A novel model incorporating two variability sources for describing motor evoked potentials

Brain Stimulation

Volumn 7, Issue 4, 2014, Pages 541-552

  Goetz, Stefan M ^a   Luber, Bruce ^a,b   Lisanby, Sarah H ^a,b   Peterchev, Angel V ^a,c  

^a DUKE UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^b DUKE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c Duke University   (United States)

Author keywords

Brain stimulation; Dual variability source model; Input output curve (IO); Motor evoked potentials (MEP); Neural recruitment; Response distribution; Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS); Trial to trial variability

Indexed keywords

ADULT; AMPLITUDE MODULATION; ARTICLE; EVOKED MUSCLE RESPONSE; FEMALE; HUMAN; MALE; NERVE EXCITABILITY; NEUROPHYSIOLOGICAL RECRUITMENT; NONLINEAR SYSTEM; NORMAL HUMAN; PRIORITY JOURNAL; SIGNAL TRANSDUCTION; TRANSCRANIAL MAGNETIC STIMULATION; CYTOLOGY; MIDDLE AGED; MOTOR CORTEX; PHYSIOLOGY; PYRAMIDAL TRACT; REGRESSION ANALYSIS;

ADULT; EVOKED POTENTIALS, MOTOR; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; MOTOR CORTEX; PYRAMIDAL TRACTS; REGRESSION ANALYSIS; TRANSCRANIAL MAGNETIC STIMULATION;

EID: 84905060570     PISSN: 1935861X     EISSN: 18764754     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.brs.2014.03.002     Document Type: Article

References (79)

1. N.C. Petersen, J.E. Butler, and J.L. Taylor et al. Probing the corticospinal link between the motor cortex and motoneurones: some neglected aspects of human motor cortical function Acta Physiol (Oxf) 198 2010 403 416
2. D. Burke, R. Hicks, and J. Stephen et al. Trial-to-trial variability of corticospinal volleys in human subjects Electromyogr Motor C 97 1995 231 237
3. D.D. Langeloo, H.L. Journee, and M. de Kleuver et al. Criteria for transcranial electrical motor evoked potential monitoring during spinal deformity surgery A review and discussion of the literature Neurophysiol Clin 37 2007 431 439
4. Y. Tufail, A. Matyushov, and N. Baldwin et al. Transcranial pulsed ultrasound stimulates intact brain circuits Neuron 66 2010 681 694
5. E.M. Wassermann Risk and safety of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation: report and suggested guidelines from the International Workshop on the Safety of Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation, June 5-7, 1996 Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 108 1998 1 16
6. S. Rossi, M. Hallett, and P.M. Rossini et al. Safety, ethical considerations, and application guidelines for the use of transcranial magnetic stimulation in clinical practice and research Clin Neurophysiol 120 2009 2008 2039
7. F. Maeda, J.P. Keenan, and J.M. Tormos et al. Interindividual variability of the modulatory effects of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation on cortical excitability Exp Brain Res 133 2000 425 430
8. N. Lang, J. Harms, and T. Weyh et al. Stimulus intensity and coil characteristics influence the efficacy of rTMS to suppress cortical excitability Clin Neurophysiol 117 2006 2292 2301
9. M. Sommer, A. Alfaro, and M. Rummel et al. Half sine, monophasic and biphasic transcranial magnetic stimulation of the human motor cortex Clin Neurophysiol 117 2006 838 844
10. C.J. Kalkman, J.C. Drummond, and A.A. Ribberink et al. Effects of propofol, etomidate, midazolam, and fentanyl on motor evoked responses to transcranial electrical or magnetic stimulation in humans Anesthesiology 76 1992 502 509
11. H. Devanne, B.A. Lavoie, and C. Capaday Input-output properties and gain changes in the human corticospinal pathway Exp Brain Res 114 1997 329 338
12. A.J. Pearce, R.A. Clark, and D.J. Kidgell A comparison of two methods in acquiring stimulus-response curves with transcranial magnetic stimulation Brain Stimul 6 3 2013 306 309
13. M.P. Malcolm, W.J. Triggs, and K.E. Light et al. Reliability of motor cortex transcranial magnetic stimulation in four muscle representations Clin Neurophysiol 117 2006 1037 1046
14. J.B. Pitcher, K.M. Ogston, and T.S. Miles Age and sex differences in human motor cortex input-output characteristics J Physiol 546 2003 605 613
15. A.A. van Kuijk, L.C. Anker, and J.W. Pasman et al. Stimulus-response characteristics of motor evoked potentials and silent periods in proximal and distal upper-extremity muscles J Electromyogr Kinesiol 19 2009 574 583
16. E. Houdayer, A. Degardin, and F. Cassim et al. The effects of low- and high-frequency repetitive TMS on the input/output properties of the human corticospinal pathway Exp Brain Res 187 2008 207 217
17. C. Moeller, N. Arai, and J. Lucke et al. Hysteresis effects on the input-output curve of motor evoked potentials Clin Neurophysiol 120 2009 1003 1008
18. M. Gangitano, A. Valero-Cabre, and J.M. Tormos et al. Modulation of input-output curves by low and high frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation of the motor cortex Clin Neurophysiol 113 2002 1249 1257
19. B. Boroojerdi, F. Battaglia, and W. Muellbacher et al. Mechanisms influencing stimulus-response properties of the human corticospinal system Clin Neurophysiol 112 2001 931 937
20. M.C. Ridding, and J.C. Rothwell Stimulus/response curves as a method of measuring motor cortical excitability in man Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 105 1997 340 344
21. L. Niehaus, B.U. Meyer, and T. Weyh Influence of pulse configuration and direction of coil current on excitatory effects of magnetic motor cortex and nerve stimulation Clin Neurophysiol 111 2000 75 80
22. M.A. Nitsche, A. Seeber, and K. Frommann et al. Modulating parameters of excitability during and after transcranial direct current stimulation of the human motor cortex J Physiol 568 2005 291 303
23. V. Di Lazzaro, P. Profice, and F. Ranieri et al. I-wave origin and modulation Brain Stimul 5 2012 512 525
24. V.E. Amassian, R.Q. Cracco, and P.J. Maccabee Focal stimulation of human cerebral cortex with the magnetic coil: a comparison with electrical stimulation Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 74 1989 401 416
25. E.D. Adrian, and G. Moruzzi Impulses in the pyramidal tract J Physiol 97 1939 153 199
26. P. Pasqualetti, and F. Ferreri W14.4 Amplitude values of motor evoked potentials: statistical properties and neurophysiological implications Clin Neurophysiol 122 Suppl. 1 2011 S44 S45
27. U. Kischka, R. Fajfr, and T. Fellenberg et al. Facilitation of motor evoked potentials from magnetic brain stimulation in man: a comparative study of different target muscles J Clin Neurophysiol 10 1993 505 512
28. L. Fadiga, L. Fogassi, and G. Pavesi et al. Motor facilitation during action observation: a magnetic stimulation study J Neurophysiol 73 1995 2608 2611
29. L. Kiers, D. Cros, and K.H. Chiappa et al. Variability of motor potentials evoked by transcranial magnetic stimulation Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 89 1993 415 423
30. M. Sommer, T. Wu, and F. Tergau et al. Intra- and interindividual variability of motor responses to repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation Clin Neurophysiol 113 2002 265 269
31. F. Maeda, M. Gangitano, and M. Thall et al. Inter- and intra-individual variability of paired-pulse curves with transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) Clin Neurophysiol 113 2002 376 382
32. W. van der Kamp, A.H. Zwinderman, and M.D. Ferrari et al. Cortical excitability and response variability of transcranial magnetic stimulation J Clin Neurophysiol 13 1996 164 171
33. K.M. Roesler, D.M. Roth, and M.R. Magistris Trial-to-trial size variability of motor-evoked potentials. A study using the triple stimulation technique Exp Brain Res 187 2008 51 59
34. M.R. Magistris, K.M. Rosler, and A. Truffert et al. Transcranial stimulation excites virtually all motor neurons supplying the target muscle. A demonstration and a method improving the study of motor evoked potentials Brain 121 1998 437 450
35. R.J. Dunnewold, W. van der Kamp, and A.M. van den Brink et al. Influence of electrode site and size on variability of magnetic evoked potentials Muscle Nerve 21 1998 1779 1782
36. I.J. Woodforth, R.G. Hicks, and M.R. Crawford et al. Variability of motor-evoked potentials recorded during nitrous oxide anesthesia from the tibialis anterior muscle after transcranial electrical stimulation Anesth Analg 82 1996 744 749
37. B. Brouwer, and J. Qiao Characteristics and variability of lower limb motoneuron responses to transcranial magnetic stimulation Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 97 1995 49 54
38. C.L. Lim, and C. Yiannikas Motor evoked potentials: a new method of controlled facilitation using quantitative surface EMG Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 85 1992 38 41
39. M. Orth, and J.C. Rothwell The cortical silent period: intrinsic variability and relation to the waveform of the transcranial magnetic stimulation pulse Clin Neurophysiol 115 2004 1076 1082
40. J.F. Nielsen Logarithmic distribution of amplitudes of compound muscle action potentials evoked by transcranial magnetic stimulation J Clin Neurophysiol 13 1996 423 434
41. N.H. Jung, I. Delvendahl, and N.G. Kuhnke et al. Navigated transcranial magnetic stimulation does not decrease the variability of motor-evoked potentials Brain Stimul 3 2010 87 94
42. K. Roy Choudhury, L. Boyle, and M. Burke et al. Intra subject variation and correlation of motor potentials evoked by transcranial magnetic stimulation Ir J Med Sci 180 2011 873 880
43. A.V. Peterchev, S.M. Goetz, and G.G. Westin et al. Pulse width dependence of motor threshold and input-output curve characterized with controllable pulse parameter transcranial magnetic stimulation Clin Neurophysiol 124 7 2013 1364 1372
44. S.M. Goetz, and A.V. Peterchev A model of variability in brain stimulation evoked responses IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc 34 2012 6434 6437
45. J. Silvanto, N. Muggleton, and V. Walsh State-dependency in brain stimulation studies of perception and cognition Trends Cogn Sci 12 2008 447 454
46. A.V. Peterchev, R. Jalinous, and S.H. Lisanby A transcranial magnetic stimulator inducing near-rectangular pulses with controllable pulse width (cTMS) IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 55 2008 257 266
47. P.M. Rossini, A.T. Barker, and A. Berardelli et al. Non-invasive electrical and magnetic stimulation of the brain, spinal cord and roots: basic principles and procedures for routine clinical application. Report of an IFCN committee Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 91 1994 79 92
48. G. Box, and D. Cox An analysis of transformations revisited, rebutted J Am Stat Assoc 77 1982 209 210
49. G.E.P. Box, and D.R. Cox An analysis of transformations J R Stat Soc Ser B Methodol 1964 211 252
50. M.B. Brown, and A.B. Forsythe Robust tests for the equality of variances J Am Stat Assoc 69 1974 364 367
51. E.M. Wassermann Variation in the response to transcranial magnetic brain stimulation in the general population Clin Neurophysiol 113 2002 1165 1171
52. D.G. Allen, G.D. Lamb, and H. Westerblad Skeletal muscle fatigue: cellular mechanisms Physiol Rev 88 2008 287 332
53. L.A. Stefanski Measurement error models J Am Stat Assoc 95 2000 1353 1358
54. R.A. Fisher On the mathematical foundations of theoretical statistics Phil Trans R Soc A 222 1922 309 368
55. J.A. Nelder, and R. Mead A simplex method for function minimization Comput J 7 1965 308 313
56. Q.H. Vuong Likelihood ratio tests for model selection and non-nested hypotheses Econometrica 1989 307 333
57. J. Neyman, and E.S. Pearson On the problem of the most efficient tests of statistical hypotheses Phil Trans R Soc A 231 1933 289 337
58. C.E. Rasmussen, and C.K.I. Williams Model selection and adaptation of hyperparameters Gaussian processes for machine learning 2006 MIT Press Cambridge, MA
59. S. Geisser, and W.F. Eddy A predictive approach to model selection J Am Stat Assoc 74 1979 153 160
60. P. Smyth Model selection for probabilistic clustering using cross-validated likelihood Stat Comput 10 2000 63 72
61. M.J. van der Laan, S. Dudoit, and S. Keles Asymptotic optimality of likelihood based cross-validation Stat Appl Genet Mol Biol 3 2004 1544 6115
62. H. Akaike A new look at the statistical model identification IEEE Trans Automatic Control 19 1974 716 723
63. R.G. Miller The jackknife - a review Biometrika 61 1974 1 15
64. B. Efron, and R. Tibshirani Bootstrap methods for standard errors, confidence intervals, and other measures of statistical accuracy Stat Sci 1 1986 54 75
65. J.A. White, R. Klink, and A. Alonso et al. Noise from voltage-gated ion channels may influence neuronal dynamics in the entorhinal cortex J Neurophysiol 80 1998 262 269
66. J.A. White, J.T. Rubinstein, and A.R. Kay Channel noise in neurons Trends Neurosci 23 2000 131 137
67. P.N. Steinmetz, A. Manwani, and C. Koch et al. Subthreshold voltage noise due to channel fluctuations in active neuronal membranes J Comput Neurosci 9 2000 133 148
68. W.H. Calvin, and C.F. Stevens Synaptic noise and other sources of randomness in motoneuron interspike intervals J Neurophysiol 31 1968 574 587
69. W.H. Calvin, and C.F. Stevens Synaptic noise as a source of variability in the interval between action potentials Science 155 1967 842 844
70. A.A. Faisal, L.P. Selen, and D.M. Wolpert Noise in the nervous system Nat Rev Neurosci 9 2008 292 303
71. A. Manwani, and C. Koch Detecting and estimating signals in noisy cable structure, I: neuronal noise sources Neural Comput 11 1999 1797 1829
72. H. Westerblad, and D.G. Allen Cellular mechanisms of skeletal muscle fatigue Adv Exp Med Biol 538 2003 563 570 discussion 571
73. D.R. Merrill, M. Bikson, and J.G. Jefferys Electrical stimulation of excitable tissue: design of efficacious and safe protocols J Neurosci Methods 141 2005 171 198
74. S. Aronson, and L.A. Geddes Electrode potential stability IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 32 1985 987 988
75. S. Letzter, and N. Webster Noise in amplifiers IEEE Spectr 7 1970 67 75
76. S.M. Goetz, C.N. Truong, and M.G. Gerhofer et al. Analysis and optimization of pulse dynamics for magnetic stimulation PLoS One 8 2013 e55771
77. S.M. Goetz, M. Pfaeffl, and J. Huber et al. Circuit topology and control principle for a first magnetic stimulator with fully controllable waveform Proc Annu Int Conf IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc 2012 2012 4700 4703
78. M. Sommer, N. Lang, and F. Tergau et al. Neuronal tissue polarization induced by repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation? Neuroreport 13 2002 809 811
79. J.L. Taylor, and C.K. Loo Stimulus waveform influences the efficacy of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation J Affect Disord 97 2007 271 276