The Limitations of Policy-Level Collaboration: A Meta-Analysis of CALFED

Society and Natural Resources

Volumn 28, Issue 1, 2015, Pages 21-37

  Dutterer, Andrew D ^a   Margerum, Richard D ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF OREGON   (United States)

Author keywords

adaptive management; CALFED; collaboration; collaborative governance; content analysis

Indexed keywords

ADAPTIVE MANAGEMENT; GOVERNANCE APPROACH; META-ANALYSIS; POLICY APPROACH; WATER MANAGEMENT; WATER RESOURCE;

CALIFORNIA; UNITED STATES;

EID: 84920124840     PISSN: 08941920     EISSN: 15210723     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/08941920.2014.945054     Document Type: Article

References (52)

1. Agranoff , R. 2007 . Managing within networks: Adding value to public organizations: Public management and change series . Washington , DC : Georgetown University Press .
2. Amy , D. 1987 . The politics of environmental mediation . New York : Columbia University Press .
3. Bennett , W. 2012 . Panelist presentation. University of California, Berkeley, Travers Conference, Managing the Delta—The governance challenges of adaptive management, Berkeley, CA, 2 March.
4. Blue Ribbon Task Force . 2008 . Delta vision strategic plan . Sacramento , CA : State of California .
5. Bobker , G. 2009 . The means do not justify the ends: A comment on CALFED . Environ. Sci. Policy 12 (6): 726 – 728 .
6. Booher , D. E. , and J. E. Innes . 2010 . Governance for resilience: CALFED as a complex adaptive network for resource management . Ecol. Society 15 (3): 1 – 16 .
7. CALFED . 2000–2007 . Annual reports. CALFED Bay–Delta Program archived website. http://calwater.ca.gov (accessed 15 August 2012) .
8. de Boer , C. , and G. Krantzberg . 2013 . Great Lakes water governance: A transboundary inter-regime analysis . In Water governance as connective capacity , ed. J. Edelenbos , N. Bressers , and P. Scholten , 315 – 332 . Burlington , VT : Ashgate .
9. Delta Stewardship Council . 2012 . Delta Stewardship Council: Home . http://deltacouncil.ca.gov. (accessed 29 September 2013).
10. Doremus , H. 2009 . CALFED and the quest for optimal institutional fragmentation . Environ. Sci. Policy 12 (6): 729 – 732 .
11. Echeverria , J. D. 2001 . No success like failure: The Platte River collaborative watershed planning process . William and Mary Environ. Law Policy Rev. 25 : 559 – 604 .
12. Feldman , D. 2007 . Water policy for sustainable development . Baltimore , MD : Johns Hopkins University Press .
13. Fuller , B. 2009 . Surprising cooperation despite apparently irreconcilable differences: Agricultural water use efficiency and CALFED . Environ. Sci. Policy 12 (6): 663 – 673 .
14. Goldsmith , S. , and W. D. Eggers . 2004 . Governing by network: The new shape of the public sector . Washington , DC : Brookings Institution Press .
15. Gray , B. 1989 . Collaborating: Finding common ground for multiparty problems . San Francisco , CA : Jossey-Bass .
16. Hanemann , M. , and C. Dyckman . 2009 . The San Francisco Bay–Delta: A failure of decision-making capacity . Environ. Sci. Policy 12 (6): 710 – 725 .
17. Heikkila , T. , and A. K. Gerlak . 2005 . The formation of large-scale collaborative resource management institutions: Clarifying the roles of stakeholders, science, and institutions . Policy Stud. J. 33 (4): 583 – 612 .
18. Herbold , B. 2012 . Panelist presentation. University of California, Berkeley, Travers Conference, Managing the Delta—The governance challenges of adaptive management, Berkeley, CA, 2 March.
19. Huxham , C. , and S. Vangen . 2005 . Managing to collaborate: The theory and practice of collaborative advantage . New York : Routledge .
20. Imperial , M. T. 2005 . Lessons from six watershed management programs . Admin. Society 37 (3): 281 – 320 .
21. Ingram , H. , and L. Fraser . 2006 . Path dependency and adroit innovation: The case of California water . In Punctuated equilibrium and the dynamics of U.S. environmental policy , ed. R. Repetto , 78 – 109 . New Haven , CT : Yale University Press .
22. Innes , J. E. , and D. E. Booher . 2009 . Planning with complexity . New York : Routledge .
23. Innes , J. E., S. Connick, and D. E. Booher. 2007. Informality as a planning strategy: Collaborative water management in the CALFED Bay-Delta Program. J. Am. Plan. Assoc.73(2):195–210.
24. Isenberg , P. 2012 . Panelist presentation. University of California, Berkeley, Travers Conference, Managing the Delta—The governance challenges of adaptive management, Berkeley, CA, 2 March.
25. Kallis , G. , M. Kiparsky , and R. Norgaard . 2009a . Collaborative governance and adaptive management: Lessons from California's CALFED water program . Environ. Sci. Policy 12 (6): 631 – 643 .
26. Kallis , G. , M. Kiparsky , and R. Norgaard . 2009b . Collectively engaging complex socio-ecological systems: Re-envisioning science, governance, and the California Delta . Environ. Sci. Policy 12 (6): 644 – 652 .
27. Layzer , J. A. 2008 . Natural experiments: Ecosystem-based management and the environment . Cambridge , MA : MIT Press .
28. Lejano , R. , and H. Ingram . 2009 . Collaborative networks and new ways of knowing . Environ. Sci. Policy 12 (6): 653 – 662 .
29. Little Hoover Commission . 2005 . Still imperiled, still important: The Little Hoover Commission's review of the CALFED Bay-Delta Program . Sacramento , CA : Little Hoover Commission .
30. Lubell , M. 2004 . Collaborative environmental institutions: All talk and no action . J. Policy Anal. Manage. 23 (3): 549 – 573 .
31. Lubell , M. , A. K. Gerlak , and T. Heikkila . 2013 . CALFED and collaborative watershed management: Success despite failure? . In Making space for the river: Governance experiences with multifunctional river flood management in the US and Europe , ed. J. F. Warner , A. Van Buuren , and J. Edelenbos , 63 – 78 . London : IWA Publishing House .
32. Lund , J. 2012 . Panelist presentation. University of California, Berkeley, Travers Conference, Managing the Delta—The governance challenges of adaptive management, Berkeley, CA, March 2.
33. Luoma , S. 2009 . Ingredients in sustainably managing water in semi-arid environments . Environ. Sci. Policy 12 (6): 737 – 740 .
34. Lurie , S. D. 2004 . Interorganizational dynamics in large-scale integrated resource management networks: Insights from the CALFED Bay-Delta Program. PhD thesis, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI.
35. Lurie , S. D. 2011 . The CALFED Bay-Delta Program: Lessons from the rise and fall of a large-scale ecosystem management network . J. Nat. Resources Policy Res. 3 (3): 251 – 262 .
36. Margerum , R. D. 2008 . A typology of collaboration efforts in environmental management . Environ. Manage. 41 (4): 487 – 500 .
37. Margerum , R. D. 2011 . Beyond consensus: Improving collaborative planning and management . Boston : MIT Press .
38. Mayer , J. 2012 . Panelist presentation. University of California, Berkeley, Travers Conference, Managing the Delta—The governance challenges of adaptive management, Berkeley, CA, 2 March.
39. Norgaard , R. 2012 . Panelist presentation. University of California, Berkeley, Travers Conference, Managing the Delta—The governance challenges of adaptive management, Berkeley, CA, 2 March.
40. Owen , D. 2007 . Law, environmental dynamism, reliability: the rise and fall of CALFED . Environ. Law 37 : 1145 – 1204 .
41. Provan , K. G. , P. Kenis , and S. E. Human . 2008 . Legitimacy building in organizational networks . In Big ideas in collaborative public management , ed. L. B. Bingham and R. O'Leary , 121 – 137 . Armonk , NY : M. E. Sharpe .
42. Rieke , E. A. 1996 . The Bay-Delta Accord: A stride toward sustainability . Colo. Law Rev. 341 : 341 – 370 .
43. Rigg , C., and N. O'Mahony. 2013. Frustrations in collaborative working: Insights from institutional theory. Public Manage. Rev.15(1):83–108.
44. Ringquist , E. 2013 . Meta-analysis for public policy and management . Hoboken , NJ : Wiley .
45. Robinson , C. , R. D. Margerum , T. Koontz , C. Moseley , and S. D. Lurie . 2011 . Policy-level collaboratives for environmental management at the regional scale: Lessons and challenges from Australia and the United States . Society Nat. Resources 24 : 849 – 859 .
46. Sabatier , P. A. , W. D. Leach , M. Lubell , and N. W. Pelkey . 2005 . Theoretical frameworks explaining partnership success . In Swimming upstream: Collaborative approaches to watershed management , ed. P. A. Sabatier , W. Focht , M. Lubell , Z. Trachtenberg , A. Vedlitz , and M. Matlock , 173 – 199 . Cambridge : MIT Press .
47. Shilling , F. M. , J. K. London , and R. Liévanos . 2009 . Marginalization by collaboration: Environmental justice as a third party in and beyond CALFED . Environ. Sci. Policy 12 (6): 694 – 709 .
48. Taylor , K. 2012 . Panelist presentation. University of California, Berkeley, Travers Conference, Managing the Delta—The governance challenges of adaptive management, Berkeley, CA, 2 March.
49. Taylor , K. , and A. Short . 2009 . Integrating scientific knowledge into large-scale restoration programs: The CALFED Bay-Delta Program experience . Environ. Sci. Policy 12 (6): 1 – 10 .
50. Thomas , C. W. 2003 . Bureaucratic landscapes: interagency cooperation and the preservation of biodiversity . Cambridge : MIT Press .
51. Weir , M. , J. Rongerude , and C. K. Ansell . 2009 . Collaboration is not enough: Virtuous cycles of reform in transportation policy . Urban Affairs Rev. 44 (4): 455 – 489 .
52. Wondolleck , J. M. , and S. L. Yaffee . 2000 . Making collaboration work: Lessons from innovation in natural resource management . Washington , DC : Island Press .