Making it Count: A Review of the Value and Techniques for Public Consultation

Journal of Planning Literature

Volumn 27, Issue 1, 2012, Pages 22-42

  Shipley, Robert ^a   Utz, Stephen ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF WATERLOO   (Canada)

^b Town of Cochrane   (Canada)

Author keywords

citizen public participation

Indexed keywords

LOCAL PARTICIPATION; PLANNING THEORY;

EID: 84861837635     PISSN: 08854122     EISSN: 15526593     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0885412211413133     Document Type: Review

References (163)

1. Adams Brian."Public Meetings and the Democratic Process.".Public Administration Review. 2004;64:43-54.
2. Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct. 2005:.
3. Al-Kodmany Kheir."Public Participation: Technology and Democracy.".Journal of Architectural Education. 2000;53:220-28.
4. Al-Kodmany Kheir."Visualization Tools and Methods in Community Planning: From Freehand Sketches to Virtual Reality.".Journal of Planning Literature. 2002;17:189-211.
5. Anderson Jon."Talk to the Hand? Community Councils and Planning Consultation.".Planning Theory. 2008;7:284-300.
6. Anderson R."Public Participation in Hazardous Waste Facility Location Decisions.Journal of Planning Literature. 1986;1 (145): 161.
7. Arnstein Sherry R."A Ladder of Citizen Participation.".Journal of the American Institute of Planners. 1969;35:216-24.
8. Austin JamesThe Collaboration Challenge. New York, NY: Jossey-Bass; 2000:.
9. Bailey Nick."Understanding Community Empowerment in Urban Regeneration and Planning in England: Putting Policy and Practice in Context.".Planning Practice & Research. 2010;25:317-32.
10. Baker Mark,Coaffee Jon,Sherriff Graeme."Achieving Successful Participation in the New UK Spatial Planning System.".Planning Practice & Research. 2007;22:79-93.
11. Barreto Matt A.,Manzano Sylvia,Ramírez Ricardo,Rim Kathy."Mobilization, Participation, and Solidaridad: Latino Participation in the 2006 Immigration Protest Rallies.".Urban Affairs Review. 2009;44:736-64.
12. Batson C. Daniel,Ahmad Nadia,Tsang Jo-Ann."Four Motives for Community Involvement.".Journal of Social Issues. 2002;58:429-45.
13. Beebeejaun Yasminah,Vanderhoven David."Informalizing Participation: Insights from Chicago and Johannesburg.".Planning Practice & Research. 2010;25:283-96.
14. Ben-Joseph Eran,Ishii Hiroshi,Underkoffler John,Piper Ben,Yeung Luke."Urban Simulation and the Luminous Planning Table: Bridging the Gap Between the Digital and the Tangible.".Journal of Planning Education and Research. 2001;21:196-203.
15. Berman Evan M."Dealing with Cynical Citizens.".Public Administration Review. 1997;57:105-12.
16. Bickerstaff Karen,Walker Gordon."Shared Visions, Unholy Alliances: Power, Governance and Deliberative Processes in Local Transport Planning.".Urban Studies. 2005;42:2123-44.
17. Bloomfield D.,Collins K.,Fry C.,Munton R."Deliberation and Inclusion: Vehicles for Increasing Trust in UK Public Governance.".Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy. 2001;19:501-13.
18. Bonafede Giulia,Piccolo Francesco Lo."Participative Planning Processes in the Absence of the (Public) Space of Democracy.".Planning Practice & Research. 2010;25:353-75.
19. Booth C."Gender and Public Consultation: Case Studies of Leicester, Sheffield and Birmingham.".Planning Practice & Research. 1996;11:9-18.
20. Brody S. D,Godschalk D. R.,Burby R. J."Mandating Citizen Participation in Plan Making: Six Strategic Planning Choices.".Journal of the American Planning Association. 2003;69:86-95.
21. Brooks M. P.Planning Theory For Practitioners. Chicago, IL: APA Planners Press; 2002:.
22. Brownill Sue,Carpenter Juliet."Increasing Participation in Planning: Emergent Experiences of the Reformed Planning System in England.".Planning Practice & Research. 2007;22:619-34.
23. Brownill Sue,Parker Gavin."Why Bother with Good Works? The Relevance of Public Participation(s) in Planning in a Post-collaborative Era.".Planning Practice & Research. 2010;25:275-82.
24. Bryan Frank M."Real Democracy: The New England Town Meeting and how it Works.".Theoria: A Journal of Social and Political Theory. 2005;107:119-24.
25. Burby J."Making Plans that Matter: Citizen Involvement and Government Action.".Journal of the American Planning Association. 2003;69:33-49.
26. Citizen Participation in Metro Toronto: Climate for Cooperation?. Toronto: Bureau of Municipal Research Civic Affairs; 1974:.
27. Burroughs Richard."When Stakeholders Choose: Process, Knowledge, and Motivation in Water Quality Decisions.".Society and Natural Resources. 1999;12:797-809.
28. Cabinet Office, 2005. Code of Practice on Consultation. https://www.wbginvestmentclimate.org/uploads/2.Code.pdf(Accessed November 22, 2011).
29. Campbell H.,Marshall R."Public Involvement in Planning: Looking Beyond the One to the Many.".International Planning Studies. 2000;5:321-44.
30. Chipeniuk R."Public Explanations for Environmental Degradation in a Sustainable Land Use Planning Exercise.".Landscape and Urban Planning. 1999;45:93-106.
31. CIP (Canadian Institute of Planners). 2004. "Code of Professional Practice."Accessed May 15, 2011. http://www.cip-icu.ca/web/la/en/fi/D99A54FB1E41489B9477902D35AF9BBB/get_file.asp.
32. Clary E. Gil,Snyder Mark."Community Involvement: Opportunities and Challenges in Socializing Adults to Participate in Society.".The Journal of Social Issues. 2002;58:581-91.
33. Connelly Steve."Participation in a Hostile State: How do Planners Act to Shape Public Engagement in Politically Difficult Environments?".Planning Practice & Research. 2010;25:333-51.
34. Connick Sarah,Innes Judith E."Outcomes of Collaborative Water Policy Making: Applying Complexity Thinking to Evaluation.".Journal of Environmental Planning and Management. 2003;46:177-97.
35. Conroy Maria Manta,Berke Philip R."What Makes a Good Sustainable Development Plan? An Analysis of Factors that Influence Principles of Sustainable Development.".Environment and Planning A. 2004;34:1381.
36. Conroy M. M.,Evans-Cowley J."Informing and Interacting: The Use of E-Government for Citizen Participation in Planning.".Journal of E-Government. 2005;1:73-92.
37. Conroy M. M.,Gordon S. I."Utility of Interactive Computer Based Materials for Enhancing Public Participation.".Environmental Planning and Management. 2004;47:19-33.
38. Creighton J. L.The Public Involvement Manual. Cambridge, MA: Abt Books; 1981:.
39. Crosby Ned,Kelly Janet M.,Schaefer Paul."Citizens Panels: A New Approach to Citizen Participation.".Public Administration Review. 1986;46:170-8.
40. Davidoff PThe City Reader. Legates S.Stout F., ed. New York: Routledge; 2003:.
41. Davies B. B.,Blackstock K.,Rauschmayer F."'Recruitment', 'Composition', and 'Mandate' Issues in Deliberative Processes: Should We Focus on Arguments Rather Than Individuals.".Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy. 2005;23:599-615.
42. Day Diane."Citizen Participation in the Planning Process: An Essentially Contested Concept?".Journal of Planning Literature. 1997;11:421-34.
43. Dekker Karien,Van Kempen Ronald."Participation, Social Cohesion and the Challenges in the Governance Process: An Analysis of a Post-World War II Neighbourhood in the Netherlands.".European Planning Studies. 2009;17:109-30.
44. Duram Leslie A.,Brown Katharin G."Assessing Public Participation in U.S Watershed Planning Initiatives.".Society and Natural Resources. 1999;12:455-67.
45. Elbanna S."Planning and Participation as Determinants of Strategic Planning Effectiveness: Evidence from the Arabic Context.".Management Decision. 2008;46:779-96.
46. Ellis Geraint."Discourses of Objection: Towards an Understanding of Third-Party Rights in Planning.".Environment and Planning A. 2004;36:1549-70.
47. Enserink B,Koppenjan J."Public Participation in China: Sustainable Urbanization and Governance.".Management of Environmental Quality: An International Journal. 2007;18:459-74.
48. Evans-Cowley Jennifer,Hollander Justin."The New Generation of Public Participation: Internet-Based Participation Tools.".Planning Practice & Research. 2010;25:397-408.
49. Filion P.,Shipley R.,Te Z."Works Planners Read: Findings from a Canadian Survey.".Canadian Journal of Urban Research. 2007;16:59-91.
50. Forester John."Bridging Interests and Community: Advocacy Planning and the Challenges of Deliberative Democracy.".Journal of the American Planning Association. 1994;60:153-58.
51. Foster-Fishman Pennie G.,Pierce Steven J.,Van Egeren Laurie A."Who Participates and why: Building a Process Model of Citizen Participation.".Health Education & Behavior. 2009;36:550-69.
52. Fourniau J. M.Concertation, Décision, Environnement, Volume II. Billé R.Mermet L., ed. Paris, la Documentation Française: Actes du Séminaire Semestriel; 2003:.
53. Frank Kathryn I."The Potential of Youth Participation in Planning.".Journal of Planning Literature. 2006;20:351-71.
54. Frisken F. J.,Homenuck H. P. M.Citizen Participation: Views and Alternatives. Toronto: York University; 1972:.
55. Gandy Oscar H."Public Opinion Surveys and the Formation of Privacy Policy.".Journal of Social Issues. 2003;59:283-99.
56. Gedikli Bahar."The Role of Leadership in the Success of Participatory Planning Processes: Experience from Turkey.".European Urban and Regional Studies. 2009;16:115-30.
57. Geertman S."Participatory Planning and GIS: A PSS to Bridge the Gap.".Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design. 2002;29:21-35.
58. Gerber Elisabeth R.,Phillips Justin H."Evaluating the Effects of Direct Democracy on Public Policy: California's Urban Growth Boundaries.".American Politics Research. 2005;33:310-30.
59. Goodlad R."Tenant Participation in Scotland: Experience and Prospects.".Community Development Journal. 1988;23:243-48.
60. Goodlad R.,Burton P.,Croft J."Effectiveness at What? The Processes and Impact of Community Involvement in Area-Based Initiatives.".Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy. 2005;23:923-38.
61. Gordon Eric,Koo G."Placeworlds: Using Virtual Worlds to Foster Civic Engagement.".Space and Culture. 2008;11:204-21.
62. Gray BarbaraCollaborating: Finding Common Ground for Multiparty Problems; Foreword by Eric Trist. New York, NY: Macmillan; 1989:.
63. Greenbaum Thomas L.The Handbook for Focus Group Research. New York, NY: Lexington Books/Macmillan; 1993:.
64. Gregory Robin,McDaniels Tim,Fields Daryl."Decision Aiding, not Dispute Resolution: Creating Insights Through Structured Environmental Decisions.".Journal of Policy Analysis and Management. 2001;20:415-32.
65. Guaraldo Choguill M. B."A Ladder of Community Participation for Underdeveloped Countries.".Habitat international. 1996;20:431-44.
66. Gunton T. I.,Peter T.,Day J. C."Evaluating Collaborative Planning: A Case Study of a Land and Resource Management Planning Process.".Environments-A Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies. 2007;34:19-37.
67. Halvorsen Kathleen E."Assessing the Effects of Public Participation.".Public Administration Review. 2003;63:535-43.
68. Harrill Rich."Residents' Attitudes Toward Tourism Development: A Literature Review with Implications for Tourism Planning.".Journal of Planning Literature. 2004;18:251-66.
69. Hatzilacou Dionyssia,Kallis Giorgos,Mexa Alexandra."Scenario Workshops: A Useful Method for Participatory Water Resources Planning?".Water Resources Research. 2007;43:1-12.
70. Healey P."Building Institutional Capacity Through Collaborative Approaches to Urban Planning.".Environment and Planning A. 1998;30:1531-46.
71. Helling Amy."Collaborative Visioning: Proceed with Caution! Results from Evaluating Atlanta's Vision 2020 Project.".Journal of the American Planning Association. 1998;64:335-49.
72. Hester RandyDesign for Ecological Democracy. Boston: MIT Press; 2006:.
73. Hollander J. A."The Social Contexts of Focus Groups.".Journal of Contemporary Ethnography. 2004;33:602-37.
74. Hollander J. B.,Thomas D."Virtual Planning: "Second Life" and the Online Studio.".Journal of Planning Education and Research. 2009;29:108-13.
75. Iannaccone Laurence R.,Everton Sean F."Never on Sunny Days: Lessons From Weekly Attendance Counts.".Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion. 2004;43:191-207.
76. IAP2 (International Association of Public Participation). 2010a. International Association of Public Participation. Accessed February 23, 2010. http://iap2.civicore.com/.
77. IAP2 (International Association of Public Participation). 2010b. International Association of Public Participation. Accessed February 25, 2010. http://www.dse.vic.gov.au/DSE/wcmn203.nsf/LinkView/FD9BEDEC51850213CA25706700054ECFA385F9180FF7023FCA25707C0006DE06.
78. Innes Judith ESocial Planning: Classics in Planning. Poon Jessie P. H.Button KennethNijkamp Peter, ed. Cheltenham, UK: Elgar; 1996 2006:445-57.
79. Innes Judith E.,Booher David E."Reframing Public Participation: Strategies for the 21st Century.".Planning Theory and Practice. 2004;5:419-36.
80. Innes Judith E.,Booher David E.Planning with Complexity: An Introduction to Collaborative Rationality for Public Policy. Abingdon, UK: Routledge; 2010:.
81. Irazábal Clara."Realizing Planning's Emancipatory Promise: Learning from Regime Theory to Strengthen Communicative Action.".Planning Theory. 2009;8:115-39.
82. Irvin Renée A.,Stansbury John."Citizen Participation in Decision Making: Is it Worth the Effort?".Public Administration Review. 2004;64:55-65.
83. Kaatz E.,Root D.,Bowen P."Broadening Project Participation Through a Modified Building Sustainability Assessment.".Building Research & Information. 2005;33:441-54.
84. Kallis Giorgos,Hatzilacou Dionyssia,Mexa Alexandra,Coccossis Harry,Svoronou Eleni."Beyond the Manual: Practicing Deliberative Visioning in a Greek Island.".Ecological Economics. 2009;68:979-89.
85. Kallis G.,Videira N.,Antunes P.,Pereira A. G.,Spash C. L.,Coccossis H.,Quintana S. C.,del Moral L.,Hatzilacou D.,Logo G.,Mexa A.,Paneque P.,Mateos B. P.,Santos R."Participatory Methods for Water Resources Planning.".Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy. 2006;24:215-34.
86. Kamete Amin Y."For Enhanced Civic Participation in Local Governance": Calling Tyranny to Account in Harare.".Environment & Urbanization. 2009;21:59-75.
87. Kathlene Lyn,Martin John A."Enhancing Citizen Participation: Panel Designs, Perspectives, and Policy Formation.".Journal of Policy Analysis and Management. 1991;10:46-63.
88. Kaufman J.,Jacobs M."A Public Planning Perspective on Strategic Planning.".Journal of the American Planning Association. 1987;53:23-32.
89. Kenyon W."A Critical Review of Citizens' Juries: How Useful are they in Facilitating Public Participation in the EU Water Framework Directive?".Journal of Environmental Planning and Management. 2005;48:431-43.
90. King Cheryl Simrell,Feltey Kathryn M.,O'Neill Susel Bridget."The Question of Participation: Toward Authentic Public Participation in Public Administration.".Public Administration Review. 1998;58:317-26.
91. Klein W.,Benson V.,Andersen J.,Herr P."Vision of Things to Come.".Planning. 1993;59:10-5.
92. Knowles-Yánez Kimberley L."Children's Participation in Planning Processes.".Journal of Planning Literature. 2005;20:3-14.
93. Lauber T. Bruce,Knuth Barbara A.Measuring Fairness in Citizen Participation: A Case Study of Moose Management.".Society and Natural Resources. 1999;12:19-37.
94. Lilley K."Geometry, Urban Planning and Town Design in the High Middle Ages.".Planning History. 1998;20:7-15.
95. Lindsay K. M.,Smith D. W."Evaluation of British Columbia ministry of Forests Aboriginal Rights and Title-Consultation Guidelines-The Ditidaht Case Study.".Environmental Engineering and Policy. 2001;2:191-201.
96. London SCollaboration and Community. 1995:.
97. Macpherson L."Joystick Not Included: New Media Technologies are Ideal Tools for Gaining Stakeholder Interest, Acceptance.".Water Environment & Technology. 1999;11:51-3.
98. Manzo Lynne C.,Perkins Douglas D."Finding Common Ground: The Importance of Place Attachment to Community Participation and Planning.".Journal of Planning Literature. 2006;20:335-50.
99. Margerum Richard D."Evaluating Collaborative Planning: Implications from an Empirical Analysis of Growth Management.".Journal of the American Planning Association. 2002;68:179-94.
100. McCool S. F.,Guthrie K."Mapping the Dimensions of Successful Public Participation in Messy Natural Resources Management Situations.".Society and Natural Resources. 2001;14:309-23.
101. McMillan Bill,Stephen MurgatroydOpening the Door: Improving Decisions Through Public Consultation. 1994:.
102. Michaels S.,Mason R. J.,Solecki W. D."Participatory Research on Collaborative Environmental Management: Results from the Adirondack Park.".Society and Natural Resources. 2001;14:251-5.
103. Michel James HDevelopment co-operation, 1996 report: Efforts and policies of the members of the development assistance committee. 1997:.
104. Mitchell Bruce."Participatory Partnerships: Engaging and Empowering to Enhance Environmental Management and Quality of Life?".Social Indicators Research. 2005;71:123.
105. Morgan David L.Focus Groups As Qualitative Research. 1997. Focus Groups As Qualitative Research. 2nd ed. Vol. 16. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage; 1997:.
106. Morris Elizabeth W."Community in Theory and Practice: A Framework for Intellectual Renewal.".Journal of Planning Literature. 1996;11:127-50.
107. Nadin VincentEuropean Spatial Planning. Faludi A., ed. Toronto: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy; 2002:121-37.
108. Noveck B. S.The State of Play: Law, Games, and Virtual Worlds. New York: New York University Press; 2006:257-82.
109. Noveck B. S."Wiki-Government: How Open-Source Technology can Make Government Decision-Making More Expert and More Democratic.".Democracy: A Journal of Ideas. 2008;7:.
110. Okubo D.The Community Visioning and Strategic Planning Handbook. Denver: The National Civic League; 1997:.
111. A Guide to Community Visioning. Chicago, IL: Planners Press; 1993:.
112. Padgett D. A."Technological Methods for Improving Citizen Participation in Locally Unacceptable Land Use (LULU) Decision-Making.".Computers, Environment and Urban Systems. 1993;17:513-20.
113. Parkin M.,R BadeMicroeconomics: Canada in the Global Environment. 2000. Microeconomics: Canadain the Global Environment. (4th ed.). Toronto: Addison Wesley Longman.Toronto: Addison Wesley Longman; 2000:.
114. Patten S."Democratizing the Institutions of Policy-Making: Democratic Consultation and Participatory Administration.".Journal of Canadian Studies. 2001;35:221-39.
115. Peel Deborah,Lloyd Greg."City-Visions: Visioning and Delivering Scotland's Economic Future.".Local Economy. 2005;20:40-52.
116. Pereira A. G.,Rinaudo P. J.,Blasques J,Quintana S. C.,Courtois N.,Funtowicz S.,Petit V."ICT Tools to Support Public Participation in Water Resources Governance and Planning: Experiences from the Design and Testing of a Multi-Media Platform.".Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management. 2003;5:395-420.
117. Peterman W."Advocacy vs. Collaboration: Comparing Inclusionary Community Planning Models.".Community Development Journal. 2004;39:266-76.
118. Piliavin J.,Grube J.,Callero P."Role as Resource for Action in Public Service.".Journal Of Social Issues. 2002;58 (3): 469-85.
119. Pilliard J. P."Current Trends and Developments: Patterns and Forms of Immigrant Participation and Representation at the Local and National Levels in Western (Continental) Europe.".International Migration. 1986;24:501-13.
120. Planetizen Planners' Web Site. 2010:.
121. Renn Ortwin,Webler Thomas,Wiedemann Peter.Fairness and Competence in Citizen Participation: Evaluating Models of Environmental Discourse. Technology, Risk, and Society Series. 1995;:.
122. Roberts N."Public Deliberation in an Age of Direct Citizen Participation.".American Review of Public Administration. 2004;34:315-53.
123. Robin W.,Brooks R.,Harris G."Citizen Participation, NEPA, and Land-Use Planning in Northern New York, USA.".Environmental Practice. 2008;10:140-51.
124. Community Engagement. 2011:.
125. Rui S.La Démocratie En Débat, Les Citoyens Face À L'action Publique. Paris: Armand Colin; 2004:.
126. Sager ToreCommunicative Planning Theory. Brookfield: Ashgate; 1994:.
127. Santo C.,Ferguso N.,Trippel A."Engaging Urban Youth Through Technology: The Youth Neighborhood Mapping Initiative.".Journal of Planning Education and Research. 2010;30:52-65.
128. Schlossberg Marc,Shuford Elliot."Delineating "Public" and "Participation" in PPGIS.".URISA Journal. 2005;16:15-26.
129. Schooley Shawn E."Appreciative Democracy: The Feasibility of Using Appreciative Inquiry at the Local Government Level by Public Administrators to Increase Citizen Participation.".Public Administration Quarterly. 2008;32:243-81.
130. Sewell J.The Shape of the City: Toronto Struggles with Modern Planning. Toronto: University of Toronto Press; 1993:.
131. Sexton KenBetter Environmental Decisions: Strategies for Governments, Businesses, and Communities. Washington, DC: Island Press; 1999:.
132. Shipley Robert."The Origin and Development of Vision and Visioning in Planning.".International Planning Studies. 2000;5:225-36.
133. Shipley R."Visioning in Planning: Is the Practice Based on Sound Theory?".Environment and Planning A. 2002;34:7-22.
134. Shipley R.,Newkirk R."Vision and Visioning in Planning: What do These Terms Really Mean?".Environment and Planning B-Planning & Design. 1999;26:573-91.
135. Shipley Robert,Feick Robert,Hall Brent,Earley Robert."Evaluating Municipal Visioning.".Planning Practice and Research. 2004;19:195-210.
136. Shipley R.,Feick R."A Practical Approach For Evaluating Cultural Heritage Landscapes: Lessons From Rural Ontario.".Planning Practice and Research. 2009;24:455-69.
137. Shipley Robert,Michela John L."Can Vision Motivate Planning Action?".Planning Practice and Research. 2006;21:223-44.
138. Simon Judy Sharken."How to Conduct Focus Groups".Nonprofit World. 1999;17:40-3.
139. Silverman R."Central City Socio-Economic Characteristics and Public Participation Strategies: A Comparative Analysis of the Niagara Falls Region's Municipalities in the USA and Canada.".International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy. 2006;26:138-53.
140. Sirianni CarmenInvesting in Democracy: Engaging Citizens in Collaborative Governance. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press; 2009:.
141. Smith P. D.,McDonough M. H."Beyond Public Participation: Fairness in Natural Resource Decision Making.".Society and Natural Resources. 2001;14:239-49.
142. Sorensen André,Sagaris Lake."From Participation to the Right to the City: Democratic Place Management at the Neighbourhood Scale in Comparative Perspective.".Planning Practice & Research. 2010;25:297-316.
143. Stewart David W.,Shamdasani Prem N.Focus Groups: Theory and Practice. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage; 1990:.
144. Street Penny."Scenario Workshops: A Participatory Approach to Sustainable Urban Living?".Futures. 1997;29:139-58.
145. Stukas Arthur A.,Dunlap Michelle R."Community Involvement: Theoretical Approaches and Educational Initiatives.The Journal of Social Issues. 2002;58:411-27.
146. Tas Murat,Tas Nilufer,Cahantimur Arzu."A Participatory Governance Model for the Sustainable Development of Cumali{dotless}ki{dotless}zi{dotless}k, a Heritage Site in Turkey.".Environment & Urbanization. 2009;21:161-84.
147. Taylor Marilyn."Community Participation in the Real World: Opportunities and Pitfalls in new Governance Spaces.".Urban Studies. 2007;44:297-317.
148. Thomas J. C.Public Participation in Public Decisions. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass; 1995:.
149. Toal Stacie A.,King Jean A.,Johnson Kelli,Lawrenz Frances."The Unique Character of Involvement in Multi-Site Evaluation Settings.".Evaluation and Program Planning. 2009;32:91-8.
150. Townsend Rebecca M."Town Meeting as a Communication Event: Democracy's act Sequence.".Research on Language and Social Interaction. 2009;42:68-89.
151. Tritter J.,McCallum A."The Snakes and Ladders of User Involvement: Moving Beyond Arnstein.Health Policy. 2006;76:156-68.
152. Tuler Seth,Webler Thomas."Voices From the Forest: What Participants Expect of a Public Participation Process.".Society and Natural Resources. 1999;12:437-53.
153. UNESCO. 2010. World Heritage List, Historical Centre of the City of Yaroslavl. Accessed February 18, 2010. http://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1170.
154. UtzStephen C. 2007. Improving Consultation Measures at the Municipal Level. (thesis).
155. Uyesugi J. L.,Shipley R."Visioning Diversity: Planning Vancouver's Multicultural Communities.".International Planning Studies. 2005;10:305-22.
156. Vogt Dawne S.,King Daniel W.,King Lynda A."Focus Groups in Psychological Assessment: Enhancing Content Validity by Consulting Members of the Target Population.".Psychological Assessment. 2004;16:231-43.
157. Walters Lawrence C.,Aydelotte James,Miller Jessica."Putting More Public in Policy Analysis.".Public Administration Review. 2000;60:349-59.
158. Ward S.Planning the Twentieth Century City. Chichester, UK: Wiley; 2001:.
159. Waterton Claire,Wynne BrianDeveloping Focus Group Research: Politics, Theory and Practice. Barbour Rosaline S.Kitzinger Jenny, ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage; 1999:127-43.
160. Wheeland C."Citywide Strategic Planning: An Evaluation of Rock Hill's Empowering Vision".Public Administration Review. 1993;53:65-72.
161. Yanez Clemente J. Navarro."Participatory Democracy and Political Opportunism: Municipal Experience in Italy and Spain (1960-93).".International Journal of Urban and Regional Research. 2004;28:819-38.
162. Yang Kaifeng."Public Administrators' Trust in Citizens: A Missing Link in Citizen Involvement Efforts.".Public Administration Review. 2005;65:273-85.
163. Zhong L.,Mol A."Participatory Environmental Governance in China: Public Hearings on Urban Water Tariff Setting.".Journal of Environmental Management. 2008;88:899-913.