How peer review empowers the academic profession and university managers: Changes in relationships between the state, universities and the professoriate

Research Policy

Volumn 42, Issue 5, 2013, Pages 1165-1173

  Musselin, Christine ^a  

^a Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique   (France)

Author keywords

Academic profession; Assessment; Elite; Higher education public policies; Power; University governance

Indexed keywords

PUBLIC POLICY;

ACADEMIC PROFESSION; ASSESSMENT; ELITE; HIGHER EDUCATION; POWER; UNIVERSITY GOVERNANCES;

MANAGERS;

EID: 84876832715     PISSN: 00487333     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.respol.2013.02.002     Document Type: Article

References (77)

1. S. Ackroyd Organisations Contra Organisations: professions and organisational change in the United Kingdom Organization Studies 17 1996 599 621 (Pubitemid 126315686)
2. S. Ackroyd, I. Kirkpatrick, and M. Walker Public management reform in the UK and its consequences for professional organization: a comparative analysis Public Administration 85 2007 9 26
3. S.J. Ball The sociological implications of the education reform act: review essay British Journal of Sociology of Education 11 4 1990 485 491
4. Barrier, J.; 2010. La science en projets. Régimes de financement et reconfigurations du travail des chercheurs académiques, PhD in Sociology at Sciences Po, Paris.
5. J. Barrier La science en projets: financements sur projet, autonomie professionnelle et transformations du travail des chercheurs académiques Sociologie du travail 53 4 2011 515 536
6. R. Berdahl Statewide boards and the alienation of governance from the campus Academe 68 1 1982 11A 14A
7. P. Bezes, and D. Demazière New Public Management et professions dans l'Etat: au-delà des oppositions, quelles recompositions? Sociologie du travail 52 2011 293 348
8. P. Bourdieu Homo Academicus 1988 [1984] Polity Press Cambridge (first published in French in 1984. Homo Academicus. Editions de Minuit, Paris)
9. D. Braun Who governs intermediary organizations? Principal-agents relations in research policy-making Journal of Public Policy 13 1993 135 162
10. D. Braun, and F.-X. Merrien Governance of Universities in a Comparative Perspective 1999 Jessica Kingsley Publishers London
11. N. Brunsson, and K. Sahlin-Andersson Constructing organizations: the example of the public sector reform Organization Studies 21 2000 721 746
12. Camerati, F. Les transformations du système de financement de la recherche dans les universités britanniques. PhD in Sociology at Sciences Po, Paris, forthcoming.
13. Chatelain, S.; Mignot-Gérard, S.; Musselin, C.; Sponem, S.; 2012. La gouvernance des universités françaises. Pouvoir, évaluation et identité. Monograph, Paris, HEC Montréal, CNAM, CSO and UPEC.
14. T. Christensen, and P. Lægreid Regulatory reforms and agencification ECPR Conference Budapest, September 2005 2005
15. M. Cohen, J. March, and J. Olsen A garbage can model of organizational choice Administrative Science Quarterly 17 1972 1 25
16. H. de Boer, J. Enders, and L. Leisyte Public sector reform in Dutch higher education: the organizational transformation of the university Public Administration 85 2007 27 46 (Pubitemid 46390860)
17. H. de Boer, J. Enders, and U. Schimank On the way towards new public management? The governance of university systems in England, the Netherlands, Austria and Germany D. Jansen, New Forms of Governance in Research Organizations. Disciplinary Approaches, Interfaces and Integration 2007 Springer Dordrecht 137 152
18. R. Deem, S. Hillyard, and M. Reed Knowledge Higher Education and the New Managerialism: The Changing Management of UK Universities 2007 Oxford University Press Oxford
19. P.B. Doeringer, and M.J. Piore Internal Labor Markets and Manpower Analysis 1971 Heath Lexington Books Lexington
20. J. Elster Deliberation and constitution making J. Elster, Deliberative Democracy 1998 Cambridge University Press Cambridge
21. J. Enders, and H. de Boer The Changing Face of Academic Life 2009 MacMillan New York, Palgrave
22. J. Enders, and C. Musselin Back to the future? The academic professions in the 21st century OECD Higher Education 2030. Vol. 1: Demography 2008 OECD Editions Paris pp. 125-150
23. Eurydice Two Decades of Reform in Higher Education in Europe: 1980 onwards 2000 Eurydice Studies, Education and Culture, European Commission Brussels
24. Eurydice Higher Education Governance in Europe 2008 Eurydice Studies, Education and Culture, European Commission Brussels
25. J. Evetts New directions in state and international professional occupations: discretionary decision-making and acquired regulation Work, Employment and Society 13 2002 353
26. E. Ferlie, C. Musselin, and G. Andresani The steering of higher education systems: a public management perspective Higher Education 56 2008 325 348
27. E. Freidson Professionalism Reborn. Theory, Prophecy and Policy 1994 Polity Press Cambridge
28. E. Freidson Professionalism, the Third Logic. On the Practice of Knowledge 2001 Chicago University Press Chicago
29. E. Friedberg, and C. Musselin L'université des professeurs Sociologie du Travail 31 4 1989 455 476
30. E. Friedberg, and C. Musselin L'Etat face aux universités 1993 Anthropos Paris
31. Fulton, O.; 1994. Remote and Ineffectual Dons? The Academic Profession at the End of the Twentieth Century. Inaugural Lecture at the University of Lancaster.
32. A. Geuna, and B. Martin University research evaluation and funding: an international comparison Minerva 41 4 2003 277 304 (Pubitemid 39101842)
33. P.J. Gumport Academic restructuring: organizational change and institutional imperatives Higher Education: The International Journal of Higher Education and Educational Planning 39 2000 67 91
34. T. Halliday Beyond Monopoly: Lawyers, Sate Crises and Professional Empowerment 1987 University of Chicago Press Chicago
35. S. Harrisson, and C. Pollitt Controlling Health Professionals 1994 Open University Press Buckingham
36. M. Henkel, and B. Little Changing Relationships between Higher Education and the State 1999 Jessica Kingsley Publishers London
37. B. Jonbloed Keeping up performances: an international survey of performance-based funding in higher education Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management 23 2 2001 127 145
38. M. Jouvenet Profession scientifique et instruments politiques: l'impact du financement «sur projet» dans des laboratoires de nanosciences Sociologie du travail 53 2011 234 252
39. B. Kehm, and U. Lanzendorf Reforming University Governance. Changing Conditions for Research in Four European Countries 2006 Bonn Lemmens
40. E. Krause Death of the Guild: Professions, States and the Advance of Capitalism 1930 to Present 1996 Yale University Press New Haven, CT
41. Krücken, G.; 2011. A European perspective on new modes of university governance and actorhood. Research & Occasional Paper Series, CSHE.17.11. http://cshe.berkeley.edu/.
42. G. Krücken, and F. Meier Turning the university into an organizational actor G. Drori, J. Meyer, H. Hwang, Globalization and Organization 2006 Oxford University Press Oxford 241 257
43. M. Lamont How Professors Think 2010 Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
44. M. Larson The Rise of Professionalism: A Sociological Analysis 1977 University of California Press Berkeley
45. E. Lazega, and Wattebled Two definitions of collegiality and their inter-relation: The case of a Roman Catholic diocese Sociologie du travail in English 53 Suppl. 1 2011 e57 e77 (originally published in French in 2010. Deux définitions de la collégialité et leur articulation: le cas d'un diocèse catholique. Sociologie du travail 52, 481-502)
46. P. Le Galès, and A. Scott A British bureaucratic revolution? Autonomy without control or "Freer actors more rules", English Annual selection Revue Française de Sociologie 51 1 2010 119 146 (first published in French: 2008. Une révolution bureaucratique britannique? Autonomie sans contrôle ou «freer markets, more rules». Revue française de sociologie 49, 301-330)
47. S.L. Lee The Research Assessment Exercise, the state and the dominance of mainstream economics in British universities Cambridge Journal of Economics 31 2 2007 309 325
48. G. Mallard, and C. Paradeise Global science and national sovereignty: a new terrain for the historical sociology of science G. Mallard, C. Paradeise, A. Peerbaye, Global Science and National Sovereignty 2008 Routledge New York 1 39
49. H. Mintzberg The Structuring of Organizations: A Synthesis of the Research 1979 Prentice Hall Englewoods Cliffs, NJ
50. R. Münch Die akademische Elite, Zur sozialen Konstruktion wissenschaftlicher Exzellenz 2007 Suhrkamp Frankfurt a. M.
51. R. Münch Stratifikation durch Evaluation: Mechanisms der Konstruktion von Statushierarchien in der Forschung Zeitschrift für Soziologie 37 2008 60 80
52. C. Musselin La longue marche des universités françaises 2004 [2001] Presses de Sciences Po Paris (The Long March of French Universities, New York, Routledge, 2004)
53. C. Musselin European academic labor markets in transition Higher Education 49 2005 135 154 (Pubitemid 40553866)
54. C. Musselin Are universities specific organizations G. Krücken, A. Kosmützky, M. Torka, Towards a Multiversity? Universities between Global Trends and National Traditions 2006 Transcript Verlag Bielefeld 63 84
55. C. Musselin The Markets for Academics 2009 [2005] Routledge New York (first published in 2005. Le marché des universitaires. France, Allemagne, Etats-Unis. Paris, Presses de Sciences Po)
56. C. Musselin Liberté, Responsabilités, Centralisation. Monograph 2012 CSO and ESEN Paris
57. R. Naidoo The competitive state and the mobilised market: higher education policy reform in the United Kingdom (1980-2007) Critique Internationale 2008 47 65
58. D. Orr, M. Jaeger, and A. Schwarzenberger Performance-based funding as an instrument of competition in German higher education 29 1 2007 3 23
59. C. Paradeise, E. Reale, I. Bleiklie, and E. Ferlie University Governance. Western European Comparative Perspectives 2009 Springer Dordrecht
60. Paye, S.; 2010. Beyond homo-academicus: new professional patterns in British universities. conference on "The Distinction of Elites: Case Studies". Maison Française d'Oxford, 21 January, Oxford, 2010.
61. J. Pfeffer, and G.R. Salancik Organizational decision making as a political process: the case of a university budget Administrative Science Quarterly 19 1974 135 151
62. J. Podolny A status-based model of market competition American Journal of Sociology 98 1993 829 872
63. G. Rosenblum, and B.R. Rosenblum The flow of instructors through the segmented labor markets of academe Higher Education 31 1996 429 445
64. G.R. Salancik, and J. Pfeffer The bases and use of power in organizational decision making: the case of a university Administrative Science Quarterly 19 1974 453 473
65. T. Schubert Empirical observations on new public management to increase efficiency in public research-boon or bane? Research Policy 38 2009 1225 1234
66. S. Schwarz, and D. Westerheijden Accreditation and Evaluation in the European Higher Education Area 2004 Springer Dordrecht
67. R. Scott Lords of the dance, professional as institutional agents Organization Studies 29 2 2008 219 238
68. K. Serrano-Velarde Evaluation, Akkreditierung und Politik-Zur Organisation von Qualitätsscherung im Zuge des Bolognaprozesses 2008 VS-Verlag Wiesbaden
69. Van den Besselaar, P.; Leydesdorff, L.; 2007, Past Performance as Predictor of Successful Grant Applications. The Hague, Rathenau Instituut SciSA rapport 0706.
70. B.J.R. Van der Meulen, and A. Rip Mediation in the Dutch science system Research Policy 27 8 1998 757 769 (Pubitemid 128418998)
71. Vinokur, A.; 2007. La loi relative aux libertés et responsabilités des universités: essai de mise en perspective. Revue de la Régulation [en ligne] 2, November 2007. Downloaded on from: http://regulation.revues.org/index1783.html (12 November 2009).
72. M. Waters Collegiality, bureaucratization and professionnalization: a Weberian analysis American Journal of Sociology 94 1989 945 972
73. K. Weaver Automatic Government: The Politics of Indexation 1988 Brookings Institution Press Washington, DC
74. K. Weick Educational organizations as loosely coupled systems Administrative Science Quarterly 21 1976 1 19
75. R. Whitley Changing governance of the public sciences: the consequences of establishing diverse research evaluation systems R. Whitley, J. Glaeser, The Changing Governance of the Sciences: The Advent of Research Evaluation Systems 2007 Springer Dordrecht, Netherlands 3 27
76. R. Whitley Constructing universities as strategic actors: limitations and variations L. Engwall, D. Weaire, The University in the Market 2008 Portland Press Limited Colchester 23 37
77. R. Whitley The impact of changes in the governance of public science systems on intellectual authority and innovation L. Wedlin, K. Sahlin, M. Grafstrom, Exploring the Worlds of Mercury and Minerva 2009 Uppsala University Uppsala 291 316