Review of robotic versus conventional laparoscopic surgery

Surgical Endoscopy

Volumn 28, Issue 5, 2014, Pages 1413-1424

  Brody, Fred ^a   Richards, Nathan G ^a  

^a GEORGE WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ABDOMINAL SURGERY; ADRENALECTOMY; CHOLECYSTECTOMY; COLON RESECTION; COLORECTAL SURGERY; CONVERSION TO OPEN SURGERY; CYSTECTOMY; GASTRIC BANDING; HYSTERECTOMY; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY; LAPAROSCOPIC SURGICAL INSTRUMENT; OPERATING ROOM; OPERATION DURATION; PANCREAS RESECTION; PANCREATICODUODENECTOMY; PARTIAL NEPHRECTOMY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROSTATECTOMY; REVIEW; ROBOTIC SURGERY; ROBOTICS; SAFETY; SLEEVE GASTRECTOMY; SPLENECTOMY; STOMACH BYPASS; STOMACH FUNDOPLICATION; SURGICAL TECHNOLOGY; HUMAN; LAPAROSCOPY; PROCEDURES; REPRODUCIBILITY;

HUMANS; LAPAROSCOPY; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; ROBOTICS;

EID: 84900331118     PISSN: 09302794     EISSN: 14322218     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s00464-013-3342-4     Document Type: Review

References (81)

1. http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/cdrh-docs/pdf9/K090993.pdf. ISRG (2000) K002489-daVinci -revised 510 k. Accessed 4 Jun 2013
2. http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/cdrh-docs/pdf/K011002.pdf. ISRG (2001) K011002-daVinci-Rad Prostatectomy. Accessed 4 Jun 2013
3. http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/cdrh-docs/pdf5/K050404.pdf. ISRG (2005) K050404-daVinci-gyn ecol. Accessed 4 Jun 2013
4. http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/cdrh-docs/pdf/k003431.pdf ISRG (2000) K003431-Zeus Robot. Accessed 4 Jun 2013
5. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZEUS-robotic-surgical-system
6. Jin LX, Ibrahim AM, Newman NA, Makarov DV, Pronovost PJ, Makary MA (2011) Robotic surgery claims on United States hospital websites. J Healthc Qual 33:48-52
7. Schiavone MB, Kuo EC, Naumann RW, Burke WM, Lewin SN, Neugut AI, Hershman DL, Herzog TJ, Wright JD (2012) The commercialization of robotic surgery: unsubstantiated marketing of gynecologic surgery by hospitals. Am J Obstet Gynecol 207(174):171-177
8. Mirkin JN, Lowrance WT, Feifer AH, Mulhall JP, Eastham JE, Elkin EB (2012) Direct-to-consumer internet promotion of robotic prostatectomy exhibits varying quality of information. Health Aff 31:760-769
9. https://materials.proxyvote.com/Approved/46120E/20100222/AR-53320/HTML2/ default.html ISRG (2009) ISRG-2009-Annual Report. Accessed 4 Jun 2013
10. Paraiso MF, Jelovsek JE, Frick A, Chen CC, Barber MD (2011) Laparoscopic compared with robotic sacrocolpopexy for vaginal prolapse: a randomized controlled trial. Obstet Gynecol 118:1005-1013
11. Sarlos D, Kots L, Stevanovic N, von Felten S, Schar G (2012) Robotic compared with conventional laparoscopic hysterectomy: a randomized controlled trial. Obstet Gynecol 120:604-611
12. Liu H, Lu D, Wang L, Shi G, Song H, Clarke J (2012) Robotic surgery for benign gynaecological disease. Cochrane database of systematic reviews 2:CD008978
13. Wright JD, Ananth CV, Lewin SN, Burke WM, Lu YS, Neugut AI, Herzog TJ, Hershman DL (2013) Robotically assisted vs laparoscopic hysterectomy among women with benign gynecologic disease. JAMA 309:689-698
14. Weissman JS, Zinner M (2013) Comparative effectiveness research on robotic surgery. JAMA 309:721-722
15. Orady M, Hrynewych A, Nawfal AK, Wegienka G (2012) Comparison of robotic-assisted hysterectomy to other minimally invasive approaches. JSLS 16:542-548
16. Wright KN, Jonsdottir GM, Jorgensen S, Shah N, Einarsson JI (2012) Costs and outcomes of abdominal, vaginal, laparoscopic and robotic hysterectomies. JSLS 16:519-524
17. Wright JD, Burke WM, Wilde ET, Lewin SN, Charles AS, Kim JH, Goldman N, Neugut AI, Herzog TJ, Hershman DL (2012) Comparative effectiveness of robotic versus laparoscopic hysterectomy for endometrial cancer. J Clin Oncol 30:783-791
18. Holtz DO, Miroshnichenko G, Finnegan MO, Chernick M, Dunton CJ (2010) Endometrial cancer surgery costs: robot vs laparoscopy. J Minim Invasive Gynecol 17:500-503
19. Pasic RP, Rizzo JA, Fang H, Ross S, Moore M, Gunnarsson C (2010) Comparing robot-assisted with conventional laparoscopic hysterectomy: impact on cost and clinical outcomes. J Minim Invasive Gynecol 17:730-738
20. AAGL (2013) AAGL position statement: robotic-assisted laparoscopic surgery in benign gynecology. J Minim Invasive Gynecol 20:2-9
21. Breeden JT (2013) Statement on robotic surgery by ACOG President James T. Breeden, MD. ACOG website
22. Ramirez PT, Adams S, Boggess JF, Burke WM, Frumovitz MM, Gardner GJ, Havrilesky LJ, Holloway R, Lowe MP, Magrina JF, Moore DH, Soliman PT, Yap S (2012) Robotic-assisted surgery in gynecologic oncology: a society of gynecologic oncology consensus statement. Developed by the society of gynecologic oncology's clinical practice robotics task force. Gynecol Oncol 124:180-184
23. Wilson EB (2009) The evolution of robotic general surgery. Scand J Surg 98:125-129
24. Moran PS, O'Neill M, Teljeur C, Flattery M, Murphy LA, Smith G, Ryan M (2013) Robot-assisted radical prostatectomy compared with open and laparoscopic approaches: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Urol 20:312-321
25. Asimakopoulos AD, Pereira Fraga CT, Annino F, Pasqualetti P, Calado AA, Mugnier C (2011) Randomized comparison between laparoscopic and robot-assisted nerve-sparing radical prostatectomy. J Sex Med 8:1503-1512
26. Hakimi AA, Blitstein J, Feder M, Shapiro E, Ghavamian R (2009) Direct comparison of surgical and functional outcomes of robotic-assisted versus pure laparoscopic radical prostatectomy: single-surgeon experience. Urology 73:119-123
27. Trabulsi EJ, Zola JC, Gomella LG, Lallas CD (2010) Transition from pure laparoscopic to robotic-assisted radical prostatectomy: a single surgeon institutional evolution. Urol Oncol 28:81-85
28. Anderson JE, Chang DC, Parsons JK, Talamini MA (2012) The first national examination of outcomes and trends in robotic surgery in the United States. J Am Coll Surg 215:107-114 discussion 114-116
29. Masson-Lecomte A, Bensalah K, Seringe E, Vaessen C, de la Taille A, Doumerc N, Rischmann P, Bruyere F, Soustelle L, Droupy S, Roupret M (2013) A prospective comparison of surgical and pathological outcomes obtained after robot-assisted or pure laparoscopic partial nephrectomy in moderate to complex renal tumours: results from a French multicentre collaborative study. BJU Int 111:256-263
30. Mir SA, Cadeddu JA, Sleeper JP, Lotan Y (2011) Cost comparison of robotic, laparoscopic, and open partial nephrectomy. J Endourol 25:447-453
31. Aboumarzouk OM, Stein RJ, Eyraud R, Haber GP, Chlosta PL, Somani BK, Kaouk JH (2012) Robotic versus laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur Urol 62:1023-1033
32. Yu HY, Hevelone ND, Lipsitz SR, Kowalczyk KJ, Hu JC (2012) Use, costs and comparative effectiveness of robotic-assisted, laparoscopic and open urological surgery. J Urol 187:1392-1398
33. Alemozaffar M, Chang SL, Kacker R, Sun M, Dewolf WC, Wagner AA (2013) Comparing costs of robotic, laparoscopic, and open partial nephrectomy. J Endourol 27(5):560-565
34. Panumatrassamee K, Autorino R, Laydner H, Hillyer S, Khalifeh A, Kassab A, Stein RJ, Haber GP, Kaouk JH (2013) Robotic versus laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for tumor in a solitary kidney: a single institution comparative analysis. Int J Urol 20:484-491
35. Gregori A, Galli S, Goumas I, Scieri F, Stener S, Gaboardi F (2007) A cost comparison of laparoscopic versus open radical cystoprostatectomy and orthotopic ileal neobladder at a single institution. Arch Italiano Urol Androl 79:127-129 (Pubitemid 350073484)
36. Zehnder P, Gill IS (2011) Cost-effectiveness of open versus laparoscopic versus robotic-assisted laparoscopic cystectomy and urinary diversion. Curr Opin Urol 21:415-419
37. Khan MS, Challacombe B, Elhage O, Rimington P, Coker B, Murphy D, Grieve A, Dasgupta P (2012) A dual-centre, cohort comparison of open, laparoscopic and robotic-assisted radical cystectomy. Int J Clin Prac 66:656-662
38. Ballantyne GH, Merola S, Weber P, Wasielewski A (2001) Robotic solutions to the pitfalls of laparoscopic colectomy. Osp Ital Chir 7:405-412
39. Alasari S, Min BS (2012) Robotic colorectal surgery: a systematic review. ISRN Surg 2012:293894
40. Baik SH, Kwon HY, Kim JS, Hur H, Sohn SK, Cho CH, Kim H (2009) Robotic versus laparoscopic low anterior resection of rectal cancer: short-term outcome of a prospective comparative study. Ann Surg Oncol 16:1480-1487
41. Bianchi PP, Ceriani C, Locatelli A, Spinoglio G, Zampino MG, Sonzogni A, Crosta C, Andreoni B (2010) Robotic versus laparoscopic total mesorectal excision for rectal cancer: a comparative analysis of oncological safety and short-term outcomes. Surg Endosc 24:2888-2894
42. Kwak JM, Kim SH, Kim J, Son DN, Baek SJ, Cho JS (2011) Robotic vs laparoscopic resection of rectal cancer: short-term outcomes of a case-control study. Dis Colon Rectum 54:151-156
43. Park JS, Choi GS, Lim KH, Jang YS, Jun SH (2010) Robotic-assisted versus laparoscopic surgery for low rectal cancer: case-matched analysis of short-term outcomes. Ann Surg Oncol 17:3195-3202
44. Trastulli S, Farinella E, Cirocchi R, Cavaliere D, Avenia N, Sciannameo F, Gulla N, Noya G, Boselli C (2012) Robotic resection compared with laparoscopic rectal resection for cancer: systematic review and meta-analysis of short-term outcome. Colorectal Dis 14:134-156
45. Tyler JA, Fox JP, Desai MM, Perry WB, Glasgow SC (2013) Outcomes and costs associated with robotic colectomy in the minimally invasive era. Dis Colon Rectum 56:458-466
46. Rawlings AL, Woodland JH, Vegunta RK, Crawford DL (2007) Robotic versus laparoscopic colectomy. Surg Endosc 21:1701-1708 (Pubitemid 47404103)
47. Lim DR, Min BS, Kim MS, Alasari S, Kim G, Hur H, Baik SH, Lee KY, Kim NK (2013) Robotic versus laparoscopic anterior resection of sigmoid colon cancer: comparative study of long-term oncologic outcomes. Surg Endosc 27:1379-1385
48. Halabi WJ, Kang CY, Jafari MD, Nguyen VQ, Carmichael JC, Mills S, Stamos MJ, Pigazzi A (2013) Robotic-assisted colorectal surgery in the united states: a nationwide analysis of trends and outcomes. World J Surg 1-9
49. Gurusamy KS, Samraj K, Fusai G, Davidson BR (2012) Robot assistant versus human or another robot assistant in patients undergoing laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Cochrane database of systematic reviews 9:CD006578
50. Zhou HX, Guo YH, Yu XF, Bao SY, Liu JL, Zhang Y, Ren YG (2006) Zeus robot-assisted laparoscopic cholecystectomy in comparison with conventional laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Hepatobil Pancreatic Dis Int HBPD INT 5:115-118
51. Maeso S, Reza M, Mayol JA, Blasco JA, Guerra M, Andradas E, Plana MN (2010) Efficacy of the Da Vinci surgical system in abdominal surgery compared with that of laparoscopy: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Ann Surg 252:254-262
52. Gozalez AM, Rabaza JR, Donkor C, Romero RJ, Kosanovic R, Verdeja JC (2013) Single-incision cholecystectomy: a comparative study of standard laparoscopic, robotic, and SPIDER platforms. Surg Endosc 27(12):4524-4531 Aug 2013
53. Buzad FA, Corne LM, Brown TC, Fagin RS, Hebert AE, Kacmarek CA, Pack AN, Payne TN (2013) Single-site robotic cholecystectomy: efficiency and cost analysis. Int J Med Robot 9(3):365-370
54. Vidovsky TJ, Carr AD, Farinholt GN, Ho HS, Smith WH, Ali MR (2013) Single-Site robotic cholecystectomy in a broadly inclusive patient population: a prospective study. Ann Surg October 28, 2013. Epub ahead of print
55. Romero-Talamis H, Kroh M (2013) Cholecystectomy by using a surgical robot system. Journal of hepato-biliary-pancreatic sciences. September 20, 2013. Epub ahead of print
56. Ross SB, Sawangkum P, De La Vega KA, Teta A, Luberice K, Rosemurgy AS (2013) Single-site robotic cholecystectomy (SSRC): an initial review of safety and feasibility. Miner Chirurg 68(5):435-443
57. Pietrabissa A, Sbrana F, Morelli L, Badessi F, Publiese L, Vinci A, Klersy C, Spinoglio G (2012) Overcoming the challenges of single-incision cholecystectomy with robotic single-site technology. Arch Surg 14(8):709-714
58. Markar SR, Karthikesalingam AP, Hagen ME, Talamini M, Horgan S, Wagner OJ (2010) Robotic vs. laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease: systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Med Robot 6:125-131
59. Mi J, Kang Y, Chen X, Wang B, Wang Z (2010) Whether robot-assisted laparoscopic fundoplication is better for gastroesophageal reflux disease in adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Surg Endosc 24:1803-1814
60. Wang Z, Zheng Q, Jin Z (2012) Meta-analysis of robot-assisted versus conventional laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease. ANZ J Surg 82:112-117
61. Sanchez BR, Mohr CJ, Morton JM, Safadi BY, Alami RS, Curet MJ (2005) Comparison of totally robotic laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass and traditional laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass. Surg Obes Rel Dis 1:549-554
62. Markar SR, Karthikesalingam AP, Venkat-Ramen V, Kinross J, Ziprin P (2011) Robotic vs. laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass in morbidly obese patients: systematic review and pooled analysis. Int J Med Robot 7:393-400
63. Scozzari G, Rebecchi F, Millo P, Rocchietto S, Allieta R, Morino M (2011) Robot-assisted gastrojejunal anastomosis does not improve the results of the laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass. Surg Endosc 25:597-603
64. Hagen ME, Pugin F, Chassot G, Huber O, Buchs N, Iranmanesh P, Morel P (2012) Reducing cost of surgery by avoiding complications: the model of robotic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass. Obes Surg 22:52-61
65. Edelson PK, Dumon KR, Sonnad SS, Shafi BM, Williams NN (2011) Robotic vs. conventional laparoscopic gastric banding: a comparison of 407 cases. Surg Endosc 25:1402-1408
66. Ayloo S, Buchs NC, Addeo P, Bianco FM, Giulianotti PC (2011) Robot-assisted sleeve gastrectomy for super-morbidly obese patients. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A 21:295-299
67. Agcaoglu O, Aliyev S, Karabulut K, Mitchell J, Siperstein A, Berber E (2012) Robotic versus laparoscopic resection of large adrenal tumors. Ann Surg Oncol 19:2288-2294
68. Karabulut K, Agcaoglu O, Aliyev S, Siperstein A, Berber E (2012) Comparison of intraoperative time use and perioperative outcomes for robotic versus laparoscopic adrenalectomy. Surgery 151:537-542
69. Agcaoglu O, Aliyev S, Karabulut K, Siperstein A, Berber E (2012) Robotic vs. laparoscopic posterior retroperitoneal adrenalectomy. Arch Surg 147:272-275
70. Brunaud L, Germain A, Zarnegar R, Cuny T, Ayav A, Bresler L (2011) Robot-assisted adrenalectomy. Surg Laparosc Endosc Percutan Tech 21:248-254
71. Gelmini R, Franzoni C, Spaziani A, Patriti A, Casciola L, Saviano M (2011) Laparoscopic splenectomy: conventional versus robotic approach - a comparative study. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A 21:393-398
72. Vasilescu C, Stanciulea O, Tudor S (2012) Laparoscopic versus robotic subtotal splenectomy in hereditary spherocytosis. Potential advantages and limits of an expensive approach. Surg Endosc 26:2802-2809
73. Kang CM, Kim DH, Lee WJ, Chi HS (2011) Conventional laparoscopic and robot-assisted spleen-preserving pancreatectomy: does da Vinci have clinical advantages? Surg Endosc 25:2004-2009
74. Waters JA, Canal DF, Wiebke EA, Dumas RP, Beane JD, Aguilar-Saavedra JR, Ball CG, House MG, Zyromski NJ, Nakeeb A, Pitt HA, Lillemoe KD, Schmidt CM (2010) Robotic distal pancreatectomy: cost effective? Surgery 148:814-823
75. Daouadi M, Zureikat AH, Zenati MS, Choudry H, Tsung A, Bartlett DL, Hughes SJ, Lee KK, Moser AJ, Zeh HJ (2013) Robot-assisted minimally invasive distal pancreatectomy is superior to the laparoscopic technique. Ann Surg 257:128-132
76. Shoup M, Brennan MF, McWhite K, Leung DH, Klimstra D, Conlon KC (2002) The value of splenic preservation with distal pancreatectomy. Arch Surg 137:164-168 (Pubitemid 34142132)
77. Kendrick ML (2012) Laparoscopic and robotic resection for pancreatic cancer. Cancer J 18:571-576
78. Giulianotti PC, Sbrana F, Bianco FM, Elli EF, Shah G, Addeo P, Caravaglios G, Coratti A (2010) Robot-assisted laparoscopic pancreatic surgery: single-surgeon experience. Surg Endosc 24:1646-1657
79. Asbun HJ, Stauffer JA (2012) Laparoscopic vs open pancreaticoduodenectomy: overall outcomes and severity of complications using the Accordion Severity Grading System. J Am Coll Surg 215:810-819
80. Buchs NC, Addeo P, Bianco FM, Ayloo S, Benedetti E, Giulianotti PC (2011) Robotic versus open pancreaticoduodenectomy: a comparative study at a single institution. World J Surg 35:2739-2746
81. Fisher SB, Kooby DA (2013) Laparoscopic pancreatectomy for malignancy. J Surg Oncol 107:39-50