Systematic review and meta-analysis of method comparison studies of Masimo pulse co-oximeters (Radical-7™ or Pronto-7™) and HemoCue® absorption spectrometers (B-Hemoglobin or 201+) with laboratory haemoglobin estimation

Anaesthesia and Intensive Care

Volumn 43, Issue 3, 2015, Pages 341-350

  Hiscock, R ^a   Kumar, D ^a   Simmons, S W ^a,b  

^a MERCY HOSPITAL FOR WOMEN   (Australia)

^b UNIVERSITY OF MELBOURNE   (Australia)

Author keywords

Haemoglobin; Oximetry

Indexed keywords

HEMOGLOBIN;

ACCURACY; ARTICLE; BLOOD ANALYSIS; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; LABORATORY TEST; META ANALYSIS; POINT OF CARE TESTING; PULSE OXIMETER; SPECTROPHOTOMETER; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; DEVICES; HEMOGLOBIN DETERMINATION; HOSPITAL INFORMATION SYSTEM; OXIMETRY; PROCEDURES; SPECTROSCOPY; STATISTICS AND NUMERICAL DATA;

HEMOGLOBINOMETRY; HEMOGLOBINS; HUMANS; OXIMETRY; POINT-OF-CARE SYSTEMS; SPECTRUM ANALYSIS;

EID: 84929721360     PISSN: 0310057X     EISSN: 14480271     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0310057x1504300310     Document Type: Article

References (89)

1. Begnoche V, O'Reilly M. Hemoglobin Monitoring. In: Ehrenfeld J, Cannesson M, ed. Monitoring Technologies in Acute Care Environments A comprehensive guide to patient monitoring. New York: Springer Science + Business Media, 2014. pp.299-304.
2. Briggs C, Kimber S, Green L. Where are we at with point-of-care testing in haematology? Br J Haematol 2012; 158:679-690.
3. HemoCue, Angelholm, Sweden. History of HemoCue development. From http://www.hemocue.com/en/about-hemocue/milestones. Accessed 10 January 2015.
4. Bland J, Altman D. Measuring agreement in method comparison studies. Stat Methods Med Res 1999; 8:135-160.
5. Bland J, Altman D. Agreement between methods of measurement with multiple observations per individual. J Biopharm Stat 2007; 17:571-182.
6. Carstensen B. Comparing methods of measurement: Extending the LoA by regression. Stat Med 2010; 29:401-410.
7. Carstensen B, Simpson J, Gurrin L. Statistical models for assessing agreement in method comparison studies with replicate measurements. Int J Biostat 2008; 4:1-26.
8. Whiting P, Rutjes A, Westwood M, Mallett S, Deeks J, Reitsma J et al. QUADRAS-2: a revised tool for Quality assessment of diagnostic accuracy studies. Ann Intern Med 2011; 155:529-536.
9. Borenstein M, Hedges LV, Higgins JP, Rothstein HR. Introduction to Meta-analysis. 1st Ed: John Wiley & Sons Ltd, 2009.
10. Williamson P, Lancaster G, Craig J, Smyth R. Meta-analysis of method comparison studies. Stat Med 2002; 21:2013-2025.
11. Kim S, Lilot M, Murphy L, Sidhu K, Yu Z, Rinehart J et al. Accuracy of continuous noninvasive hemoglobin monitoring: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Anesth Analg 2014; 119:332-346.
12. Mimoz O, Frasca D, Soubiron L, Debaene B, Dahyot-Fizelier C. Reliability of the HemoCue hemoglobinometer in critically ill patients: a prospective observational study. Minerva Anestesiol 2011; 77:979-985.
13. Adam I, Ahmed S, Mahmoud M, Yassin M. Comparison of HemoCue hemoglobin-meter and automated hematology analyzer in measurement of hemoglobin levels in pregnant women at Khartoum hospital, Sudan. Diagn Pathol 2012; 7:30-36.
14. Kim M, Park Q, Kim M, Shin J, Kim H. Comparison of accuracy of noninvasive hemoglobin sensor (NBM-200) and portable Hemoglobinometer (Hemocue) with an automated hematology nalyzer (LH500) in blood donor screening. Ann Lab Med 2013; 33:261-267.
15. Munoz M, Romero A, Gomez J, Mantecas A, Naveira E, Ramirez G. Utility of point-of-care measurement in the HemoCue-B haemoglobin for the initial diagnosis of anaemia. Clin Lab Haematol 2005; 27:99-104.
16. Neufeld L, Garcia-Guerra A, Sanchez-Francia D, Newton-Sanchez O, Ramirez-Villalobos M, Rivera-Dommarco J. Hemoglobin measured by Hemocue and a reference method in venous and capillary blood. Salud Publica Mex 2002; 44:219-227.
17. Gomez-Simon A, Navarro-Nunez L, Perez-Ceballos E, Lozano M, Candela M, Cascales A et al. Evaluation of four rapid methods for hemoglobin screening of whole blood donors in mobile collection settings. Transfus Apher Sci 2007; 36:235-242.
18. Chen P, Short T, Leung D, Oh T. A clinical evaluation of the Hemocue haemoglobinometer using capillary, venous and arterial samples. Anaesth Intensive Care 1992; 20:497-503.
19. Hiscock R, Simmons S, Carstensen B, Gurrin L. Comparison of Masimo Pronto-7 and HemoCue Hb 201+ with laboratory haemoglobin estimation: a clinical study. Anaesth Intensive Care 2014; 42:608-613.
20. Coquin J, Dewitte A, Le Manach Y, Caujolle M, Joannes-Boyau O, Fleureau C et al. Precision of noninvasive hemoglobin-level measurements by pulse co-oximetry in patients admitted to intensive care units for severe gastrointestinal bleeds. Crit Care Med 2012; 40:2576-2582.
21. Frasca D, Dahyot-Fizelier C, Catherine K, Levrat Q, Debaene B, Mimoz O. Accuracy of a continuous noninvasive hemoglobin monitor in intensive care unit patients. Crit Care Med 2011; 39:2277-2282.
22. Nguyen B, Vincent J, Nowak E, Coat M, Paleiron N, Gouny P et al. The accuracy of noninvasive hemoglobin measurement by multiwavelength pulse oximetry after cardiac surgery. Anesth Analg 2011; 113:1052-1057.
23. Lamhaut L, Apriotesei R, Combes X, Lejay M, Vivien B. Comparison of the accuracy of noninvasive hemoglobin monitoring by spectrophotometry (SpHb) and HemoCue with automated laboratory hemoglobin measurement. Anesthesiology 2011; 115:548-554.
24. Giraud B, Frasca D, Debaene B, Mimoz O. Comparison of haemoglobin measurement methods in the operating theatre. Br J Anaesth 2013; 111:946-954.
25. Applegate R, Barr S, Collier C, Rook J, Mangus D, Allard M. Evaluation of pulse cooximetry in patients undergoing abdominal or pelvic surgery. Anesthesiology 2012; 116:65-72.
26. Berkow L, Rotolo S, Mirski E. Continuous noninvasive hemoglobin monitoring during complex spine surgery. Anesth Analg 2011; 113:1396-1402.
27. Butwick A, Hilton G, Carvalho B. Non-invasive haemoglobin measurement in patients undergoing elective caesarean section. Br J Anaesth 2012; 108:271-277.
28. Colquhoun D, Forkin K, Durieux M, Thiele R. Ability of the Masimo pulse CO-Oximeter to detect changes in hemoglobin. J Clin Monit Comput 2012; 26:69-73.
29. Isosu T, Obara S, Hosono A, Ohashi S, Nakano Y, Imaizumi T et al. Validation of continuous and noninvasive hemoglobin monitoring by pulse CO-oximetry in Japanese surgical patients. J Clin Monit Comput 2013; 27:55-60.
30. Miller R, Ward T, Shiboski S, Cohen N. A comparison of three methods of hemoglobin monitoring in patients undergoing spine surgery. Anesth Analg 2011; 112:858-863.
31. Park Y, Lee J, Song H, Byon H, Kim H, Kim J. The accuracy of noninvasive hemoglobin monitoring using the radical-7 pulse CO-Oximeter in children undergoing neurosurgery. Anesth Analg 2012; 115:1302-1307.
32. Skelton V, Wijayasinghe N, Sharafudeen S, Sange A, Parry N, Junghans C. Evaluation of point-of-care haemoglobin measuring devices: a comparison of Radical-7 pulse co-oximetry, HemoCue and laboratory haemoglobin measurements in obstetric patients. Anaesthesia 2013; 68:40-45.
33. Vos J, Kalmar A, Struys M, Porte R, Wietasch J, Scheeren T et al. Accuracy of non-invasive measurement of haemoglobin concentration by pulse co-oximetry during steady-state and dynamic conditions in liver surgery. Br J Anaesth 2012; 109:522-528.
34. Gayat E, Aulagnier J, Matthieu E, Boisson M, Fischler Ml. Noninvasive measurement of hemoglobin: assessment of two different point-of-care technologies. PLoS One 2012; 7:e30065.
35. Moore L, Wade C, Vincent L, Podbielski J, Camp E, Junco D. Evaluation of hemoglobin measurements in trauma patients. Am J Surg 2013; 206:1041-1047.
36. Al-Khabori M, Al-Hashim A, Jabeen Z, Al-Farsi K, Al-Huneini M, Al-Riyami A et al. Validation of a noninvasive pulse CO-oximetrybased hemoglobin estimation in patients with sickle cell disease. Int J Lab Hematol 2013; 35:e21-23.
37. Seguin P, Kleiber A, Chanavaz C, Morcet J, Malledant Y. Determination of capillary hemoglobin levels using the HemoCue system in intensive care patients. J Crit Care 2011; 26:423-427.
38. Gehring H, Hornberger C, Dibbelt L, Roth-Isigkeit A, Gerlach K, Schumacher J et al. Accuracy of point of care testing (POCT) for determining hemoglobin concentrations. Acta Anaesth Scand 2002; 46:980-986.
39. Srinivasan N, Kasturba M. Intra-operative point of care haemoglobin estimation: a comparison of three methods. Sri Lankan Journal of Anaesthesiology 2010; 18:15-19.
40. McNulty S, Torjman M, Grodecki W, Marr A, Schieren H. A comparison of four bedside methods of hemoglobin assessment during cardiac surgery. Anesth Analg 1995; 81:1197-1202.
41. Rippmann C, Nett P, Popovic D, Seifert B, Pasch T, Spahn D. HemoCue, an accurate bedside method of hemoglobin measurement? J Clin Monit 1997; 13:373-377.
42. Al-Khabori M, Al-Riyami A, Al-Farsi K, Al-Huneini M, Al-Hashim A, Al-Kemyani N et al. Validation of a non-invasive pulse CO-oximetry based hemoglobin estimation in normal blood donors. Transfus Apher Sci 2014; 50:95-98.
43. Sari M, de Pee S, Martini E, Herman S, Sugiatmi, Bloem M et al. Estimating the prevalence of anaemia: a comparison of three methods. Bull World Health Organ 2001; 79:506-511.
44. Knutson T, Della-Giustina D, Tomich E, Wills B, Luerssen E, Reynolds P. Evaluation of a new nonnvasive device in determining hemoglobin levels in emergency department patients. West J Emerg Med 2013; 14:283-286.
45. Mendrone A, Sabino E, Sampaio L, Neto C, Schreiber G, Chamone DA et al. Anemia screening in potential female blood donors: comparison of two different quantitative methods. Transfusion 2009; 49:662-668.
46. Van de Louw A, Lasserre N, Drouhin F, Thierry S, Lecuyer L, Caen D et al. Reliability of HemoCue in patients with gastrointestinal bleeding. Intensive Care Med 2007; 33:355-358.
47. Radtke H. Hemoglobin screening in prospective blood donors: Comparison of different blood samples and different quantitative methods. Transfus Apher Sci 2005; 33:31-35.
48. Tong E, Murphy W, Kinsella A, Darragh E, Woods J, Merphy C et al. Capillary and venous haemoglobin levels in blood donors: a 42 month study of 36,258 paired samples. Vox Sang 2009; 98:547-553.
49. Zhou X, Yan H, Xing Y, Dang S, Zhuoma B, Wang D. Evaluation of a portable hemoglobin photometer in pregnant women in a high altitude area: a pilot study. BMC Public Health 2009; 9:228-233.
50. Bhaskaram P, Balakrishna N, Radhakrishna K, Krishnaswamy K. Validation of hemoglobin estimation using HemoCue. Indian J Pediatr 2003; 70:25-28.
51. Marino Z, Carrion J, Bedini J, Crespo G, Martinez S. Evaluation of a portable hemoglobinometer (HemoCue) to control anemia in hepatitis C liver transplant recipients undergoing antiviral therapy. Eur J Gastroenterol Hepatol 2011; 23:942-947.
52. Cohen A, Seidl-Friedman J. HemoCue system for hemoglobin measurement. Evaluation in anemic and nonanemic children. Am J Clin Pathol 1988; 90:302-305.
53. Amano I, Murakami A. Use of non-invasive total hemoglobin measurement as a screenimg tool for anaemia in children. Pediatr Int 2013; 55:803-805.
54. Conway A, Hinchliffe R, Earland J, Anderson L. Measurement of haemoglobin using single drops of skin puncture blood: is precision acceptable? J Clin Pathol 1998; 51:248-250.
55. Shah N, Osea E, Martinez G. Accuracy of noninvasive hemoglobin and invasive point-of-care hemoglobin testing compared with a laboratory analyzer. Int J Lab Hematol 2014; 36:56-61.
56. Belardinelli A, Benni M, Tazzari P, Pagliaro P. Noninvasive methods for haemoglobin screening in prospective blood donors. Vox Sang 2013; 105:116-120.
57. Raikhel M. Accuracy of noninvasive and invasive point-of-care total blood hemoglobin measurements in an outpatient setting. Postgrad Med 2012; 124:250-255.
58. Lardi A, Hirst C, Mortimer A, McCollum C. Evaluation of the HemoCue for measuring intra-operative haemoglobin concentration: a comparison with the Coulter Max-M. Anaesthesia 1998; 53:349-352.
59. Macknet M, Allard M, Applegate R, Rook J. The accuracy of noninvasive and continuous total hemoglobin measurement by pulse CO-Oximetry in human subjects undergoing hemodilution. Anesth Analg 2010; 111:1424-1426.
60. Jaeger M, Ashbury T, Adams M, Duncan P. Perioperative on-site haemoglobin determination: as accurate as laboratory values? Can J Anaesth 1996; 43:795-798.
61. Bruells C, Menon A, Rossaint R, Goetzenich A, Czaplik M, Zoremba N et al. Accuracy of the Masimo Pronto-7 system in patients with left ventricular assist device. J Cardiothorac Surg 2013; 8:159-164.
62. Be W, Kerkkamp H, Booji L. Hemocue-a new haemoglobinometer in the clinic. Eur J Anaesthesiol 1991; 8:55-58.
63. Patel K, Hay G, Cheteri M, Holt D. Hemoglobin test result variability and cost analysis of eight different analyzers during open heart surgery. J Extra Corpor Technol 2007; 39:10-17.
64. Spielmann N, Mauch J, Madjdpour C, Schmugge M, Weiss M, Haas T. Accuracy and precision of hemoglobin point-of-care testing during major pediatric surgery. Int J Lab Hematol 2012; 34:86-90.
65. Dewhirst E, Naguib A, Winch P. Accuracy of noninvasive and continuous hemoglobin measurement by pulse co-oximetry during preoperative phlebotomy. J Intensive Care Med 2013; 29:238-242.
66. Yoshida A, Saito K, Ishii K, Azuma I, Sasa H, Furuya K. Assessment of noninvasive, percutaneous hemoglobin measurement in pregnant and early postpartum women. Med Devices (Auckl) 2014; 7:11-16.
67. Causey M, Miller S, Foster A, Beekley A, Zenger D, Martin M. Validation of noninvasive hemoglobin measurements using the Masimo Radical-7 SpHb station. Am J Surg 2011; 201:592-598.
68. Schapkaitz E, Mahlangu J, Letsoalo M. Point-of-care estimation of haemoglobin concentration in neonates and infants. SAJCH 2012; 6:10-11.
69. Jung Y, Lee J, Kim H, Shin S, Sohn J, Kim E, et al. The efficiency of noninvasive hemoglobin measurement by pulse co-oximetry in neonates. Pediatr Crit Care Med 2013; 14:70-73.
70. Agrawal A, Sullivan J, Zink M, Jones B. Evaluation of the Masimo Rainbow SET Radical-7 in a 6 month-old pediatric multivisceral organ transplant. J Anesth 2012; 26:629-630.
71. Rechner IJ, Twigg A, Davies AF, Imong S. Evaluation of the HemoCue compared with the Coulter STKS for measurement of neonatal haemoglobin. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2002; 86:F188-189.
72. Patel AJ, Wesley R, Leitman SF, Bryant BJ. Capillary versus venous haemoglobin determination in the assessment of healthy blood donors. Vox Sang 2013; 104:317-323.
73. Paiva A, Rondo P, Silva S, Latorre M. Comparison between the HemoCue and an automated counter for measuring hemoglobin. Rev Saude Publica 2004; 38:585-587.
74. Cohen J, Hass J. Hemoglobin correction factors for estimating the prevalence of iron deficiency anemia in pregnant women residing at high altitudes in Bolivia. Rev Panam Salud Publica 1999; 6:392-399.
75. Back S, Magnusson C, Norlund L, von Schenck H, Menschik M, Lindberg P. Multiple-site analytic evaluation of a new portable analyzer, HemoCue Hb 201+, for point-of-care testing. Point Care 2004; 3:60-65.
76. Joseph B, Hadjizacharia P, Aziz H, Snyder K, Wynne J, Kulvantunyou N et al. Continuous noninvasive hemoglobin monitor from pulse ox: ready for prime time? World J Surg 2013; 37:525-529.
77. Hudson-Thomas M, Bingham K, Simmons W. An evaluation of the HemoCue for measuring haemoglobin in field studies in Jamaica. Bull World Health Organ 1994; 72:423-426.
78. Ojengbede O, Okonkwo S, Morhason-Bello I. Comparative evaluation of haemoglobin estimation amongst pregnant women in Ibadan: Hemocue-B haemoglobin analyzer versus haemoglobincyanide (standard) method as the gold standard. Afr J Reprod Health 2008; 12:153-159.
79. Ziemann M, Lizardo B, Geusendam G, Schlenke P. Reliability of capillary hemoglobin screening under routine conditions. Transfusion 2011; 51:2714-2719.
80. Crowley C, Montenegro-Bethancourt G, Solomons N, Schumann N. Validity and correspondence of non-invasively determined hemoglobin concentrations by two trans-cutaneous digital measuring devices. Asia Pac J Clin Nutr 2012; 21:191-200.
81. Shahshahani H, Meraat N, Mansouri F. Evaluation of the validity of a rapid method for measuring high and low haemoglobin in whole blood donors. Blood Transfusion 2013; 11:385-390.
82. Krenzischek D, Tanseco F. Comparative study of bedside and laboratory measurements of hemoglobin. Am J Crit Care 1996; 5:427-432.
83. Sjostrand F, Rodhe P, Berglund E, Lundstrom N, Svensen C. The use of a noninvasive hemoglobin monitor for volume kinetic analysis in an emergency room setting. Anesth Analg 2013; 116:337-342.
84. Agarwal R, Heinz T. Bedside hemoglobinometry in hemodialysis patients: lessons from point of care testing. ASAIO J 2001; 47:240-243.
85. Bahadur S, Jain S, Jain M. Estimation of hemoglobin in blood donors: a comparative study using hemocue and cell counter. Transfus Apher Sci 2010; 43:155-157.
86. Nkrumah B, Nguah S, Sarpong N, Dekker D, Idriss A, May J et al. Hemoglobin estimation by the HemoCue(R) portable hemoglobin photometer in a resource poor setting. BMC Clin Pathol 2011; 11:5.
87. Richards N, Boyce H, Yentis S. Estimation of blood haemoglobin concentration using the HemoCue during caesarean section: the effect of sampling site. Int J Obstet Anesth 2010; 19:67-70.
88. Rosenblit J, Abreu CR, Szterling LN, Kutner JM, Hamerschlak N, Frutuoso P et al. Evaluation of three methods for hemoglobin measurement in a blood donor setting. Sao Paulo Med J 1999; 117:108-112.
89. Rudolf-Oliveira R, Goncalves K, Martignago M, Mengatto V, Gaspar P, Ferreira J et al. Comparison between two portable hemoglobinometers and a reference method to verify the reliability of screening in blood donors. Transfus Apher Sci 2013; 49:578-582.