A., and Koch, C. (2012). The origin of extracellular fields and currents - EEG, ECoG, LFP and spikes. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 13, 407-420.
15. Canolty, R.T., Soltani, M., Dalal, S.S., Edwards, E., Dronkers, N.F., Nagarajan, S.S., Kirsch, H.E., Barbaro, N.M., and Knight, R.T. (2007). Spatiotemporal dynamics of word processing in the human brain. Front. Neurosci. 1, 185-196.
16. Caspers, H., and Schulze, H. (1959). Die Veränderungen der corticalen Gleichspannung während der natürlichen Schlaf-Wach-Perioden beim freibeweglichen Tier. Pflugers Arch. Gesamte Physiol. Menschen Tiere 270, 103-120.
17. Caspers, H., Speckmann, E.J., and Lehmenkuhler, A. (1980). Electrogenesis of cortical DC potentials. Prog. Brain Res. 54, 3-15.
18. Coles, M.G. (1989). Modern mind-brain reading: psychophysiology, physiology, and cognition. Psychophysiology 26, 251-269.
19. Corallo, G., Sackur, J., Dehaene, S., and Sigman, M. (2008). Limits on introspection:distorted subjective time during the dual-task bottleneck. Psychol. Sci. 19, 1110-1117.
20. Crone, N.E., Sinai, A., and Korzeniewska, A. (2006). High-frequency gamma oscillations and human brain mapping with electrocorticography. Prog. Brain Res. 159, 275-295.
21. Cunnington, R., Windischberger, C., Robinson, S., and Moser, E. (2006). The selection of intended actions and the observation of others' actions: a time-resolved fMRI study. Neuroimage 29, 1294-1302.
22. Custers, R., and Aarts, H. (2010). The unconscious will: how the pursuit of goals operates outside of conscious awareness. Science 329, 47-50.
23. Dalal, S.S., Guggisberg, A.G., Edwards, E., Sekihara, K., Findlay, A.M., Canolty, R.T., Berger, M.S., Knight, R.T., Barbaro, N.M., Kirsch, H.E., and Nagarajan, S.S. (2008). Five-dimensional neuroimaging: Localization of the time-frequency dynamics of cortical activity. Neuroimage 40, 1686-1700.
24. Danquah, A.N., Farrell, M.J., and O'boyle, D.J. (2008). Biases in the subjective timing of perceptual events: Libet et al. (1983) revisited. Conscious. Cogn. 17, 616-627.
25. De Jong, B.M. (2011). Neurology of widely embedded free will. Cortex 47, 1160-1165.
26. Deiber, M.P., Honda, M., Ibanez, V., Sadato, N., and Hallett, M. (1999). Mesial motor areas in self-initiated versus externally triggered movements examined with fMRI: effect of movement type and rate. J. Neurophysiol. 81, 3065-3077.
27. Deiber, M.P., Ibanez, V., Sadato, N., and Hallett, M. (1996). Cerebral structures participating in motor preparation in humans: a positron emission tomography study. J. Neurophysiol. 75, 233-247.
28. Desmurget, M., Reilly, K.T., Richard, N., Szathmari, A., Mottolese, C., and Sirigu, A. (2009). Movement intention after parietal cortex stimulation in humans. Science 324, 811-813.
29. Dirnberger, G., Fickel, U., Lindinger, G., Lang, W., and Jahanshahi, M. (1998). The mode of movement selection. Movement-related cortical potentials prior to freely selected and repetitive movements. Exp. Brain Res. 120, 263-272.
30. Eagleman, D.M., and Sejnowski, T.J. (2000). Motion integration and postdiction in visual awareness. Science 287, 2036-2038.
31. Edwards, E., Nagarajan, S.S., Dalal, S.S., Canolty, R.T., Kirsch, H.E., Barbaro, N.M., and Knight, R.T. (2010). Spatiotemporal imaging of cortical activation during verb generation and picture naming. Neuroimage 50, 291-301.
32. Edwards, E., Soltani, M., Deouell, L.Y., Berger, M.S., and Knight, R.T. (2005). High gamma activity in response to deviant auditory stimuli recorded directly from human cortex. J. Neurophysiol. 94, 4269-4280.
33. Fahle, M.W., Stemmler, T., and Spang, K.M. (2011). How Much of the Unconscious is Just Pre - Threshold? Front. Hum. Neurosci. 5, 120.
34. Fox, M.C., Ericsson, K.A., and Best, R. (2011). Do procedures for verbal reporting of thinking have to be reactive? A meta-analysis and recommendations for best reporting methods. Psychol. Bull. 137, 316-344.
35. Fried, I., Katz, A., Mccarthy, G., Sass, K.J., Williamson, P., Spencer, S.S., and Spencer, D.D. (1991). Functional organization of human supplementary motor cortex studied by electrical stimulation. J. Neurosci. 11, 3656-3666.
36. Fried, I., Mukamel, R., and Kreiman, G. (2011). Internally generated preactivation of single neurons in human medial frontal cortex predicts volition. Neuron 69, 548-562.
37. Gallagher, S., and Zahavi, D. (2010). Phenomenological Approaches to Self-Consciousness, in: The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. (ed.) E.N. Zalta.).
38. Gerloff, C., Richard, J., Hadley, J., Schulman, A.E., Honda, M., and Hallett, M. (1998). Functional coupling and regional activation of human cortical motor areas during simple, internally paced and externally paced finger movements. Brain 121, 1513-1531.
39. Guggisberg, A.G., Dalal, S.S., Findlay, A.M., and Nagarajan, S.S. (2008). High-frequency oscillations in distributed neural networks reveal the dynamics of human decision making. Front. Hum. Neurosci. 1, 14.
40. Guggisberg, A.G., Dalal, S.S., Schnider, A., and Nagarajan, S.S. (2011). The neural basis of event-time introspection. Conscious. Cogn. 20, 1899-1915.
41. Haggard, P. (2008). Human volition: towards a neuroscience of will. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 9, 934-946.
42. Haggard, P., Clark, S., and Kalogeras, J. (2002). Voluntary action and conscious awareness. Nat. Neurosci. 5, 382-385.
43. Haggard, P., and Eimer, M. (1999). On the relation between brain potentials and the awareness of voluntary movements. Exp. Brain Res. 126, 128-133.
44. Herrmann, C.S., Pauen, M., Min, B.-K., Busch, N.A., and Rieger, J.W. (2008). Analysis of a choice-reaction task yields a new interpretation of Libet's experiments. Int. J. Psychophysiol. 67, 151-157.
45. Hurlburt, R., and Heavey, C.L. (2004). To Beep or Not To Beep: Obtaining Accurate Reports About Awareness. J. Consciousness Stud. 11, 113-128.
46. Husserl, E. (1984). Einleitung in die Logik und Erkenntnistheorie. Den Haag: Martinus Nijhoff.
47. Jahanshahi, M., Jenkins, I.H., Brown, R.G., Marsden, C.D., Passingham, R.E., and Brooks, D.J. (1995). Self-initiated versus externally triggered movements. I. An investigation using measurement of regional cerebral blood flow with PET and movement-related potentials in normal and Parkinson's disease subjects. Brain 118, 913-933.
48. Jenkins, I.H., Jahanshahi, M., Jueptner, M., Passingham, R.E., and Brooks, D.J. (2000). Selfinitiated versus externally triggered movements. II. The effect of movement predictability on regional cerebral blood flow. Brain 123 (Pt 6), 1216-1228.
49. Karp, B.I., Porter, S., Toro, C., and Hallett, M. (1996). Simple motor tics may be preceded by a premotor potential. J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry 61, 103-106.
50. Keller, I., and Heckhausen, H. (1990). Readiness potentials preceding spontaneous motor acts: voluntary vs. involuntary control. Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 76, 351-361.
51. Kitamura, J., Shabasaki, H., Terashi, A., and Tashima, K. (1999). Cortical potentials preceding voluntary finger movement in patients with focal cerebellar lesion. Clin. Neurophysiol. 110, 126-132.
52. Kitamura, J., Shibasaki, H., Takagi, A., Nabeshima, H., and Yamaguchi, A. (1993). Enhanced negative slope of cortical potentials before sequential as compared with simultaneous extensions of two fingers. Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 86, 176-182.
53. Kornhuber, H.H., and Deecke, L. (1965). Hirnpotentialänderungen bei Willkürbewegungen und passiven Bewegungen des Menschen: Bereitschaftspotential und reafferente Potentiale. Pflugers Arch. Gesamte Physiol. Menschen Tiere 284, 1-17.
54. Krieghoff, V., Waszak, F., Prinz, W., and Brass, M. (2011). Neural and behavioral correlates of intentional actions. Neuropsychologia 49, 767-776.
55. Lang, W., Lang, M., Heise, B., Deecke, L., and Kornhuber, H.H. (1984). Brain potentials related to voluntary hand tracking, motivation and attention. Hum. Neurobiol. 3, 235-240.
56. Lau, H.C., Rogers, R.D., Haggard, P., and Passingham, R.E. (2004). Attention to intention. Science 303, 1208-1210.
57. Lau, H.C., Rogers, R.D., and Passingham, R.E. (2007). Manipulating the experienced onset of intention after action execution. J. Cogn. Neurosci. 19, 81-90.
58. Libet, B., Gleason, C.A., Wright, E.W., and Pearl, D.K. (1983). Time of conscious intention to act in relation to onset of cerebral activity (readiness-potential). The unconscious initiation of a freely voluntary act. Brain 106, 623-642.
59. Libet, B., Wright, E.W., Jr., and Gleason, C.A. (1982). Readiness-potentials preceding unrestricted 'spontaneous' vs. pre-planned voluntary acts. Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 54, 322-335.
60. Logothetis, N.K., Pauls, J., Augath, M., Trinath, T., and Oeltermann, A. (2001). Neurophysiological investigation of the basis of the fMRI signal. Nature 412, 150-157.
61. Marcel, A.J. (2003). Introspective Report: Trust, Self-Knowledge and Science. J. Consciousness Stud. 10, 167-186.
62. Matsuhashi, M., and Hallett, M. (2008). The timing of the conscious intention to move. Eur. J. Neurosci. 28, 2344-2351.
63. Miller, J., Shepherdson, P., and Trevena, J. (2011). Effects of clock monitoring on electroencephalographic activity: is unconscious movement initiation an artifact of the clock? Psychol. Sci. 22, 103-109.
64. Moutoussis, K., and Zeki, S. (1997). Functional segregation and temporal hierarchy of the visual perceptive systems. Proc. Biol. Sci. 264, 1407-1414.
65. Niessing, J., Ebisch, B., Schmidt, K.E., Niessing, M., Singer, W., and Galuske, R.A. (2005). Hemodynamic signals correlate tightly with synchronized gamma oscillations. Science 309, 948-951.
66. Obeso, J.A., Rothwell, J.C., and Marsden, C.D. (1981). Simple tics in Gilles de la Tourette's syndrome are not prefaced by a normal premovement EEG potential. J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry 44, 735-738.
67. Oga, T., Ikeda, A., Nagamine, T., Sumi, E., Matsumoto, R., Akiguchi, I., Kimura, J., and Shibasaki, H. (2000). Implication of sensorimotor integration in the generation of periodic dystonic myoclonus in subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE). Mov. Disord. 15, 1173-1183.
68. Overgaard, M., and Sorensen, T.A. (2004). Introspection distinct from first-order experiences. J. Consciousness Stud. 11, 77-95.
69. Papa, S.M., Artieda, J., and Obeso, J.A. (1991). Cortical activity preceding self-initiated and externally triggered voluntary movement. Mov. Disord. 6, 217-224.
70. Pockett, S., and Miller, A. (2007). The rotating spot method of timing subjective events. Conscious. Cogn. 16, 241-254.
71. Pockett, S., and Purdy, S. (2010). Are voluntary movements initiated preconsciously? The relationships between readiness potentials, urges and decisions, in Conscious Will and Responsibility: A Tribute to Benjamin Libet, eds. W. Sinnott-Armstrong & L. Nadel. (New York: Oxford University Press).
72. Praamstra, P., Stegeman, D.F., Horstink, M.W., Brunia, C.H., and Cools, A.R. (1995). Movement-related potentials preceding voluntary movement are modulated by the mode of movement selection. Exp. Brain Res. 103, 429-439.
73. Rasch, M.J., Gretton, A., Murayama, Y., Maass, W., and Logothetis, N.K. (2008). Inferring spike trains from local field potentials. J. Neurophysiol. 99, 1461-1476.
74. Rigoni, D., Brass, M., Roger, C., Vidal, F., and Sartori, G. (2013a). Top-down modulation of brain activity underlying intentional action and its relationship with awareness of intention: an ERP/Laplacian analysis. Exp. Brain Res.
75. Rigoni, D., Brass, M., and Sartori, G. (2010). Post-action determinants of the reported time of conscious intentions. Front. Hum. Neurosci. 4, 38.
76. Rigoni, D., Kuhn, S., Gaudino, G., Sartori, G., and Brass, M. (2012). Reducing self-control by weakening belief in free will. Conscious. Cogn. 21, 1482-1490.
77. Rigoni, D., Kuhn, S., Sartori, G., and Brass, M. (2011). Inducing disbelief in free will alters brain correlates of preconscious motor preparation: the brain minds whether we believe in free will or not. Psychol. Sci. 22, 613-618.
78. Rigoni, D., Wilquin, H., Brass, M., and Burle, B. (2013b). When errors do not matter: weakening belief in intentional control impairs cognitive reaction to errors. Cognition 127, 264-269.
79. Rolls, E.T., and Deco, G. (2011). Prediction of Decisions from Noise in the Brain before the Evidence is Provided. Front. Neurosci. 5, 33.
80. Sanfey, A.G., Loewenstein, G., Mcclure, S.M., and Cohen, J.D. (2006). Neuroeconomics: cross-currents in research on decision-making. Trends Cogn. Sci. 10, 108-116.
81. Schooler, J.W. (2002). Re-representing consciousness: dissociations between experience and meta-consciousness. Trends Cogn. Sci. 6, 339-344.
82. Schurger, A., Sitt, J.D., and Dehaene, S. (2012). An accumulator model for spontaneous neural activity prior to self-initiated movement. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 109, 2904-2913.
83. Shibasaki, H., Barrett, G., Halliday, E., and Halliday, A.M. (1980). Components of the movement-related cortical potential and their scalp topography. Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 49, 213-226.
84. Shibasaki, H., and Hallett, M. (2006). What is the Bereitschaftspotential? Clin. Neurophysiol. 117, 2341-2356.
85. Shibasaki, H., and Kuroiwa, Y. (1975). Electroencephalographic correlates of myoclonus. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 39, 455-463.
86. Siegel, M., Engel, A.K., and Donner, T.H. (2011). Cortical network dynamics of perceptual decision-making in the human brain. Front. Hum. Neurosci. 5, 21.
87. Sirigu, A., Daprati, E., Ciancia, S., Giraux, P., Nighoghossian, N., Posada, A., and Haggard, P. (2004). Altered awareness of voluntary action after damage to the parietal cortex. Nat. Neurosci. 7, 80-84.
88. Sochurkova, D., Rektor, I., Jurak, P., and Stancak, A. (2006). Intracerebral recording of cortical activity related to self-paced voluntary movements: a Bereitschaftspotential and event-related desynchronization/synchronization. SEEG study. Exp. Brain Res. 173, 637-649.
89. Soon, C.S., Brass, M., Heinze, H.J., and Haynes, J.D. (2008). Unconscious determinants of free decisions in the human brain. Nat. Neurosci. 11, 543-545.
90. Stetson, C., Cui, X., Montague, P.R., and Eagleman, D.M. (2006). Motor-sensory recalibration leads to an illusory reversal of action and sensation. Neuron 51, 651-659.
91. Sugrue, L.P., Corrado, G.S., and Newsome, W.T. (2004). Matching behavior and the representation of value in the parietal cortex. Science 304, 1782-1787.
92. Thaler, D., Chen, Y.C., Nixon, P.D., Stern, C.E., and Passingham, R.E. (1995). The functions of the medial premotor cortex. I. Simple learned movements. Exp. Brain Res. 102, 445-460.
93. Thickbroom, G.W., Mastaglia, F.L., Carroll, W.M., and Davies, H.D. (1985). Cerebral potentials accompanying visually triggered finger movement in man. Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 62, 209-218.
94. Trenkwalder, C., Bucher, S.F., Oertel, W.H., Proeckl, D., Plendl, H., and Paulus, W. (1993). Bereitschaftspotential in idiopathic and symptomatic restless legs syndrome. Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 89, 95-103.
95. Trevena, J., and Miller, J. (2010). Brain preparation before a voluntary action: evidence against unconscious movement initiation. Conscious. Cogn. 19, 447-456.
96. Vohs, K.D., and Schooler, J.W. (2008). The value of believing in free will: encouraging a belief in determinism increases cheating. Psychol. Sci. 19, 49-54.
97. Voipio, J., Tallgren, P., Heinonen, E., Vanhatalo, S., and Kaila, K. (2003). Millivolt-scale DC shifts in the human scalp EEG: evidence for a nonneuronal generator. J. Neurophysiol. 89, 2208-2214.
98. Whittingstall, K., and Logothetis, N.K. (2009). Frequency-band coupling in surface EEG reflects spiking activity in monkey visual cortex. Neuron 64, 281-289.
99. Zhang, J., Hughes, L.E., and Rowe, J.B. (2012). Selection and inhibition mechanisms for human voluntary action decisions. Neuroimage 63, 392-402.