Maternity Care and Liability: Pressing Problems, Substantive Solutions

Women's Health Issues

Volumn 23, Issue 1, 2013, Pages

  Sakala, Carol ^a   Yang, Y Tony ^b   Corry, Maureen P ^a  

^a Childbirth Connection New York   (United States)

^b GEORGE MASON UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BILLING AND CLAIMS; CAREGIVER; CHILD HEALTH; DEFENSIVE MEDICINE; EVIDENCE BASED PRACTICE; HEALTH BELIEF; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HEALTH CARE QUALITY; HEALTH CARE SYSTEM; HEALTH ECONOMICS; HEALTH IMPACT ASSESSMENT; HEALTH PRACTITIONER; HEALTH SERVICE; HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH; HEALTH STATUS; HUMAN; INSURANCE; JOB SATISFACTION; LAW SUIT; LEGAL ASPECT; MALPRACTICE; MATERNAL CARE; MATERNAL WELFARE; MEDICAL DECISION MAKING; MEDICAL FEE; MEDICAL LIABILITY; MEDICAL PRACTICE; MEDICAL RESEARCH; NEGLIGENCE; REIMBURSEMENT; SOCIAL PROBLEM; UNITED STATES;

DEFENSIVE MEDICINE; FEMALE; HEALTH SERVICES ACCESSIBILITY; HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH; HUMANS; INFANT, NEWBORN; INSURANCE, LIABILITY; LIABILITY, LEGAL; MALPRACTICE; MATERNAL HEALTH SERVICES; OBSTETRICS; POLICY MAKING; TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT; UNITED STATES;

EID: 84872233890     PISSN: 10493867     EISSN: 18784321     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.whi.2012.11.001     Document Type: Article

References (96)

1. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. (2012). HCUPnet. Available: Accessed: September 5, 2012. http://hcupnet.ahrq.gov.
2. Angelini D.J., Greenwald L. Closed claims analysis of 65 medical malpractice cases involving nurse-midwives. Journal of Midwifery & Women's Health 2005, 50:454-460.
3. Baicker K., Buckles K.S., Chandra A. Geographic variation in the appropriate use of cesarean delivery. Health Affairs 2006, 25:w355-w367.
4. Baicker K., Chandra A. The effect of malpractice liability on the delivery of health care. Forum for Health Economics & Policy 2005, 8:1-27.
5. Benedetti T.J., Baldwin L.-M., Skillman S.M., Andrilla C.H.A., Bowditch E., Carr K.C., et al. Professional liability issues and practice patterns of obstetric providers in Washington State. Obstetrics & Gynecology 2006, 107:1238-1246.
6. Berenson R.A., Kuo S., May J.H. Medical malpractice liability crisis meets markets: Stress in unexpected places 2003, September, Issue Brief No. 68, Center for Studying Health System Change, Washington, DC.
7. Bors-Koefoed R., Zylstra S., Ressuguie L.J., Ricci B.A., Kelly E.E., Mondor M.C. Statistical models of outcome in malpractice lawsuits involving death or neurologically impaired infants. Journal of Maternal-Fetal Medicine 1998, 7:124-131.
8. Brennan T.A., Leape L.L., Laird N.M., Hebert L., Localio A.R., Lawthers A.G., et al. Incidence of adverse events and negligence in hospitalized patients: Results of the Harvard Medical Practice Study I. New England Journal of Medicine 1991, 324:370-376.
9. Brennan T.A., Sox C.M., Burstin H.R. Relation between negligent adverse events and the outcomes of medical-malpractice litigation. New England Journal of Medicine 1996, 335:1963-1967.
10. Carrier E.R., Reschovsky J.D., Mello M.M., Mayrell R.C., Katz D. Physicians' fears of malpractice lawsuits are not assuaged by tort reforms. Health Affairs 2010, 29:1585-1592.
11. Carroll A.E., Buddenbaum J.L. Malpractice claims involving pediatricians: Epidemiology and etiology. Pediatrics 2007, 120:10-17.
12. Chauhan S.P., Chauhan V.B., Cowan B.D., Hendrix N.W., Magann E.F., Morrison J.C. Professional liability claims and Central Association of Obstetricians and Gynecologists members: Myth versus reality. American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology 2005, 192:1820-1826.
13. Chervenak F.A., McCullough L.B. The diagnosis and management of progressive dysfunction of health care organizations. Obstetrics & Gynecology 2005, 105:882-887.
14. Clark S.L. Patient safety and litigation reduction: 2 sides of the same coin. The Female Patient 2009, 34(10):20-24.
15. Clark S.L., Belfort M.A., Dildy G.A., Meyers J.A. Reducing obstetric litigation through alterations in practice patterns. Obstetrics & Gynecology 2008, 112:1279-1283.
16. Clark S.L., Meyers J.A., Frye D.K., Perlin J.A. Patient safety in obstetrics-The Hospital Corporation of America experience. American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology 2011, 204:283-287.
17. Classen D.C., Resar R., Griffin F., Federico F., Frankel T., Kimmel N., et al. 'Global Trigger Tool' shows that adverse events in hospitals may be ten times greater than previously measured. Health Affairs 2011, 30:581-589.
18. Cohen A.W., Hill W., Parer J., Ogburn P., Stiller R., Yankowitz J., et al. Professional liability claims and maternal fetal medicine specialists: MFM compared to general obstetrician gynecologists. American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology 2005, 193(Suppl. 6):S13.
19. Currie J., MacLeod W.B. First do no harm? Tort reform and birth outcomes. Quarterly Journal of Economics 2008, 123:795-830.
20. Dresden G.M., Baldwin L.-M., Andrilla C.H.A., Skillman S.M., Benedetti T.J. Influence of obstetric practice on workload and practice patterns of family physicians and obstetrician-gynecologists. Annals of Family Medicine 2008, 6(Suppl. 1):S5-S11.
21. Dubay L., Kaestner R., Waidmann T. Medical malpractice liability and its effect on prenatal care utilization and infant health. Journal of Health Economics 2001, 20:591-611.
22. Encinosa W.E., Hellinger F.J. Have state caps on malpractice awards increased the supply of physicians?. Health Affairs 2005, 24. (Web Exclusive), W5-250-W5-258.
23. Ginsburg P.B., Grossman J.A. When the price isn't right: How inadvertent payment incentives drive medical care. Health Affairs 2005, 24. (Web Exclusive), W5-376-W5-384.
24. Gregory K.D., Jackson S., Korst L., Fridman M. Cesarean versus vaginal delivery: Whose risks? Whose benefits?. American Journal of Perinatology 2012, 29:7-18.
25. Grimaldi P.L. RBRVS: How new physician fee schedules will work: Resource-Based Relative Value Scale payment system. Healthcare Financial Management 1991, 45. 58, 60, 64 passim.
26. Grunebaum A., Chervenak F., Skupski D. Effect of a comprehensive obstetric patient safety program on compensation payments and sentinel events. American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology 2011, 204:97-105.
27. Hale R.W. Medical professional liability revisited. Obstetrics & Gynecology 2006, 107:1224-1225.
28. Hankins G.D.V., MacLennan A.H., Speer M.E., Strunk A., Nelson K. Obstetric litigation is asphyxiating our maternity services. Obstetrics & Gynecology 2006, 107:1382-1385.
29. Hyman D.A., Silver C. The poor state of health care quality in the U.S.: Is malpractice liability part of the problem or part of the solution?. Cornell Law Review 2005, 90:893-993.
30. Institute of Medicine, Division of Health Promotion and Disease Prevention, Committee to Study Medical Professional Liability and the Delivery of Obstetrical Care Medical professional liability and the delivery of obstetrical care, volume I 1989, National Academy Press, Washington, DC.
31. Institute of Medicine, Division of Health Promotion and Disease Prevention, Committee to Study Medical Professional Liability and the Delivery of Obstetrical Care Medical professional liability and the delivery of obstetrical care, volume II: An interdisciplinary review 1989, National Academy Press, Washington, DC.
32. Iverson R.E., Heffner L.J. Obstetric safety improvement and its reflection in reserved claims. American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology 2011, 205:398-401.
33. James B.C., Savitz L.A. How Intermountain trimmed health care costs through robust quality improvement efforts. Health Affairs 2011, 30:1185-1191.
34. Kane C.K. Medical liability claim frequency: A 2007-2008 snapshot of physicians 2010, American Medical Association, Chicago.
35. Kessler D.P., Sage W.M., Becker D.J. Impact of malpractice reforms on the supply of physician services. JAMA 2005, 293:2618-2625.
36. Kim B. Current research on medical malpractice liability: The impact of malpractice risk on the use of obstetrics procedures. Journal of Legal Studies 2007, 36(Suppl. 2):S79-S120.
37. Klagholz J., Strunk A.L. Overview of the 2009 ACOG Survey on Professional Liability. ACOG Clinical Review 2009, 14(6). 1, 13-16.
38. Klick J., Stratmann T. Medical malpractice reform and physicians in high-risk specialties. Journal of Legal Studies 2007, 36:S121-S142.
39. Klingman D., Localio A.R., Sugarman J., Wagner J.L., Polishuk P.T., Wolfe L., et al. Measuring defensive medicine using clinical scenario surveys. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 1996, 21:185-217.
40. Kocher R., Sahni B.S. Hospitals' race to employ physicians: The logic behind a money-losing proposition. New England Journal of Medicine 2011, 364:1790-1793.
41. Kravitz R.L., Leigh J.P., Samuels S.J., Schembri M., Gilbert W.M. Tracking career satisfaction and perceptions of quality among US obstetricians and gynecologists. Obstetrics & Gynecology 2003, 102:463-470.
42. Leape L.L., Berwick D.M. Five years after To Err is Human: What have we learned?. JAMA 2005, 293:2384-2390.
43. Leape L.L., Brennan T.A., Laird N., Lawthers A.G., Localio A.R., Barnes B.A., et al. The nature of adverse events in hospitalized patients: Results of the Harvard Medical Practice Study II. New England Journal of Medicine 1991, 324:377-384.
44. Leape L.L., Fromson J.A. Problem doctors: Is there a system-level solution?. Annals of Internal Medicine 2006, 144:107-115.
45. Leigh J.P., Tancredi D.J., Kravitz R.L. Physician career satisfaction within specialties. BMC Health Services Research 2009, 9:166.
46. Localio A.R., Lawthers A.G., Brennan T.A., Laird N.M., Hebert L.E., Peterson L.M., et al. Relation between malpractice claims and adverse events due to negligence: Results of the Harvard Medical Practice Study III. New England Journal of Medicine 1991, 325:245-251.
47. Lockwood C.J., Auerbach R.D., Scott J.R., & Strunk A.L. Roundtable: The Ob/Gyn and legal liability: Condition critical, part 2. Contemporary OB/GYN 2005, 50(1):57-72.
48. Lockwood C.J., Strunk A.L., Scott J.R., Auerbach R.D. Roundtable: The Ob/Gyn and legal liability: Condition critical, part 1. Contemporary OB/GYN 2004, 49(11):73-74. 76, 78, 80-82, 85, 88-90, 92.
49. Martinez G., Daniels K., Chandra A. Fertility of men and women aged 15-44 years in the United States: National Survey of Family Growth, 2006-2010. National Vital Statistics Reports 2012, 51:1-28.
50. McCarthy J.L. Commentary: Carrots, not sticks: Using malpractice insurance premium incentives to promote patient safety. CRICO/RMF Forum 2007, 25(3):1.
51. Medical Liability Monitor. (2011, October). Annual rate survey issue.
52. Mehlman M.J. Bad " bad baby" bills. American Journal of Law & Medicine 1994, 20:129-145.
53. Mello, M. M. (2006a). Medical malpractice: Impact of the crisis and effect of state tort reforms. Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, Research Synthesis Report No. 10. Available at: http://www.rwjf.org/files/research/15168.medmalpracticeimpact.report.pdf.
54. Mello, M. M. (2006b). Understanding medical malpractice insurance: A primer. Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, Research Synthesis Report No. 8. Available at: http://www.rwjf.org/pr/synthesis/reports_and_briefs/pdf/no8_primer.pdf.
55. Mello M.M., Kachalia A. Evaluation of options for medical malpractice system reform: A report to the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC) April, 2010, MedPAC, Washington, DC.
56. Mello M.M., Studdert D.M. Deconstructing negligence: The role of individual and system factors in causing medical injuries. Georgetown Law Journal 2008, 96:599-623.
57. Mello M.M., Studdert D.M., Schumi J., Brennan T.A., Sage W.M. Changes in physician supply and scope of practice during a malpractice crisis: Evidence from Pennsylvania. Health Affairs 2007, 26:w425-w435.
58. Mello M.M., Zeiler K. Empirical health law scholarship: The state of the field. Georgetown Law Journal 2008, 96:649-702.
59. Minkoff H. Fear of litigation and cesarean section rates. Seminars in Perinatology 2012, 36:390-394.
60. O'Malley A.S., Bond A.M., Berenson R.A. Rising hospital employment of physicians: Better quality, higher costs? 2011, August, Issue Brief 136, Center for Studying Health System Change, Washington, DC.
61. Pauly M.V. Who pays when malpractice premiums rise?. Medical malpractice and the U.S. health care system 2006, 71-83. Cambridge University Press, New York. W.M. Sage, R. Kersh (Eds.).
62. Public Citizen Comprehensive survey finds Washington, D.C., Medical Society significantly lowballs the number of OB/GYNs in the District 2005, Public Citizen, Washington, DC.
63. Rittenhouse D.R., Mertz E., Keane D., Grumbach K. No exit: An evaluation of measures of physician attrition. Health Services Research 2004, 39:1571-1588.
64. Robeznieks A. Par for doc pay?. Modern Healthcare 2011, 41(29). 22, 24-27.
65. Rodwin M.A., Chang H.J., Clausen J. Malpractice premiums and physicians' income: Perceptions of a crisis conflict with empirical evidence. Health Affairs 2006, 25:750-758.
66. Rodwin M.A., Chang H.J., Ozaeta M.M., Omar R.J. Malpractice premiums in Massachusetts, a high-risk state: 1975 to 2005. Health Affairs 2008, 27:835-844.
67. Sakala C., Yang Y.T., Corry M.P. Maternity Care and liability: Least promising policy Strategies for Improvement. Womens' Health Issues 2013, 23(1):e15-e23.
68. Sakala C., Yang Y.T., Corry M.P. Maternity care and liability: Most promising strategies for improvement. Women's Health Issues 2013, 23(1):e25-e37.
69. Sakala C., Yang Y.T., Corry M.P. Maternity care and liability: Pressing problems, substantive solutions 2013, Childbirth Connection, New York, Available at: http://www.transform.childbirthconnection.org/reports/liability/.
70. Shea K.G., Scanlan K.J., Nilsson K.J., Wilson B., Mehlman C.T. Interstate variability of the statute of limitations for medical liability: A cause for concern?. Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics 2008, 28:370-374.
71. Simpson K.R. Disruptive clinician behavior. MCN: American Journal of Maternal Child Nursing 2007, 32:64.
72. Simpson K.R., Kortz C.C., Knox G.E. A comprehensive perinatal patient safety program to reduce preventable adverse outcomes and costs of liability claims. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety 2009, 35:565-574.
73. Sloan F.A., Entman S.S., Reilly B.A., Glass C.A., Hickson G.B., Zhang H.H. Tort liability and obstetricians' care levels. International Review of Law and Economics 1997, 17:245-260.
74. Sloan F.A., Whetten-Goldstein K., Entman S.S., Kulas E.D., Stout E.M. The road from medical injury to claims resolution: How no-fault and tort differ. Law and Contemporary Problems 1997, 60(2):35-70.
75. Smith L.L., Berry D. Partnering with technology to reduce OB losses. Journal of Healthcare Risk Management 2007, 27(4):25-30.
76. Smits A.K., Clark E.C., Nichols M., Saultz J.W. Factors influencing cessation of pregnancy care in Oregon. Family Medicine 2004, 36:490-495.
77. Smits A.K., King V.J., Rdesinski R.E., Dodson L.G., Saultz J.W. Change in Oregon maternity care workforce after malpractice premium subsidy implementation. Health Services Research 2009, 44:1253-1270.
78. Struve C.T. Doctors, the adversary system, and procedural reform in medical liability litigation. Fordham Law Review 2004, 72:943-1016.
79. Studdert D.M., Mello M.M. When tort resolutions are " wrong": Predictors of discordant outcomes in medical malpractice litigation. Journal of Legal Studies 2007, 36:S47-S78.
80. Studdert D.M., Mello M.M., Brennan T.A. Medical malpractice. New England Journal of Medicine 2004, 350:283-292.
81. Studdert D.M., Mello M.M., Gawande A.A., Gandhi T.K., Kachalia A., Yoon C., et al. Claims, errors, and compensation payments in medical malpractice litigation. New England Journal of Medicine 2006, 354:2024-2033.
82. Studdert D.M., Fritz L.A., Brennan T.A. The jury is still in: Florida's birth-related neurological injury compensation plan after a decade. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 2000, 25:499-526.
83. Thomas E.J., Studdert D.M., Burstin H.R., Orav E.J., Zeena T., Williams E.J., et al. Incidence and types of adverse events and negligent care in Utah and Colorado. Medical Care 2000, 38:261-271.
84. Thomas J.W., Ziller E.K., Thayer D.A. Low costs of defensive medicine, small savings from tort reform. Health Affairs 2010, 29:1578-1584.
85. U.S.General Accounting Office Medical malpractice: Implications of rising premiums on access to health care (GAO-03-836) 2003, Author, Washington, DC.
86. Veltman L.L. Disruptive behavior in obstetrics: A hidden threat to patient safety. American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology 2007, 196:587.e1-587.e4.
87. White A.A., Pichert J.W., Bledsoe S.H., Irwin C., Entman S.S. Cause and effect analysis of closed claims in obstetrics and gynecology. Obstetrics & Gynecology 2005, 105:1031-1038.
88. White F.J., Pettiette L.S., Wiggins R.B., Kiss A. Medical malpractice review panels and medical liability system cost, timeliness, and efficiency: A cross-sectional study. Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 2008, 5:375-405.
89. Wu A.W. Medical error: The second victim: The doctor who makes the mistake needs help, too. BMJ 2000, 320:726-727.
90. Xu X., Lori J.R., Siefert K.A., Jacobson P.D., Ransom S.B. Malpractice liability burden in midwifery: A survey of Michigan certified nurse-midwives. Journal of Midwifery & Women's Health 2008, 53:19-27.
91. Yang Y.T., Mello M.M., Subramanian S.V., Studdert D.M. Relationship between malpractice litigation pressure and rates of cesarean section and vaginal birth after cesarean section. Medical Care 2009, 47:234-242.
92. Yang Y.T., Studdert D.M., Subramanian S.V., Mello M.M. Does tort law improve the health of newborns, or miscarry? A longitudinal analysis of the effect of liability pressure on birth outcomes. Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 2012, 9:217-245.
93. Yang Y.T., Studdert D.M., Subramanian S.V., Mello M.M. A longitudinal analysis of the impact of liability pressure on the supply of obstetrician-gynecologists. Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 2008, 5:21-53.
94. Yates J. Data on liability claims offer bright spots for ObGyns: And sobering statistics. OBG Management 2012, 24:44-48.
95. Zhao L. Why Are fewer hospitals in the delivery business? 2007, NORC, Bethesda, MD.
96. Zuckerman S., Koller C.F., Bovbjerg R.R. Information on malpractice: A review of empirical research on major policy issues. Law and Contemporary Problems 1986, 49:85-111.