Comparative outcomes and cost-utility after surgical treatment of focal lumbar spinal stenosis compared with osteoarthritis of the hip or knee - Part 1: Long-term change in health-related quality of life

Spine Journal

Volumn 14, Issue 2, 2014, Pages 234-243

  Rampersaud, Y Raja ^a   Lewis, Stephen J ^a   Davey, J Roderick ^a   Gandhi, Rajiv ^a   Mahomed, Nizar N ^a  

^a TORONTO WESTERN HOSPITAL   (Canada)

Author keywords

Health related quality of life; Hip; Knee; Long term; Osteoarthritis; Spinal stenosis; Surgery

Indexed keywords

ADULT; AGED; ARTICLE; BODY MASS; COST UTILITY ANALYSIS; FEMALE; FOLLOW UP; HIP OSTEOARTHRITIS; HUMAN; KNEE OSTEOARTHRITIS; LUMBAR SPINAL STENOSIS; MAJOR CLINICAL STUDY; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; PRIORITY JOURNAL; QUALITY OF LIFE; SHORT FORM 36; SPINAL CORD DECOMPRESSION; SPONDYLOLISTHESIS; TOTAL HIP PROSTHESIS; TOTAL KNEE REPLACEMENT; VERY ELDERLY;

HEALTH-RELATED QUALITY OF LIFE; HIP; KNEE; LONG TERM; OSTEOARTHRITIS; SPINAL STENOSIS; SURGERY;

ADULT; AGED; AGED, 80 AND OVER; ARTHROPLASTY, REPLACEMENT, HIP; ARTHROPLASTY, REPLACEMENT, KNEE; COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS; FEMALE; FOLLOW-UP STUDIES; HUMANS; LUMBAR VERTEBRAE; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; ORTHOPEDIC PROCEDURES; OSTEOARTHRITIS; QUALITY OF LIFE; REOPERATION; RETROSPECTIVE STUDIES; SPINAL STENOSIS; SPONDYLOLISTHESIS; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 84892749416     PISSN: 15299430     EISSN: 18781632     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.spinee.2013.12.010     Document Type: Article

References (79)

1. T. Vos, A.D. Flaxman, and M. Naghavi et al. Years lived with disability (YLDs) for 1160 sequelae of 289 diseases and injuries 1990-2010: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2010 Lancet 380 2013 2163 2196
2. D.L. Reynolds, L.W. Chambers, and E.M. Badley et al. Physical disability among Canadians reporting musculoskeletal diseases J Rheumatol 19 1992 1020 1030
3. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. Healthcare cost and utilization project, HCUPnet. Available at: http://www.ahrg.gov/data/hcup/index. html. Accessed January 26, 2013.
4. R.A. Deyo, S.K. Mirza, and B.I. Martin et al. Trends, major medical complications, and charges associated with surgery for lumbar spinal stenosis in older adults JAMA 303 2010 1259 1265
5. R.A. Deyo, D.T. Gray, and W. Kreuter et al. United States trends in lumbar fusion surgery for degenerative conditions Spine 30 2005 1441 1445 discussion 1446-7
6. S. Kurtz, F. Mowat, and K. Ong et al. Prevalence of primary and revision total hip and knee arthroplasty in the United States from 1990 through 2002 J Bone Joint Surg Am 87 2005 1487 1497
7. N.B. Jain, L.D. Higgins, and D. Ozumba et al. Trends in epidemiology of knee arthroplasty in the United States, 1990-2000 Arthritis Rheum 52 2005 3928 3933
8. C. Mehrotra, P.L. Remington, and T.S. Naimi et al. Trends in total knee replacement surgeries and implications for public health, 1990-2000 Public Health Rep 120 2005 278 282
9. J.A. Buckwalter, J.D. Heckman, D.P. Petrie AOA An AOA critical issue: aging of the North American population: new challenges for orthopaedics J Bone Joint Surg Am 85-A 2003 748 758
10. O. Ethgen, O. Bruyere, and F. Richy et al. Health-related quality of life in total hip and total knee arthroplasty. A qualitative and systematic review of the literature J Bone Joint Surg Am 86-A 2004 963 974
11. H. Malchau, G. Garellick, and T. Eisler et al. Presidential guest address: the Swedish Hip Registry: increasing the sensitivity by patient outcome data Clin Orthop Relat Res 441 2005 19 29
12. H. Malchau, P. Herberts, and T. Eisler et al. The Swedish total hip replacement register J Bone Joint Surg Am 84-A 2 Suppl 2002 2 20
13. A. Laupacis, R. Bourne, and C. Rorabeck Costs of elective total hip arthroplasty during the first year J Arthroplasty 9 1994 315 321
14. C.J. Lavernia, J.F. Guzman, and A. Gachupin-Garcia Cost effectiveness and quality of life in knee arthroplasty Clin Orthop Relat Res 345 1997 134 139
15. R.W. Chang, J.M. Pellisier, and G.B. Hazen A cost-effectiveness analysis of total hip arthroplasty for osteoarthritis of the hip J Am Med Assoc 275 1996 858 865
16. M.J. Dobrow, V. Goel, and R.E.G. Uphsur Evidence-based health policy: context and utilisation Soc Sci Med 58 2004 207 217
17. J.A. Cowan Jr., J.B. Dimick, and R. Wainess et al. Changes in the utilization of spinal fusion in the United States Neurosurgery 59 2006 15 20
18. J.N. Weinstein, J.D. Lurie, and P.R. Olson et al. United States' trends and regional variations in lumbar spine surgery: 1992-2003 Spine 31 2006 2707 2714
19. D. Shipton, E.M. Badley, and N.N. Mahomed Critical shortage of orthopaedic services in Ontario, Canada J Bone Joint Surg Am 85-A 2003 1710 1715
20. C. Lavernia, D.J. Lee, and V.H. Hernandez The increasing financial burden of knee revision surgery in the United States Clin Orthop Relat Res 446 2006 221 226
21. P. Rasanen, J. Ohman, and H. Sintonen et al. Cost-utility analysis of routine neurosurgical spinal surgery J Neurosurg Spine 5 2006 204 209
22. O. Rivero-Arias, H. Campbell, and A. Gray et al. Surgical stabilisation of the spine compared with a programme of intensive rehabilitation for the management of patients with chronic low back pain: cost utility analysis based on a randomised controlled trial Br Med J 330 2005 1239 1245
23. P.J. Neumann, A.B. Rosen, and M.C. Weinstein Medicare and cost-effectiveness analysis N Engl J Med 353 2005 1516 1522
24. Canadian Orthopaedic Foundation. First Ministers' Health Accord 2004. Position Statement on First Ministers' Health Accord 2004-March 2005. Available at: http://www.canorth.org/en/docs/PositionsonPublicPolicy-HealthAccord2004.pdf. Accessed November 15, 2009.
25. A.N.A. Tosteson, T.D. Tosteson, and J.D. Lurie et al. Comparative effectiveness evidence for spinal stenosis, degenerative spondylolisthesis, and intervertebral disc herniation Spine 36 2011 2061 2068
26. J.N. Weinstein, T.D. Tosteson, and J.D. Lurie et al. Surgical versus nonoperative treatment for lumbar spinal stenosis: four-year results of the Spine Patient Outcomes Research Trial Spine 35 2010 1329 1338
27. J.N. Weinstein, J.D. Lurie, and T.D. Tosteson et al. Surgical compared with nonoperative treatment for lumbar degenerative spondylolisthesis: four-year results in the Spine Patient Outcomes Research Trial (SPORT) randomized and observational cohorts J Bone Joint Surg Am 91 2009 1295 1304
28. J.N. Katz Cost-effectiveness of spine surgery: the jury is out Ann Intern Med 149 2008 901 903
29. J.N. Gibson, and G. Waddell Surgery for degenerative lumbar spondylosis: updated Cochrane Review Spine 30 2005 2312 2320
30. S.M. Mardjetko, P.J. Connolly, and S. Shott Degenerative lumbar spondylolisthesis: a meta-analysis of literature 1970-1993 Spine 19 20 Suppl 1994 2256 2265
31. J.A. Turner, M. Ersek, L. Herron, and R. Deyo Surgery for lumbar spinal stenosis: attempted meta-analysis of literature1970-93 Spine 17 1992 1 8
32. C.M. Bono, and C.K. Lee The influence of subdiagnosis on radiographic and clinical outcomes after lumbar fusion for degenerative disc disorders: an analysis of the literature from two decades Spine 30 2005 227 234
33. Y.R. Rampersaud, E.K. Wai, and C.G. Fisher et al. Postoperative improvement in health-related quality of life: a national comparison of surgical treatment for focal (one- to two-level) lumbar spinal stenosis compared with total joint arthroplasty for osteoarthritis Spine J 11 2011 1033 1041
34. S.A. Mokhtar, P.F. McCombe, and O.D. Williamson et al. Health-related quality of life: a comparison of outcomes after lumbar fusion for degenerative spondylolisthesis with large joint replacement surgery and population norms Spine J 10 2010 306 312
35. T. Hansson, E. Hansson, and H. Malchau Utility of spine surgery: a comparison of common elective orthopaedic surgical procedures Spine 33 2008 2819 2830
36. Y.R. Rampersaud, B. Ravi, and S.J. Lewis et al. Assessment of health-related quality of life after surgical treatment of focal symptomatic spinal stenosis compared with osteoarthritis of the hip or knee Spine J 8 2008 296 304
37. O. Juul, F.G. Sigmundsson, and O. Ovesen et al. No difference in health-related quality of life in hip osteoarthritis compared to degenerative lumbar instability at pre- and 1-year postoperatively: a prospective study of 101 patients Acta Orthop 77 2006 748 754
38. P. Tso, K. Walker, and N. Mahomed et al. Comparison of lifetime incremental cost:utility ratios of surgery relative to failed medical management for the treatment of hip, knee and spine osteoarthritis modelled using 2-year postsurgical values Can J Surg 55 2012 181 190
39. F. Salaffi, M. Carotti, A. Stancati, and W. Grassi Health-related quality of life in older adults with symptomatic hip and knee osteoarthritis: a comparison with matched healthy controls Aging Clin Exp Res 17 2005 255 263
40. R.G. Marx, E.C. Jones, and N.C. Atwan et al. Measuring improvement following total hip and knee arthroplasty using patient-based measures of outcome J Bone Joint Surg Am 87 2005 1999 2005
41. T.L. Walsh, B. Hanscom, J.D. Lurie, and J.N. Weinstein Is a condition-specific instrument for patients with low back pain/leg symptoms really necessary? The responsiveness of the Oswestry Disability Index, MODEMS, and the SF-36 Spine 28 2003 607 615
42. Statistics Canada Population projections: Canada, the provinces and territories 2010 The Daily Available at: www.statcan.gc.ca Accessed December 22, 2010
43. US Census Bureau. An older and more diverse nation by midcentury. Available at: www.census.gov/newsroom/releases/archives/population/cb08-123. html. Accessed December 22, 2010.
44. G. Lafortune, and G. Balestat Trends in severe disability among elderly people: assessing the evidence in 12 OECD countries and the future implications OECD Health Working Papers, No. 26 2007 OECD Publishing
45. A.V. Perruccio, J.D. Power, and E.M. Badley Revisiting arthritis prevalence projections - it's more than just the aging of the population J Rheumatol 33 2006 1856 1862
46. J. Braybrooke, H. Ahn, and A. Gallant et al. The impact of surgical wait-time on patient-based outcomes in posterior lumbar spinal surgery Eur Spine J 16 2007 1832 1839
47. B. Barua, M. Rovere, and B.J. Skinner Waiting your turn-wait-times for health care in Canada 2010 Studies in Health Care Policy-Fraser Institute
48. A.B. Aiken, M.M. Harrison, and M. Atkinson et al. Easing the burden for joint replacement wait-times: the role of the expanded practice physiotherapist Healthc Q 11 2008 62 66
49. J.L. Mahon, R.B. Bourne, and C.H. Rorabeck et al. Health-related quality of life and mobility of patients awaiting elective total hip arthroplasty: a prospective study CMAJ 167 2002 1115 1121
50. Health Canada. First Ministers' Accord on Health Care Renewal. Available at: http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/hcs-sss/delivery-prestation/fptcollab/2003accord/ index-eng.php. Accessed September 28, 2011.
51. Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-term Care. Provincial wait time trends. Available at: www.waittimes.net/SurgeryDI/EN/wt-trend.aspx?view=1. Accessed September 28, 2012.
52. M.E. Porter What is value in health care? N Engl J Med 363 2010 2477 2481
53. S. Genevay, and S.J. Atlas Lumbar spinal stenosis [review] Best Pract Res Clin Rheumatol 24 2010 253 265
54. M.C. Battié, C.A. Jones, D.P. Schopflocher, and R.W. Hu Health-related quality of life and comorbidities associated with lumbar spinal stenosis Spine J 12 2012 189 195
55. A. Malmivaara, P. Slatis, and M. Heliovaara et al. Surgical or nonoperative treatment for lumbar spinal stenosis Spine 32 2007 1 8
56. T. Amundsen, H. Weber, and H.J. Nordal et al. Lumbar spinal stenosis: conservative or surgical management? A prospective 10-year study Spine 25 2000 1424 1435 discussion 1435-6
57. S.K. Mirza, and R.A. Deyo Systematic review of randomized trials comparing lumbar fusion surgery to nonoperative care for treatment of chronic back pain Spine 32 2007 816 823
58. R. Chou, J. Baisden, and E.J. Carragee et al. Surgery for low back pain: a review of the evidence for an American Pain Society Clinical Practice Guideline Spine 34 2009 1094 1109
59. T. Iguchi, A. Kurihara, and J. Nakayama et al. Minimum 10-year outcome of decompressive laminectomy for degenerative lumbar spinal stenosis Spine 25 2000 1754 1759
60. M.F. Oertel, Y.M. Ryang, and M.C. Korinth et al. Long-term results of microsurgical treatment of lumbar spinal stenosis by unilateral laminotomy for bilateral decompression Neurosurgery 59 2006 1264 1269 discussion 1269-70
61. K. Yamashita, K. Ohzono, and K. Hiroshima Five-year outcomes of surgical treatment for degenerative lumbar spinal stenosis: a prospective observational study of symptom severity at standard intervals after surgery Spine 31 2006 1484 1490
62. B. Jönsson, M. Annertz, C. Sjöberg, and B. Strömqvist A prospective and consecutive study of surgically treated lumbar spinal stenosis. Part II: five-year follow-up by an independent observer Spine 22 1997 2938 2944
63. S.J. Atlas, R.B. Keller, and Y.A. Wu et al. Long-term outcomes of surgical and nonsurgical management of lumbar spinal stenosis: 8 to 10 year results from the maine lumbar spine study Spine 30 2005 936 943
64. M. Cornefjord, G. Byröd, H. Brisby, and B. Rydevik A long-term (4- to 12-year) follow-up study of surgical treatment of lumbar spinal stenosis Eur Spine J 9 2000 563 570
65. H. Cavuşoǧlu, R.A. Kaya, and O.N. Türkmenoglu et al. Midterm outcome after unilateral approach for bilateral decompression of lumbar spinal stenosis: 5-year prospective study Eur Spine J 16 2007 2133 2142
66. H.T. Hee, and H.K. Wong The long-term results of surgical treatment for spinal stenosis in the elderly Singapore Med J 44 2003 175 180
67. P. Slätis, A. Malmivaara, and M. Heliövaara et al. Long-term results of surgery for lumbar spinal stenosis: a randomised controlled trial Eur Spine J 20 2011 1174 1181
68. K. Nakanishi, N. Tanaka, and Y. Fujimoto et al. Medium-term clinical results of microsurgical lumbar flavectomy that preserves facet joints in cases of lumbar degenerative spondylolisthesis: comparison of bilateral laminotomy with bilateral decompression by a unilateral approach J Spinal Disord Tech 26 2013 351 358
69. B.I. Martin, S.K. Mirza, and B.A. Comstock et al. Reoperation rates following lumbar spine surgery and the influence of spinal fusion procedures Spine 32 2007 382 387
70. O. Bruyère, O. Ethgen, and A. Neuprez et al. Health-related quality of life after total knee or hip replacement for osteoarthritis: a 7-year prospective study Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 132 2012 1583 1587
71. A.K. Nilsdotter, and F. Isaksson Patient relevant outcome 7 years after total hip replacement for OA - a prospective study BMC Musculoskelet Disord 11 2010 47
72. M. Núñez, L. Lozano, and E. Núñez et al. Total knee replacement and health-related quality of life: factors influencing long-term outcomes Arthritis Rheum 61 2009 1062 1069
73. A.C. Rat, F. Guillemin, and G. Osnowycz et al. Total hip or knee replacement for osteoarthritis: mid- and long-term quality of life Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken) 62 2010 54 62
74. J. Cushnaghan, D. Coggon, and I. Reading et al. Long-term outcome following total hip arthroplasty: a controlled longitudinal study Arthritis Rheum 57 2007 1375 1380
75. J. Cushnaghan, J. Bennett, and I. Reading et al. Long-term outcome following total knee arthroplasty: a controlled longitudinal study Ann Rheum Dis 68 2009 642 647
76. K.L. Corbett, E. Losina, and A.A. Nti et al. Population-based rates of revision of primary total hip arthroplasty: a systematic review PLoS One 5 2010 e13520
77. R. Gandhi, D. Tsvetkov, J.R. Davey, and N.N. Mahomed Survival and clinical function of cemented and uncemented prostheses in total knee replacement: a meta-analysis J Bone Joint Surg Br 91 2009 889 895
78. L. Busija, R.H. Osborne, and A. Nilsdotter et al. Magnitude and meaningfulness of change in SF-36 scores in four types of orthopedic surgery Health Qual Life Outcomes 6 2008 55
79. J. Slover, W.A. Abdu, B. Hanscom, and J.N. Weinstein The impact of comorbidities on the change in short-form 36 and oswestry scores following lumbar spine surgery Spine 31 2006 1974 1980