Overconfidence in IT investment decisions: Why knowledge can be a boon and bane at the same time

International Conference on Information Systems 2011, ICIS 2011

Volumn 5, Issue , 2011, Pages 4335-4351

  Vetter, Johannes ^a   Benlian, Alexander ^a   Hess, Thomas ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MUNICH   (Germany)

Author keywords

Better than average effect; Decision biases; Illusion of control; IT investment decisions; IT outsourcing; Knowledge types; Miscalibration; Overconfidence

Indexed keywords

BETTER-THAN-AVERAGE EFFECT; DECISION BIAS; IT INVESTMENT DECISIONS; IT OUTSOURCING; KNOWLEDGE TYPES; MISCALIBRATION; OVERCONFIDENCE;

DECISION MAKING; INFORMATION SYSTEMS; OUTSOURCING; RESEARCH;

INVESTMENTS;

EID: 84884643825     PISSN: None     EISSN: None     Source Type: Conference Proceeding    
DOI: None     Document Type: Conference Paper

References (69)

1. Alba, J.W., and Hutchinson, J.W. 1987. "Dimensions of Consumer Expertise,". The Journal of Consumer Research. (13:4), pp. 411-454.
2. Apte, U., Sobol, M., Hanaoka, S., Shimada, T., Saarinen, T., Salmela, T., and Vepsalainen, A. 1997. "Is Outsourcing Practices in the USA, Japan and Finland: A Comparative Study,". Journal of Information Technology. (12:4), pp. 289-304.
3. Armstrong, J.S., and Overton, T.S. 1977. "Estimating Nonresponse Bias in Mail Surveys,". Journal of Marketing Research. (14:3), pp. 396-402.
4. Barnes, J.H. 1984. "Cognitive Biases and Their Impact on Strategic Planning,". Strategic Management Journal. (5:2), pp. 129-137.
5. Bassellier, G., Reich, B.H., and Benbasat, I. 2001. "Information Technology Competence of Business Managers: A Definition and Research Model,". Journal of Management Information Systems. (17:4), Spring2001, pp. 159-182.
6. Benamati, J., and Rajkumar, T.M. 2002. "The Application Development Outsourcing Decision: An Application of the Technology Acceptance Model,". Journal of Computer Information Systems. (42:4), p. 35.
7. Benaroch, M. 2002. "Managing Information Technology Investment Risk: A Real Options Perspective,". Journal of Management Information Systems. (19:2), Fall2002, pp. 43-84.
8. Benaroch, M., Jeffery, M., Kauffman, R.J., and Shah, S. 2007. "Option-Based Risk Management: A Field Study of Sequential Information Technology Investment Decisions,". Journal of Management Information Systems. (24:2), Fall2007, pp. 103-140.
9. Brucks, M. 1985. "The Effects of Product Class Knowledge on Information Search Behavior,". Journal of Consumer Research. (12), pp. 1-16.
10. Burger, J., and Cooper, H. 1979. "The Desirability of Control,". Motivation and Emotion, (3:4), pp. 381-393.
11. Carlson, J.P., Vincent, L.H., Hardesty, D.M., and Bearden, W.O. 2009. "Objective and Subjective Knowledge Relationships: A Quantitative Analysis of Consumer Research Findings,". Journal of Consumer Research. (35:5), pp. 864-876.
12. Cheng, F.-F., and Wu, C.-S. 2010. "Debiasing the Framing Effect: The Effect of Warning and Involvement,". Decision Support Systems. (49:3), pp. 328-334.
13. Darwin, C. 1871. The Descent of Man. London: John Murray.
14. Deaves, R., Luders, E., and Schroder, M. 2010. "The Dynamics of Overconfidence: Evidence from Stock Market Forecasters,". Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization. (75), pp. 402-412.
15. DeBondt, W., and Thaler, R. 1995. "Financial Decision Making in Markets and Firms: A Behavioral Perspective " Handbooks in Operational Research and Management Science. (9), pp. 385-410.
16. DePaulo, B.M., Charlton, K, Cooper, H., Lindsay, J.J., and Muhlenbruck, L. 1997. "The Accuracy-Confidence Correlation in the Detection of Deception,". Personality and Social Psychology Review. (4:1), pp. 346-357.
17. Der Vyver, G. 2004. "The Overconfidence Effect and It Professionals,". European Conference on Information Systems, pp. 163-175.
18. Dodd, T., Laverie, D., Wilcox, J., and Duhan, D. 2005. "Differential Effects of Experience, Subjective Knowledge, and Objective Knowledge on Sources of Information Used in Consumer Wine Purchasing,". Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research. (29:1), pp. 3-19.
19. Du, S., Keil, M., Mathiassen, L., Shen, Y., and Tiwana, A. 2007. "Attention-Shaping Tools, Expertise, and Perceived Control in It Project Risk Assessment,". Decision Support Systems. (43:1), pp. 269-283.
20. Dunning, D., Meyerowitz, J.A., and Holzberg, A.D. 1989. "Ambiguity and Self-Evaluation: The Role of Idiosyncratic Trait Definitions in Self-Serving Assessments of Ability,". Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. (57:6), pp. 1082-1090.
21. Ehrlinger, J., and Dunning, D. 2003. "How Chronic Self-Views Influence. (and Potentially Mislead) Estimates of Performance,". Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. (84:1), pp. 5-17.
22. Ehrlinger, J., Johnson, K, Banner, M., Dunning, D., and Kruger, J. 2008. "Why the Unskilled Are Unaware: Further Explorations of. (Absent) Self-Insight among the Incompetent,". Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. (105), pp. 98-121.
23. Enns, H.G., Huff, S.L., and Golden, B.R. 2003. "Cio Influence Behaviors: The Impact of Technical Background,". Information & Management. (40:5), pp. 467-485.
24. Finkelstein, S., Whitehead, J., and Campbell, A. 2008. Think Again: Why Good Leaders Make Bad Decisions and How to Keep It from Happening to You. Boston, MA: Harvard Business Press.
25. Forbes, D.P. 2005. "Are Some Entrepreneurs More Overconfident Than Others?,". Journal of Business Venturing. (20:5), pp. 623-640.
26. Gartner. 2009. "Gartner Says It Spending to Rebound in 2010 with 3.3 Percent Growth after Worst Year Ever in 2009,". in: http://www.aartner.com/it/paae.jsp?id=i20QQi.i. Stamford, Connecticut.
27. Gino, F., Sharek, Z., and Moore, DA. 2011. "Keeping the Illusion of Control under Control: Ceilings, Floors, and Imperfect Calibration,". Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. (114:2), pp. 104-114.
28. Glaser, M., and Weber, M. 2007. "Overconfidence and Trading Volume,". Geneva Risk & Insurance Review. (32:1), pp. 1-36.
29. Gorla, N, and Mei Bik, L. 2010. "Will Negative Experiences Impact Future It Outsourcing?,". Journal of Computer Information Systems. (50:3), pp. 91-101.
30. Hodges, B., Regher, G., and Martin, D. 2001. "Difficulties in Recognizing One's Own Incompetence: Novice Physicians Who Are Unskilled and Unaware of It,". Academic Medicine. (76:10), pp. 87-89.
31. Iacovou, C.L., Thompson, R.L., and Smith, H.J. 2009. "Selective Status Reporting in Information Systems Projects: A Dyadic-Level Investigation,". MIS Quarterly. (33:4), pp. 785-A785.
32. Jamieson, K., and Hyland, P. 2006. "Good Intuition or Fear and Uncertainty:The Effects of Bias on Information Systems Selection Decisions,". Informing Science Journal. (9), pp. 49-69.
33. Keren, G. 1997. "On the Calibration of Probability Judgments: Some Critical Comments and Alternative Perspectives,". Journal of Behavioral Decision Making. (10:3), pp. 269-278.
34. Khan, S., and Kumar, R. 2009. "Understanding Managerial Decision Risks in It Project Management: An Integrated Behavioral Decision Analysis Perspective,". American Conference on Information Systems, pp. 120-131.
35. Khan, S., and Stylianou, A. 2009. "It Project Management & Managerial Risk: Effects of Overconfidence,". 4th International Research Workshop on Information Technology Project Management, pp. 63-73.
36. Kim, H.-W., and Kankanhalli, A. 2009. "Investigating User Resistance to Information Systems Implementation: A Status Quo Bias Perspective,". MIS Quarterly. (33:3), pp. 567-582.
37. Klayman, J., Soil, J.B., González-Vallejo, C, and Barlas, S. 1999. "Overconfidence: It Depends on How, What, and Whom You Ask,". Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. (79:3), pp. 216-247.
38. Koriat, A., Lichtenstein, S., and Fischhoff, B. 1980. "Reasons for Confidence,". Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory. (6:2), pp. 107-118.
39. Kruger, J., and Dunning, D. 1999. "Unskilled and Unaware of It: How Difficulties in Recognizing One's Own Incompetence Lead to Inflated Self-Assessments,". Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. (77:6), pp. 1121-1134.
40. Langer, E. 1975. "The Illusion of Control,". Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. (32:2), pp. 311-328.
41. Larrick, R., Burson, K, and Soil, J. 2007. "Social Comparison and Confidence: When Thinking You're Better Than Average Predicts Overconfidence. (and When It Does Not),". Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. (102:1), pp. 76-94.
42. Marteau, T.M., Johnston, M.W. G., and Evans, T.R. 1989. "Cognitive Factors in the Explanation of the Mismatch between Confidence and Competence in Performing Basic Life Support,". Psychology and Health. (3), pp. 173-182.
43. Mattila, A., and Wirtz, J. 2002. "The Impact of Knowledge Types on the Consumer Search Process: An Investigation in the Context of Credence Services,". International Journal of Service Industry Management. (13:3), pp. 214-230.
44. McKenzie, C.R.M., Liersch, M.J., and Yaniv, I. 2008. "Overconfidence in Interval Estimates: What Does Expertise Buy You?,". Organizational Behavior & Human Decision Processes. (107:2), pp. 179-191.
45. Menkhoff, L., Schmidt, U., and Brozynski, T. 2006. "The Impact of Experience on Risk Taking, Overconfidence, and Herding of Fund Managers: Complementary Survey Evidence,". European Economic Review. (50:7), pp. 1753-1766.
46. Messerschmidt, M., Schulein, P., and Murnleitner, M. 2008. Der Wertbeitrag Der It Zum Unternehmenserfolg. Stuttgart: PricewaterhouseCoopers AG Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft.
47. Moore, D., and Healy, P. 2008. "The Trouble with Overconfidence,". Psychological Review. (115:2), pp. 502-517.
48. Orange Business Services. 2009. Cxo Survey 200c-Results: Outsourcing Services. Paris: Orange Business Services.
49. Phillips, J., Klein, G., and Sieck, W. 2004. "Expertise in Judgement and Decision Making: A Case for Training Intuitive Decision Skills,". in Blackwell Handbook of Judgement and Decision-Making, Blackwell, Oxford, D.J. Koehler and N. Harvey. (eds.). London: Blackwell, pp. 297-315.
50. Presson, P.K., and Benassi, VA. 1996. "Illusion of Control: A Meta-Analytic Review,". Journal of Social Behavior & Personality. (11:3), pp. 493-510.
51. Raju, P., Lonial, S., and Mangold, W. 1995. "Differential Effects of Subjective Knowledge, Objective Knowledge, and Usage Experience on Decision Making: An Exploratory Investigation,". Journal of Consumer Psychology. (4:2), pp. 153-180.
52. Riggio, R.E., Widaman, K.F., and Friedman, H.S. 1985. "Actual and Perceived Emotional Sending and Personality Correlates,". Journal of Nonverbal Behavior. (9), pp. 69-83.
53. Roch, S.G., Lane, J.A.S., Samuelson, CD., Allison, S.T., and Dent, J.L. 2000. "Cognitive Load and the Equality Heuristic: A Two-Stage Model of Resource Overconsumption in Small Groups,". Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. (83:2), pp. 185-212.
54. Ross, L., Greene, D., and House, P. 1977. "The "False Consensus Effect": An Egocentric Bias in Social Perception and Attribution Processes,". Journal of Experimental Social Psychology. (13:3), pp.279-301.
55. Rouse, A.C., and Corbitt, B. 2007. "Understanding Informations Systems Outsourcing Success and Risks through the Lens of Cognitive Biases,". 15th European Conference on Information Systems, University of St. Gallen, St. Gallen, Switzerland, pp. 1167-1178.
56. Russo, J.E., and Schoemaker, P.J.H. 1992. "Managing Overconfidence,". Sloan Management Review. (33:2), Winter92, pp. 7-17.
57. Sabherwa, R., and King, W.R. 1995. "An Empirical Taxonomy of the Decision- Making Processes Concerning Strategic Applications of Information Systems,". Journal of Management Information Systems. (11:4), Spring, pp. 177-214.
58. Shepherd, D., Zacharakis, A., and Baron, R. 2003. "Vcs' Decision Processes: Evidence Suggesting More Experience May Not Always Be Better,". Journal of Business Venturing. (18:3), pp. 381-401.
59. Simon, HA. 1959. "Theories of Decision-Making in Economics and Behavioral Science,". American Economic Review. (49:3), pp. 253-283.
60. Simon, M., Houghton, S.M., and Aquino, L. 1999. "Cognitive Biases, Risk Perception, and Venture Formation: How Individuals Decide to Start Companies,". Journal of Business Venturing. (15), pp.113-134.
61. Skala, D. 2008. "Overconfidence in Psychology and Finance-an Interdisciplinary Literature Review," Bank i Kredyt. (4), pp. 33-50.
62. Sporer, S., Penrod, S.D., Read, D., and Cutler, B.L. 1995. "Gaining Confidence in Confidence: A New Meta-Analysis on the Confidence-Accuracy Relationship in Eyewitness Identification Studies," Psychological Bulletin. (118), pp. 315-327.
63. Taylor, S.E., and Brown, J.D. 1988. "Illusion and Well-Being: A Social Psychological Perspective on Mental Health,". Psychological Bulletin. (103:2), pp. 193-210.
64. Thompson, S.C. 1999. "Illusions of Control: How We Overestimate Our Personal Influence,". Current Directions in Psychological Science. (8:6), pp. 187-190.
65. Tracey, J., Arroll, B., Richmond, D., and Barham, P. 1997. "The Validity of General Practitioners' Self Assessment of Knowledge: Cross Sectional Study,". British Medical Journal. (315:7120), pp. 1426-1428.
66. van de Venter, G., and Michayluk, D. 2008. "An Insight into Overconfidence in the Forecasting Abilities of Financial Advisors,". Australian Journal of Management. (32:3), p. 545.
67. Yaniv, I., and Foster, D.P. 1997. "Precision and Accuracy of Judgmental Estimation,". Journal of Behavioral Decision Making. (10), pp. 21-32.
68. Yeo, K.T. 2002. "Critical Failure Factors in Information System Projects,". International Journal of Project Management. (20:3), pp. 241-246.
69. Zacharakis, A., and Shepherd, DA. 1999. "Knowledge, Overconfidence and the Quality of Venture Capitalists' Decisions,". 13th Annual National Conference of the United States Association for Small Business and Entrepreneurship, M.D. Meeks and S. Kunkel. (eds.), San Diego, CA: United States Association for Small Business and Entrepreneurship.