Their pain gives us pleasure: How intergroup dynamics shape empathic failures and counter-empathic responses

Journal of Experimental Social Psychology

Volumn 55, Issue , 2014, Pages 110-125

  Cikara, M ^a   Bruneau, E ^b   Van Bavel, J J ^c   Saxe, R ^b  

^a HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY   (United States)

^c NEW YORK UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Competition; Conflict; Empathy; Intergroup; Schadenfreude; Social identity

Indexed keywords

EID: 84903884979     PISSN: 00221031     EISSN: 10960465     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jesp.2014.06.007     Document Type: Article

References (116)

1. Allport G.W. The nature of prejudice 1954, Addison-Wesley, Cambridge, MA.
2. Avenanti A., Sirigu A., Aglioti S.M. Racial bias reduces empathic sensorimotor resonance with other-race pain. Current Biology 2010, 20:1018-1022.
3. Batson C.D. These things called empathy: Eight related but distinct phenomena. The social neuroscience of empathy 2009, 3-15. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA. J. Decety, W.J. Ickes (Eds.).
4. Batson C.D., Ahmad N.Y. Using empathy to improve intergroup attitudes and relations. Social Issues and Policy Review 2009, 3:141.
5. Berinsky A.J., Huber G.A., Lenz G.S. Evaluating online labor markets for experimental research: Amazon. com's Mechanical Turk. Political Analysis 2012, 20(3):351-368.
6. Branscombe N.R., Ellemers N., Spears R., Doosje B. The context and content of social identity threat. Social identity: Context, commitment, content 1999, 35-58. Blackwell, Oxford, England. N. Ellemers, R. Spears, B. Doosje (Eds.).
7. Brewer M.B. The psychology of prejudice: In-group love or out-group hate?. Journal of Social Issues 1999, 55:429-444.
8. Brown L.M., Bradley M.M., Lang P.J. Affective reactions to pictures of in-group and out-group members. Biological Psychology 2006, 71:303-311.
9. Bruneau E.G., Dufour N., Saxe R. Social cognition in members of conflict groups: Behavioral and neural responses in Arabs, Israelis and South Americans to each other's misfortunes. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B 2012, 367:717-730.
10. Buhrmester M.D., Kwang T., Gosling S.D. Amazon's Mechanical Turk: A new source of inexpensive, yet high-quality, data?. Perspectives on Psychological Science 2011, 6:3-5.
11. Campbell D.T. Common fate, similarity, and other indices of the status of aggregates of persons as social entities. Behavioral Science 1958, 3:14-25.
12. Carr E.W., Winkielman P., Oveis C. Transforming the mirror: Power fundamentally changes facial responding to emotional expressions. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 2014, 143:997-1003.
13. Chiao J.Y., Mathur V.A. Intergroup empathy: How does race affect empathic neural responses?. Current Biology 2010, 20:R478-R480.
14. Cikara M., Botvinick M.M., Fiske S.T. Us versus them: Social identity shapes neural responses to intergroup competition and harm. Psychological Science 2011, 22:306-313.
15. Cikara M., Bruneau E.G., Saxe R. Us and them: Intergroup failures of empathy. Current Directions in Psychological Science 2011, 20:149-153.
16. Cikara M., Fiske S.T. Bounded empathy: Neural responses to out-group targets' (mis)fortunes. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2011, 23:3791-3803.
17. Cikara M., Fiske S.T. Stereotypes and Schadenfreude: Behavioral and physiological markers of pleasure at others' misfortunes. Social Psychological and Personality Science 2012, 3:63-71.
18. Cikara M., Van Bavel J.J. The Neuroscience of Intergroup Relations An Integrative Review. Perspectives on Psychological Science 2014, 9(3):245-274.
19. Cohen J., Cohen P., West S.G., Aiken L.S. Applied multiple regression/correlation analysis for the behavioral sciences 2003, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ. 3rd ed.
20. Cohen T.R., Insko C.A. War and peace: Possible approaches to reducing intergroup conflict. Perspectives on Psychological Science 2008, 3(2):87-93.
21. Combs D.J.Y., Powell C.A.J., Schurtz D.R., Smith R.H. Politics, Schadenfreude, and in-group identification: The sometimes happy thing about a poor economy and death. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 2009, 45:635-646.
22. Costa P.T., McCrae R.R. Revised NEO Personality Inventory (NEO-PI-R) and NEO Five-Factor Inventory (NEO-FFI) manual 1992, Psychological Assessment Resources, Odessa, FL.
23. Cuddy A.J.C., Fiske S.T., Glick P. The BIAS map: Behaviors from intergroup affect and stereotypes. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2007, 92:631-648.
24. Cuddy A.J.C., Rock M.S., Norton M.I. Aid in the after-math of Hurricane Katrina: Inferences of secondary emotions and intergroup helping. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations 2007, 10:107-118.
25. Davis M.H. Empathy: A social psychological approach 1994, Westview Press, Boulder, CO.
26. Decety J., Echols S., Correll J. The blame game: The effect of responsibility and social stigma on empathy for pain. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2010, 22(5):985-997.
27. Deutsch M. Cooperation and competition. The handbook of conflict resolution: Theory and practice 2006, 23-42. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco. M. Deutsch, P.T. Coleman, E.C. Marcus (Eds.).
28. Dovidio J.F., Gaertner S.L., Validzic A., Matoka K., Johnson B., Frazier S. Extending the benefits of re-categorization: Evaluations, self-disclosure and helping. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 1997, 33:401-420.
29. Dovidio J.F., Johnson J.D., Gaertner S.L., Pearson A.R., Saguy T., Ashburn-Nardo L. Empathy and intergroup relations. Prosocial motives, emotions, and behavior 2010, 393-408. American Psychological Association, Washington, D.C. M. Mikulincer, P.R. Shaver (Eds.).
30. Dovidio J.F., ten Vergert M., Stewart T.L., Gaertner S.L., Johnson J.D., Esses V.M., et al. Perspective and prejudice: Antecedents and mediating mechanisms. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2004, 30(12):1537-1549.
31. Dunham Y. An angry=Outgroup effect. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 2011, 47(3):668-671.
32. Eisenberg N., Shea C.L., Carlo G., Knight G.P. Empathy-related responding and cognition: A chicken and the egg dilemma. Handbook of moral behavior and development: Vol. 2: Research 1991, 63-88. Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ. W.M. Kurtines (Ed.).
33. Ellemers N., Spears R., Doosje B. Social identity: Context, commitment, content 1999, Blackwell, Oxford.
34. Esses V.M., Dovidio J.F., Jackson L.M., Armstrong T.L. The immigration dilemma: The role of perceived group competition, ethnic prejudice, and national identity. Journal of Social Issues 2001, 57:389-412.
35. Esses V.M., Jackson L.M., Armstrong T.L. Intergroup competition and attitudes toward immigrants and immigration: An instrumental model of group conflict. Journal of Social Issues 1998, 54:699-724.
36. Feather N.T. Values, achievement, and justice: Studies in the psychology of deservingness 1999, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Press, New York, NY.
37. Feather N.T. Deservingness and emotions: Applying the structural model of deservingness to the analysis of affective reactions to outcomes. European Review of Social Psychology 2006, 17:38-73.
38. Feather N.T., Nairn K. Resentment, envy, Schadenfreude, and sympathy: Effects of own and other's deserved or undeserved status. Australian Journal of Psychology 2005, 57:87-102.
39. Feather N.T., Sherman R. Envy, resentment, Schadenfreude, and sympathy: Reactions to deserved and underserved achievement and subsequent failure. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2002, 28:953-961.
40. Fiske S.T., Cuddy A.J.C., Glick P. Universal dimensions of social cognition: Warmth and competence. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2007, 11:77-83.
41. Fiske S.T., Cuddy A.J.C., Glick P., Xu J. A model of (often mixed) stereotype content: Competence and warmth respectively follow from perceived status and competition. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2002, 82:878-902.
42. Fiske S.T., Ruscher J.B. Negative interdependence and prejudice: Whence the affect?. Affect, cognition, and stereotyping: Interactive processes in group perception 1993, 239-268. Academic Press, San Diego, CA. D.M. Mackie, D.L. Hamilton (Eds.).
43. Gaertner S.L., Dovidio J.F., Rust M.C., Nier J.A., Banker B.S., Ward C.M., et al. Reducing intergroup bias: Elements of intergroup cooperation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1999, 76:388-402.
44. Gaertner L., Schopler J. Perceived in-group entitativity and intergroup bias: An interconnection of self and others. European Journal of Social Psychology 1998, 28:963-980.
45. Galinsky A.D., Magee J.C., Inesi M.E., Gruenfeld D.H. Power and perspectives not taken. Psychological Science 2006, 17(12):1068-1074.
46. Guinote A. Power affects basic cognition: Increased attentional inhibition and flexibility. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 2007, 43:685-697.
47. Gutsell J.N., Inzlicht M. Empathy constrained: Prejudice predicts reduced mental simulation of actions during observation of out-groups. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 2010, 46:841-845.
48. Gutsell J.N., Inzlicht M. Intergroup differences in the sharing of emotive states: Neural evidence of an empathy gap. Social Cognitive Affective Neuroscience 2012, 7:596-603. 10.1093/scan/nsr035.
49. Gutsell J.N., Inzlicht M. Using EEG mu-suppression to explore group biases in motor resonance. The neuroscience of prejudice 2013, 278-298. Psychology Press, London, England. B. Derks, D. Scheepers, N. Ellemers (Eds.).
50. Hamilton D.L., Sherman S.J. Perceiving persons and groups. Psychological Review 1996, 103:336-355.
51. Handgraaf M.J., Van Dijk E., Vermunt R.C., Wilke H.A., De Dreu C.K. Less power or powerless? Egocentric empathy gaps and the irony of having little versus no power in social decision making. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2008, 95(5):1136.
52. Hareli S., Weiner B. Dislike and envy as antecedents of pleasure at another's misfortune. Motivation and Emotion 2002, 26:257-277.
53. Heider F. The psychology of interpersonal relations 1958, Wiley, New York.
54. Hein G., Silani G., Preuschoff K., Batson C.D., Singer T. Neural responses to in-group and out-group members' suffering predict individual differences in costly helping. Neuron 2010, 68:149-160.
55. Hogg M.A. The social psychology of group cohesiveness: From attraction to social identity 1992, Harvester Wheatsheaf, London.
56. Hogg M.A. Group cohesiveness: A critical review and some new directions. European Review of Social Psychology 1993, 4:85-111.
57. Hoogland C., Schurtz D.R., Combs D.J.Y., Powell C.A.J., Smith R.H. Enjoying bad news and suffering good news: In-group identification and the joys of Schadenfreude and the sorrows of Glückschmerz. Poster presented at SPSP 2012, San Diego, CA 2012.
58. Hornstein H.A. Promotive tension and prosocial behavior: A Lewinian analysis. Altruism, sympathy, and helping: Psychological and sociological principles 1978, 177-207. Academic, New York. L. Wispe (Ed.).
59. Insko C.A., Schopler J. Differential distrust of groups and individuals. Intergroup Cognition and Intergroup behavior 1998, 75-108. Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ. C. Sedikides, J. Schopler, C.A. Insko (Eds.).
60. Johnson D.W., Johnson R.T. Cooperation and competition: Theory and research 1989, Interaction, Edina, MN.
61. Johnson J., Simmons C., Jordan A., MacLean L., Taddei J., Thomas D. Rodney King and O. J. revisited: The impact of race and defendant empathy induction on judicial decisions. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 2002, 32:1208-1223.
62. Judd C.M., Park B. Out-group homogeneity: Judgments of variability at the individual and group levels. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1988, 54:778-788.
63. Lanzetta J.T., Englis B.G. Expectations of cooperation and competition and their effects on observers' vicarious emotional responses. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1989, 56:543-554.
64. Leach C.W., Spears R. "A vengefulness of the impotent": The pain of in-group inferiority and Schadenfreude toward successful out-groups. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2008, 95:1383-1396.
65. Leach C.W., Spears R. Dejection at in-group defeat and Schadenfreude toward second- and third-party out-groups. Emotion 2009, 9:659-665.
66. Leach C.W., Spears R., Branscombe N.R., Doosje B. Malicious pleasure: Schadenfreude at the suffering of another group. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2003, 84:923-943.
67. Levine M., Prosser A., Evans D., Reicher S. Identity and emergency intervention: How social group membership and inclusiveness of group boundaries shape helping behavior. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2005, 31(4):443-453.
68. Lickel B., Miller N., Stenstrom D.M., Denson T.F., Schmader T. Vicarious retribution: The role of collective blame in intergroup aggression. Personality and Social Psychology Review 2006, 10(4):372-390.
69. Mackie D.M., Devos T., Smith E.R. Intergroup emotions: Explaining offensive action tendencies in an intergroup context. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2000, 79(4):602.
70. Maitner A.T., Mackie D.M., Smith E.R. Antecedents and consequences of satisfaction and guilt following ingroup aggression. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations 2007, 10(2):223-237.
71. Masten C.L., Gillen-O'Neel C., Brown C.S. Children's intergroup empathic processing: The roles of novel in-group identification, situational distress, and social anxiety. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 2010, 106:115-128.
72. Mathur V.A., Harada T., Lipke T., Chiao J. Neural basis of extraordinary empathy and altruistic motivation. NeuroImage 2010, 51:1468-1475.
73. Meier B.P., Hinsz V.B. A comparison of human aggression committed by groups and individuals: An interindividual-intergroup discontinuity. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 2004, 40:551-559.
74. Miron A.M., Branscombe N.R., Biernat M. Motivated shifting of justice standards. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2010, 36(6):768-779.
75. Montalan B., Lelard T., Godefroy O., Mouras H. Behavioral investigation of the influence of social categorization on empathy for pain: A minimal group paradigm study. Frontiers in Psychology 2012, 3:389.
76. Mullen B., Brown R., Smith C. In-group bias as a function of salience, relevance, and status: An integration. European Journal of Social Psychology 1992, 22:103-122.
77. Mummendey A., Otten S. Positive-negative asymmetry in social discrimination. European review of social psychology 1998, 107-143. Wiley, Chichester, UK. W. Stroebe, M. Hewstone (Eds.).
78. Mummendey A., Otten S., Berger U., Kessler T. Positive-negative asymmetry in social discrimination: Valence of evaluation and salience of categorization. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2001, 26:1258-1270.
79. Neuberg S.L., Cottrell C.A. Intergroup emotions: A biocultural approach. From prejudice to intergroup emotions: Differentiated reactions to social groups 2002, 265-283.
80. Oppenheimer D.M., Meyvisb T., Davidenkoc N. Instructional manipulation checks: Detecting satisficing to increase statistical power. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 2009, 45:867-872.
81. Ortony A., Clore G.L., Collins A. The cognitive structure of emotions 1988, Cambridge University Press, New York.
82. Paolacci G., Chandler J., Ipeirotis P.G. Running experiments on Amazon Mechanical Turk. Judgment and Decision Making 2010, 5:411-419.
83. Pemberton M.B., Insko C.A., Schopler J. Memory for and experience of differential competitive behavior of individuals and groups. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1996, 71:953-966.
84. Perry D., Hendler T., Shamay-Tsoory S.G. Can we share the joy of others? Empathic neural responses to distress vs joy. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 2012, 7(8):909-916.
85. 2, a measure of local effect size, from PROC MIXED. Frontiers in Psychology 2012, 3.
86. Shamay-Tsoory S.G., Abu-Akel A., Palgi S., Sulieman R., Fischer-Shofty M., Levkovitz Y., et al. Giving peace a chance: Oxytocin increases empathy to pain in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Psychoneuroendocrinology 2013, 38(12):3139-3144.
87. Sherif M., Harvey O.J., White B.J., Hood W.R., Sherif C.W. Intergroup cooperation and competition: The Robbers Cave experiment 1954/1961, University Book Exchange, Norman, OK.
88. Singer T., Seymour B., O'Doherty J.P., Stephan K.E., Dolan R.J., Frith C.D. Empathic neural responses are modulated by the perceived fairness of others. Nature 2006, 439:466-469.
89. Smith R.H. Assimilative and contrastive emotional reactions to upward and downward social comparisons. Handbook of social comparison: Theory and research 2000, 173-200. Kluwer, Dordrecht, NL. J. Suls, L. Wheeler (Eds.).
90. Smith R.H. The Joy of Pain: Schadenfreude and the Dark Side of Human Nature 2013, Oxford University Press.
91. Smith R.H., Eyre H.L., Powell C.A., Kim S.H. Relativistic origins of emotional reactions to events happening to others and to ourselves. British Journal of Social Psychology 2006, 45:357-371.
92. Smith H.J., Kessler T. Group-based emotions and intergroup behaviour: The case of relative deprivation. The social life of emotions 2004, 292-313. Cambridge University Press, New York. L.Z. Tiedens, C.W. Leach (Eds.).
93. Smith R.H., Powell C.A.J., Combs D.J.Y., Schurtz R.D. Exploring the when and why of Schadenfreude. Social and Personality Psychology Compass 2009, 3:530-546.
94. Smith R.H., Turner T., Leach C., Garonzik R., Urch-Druskat V., Weston C.M. Envy and schadenfreude. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 1996, 22:158-168.
95. Struch N., Schwartz S.H. Intergroup aggression: Its predictors and distinctness from in-group bias. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1989, 56:364-373.
96. Stürmer S., Snyder M., Kropp A., Siem B. Empathy-motivated helping: The moderating role of group membership. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2006, 32:943-956.
97. Stürmer S., Snyder M., Omoto A.M. Prosocial emotions and helping: The moderating role of group membership. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2005, 88:532-546.
98. Takahashi H., Kato M., Matsuura M., Mobbs D., Suhara T., Okubo Y. When your gain is my pain and your pain is my gain: neural correlates of envy and schadenfreude. Science 2009, 323(5916):937-939.
99. Tajfel H. Social identity and intergroup relations 1982, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, England.
100. Tajfel H., Billig M., Bundy R.P., Flament C. Social categorization and intergroup behaviour. European Journal of Social Psychology 1971, 1:149-178.
101. Tajfel H., Turner J. An integrative theory of intergroup conflict. The social psychology of intergroup relations 1979, 33-47. Brooks/Cole Publishing, Pacific Grove, CA. W.G. Austin, S. Worschel (Eds.).
102. Turner J.C., Hogg M.A., Oakes P.J., Reicher S.D., Wetherell M.S. Rediscovering the social group: A self-categorization theory 1987, Basil Blackwell, Cambridge, MA.
103. Tarrant M., Dazeley S., Cottom T. Social categorization and empathy for outgroup members. British Journal of Social Psychology 2009, 48(3):427-446.
104. Turner J.C., Oakes P.J., Haslam S.A., McGarty C. Self and collective: Cognition and social context. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 1994, 20:454-463.
105. Van Bavel J.J., Cunningham W.A. Self-categorization with a novel mixed-race group moderates automatic social and racial biases. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2009, 35:321-335.
106. Van Bavel J.J., Cunningham W.A. A social neuroscience approach to self and social categorisation: A new look at an old issue. European Review of Social Psychology 2011, 21:237-284.
107. Van Bavel J.J., Cunningham W.A. A social identity approach to person memory: Group membership, collective identification, and social role shape attention and memory. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2012, 38(12):1566-1578.
108. Van Bavel J.J., Packer D.J., Cunningham W.A. The neural substrates of in-group bias: A functional magnetic resonance imaging investigation. Psychological Science 2008, 19:1131-1139.
109. Van Bavel J.J., Packer D.J., Cunningham W.A. Modulation of the Fusiform Face Area following minimal exposure to motivationally relevant faces: Evidence of in-group enhancement (not out-group disregard). Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2011, 23:3343-3354.
110. van Dijk W.W., Ouwerkerk J.W., Goslinga S., Nieweg M. Deservingness and Schadenfreude. Cognition and Emotion 2005, 19:933-939.
111. Van Dijk W.W., Ouwerkerk J.W., Wesseling Y.M., Van Koningsbruggen G.M. Towards understanding pleasure at the misfortunes of others: The impact of self-evaluation threat on Schadenfreude. Cognition and Emotion 2011, 25:360-368.
112. Waytz A., Young L. The group-member mind trade-off attributing mind to groups versus group members. Psychological Science 2012, 23(1):77-85.
113. Weisbuch M., Ambady N. Affective divergence: Automatic responses to others' emotions depend on group membership. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2008, 95:1063-1079.
114. Wildschut T., Pinter B., Vevea J.L., Insko C.A., Schopler J. Beyond the group mind: A quantitative review of the interindividual intergroup discontinuity effect. Psychological Bulletin 2003, 129:698-722.
115. Xu X., Zuo X., Wang X., Han S. Do you feel my pain? Racial group membership modulates empathic neural responses. Journal of Neuroscience 2009, 29:8525-8529.
116. Yzerbyt V.Y., Corneille O., Estrada C. The interplay of subjective essentialism and entitativity in the formation of stereotypes. Personality and Social Psychology Review 2001, 5:141-155.