Recommendations following a multi-laboratory comparison of microbial source tracking methods

Water Research

Volumn 47, Issue 18, 2013, Pages 6829-6838

  Stewart, Jill R ^a   Boehm, Alexandria B ^b   Dubinsky, Eric A ^c   Fong, Theng Theng ^d   Goodwin, Kelly D ^e,k   Griffith, John F ^f   Noble, Rachel T ^a,g   Shanks, Orin C ^h   Vijayavel, Kannappan ^i,j   Weisberg, Stephen B ^f  

^a IL   (United States)

^b Stanford University   (United States)

^c LAWRENCE BERKELEY NATIONAL LABORATORY   (United States)

^d TETRA TECH INC   (United States)

^e NOAA EARTH SYSTEM RESEARCH LABORATORY   (United States)

^f SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA COASTAL WATER RESEARCH PROJECT   (United States)

^g University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill   (United States)

^h U S ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY   (United States)

ⁱ WAYNE STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^j Environmental Health Division   (United States)

^k Protected Resources Division   (United States)

more..

Author keywords

Bacteroidales; Coliform; Enterococcus; Microbial source tracking; QPCR; Water quality

Indexed keywords

DATA HANDLING; HEALTH RISKS; POLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION; RISK ASSESSMENT; WATER MANAGEMENT; WATER QUALITY;

BACTEROIDALES; COLIFORM; ENTEROCOCCUS; MICROBIAL SOURCE TRACKING; QPCR;

WATER POLLUTION;

MORPHINE SULFATE;

FECES; LABORATORY METHOD; MICROBIAL ACTIVITY; MICROBIAL COMMUNITY; POLLUTANT SOURCE; POLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION; PUBLIC HEALTH; RISK ASSESSMENT; WATER MANAGEMENT; WATER QUALITY;

ARTICLE; BIOREMEDIATION; BIRD; CONTROLLED STUDY; DATA PROCESSING; FALSE POSITIVE RESULT; FECES ANALYSIS; GEOGRAPHIC DISTRIBUTION; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; LABORATORY; LIMIT OF DETECTION; LIMIT OF QUANTITATION; MICROBIAL SOURCE TRACKING; NONHUMAN; PRIORITY JOURNAL; QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS; RISK ASSESSMENT; WASTE WATER MANAGEMENT; WATER CONTAMINATION; WATER QUALITY; WATER SAMPLING; WATER STANDARD; WATER SUPPLY;

CALIFORNIA; UNITED STATES;

AVES; BACTEROIDALES; ENTEROCOCCUS;

BACTEROIDALES; COLIFORM; ENTEROCOCCUS; MICROBIAL SOURCE TRACKING; QPCR; WATER QUALITY;

ANIMALS; BIRDS; CALIFORNIA; CATTLE; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; FECES; HUMANS; POLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; WATER MICROBIOLOGY; WATER POLLUTION;

EID: 84887168590     PISSN: 00431354     EISSN: 18792448     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.watres.2013.04.063     Document Type: Article

References (63)

1. AOAC, 2006. Final report and executive summaries from the AOAC international presidential task force on best practices in microbiological methodology, Report #223-01-2464.
2. Armbruster D.A., Pry T. Limit of blank, limit of detection and limit of quantitation. Clin. Biochem. Rev. 2008, 29(Suppl. 1):S49-S52.
3. Bae S., Wuertz S. Survival of host-associated bacteroidales cells and their relationship with Enterococcus spp., Campylobacter jejuni, Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium, and adenovirus in freshwater microcosms as measured by propidium monoazide-quantitative PCR. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2012, 78(4):922-932.
4. Baums I.B., Goodwin K.D., Kiesling T., Wanless D., Diaz M.R., Fell J.W. Luminex detection of fecal indicators in river samples, marine recreational water, and beach sand. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2007, 54(5):521-536.
5. Boehm A.B., Ashbolt N.J., Colford J.M., Dunbar L.E., Fleming L.E., Gold M.A., Hansel J.A., Hunter P.R., Ichida A.M., McGee C.D., Soller J.A., Weisberg S.B. A sea change ahead for recreational water quality criteria. J. Water Health 2009, 7(1):9-20.
6. Boehm A.B., Van De Werfhorst L.C., Griffith J.F., Holden P.A., Jay J.A., Shanks O.C., Wang D., Weisberg S.B. Performance of forty-one microbial source tracking methods: a twenty-seven lab evaluation study. Water Res 2013, 47(18):6812-6828.
7. Burd E.M. Validation of laboratory-developed molecular assays for infectious diseases. Clin. Microbiol. Rev. 2010, 23(3):550-576.
8. Burns M., Valdivia H. Modelling the limit of detection in real-time quantitative PCR. Eur. Food Res. Technol. 2008, 226:1513-1524.
9. Bustin S.A., Benes V., Garson J.A., Hellemans J., Huggett J., Kubista M., Mueller R., Nolan T., Pfaffl M.W., Shipley G.L., Vandesompele J., Wittwer C.T. The MIQE guidelines: minimum information for publication of quantitative real-time PCR experiments. Clin. Chem. 2009, 55(4):611-622.
10. Byappanahalli M.N., Yan T., Hamilton M.J., Ishii S., Fujioka R.S., Whitman R.L., Sadowsky M.J. The population structure of Escherichia coli isolated from subtropical and temperate soils. Sci. Total Environ. 2012, 417-418:273-279.
11. Cao Y., Van der Werfhorst L.C., Dubinsky E.A., Badgley B.D., Sadowsky M.J., Andersen G.L., Griffith J.F., Holden P.A. Evaluation of molecular community analysis methods for discerning fecal sources and human waste. Water Res 2013, 47(18):6862-6882.
12. California State Water Resources Control Board A resolution amending the water quality control plan for the San Diego Basin (9) to incorporate implementation provisions for indicator bacteria water quality objectives to account for loading from natural uncontrollable sources within the context of a total maximum daily load. Resolution no. R9-2008-0028 Available on-line:. http://waterboards.ca.gov/sandiego/board_decisions/adopted_orders/2008/R9-2008-0028.pdf.
13. CODEX, 2010. Guidelines on performance criteria and validation of methods for detection, identification and quantification of specific DNA sequences and specific proteins in foods, Codex Committee on Methods of Analysis and Sampling CAC/GL 74-2010, Rome.
14. Dickerson J.W., Hagedorn C., Hassall A. Detection and remediation of human-origin pollution at two public beaches in Virginia using multiple source tracking methods. Water Res. 2007, 41(16):3758-3770.
15. Ebentier D.L., Hanley K.T., Cao Y., Badgley B.D., Boehm A.B., Ervin J.S., Goodwin K.D., Gourmelon M., Griffith J.F., Holden P.A., Kelty C.A., Lozach S., McGee C., Peed L.A., Raith M., Ryu H., Sadowsky M.J., Scott E.A., Santo Domingo J., Schriewer A., Sinagalliano C.D., Shanks O.C., Van De Werfhorst L.C., Wang D., Wuertz S., Jay J.A. Evaluation of the repeatibility and reproducibility of a suite of qPCR-based microbial source tracking methods. Water Res 2013, 47(18):6839-6848.
16. Ervin J.S., Russell T.L., Layton B.A., Yamahara K.M., Wang D., Sassoubre L.M., Cao Y., Kelty C.A., Sivaganesan M., Boehm A.B., Holden P., Weisberg S.B., Shanks O.C. Characterization of fecal concentrations in human and other animal sources by physical, culture, and quantitative real-time PCR methods. Water Res 2013, 47(18):6873-6882.
17. Field K.G., Samadpour M. Fecal source tracking, the indicator paradigm, and managing water quality. Water Res. 2007, 41(16):3517-3538.
18. Gentry-Shields J., Rowny J.G., Stewart J.R. HuBac and nifH source tracking markers display a relationship to land use but not rainfall. Water Res. 2012, 46(18):6163-6174.
19. Gonzalez R.A., Conn K.E., Crosswell J.R., Noble R.T. Application of empirical predictive modeling using conventional and alternative fecal indicator bacteria in eastern North Carolina waters. Water Res. 2012, 46(18):5871-5882.
20. Green H., Shanks O.C., Sivaganesan M., Haugland R., Field K. Differential decay of human faecal Bacteroides in marine and freshwater. Environ. Microbiol. 2011, 13:3235-3249.
21. Griffith J.F., Weisberg S.B., McGee C. Evaluation of microbial source tracking methods using mixed fecal sources in aqueous test samples. J. Water Health 2003, 1(4):141-151.
22. Harrington P.R., Zeng W., Naeger L.K. Clinical relevance of detectable but not quantifiable hepatitis C virus RNA during boceprevir or telaprevir treatment. Hepatology 2012, 55(4):1048-1057.
23. Harwood, V., Gordon, K., Staley, C., 2011. Validation of Rapid Methods for Enumeration of Markers for Human Sewage Contamination in Recreational Waters. WERF Report PATH3C09, Alexandria, VA.
24. Harwood V.J., Boehm A.B., Sassoubre L.M., Kannappan V., Stewart J.R., Fong T.-T., Caprais M.-P., Converse R.R., Diston D., Ebdon J., Fuhrman J.A., Gourmelon M., Gentry-Shields J., Griffith J.F., Kashian D., Noble R.T., Taylor H., Wicki M. Performance of viruses and bacteriophages for fecal source determination in a multi-laboratory, comparative study. Water Res 2013, 47(18):6929-6943.
25. Haznedaroglu B.Z., Kim H.N., Bradford S.A., Walker S.L. Relative transport behavior of Escherichia coli O157:H7 and Salmonella enterica serovar pullorum in packed bed column systems: influence of solution chemistry and cell concentration. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 43(6):1838-1844.
26. Huggett J., Novak T., Garson J.A., Green C., Morris-Jones S.D., Miller R.F., Zumla A. Differential susceptibility of PCR reactions to inhibitors: an important and unrecognized phenomenon. BMC Res. Notes 2008, 1:70-79.
27. Imamura G.J., Thompson R.S., Boehm A.B., Jay J.A. Wrack promotes the persistence of fecal indicator bacteria in marine sands and seawater. FEMS Microbiol. Ecol. 2011, 77(1):40-49.
28. Jenkins M.W., Tiwari S., Lorente M., Gichaba C.M., Wuertz S. Identifying human and livestock sources of fecal contamination in Kenya with host-specific Bacteroidales assays. Water Res. 2009, 43(19):4956-4966.
29. Kildare B.J., Leutenegger C.M., McSwain B.S., Bambic D.G., Rajal V.B., Wuertz S. 16S rRNA-based assays for quantitative detection of universal, human-, cow-, and dog-specific fecal Bacteroidales: a Bayesian approach. Water Res. 2007, 41:3701-3715.
30. Laperche S., Bouchardeau F., Andre-Garnier E., Thibault V., Roque-Afonso A.M., Trimoulet P., Colimon R., Duverlie G., Leguillou-Guillemette H., Lunel F., Bouvier-Alias M., Pawlotsky J.M., Henquell C., Schvoerer E., Stoll-Keller F., Chaix M.L., Branger M., Gaudy-Graffin C., Rosenberg A.R., Pozzetto B., Vallet S., Baazia Y., Izopet J., Lefrere J.J. Interpretation of real-time PCR results for hepatitis C virus RNA when viral load is below quantification limits. J. Clin. Microbiol. 2011, 49(3):1113-1115.
31. Layton A., McKay L., Williams D., Garrett V., Gentry R., Sayler G. Development of Bacteroides 16S rRNA gene TaqMan-based real-time PCR assays for estimation of total, human, and bovine fecal Pollution in water. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2006, 72(6):4214-4224.
32. Layton, B., Cao, Y., Ebentier, D.L., Hanley, K.T., Ballesté, E., Brandão, J., Byappanahalli, M.N., Converse, R.R., Farnleitner, A.H., Gentry-Shields, J. Gidley, M.L., Gourmelon, M., Lee, C.S., Lee, J., Lozach, S., Madi, T., Meijer, W.G., Noble, R.T., Peed, L., Reischer, G.H., Rodrigues, R., Rose, J.B., Schriewer, A., Sinigalliano, C., Srinivasan, S., Stewart, J.R., Van De Werfhorst, L.C., Wang, D., Whitman, R., Wuertz, S., Jay, J., Holden, P.A., Boehm, A.B., Shanks, O.C., Griffith, J.F. Performance of human fecal anaerobe-associated PCR-based assays in a multi-laboratory method evaluation study. Water Res. 47(18), 6897-6908.
33. Manter D.K., Wier T.L., Vivanco J.M. Negative effects of sample pooling on PCR-based estimates of soil microbial richness and community structure. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2010, 76:2086-2090.
34. McQuaig S.M., Scott T.M., Harwood V.J., Farrah S.R., Lukasik J. Detection of human-derived fecal pollution in environmental waters by use of a PCR-based human polyomavirus assay. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2006, 72:7567-7574.
35. Mumy K.L., Findaly R.H. Convenient determination of DNA extraction efficiency using an external DNA recovery standard and quantitative-competitive PCR. J. Microbiol. Methods 2004, 57:259-268.
36. Okabe S., Okayama N., Savichtcheva O., Ito T. Quantification of host-specific Bacteroides-Prevotella 16S rRNA genetic markers for assessment of fecal pollution in freshwater. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 2007, 74:890-901.
37. Preston C.M., Marin R., Jensen S.D., Feldman J., Birch J.M., Massion E.I., Delong E.F., Suzuki M., Wheeler K., Scholin C.A. Near real-time, autonomous detection of marine bacterioplankton on a coastal mooring in Monterey Bay, California, using rRNA-targeted DNA probes. Environ. Microbiol. 2009, 11(5):1168-1180.
38. Raith M.R., Kelty C.A., Griffith J.F., Schriewer A., Wuertz S., Mieszkin S., Gourmelon M., Reischer G.H., Farnleitner A.H., Ervin J.S., Holden P.A., Ebentier D.L., Jay J.A., Wang D., Boehm A.B., Gim Aw T., Rose J.B., Balleste E., Meijer W.G., Sivaganesan M., Shanks O.C. Comparison of PCR and quantitative real-time PCR methods for the characterization of ruminant and cattle fecal pollution sources. Water Res 2013, 47(18):6921-6928.
39. Rogers S.W., Donnelly M., Peed L., Kelty C.A., Mondal S., Zhong Z., Shanks O.C. Decay of bacterial pathogens, fecal indicators, and real-time quantitative PCR genetic markers in manure-amended soils. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2011, 77:4839-4848.
40. Sauer E.P., Vandewalle J.L., Bootsma M.J., McLellan S.L. Detection of the human specific Bacteroides genetic marker provides evidence of widespread sewage contamination of stormwater in the urban environment. Water Res. 2011, 45(14):4081-4091.
41. Savichtcheva O., Okabe S. Alternative indicators of fecal pollution: relations with pathogens and conventional indicators, current methodologies for direct pathogen monitoring and future application perspectives. Water Res. 2006, 40(13):2463-2476.
42. Schinner T., Letzner A., Liedtke S., Castro F.D., Eydelnant I.A., Tufenkji N. Transport of selected bacterial pathogens in agricultural soil and quartz sand. Water Res. 2010, 44(4):1182-1192.
43. Schriewer A., Goodwin K.D., Sinigalliano C.D., Cox A.M., Wanless D., Bartkowiak J., Ebentier D.L., Hanley K.T., Ervin J., Deering L.A., Shanks O.C., Peed L.A., Mijer W.G., Griffith J.F., Santo Domingo J., Jay J.A., Holden P.A., Wuertz S. Performance evaluation of canine-associated Bacteroidales assays in a multi-laboratory comparison study. Water Res 2013, 47(18):6909-6920.
44. Schulz C.J., Childers G.W. Fecal Bacteroidales diversity and decay in response to variations in temperature and salinity. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2011, 77(8):2563-2571.
45. Shanks O.C., White K., Kelty C.A., Sivaganesan M., Blannon J., Meckes M., Varma M., Haugland R.A. Performance of PCR-based assays targeting Bacteroidales genetic markers of human fecal pollution in sewage and fecal samples. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2010, 44(16):6281-6288.
46. Shanks O.C., White K., Kelty C.A., Hayes S., Sivaganesan M., Jenkins M., Varma M., Haugland R.A. Performance assessment of cattle-associated PCR and quantitative real-time PCR assays targeting Bacteroidales Genes. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2010, 76(5):1359-1366.
47. Shanks O.C., Kelty C.A., Archibeque S.L., Jenkins M., Newton R.J., McLellan S.L., Huse S.M., Sogin M.L. Community structures of fecal bacteria in cattle from different animal feeding operations. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2011, 77(9):2992-3001.
48. Shanks O.C., Newton R.J., Kelty C.A., Huse S.M., Sogin M.L., McLellan S.L. Comparison of microbial community structure in untreated wastewater from different geographic locales. Appl. Environ. Microbiol 2013, 79(9):2906-2913.
49. Silkie S.S., Nelson K.L. Concentrations of host-specific and generic fecal markers measured by quantitative PCR in raw sewage and fresh animal feces. Water Res. 2009, 43:4860-4871.
50. Sinigalliano C.D., Ervin J., Van De Werfhorst L.C., Badgley B., Ballesté E., Bartkowiak J., Boehm A.B., Byappanahalli M., Goodwin K.D., Gourmelon M., Griffith J., Holden P.A., Jay J., Layton B., Lee C., Lee J., Meijer W.G., Noble R.T., Raith M., Ryu H., Sadowsky M.J., Schriewer A., Wang D., Wanless D., Whitman R., Wuertz S., Santo Domingo J.W. Multi-laboratory evaluations of the performance of Catellicoccus marimammalium PCR assays developed to target gull fecal sources. Water Res 2013, 47(18):6883-6896.
51. Staley C., Gordon K.V., Schoen M.E., Harwood V.J. Performance of two quantitative PCR methods for microbial source tracking of human sewage and implications for microbial risk assessment in recreational waters. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2012, 78(20):7317-7326.
52. Stewart-Pullaro J., Daugomah J.W., Chestnut D.E., Graves D.A., Sobsey M.D., Scott G.I. F+ RNA coliphage typing for microbial source tracking in surface waters. J. Appl. Microbiol. 2006, 101(5):1015-1026.
53. Stoeckel D.M., Harwood V.J. Performance, design, and analysis in microbial source tracking studies. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2007, 73(8):2405-2415.
54. Stoeckel D.M., Stelzer E.A., Dick L.K. Evaluation of two spike-and -recovery controls for assessment of extraction efficiency in microbial source tracking studies. Water Res. 2009, 43:4820-4827.
55. Straub T.M., Chandler D.P. Towards a unified system for detecting waterborne pathogens. J. Microbiol. Methods 2003, 53(2):185-197.
56. Stumpf C.H., Piehler M.F., Thompson S., Noble R.T. Loading of fecal indicator bacteria in North Carolina tidal creek headwaters: hydrographic patterns and terrestrial runoff relationships. Water Res. 2010, 44(16):4704-4715.
57. USEPA 2012 Recreational Water Quality Criteria 2012, EPA Office of Water, Washington, DC, Available on-line:, Criteria Document 820-F-12-058. http://water.epa.gov/scitech/swguidance/standards/criteria/health/recreation/index.cfm.
58. Verhougstraete M.P., Byappanahalli M.N., Rose J.B., Whitman R.L. Cladophora in the Great Lakes: impacts on beach water quality and human health. Water Sci. Technol. 2010, 62(1):68-76.
59. Walters S.P., Yamahara K.M., Boehm A.B. Persistence of nucleic acid markers of health-relevant organisms in seawater microcosms: implications for their use in assessing risk in recreational waters. Water Res. 2009, 43:4929-4939.
60. Wang D., Silkie S.S., Nelson K.L., Wuertz S. Estimating true human and animal host source contribution in quantitative microbial source tracking using the Monte Carlo method. Water Res. 2010, 44:4760-4775.
61. Wang D., Farnleitner A.H., Field K.G., Green H.C., Shanks O.C., Boehm A.B. Enterococcus and Escherichia coli fecal source apportionment with microbial source tracking genetic markers - is it feasible?. Water Res 2013, 47(18):6849-6861.
62. Wilson I.G. Inhibition and facilitation of nucleic acid amplification. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 1997, 63:3741-3751.
63. Yamahara K.M., Walters S.P., Boehm A.B. Growth of enterococci in unaltered, unseeded beach sands subjected to tidal wetting. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2009, 75(6):1517-1524.