Gender and the evaluation of research

Research Policy

Volumn 43, Issue 6, 2014, Pages 990-1001

  Brooks, Chris ^a   Fenton, Evelyn M ^a   Walker, James T ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF READING   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Gender; Research assessment exercise; Research evaluation; Research excellence framework; Research quality

Indexed keywords

INFORMATION MANAGEMENT; RATING; RESEARCH;

BUSINESS SCHOOLS; GENDER; RESEARCH ASSESSMENT EXERCISE; RESEARCH EVALUATION; RESEARCH QUALITY; SUB-DISCIPLINES;

QUALITY CONTROL;

EID: 84899907319     PISSN: 00487333     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.respol.2013.12.005     Document Type: Article

References (71)

1. V.K. Agrawal, V. Agrawal, and M. Rungtusanatham Theoretical and interpretation challenges to using the author affiliation index method to rank journals Production and Operations Management 20 2 2011 280 300
2. D.W. Aksnes, K. Rorstad, F. Piro, and S. Gunnar Are female researchers less cited? A large-scale study of Norwegian scientists Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 62 2011 628 636
3. D.A. Barbezat Salary differentials by sex in the academic labour market Journal of Human Resources 22 1987 422 428
4. V. Beattie, and A. Goodacre Publication records of accounting and finance faculty promoted to professor: evidence from the UK Accounting and Business Research 42 2 2012 197 231
5. D. Blackaby, A. Booth, and J. Frank Outside offers and the gender pay gap: empirical evidence from the UK academic labour market Economic Journal 115 2005 F81 F107
6. B. Bozeman, and M. Gaughan How do men and women differ in research collaborations? Analysis of the collaborative motives and strategies of academic researchers Research Policy 40 10 2011 1393 1402
7. J. Broadbent The UK Research Assessment Exercise: Performance measurement and resource allocation Australian Accounting Review 20 2010 14 23
8. M. Browning Children and household economic behavior Journal of Economic Literature 30 1992 1434 1475
9. M.J. Budig, and P. England The wage penalty for motherhood American Sociological Review 66 2001 204 225
10. L. Butler Assessing university research: a plea for a balanced approach Science and Public Policy 34 8 2007 565 574
11. S. Collini Absent Minds: Intellectuals in Britain 2008 Oxford University Press Oxford
12. J. Colyvas Performance metrics as formal structures and through the lens of social mechanisms: when do they work and how do they influence? American Journal of Education 118 2 2012 167 197
13. T. Coupé, V. Ginsburgh, and A. Noury Are leading papers of better quality? Evidence from a natural experiment Oxford Economic Papers 62 2010 1 11
14. E. Davenport, and H. Snyder Who cites women? Whom do women cite? An exploration of gender and scholarly citation in sociology Journal of Documentation 51 1995 404 410
15. Department for Business Innovation and Skills Annual Innovation Report: Innovation, Growth, and Research 2012
16. C. Donovan The qualitative future of research evaluation Science and Public Policy 34 8 2007 585 597
17. P.D. Dwyer Gender differences in the scholarly activities of accounting academics: an empirical investigation Issues in Accounting Education 9 1994 231 247
18. G. Easton, and D.M. Easton Marketing journals and the Research Assessment Exercise Journal of Marketing Management 19 2003 5 24
19. European Commission Realising the European higher education area: achieving the goals Conference of European Higher Education Ministers Contribution of the European Commission, Bergen 19/20 May 2005, Brussels 2005
20. J. Finch Foreword: Why be Interested in Women's Position in Academe?. Gender, Work & Organization 10 2003 133 136
21. A. Findlay, and L. Sparks The UK research assessment exercise (RAE 2008) and retail research output International Review of Retail, Distribution & Consumer Research 20 5 2010 583 595
22. C. Fletcher Passing the buck: gender and management of research production in UK higher education: management perspectives from a case study Equal Opportunities International 26 2007 269 286
23. M.W. Giles, and J.C. Garand Ranking political science journals: reputational and citational approaches PS: Political Science & Politics 40 4 2007 741 751
24. D.K. Ginther, and S. Kahn Women in economics: moving up or falling off the academic career ladder? Journal of Economic Perspectives 18 2004 193 214
25. K. Haynes, and A. Fearfull Exploring ourselves: exploiting and resisting gendered identities of women academics in accounting and management Pacific Accounting Review 20 2008 185 204
26. HEFCE Analysis of data from the pilot exercise to develop bibliometric indicators for the REF: the effect of using normalised citation scores for particular staff characteristics Issues Paper, February 2011/03 2011 HEFCE
27. A.G.F. Hoepner, and J. Unerman Explicit and implicit subject biases in the ABS Journal Quality Guide Accounting Education 21 2012 3 15
28. L.A. Hunter, and E. Leahey Parenting and research productivity: new evidence and methods Social Studies of Science 40 2010 433 451
29. J.A. Jacobs, and S.E. Winslow The academic life course, time pressures and gender inequality Community, Work and Family 7 2 2004 143 161
30. C.E. Jordan, S.J. Clark, and C.E. Vann Do gender differences exist in the publication productivity of accounting faculty? Journal of Applied Business Research 24 2008 77 85
31. A. Kelly, H. Morris, and C. Harvey Modelling the Outcome of the UK Business and Management Studies RAE 2008 with Reference to the ABS Journal Quality Guide 2009 (downloaded on 29 April 2011 from http://www.the-abs.org.uk/ files/RAE2008-ABS2009-final.pdf)
32. D. Knights, and W. Richards Sex discrimination in UK academia Gender, Work and Organisation 10 2003 213 238
33. E. Leahey, J.L. Crockett, and L.A. Hunter Gendered academic careers: specializing for success? Social Forces 86 3 2008 1273 1309
34. B. London, D.G. Rattan, R. Romero-Canyas, and D. Tyson Gender-based rejection sensitivity and academic self-silencing in women Journal of Personality & Social Psychology 5 2012 961 979
35. S.J. Long, P.D. Allison, and R. McGinnis Rank advancement in academic careers: sex differences and the effects of productivity American Sociological Review 58 5 1993 703 722
36. S. Macdonald, and J. Kam A ring a ring o'roses: quality journals and gamesmanship in management studies Journal of Management Studies 44 2007 640 655
37. S. Macdonald, and J. Kam Quality journals and gamesmanship in management studies Journal of Information Science 33 2007 702 717
38. C.L. Maranto, and A.E.C. Griffin The antecedents of a 'chilly climate' for women faculty in higher education Human Relations 64 2011 139 159
39. A.L. Mayer, and P.M. Tikka Family-friendly policies and gender bias in academia Journal of Higher Education Policy & Management 30 4 2008 363 374
40. J.M. McDowell, L.D. Singell, and M. Stater Two to tango? Gender differences in the decisions to publish and co-author Economic Inquiry 44 2005 153 168
41. B. McElhinny, M. Hols, J. Holtzkener, S. Unger, and C. Hicks Gender, publication and citation in sociolinguistics and linguistic anthropology: the construction of a scholarly canon Language in Society 32 2003 299 328
42. C.C. Miller, W.H. Glick, and L.B. Cardinal The allocation of prestigious positions in organizational science: accumulative advantage, sponsored mobility and contest mobility Journal of Organizational Behaviour 26 5 2005 489 516
43. D.L. Millimet The impact of children on wages, job tenure, and the division of household labour Economic Journal 110 2000 139 157
44. H.F. Moed Citation Analysis in Research Evaluations 2005 Springer Dordrecht, The Netherlands
45. H.F. Moed The future of research evaluation rests with an intelligent combination of advanced metrics and transparent peer review Science and Public Policy 34 8 2007 575 583
46. H. Morris, C. Harvey, and A. Kelly Journal rankings and the ABS journal quality guide Management Decision 47 2009 1441 1451
47. H. Morris, C. Harvey, A. Kelly, and M. Rowlinson Food for thought? A rejoinder on peer-review and RAE2008 evidence Accounting Education 20 2011 561 573
48. P. Nightingale, and A. Scott Peer review and the relevance gap: ten suggestions for policy-makers Science and Public Policy 34 2007 543 553
49. D. Northcott, and S. Linacre Producing spaces for academic discourse: the impact of research assessment exercises and journal quality rankings Australian Accounting Review 20 1 2010 38 54
50. A.J. Oswald An examination of the reliability of prestigious scholarly journals: evidence and implications for decision-makers Economica 74 2007 21 31
51. M. Pezzoni, V. Sterzi, and F. Lissoni Career progress in centralized academic systems: social capital and institutions in France and Italy Research Policy 41 2012 704 719
52. N. Piercy Why it is fundamentally stupid for a business school to try to improve its research assessment score European Journal of Marketing 34 2000 27 36
53. B. Probert 'I just couldn't fit it in': gender and unequal outcomes in academic careers Gender, Work & Organization 12 2005 50 72
54. I. Rafols, L. Leydesdorff, A. O'Hare, P. Nightingale, and A. Stirling How journal rankings can suppress interdisciplinary research: a comparison between innovation studies and business & management Research Policy 41 2012 1262 1282
55. D. Rama, K. Raghunandan, L.B. Logan, and B.V. Barkman Gender differences in publications by promoted faculty Issues in Accounting Education 12 2 1997 353 365
56. A. Reinstein, and T.G. Calderon Examining accounting department's rankings of the quality of accounting journals Critical Perspectives on Accounting 17 2006 457 490
57. R. Sealy, and V. Singh The importance of role models and demographic context for senior women's work identity development International Journal of Management Reviews 12 2010 284 300
58. M. Simonsen, and L. Skipper An empirical assessment of effects of parenthood on wages Advances in Econometrics 21 2008 359 380
59. J. Stewart The UK Research Assessment Exercise Human Resource Development International 8 2005 489 494
60. J.A. Taylor The assessment of research quality in UK universities: peer review or metrics? British Journal of Management 22 2011 202 217
61. J. Taylor How Biased Were the Peer Review Panels in the UK's 2008 Research Assessment Exercise? Mimeo Department of Economics 2011 Lancaster University
62. Times Higher Education Unequal Opportunities in Final RAE.17September 2009 2009 (downloaded on 26 July 2013 from http://www.timeshighereducation.co. uk/story.asp?storycode=408202)
63. M. Van Den Brink, M. Brouns, and S. Waslander Does excellence have a gender? Employee Relations 28 6 2006 523 539
64. C. Voss Reflections on the state of OM POMS Chronicle 17 1 2010 11 12
65. J. Waldfogel Understanding the "family gap" in pay for women with children Journal of Economic Perspectives 12 1998 137 156
66. J. Waldfogel The family gap for young women in the United States and Britain: can maternity leave make a difference? Journal of Labor Economics 16 1998 505 545
67. J.T. Walker, A. Vignoles, and M. Collins Higher education academic salaries in the UK Oxford Economic Papers 62 2010 12 35
68. K.B. Ward, J. Gast, and L. Grant Visibility and dissemination of women's and men's sociological scholarship Social Problems 39 1992 291 298
69. M. Ward Gender and promotion in the academic profession Scottish Journal of Political Economy 48 2001 283 302
70. M. Ward The gender salary gap in British academia Applied Economics 33 2001 1669 1681
71. N.H. Wolfinger, M.A. Mason, and M. Goulden Stay in the game: gender, family formation and alternative trajectories in the academic life course Social Forces 87 3 2009 1591 1621