The sustainability of organic grain production on the Canadian prairies - A review

Sustainability

Volumn 2, Issue 4, 2010, Pages 1016-1034

  Snyder, Crystal ^a   Spaner, Dean ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF ALBERTA   (Canada)

Author keywords

Canada; Conventional agriculture; Grain farming; Organic agriculture; Sustainability

Indexed keywords

EID: 84861215143     PISSN: 20711050     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.3390/su2041016     Document Type: Review

References (92)

1. IFOAM. The IFOAM Basic Norms for Organic Production and Processing Version 2005; Available online: http://www.ifoam.org/about_ifoam/standards/norms/norm_documents_library/Norms_ENG_V4_20090113.pdf (access on 16 January 2010).
2. Willer, H. The world of organic agriculture 2009: Summary. In The World of Organic Agriculture: Statistics and Emerging Trends 2009; Willer, H., Klicher, L., Eds.; IFOAM: Bonn, Germany; FiBL: Frick, Switzerland; ITC: Geneva, Switzerland, 2009; pp. 19-24.
3. Sahota, A. Overview of the Global Market for Organic Food and Drink. In The World of Organic Agriculture: Statistics and Emerging Trends 2004; Willer, H., Yussefi, M., Eds.; International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements: Bonn, Germany, 2004; pp. 21-26.
4. Macey, A. Retail Sales of Certified Organic Food Products in Canada in 2006; Available online: http://www.organicagcentre.ca/Docs/RetailSalesOrganic_Canada2006.pdf (access on 30 December 2009).
5. Canadian Food Inspection Agency. Organic Products; Available online: http://www.inspection. gc.ca/english/fssa/orgbio/orgbioe.shtml (access on 19 December 2009).
6. Kendrick, J. Organic: From Niche to Mainstream (Statistics Canada: Canadian Agriculture at a Glance); Available online: http://www.statcan.gc.ca/bsolc/olc-cel/olc-cel?lang=eng&catno=96-325-X200700010529 (access on 17 January 2010).
7. Entz, M.H.; Guilford, R.; Gulden, R. Crop yield and soil nutrient status on 14 organic farms in the eastern portion of the northern Great Plains. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2001, 81, 351-354.
8. Nelson, A.; Froese, J.; Beavers, R.L. Lowering Soil Erosion Risk in Organic Cropping Systems; Final Research Report W2006-09; Available online: http://www.organicagcentre.ca/Docs/OACC_bulletins06/OACC_Bulletin9_erosion_risk.pdf (access on 26 February 2010).
9. Macrae, R.J.; Frick, B.; Martin, R.C. Economic and social impacts of organic production systems. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2007, 87, 1037-1044.
10. Pimentel, D.; Hepperly, P.; Hanson, J.; Douds, D.; Seidel, R. Environmental, energetic, and economic comparisons of organic and conventional farming systems. Bioscience 2005, 55, 573-582.
11. Khakbazan, M.; Mohr, R.M.; Derksen, D.A.; Monreal, M.A.; Grant, C.A.; Zentner, R.P.; Moulin, A.P.; McLaren, D.L.; Irvine, R.B.; Nagy, C.N. Effects of alternative management practices on the economics, energy and GHG emissions of a wheat-pea cropping system in the Canadian prairies. Soil Till. Res. 2009, 104, 30-38.
12. Pelletier, N.; Arsenault, N.; Tyedmers, P. Scenario Modeling Potential Eco-Efficiency Gains from a Transition to Organic Agriculture: Life Cycle Perspectives on Canadian Canola, Corn, Soy, and Wheat Production. Environ. Manage. 2008, 42, 989-1001.
13. Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada. Sustainable Agriculture: Our Path Forward; Available online: http://www4.agr.gc.ca/AAFC-AAC/display-afficher.do?id=1175533355176&lang=eng (access on 30 December 2009).
14. Rodale Institute. Organic or "Natural"; Available online: http://www.rodaleinstitute.org/organic_or_natural (access on 7 February 2010).
15. IFOAM. Principles of Organic Agriculture; Available online: http://www.ifoam.org/about_ifoam/principles/index.html (access on 16 January 2010).
16. Sustainable Table. The Issues: Organic; Available online: http://www.sustainabletable.org/issues/organic/(access on 7 February 2010).
17. Statistics Canada. Total Area of Farms, Land Tenure and Land in Crops, by Province; Available online: http://www40.statcan.ca/l01/cst01/agrc25a.htm (access on 26 February 2010).
18. Macey, A. Certified Organic Production in Canada, 2004; Available online: http://www.cog.ca/documents/certified_organic_production_2004_report.pdf (access on 26 February 2010).
19. Frick, B.; Beavers, R.L.; Hammermeister, A.M.; Thiessen-Martens, J.R. Research Needs Assessment of Saskatchewan Organic Farmers; Available online: http://www.organicagcentre.ca/Docs/Saskatchewan%20Research%20Needs%20Survey%20with%20cover.pdf (access on 13 December 2009).
20. Organic Agriculture Centre of Canada. Research Needs Assessment of Manitoba Organic Farmers; Available online: http://oacc.info/Docs/Manitoba%20Research%20Needs%20Survey%20Final%20Report_dec08.pdf (access on 13 December 2009).
21. Organic Agriculture Centre of Canada. Research Needs Assessment of Alberta Organic Farmers; Available online: http://www.organicagcentre.ca/Docs/Alberta%20survey%20Nov12.pdf (access on 13 December 2009).
22. Canadian Organic Growers Economics of Organic Farming. In Organic Field Crop Handbook; Wallace, J., Ed.; Canadian Organic Growers: Ottawa, ON, Canada, 2001; pp. 8-10.
23. Mason, H.E.; Spaner, D. Competitive ability of wheat in conventional and organic management systems: A review of the literature. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2006, 86, 333-343.
24. Johnson, E.; Wolf, T.; Caldwell, B.; Barbour, R.; Holm, R.; Sapsford, K. Efficacy of vinegar (acetic acid) as an organic herbicide (ADF Project # 20020202, AAFC Project # A03637); Available online: http://www.agr.gov.sk.ca/apps/adf/adf_admin/reports/20020202.pdf (access on 31 December 2009).
25. Bailey, K.; Johnson, E.; Kutcher, R.; Braaten, C. An Organic Option for Broadleaved Weed Control in Cereals Using a Microbial Herbicide; Interim Report; Organic Sector Market Development Initiative (OSMDI), Canadian Wheat Board: Manitoba, Canada, 2009; Available online: http://www.organicagcentre.ca/Docs/OSMDI%20Oct%202009%20Bailey%20Interim%20Report.pdf (access on 31 December 2009).
26. Lafond, G.P.; Derksen, D.A. Long-term potential of conservation tillage on the Canadian prairies. Can. J. Plant Pathol. 1996, 18, 151-158.
27. Trewavas, A. A critical assessment of organic farming-and-food assertions with particular respect to the UK and the potential environmental benefits of no-till agriculture. Crop Prot. 2004, 23, 757-781.
28. Teasdale, J.R.; Coffman, C.B.; Mangum, R.W. Potential Long-Term Benefits of No-Tillage and Organic Cropping Systems for Grain Production and Soil Improvement. Agron. J. 2007, 99, 1297-1305.
29. Blackshaw, R.E. Tillage intensity affects weed communities in agroecosystems. In Invasive Plants: Ecological and Agricultural Aspects; Inderjit, S., Ed.; Birkhauser Verlag: Basel, Switzerland, 2005; pp. 209-221.
30. Nelson, A. Soil Erosion Risk and Mitigation through Crop Rotation on Organic and Conventional Cropping Systems; M.Sc. Thesis; University of Manitoba: Winnipeg, MB, Canada, 2005.
31. Entz, M.H.; Baron, V.S.; Carr, P.M.; Meyer, D.W.; Smith, S.R.; McCaughey, W.P. Potential of forages to diversify cropping systems in the northern Great Plains. Agron. J. 2002, 94, 240-250.
32. Smil, V. Feeding the World: A Challenge for the Twenty-First Century; The MIT Press: Cambridge, MA, USA, 2000.
33. Wiens, M.J.; Entz, M.H.; Martin, R.C.; Hammermeister, A.M. Agronomic benefits of alfalfa mulch applied to organically managed spring wheat. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2006, 86, 121-131.
34. Malhi, S.S.; Brandt, S.A.; Lemke, R.; Moulin, A.P.; Zentner, R.P. Effects of input level and crop diversity on soil nitrate-N, extractable P, aggregation, organic C and N, and nutrient balance in the Canadian Prairie. Nutr. Cycl. Agroecosyst. 2009, 84, 1-22.
35. Blackshaw, R.E.; Moyer, J.R.; Doram, R.C.; Boswell, A.L. Yellow sweetclover, green manure, and its residues effectively suppress weeds during fallow. Weed Sci. 2001, 49, 406-413.
36. Blackshaw, R.E.; Moyer, J.R.; Doram, R.C.; Boswall, A.L.; Smith, E.G. Suitability of undersown sweetclover as a fallow replacement in semiarid cropping systems. Agron. J. 2001, 93, 863-868.
37. Blackshaw, R.E.; Molnar, L.J.; Moyer, J.R. Suitability of legume cover crop-winter wheat intercrops on the semi-arid Canadian Prairies. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2010, (in press).
38. Moyer, J.R.; Blackshaw, R.E.; Huang, H.C. Effect of sweetclover cultivars and management practices on following weed infestations and wheat yield. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2007, 87, 973-983.
39. O'Donovan, J.T.; Blackshaw, R.E.; Harker, K.N.; Clayton, G.W.; Moyer, J.R.; Dosdall, L.M.; Maurice, D.C.; Turkington, T.K. Integrated approaches to managing weeds in spring-sown crops in western Canada. Crop Prot. 2007, 26, 390-398.
40. O'Donovan, J.T.; Blackshaw, R.E.; Harker, K.N.; Clayton, G.W.; McKenzie, R. Variable crop plant establishment contributes to differences in competitiveness with wild oat among cereal varieties. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2005, 85, 771-776.
41. Nazarko, O.M.; Van Acker, R.C.; Entz, M.H. Strategies and tactics for herbicide use reduction in field crops in Canada: A review. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2005, 85, 457-479.
42. O'Donovan, J.T.; Harker, K.N.; Clayton, G.W.; Newman, J.C.; Robinson, D.; Hall, L.M. Barley seeding rate influences the effects of variable herbicide rates on wild oat. Weed Sci. 2001, 49, 746-754.
43. Blackshaw, R.E.; Beckie, H.J.; Molnar, L.J.; Entz, T.; Moyer, J.R. Combining agronomic practices and herbicides improves weed management in wheat-canola rotations within zero-tillage production systems. Weed Sci. 2005, 53, 528-535.
44. Harker, K.N.; Clayton, G.W.; Blackshaw, R.E.; O'Donovan, J.T.; Stevenson, F.C. Seeding rate, herbicide timing and competitive hybrids contribute to integrated weed management in canola (Brassica napus). Can. J. Plant Sci. 2003, 83, 433-440.
45. Smith, E.G.; Upadhyay, B.M.; Blackshaw, R.E.; Beckie, H.J.; Harker, K.N.; Clayton, G.W. Economic benefits of integrated weed management systems for field crops in the Dark Brown and Black soil zones of western Canada. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2006, 86, 1273-1279.
46. Blackshaw, R.E.; Harker, K.N.; O'Donovan, J.T.; Beckie, H.J.; Smith, E.G. Ongoing development of integrated weed management systems on the Canadian prairies. Weed Sci. 2008, 56, 146-150.
47. Mason, H.; Navabi, A.; Frick, B.; O'Donovan, J.; Spaner, D. Cultivar and seeding rate effects on the competitive ability of spring cereals grown under organic production in northern Canada. Agron. J. 2007, 99, 1199-1207.
48. Beavers, R.L.; Hammermeister, A.M.; Frick, B.; Astatkie, T.; Martin, R.C. Spring wheat yield response to variable seeding rates in organic farming systems at different fertility regimes. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2008, 88, 43-52.
49. Baird, J.M.; Shirtliffe, S.J.; Walley, F.L. Optimal seeding rate for organic production of lentil in the northern Great Plains. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2009, 89, 1089-1097.
50. Baird, J.M.; Walley, F.L.; Shirtliffe, S.J. Optimal seeding rate for organic production of field pea in the northern Great Plains. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2009, 89, 455-464.
51. Kaut, A.H.E.E.; Mason, H.E.; Navabi, A.; O'Donovan, J.T.; Spaner, D. Organic and conventional management of mixtures of wheat and spring cereals. Agron. Sustain. Dev. 2008, 28, 363-371.
52. Pridham, J.C.; Entz, M.H.; Martin, R.C.; Hucl, R.J. Weed, disease and grain yield effects of cultivar mixtures in organically managed spring wheat. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2007, 87, 855-859.
53. Kaut, A.H.E.E.; Mason, H.E.; Navabi, A.; O'Donovan, J.T.; Spaner, D. Performance and stability of performance of spring wheat variety mixtures in organic and conventional management systems in western Canada. J. Agr. Sci. 2009, 147, 141-153.
54. Pridham, J.C.; Entz, M.H. Intercropping spring wheat with cereal grains, legumes, and oilseeds fails to improve productivity under organic management. Agron. J. 2008, 100, 1436-1442.
55. Murphy, K.M.; Dawson, J.C.; Jones, S.S. Relationship among phenotypic growth traits, yield and weed suppression in spring wheat landraces and modern cultivars. Field Crop Res. 2008, 105, 107-115.
56. Mason, H.E.; Navabi, A.; Frick, B.L.; O'Donovan, J.T.; Spaner, D.M. The weed-competitive ability of Canada western red spring wheat cultivars grown under organic management. Crop Sci. 2007, 47, 1167-1176.
57. Mason, H.; Goonewardene, L.; Spaner, D. Competitive traits and the stability of wheat cultivars in differing natural weed environments on the northern Canadian Prairies. J. Agr. Sci. 2008, 146, 21-33.
58. Reid, T.A.; Navabi, A.; Cahill, J.C.; Salmon, D.; Spaner, D. A genetic analysis of weed competitive ability in spring wheat. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2009, 89, 591-599.
59. Reid, T.A.; Yang, R.C.; Salmon, D.F.; Spaner, D. Should spring wheat breeding for organically managed systems be conducted on organically managed land? Euphytica 2009, 169, 239-252.
60. Murphy, K.M.; Campbell, K.G.; Lyon, S.R.; Jones, S.S. Evidence of varietal adaptation to organic farming systems. Field Crop Res. 2007, 102, 172-177.
61. Canadian General Standards Board. Organic Production Systems General Principles and Management Standards; Available online: http://www.organicagcentre.ca/Docs/Cdn_Stds_Principles2006_e.pdf (access on 16 January 2010).
62. Martin, R.C.; Lynch, D.; Frick, B.; van Straaten, P. Phosphorous status on Canadian organic farms. J. Sci. Food Agric. 2007, 87, 2737-2740.
63. Malhi, S.S.; Brandt, S.A.; Ulrich, D.; Lemke, R.; Gill, K.S. Accumulation and distribution of nitrate-nitrogen and extractable phosphorous in the soil profile under various alternative cropping systems. J. Plant Nutr. 2002, 25, 2499-2520.
64. Kabir, Z.; OHalloran, I.P.; Fyles, J.W.; Hamel, C. Seasonal changes of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi as affected by tillage practices and fertilization: Hyphal density and mycorrhizal root colonization. Plant Soil 1997, 192, 285-293.
65. Douds, D.D.; Galvez, L.; Franke-Snyder, M.; Reider, C.; Drinkwater, L.E. Effect of compost addition and crop rotation point upon VAM fungi. Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 1997, 65, 257-266.
66. Brechelt, A. Effect of Different Organic Manures on the Efficiency of Va Mycorrhiza. Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 1990, 29, 55-58.
67. Hamel, C.; Strullu, D.G. Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi in field crop production: Potential and new direction. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2006, 86, 941-950.
68. Nelson, A.; Spaner, D. Cropping systems management, soil microbial communities, and soil biological fertility: A review. In Genetic Engineering, Biofertilisation, Soil Quality and Organic Farming, Sustainable Agriculture Reviews 4; Lichtfouse, E., Ed.; Springer Science+Business Media B.V.: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2010.
69. Clapperton, M.J.; Yin Chan, K.; Larney, F.J. Managing the soil habitat for enhanced biological fertility. In Soil Biological Fertility-A Key to Sustainable Land Use in Agriculture; Abbott, L.K., Murphy, D.V., Eds.; Springer: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2007; pp. 203-222.
70. Welsh, C.; Tenuta, M.; Flaten, D.N.; Thiessen-Martens, J.R.; Entz, M.H. High Yielding Organic Crop Management Decreases Plant-Available but Not Recalcitrant Soil Phosphorus. Agron. J. 2009, 101, 1027-1035.
71. Duval, J. Co-dependency between Organic and Conventional Agriculture: Transient or Long-lasting? Available online: http://www.organicagcentre.ca/Docs/DiscussionPapers09/Codependency%20final%20version.pdf (access on 18 January 2010).
72. Russelle, M.P.; Entz, M.H.; Franzluebbers, A.J. Reconsidering Integrated Crop-Livestock Systems in North America. Agron. J. 2007, 99, 325-334.
73. Entz, M.H.; Hoeppner, J.W.; Wilson, L.; Tenuta, M.; Bamford, K.C.; Holliday, N. Influence of organic management with different crop rotations on selected productivity parameters in a long-term Canadian field study. In Researching Sustainable Systems, Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference on Organic Agriculture, Adeledaide, Australia, 21-23 September 2005.
74. Lynch, D. Environmental impacts of organic agriculture: A Canadian perspective. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2009, 89, 621-628.
75. Hoeppner, J.W.; Entz, M.H.; McConkey, B.G.; Zentner, R.P.; Nagy, C.N. Energy use and efficiency in two Canadian organic and conventional crop production systems. Renew. Agr. Food Syst. 2006, 21, 60-67.
76. Ammann, K. Why farming with high tech methods should integrate elements of organic agriculture. New Biotechnol. 2009, 25, 378-388.
77. Ammann, K. Integrated farming: why organic farmers should use transgenic crops. New Biotechnol. 2008, 25, 101-107.
78. AC Nielsen. Functional Foods and Organics: A Global AC Nielsen Online Survey on Consumer Behavior and Attitudes; Available online: http://it.nielsen.com/trends/2005_cc_functional_organics.pdf.pdf (access on 17 January 2010).
79. West, G.E.; Gendron, C.; Larue, B.; Lambert, R. Consumers' valuation of functional properties of foods: Results from a Canada-wide survey. Can. J. Agr. Econ. 2002, 50, 541-558.
80. Annett, L.E.; Muralidharan, V.; Boxall, P.C.; Cash, S.B.; Wismer, W.V. Influence of health and environmental information on hedonic evaluation of organic and conventional bread. J. Food Sci. 2008, 73, H50-H57.
81. Annett, L.E.; Spaner, D.; Wismer, W.V. Sensory profiles of bread made from paired samples of organic and conventionally grown wheat grain. J. Food Sci. 2007, 72, S254-S260.
82. Mason, H.; Navabi, A.; Frick, B.; O'Donovan, J.; Niziol, D.; Spaner, D. Does growing Canadian Western Hard Red Spring wheat under organic management alter its breadmaking quality? Renew. Agr. Food Syst. 2007, 22, 157-167.
83. Gelinas, P.; Morin, C.; Reid, J.F.; Lachance, P. Wheat cultivars grown under organic agriculture and the bread making performance of stone-ground whole wheat flour. Int. J. Food Sci. Technol. 2009, 44, 525-530.
84. Turmel, M.S.; Entz, M.H.; Bamford, K.C.; Martens, J.R.T. The influence of crop rotation on the mineral nutrient content of organic vs. conventionally produced wheat grain: Preliminary results from a long-term field study. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2009, 89, 915-919.
85. Nelson, A.; Quideau, S.; Frick, B.; Hucl, P.; Thavarajah, D.; Clapperton, J.; Spaner, D. The soil microbial community and grain micronutrient content of wheat grown organically and conventionally. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2010, (submitted).
86. Bourn, D.; Prescott, J. A comparison of the nutritional value, sensory qualities, and food safety of organically and conventionally produced foods. Crit. Rev. Food Sci. 2002, 42, 1-34.
87. Cranfield, J.; Deaton, B.J.; Shellikeri, S. Evaluating Consumer Preferences for Organic Food Production Standards. Can J. Agr. Econ. 2009, 57, 99-117.
88. Smith, E.G.; Clapperton, M.J.; Blackshaw, R.E. Profitability and risk of organic production systems in the northern Great Plains. Rene. Agr. Food Syst. 2004, 19, 152-158.
89. Khakbazan, M.; Grant, C.A.; Irvine, R.B.; Mohr, R.M.; McLaren, D.L.; Monreal, M. Influence of alternative management methods on the economics of flax production in the Black Soil Zone. Can. J. Plant Sci. 2009, 89, 903-913.
90. Degenhardt, R.; Martin, R.; Spaner, D. Organic farming in Central Alberta: Current trends, production constraints and research needs. J. Sustain. Agr. 2005, 27, 153-173.
91. Vanloqueren, G.; Baret, P.V. How agricultural research systems shape a technological regime that develops genetic engineering but locks out agroecological innovations. Res. Policy 2009, 38, 971-983.
92. Love, B.; Spaner, D. Agrobiodiversity: Its value, measurement, and conservation in the context of sustainable agriculture. J. Sustain. Agr. 2007, 31, 53-82.