Use of coercive measures in mental health practice and its impact on outcome: A critical review

Expert Review of Neurotherapeutics

Volumn 14, Issue 2, 2014, Pages 131-141

  Luciano, Mario ^a   Sampogna, Gaia ^a   Del Vecchio, Valeria ^a   Pingani, Luca ^b,c   Palumbo, Claudia ^d   De Rosa, Corrado ^a   Catapano, Francesco ^a   Fiorillo, Andrea ^a  

^a SECOND UNIVERSITY OF NAPLES   (Italy)

^b UNIVERSITY OF MODENA AND REGGIO EMILIA   (Italy)

^c PATHOLOGY UNIT   (Italy)

^d UNIVERSITY OF BARI   (Italy)

Author keywords

coercion in psychiatry; coercive measures; outcome; perceived coercion; predictors; therapeutic relation

Indexed keywords

CLINICAL PRACTICE; DEMOGRAPHY; DOCTOR PATIENT RELATION; GLOBAL ASSESSMENT OF FUNCTIONING; HUMAN; MENTAL DISEASE; MENTAL HEALTH CARE; MENTAL HEALTH CARE PERSONNEL; MENTAL HEALTH RESEARCH; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PATIENT SATISFACTION; PSYCHIATRIC DEPARTMENT; PSYCHOSIS; REVIEW; SUBSTANCE ABUSE;

COERCION; HUMANS; MENTAL DISORDERS; MENTAL HEALTH; PATIENT OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PSYCHIATRIC STATUS RATING SCALES;

EID: 84893144170     PISSN: 14737175     EISSN: 17448360     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1586/14737175.2014.874286     Document Type: Review

References (80)

1. Sjostrand M, Helgesson G. Coercive treatment and autonomy in psychiatry. Bioethics 2008;22(2):113-20
2. Salize HJ, Dressing H. Epidemiology of involuntary placement of mentally ill people across the European Union. Br J Psychiatr 2004;182:163-8
3. Kallert T, Rymaszewska J, Torres-Gonzales F. The clinical point of view: Comparing differences of legal regulations related to involuntary admissions and hospital stay in twelve European countries. In: Kallert T, Torres-Gonzales F, editors. Legislation on coercive mental health care in Europe. Peter Lang, Frankfurt am Maine; Germany: 2006. p. 375-400
4. Bergk J, Einsiedler B, Flammer E, Steinert T. A randomized controlled comparison of seclusion and mechanical restraint in inpatient settings. Psychiatr Serv 2011;62(11):1310-17 perceptions of restriction of their human right is provided
5. Fiorillo A, De Rosa C, Del Vecchio V, et al. How to improve clinical practice on involuntary hospital admissions of psychiatric patients: Suggestions from the EUNOMIA study. Eur Psychiatry 2011; 26(4):201-7
6. Curie CG. SAMHSA's commitment to eliminating the use of seclusion and restraint. Psychiatr Serv 2005;56(9): 1139-40
7. Huckshorn KA. Re-designing state mental health policy to prevent the use of seclusion and restraint. Adm Policy Ment Health 2006;33(4):482-91
8. Marder SR. A review of agitation in mental illness: Treatment guidelines and current therapies. J Clin Psychiatry 2006;67(10s): 13-21
9. Council of Europe steering committee on bioethics working party. White paper on the protection of Human Rights and Dignity of People Suffering from mental disorder, especially those placed as involuntary patients in psychiatric establishments. Strasbourg, 2000. Available from: Https:// wcd.coe.int 10. WHO Resource book on mental health, human rights and legislation: Stop exclusion, dare to care. WHO, Geneva; 2005. Available from: Who.Int/mental-health/ policy/resource-book-MHLeg.pdf 11. American Psychiatric Association, work Group on Schizophrenia, 2nd edition, 2004. Available from: Www. psychiatryonline.com/ content.aspx? aid=109116
10. Fiorillo A, Giacco D, De Rosa C, et al. Patient characteristics and symptoms associated with perceived coercion during hospital treatment. Acta Psychiatr Scand 2012;125(6):460-7
11. Gudjonsson GH, Rabe-Hesket S, Szmukler G. Management of psychiatric in-patient violence: Patient ethnicity and use of medication, restraint and seclusion. Br J Psychiatry 2004;184:258-62
12. Ryan CJ, Bowers L. An analysis of nurses' post-incident manual restraint reports. J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs 2006;13(5): 527-32
13. Southcott J, Howard A, Collins E. Control and restraint training in acute mental health care. Nurs Stand 2002;16(27):33-6
14. Sheehan KA, Burns T. Perceived coercion and the therapeutic relationship: A neglected association? Psychiatr Serv 2011;62(5):471-6
15. Kontio R, Joffe G, Putkonen H, et al. Seclusion and restraint in psychiatry: Patients' experiences and practical suggestions on how to improve practices and use alternatives. Perspect Psychiatr Care 2012;48(1):16-24
16. O'Donoghue B, Lyne J, Hill M, et al. Physical coercion, perceived pressures and procedural justice in the involuntary admission and future engagement with mental health services. Eur Psychiatry 2011; 26(4):208-14
17. Scanlan JN. Interventions to reduce the use of seclusion and restraint in inpatient psychiatric settings: What we know so far a review of the literature. Int J Soc Psychiatry 2010;56(4):412-23
18. Stubbs B, Leadbetter D, Paterson B, et al. Physical intervention: A review of the literature on its use, staff and patient views, and the impact of training. J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs 2009;16(1):99-105
19. Galon PA, Wineman NM. Coercion and procedural justice in psychiatric care: State of the science and implications for nursing. Arch Psychiatr Nurs 2010;24(5):307-16
20. Kisely SR, Campbell LA, Preston NJ. Compulsory community and involuntary outpatient treatment for people with severe mental disorders. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2011;16(2):CD004408
21. Zinkler M, Priebe S. Detention of the mentally ill in Europe - A review. Acta Psychiatr Scand 2002;106(1):3-8
22. Taylor K, Mammen K, Barnett S, et al. Characteristics of patients with histories of multiple seclusion and restraint events during a single psychiatric hospitalization. J Am Psychiatr Nurses Assoc 2012;18(3): 159-65
23. Dumais A, Larue C, Drapeau A, et al. Prevalence and correlates of seclusion with or without restraint in a Canadian psychiatric hospital: A 2-year retrospective audit. J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs 2011; 18(5):394-402
24. Knutzen M, Mjosund NH, Eidhammer G, et al. Characteristics of psychiatric inpatients who experienced restraint and those who did not: A case-control study. Psychiatr Serv 2011;62(5):492-7
25. Lay B, Nordt C, Rossler W. Variation in use of coercive measures in psychiatric hospitals. Eur Psychiatry 2011;26(4):244-51
26. Hendryx M, Trusevich Y, Coyle F, et al. The distribution and frequency of seclusion and/or restraint among psychiatric inpatients. J Behav Health Serv Res 2010;37(2):272-81
27. Migon MN, Coutinho ES, Huf G, et al. Factors associated with the use of physical restraints for agitated patients in psychiatric emergency rooms. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 2008;30(3):263-8
28. Hunt GE, O'Hara-Aarons M, O'Connor N, Cleary M. Why are some patients admitted to psychiatric hospital while others are not? A study assessing risk during the admission interview and relationship to outcome. Int J Mental Health Nursing 2012;21(2):145-53
29. Husum TL, Bjørngaard JH, Finset A, Ruud T. A cross-sectional prospective study of seclusion, restraint and involuntary medication in acute psychiatric wards: Patient, staff and ward characteristics. BMC Health Serv Res 2010;6(10):89
30. Raboch J, Kalisová L, Nawka A, et al. Use of coercive measures during involuntary hospitalization: Findings from ten European countries. Psychiatr Serv 2010;61(10): 1012-17
31. Hustoft K, Larsen TK, Auestad B, et al. Predictors of involuntary hospitalizations to acute psychiatry. Int J Law Psychiatry 2013; 36(2):136-43
32. Lawlor C, Johnson S, Cole L, Howard LM. Ethnic variations in pathways to acute care and compulsory detention for women experiencing a mental health crisis. Int J Soc Psychiatry 2010;58(1):3-15
33. Tarsitani L, Pasquini M, Maraone A, et al. Acute psychiatric treatment and the use of physical restraint in first-generation immigrants in Italy: A prospective concurrent study. Int J Soc Psychiatry 2013;59(6):613-18
34. Priebe S, Katsakou C, Amos T, et al. Patients' views and readmissions 1 year after involuntary hospitalization. Br J Psychiatry 2009;194(1):49-54
35. Norredam M, Garcia-Lopez A, Keiding N, Krasnik A. Excess use of coercive measures in psychiatry among migrants compared with native Danes. Acta Psychiatr Scand 2010;121(2):143-51
36. Steinert T, Bergbauer G, Schmid P, Gebhardt RP. Seclusion and restraint in patients with schizophrenia: Clinical and biographical correlates. J Nerv Ment Dis 2007;195(6):492-6
37. De Benedictis L, Dumais A, Sieu N, et al. Staff perceptions and organizational factors as predictors of seclusion and restraint on psychiatric wards. Psychiatr Serv 2011; 62(5):484-91
38. Bowers L, Van Der Merwe M, Paterson B, Stewart D. Manual restraint and shows of force: The City-128 study. Int J Ment Health Nurs 2012;21(1):30-40
39. Huf G, Coutinho ES, Adams CE. TREC-SAVE Collaborative Group. Physical restraints versus seclusion room for management of people with acute aggression or agitation due to psychotic illness (TRECSAVE): A randomized trial. Psychol Med 2012;42(11):2265-73
40. Kjellin L, Wallsten T. Accumulated coercion and short-Term outcome of inpatient psychiatric care. BMC Psychiatry 2010;28(10):53
41. Opjordsmoen S, Friis S, Melle I, et al. A 2-year follow-up of involuntary admissions influence upon adherence and outcome in first-episode psychosis. Acta Psychiatr Scand 2010;121(5):371-6
42. Seo MK, Kim SH, Rhee M. The impact of coercion on treatment outcome: One-year follow-up survey. Int J Psychiatry Med 2013;45(3):279-98
43. Georgieva I, Mulder CL, Whittington R. Evaluation of behavioral changes and subjective distress after exposure to coercive inpatient interventions. BMC Psychiatry 2012;30(12):54
44. Kallert TW, Katsakou C, Adamowski T, et al. Coerced hospital admission and symptom change-A prospective observational multi-centre study. PLoS ONE 2011;6(11): E28191
45. Priebe S, Katsakou C, Yeeles K, et al. Predictors of clinical and social outcomes following involuntary hospital admission: A prospective observational study. Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 2011;261(5):377-86
46. Strauss JL, Zervakis JB, Stechuchak KM, et al. Adverse impact of coercive treatments on psychiatric inpatients' satisfaction with care. Community Ment Health J 2013; 49(4):457-65
47. Theodoridou A, Schlatter F, Ajdacic V, et al. Therapeutic relationship in the context of perceived coercion in a psychiatric population. Psychiatry Res 2012;200(2-3):939-44
48. Iversen KI, Høyer G, Sexton HC. Coercion and patient satisfaction on psychiatric acute wards. Int J Law Psychiatry 2007;30(6):504-11
49. Jaeger S, Pfiffner C, Weiser P, et al. Long-Term effects of involuntary hospitalization on medication adherence, treatment engagement and perception of coercion. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 2013;48(11):1787-96
50. Kallert TW, Glockner M, Onchev G, et al. The EUNOMIA project on coercion in psychiatry: Study design and preliminary data. World Psychiatry 2005;4:168-72
51. Priebe S, Katsakou C, Glockner M, et al. Patients' views of involuntary hospital admission after 1 and 3 months: Prospective study in 11 European countries. Br J Psychiatry 2010;196(3):179-85
52. Raboch J, Kalisová L, Nawka A, et al. Use of coercive measures during involuntary hospitalization: Findings from ten European countries. Psychiatr Serv 2010;61(10): 1012-107
53. Petkari E, Salazar-Montes AM, Kallert TW, et al. Acute psychopathology as a predictor of global functioning in patients with ICD-10 non-Affective psychosis: A prospective study in 11 European countries. Schizophr Res 2011;131(1-3): 105-11
54. Giacco D, Fiorillo A, Del Vecchio V, et al. Caregivers' appraisals of patients' involuntary hospital treatment: European multicentre study. Br J Psychiatry 2011; 201(6):486-91
55. Bowers L, Jeffery D, Nijman H, et al. Junior staffing changes and the temporal ecology of adverse incidents in acute psychiatry: The Tompkins Acute Ward Study. J Adv Nurs 2007;57(2):153-60
56. De Rosa C, Luciano M, Del Vecchio V, et al. Urban insecurity and fear of crime in patients with mental disorders: Preliminary results of a multicenter Italian study. Riv Psichiatr 2013;48(4):321-7
57. Carra G, Johnson S, Bebbington P, et al. The lifetime and past-year prevalence of dual diagnosis in people with schizophrenia across Europe: Findings from the European Schizophrenia Cohort (EuroSC). Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 2012;262(7): 607-16
58. Carra G, Johnson S. Variations in rates of comorbid substance use in psychosis between mental health settings and geographical areas in the UK. A systematic review. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 2009;44(6):429-47
59. Jaeger S, Pfiffner C, Weiser P, et al. Long-Term effects of involuntary hospitalization on medication adherence, treatment engagement and perception of coercion. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 2013;48(11):1787-96
60. Ambrosini DL, Crocker AG. Psychiatric advance directives and the right to refuse treatment in Canada. Can J Psychiatry 2007;52(6):397-402
61. Sackeim HA, Haskett RF, Mulsant BH, et al. Continuation of pharmacotherapy in the prevention of relapse following electroconvulsive therapy: A randomized controlled trial. JAMA 2001;285(10): 1299-307
62. Mental Health Act, R.S.O. 1990, chapter M.7. Government of Ontario, Canada; 1990. s. 49
63. Maître E, Debien C, Nicaise P, et al. Advanced directives in psychiatry: A review of the qualitative literature, a state-of-The-Art and viewpoints. Encephale 2013;39(4): 244-51
64. Sailas E, Fenton M. Seclusion and restraint for people with serious mental illnesses. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2000;(1): CD001163
65. Martin V, Kuster W, Baur M, et al. Incidence of coercive measures as an indicator of quality in psychiatric hospitals. Problems of data recording and processing, preliminary results of a benchmarking study. Psychiatr Prax 2007;34:26-33
66. Janssen WA, Van De Sande R, Noorthoorn EO, et al. Methodological issues in monitoring the use of coercive measures. Int J Law Psychiatry 2011;34(6): 429-38
67. Lepping P, Steinert T, Needham I, et al. Ward safety perceived by ward managers in Britain, Germany and Switzerland: Identifying factors that improve ability to deal with violence. J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs 2009;16:629-35
68. Steinert T, Lepping P, Bernhardsgrutter R, et al. Incidence of seclusion and restraint in psychiatric hospitals: A literature review and survey of international trends. Soc Psychiatr Epidemiol 2010;45:889-97
69. Jacobsen TB. Involuntary treatment in Europe: Different countries, different practice. Curr Opin Psychiatry 2012;25(4): 307-10
70. Suryani LK, Jaya Lesmana CB, Tiliopoulos N. Treating the untreated: Applying a community-based, culturally sensitive psychiatric intervention to confined and physically restrained mentally ill individuals in Bali, Indonesia. Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 2011;261(2): S140-4
71. Gjerberg E, Helene Hem M, Førde R, Pedersen R. How to avoid and prevent coercion in nursing homes: A qualitative study. Nurs Ethics 2013;20(6):632-44
72. Hottinen A, Valimaki M, Sailas E, et al. Mechanical restraint in adolescent psychiatry: A Finnish Register study. Nord J Psychiatry 2013;67(2):132-9
73. Kaliski SZ, de Clercq HG. When coercion meets hope: Can forensic psychiatry adopt the recovery model. Afr J Psychiatry 2012; 15(3):162-6
74. Sheehan KA. Compulsory treatment in psychiatry. Curr Opin Psychiatry 2009; 22(6):582-6
75. Uher R, Rutter M. Classification of feeding and eating disorders: Review of evidence and proposals for ICD-11. World Psychiatry 2012;11(2):80-92
76. Wolfe S, Kay-Lambkin F, Bowman J, Childs S. To enforce or engage: The relationship between coercion, treatment motivation and therapeutic alliance within community-based drug and alcohol clients. Addict Behav 2013;38(5):2187-95
77. Maj M. Adherence to psychiatric treatments and the public image of psychiatry. World Psychiatry 2013;12(3):185-96
78. Kane JM, Kishimoto T, Korrell CU. Nonadherence to medication in patients with psychotic disorders: Epidemiology, contributing factors and management strategies. World Psychiatry 2013;12(9): 216-26
79. David AS. Managing non-Adherence and the 3 Cs: Collaboration, cash and coercion. World Psychiatry 2013;12(3):229-30
80. Fiorillo A, Luciano M, Del Vecchio V, et al. Priorities for mental health research in Europe: A survey among national stakeholders' associations within the ROAMER project. World Psychiatry 2013; 12(2):165-70