Outdoor recreation planning: A comprehensive approach to understanding use interaction

CAB Reviews: Perspectives in Agriculture, Veterinary Science, Nutrition and Natural Resources

Volumn 3, Issue , 2008, Pages

  Marcouiller, David W ^a   Scott, Ian ^a   Prey, Jeff ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN MADISON   (United States)

^b WISCONSIN DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES   (United States)

Author keywords

Antagonistic; Compatibility; Competitive; Complements; Conflict; Dispute; Leisure; Management; Outdoor recreation planning; Supplements; User groups

Indexed keywords

EID: 84874168193     PISSN: None     EISSN: 17498848     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1079/PAVSNNR20083090     Document Type: Review

References (91)

1. Clawson M. Conflict, strategies, and possibilities for consensus in forest land use and management. In: Clawson M, editor. Forest Policy for the Future: Conflict, Compromise, Consensus. Resources for the Future, Washington; 1974. p. 105-191.
2. Manning R, Valliere W. Coping in outdoor recreation: causes and consequences of crowding and conflict among community residents. Journal of Leisure Research 2001;33(4):410-26. (Pubitemid 33744375)
3. Roe M, Benson J. Planning for conflict resolution: jet-ski use on the Northumberland coast. Coastal Management 2001; 29(1):19-39. (Pubitemid 32175425)
4. Wang C, Dawson C. Recreation conflict along New York's Great Lakes coast. Coastal Management 2005;33(3):297-314. (Pubitemid 40990418)
5. van Kooten GC. Land Resource Economics and Sustainable Development: Economic Policies and the Common Good. UBC Press, Vancouver; 1993.
6. Bailey E, Friedlaender A. Market structure and multiproduct industries. Journal of Economic Literature 1982;20:1024-48.
7. Weitzman ML. On diversity. Quarterly Journal of Economics 1992;107:363-405.
8. Hammitt WE, Schneider IE. Recreation conflict management. In: Gartner WC, Lime DW, editors. Trends in Outdoor Recreation, Leisure and Tourism. CABI Publishing, New York; 2000. p. 347-56.
9. Schneider I. Revisiting and revising recreation conflict research. Journal of Leisure Research 2000;32(1):129-32.
10. Jacob GR, Schreyer R. Conflict in outdoor recreation: A theoretical perspective. Journal of Leisure Research 1980; 12:368-80.
11. Vaske J, Donnelly M, Wittmann K, Laidlaw S. Interpersonal versus social-values conflict. Leisure Sciences 1995; 17(3):205-22. (Pubitemid 26471633)
12. Carothers P, Vaske J, Donnelly M. Social values versus interpersonal conflict among hikers and mountain bikers. Leisure Sciences 2001;23(1):47-61. (Pubitemid 32243185)
13. Hammitt WE. The spectrum of conflict in outdoor recreation. Proceedings of the Outdoor Recreation Forum 13-14 January 1988, Tampa; 1988. p. 439-50.
14. Gramann JH, Burdge RJ. The effect of recreation goals on conflict perception: The case of water skiers and fishermen. Journal of Leisure Research 1981;13(1):15-27.
15. Ivy MI, Stewart WP, Lue CC. Exploring the role of tolerance in recreational conflict. Journal of Leisure Research 1992; 24(4):348-60.
16. Watson AE, Niccolucci MJ, Williams DR. Hikers and recreational stocks users: Predicting and managing conflicts in three wildernesses. Intermountain Research Station Research Paper, United States Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, USA; 1993.
17. Ruddell EJ, Gramann JH. Goal orientation, norms, and noise-induced conflict among recreation areas users. Leisure Sciences 1994;16(2):93-104.
18. Gibbons S, Ruddell E. The effect of goal orientation and place dependence on select goal interferences among winter backcountry users. Leisure Sciences 1995;17(3):171-83. (Pubitemid 26471631)
19. Vaske J, Dyar R, Timmons N. Skill level and recreation conflict among skiers and snowboarders. Leisure Sciences 2004; 26(2):215-25. (Pubitemid 38587446)
20. Vaske J, Carothers P, Donnelly M, Baird B. Recreation conflict among skiers and snowboarders. Leisure Sciences 2000; 22(4):297-313. (Pubitemid 32007551)
21. Blahna D, Smith K, Anderson J. Backcountry llama packing: visitor perceptions of acceptability and conflict. Leisure Sciences 1995;17(3):185-204. (Pubitemid 26471632)
22. Watson AE, Niccolucci MJ, Williams DR. The nature of conflict between hikers and recreational stock users in the John-Muir-Wilderness. Journal of Leisure Research 1994;26(4):372-85.
23. Manning RE. Carrying capacity: An organizational framework. In: Studies in Outdoor Recreation: Search and Research for Satisfaction, 2nd edn. Oregon State University Press, Corvallis; 1999. p. 67-79.
24. Manning RE. Crowding in outdoor recreation: Use level, perceived crowding and satisfaction. In: Studies in Outdoor Recreation: Search and Research for Satisfaction, 2nd edn. Oregon State University Press, Corvallis; 1999. p. 80-121.
25. Manning RE. Indicators and standards of quality: A normative approach. In: Studies in Outdoor Recreation: Search and Research for Satisfaction, 2nd edn. Oregon State University Press, Corvallis; 1999. p. 122-55.
26. Manning RE. Recreation conflict: Goal interference. In: Studies in Outdoor Recreation: Search and Research for Satisfaction, 2nd edn. Oregon State University Press, Corvallis; 1999. p. 194-206.
27. Manning RE. The recreation opportunity spectrum: designs for diversity. In: Studies in Outdoor Recreation: Search and Research for Satisfaction, 2nd edn. Oregon State University Press, Corvallis; 1999. p. 176-93.
28. Adelman BJE, Heberlein TA, Bonnicksen TM. Social psychological explanations for the persistence of a conflict between paddling canoeists and motorcraft users in the Boundary Waters Canoe Area. Leisure Sciences 1982; 5(1):45-61.
29. Saremba J, Gill A. Value conflicts in mountain park settings. Annals of Tourism Research 1991;18(3):455-72.
30. Whittaker D, Manfredo M, Fix P, Sinnott R, Miller S, Vaske J. Understanding beliefs and attitudes about an urban wildlife hunt near Anchorage, Alaska. Wildlife Society Bulletin 2001; 29(4):1114-24. (Pubitemid 34054336)
31. Owens PL. Conflict as a social interaction process in environment and behavior research: The example of leisure and recreational research. Journal of Environmental Psychology 1985;5:243-59.
32. Schneider I, Hammitt W. Visitor response to outdoor recreation conflict: a conceptual approach. Leisure Sciences 1995; 17(3):223-34. (Pubitemid 26470942)
33. Heberlein TA, Shelby B. Carrying capacity, values, and the satisfaction model: a reply to Greist. Journal of Leisure Research 1977;9(2):142-8.
34. Manning RE, Ciali CP. Recreation density and user satisfaction: a further explanation of the satisfaction model. Journal of Leisure Research 1980;12(4):329-45.
35. Becker RH. Displacement of recreational users between the Lower St. Croix and Upper Mississippi Rivers. Journal of Environmental Management 1981;13:259-67. (Pubitemid 12274855)
36. Robertson RA, Regula JA. Recreational displacement and overall satisfaction - A study of central Iowa licensed boaters. Journal of Leisure Research 1994;26(2):174-81.
37. Stewart W, Cole D. Number of encounters and experience quality in grand canyon backcountry: consistently negative and weak relationships. Journal of Leisure Research 2001; 33(1):106-20. (Pubitemid 33744213)
38. Schuster R, Hammitt WE. Effective coping strategies in stressful outdoor recreation situations: conflict on the Ocoee River. USDA Forest Service Proceedings RMRS-P 2000; 15(4):167-74.
39. Gramann JH. Toward a behavioral theory of crowding in outdoor recreation: an evaluation and synthesis of research. Leisure Sciences 1982;5(2):109-26.
40. Stankey GH, McCool SF. Carrying capacity in recreational settings: evolution, appraisal, and application. Leisure Sciences 1984;6(4):453-73.
41. Heberlein TA, Vaske JJ. Crowding and visitor conflict on the Bois Brule River. Water Resources Center, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison; 1977.
42. Vaske JJ, Donnelly MP, Heberlein TA. Perceptions of crowding and resource quality by early and more recent visitors. Leisure Sciences 1980;3(4):367-81.
43. Hammitt WE, McDonald CD, Noe FP. Use level and encounters: important variables of perceived crowding among nonspecialized recreationists. Journal of Leisure Research 1984;16(1):1-8.
44. Shelby B, Vaske JJ, Heberlein TA. Comparative analysis of crowding in multiple locations: results from fifteen years of research. Leisure Sciences 1989;11:269-91.
45. Anderson DH, Brown PJ. The displacement process in recreation. Journal of Leisure Research 1984;16(1):61-73.
46. Shelby B, Bregenzer NS, Johnson R. Displacement and product shift - Empirical evidence from Oregon rivers. Journal of Leisure Research 1988;20(4):274-88.
47. Shindler B, Shelby B. Product shift in recreation settings - findings and implications from panel research. Leisure Sciences 1995;17(2):91-107.
48. Whittaker D, Shelby B. Types of norms for recreation Impacts - Extending the social norms concept. Journal of Leisure Research 1988;20(4):261-73.
49. Patterson ME, Hammitt WE. Backcountry encounter norms, actual reported encounters, and their relationship to wilderness solitude. Journal of Leisure Research 1990; 22(3):259-75.
50. Hall T, Shelby B. Who cares about encounters? Differences between those with and without norms. Leisure Sciences 1996;18(1):7-22.
51. Manning R, Valliere W, Wang B. Crowding norms: Alternative measurement approaches. Leisure Sciences 1999;21(2): 97-115. (Pubitemid 30024271)
52. Donnelly M, Vaske J, Whittaker D, Shelby B. Toward an understanding of norm prevalence: A comparative analysis of 20 years of research. Environmental Management 2000;25(4):403-14. (Pubitemid 30118145)
53. Vaske J, Donnelly M. Generalizing the encounter - norm - crowding relationship. Leisure Sciences 2002;24(3-4): 255-69. (Pubitemid 34973911)
54. Lee H, Graefe AR. Crowding at an arts festival: Extending crowding models to the frontcountry. Tourism Management 2003;24(1):1-11. (Pubitemid 36166790)
55. Miller T, McCool S. Coping with stress in outdoor recreational settings: An application of transactional stress theory. Leisure Sciences 2003;25(2-3):257-75. (Pubitemid 36854911)
56. Hammitt WE, Patterson ME. Coping behavior to avoid visitor encounters: its relationship to wildland policy. Journal of Leisure Research 1991;23(3):225-37.
57. Kuentzel WF, Heberlein TA. Cognitive and behavioral adaptations to perceived crowding: A panel study of coping and displacement. Journal of Leisure Research 1992; 24(4):377-93.
58. Hall T, Shelby B. Temporal and spatial displacement: evidence from a high-use reservoir and alternate sites. Journal of Leisure Research 2000;32(4):435-56.
59. Johnson A, Dawson C. An exploratory study of the complexities of coping behavior in the Adirondack Wilderness. Leisure Sciences 2004;26(3):281-93. (Pubitemid 39073783)
60. Shelby B, Vaske JJ. Using normative data to develop evaluative standards for resource-management - a comment on 3 recent papers. Journal of Leisure Research 1991; 23(2):173-87.
61. Hendee JC, Burdge RJ. The substitutability concept: implications for recreation research and management. Journal of Leisure Research 1974;6(2):157-62.
62. Manfredo MJ, Anderson D. The influence of activity importance and similarity on perception of recreation substitutes. Leisure Sciences 1987;9(1):77-86.
63. Vaske JJ, Donnelly MP, Tweed DL. Recreationist-defined versus researcher-defined similarity judgments in substitutability research. Journal of Leisure Research 1983;15(3):251-62.
64. Vaske JJ, Donnelly MP, Shelby B. Comparing two approaches for identifying recreation activity substitutes. Leisure Sciences 1990;12(4):289-302.
65. Schuster RM, Hammitt WE, Moore D. Stress appraisal and coping response to hassles experienced in outdoor recreation settings. Leisure Sciences 2006;28(2):97-113. (Pubitemid 43203337)
66. Jackson EL, Wong RAG. Perceived conflict between urban cross-country skiers and snowmobilers in Alberta. Journal of Leisure Research 1982;14(1):47-62.
67. Lee B, Shafer CS. The dynamic nature of leisure experience: An application of Affect Control Theory. Journal of Leisure Research 2002;34(3):290-310.
68. Lee B, Shafer C, Kang I. Examining relationships among perceptions of self, episode-specific evaluations, and overall satisfaction with a leisure activity. Leisure Sciences 2005; 27(2):93-109. (Pubitemid 40473473)
69. Diener E, Emmons RA. The independence of positive and negative affect. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1985;47(5):1105-17.
70. Watson D, Clark LA, Tellegen A. Development and validation of brief measures of positive and negative affect: the PANAS scales. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1988;54(6):1063-70.
71. Vitterso J, Chipeniuk R, Skar M, Vistad O. Recreational conflict is affective: The case of cross-country skiers and snowmobiles. Leisure Sciences 2004;26(3):227-43. (Pubitemid 39073780)
72. Shelby B, Heberlein TA. Carrying Capacity in Recreation Settings. Oregon State University Press, Corvalis; 1986.
73. Peterson GLA. comparison of the sentiments and perceptions of wilderness managers and canoeists in the boundary waters canoe area. Journal of Leisure Research 1974;6(Summer): 194-206.
74. Clark RN, Hendee JC, Campbell FL. Values, behavior, and conflict in modern camping culture. Journal of Leisure Research 1971;3:143-59.
75. Shelby B. Contrasting recreational experiences: motors and oars in the Grand Canyon. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 1980;35:129-31.
76. Shelby B, Vaske J, Donnelly M. Norms, standards, and natural resources. Leisure Sciences 1996;18(2):103-23.
77. Jackson JM. Structural characteristics of norms. In: Steiner ID, Fishbein MF, editors. Current Studies in Social Psychology. Holt, Rinehart, Winston, New York; 1965. p. 301-9.
78. Vaske JJ, Graefe AR, Shelby B, Heberlein TA. Backcountry encounter norms - theory, method and empirical-evidence. Journal of Leisure Research 1986;18(3):137-53.
79. Needham M, Rollins RB. Interest group standards for recreation and tourism impacts at ski areas in the summer. Tourism Management 2005;26(1):1-13. (Pubitemid 39428215)
80. Lewis M, Lime D, Anderson D. Paddle canoeists' encounter norms in Minnesota's boundary waters canoe area wilderness. Leisure Sciences 1996;18(2):143-60.
81. Manning R, Johnson D, VandeKamp M. Norm congruence among tour boat passengers to Glacier Bay National Park. Leisure Sciences 1996;18(2):125-41.
82. Manning R, Newman P, Valliere W, Wang B, Lawson S. Respondent self-assessment of research on crowding norms in outdoor recreation. Journal of Leisure Research 2001; 33(3):251-71. (Pubitemid 33744367)
83. Manning R, Lawson S, Newman P, Laven D, Valliere W. Methodological issues in measuring crowding-related norms in outdoor recreation. Leisure Sciences 2002; 24(3-4):339-48. (Pubitemid 34973917)
84. Stankey GH, Cole DN, Lucas RC, Petersen ME, Frissell SS. The Limits of Acceptable Change (LAC) System for Wilderness Planning. General Technical Report INT-176. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Intermountain Forest and Range Experiment Station, Ogden, UT; 1985. 37 p.
85. Graefe AR, Kuss FR, Vaske JJ. Visitor Impact Management: A Planning Framework. National Parks and Conservation Association, Washington, DC; 1990.
86. USDI, National Park Service. The Visitor Experience and Resource Protection (VERP) Framework A Handbook for Planners and Managers. USDI, NPS, Denver, CO; 1997.
87. Hof M, Lime DW. Visitor experience and resource protection framework in the National Park System: rationale, current status, and future direction. In: McCool SF, Cole DN, editors. Proceedings - Limits of Acceptable Change and Related Planning Processes: Progress and Future Directions (from a workshop held at the University of Montana's Lubrecht Experimental Forest). General Technical Report INT-GTR-371. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Ogden, UT; 1997. p. 29-36.
88. Hay MJ, McConnel KE. Harvesting and nonconsumptive wildlife recreation decisions. Land Economics 1984; 60(4):388-96.
89. Fesenmaier DR, Lieber SR. Destination diversification as an indicator of activity compatibility: an exploratory analysis. Leisure Sciences 1988;10:167-78.
90. Dennis DF. Analyzing public inputs to multiple objective decisions on national forests using conjoint analysis. Forest Science 1998;44(3):421-9.
91. Marcouiller DW, Mace T. Forests and Regional Development: Economic Impacts of Woodland Use for Recreation and Timber in Wisconsin. University of Wisconsin Extension, Madison; 1999.