Brain death, paternalism, and the language of "death"

Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal

Volumn 23, Issue 1, 2013, Pages 53-104

  Nair Collins, Michael ^a  

^a FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF MEDICINE   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BRAIN DEATH; COMPREHENSION; ETHICS; HUMAN; INFORMED CONSENT; INTERPERSONAL COMMUNICATION; LANGUAGE; LEGAL ASPECT; MORALITY; NOMENCLATURE; PATERNALISM; PERSISTENT VEGETATIVE STATE; PERSONAL AUTONOMY; PERSUASIVE COMMUNICATION; PUBLIC OPINION; RELIGION; TRANSPLANTATION; TRUST;

BRAIN DEATH; COMPREHENSION; ETHICAL ANALYSIS; HUMANS; INFORMED CONSENT; LANGUAGE; MORALS; PATERNALISM; PERSISTENT VEGETATIVE STATE; PERSONAL AUTONOMY; PERSUASIVE COMMUNICATION; PUBLIC OPINION; RELIGION; TERMINOLOGY AS TOPIC; TISSUE AND ORGAN HARVESTING; TISSUE AND ORGAN PROCUREMENT; TRUST; TRUTH DISCLOSURE;

EID: 84876008598     PISSN: 10546863     EISSN: 10863249     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1353/ken.2013.0002     Document Type: Article

References (89)

1. American Academy of Neurology. AAN Summary of Evidence-Based Guideline for Caregivers and Families of Patients. Available at http://www.aan.com/ globals/axon/assets/7562.pdf, accessed 4 December 2012.
2. Beauchamp, Tom, and James Childress. 2009. Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 6th ed. New York: Oxford University Press.
3. Bedir, Ahmet, and Şahin Aksoy. 2011. Brain Death Revisited: It Is Not 'Complete Death' According to Islamic Sources. Journal of Medical Ethics 37 (5): 290-294.
4. Beecher, Henry. 1968. A Definition of Irreversible Coma. Report of the Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School to Examine the Definition of Brain Death. Journal of the American Medical Association 205: 337-340.
5. Belkin, Gary. 2003. Brain Death and the Historical Understanding of Bioethics. Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences 58 (3): 325-361.
6. Bernat, James. 1998. A Defense of the Whole-Brain Concept of Death. Hastings Center Report 28 (2): 14-23.
7. Bernat, James. 2002. The Biophilosophical Basis of Whole-Brain Death. Social Philosophy and Policy 19 (2): 324-342.
8. Bernat, James. 2006. The Whole-Brain Concept of Death Remains Optimum Public Policy. Journal of Law, Medicine, and Ethics 1: 35-43.
9. Bernat, James, Charles Culver, and Bernard Gert. 1981. On the Definition and Criterion of Death. Annals of Internal Medicine 94: 389-394.
10. Byrne, Paul, Sean O'Reilly, Paul M. Quay, and Peter W. Salsich. 1982-1983. Brain Death-The Patient, The Physician, and Society. Gonzaga Law Review 18 (3): 429-516.
11. Capron, Alexander M. 2001. Brain Death-Well Settled Yet Still Unresolved. New England Journal of Medicine 344 (16): 1244-1246.
12. Capron, Alexander M., and Leon R. Kass. 1972. A Statutory Definition of the Standards for Determining Human Death: An Appraisal and a Proposal. University of Pennsylvania Law Review 121 (1): 87-118.
13. Cheng-tek Tai, Michael. 2009. An Asian Perspective on Organ Transplantation. Wiener Medizinische Wochenschrift 159 (17): 452-456.
14. Chiong, Winston. 2005. Brain Death Without Definitions. Hastings Center Report 35: 20-30.
15. Collins, Mike. 2009. Consent for Organ Retrieval Cannot Be Presumed. HEC Forum 21 (1): 71-106.
16. Collins, Mike. 2010. Reevaluating the Dead Donor Rule. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 35 (2): 154-179.
17. Dubois, James M. 2010. The Ethics of Creating and Responding to Doubts about Death Criteria. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 35 (3): 365-380.
18. Dubois, James M. 2011. Dead Tired of Repetitious Debates About Death Criteria. The American Journal of Bioethics 11 (8): 45-47.
19. Dworkin, Gerald. 1999. Paternalism. In The Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy, ed. Robert Audi, 649-650. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
20. Fitzgerald, Robert D., Irina Dechtyar, Eva Templ, Thomas Pernerstorfer, Wolfgang Hackl, and Franz X. Lackner. 1996. Endocrine Stress Reaction to Surgery in Brain-Dead Organ Donors. Transplant International 9 (2): 102-108.
21. Franz, Holly, William DeJong, and Susan M. Wolfe. 1997. Explaining Brain Death: A Critical Feature of the Donation Process. Journal of Transplant Coordination 7 (1).
22. Green, Michael B., and Daniel Wikler. 1980. Brain Death and Personal Identity. Philosophy & Public Affairs 9 (2): 105-133.
23. Grill, Kalle. 2007. The Normative Core of Paternalism. Res Publica 13 (4).
24. Halevy, Amir, and Baruch Brody. 1993. Brain Death: Reconciling Definitions, Criteria, and Tests. Annals of Internal Medicine 119: 519-525.
25. Hill, David J., Rajesh Munglani, and David Sapsford. 1994. Haemodynamic Responses to Surgery in Brain-Dead Organ Donors. Anaesthesia 49: 835-836.
26. Hofmann, Bjorn. 2002. Is There a Technological Imperative in Health Care? International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care 18 (3): 675-689.
27. Holland, Stephen. 2010. On the Ordinary Concept of Death. Journal of Applied Philosophy 27 (2): 109-122.
28. Jain, Samay, and Michael DeGeorgia. 2005. Brain Death-Associated Reflexes and Automatisms. Neurocritical Care 3 (2): 122-126.
29. Joffe, Ari R. 2009. Is There Good Justification for the Universal Medical Acceptance of Brain Death as Death? American Philosophical Association Newsletter on Philosophy and Medicine 9 (1): 9-13.
30. Joffe, Ari R., Natalie R. Anton, Jonathan P. Duff, and Allan Decaen. 2012. A Survey of American Neurologists About Brain Death: Understanding the Conceptual Basis and Diagnostic Tests for Brain Death. Annals of Intensive Care 2 (1): 4.
31. Keown, Damien. 2010. Buddhism, Brain Death, and Organ Transplantation. Journal of Buddhist Ethics 17: 1-35.
32. Kesselring, Annemarie, M. Kainz, and Alexander Kiss. 2007. Traumatic Memories of Relatives Regarding Brain Death, Request for Organ Donation and Interactions with Professionals in the ICU. American Journal of Transplantation 7 (1): 211-217.
33. Khushf, George. 2010. A Matter of Respect: A Defense of the Dead Donor Rule and of a "Whole-Brain" Criterion for Determination of Death. Journal of Medical Philosophy 35 (3): 330-364.
34. Korein, Julius. 1978. The Problem of Brain Death: Development and History. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 315 (1): 19-38.
35. Korein, Julius, and Calixto Machado. 2004. Brain Death-Updating a Valid Concept for 2004. In Brain Death and Disorders of Consciousness, ed. Calixto Machado and Alan Shewmon. Springer.
36. Kripke, Saul. 1980. Naming and Necessity. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
37. Kunin, Joshua. 2004. Brain Death: Revisiting the Rabbinic Opinions in Light of Current Medical Knowledge. Tradition 38 (4): 48.
38. Lizza, John P. 2006. Persons, Humanity, and the Definition of Death. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
39. Lizza, John P. 2009. Is 'Brain Death' Death?: Commentary on Papers Presented by Bernard Gert, D. Alan Shewmon, Robert Truog, Ari Joffe, and Donald Marquis at the Special Session Arranged by the APA Committee on Philosophy and Medicine at the APA Pacific Division Meeting, April 10, 2009. APA Newsletter on Philosophy and Medicine 9 (1): 20-22.
40. Lock, Margaret. 2004. Living Cadavers and the Calculation of Death. Body & Society 10 (2-3): 135-152.
41. Miller, Franklin, and Robert Truog. 2008. An Apology for Socratic Bioethics. American Journal of Bioethics 8 (7): 3-7.
42. Miller, Franklin, and Robert Truog. 2012. Death, Dying, and Organ Transplantation. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
43. Mizuno, Toshinari, and Brian T. Slingsby. 2007. Eye on Religion: Considering the Influence of Buddhist and Shinto Thought on Contemporary Japanese Bioethics. Southern Medical Journal 100 (1): 115-117.
44. Nair-Collins, Mike. 2010. Death, Brain Death, and the Limits of Science: Why the Whole-Brain Concept of Death Is a Flawed Public Policy. Journal of Law, Medicine, and Ethics 38 (3): 667-683.
45. New York State Department of Health. 2005. Guidelines for Determining Brain Death. Available at http://www.health.state.ny.us/professionals/doctors/guidelines/ determination_of_brain _death/docs/determination_of_brain_death.pdf, accessed 4 December 2012.
46. Pallis, Christopher. 1983. Prognostic Significance of a Dead Brain Stem. British Medical Journal 286: 123-124.
47. Pennefather, Stephen, J. H. Dark, and R. E. Bullock. 1993. Haemodynamic Responses to Surgery in Brain-Dead Organ Donors. Anaesthesia 48: 1034-1038.
48. Perry, John. 1975. Personal Identity. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press.
49. Potts, Michael, Paul A. Byrne, and Richard G. Nilges. 2000. Beyond Brain Death: The Case Against Brain Based Criteria for Human Death. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
50. Powner, David, and Ira M. Bernstein. 2003. Extended Somatic Support for Pregnant Women After Brain Death. Critical Care Medicine 31 (4): 1241-1249.
51. President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Biobehavioral Research. 1981a. Defining Death: Medical, Legal, and Ethical Issues in the Determination of Death. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
52. Biomedical and Biobehavioral Research. 1981b. Guidelines for the Determination of Death. Report of the Medical Consultants on the Diagnosis of Death to the President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. Journal of the American Medical Association 246 (19): 2184.
53. President's Council on Bioethics. 2008. Controversies in the Determination of Death: A White Paper by the President's Council on Bioethics. Available at http://bioethics.georgetown.edu/pcbe/reports/death/index.html, accessed 4 December 2012.
54. Putnam, Hilary. 1973. Meaning and Reference. Journal of Philosophy 70: 699-711.
55. Rady, Mohamed, Joan McGregor, and Joseph Verheijde. 2011. Mass Media Campaigns and Organ Donation: Managing Conflicting Messages and Interests. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy: 1-13.
56. Rady, Mohamed Y., and Joseph L. Verheijde. 2012. Brain-Dead Patients Are Not Cadavers: The Need to Revise the Definition of Death in Muslim Communities. HEC Forum. September 2012. Available at http://link.springer.com/arti cle/10.1007%2Fs10730-012-9196-7, accessed 4 December 2012.
57. Rodrigue, James R., Danielle L. Cornell, and Richard J. Howard. 2008. Pediatric Organ Donation: What Factors Most Influence Parents' Donation Decisions? Pediatric Critical Care Medicine: A Journal of the Society of Critical Care Medicine and the World Federation of Pediatric Intensive and Critical Care Societies 9 (2): 180.
58. Rosenblueth, Arturo, Norbert Wiener, and Julian Bigelow. 1943. Behavior, Purpose and Teleology. Philosophy of Science 10 (1): 18-24.
59. Rosengart, Axel J., Roberta L. Novakovic, and Jeffrey I. Frank. 2005. Coma, Persistent Vegetative State, and Brain Death. In Principles of Critical Care, ed. Jesse B. Hall, Gregory A. Schmidt, and Lawrence D. H. Wood, Chapter 67. New York: McGraw-Hill. Available at http://www.accessmedicine.com/ resourceTOC.aspx?resourceID=76, accessed 4 December 2012.
60. Royal College of Physicians. 1995. Criteria for the Diagnosis of Brain Stem Death. Review by a Working Group Convened by the Royal College of Physicians and Endorsed by the Conference of Medical Royal Colleges and their Faculties in the United Kingdom. Journal of the Royal College of Physicians London 29 (5): 381-382.
61. Rutenberg, Jim. The New York Times. 2009. False 'Death Panel' Rumor Has Some Familiar Roots (August 13).
62. Shafer, Teresa J. 2009. Improving Relatives' Consent to Organ Donation. British Medical Journal 338.
63. Shah, Seema K., Robert D. Truog, and Franklin G. Miller. 2011. Death and Legal Fictions. Journal of Medical Ethics 37: 719-722.
64. Sharif, Adnan, Haifaa Jawad, Peter Nightingale, James Hodson, Graham Lipkin, Paul Cockwell, Simon Ball, and Richard Borrows. 2011. A Quantitative Survey of Western Muslim Attitudes to Solid Organ Donation. Transplantation 92 (10): 1108.
65. Shea, John B., and F. C. I. Magazine. 2007. Organ Donation: The Inconvenient Truth. Catholic Insight. Available at http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2007_ docs/ Organdonationinconvenienttruth.pdf, accessed 4 December 2012.
66. Shewmon, D. Alan. 1997. Recovery from 'Brain Death': A Neurologist's Apologia. Linacre Quarterly 64 (1): 30-96.
67. Shewmon, D. Alan. 1998a. 'Brainstem Death', 'Brain Death' and Death: A Critical Re-Evaluation of the Purported Equivalence. Issues in Law & Medicine 14: 125-145.
68. Shewmon, D. Alan. 1998b. Chronic 'Brain-Death': Meta-Analysis and Conceptual Consequences. Neurology 51: 1538-1545.
69. Shewmon, D. Alan. 1999. Spinal Shock and 'Brain Death': Somatic Pathophysiological Equivalence and Implications for the Integrative-Unity Rationale. Spinal Cord 37: 313-324.
70. Shewmon, D. Alan. 2001. The Brain and Somatic Integration: Insights into the Standard Biological Rationale for Equating 'Brain Death' with Death. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 26: 457-478.
71. Shewmon, D. Alan. 2004. The Dead Donor Rule: Lessons from Linguistics? Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 14 (3): 277-300.
72. Shewmon, D. Alan. 2010. Constructing the Death Elephant: A Synthetic Paradigm Shift for the Definition, Criteria, and Tests for Death. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 35 (3): 256-298.
73. Shewmon, D. Alan, and Elizabeth S. Shewmon. 2004. The Semiotics of Death and Its Medical Implications. Advances in Experimental Medicine and Biology 550: 89-114.
74. Stevens, M. L. Tina. 1995. Redefining Death in America, 1968. Caduceus 11 (3): 207-219.
75. Sugimoto, Toshitsugu, Tsutomu Sakano, Yoshihiro Kinoshata, Masao Massui, and Takashi Yoshioka. 1992. Morphological and Functional Alterations of the Hypothalamic-Pituitary System in Brain Death with Long Term Bodily Living. Acta Neurochirurgica 115 (1-2).
76. Truog, Robert, and James C. Fackler. 1992. Rethinking Brain Death. Critical Care Medicine 20: 1705-1713.
77. Truog, Robert, and Walter M. Robinson. 2003. Role of Brain Death and the Dead-Donor Rule in the Ethics of Organ Transplantation. Critical Care Medicine 31: 2391-2396.
78. United Network for Organ Sharing. Common Myths. Available at http://www. unos.org/ donation/index.php?topic=fact_sheet_7, accessed 4 December 2012. United Network for Organ Sharing. Theological Perspectives. Available at http://www.unos.org/donation/ index.php?topic=fact_sheet_9, accessed 4 December 2012.
79. United Network for Organ Sharing. Theological Perspectives. Available at http://www.unos.org/donation/ index.php?topic=fact_sheet_9, accessed 4 December 2012.
80. United States Department of Health and Human Services. Organ Donation: The Process. Available at http://www.organdonor.gov/about/organdonationprocess. html, accessed 4 December 2012.
81. Van Os, Joanne M. 2009. The Hidden Trauma of Organ Donation. Medical Journal of Australia 191 (11-12): 612-613.
82. Veatch, Robert M. 1975. The Whole-Brain Oriented Concept of Death: An Outmoded Philosophical Formulation. Journal of Thanatology 3: 13-30.
83. Veatch, Robert M. 1993. Impending Collapse of the Whole-Brain Definition of Death. Hastings Center Report 23: 18-24.
84. Veatch, Robert M. 2003. The Dead Donor Rule: True by Definition. American Journal of Bioethics 3 (1): 10-11.
85. Veatch, Robert M. 2004. Abandon the Dead Donor Rule or Change the Definition of Death? Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 14 (3): 261-276.
86. Veatch, Robert M. 2005. The Death of Whole-Brain Death: The Plague of the Disaggregators, Somaticists, and Mentalists. Journal of Medicine & Philosophy 30 (4): 353-378.
87. Verheijde, Joseph L., and Michael Potts. 2010. Commentary on the Concept of Brain Death Within the Catholic Bioethical Framework. Christian Bioethics 16 (3): 246-256.
88. Woien, Sandra, Mohamed Y. Rady, Joeseph L. Verheijde, and Joan McGregor. 2006. Organ Procurement Organizations Internet Enrollment for Organ Donation: Abandoning Informed Consent. BMC Medical Ethics 7 (14).
89. Yoshioka, Toshitada, Hisashi Sugimoto, Masaaki Uenishi, Toshihisa Sakamoto, D. Sadamitsu, Tsutomu Sakano, and Toshitsugu Sugimoto. 1986. Prolonged Hemodynamic Maintenance by the Combined Administration of Vasopressin and Epinephrine in Brain Death: A Clinical Study. Neurosurgery 18 (5): 565-567.