Restrictive versus liberal transfusion strategy for red blood cell transfusion: Systematic review of randomised trials with meta-analysis and trial sequential analysis

BMJ (Online)

Volumn 350, Issue , 2015, Pages

  Holst, Lars B ^a   Petersen, Marie W ^a   Haase, Nicolai ^a   Perner, Anders ^a   Wetterslev, J o ^a  

^a Rigshospitalet   (Denmark)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ANGINA PECTORIS; BACTERIAL INFECTION; BLEEDING; BLOOD TRANSFUSION REACTION; CEREBROVASCULAR ACCIDENT; COMPARATIVE EFFECTIVENESS; ERYTHROCYTE TRANSFUSION; HEART ARREST; HEART ARRHYTHMIA; HEART INFARCTION; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; KIDNEY FAILURE; LIBERAL RED BLOOD CELL TRANSFUSION; META ANALYSIS; MORBIDITY; MORTALITY; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PATIENT RISK; PATIENT SAFETY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); RESTRICTIVE RED BLOOD CELL TRANSFUSION; REVIEW; RISK BENEFIT ANALYSIS; RISK REDUCTION; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; THROMBOEMBOLISM; TRANSIENT ISCHEMIC ATTACK; ADVERSE EFFECTS; COMPARATIVE STUDY; ODDS RATIO; PROCEDURES; STATISTICAL MODEL;

ERYTHROCYTE TRANSFUSION; HUMANS; MODELS, STATISTICAL; ODDS RATIO; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC;

EID: 84926370902     PISSN: 09598146     EISSN: 17561833     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1136/bmj.h1354     Document Type: Review

References (77)

1. Corwin HL, Gettinger A, Pearl RG, Fink MP, Levy MM, Abraham E, et al. The CRIT Study: anemia and blood transfusion in the critically ill-current clinical practice in the United States. Crit Care Med 2004;32:39-52.
2. Vincent JL, Sakr Y, Sprung CL, Ranieri VM, Reinhart K, Gerlach H, et al. Sepsis in European intensive care units: results of the SOAP study. Crit Care Med 34:344-53.
3. Rosland RG, Hagen MU, Haase N, Holst LB, Plambech M, Madsen KR, et al. Red blood cell transfusion in septic shock-clinical characteristics and outcome of unselected patients in a prospective, multicentre cohort. Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med 2014;22:14.
4. Hébert P, Wells G, Blajchman MA, Marshall JC. A multicenter, randomized, controlled clinical trial of transfusion requirements in critical care. N Engl J Med 1999;340:409-17.
5. Lacroix J, Hébert PC, Hutchison JS, Hume HA. Transfusion strategies for patients in pediatric intensive care units. N Engl J Med 2007;356:1609-19.
6. Villanueva C, Colomo A, Bosch A, Concepción M, Hernandez-Gea V, Aracil C, et al. Transfusion strategies for acute upper gastrointestinal bleeding. N Engl J Med 2013;368:11-21.
7. Hajjar LA, Vincent J, Galas FR, Nakamura RE. Transfusion Requirements After Cardiac Surgery: the TRACS Randomized Controlled Trial. JAMA 2010;304:1559-67.
8. Carson JL, Brooks MM, Abbott JD, Chaitman B, Kelsey SF, Triulzi DJ, et al. Liberal versus restrictive transfusion thresholds for patients with symptomatic coronary artery disease. Am Heart J 2013;165:964-71.e1.
9. Holst LB, Haase N, Wetterslev J, Wernerman J, Guttormsen AB, Karlsson S, et al. Lower versus higher hemoglobin threshold for transfusion in septic shock. N Engl J Med 2014;371:1381-91.
10. Walsh TS, Boyd JA, Watson D, Hope D, Lewis S, Krishan A, et al. Restrictive versus liberal transfusion strategies for older mechanically ventilated critically ill patients: a randomized pilot trial. Crit Care Med 2013;41:1-10.
11. Almeida J, Galas F, Osawa E, Fukisama J. Transfusion Requirements in Surgical Oncology Patients (TRISOP): a randomized, controlled trial. Crit Care 2013;17:s137.
12. Parker MJ. Randomised trial of blood transfusion versus a restrictive transfusion policy after hip fracture surgery. Injury 2013;44:1916-8.
13. Prick BW, Jansen AJG, Steegers EAP, Hop WCJ. Transfusion policy after severe postpartum haemorrhage: a randomised non-inferiority trial. Br J Obstetr Gynaecol 2014;121:1005-14.
14. Carson JL, Carless PA, Hébert PC. Transfusion thresholds and other strategies for guiding allogeneic red blood cell transfusion. Cochrane Database Syst 2012;18:CD002042.
15. Carson JL, Terrin ML, Noveck H, Sanders DW, Chaitman BR, Rhoads GG, et al. Liberal or restrictive transfusion in high-risk patients after hip surgery. N Engl J Med 2011;365:2453-62.
16. Napolitano LM, Kurek S, Luchette FA, Corwin HL, Barie PS, Tisherman SA, et al. Clinical practice guideline: red blood cell transfusion in adult trauma and critical care. Crit Care Med 2009;37:3124-57.
17. Higgins J, Green S, eds. Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions, version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011]. Cochrane Collaboration 2011. www.cochrane-handbook.org.
18. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman D, Group P. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. BMJ 2009;399:b2700.
19. Guyatt GH. GRADE: what is " quality of evidence " and why is it important to clinicians? BMJ 2008;336:995-8.
20. Wetterslev J, Thorlund K, Brok J, Gluud C. Trial sequential analysis may establish when firm evidence is reached in cumulative meta-analysis. J Clin Epidemiol 2008;61:64-75.
21. DeMets DL. Methods of combining randomized clinical trials: strengths and limitations. Stat Med 1987;6:341-50.
22. Higgins JPT, Thompson SG. Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis. Stat Med 2002;21:1539-58.
23. Turner RM, Bird SM, Higgins JPT. The impact of study size on meta-analyses: examination of underpowered studies in Cochrane reviews. PLoS One 2013;8:e59202.
24. Brok J, Thorlund K, Wetterslev J, Gluud C. Apparently conclusive meta-analyses may be inconclusive-trial sequential analysis adjustment of random error risk due to repetitive testing of accumulating data in apparently conclusive neonatal meta-analyses. Int J Epidemiol 2009;38:287-98.
25. Bangalore S, Kumar S, Wetterslev J, Messerli FH. Angiotensin receptor blockers and risk of myocardial infarction: meta-analyses and trial sequential analyses of 147 020 patients from randomised trials. BMJ 2011;342:d2234.
26. Thorlund K, Devereaux PJ, Wetterslev J, Guyatt G, Ioannidis JP, Thabane L, et al. Can trial sequential monitoring boundaries reduce spurious inferences from meta-analyses? Int J Epidemiol 2009;38:276-86.
27. Wetterslev J, Thorlund K, Brok J, Gluud C. Estimating required information size by quantifying diversity in random-effects model meta-analyses. BMC Med Res Methodol 2009;9:86.
28. Foss NB, Kristensen MT, Jensen PS, Palm H. The effects of liberal versus restrictive transfusion thresholds on ambulation after hip fracture surgery. Transfusion 2009;49:227-34.
29. Blair SD, Janvrin SB, McCollum CN, Greenhalgh RM. Effect of early blood transfusion on gastrointestinal haemorrhage. Br J Surg 1986;73:783-5.
30. Bush RL, Pevec WC, Holcroft JW. A prospective, randomized trial limiting perioperative red blood cell transfusions in vascular patients. Am J Surg 1997;174:143-8.
31. Bracey AW, Radovancevic R, Riggs SA, Houston S, Cozart H, Vaughn WK, et al. Lowering the hemoglobin threshold for transfusion in coronary artery bypass procedures: effect on patient outcome. Transfusion 1999;39:1070-7.
32. Carson JL, Terrin ML, Barton FB, Aaron R, Greenburg AG, Heck DA, et al. A pilot randomized trial comparing symptomatic vs. hemoglobin- level-driven red blood cell transfusions following hip fracture. Transfusion 1998;38:522-9.
33. Cholette JM, Rubenstein JS, Alfieris GM, Powers KS, Eaton M, Lerner NB. Children with single-ventricle physiology do not benefit from higher hemoglobin levels post cavopulmonary connection: results of a prospective, randomized, controlled trial of a restrictive versus liberal red-cell transfusion strategy. Pediatr Crit care Med 2011;12:39-45.
34. Fortune JB, Feustel PJ, Saifi J, Stratton HH, Newell JC, Shah DM. Influence of hematocrit on cardiopulmonary function after acute hemorrhage. J Trauma 1987;27:243-9.
35. De Gast-Bakker DH, de Wilde RBP, Hazekamp MG, Sojak V, Zwaginga JJ, Wolterbeek R, et al. Safety and effects of two red blood cell transfusion strategies in pediatric cardiac surgery patients: a randomized controlled trial. Intensive Care Med 2013;39:2011-9.
36. Grover M, Talwalkar S, Casbard A, Boralessa H, Contreras M, Brett S, et al. Silent myocardial ischaemia and haemoglobin concentration: a randomized controlled trial of transfusion strategy in lower limb arthroplasty. Vox Sang 2006;90:105-12.
37. Hébert PC. Transfusion requirements in critical care, a pilot study. JAMA 1995;273:1439-48.
38. Johnson RG, Thurer RL, Kruskall MS, Sirois C, Gervino E V, Critchlow J, et al. Comparison of two transfusion strategies after elective operations for myocardial revascularization. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1992;104:307-14.
39. Lotke PA, Barth P, Garino JP, Cook EF. Predonated autologous blood transfusions after total knee arthroplasty: immediate versus delayed administration. J Arthroplasty 1999;14:647-50.
40. Robertson CS, Hannay HJ, Yamal J-M, Gopinath S, Goodman JC, Tilley BC, et al. Effect of erythropoietin and transfusion threshold on neurological recovery after traumatic brain injury. JAMA 2014;312:36.
41. Shehata N, Burns LA, Nathan H, Hébert P, Hare GMT, Fergusson D, et al. A randomized controlled pilot study of adherence to transfusion strategies in cardiac surgery. Transfusion 2012;52:91-9.
42. Wu JF, Guan XD, Chen J, Ou-Yang B. A randomized, controlled clinical trial of transfusion of requirement in patients after orthotopicliver transplantation. ESICM LIVES 2011, 24th annual congress 2011;37:1-314.
43. Zygun DA, Nortje J, Hutchinson PJ, Timofeev I, Menon DK, Gupta AK. The effect of red blood cell transfusion on cerebral oxygenation and metabolism after severe traumatic brain injury. Neurologic Crit Care 2009;37:1074-8.
44. Webert KE, Cook RJ, Couban S, Carruthers J, Lee KA, Blajchman MA, et al. A multicenter pilot-randomized controlled trial of the feasibility of an augmented red blood cell transfusion strategy for patients treated with induction chemotherapy for acute leukemia or stem cell transplantation. Transfusion 2008;48(1):81-91.
45. So-Osman C, Nelissen R, Te Slaa R, Coene L, Brand R, Brand A. A randomized comparison of transfusion triggers in elective orthopaedic surgery using leucocyte-depleted red blood cells. Vox Sang 2010;98:56-64.
46. So-Osman C, Hout WB Van Den, Brand R, Brand A. Patient blood management in elective total hip- and knee-replacement surgery (part 2): a randomized controlled trial on blood salvage as transfusion alternative using a restrictive transfusion policy in patients with a preoperative hemoglobin above 13 g/dl. Anesthesiology 2014;120:852-60.
47. So-Osman C, Nelissen RGHH, Koopman-van Gemert AWMM, Kluyver E, Pöll RG, Onstenk R, et al. Patient blood management in elective total hip- and knee-replacement surgery (Part 1): a randomized controlled trial on erythropoietin and blood salvage as transfusion alternatives using a restrictive transfusion policy in erythropoietineligible patients. Anesthesiology 2014;120:839-51.
48. Topley E, Fisher MR. The illness of trauma. Br J Clin Pract 1956;10:770-6.
49. Vichinsky EP, Haberkern CM, Neumayr L, Earles AN, Black D, Koshy M, et al. A comparison of conservative and aggressive transfusion regimens in the perioperative management of sickle cell disease. The Preoperative Transfusion in Sickle Cell Disease Study Group. N Engl J Med 1995;333:206-13.
50. Olgun H, Buyukavci M, Sepetcigil O, Yildirim ZK, Karacan M, Ceviz N. Comparison of safety and effectiveness of two different transfusion rates in children with severe anemia. J Pediatr Hematol Oncol 2009;31:843-6.
51. Atilla E, Topcuoglu P, Yavasoglu S, Karakaya A, Gencturk C, Bozdag S, et al. A randomized comparison of hemoglobin content-based vs standard (Unit-Based) RBC transfusion policy efficiencies. Vox Sang 2011;101(suppl 2):39-134.
52. Karkouti K, Wijeysundera DN, Yau TM, McCluskey SA, Chan CT, Wong PY, et al. Advance targeted transfusion in anemic cardiac surgical patients for kidney protection: an unblinded randomized pilot clinical trial. Anesthesiology 2012;116:613-21.
53. Zheng H, Wu JJ, Wang J. Evaluation of effectiveness and analysis of goal-directed blood transfusion in peri-operation of major orthopedic surgery in elderly patients. Exp Ther Med 2013;5:511-6.
54. McCoy TE, Conrad AL, Richman LC, Lindgren SD, Nopoulos PC, Bell EF. Neurocognitive profiles of preterm infants randomly assigned to lower or higher hematocrit thresholds for transfusion. Child Neuropsychol 2011;17:347-67.
55. Chen H-L, Tseng H-I, Lu C-C, Yang S-N, Fan H-C, Yang R-C. Effect of blood transfusions on the outcome of very low body weight preterm infants under two different transfusion criteria. Pediatr Neonatol 2009;50:110-6. 56 Bell 2005
56. Whyte RK, Kirpalani H, Asztalos EV, Andersen C, Blajchman M, Heddle N, et al. Neurodevelopmental outcome of extremely low birth weight infants randomly assigned to restrictive or liberal hemoglobin thresholds for blood transfusion. Pediatrics 2009;123:207-13.
57. Nopoulos PC, Conrad AL, Bell EF, Strauss RG, Widness JA, Magnotta VA. Long-term outcome of brain structure in premature infants: effects of liberal vs restricted red blood cell transfusions. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 2011;165:443-50.
58. Fredrickson LK, Bell EF, Cress GA, Johnson KJ, Zimmerman MB, Mahoney LT, et al. Acute physiological effects of packed red blood cell transfusion in preterm infants with different degrees of anaemia. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2011;96:249-53.
59. Elterman J, Brasel K, Brown S, Bulger E, Kerby JD, Kannas D, et al. Transfusion of red blood cells in patients with a pre-hospital gcs ≤8 and no evidence of shock is associated with worse outcomes. J Trauma Acute Care Sur 2013;75:1-13.
60. Colomo A, Hernandez-Gea V, Muniz-Diaz E, Madoz P, Araci LC, C. Alvarez-Urturi C, et al. Transfusion strategies in patients with cirrhosis and acute gastrointestinal bleeding. Hepatology 2008;48:413A.
61. Karam O, Tucci M, Ducruet T, Hume HA, Lacroix J, Gauvin F. Red blood cell transfusion thresholds in pediatric patients with sepsis. Pediatr Crit Care Med 2011;12:512-8.
62. Rouette J, Trottier H, Ducruet T, Beaunoyer M, Lacroix J, Tucci M. Red blood cell transfusion threshold in postsurgical pediatric intensive care patients: a randomized clinical trial. Ann Surg 2010;251:421-7.
63. Willems A, Harrington K, Lacroix J, Biarent D, Joffe AR, Wensley D, et al. Comparison of two red-cell transfusion strategies after pediatric cardiac surgery: a subgroup analysis. Pediatr Crit care 2010;38:649-56.
64. Nakamura R, Sundin M, Fukushima J, Almeida J, Gergamin F. A liberal strategy of red blood cell transfusion reduces cardiovascular complications in older patients undergoing cardiac surgery. Crit Care 2014;18:P107.
65. Bergamin F, Almeida J, Park C, Osawa E, Silva J. Transfusion requirements in septic shock patients: a randomized controlled trial. Crit Care 2014;18:112.
66. Pike K, Brierley R, Rogers CA, Murphy GJ, Reeves BC. Adherence in a randomised controlled trial comparing liberal and restrictive red blood cell (RBC) transfusion protocols after cardiac surgery (TITRe2). Trials 2011;12(suppl 1):A121.
67. Gray A, Jairath V, Kahan B, Dore C, Palmer K, Travis S, et al. Restrictive versus liberal blood transfusion for acute upper gastrointestinal bleeding (trigger): pragmatic, cluster randomised, feasibility trial. Emerg Med J 2014;31:780.
68. Franz AR, Maier RF, Thome UH, Rudiger M, Kron M, Bassler D, et al. The "effects of transfusion thresholds on neurocognitive outcome of extremely low birth-weight infants (ETTNO)" study: background, aims, and study protocol. Neonatology 2012;101:301-5.
69. Brown CH, Grega M, Selnes OA, McKhann GM, Shah AS, LaFlam A, et al. Length of red cell unit storage and risk for delirium after cardiac surgery. Anesth Analg 2014;119:242-50.
70. Kirpalani H, Whyte RK, Andersen C, Asztalos EV, Heddle N, Blajchman MA, et al. The premature infants in need of transfusion(pint) study: a randomized, controlled trial of a restrictive (low) versus liberal (high) transfusion threshold for extremely low birth weight infants. J Pediatr 2006;149:301-7.e3.
71. Gregersen M, Borris LC, Damsgaard EM. A liberal blood transfusion strategy after hip fracture surgery does not increase the risk of infection in frail elderly. Eur Geriatr Med 2012;32:S74.
72. Cooper HA, Rao SV, Greenberg MD, Rumsey MP, McKenzie M, Alcorn KW, et al. Conservative versus liberal red cell transfusion in acute myocardial infarction (the CRIT Randomized Pilot Study). Am J Cardiol 2011;108:1108-11.
73. Salpeter SR, Buckley JS, Chatterjee S. Impact of more restrictive blood transfusion strategies on clinical outcomes: a meta-analysis and systematic review. Am J Med 2013;127:124-31.e3.
74. Rohde JM, Dimcheff DE, Blumberg N, Saint S, Langa KM, Kuhn L, et al. Health care-associated infection after red blood cell transfusion. JAMA 2014;311:1317.
75. Savovic J, Jones HE, Altman DG, Harris RJ. Influence of reported study design characteristics on intervention effect estimates from randomized, controlled trials. Ann Intern Med 2012;157:429-38.
76. Chatterjee S, Wetterslev J, Sharma A, Lichstein E, Mukherjee D. Association of blood transfusion with increased mortality in myocardial infarction: a meta-analysis and diversity-adjusted study sequential analysis. JAMA Intern Med 2013;173:132-9.
77. LeRoux P. Haemoglobin management in acute brain injury. Curr Opin Crit Care 2013;19:83-91.