Comparison of perioperative outcomes between robotic and laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: A systematic review and meta-analysis

European Urology

Volumn 67, Issue 5, 2015, Pages 891-901

  Choi, Ji Eun ^a   You, Ji Hye ^a   Kim, Dae Keun ^b   Rha, Koon Ho ^b   Lee, Seon Heui ^c  

^a National Evidence Based Healthcare Collaborating Agency   (South Korea)

^b Yonsei University College of Medicine   (South Korea)

^c Gachon University College of Medicine   (South Korea)

Author keywords

Kidney neoplasms; Laparoscopy; Nephrectomy; Robotics

Indexed keywords

CREATININE;

BLEEDING; CONVERSION TO OPEN SURGERY; CREATININE BLOOD LEVEL; GLOMERULUS FILTRATION RATE; HUMAN; ISCHEMIA; KIDNEY CANCER; LAPAROSCOPIC PARTIAL NEPHRECTOMY; LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY; LENGTH OF STAY; META ANALYSIS; OPERATION DURATION; PARTIAL NEPHRECTOMY; PERIOPERATIVE PERIOD; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; ROBOTIC PARTIAL NEPHRECTOMY; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; TREATMENT OUTCOME; DEVICES; LAPAROSCOPY; NEPHRECTOMY; PROCEDURES; ROBOTIC SURGICAL PROCEDURE; ROBOTICS; STATISTICS AND NUMERICAL DATA;

CONVERSION TO OPEN SURGERY; GLOMERULAR FILTRATION RATE; HUMANS; LAPAROSCOPY; LENGTH OF STAY; NEPHRECTOMY; OPERATIVE TIME; ROBOTIC SURGICAL PROCEDURES; ROBOTICS; TREATMENT OUTCOME; WARM ISCHEMIA;

EID: 84926205878     PISSN: 03022838     EISSN: 18737560     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.eururo.2014.12.028     Document Type: Review

References (37)

1. S. MacLennan, M. Imamura, and M.C. Lapitan Systematic review of oncological outcomes following surgical management of localised renal cancer Eur Urol 61 2012 972 993
2. B. Ljungberg, N.C. Cowan, and D.C. Hanbury EAU guidelines on renal cell carcinoma: the 2010 update Eur Urol 58 2010 398 406
3. P.M. Pierorazio, H.D. Patel, T. Feng, J. Yohannan, E.S. Hyams, and M.E. Allaf Robotic-assisted versus traditional laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: comparison of outcomes and evaluation of learning curve Urology 78 2011 813 819
4. C. Ho, E. Tsakonas, and K. Tran Robot-assisted surgery compared with open surgery and laparoscopic surgery: clinical effectiveness and economic analyses [Technology report no. 137] 2011 Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health Ottawa, Canada
5. X. Zhang, Z. Shen, S. Zhong, Z. Zhu, X. Wang, and T. Xu Comparison of peri-operative outcomes of robot-assisted vs laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: a meta-analysis BJU Int 112 2013 1133 1142
6. S. Froghi, K. Ahmed, M.S. Khan, P. Dasgupta, and B. Challacombe Evaluation of robotic and laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for small renal tumours (T1a) BJU Int 112 2013 E322 E333
7. L. Bi, C. Zhang, and K. Li Robotic partial nephrectomy for renal tumors larger than 4 cm: a systematic review and meta-analysis PLoS One 8 2013 e75050
8. A. Masson-Lecomte, K. Bensalah, and E. Seringe A prospective comparison of surgical and pathological outcomes obtained after robot-assisted or pure laparoscopic partial nephrectomy in moderate to complex renal tumours: results from a French multicentre collaborative study BJU Int 111 2013 256 263
9. J.A. Long, R. Yakoubi, and B. Lee Robotic versus laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for complex tumors: comparison of perioperative outcomes Eur Urol 61 2012 1257 1262
10. H.J. Lavery, A.C. Small, D.B. Samadi, and M.A. Palese Transition from laparoscopic to robotic partial nephrectomy: the learning curve for an experienced laparoscopic surgeon JSLS 15 2011 291 297
11. K. Slim, E. Nini, D. Forestier, F. Kwiatkowski, Y. Panis, and J. Chipponi Methodological index for non-randomized studies (minors): development and validation of a new instrument ANZ J Surg 73 2003 712 716
12. J.P. Higgins, S.G. Thompson, J.J. Deeks, and D.G. Altman Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses BMJ 327 2003 557 560
13. R.H. Thompson, B.R. Lane, and C.M. Lohse Every minute counts when the renal hilum is clamped during partial nephrectomy Eur Urol 58 2010 340 345
14. O.M. Aboumarzouk, R.J. Stein, and R. Eyraud Robotic versus laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: a systematic review and meta-analysis Eur Urol 62 2012 1023 1033
15. M. Boger, S.M. Lucas, S.C. Popp, T.A. Gardner, and C.P. Sundaram Comparison of robot-assisted nephrectomy with laparoscopic and hand-assisted laparoscopic nephrectomy JSLS 14 2010 374 380
16. T. Deklaj, D.A. Lifshitz, S.A. Shikanov, M.H. Katz, K.C. Zorn, and A.L. Shalhav Laparoscopic radical versus laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for clinical T1bN0M0 renal tumors: comparison of perioperative, pathological, and functional outcomes J Endourol 24 2010 1603 1607
17. M.T. Gettman, M.L. Blute, G.K. Chow, R. Neururer, G. Bartsch, and R. Peschel Robotic-assisted laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: technique and initial clinical experience with DaVinci robotic system Urology 64 2004 914 918
18. V. Ficarra, S. Bhayani, and J. Porter Robot-assisted partial nephrectomy for renal tumors larger than 4 cm: results of a multicenter, international series World J Urol 30 2012 665 670
19. Komninos C, Shin TY, Tuliao P, et al. Renal function is the same regardless of clamp technique 6 months after robot-assisted partial nephrectomy: analysis of off-clamp, selective arterial clamp and main artery clamp with minimum of 1 year follow-up. BJU Int. In press. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/bju.12975
20. M. Alemozaffar, S.L. Chang, R. Kacker, M. Sun, W.C. DeWolf, and A.A. Wagner Comparing costs of robotic, laparoscopic, and open partial nephrectomy J Endourol 27 2013 560 565
21. D. Chaste, J.P. Couapel, and T. Fardoun Robot-assisted partial nephrectomy versus laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: a single institution experience [in French] Prog Urol 23 2013 176 183
22. S.B. Williams, R. Kacker, M. Alemozaffar, I.S. Francisco, J. Mechaber, and A.A. Wagner Robotic partial nephrectomy versus laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: a single laparoscopic trained surgeon's experience in the development of a robotic partial nephrectomy program World J Urol 31 2013 793 798
23. J.S. Ellison, J.S. Montgomery, J.S. Wolf Jr., K.S. Hafez, D.C. Miller, and A.Z. Weizer A matched comparison of perioperative outcomes of a single laparoscopic surgeon versus a multisurgeon robot-assisted cohort for partial nephrectomy J Urol 188 2012 45 50
24. E. Hyams, P. Pierorazio, J.K. Mullins, M. Ward, and M. Allaf A comparative cost analysis of robot-assisted versus traditional laparoscopic partial nephrectomy J Endourol 26 2012 843 847
25. S.M. Lucas, M.J. Mellon, L. Erntsberger, and C.P. Sundaram A comparison of robotic, laparoscopic and open partial nephrectomy JSLS 16 2012 581 587
26. C.L. Cho, K.L. Ho, S.S. Chu, and P.C. Tam Robot-assisted versus standard laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: comparison of perioperative outcomes from a single institution Hong Kong Med J 17 2011 33 38
27. I.Y. Seo, H. Choi, Y. Boldbaatr, J.W. Lee, and J.S. Rim Operative outcomes of robotic partial nephrectomy: a comparison with conventional laparoscopic partial nephrectomy Korean J Urol 52 2011 279 283
28. J.D. Choi, J.W. Park, and J.Y. Choi Renal damage caused by warm ischaemia during laparoscopic and robot-assisted partial nephrectomy: an assessment using Tc 99m-DTPA glomerular filtration rate Eur Urol 58 2010 900 905
29. J.M. DeLong, O. Shapiro, and A. Moinzadeh Comparison of laparoscopic versus robotic assisted partial nephrectomy: one surgeon's initial experience Can J Urol 17 2010 5207 5212
30. G.P. Haber, W.M. White, and S. Crouzet Robotic versus laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: single-surgeon matched cohort study of 150 patients Urology 76 2010 754 758
31. S.D. Wu, D.P. Viprakasit, J. Cashy, N.D. Smith, K.T. Perry, and R.B. Nadler Radiofrequency ablation-assisted robotic laparoscopic partial nephrectomy without renal hilar vessel clamping versus laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: a comparison of perioperative outcomes J Endourol 24 2010 385 391
32. B.M. Benway, S.B. Bhayani, and C.G. Rogers Robot assisted partial nephrectomy versus laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for renal tumors: a multi-institutional analysis of perioperative outcomes J Urol 182 2009 866 872
33. W. Jeong, S.Y. Park, E.I. Lorenzo, C.K. Oh, W.K. Han, and K.H. Rha Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy versus robot-assisted laparoscopic partial nephrectomy J Endourol 23 2009 1457 1460
34. J.H. Kaouk, and R.K. Goel Single-port laparoscopic and robotic partial nephrectomy Eur Urol 55 2009 1163 1169
35. A.R. Kural, F. Atug, I. Tufek, and H. Akpinar Robot-assisted partial nephrectomy versus laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: comparison of outcomes J Endourol 23 2009 1491 1497
36. A.J. Wang, and S.B. Bhayani Robotic partial nephrectomy versus laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for renal cell carcinoma: single-surgeon analysis of >100 consecutive procedures Urology 73 2009 306 310
37. M. Aron, P. Koenig, J.H. Kaouk, M.M. Nguyen, M.M. Desai, and I.S. Gill Robotic and laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: a matched-pair comparison from a high-volume centre BJU Int 102 2008 86 92