A review on anaerobic biofilm reactors for the treatment of dairy industry wastewater

Process Biochemistry

Volumn 50, Issue 2, 2015, Pages 262-271

  Karadag, Dogan ^a   Köroʇlu, Oguz Emre ^a   Ozkaya, Bestami ^a   Cakmakci, Mehmet ^a  

^a YILDIZ TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY   (Turkey)

Author keywords

Anaerobic treatment; Biofilm reactor; Dairy wastewater; Methane yield

Indexed keywords

BIOCONVERSION; BIODEGRADABILITY; BIOFILMS; BIOREACTORS; DAIRY PRODUCTS; HEAVY METALS; METHANE;

ANAEROBIC TREATMENTS; BIOFILM REACTORS; DAIRY WASTEWATER; HYDRAULIC RETENTION TIME; METHANE YIELD; OPERATIONAL CONDITIONS; ORGANIC LOADING RATES; ORGANIC MATTER REMOVAL;

WASTEWATER TREATMENT;

EID: 84922606107     PISSN: 13595113     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.procbio.2014.11.005     Document Type: Review

References (96)

1. A.A. Chatzipaschali, and A.G. Stamatis Biotechnological utilization with a focus on anaerobic treatment of cheese whey: current status and prospects Energies 5 2012 3492 3525
2. S. Goblos, P. Portoro, D. Bordas, M. Kalman, and I. Kiss Comparison of the effectivities of two-phase and single-phase anaerobic sequencing batch reactors during dairy wastewater treatment Renew Energy 33 2008 960 965
3. V. Perna, E. Castello, J. Wenzel, C. Zampol, D.M.F. Lima, L. Borzacconi, et al. Hydrogen production in an upflow anaerobic packed bed reactor used to treat cheese whey Int J Hydrogen Energy 38 2013 54 62
4. M. Amini, H. Younesi, A.A.Z. Lorestani, and G.D. Najafpour Determination of optimum conditions for dairy wastewater treatment in UAASB reactor for removal of nutrients Bioresour Technol 145 2013 71 79
5. G. Merlin, F. Kohler, M. Bouvier, T. Lissolo, and H. Boileau Importance of heat transfer in an anaerobic digestion plant in a continental climate context Bioresour Technol 124 2012 59 67
6. E.C. Urbin, A.R.N. Munoz, F.J.M. Rojas, C.J. Ramirez, N.R. Ordaz, and J.G. Mayer Batch and fed-batch cultures for the treatment of whey with mixed yeast cultures Process Biochem 35 2000 649 657
7. G. Guven, A. Perendeci, and A. Tanyolac Electrochemical treatment of deproteinated whey wastewater and optimization of treatment conditions with response surface methodology J Hazard Mater 157 2008 69 78
8. J.P. Kushwaha, V.C. Srivastava, and I.D. Mall An overview of various technologies for the treatment of dairy wastewaters Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 51 2011 442 452
9. V.D. Savant, and J.A. Torres Chitosan-based coagulating agents for treatment of cheddar cheese whey Biotechnol Prog 16 2000 1091 1097
10. J. Rivas, A.R. Prazeres, F. Carvalho, and F. Beltran Treatment of cheese whey wastewater: combined coagulation-flocculation and aerobic biodegradation J Agric Food Chem 58 2010 7871 7877
11. B. Sarkar, P.P. Chakrabarti, A. Vijaykumar, and V. Kale Wastewater treatment in dairy industries - possibility of reuse Desalination 195 2006 141 152
12. M. Turan Influence of filtration conditions on the performance of nanofiltration and reverse osmosis membranes in dairy wastewater treatment Desalination 170 2004 83 90
13. L.H. Andrade, F.D.S. Mendes, J.C. Espindola, and M.C.S. Amaral Nanofiltration as tertiary treatment for the reuse of dairy wastewater treated by membrane bioreactor Sep Purif Technol 126 2014 21 29
14. A.R. Prazeres, F. Carvalho, and J. Rivas Cheese whey management: a review J Environ Manage 110 2012 48 68
15. B. Demirel, O. Yenigun, and T.T. Onay Anaerobic treatment of dairy wastewaters: a review Process Biochem 40 2005 2583 2595
16. A. Gomez, J. Zubizarreta, M. Rodrigues, C. Dopazo, and N. Fueyo An estimation of the energy potential of agro-industrial residues in Spain Resour Conserv Recycl 54 2010 972 984
17. P. Kaparaju, and J. Rintala Mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions by adopting anaerobic digestion technology on dairy, sow and pig farms in Finland Renew Energy 36 2011 31 41
18. T.H. Erguder, U. Tezel, E. Guven, and G.N. Demirer Anaerobic biotransformation and methane generation potential of cheese whey in batch and UASB reactors Waste Manage 21 2001 643 650
19. A.V. Qasim, and A.V. Mane Characterization and treatment of selected food industrial effluents by coagulation and adsorption techniques Water Resour Ind 4 2013 1 12
20. S.J. Rad, and M.J. Lewis Water utilisation, energy utilisation and waste water management in the dairy industry: a review Int J Dairy Technol 67 2014 1 20
21. H. Gannoun, E. Khelifi, H. Bouallagui, Y. Touhami, and M. Hamdi Ecological clarification of cheese whey prior to anaerobic digestion in upflow anaerobic filter Bioresour Technol 99 2008 6105 6111
22. D. Traversi, S. Bonetta, R. Degan, S. Villa, A. Porfido, M. Bellero, et al. Environmental advances due to the integration of food industries and anaerobic digestion for biogas production: perspectives of the Italian milk and dairy product sector Bioenergy Res 6 2013 851 863
23. R. Borja, and C.J. Banks Response of an anaerobic fluidized bed reactor treating ice-cream wastewater to organic, hydraulic, temperature and pH shocks J Biotechnol 39 1995 251 259
24. F.R. Hawkes, T. Donnely, and G.K. Anderson Comparative performance of anaerobic digesters operating on ice-cream wastewater Water Res 29 1995 525 533
25. S. Wang, N.C. Rao, R. Qiu, and R. Molett Performance and kinetic evaluation of anaerobic moving bed biofilm reactor for treating milk permeate from dairy industry Bioresour Technol 100 2009 5641 5647
26. R.A. Bezerra, J.A.D. Rodrigues, S.M. Ratusznei, M. Zaiat, and E. Foresti Whey treatment by AnSBBR with circulation: effects of organic loading, shock loads and alkalinity supplementation Appl Biochem Biotechnol 143 2007 257 275
27. A.A. Pretti, J.G. Moreno, R.S.S. Santana, and S. Cristina Effect of configuration of biomass on the behaviour of anaerobic batch reactors in pilot-scale treating dairy wastewater 11th international congress on engineering and food Greece, 22-26 May 2011
28. O. Ince Potential energy production from anaerobic digestion of dairy wastewater J Environ Sci Health, Part A 33 1998 1219 1228
29. J.R. Banu, S. Anandan, S. Kaliappan, and I.T. Yeom Treatment of dairy wastewater using anaerobic and solar photocatalytic methods Sol Energy 82 2008 812 819
30. R. Borja, and C.J. Banks Kinetics of an upflow anaerobic sludge blanket reactor treating ice-cream wastewater Environ Technol 15 1994 219 232
31. M. Rodgers, X.M. Zhan, and B. Dolan Mixing characteristics and whey wastewater treatment of a novel moving anaerobic biofilm reactor J Environ Sci Health 39 2004 2183 2193
32. K. Kundu, I. Bergmann, S. Hahnke, M. Klocke, S. Sharma, and T.R. Sreekrishnan Carbon source - a strong determinant of microbial community structure and performance of an anaerobic reactor J Biotechnol 168 2013 616 624
33. W.C. Hu, K. Thayanithy, and C.F. Forster A kinetic study of the anaerobic digestion of ice-cream wastewater Process Biochem 37 2002 965 971
34. C.B. Cota-Navarro, J. Carrillo-Reyes, G. Davila-Vazquez, F. Alatriste-Mondragon, and E. Razo-Flores Continuous hydrogen and methane production in a two-stage cheese whey fermentation system Water Sci Technol 64 2011 367 374
35. M. Kisielewska, I. Wysocka, and Rynkiewicz Continuous biohydrogen and biomethane production from whey permeate in a two-stage fermentation process Environ Prog Sust Energy 33 2014 1411 1418
36. H.Q. Yu, and H.H.P. Fang Acidogenesis of dairy wastewater at various pH levels Water Sci Technol 45 2002 201 206
37. P. Sivakumar, M. Bhagiyalakshmi, and K. Anbarasu Anaerobic treatment of spoiled milk from milk processing industry for energy recovery - a laboratory to pilot scale study Fuel 96 2012 482 486
38. G. Zayed, and J. Winter Inhibition of methane production from whey by heavy metals protective effect of sulphide Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 53 2000 726 731
39. V.I. Diamantis, A.G. Kapagiannidisd, S. Ntougias, V. Tataki, P. Melidis, and A. Aivasidis Two-stage CSTR-UASB digestion enables superior and alkali addition-free cheese whey treatment Biochem Eng 84 2014 45 52
40. S.V. Kalyuzhnyi, E.P. Martinez, and J.P. Martinez Anaerobic treatment of high-strength cheese whey wastewaters in laboratory and pilot UASB-reactors Bioresour Technol 60 1997 59 65
41. G.K. Anderson, and G. Yang pH control in anaerobic treatment of industrial wastewater J Environ Eng 118 1992 551 567
42. A. Haridas, S. Surech, K.R. Chitra, and V.B. Manilal The Buoyant filter bioreactor: a high-rate anaerobic reactor for complex wastewater - process dynamics with dairy effluent Water Res 39 2005 993 1004
43. M.M. Alves, J.A.M. Vieira, R.M.A. Pereira, M.A. Pereira, and M. Mota Effect of lipids and oleic acid on biomass development in anaerobic fixed-bed reactors. Part I. Biofilm growth and activity Water Res 35 2001 255 263
44. S. Suwannoppadol, G. Ho, and R.C. Ruwisch Overcoming sodium toxicity by utilizing grass leaves as co-substrate during the start-up of batch thermophilic anaerobic digestion Bioresour Technol 125 2012 188 192
45. P. Patel, M. Desai, and D. Madamwar Biomethanation of cheese whey using anaerobic upflow fixed film reactor J Ferment Bioeng 79 1995 398 399
46. G. Zellner, P. Vogel, H. Kneifel, and J. Winter Anaerobic digestion of whey and whey permeate with suspended and immobilized complex and defined consortia Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 27 1987 306 314
47. M. Liu, Y. Zhao, B. Xi, and L. Hou Efficiency of a hybrid granular bed-contact oxidation biofilm baffled reactor for treating molasses wastewater Desalination Water Treat 2014 1 8
48. O.B. Zizi, and H.A. Amar Treatment of dairy wastewater by fixed-film system in continuous flow Desalination Water Treat 51 2013 2214 2224
49. P.A.G. Encina, and M.D. Hidalgo Influence of substrate feed patterns on biofilm development in anaerobic fluidized bed reactors (AFBR) Process Biochem 40 2005 2509 2516
50. S. Wang, N.C. Rao, R. Qiu, and R. Molett Treatability and kinetic analysis of anaerobic moving bed biofilm reactor treating high strength milk permeate Desalination Water Treat 4 2009 1 3
51. R. Rajagopal, N.M.C. Saady, M. Torrijos, J.V. Thanikal, and Y.T. Hung Sustainable agro-food industrial wastewater treatment using high rate anaerobic process Water 5 2013 292 311
52. J.I. Qazi, M. Nadeem, S.S. Baig, S. Baig, and Q. Syed Anaerobic fixed film biotreatment of dairy wastewater Middle-East J Sci Res 8 2011 590 593
53. G.D. Najafpour, M. Komeili, M. Tajallipour, and M. Asadi Bioconversion of cheese whey to methane in an upflow anaerobic packed bed bioreactor Chem Biochem Eng Q 24 2010 111 117
54. G.K. Anderson, B. Kasapgil, and O. Ince Comparison of porous and non-porous media in upflow anaerobic filters when treating dairy wastewater Water Res 28 1994 1619 1624
55. S.T. Yang, and M.A. Guo Kinetic model for methanogenesis from whey permeate in a packed bed immobilized cell bioreactor Biotechnol Bioeng 37 2004 375 382
56. O. Ince, B.K. Ince, and T. Donnelly Attachment, strength and performance of a porous media in an upflow anaerobic filter treating dairy wastewater Water Sci Technol 41 2000 261 270
57. D.M. Marques, S. Cayless, and J.N. Lester An investigation of start-up in anaerobic filters utilising dairy waste Environ Technol Lett 10 1989 567 576
58. S.M. Cayless, D.M.L.M. Marques, and J.N. Lester The effect of transient loading, pH and temperature shocks on anaerobic filters and fluidised beds Environ Technol Lett 10 1989 951 968
59. R. Borja, A. Martin, M.M. Duran, and J. Barrious Influence of clay immobilization supports on the kinetic constants of anaerobic digestion of dairy industry wastewater Appl Clay Sci 7 1993 367 381
60. M. Dębowski, M. Zieliński, M. Krzemieniewski, and A. Brudniak Effect of magneto-active filling on the effectiveness of methane fermentation of dairy wastewaters Int J Green Energy 2014 10.1080/15435075.2014.909362
61. M. Fuentes, N.J. Scenna, P.A. Aguirre, and M.C. Mussati Application of two anaerobic digestion models to biofilm systems Biochem Eng J 38 2008 259 269
62. S.S. Ramakant, and S.N. Kaul Kinetics of an anaerobic moving bed reactor system treating synthetic milk wastewater J Environ Sci Health, Part A: Toxic/Hazard Subst Environ Eng 37 2002 1737 1755
63. M.C. Fuzzato, M.A.T. Adorno, S.C. Pinho, R. Ribeiro, and G. Tommaso Simplified mathematical model for an anaerobic sequencing batch biofilm reactor treating lipid-rich wastewater subject to rising organic loading rates Environ Eng Sci 26 2009 1197 1206
64. J.R. Banu, S. Kaliappan, and I.T. Yeom Two-stage anaerobic treatment of dairy wastewater using HUASB with PUF and PVC carrier Biorechnol Bioprocess Eng 12 2007 257 264
65. M. Zielinska, A. Cydzik-Kwiatkowska, M. Zielinski, and M. Debowski Impact of temperature, microwave radiation and organic loading rate on methanogenic community and biogas production during fermentation of dairy wastewater Bioresour Technol 129 2013 308 314
66. E.V. Ramasamy, and S.A. Abbasi Energy recovery from dairy waste-waters: impacts of biofilm support systems on anaerobic CST reactors Appl Energy 65 2000 91 98
67. R. Rajinikanth, R. Ganesh, R. Escudie, I. Mehrotra, P. Kuman, J.V. Thanikal, et al. High rate anaerobic filter with floating supports for the treatment of effluents from small-scale agro-food industries Desalination Water Treat 4 2009 183 190
68. P.R. Cordoba, F.C. Riera, and F. Sineriz Treatment of dairy industry wastewater with an anaerobic filter Biotechnol Lett 6 1984 753 758
69. R. Rajinikanth, M. Torrijos, P. Kumar, and I. Mehrotra Substrate removal kinetics in high-rate upflow anaerobic filters packed with low-density polyethylene media treating high-strength agro-food wastewaters J Environ Manage 116 2013 101 106
70. Q. Liu, K. Mancl, and O.H. Tuovinen Biomass accumulation and carbon utilization in layered sand filter biofilm systems receiving milk fat and detergent mixtures Bioresour Technol 89 2003 275 279
71. G.D. Najafpour, M. Tajallipour, M. Komeili, and M. Mohammadi Kinetic model for an upflow anaerobic packed bed bioreactor: dairy wastewater treatment African J Biotechnol 8 2009 3590 3596
72. G.D. Najafpour, B.A. Hashemiyeh, M. Asadi, and M.B. Ghasemi Biological treatment of dairy wastewater in an upflow anaerobic sludge-fixed film bioreactor American-Eurasian J Agric Environ Sci 4 2008 251 257
73. S.S. Patil, N.V. Ghasghse, A.P. Nashte, S.S. Kanase, and R.H. Pawar Anaerobic digestion treatment of cheese whey for production of methane in a two stage upflow packed bed reactor Int J Adv Sci Eng Technol 1 2012 1 7
74. H. Chua, W.F. Hu, P.H.F. Yu, and M.W.L. Cheung Response of an anaerobic fixed-film reactor to hydraulic shock loadings Bioresour Technol 61 1997 79 83
75. A. Punal, R.J. Mendez-Pampin, and J.M. Lema Characterization and comparison of biomasses from single- and multi-fed upflow anaerobic filters Bioresour Technol 68 1999 293 300
76. D.R. Vartak, C.R. Engler, M.J. Farlnd, and S.C. Ricke Attached-film media performance in psychrophilic anaerobic treatment of dairy cattle wastewater Bioresour Technol 62 1997 79 84
77. P. Patel, C. Patel, and Madamwar Anaerobic upflow fixed-film bioreactor for biomethanation of salty cheese whey Appl Biochem Biotechnol 76 1999 193 201
78. F. Omil, J.M. Garrido, B. Arrojo, and R. Mendez Anaerobic filter reactor performance for the treatment of complex dairy wastewater at industrial scale Water Res 37 2003 4099 4108
79. G. Yilmazer, and O. Yenigun Two-phase anaerobic treatment of cheese whey Water Sci Technol 40 1999 289 295
80. F. Malaspina, C.M. Cellamare, and A. StanteL. Tilche Anaerobic treatment of cheese whey with a downflow-upflow hybrid reactor Bioresour Technol 55 1996 131 139
81. L.H.S. Damasceno, A.D. Rodrigues, S.M. Ratusznei, M. Zaiat, and E. Foresti Effects of feeding time and organic loading in an anaerobic sequencing batch biofilm reactor (ASBBR) treating diluted whey J Environ Manage 85 2007 927 935
82. H.N. Gavala, H. Kopsinis, I.V. Skiadas, K. Stamatelatou, and G. Lyberatos Treatment of dairy wastewater using an upflow anaerobic sludge blanket reactor J Agric Eng Res 73 1999 59 63
83. J. De-Haast, T.J. Britz, J.C. Novello, and E.W. Verwey Anaerobic digestion of deproteinated cheese whey J Dairy Res 52 1985 457 467
84. M. Alves, A. Pereira, M. Mota, J.M. Novais, and E. Colleran Staged and non-staged anaerobic filters: microbial activity segregation, hydrodynamic behaviour and performance J Chem Technol Biotechnol 73 1998 99 108
85. R. Borja, B. Rincón, F. Raposo, J.R. Dominguez, F. Millan, and A. Martín Mesophilic anaerobic digestion in a fluidised-bed reactor of wastewater from the production of protein isolates from chickpea flour Process Biochem 39 2004 1913 1921
86. F. Toldra, A. Flors, J.L. Lequerica, and S. Valles Fluidized bed anaerobic biodegradation of food industry wastewaters Biol Wastes 21 1987 55 61
87. D.M.L.D. Marques, S.M. Cayless, and J.N. Lester Process aiders for start-up of anaerobic fluidised bed systems Environ Technol 11 1990 1093 1106
88. K. Bialek, J. Kim, C. Lee, G. Collins, T. Mahony, and V. O'Flaherty Quantitative and qualitative analyses of methanogenic community development in high-rate anaerobic bioreactors Water Res 45 2011 1298 1308
89. C. Arnaiz, P. Buffiere, S. Elmaleh, J. Lebrato, and R. Moletta Anaerobic digestion of dairy wastewater by inverse fluidization: the inverse fluidized bed and the inverse turbulent bed reactors Environ Technol 24 2003 1431 1443
90. G. Mockaitis, S.M. Ratusznei, A.D. Rodrigues, M. Zaiat, and E. Foresti Anaerobic whey treatment by a stirred sequencing batch reactor (ASBR): effects of organic loading and supplemented alkalinity J Environ Manage 79 2006 198 206
91. N. Buyukkamaci, and A. Filibeli Concentrated wastewater treatment studies using an anaerobic hybrid reactor Process Biochem 38 2002 771 775
92. G.D. Najafpour, A.A.L. Zinatizadeh, A.R. Mohamed, M.H. Isac, and H. Nasrollahzadeh High-rate anaerobic digestion of palm oil mill effluent in an upflow anaerobic sludge-fixed film bioreactor Process Biochem 41 2006 370 379
93. D. Belancon, M. Fuzzato, D.R.S. Gomes, G.C.V. Cichello, S. Pinho, R. Ribeiro, et al. A comparison of two bench-scale anaerobic systems used for the treatment of dairy effluents Int J Dairy 63 2010 290 296
94. P. Kongsil, J.L. Irvine, and P.Y. Yang Integrating an anaerobic Bio-nest and an aerobic EMMC process as pretreatment of dairy wastewater for reuse: a pilot plant study Clean Technol Environ Policy 12 2010 301 311
95. S. McHugh, G. Collins, and V. O'Flaherty Long-term, high-rate anaerobic biological treatment of whey wastewaters at psychrophilic temperatures Bioresour Technol 97 2006 1669 1678
96. J.P. Strydom, T.J. Britz, and J.F. Mostert Two-phase anaerobic digestion of three different dairy effluents using a hybrid bioreactor Water SA 23 1997 151 156