Does Tort Law Improve the Health of Newborns, or Miscarry? A Longitudinal Analysis of the Effect of Liability Pressure on Birth Outcomes

Journal of Empirical Legal Studies

Volumn 9, Issue 2, 2012, Pages 217-245

  Yang, Y Tony ^a   Studdert, David M ^b   Subramanian, S V ^c   Mello, Michelle M ^c  

^a GEORGE MASON UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF MELBOURNE   (Australia)

^c HARVARD SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84867341809     PISSN: 17401453     EISSN: 17401461     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1740-1461.2012.01252.x     Document Type: Article

References (90)

1. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) (2003) "Management of Preterm Labor, " 43 ACOG Practice Bulletin.
2. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) (2005) Your Pregnancy & Birth, 4th ed. Washington, DC: ACOG.
3. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) (2006) "Access to Prenatal Care Not Significantly Improving Pregnancy Outcomes for Minorities, " February 28 News Release. ACOG. Available at http://www.medisurf.com/My_Medisurf/iFrame_News.asp?Select_Code=X026001&NewsGroup=Public%20Health&USER_ID=&Page=40.
4. American Medical Association (19932004) Physician Characteristics and Distribution in the US https://catalog.ama-assn.org/Catalog/product/product_detail.jsp?productId=prod1910039.
5. American Trial Lawyers Association (2004) Medical Malpractice Insurance: Did New Malpractice Caps Stop Spiraling Premiums ? Available at http://www.atlanet.org/pressroom/FACTS/medmal/newcaps.pdf.
6. Avraham, R. (2006) Database of State Tort Law Reforms (DSTLR 2nd), Northwestern Law & Econ Research Paper No. 06-08. Available at http://ssrn.com/abstract=902711.
7. Beider, P., & S. Hagen (2004) Limiting Tort Liability for Medical Malpractice. Washington, DC: Congressional Budget Office.
8. Berkman, L. F., & I. Kawachi (2000) Social Epidemiology. New York: Oxford University Press.
9. Berkowitz, G. S., & E. Papiernik (1993) "Epidemiology of Preterm Birth, " 15 Epidemiologic Reviews 414.
10. Betran, A. P., M. Merialdi, J. A. Lauer, W. Bing-Shun, & J. Thomas (2007) "Rates of Caesarean Section: Analysis of Global, Regional and National Estimates, " 21 Paediatric & Perinatal Epidemiology 98.
11. Bjartveit, K., & A. Tverdal (2005) "Health Consequences of Smoking 1-4 Cigarettes per Day, " 14 Tobacco Control 315.
12. Calabresi, G. (1970) The Costs of Accidents: A Legal and Economic Analysis. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
13. Casey, B. M., D. D. McIntire, & K. J. Leveno (2001) "The Continuing Value of the Apgar Score for the Assessment of Newborn Infants, " 344(7) New England J. of Medicine 467.
14. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (2002) "Annual Smoking-Attributable Mortality, Years of Potential Life Lost, and Economic Costs-United States, 1995-1999, " 51(4) MMWR 300.
15. Chen, R., Y. Wax, A. Lusky, G. Toppleberg, & V. Barell (1991) "A Criterion for a Standardized Definition of Low Birthweight, " 20 International J. of Epidemiology 180.
16. Chhabra, S. (1991) "Perinatal Outcome in Teenage Mothers, " 41 J. of Obstetrics & Ganecology of India 30.
17. Conway, K. S., & P. Deb (2005) "Is Prenatal Care Really Ineffective? Or, is the 'Devil' in the Distribution?" 24(3) J. of Health Economics 489.
18. Currie, J., & J. Grogger (2000) Medicaid Expansions and Welfare Contractions: Offsetting Effects on Prenatal Care and Infant Health? Working Paper 7667, NBER. Available at http://www.econ.columbia.edu/currie/Papers/Medicaid_Expansions.pdf.
19. Currie, J., & W. B. MacLeod (2008) "First Do No Harm? Tort Reform and Birth Outcomes, " 123 Q. J. of Economics 795.
20. Danzon, P. M. (2000) "Liability for Medial Malpractice, " in A. J. Culver & J. P. Newhouse, eds., Handbook of Health Economics, vol. 1B. Amsterdam: Elsevier North Holland.
21. Danzon, P. M., A. Epstein, & S. Johnson (2004) The "Crisis" in Medical Malpractice Insurance, Brookings-Wharton Papers on Financial Services. Available at http://hc.wharton.upenn.edu/danzon/html/CV%20pubs/2004_DanzonEpsteinJohnson_TheCrisisInMedicalMalpracticeInsurance_%20BrookingsWhartonPapersOnFinancialServices_Chapter.pdf.
22. Dhankhar, P., M. M. Khan, & I. M. S. Alam (2005) Threat of Malpractice Lawsuit, Physician Behavior and Health Outcomes: Testing the Presence of Defensive Medicine. Available at http://www.aeaweb.org/assa/2005/0107_0800_1213.pdf.
23. Donabedian, A. (1988) "Quality Assessment and Assurance: Unity of Purpose, Diversity of Means, " 25 Inquiry 173.
24. Dranove, D., & Y. Watanabe (2010) "Influence and Deterrence: How Obstetricians Respond to Litigation Against Themselves and Their Colleagues, " 12 American Law & Economics Rev. 69.
25. Dubay, L., R. Kaestner, & T. Waidmann (1999) "The Impact of Malpractice Fears on Cesarean Section Rates, " 18 J. of Health Economics 491.
26. Eden, R. D., & and F. H. Boehm, eds. (1990) Assessment and Care of the Fetus: Physiological, Clinical and Medicolegal Principles. Norwalk, CT: Appleton and Lange.
27. Finster, M., & M. Wood (2005) "The Apgar Score Has Survived the Test of Time, " 102(4) Anesthesiology 855.
28. Fiscella, K. (1995) "Does Prenatal Care Improve Birth Outcomes? A Critical Review, " 85(3) Obstetrics & Gynecology 468.
29. Flamm, B. L. (1997) "Once a Cesarean, Always a Controversy, " 90 Obstetrics & Gynecology 312.
30. Fortney, J., K. M. Rost, M. Zhang, & J. Pyne (2001) "The Relationship Between Quality and Outcomes in Routine Depression Care, " 52(1) Psychiatric Services 56.
31. Fraser, A. M., J. E. Brockert, & R. H. Ward (1995) "Association of Young Maternal Age with Adverse Reproductive Outcomes, " 332 New England J. of Medicine 1113.
32. Gawande, A. A., M. R. Kwaan, S. E. Regenbogen, S. A. Lipsitz, & M. J. Zinner (2007) "An Apgar Score for Surgery, " 204(2) J. of the American College of Surgeons 201.
33. Goldenberg, R. L., & L. V. Klerman (1995) "Adolescent Pregnancy: Another Look, " 332 New England J. of Medicine 1161.
34. Grant, D., & M. M. McInnes (2004) "Malpractice Experience and the Incidence of Cesarean Delivery: A Physician-Level Longitudinal Analysis, " 41 Inquiry 170.
35. Gudmundsson, S., L. Björgvinsdóttir, J. Molin, G. Gunnarsson, & K. Marsal (1997) "Socioeconomic Status and Perinatal Outcome According to Residence Area in the City of Malmo, " 76(4) Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica 318.
36. Guise, J.-M., M. Berlin, M. McDonagh, P. Osterweil, B. Chan, & M. Helfand (2004) "Safety of Vaginal Birth After Cesarean: A Systematic Review, " 103 Obstetrics & Gynecology 420.
37. Hack, M., N. K. Klein, & H. G. Taylor (1995) "Long-Term Developmental Outcomes of Low Birth Weight Infants, " 5(1) Future Child 176.
38. Harer, W. B. (2002) "Vaginal Birth After Cesarean Delivery: Current Status, " 287 J. of the American Medical Association 2627.
39. Harvard Medical Practice Study (1990) Patients, Doctors, and Lawyers: Medical Injury, Malpractice Litigation, and Patient Compensation in New York. Report of the Harvard Medical Practice Study to the State of New York. Cambridge, MA: President & Fellows of Harvard College.
40. Hosono, S., T. Ohno, H. Kimoto, M. Shimizu, & K. Harada (2006) "Morbidity and Mortality of Infants Born at the Threshold of Viability: Ten Years' Experience in a Single Neonatal Intensive Care Unit, 1991-2000, " 48(1) Pediatric International 33.
41. Institute of Medicine (1994) "Prenatal Care and Low Birthweight: Effects on Health Care Expenditures, " in Preventing Low Birthweight, pp. 212-37. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
42. Institute of Medicine (2000) To Err is Human: Building a Safer Health System. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
43. Institute of Medicine (2007) Preterm Birth: Causes, Consequences, and Prevention. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
44. Janssen, P.A., S. K. Lee, E. M. Ryan, D. J. Etches, D. F. Farquharson, D. Peacock, & M. C. Klein (2002) "Outcomes of Planned Home Births Versus Planned Hospital Births After Regulation of Midwifery in British Columbia, " 166(3) Canadian Medical Association J. 315.
45. Johnson, K. C., & B. A. Daviss (2005) "Outcomes of Planned Home Births with Certified Professional Midwives: Large Prospective Study in North America, " 330(7505) British Medical J. 1416.
46. Joseph, K. S., A. C. Allen, L. Dodds, L. A. Turner, S. Scott, & R. Liston (2005) "The Perinatal Effects of Delayed Childbearing, " 105 Obstetrics & Gynecology 1410.
47. Kachalia, A. B., David Studdert, Troyen Brennan, & Michelle Mello (2008) "Beyond Negligence: Avoidability and Medical Injury Compensation, " 66 Social Science & Medicine 387.
48. Kaestner, R. (1999) "Health Insurance, the Quantity and Quality of Prenatal Care, and Infant Health, " 36 Inquiry 162.
49. Keeton, W. P., D. B. Dobbs, R. E. Keeton, & D. G. Owen (1984) Prosser and Keeton on Torts, 5th ed. St. Paul, MN: West Publishing.
50. Kessler, D. P., & M. McClellan (1996) "Do Doctors Practice Defensive Medicine?" 111 Q. J. of Economics 353.
51. Kessler, D. P., & M. McClellan (1997) "The Effects of Malpractice Pressure and Liability Reforms on Physicians' Perceptions of Medical Care, " 60 Law & Contemporary Problems 81.
52. Kotelchuck, M. (1994) "An Evaluation of the Kessner Adequacy of Prenatal Care Index and a Proposed Adequacy of Prenatal Care Utilization Index, " 84 American J. of Public Health 1414.
53. Lee, K. S., B. Khoshnood, S. Sriram, H. L. Hsieh, & J. Singh (1998) "Relationship of Cesarean Delivery to Lower Birth Weight-Specific Neonatal Mortality in Singleton, " 92(5) Obstetrics & Gynecology 769.
54. Localio, A. R., A. G. Lawthers, J. M. Bengtson, L. E. Hebert, S. L. Weaver, T. A. Brennan, & J. R. Landis (1993) "Relationship Between Malpractice Claims and Cesarean Delivery, " 269 J. of the American Medical Association 366.
55. Malloy, M. H., L. Onstad, & E. Wright (1991) "The Effect of Cesarean Delivery on Birth Outcome in Very Low Birth Weight Infants. National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Neonatal Research Network, " 77(4) Obstetrics & Gynecology 498.
56. Martin, J. A., B. E. Hamilton, P. D. Sutton, S. J. Ventura, F. Menacker, & M. L. Munson (2005) "Births: Final Data for 2003, " 54(2) National Vital Statistics Reports.
57. McDuffie, R. S. Jr., A. Beck, K. Bischoff, J. Cross, & M. Orleans (1996) "Effect of Frequency of Prenatal Care Visits on Perinatal Outcome Among Low-Risk Women: A Randomized Controlled Trial, " 275 J. of the American Medical Association 847.
58. Mello, M. M. (2006) Medical Malpractice: Impact of the Crisis and Effect of State Tort Reforms. Princeton, NJ: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. Available at http://www.rwjf.org/publications/synthesis/reports_and_briefs/issue10.html.7
59. Mello, M. M., & T. A. Brennan (2002) "Deterrence of Medical Errors: Theory and Evidence for Malpractice Reform, " 80 Texas Law Rev. 1595.
60. Mello, M. M., & D. M. Studdert (2008) "Deconstructing Negligence: The Role of Individual and System Factors in Causing Medical Injury, " 96(2) Georgetown Law J. 600.
61. Mello, M. M., D. M. Studdert, E. J. Thomas, C. Yoon, & T. A. Brennan (2007) "Who Pays for Medical Errors? An Analysis of Adverse Event Costs, the Medical Liability System, and Incentives for Patient Safety Improvement, " 4(4) J. of Empirical Legal Studies 835.
62. National Association of Insurance Commissioners (19932004) Market Share Reports for Groups and Companies: Medical Malpractice. Available at http://www.naic.org/store_pub_statistical.htm "market_share" http://www.naic.org/store_pub_statistical.htm#market_share.
63. National Center for Health Statistics (19912002) Natality Detail File. Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health Statistics.
64. Overholser, J. C. (1990) Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. A Review of the Disorder, 20 J. of Contemporary Psychotherapy 163.
65. Pang, W. Y., J. D. Heffelfinger, G. J. Huang, T. J. Benedetti, & N. S. Weiss (2002) Outcomes of Planned Home Births in Washington State: 1989-1996, 100(2) Obstetrics & Gynecology 253.
66. Pauly, M. V. (2006) Who Pays When Malpractice Premiums Rise? in W. M. Sage & R. Kersh, eds., Medical Malpractice and the U.S. Health Care System. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.
67. Peterson, E. D., etal. (2006) Association Between Hospital Process Performance and Outcomes Among Patients with Acute Coronary Syndromes, 295 J. of the American Medical Association 1912.
68. Phelan, J. C., & B. G. Link (2003) When Income Affects Outcome: Socioeconomic Status and Health, 6 Research in Profile.
69. Picaud, A., R. Nlome-Nze, N. Ogowet-Igumu, A. Faye, & L. Mba Allo (1989) Perinatal and Maternal Risks in Multiple Pregnancies, 84 Revue Francaise de Gynecologie et d Obstetrique 381.
70. Quinn, R. (1998)Medical Malpractice Insurance: The Reputation Effect and Defensive Medicine, 65(3) J. of Risk & Insurance 467.
71. Raatikainenl, K., etal. (2006) Good Outcome of Teenage Pregnancies in High-Quality Maternity Care, " 16(2) European J. of Public Health 157.
72. Rock, S. M. (1988) "Malpractice Premiums and Primary Cesarean Section Rates in New York and Illinois, " 103 Public Health Reports 459.
73. Sloan, F., & R. R. Bovbjerg (1989) "Effects of Tort Reforms on the Value of Closed Medical Malpractice Claims: A Microanalysis, " 14 J. of Health Politics, Policy & Law 663.
74. Sloan, F., C. A. Mathews, C. J. Conover, & W. M. Sage (2005) "Public Medical Malpractice Insurance: An Analysis of State-Operated Patient Compensation Funds, " 54 DePaul Law Rev. 247.
75. Sloan, F., K. Whetten-Goldstein, P. Githens, & S. Entman (1995) "Effects of the Threat of Medical Malpractice Litigation and Other Factors on Birth Outcomes, " 33(7) Medical Care 700.
76. Smarr, L. (1997) "A Comparative Assessment of the PIAA Data Sharing Project and the National Practitioner Data Bank: Policy, Purpose, and Application, " 60 Law & Contemporary Problems 59.
77. Studdert, D. M., & Troyen Brennan (2001) "No-Fault Compensation for Medical Injuries: The Prospect for Error Prevention, " 286(2) J. of the American Medical Association 217.
78. Studdert, D. M., M. M. Mello, C. M. DesRoches, J. Peugh, K. Zapert, T. A. Brennan, & W. M. Sage (2005) "Defensive Medical Practice by Physicians at High Risk of Malpractice Litigation, " 293 J. of the American Medical Association 2609.
79. Studdert, D. M., M. J. Spittal, M. M. Mello, A. J. O'Malley, & D. G. Stevenson (2011) "Relationship Between Quality of Care and Negligence Litigation in Nursing Homes, " 364 New England J. of Medicine 1243.
80. Thorpe, K. E. (2004) "The Medical Malpractice 'Crisis': Recent Trends and the Impact of State Tort Reforms, " January-June Health Affairs, Suppl Web Exclusives.
81. Tough, S. C., C. Newburn-Cook, D. W. Johnston, L. W. Svenson, S. Rose, & J. Belik (2002) "Delayed Childbearing and its Impact on Population Rate Changes in Lower Birth Weight, Multiple Birth, and Preterm Delivery, " 109 Pediatrics 399.
82. Tu, H. T., & P. B. Ginsburg (2006) Losing Ground: Physician Income, 1995-2003, Center for Studying Health System Change, Tracking Report 15. Available at http://www.hschange.com/CONTENT/851/851.pdf.
83. Tussing, A. D., & M. A. Wojtowycz (1992) "The Cesarean Decision in New York State, 1986: Economic and Noneconomic Aspects, " 30 Medical Care 529.
84. Warner, R. H., & H. L. Rosett (1975) "The Effects of Drinking on Offspring. An Historical Survey of the American and British Literature, " 36 J. of Studies on Alcohol & Drugs 1395.
85. Waters, T. M., D. M. Studdert, T. A. Brennan, E. J. Thomas, O. Almagor, M. Mancewicz, & P. P. Budetti (2003) "Impact of the National Practitioner Data Bank on Resolution of Malpractice Claims, " 40(3) Inquiry 283.
86. Windridge, K. C., & J. C. Berryman (1999) "Women's Experience of Giving Birth After 35, " 26 Birth 16.
87. Yang, Y. T., M. M. Mello, S. V. Subramanian, & D. S. Studdert (2009) "Relationship Between Malpractice Litigation Pressure and Rates of Cesarean Section and Vaginal Birth After Cesarean Section, " 47(2) Medical Care 234.
88. Yang, Y. T., D. S. Studdert, S. V. Subramanian, & M. M. Mello (2008) "A Longitudinal Analysis of the Impact of Liability Pressure on the Supply of Obstetrician-Gynecologists, " 5(1) J. of Empirical Legal Studies 21.
89. Yates, J., H. Tankersley, & P. Brace (2009) "Assessing the Impact of State Judicial Structures on Citizen Litigiousness, " Political Research Q. Available at http://law.bepress.com/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3640&context=expresso).
90. Zuckerman, S., S. Norton, & B. Wadler (1992) A State-Based Survey of Malpractice Premiums: Implications for Medicare Physician Payment Policy, Working Paper 6090-02, Urban Institute, Washington, DC.