Involvement of human internal globus pallidus in the early modulation of cortical error-related activity

Cerebral Cortex

Volumn 24, Issue 6, 2014, Pages 1502-1517

  Ruiz, María Herrojo ^a   Huebl, Julius ^a   Schönecker, Thomas ^a   Kupsch, Andreas ^a   Yarrow, Kielan ^b   Krauss, Joachim K ^c   Schneider, Gerd Helge ^a   Kühn, Andrea A ^a  

^a CHARITÉ UNIVERSITÄTSMEDIZIN BERLIN   (Germany)

^b CITY UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^c HANNOVER MEDICAL SCHOOL   (Germany)

Author keywords

Basal ganglia; Error monitoring; Error related negativity; Granger causality; Response errors

Indexed keywords

ADULT; AGED; ARTICLE; BASAL GANGLION; BRAIN CORTEX; CAUSAL ATTRIBUTION; CERVICAL DYSTONIA; CLINICAL ARTICLE; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAM; ERROR; EVENT RELATED POTENTIAL; FEMALE; FRONTAL CORTEX; GLOBUS PALLIDUS; HUMAN; LEARNING; MALE; MONITORING; NEUROMODULATION; OSCILLATION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REINFORCEMENT; SCALP; SENSORIMOTOR CORTEX; STIMULUS RESPONSE; TASK PERFORMANCE; DYSTONIC DISORDERS; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY; EVOKED RESPONSE; EXECUTIVE FUNCTION; IMPLANTABLE NEUROSTIMULATOR; MIDDLE AGED; NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL TEST; PATHOLOGY; PATHOPHYSIOLOGY; PHYSIOLOGY; PSYCHOMOTOR PERFORMANCE; REACTION TIME; SIGNAL PROCESSING; THETA RHYTHM; TIME;

ADULT; AGED; CEREBRAL CORTEX; DYSTONIC DISORDERS; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY; EVOKED POTENTIALS; EXECUTIVE FUNCTION; FEMALE; GLOBUS PALLIDUS; HUMANS; IMPLANTABLE NEUROSTIMULATORS; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL TESTS; PSYCHOMOTOR PERFORMANCE; REACTION TIME; SIGNAL PROCESSING, COMPUTER-ASSISTED; TASK PERFORMANCE AND ANALYSIS; THETA RHYTHM; TIME FACTORS;

EID: 84900796901     PISSN: 10473211     EISSN: 14602199     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/cercor/bht002     Document Type: Article

References (104)

1. Agam Y, Hämäläinen MS, Lee AK, Dyckman KA, Friedman JS, Isom M, Makris N, Manoach DS. 2011. Multimodal neuroimaging dissociates hemodynamic and electrophysiological correlates of error processing. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 108(42):17556-17561.
2. Albin RL, Young AB, Penney JB. 1989. The functional anatomy of basal ganglia disorders. Trends Neurosci. 12(10):366-375. Review.
3. Alegre M, Gurtubay IG, Labarga A, Iriarte J, Valencia M, Artieda J. 2004. Frontal and central oscillatory changes related to different aspects of the motor process: a study in go/no-go paradigms. Exp Brain Res. 159:14-22.
4. Arkadir D, Morris G, Vaadia E, Bergman H. 2004. Independent coding of movement direction and reward prediction by single pallidal neurons. J Neurosci. 24(45):10047-10056.
5. Baccalá LA, Sameshima K. 2001. Partial directed coherence: a new concept in neural structure determination. Biol Cybern. 84 (6):463-474.
6. Basso D, Chiarandini M, Salmaso L. 2007. Synchronized permutation tests in replicated IxJ designs. J Stat Planning Inference. 137 (8):2564-2578.
7. Benjamini Y, Krieger AM, Yekuteli D. 2006. Adaptive linear step-up procedures that control the false discovery rate. Biometrika. 93 (3):491-507.
8. Beste C, Saft C, Andrich J, Gold R, Falkenstein M. 2006. Error processing in Huntington's disease. PLoS One. 1(1):e86.
9. Beste C, Saft C, Konrad C, Andrich J, Habbel A, Schepers I, Jansen A, Pfleiderer B, Falkenstein M. 2008. Levels of error processing in Huntington's disease: a combined study using event-related potentials and voxel-based morphometry. Hum Brain Mapp. 29 (2):121-130.
10. Botvinick M, Nystrom LE, Fissell K, Carter CS, Cohen JD. 1999. Conflict monitoring versus selection-for-action in anterior cingulate cortex. Nature. 402(6758):179-181.
11. Botvinick MM, Braver TS, Barch DM, Carter CS, Cohen JD. 2001. Conflict monitoring and cognitive control. Psychol Rev. 108:624-652.
12. Brücke C, Huebl J, Schönecker T, Neumann WJ, Yarrow K, Kupsch A, Blahak C, Lütjens G, Brown P, Krauss JK et al. 2012. Scaling of movement is related to pallidal γ oscillations in patients with dys-tonia. J Neurosci. 32(3):1008-1019.
13. Brücke C, Kempf F, Kupsch A, Schneider GH, Krauss JK, Aziz T, Yarrow K, Pogosyan A, Brown P, Kühn AA. 2008. Movement-related synchronization of gamma activity is lateralized in patients with dystonia. Eur J Neurosci. 27(9):2322-2329.
14. Cavanagh JF, Cohen MX, Allen JJ. 2009. Prelude to and resolution of an error: EEG phase synchrony reveals cognitive control dynamics during action monitoring. J Neurosci. 29(1):98-105.
15. Cheyne D, Bells S, Ferrari P, Gaetz W, Bostan AC. 2008. Self-paced movements induce high-frequency gamma oscillations in primary motor cortex. Neuroimage. 42:332-342.
16. Cockburn J, Frank MJ. 2011. Reinforcement learning, conflict monitoring, and cognitive control: an integrative model of cingulate-striatal interactions and the ERN. In: Mars RB, Sallet J, Rushworth MFS, Yeung N, editors. Neural basis of motivational and cognitive control. Vol. 9. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, p. 311-331.
17. Cohen MX, Axmacher N, Lenartz D, Elger CE, Sturm V, Schlaepfer TE. 2009a. Good vibrations: cross-frequency coupling in the human nucleus accumbens during reward processing. 21 (5):875-889.
18. Cohen MX, Axmacher N, Lenartz D, Elger CE, Sturm V, Schlaepfer TE. 2009b. Nuclei accumbens phase synchrony predicts decision-making reversals following negative feedback. J Neurosci. 29 (23):7591-7598.
19. Cohen MX, Ranganath C. 2007. Reinforcement learning signals predict future decisions. J Neurosci. 27(2):371-378.
20. Coles MG, Scheffers MK, Holroyd CB. 2001. Why is there an ERN/Ne on correct trials? Response representations, stimulus-related components, and the theory of error-processing. Biol Psychol. 56 (3):173-189.
21. Crone NE, Miglioretti DL, Gordon B, Lesser RP. 1998. Functional mapping of human sensorimotor cortex with electrocorticographic spectral analysis. II. Event-related synchronization in the gamma band. Brain. 121:2301-2315.
22. Debener S, Ullsperger M, Siegel M, Fiehler K, von Cramon DY, Engel AK. 2005. Trial-by-trial coupling of concurrent electroencephalogram and functional magnetic resonance imaging identifies the dynamics of performance monitoring. J Neurosci. 25(50): 11730-11737.
23. DeLong MR. 1990. Primate models of movement disorders of basal ganglia origin. Trends Neurosci. 13(7):281-285. Review.
24. Delorme A, Makeig S. 2004. EEGLAB: an open source toolbox for analysis of single-trial EEG dynamics including independent component analysis. J Neurosci Methods. 134(1):9-21.
25. Desmurget M, Gaveau V, Vindras P, Turner RS, Broussolle E, Thobois S. 2004. On-line motor control in patients with Parkinson's disease. Brain. 127:1755-1773.
26. Desmurget M, Grafton S. 2000. Forward modeling allows feedback control for fast reaching movements. Trends Cogn Sci. 4 (11):423-431.
27. Desmurget M, Gréa H, Grethe JS, Prablanc C, Alexander GE, Grafton ST. 2001. Functional anatomy of nonvisual feedback loops during reaching: a positron emission tomography study. J Neurosci. 21 (8):2919-2928.
28. Ding M, Bressler SL, Yang W, Liang H. 2000. Short-window spectral analysis of cortical event-related potentials by adaptive multivariate autoregressive modeling: data preprocessing, model validation, and variability assessment. Biol Cybern. 83 (1):35-45.
29. Doñamayor N, Heilbronner U, Münte TF. 2011. Coupling electro-physiological and hemodynamic responses to errors. Hum Brain Mapp. doi:10.1002/hbm.21305.
30. Draganski B, Kherif F, Klöppel S, Cook PA, Alexander DC, Parker GJ, Deichmann R, Ashburner J, Frackowiak RS. 2008. Evidence for segregated and integrative connectivity patterns in the human basal ganglia. J Neurosci. 28(28):7143-7152.
31. Efron B. 1992. Jackknife-after-bootstrap standard errors and influence functions. J R Stat Soc B. 54(1):83-127.
32. Falkenstein M, Hielscher H, Dziobek I, Schwarzenau P, Hoormann J, Sunderman B, Hohnsbein J. 2001. Action monitoring, error detection, and the basal ganglia: an ERP study. Neuroreport. 12 (1):157-161.
33. Falkenstein M, Hohnsbein J, Hoormann J, Blanke L. 1990. Effects of errors in choice reaction tasks on the ERP under focused and divided attention. In: Brunia CHM, Gaillard AWK, Kok A, editors. Psychophysiological brain research. Tilburg, The Netherlands: Tilburg University Press, p 192-195.
34. Falkenstein M, Hohnsbein J, Hoormann J. 1995. Event-related potential correlates of errors in reaction tasks. In Karmos G, Molnar M, Csepe V, Czigler I, Desmedt JE, editors. Perspectives of event-related brain potentials research. Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp. 287-296.
35. Fiehler K, Ullsperger M, Von Cramoncd DY. 2005. Electrophysiologi-cal correlates of error correction. Psychophysiology. 42:72-82.
36. Florin E, Gross J, Pfeifer J, Fink GR, Timmermann L. 2010. The effect of filtering on Granger causality based multivariate causality measures. Neuroimage. 50(2):577-588.
37. Fogelson N, Williams D, Tijssen M, van Bruggen G, Speelman H, Brown P. 2006. Different functional loops between cerebral cortex and the subthalamic area in Parkinson's disease. Cereb Cortex. 16:64-75.
38. Frank MJ, Seeberger LC, O'reilly RC. 2004. By carrot or by stick: cognitive reinforcement learning in parkinsonism. Science. 306 (5703):1940-1943.
39. Gehring WJ, Gross B, Coles MGH, Meyer DE, Donchin E. 1993. A neural system for error detection and compensation. Psychol Sci. 4:385-390.
40. Godlove DC, Emeric EE, Segovis CM, Young MS, Schall JD, Woodman GF. 2011. Event-related potentials elicited by errors during the stop-signal task. I. Macaque monkeys. J Neurosci. 31 (44):15640-15649.
41. Good P. 2005. Permutation, parametric, and bootstrap tests of hypotheses. 2nd ed. Berlin: Springer.
42. Grafton ST, Tunik E. 2011. Human basal ganglia and the dynamic control of force during on-line corrections. J Neurosci. 31 (5):1600-1605.
43. Granger CWJ. 1969. s Investigating causal relations by econometric models and cross-spectral methods. Econometrica. 37:424-438.
44. Hallet M. 1998. The neurophysiology of dystonia. Arch Neurol. 55:601-603.
45. Heinze HJ, Heldmann M, Voges J, Hinrichs H, Marco-Pallares J, Hopf JM, Müller UJ, Galazky I, Sturm V, Bogerts B et al. 2009. Counteracting incentive sensitization in severe alcohol dependence using deep brain stimulation of the nucleus accumbens: clinical and basic science aspects. Front Hum Neurosci. 3:22.
46. Hester R, Fassbender C, Garavan H. 2004. Individual differences in error processing: a review and reanalysis of three event-related fMRI studies using the GO/NOGO task. Cereb Cortex. 14: 986-994.
47. Hester R, Madeley J, Murphy K, Mattingley JB. 2009. Learning from errors: error-related neural activity predicts improvements in future inhibitory control performance. J Neurosci. 29:7158-7165.
48. Hikosaka O, Bromberg-Martin E, Hong S, Matsumoto M. 2008. New insights on the subcortical representation of reward. Curr Opin Neurobiol. 18(2):203-208.
49. Holroyd CB, Coles MG. 2002. The neural basis of human error processing: reinforcement learning, dopamine, and the error-related negativity. Psychol Rev. 109:679-709.
50. Holroyd CB, Nieuwenhuis S, Yeung N, Nystrom L, Mars RB, Coles MGH, Cohen JD. 2004. Dorsal anterior cingulate cortex shows fMRI response to internal and external error signals. Nat Neurosci. 7:497-498.
51. Hong S, Hikosaka O. 2008. The globus pallidus sends reward-related signals to the lateral habenula. Neuron. 60:720-729.
52. Hong S, Jhou TC, Smith M, Saleem KS, Hikosaka O. 2011. Negative reward signals from the lateral habenula to dopamine neurons are mediated by rostromedial tegmental nucleus in primates. J Neuro-sci. 31(32):11457-11471.
53. Houk JC, Bastianen C, Fansler D, Fishbach A, Fraser D, Reber PJ, Roy SA, Simo LS. 2007. Action selection and refinement in subcortical loops through basal ganglia and cerebellum. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 362:1573-1583.
54. Huo X, Xiang J, Wang Y, Kirtman EG, Kotecha R, Fujiwara H, Hema-silpin N, Rose DF, Degrauw T. 2010. Gamma oscillations in the primary motor cortex studied with MEG. Brain Dev. 32(8): 619-624.
55. Johannes S, Wieringa BM, Nager W, Müller-Vahl KR, Dengler R, Münte TF. 2002. Excessive action monitoring in Tourette syndrome. J Neurol. 249:961-966.
56. Kempf F, Brücke C, Kühn AA, Schneider GH, Kupsch A, Chen CC, Androulidakis AG, Wang S, Vandenberghe W, Nuttin B et al. 2007. Modulation by dopamine of human basal ganglia involvement in feedback control of movement. Curr Biol. 17(15):587-589.
57. Kiehl KA, Liddle PF, Hopfinger JB. 2000. Error processing and the rostral anterior cingulate: an event-related fMRI study. Psychophy-siology. 37:216-223.
58. Klostermann F, Wahl M, Marzinzik F, Schneider GH, Kupsch A, Curio G. 2006. Mental chronometry of target detection: human thalamus leads cortex. Brain. 129(Pt 4):923-931.
59. Kopp B, Rist F, Mattler U. 1996. N200 in the flanker task as a neuro-behavioral tool for investigating executive control. Psychophysiol-ogy. 33(3):282-294.
60. Kuhn J, Gründler TO, Bauer R, Huff W, Fischer AG, Lenartz D, Maarouf M, Bührle C, Klosterkötter J, Ullsperger M et al. 2011. Successful deep brain stimulation of the nucleus accumbens in severe alcohol dependence is associated with changed performance monitoring. Addict Biol. 16(4):620-623.
61. Lalo E, Thobois S, Sharott A, Polo G, Mertens P, Pogosyan A, Brown P. 2008. Patterns of bidirectional communication between cortex and basal ganglia during movement in patients with Parkinson disease. J Neurosci. 28:3008-3016.
62. Lardeux S, Pernaud R, Paleressompoulle D, Baunez C. 2009. Beyond the reward pathway: coding reward magnitude and error in the rat subthalamic nucleus. J Neurophysiol. 102(4): 2526-2537.
63. Litvak V, Jha A, Eusebio A, Oostenveld R, Foltynie T, Limousin P, Zrinzo L, Hariz MI, Friston K, Brown P. 2011. Resting oscillatory cortico-subthalamic connectivity in patients with Parkinson's disease. Brain. 134(Pt 2):359-374.
64. Liu X, Wang S, Yianni J, Nandi D, Bain PG, Gregory R, Stein JF, Aziz TZ. 2008. The sensory and motor representation of synchronized oscillations in the globus pallidus in patients with primary dysto-nia. Brain. 131:1562-1573.
65. Luu P, Tucker DM, Makeig S. 2004. Frontal midline theta and the error-related negativity: neurophysiological mechanisms of action regulation. Clin Neurophysiol. 115:1821-1835.
66. Mallat S. 1999. A wavelet tour of signal processing. San Diego: Academic Press.
67. Marco-Pallarés J, Camara E, Münte TF, Rodríguez- Fornells A. 2008. Neural mechanisms underlying adaptive actions after slips. J Cogn Neurosci. 20(9):1595-1610.
68. Mazzoni P, Hristova A, Krakauer JW. 2007. Why don't we move faster? Parkinson's disease, movement vigor, and implicit motivation. J Neurosci. 27(27):7105-7116.
69. McClure SM, Daw ND, Montague PR. 2003. A computational substrate for incentive salience. Trends Neurosci. 26(8):423-428.
70. Mogenson GJ, Jones DL, Yim CY. 1980. From motivation to action: functional interface between the limbic system and the motor system. Prog Neurobiol. 14:69-97.
71. Münte TF, Heldmann M, Hinrichs H, Marco-Pallares J, Krämer UM, Sturm V, Heinze HJ. 2008. Nucleus accumbens is involved in human action monitoring: evidence from invasive electrophysio-logical recordings. Front Hum Neurosci. 1:11.
72. Muthukumaraswamy SD. 2010. Functional properties of human primary motor cortex gamma oscillations. J Neurophysiol. 104:2873-2885.
73. Nambu A, Tokuno H, Hamada I, Kita H, Imanishi M, Akazawa T, Ikeuchi Y, Hasegawa N. 2000. Excitatory cortical inputs to pallidal neurons via the subthalamic nucleus in the monkey. J Neurophy-siol. 84(1):289-300.
74. Niv Y, Daw ND, Joel D, Dayan P. 2007. Tonic dopamine: opportunity costs and the control of response vigor. Psychopharmacology (Berl). 191(3):507-520.
75. Pasupathy A, Miller EK. 2005. Different time courses of learning-related activity in the prefrontal cortex and striatum. Nature. 433(7028):873-876.
76. Pikovsky A, Rosenblum M, Kurths J. 2001. Synchronization-A universal concept in nonlinear sciences. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
77. Ridderinkhof KR, Ullsperger M, Crone EA, Nieuwenhuis S. 2004. The role of the medial frontal cortex in cognitive control. Science. 306 (5695):443-447. Review.
78. Rodríguez-Fornells A, Kurzbuch AR, Münte TF. 2002. Time course of error detection and correction in humans: neurophysiological evidence. J Neurosci. 22(22):9990-9996.
79. Rodriguez-Oroz MC, López-Azcárate J, Garcia-Garcia D, Alegre M, Toledo J, Valencia M, Guridi J, Artieda J, Obeso JA. 2011. Involvement of the subthalamic nucleus in impulse control disorders associated with Parkinson's disease. Brain. 134:36-49.
80. Schlögl A, Supp G. 2006. Analyzing event-related EEG data with multivariate autoregressive parameters. Prog Brain Res. 159:135-147.
81. Schönecker T, Kupsch A, Kuhn AA, Schneider GH, Hoffmann KT. 2009. Automated optimization of subcortical cerebral MR imaging-atlas co-registration for improved postoperative electrode localization in deep brain stimulation. Am J Neuroradiol. 30:1914-1921.
82. Schultz W. 2002. Getting formal with dopamine and reward. Neuron. 36(2):241-263. Review.
83. Schultz W, Dayan P, Montague PR. 1997. A neural substrate of prediction and reward. Science. 275(5306):1593-1599.
84. Schwarz G. 1978. Estimating the dimension of a model. Ann Stat. 6 (2):461-464.
85. Seifert S, von Cramon DY, Imperati D, Tittgemeyer M, Ullsperger M. 2011. Thalamocingulate interactions in performance monitoring. J Neurosci. 31(9):3375-3383.
86. Shadmehr R, Krakauer JW. 2008. A computational neuroanatomy for motor control. Exp Brain Res. 185(3):359-381. Review.
87. Sharott A, Grosse P, Kühn AA, Salih F, Engel AK, Kupsch A, Schneider GH, Krauss JK, Brown P. 2008. Is the synchronization between pallidal and muscle activity in primary dystonia due to peripheral afferance or a motor drive? Brain. 131(Pt 2):473-484.
88. Silvetti M, Seurinck R, Verguts T. 2011. Value and prediction error in medial frontal cortex: integrating the single-unit and systems levels of analysis. Front Hum Neurosci. 5:75.
89. Stemmer B, Segalowitz SJ, Dywan J, Panisset M, Melmed C. 2007. The error negativity in non-medicated and medicated patients with Parkinson's disease. Clin Neurophysiol. 118:1223-1229.
90. Strutt JW. 1905. The problem of the random walk. Nature. 72:318.
91. Sutton RS. 1988. Learning to predict by the methods of temporal differences. Machine Learn. 3:9-44.
92. Sutton RS, Barto AG. 1998. Reinforcement learning: an introduction. Cambridge (MA): MIT Press.
93. Taha SA, Nicola SM, Fields HL. 2007. Cue-evoked encoding of movement planning and execution in the rat nucleus accumbens. J Physiol. 584(Pt 3):801-818.
94. Taylor SF, Stern ER, Gehring WJ. 2007. Neural systems for error monitoring: recent findings and theoretical perspectives. Neuroscientist. 13:160-172.
95. Todorov E, Jordan MI. 2002. Optimal feedback control as antheory of motor coordination. Nat Neurosci. 5:1226-1235.
96. Trujillo LT, Allen JJ. 2007. Theta EEG dynamics of the error-related negativity. Clin Neurophysiol. 118(3):645-668.
97. Trujillo LT, Peterson MA, Kaszniak AW, Allen JJ. 2005. EEG phase synchrony differences across visual perception conditions may depend on recording and analysis methods. Clin Neurophysiol. 116(1):172-189.
98. Tunik E, Houk JC, Grafton ST. 2009. Basal ganglia contribution to the initiation of corrective submovements. Neuroimage. 47(4):1757-1766.
99. Turner RS, Desmurget M. 2010. Basal ganglia contributions to motor control: a vigorous tutor. Curr Opin Neurobiol. 20:704-716.
100. Ullsperger M, Nittono H, von Cramon DY. 2007. When goals are missed: dealing with self-generated and externally induced failure. Neuroimage. 35(3):1356-1364.
101. Ullsperger M, von Cramon DY. 2006. The role of intact frontostriatal circuits in error processing. J Cogn Neurosci. 18(4):651-664.
102. van Veen V, Carter CS. 2002. The anterior cingulate as a conflict monitor: fMRI and ERP studies. Physiol Behav. 77(4-5):477-482.
103. Willemssen R, Müller T, Schwarz M, Falkenstein M, Beste C. 2009. Response monitoring in de novo patients with Parkinson's disease. PLoS One. 4(3):e4898.
104. Williams D, Tijssen M, Van Bruggen G, Bosch A, Insola A, Di Lazzaro V, Mazzone P, Oliviero A, Quartarone A, Speelman H et al. 2002. Dopamine-dependent changes in the functional connectivity between basal ganglia and cerebral cortex in humans. Brain. 125 (Pt 7):1558-1569.