'Physics envy', cognitive legitimacy or practical relevance: Dilemmas in the evolution of management research in the UK

British Journal of Management

Volumn 22, Issue 3, 2011, Pages 443-456

  Thomas, Howard ^a,b   Wilson, Alexander D ^a,b  

^a Lee Kong Chian School of Business   (Singapore)

^b UNIVERSITY OF WARWICK   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84860388977     PISSN: 10453172     EISSN: 14678551     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-8551.2011.00766.x     Document Type: Article

References (71)

1. AACSB (2007). Final Report of the AACSB International: Impact of Research, p. 51. Tampa, FL: AACSB.
2. Adler, N. J. and A.-W. Harzing (2009). 'When knowledge wins: transcending the sense and nonsense of academic rankings', Academy of Management Learning and Education, 8, pp. 72-95.
3. Antonacopoulou, E. P. (2010). 'Making the business school more "critical": reflexive critique based on phronesis as a foundation for impact', British Journal of Management, 21, pp. S6-S25.
4. Antunes, D. and H. Thomas (2007). 'The competitive (dis)advantages of European business schools', Long Range Planning, 40, pp. 382-404.
5. Baldridge, D. C., S. W. Floyd and L. Markóczy (2004). 'Are managers from Mars and academicians from Venus? Toward an understanding of the relationship between academic quality and practical relevance', Strategic Management Journal, 25, pp. 1063-1074.
6. Barreto, I. and C. Baden-Fuller (2006). 'To conform or to perform? Mimetic behaviour, legitimacy-based groups and performance consequences', Journal of Management Studies, 43, pp. 1559-1581.
7. Bennis, W. G. and J. O'Toole (2005). 'How business schools lost their way', Harvard Business Review, 83, pp. 96-104.
8. Bok, D. C. (2003). Universities in the Marketplace: The Commercialization of Higher Education. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
9. Bones, C. (2009). 'A crisis of confidence?', The Economist, 20 July. Available at.
10. Caswill, C. and R. Wensley (2007). 'Doors and boundaries: a recent history of the relationship between research and practice in UK organizational and management research', Business History, 49, pp. 293-320.
11. Chia, R. and R. Holt (2008). 'The nature of knowledge in business schools', Academy of Management Learning and Education, 7, pp. 471-486.
12. Cooke, A. and V. Galt (2010). The Impact of Business Schools in the UK. Nottingham: Association of Business Schools/Nottingham Business School.
13. Crainer, S. and D. Dearlove (1998). Gravy Training: Inside the World's Top Business Schools. Oxford: Capstone.
14. Currie, G., D. Knights and K. Starkey (2010). 'Introduction: a post-crisis critical reflection on business schools', British Journal of Management, 21, pp. S1-S5.
15. Czarniawska, B. (2009). 'Emerging institutions: pyramids or anthills?', Organization Studies, 30, pp. 423-441.
16. Davies, J. and H. Thomas (2009). 'What do business school deans do? Insights from a UK study', Management Decision, 47, pp. 1396-1419.
17. Dowling, J. and J. Pfeffer (1976). 'Organizational legitimacy', Pacific Soliological Review, 18, pp. 122-136.
18. Engwall, L. and R. Danell (2011). 'Britannia and her business schools', British Journal of Management, 22, pp. 432-442.
19. Ferlie, E., G. McGivern and A. De Moraes (2010). 'Developing a public interest school of management', British Journal of Management, 21, pp. S60-S70.
20. Fiegenbaum, A. and H. Thomas (1995). 'Strategic groups as reference groups: theory, modeling and empirical examination of industry and competitive strategy', Strategic Management Journal, 16, pp. 461-476.
21. Fragueiro, F. and H. Thomas (2011). Strategic Leadership in the Business School: Keeping One Step Ahead. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
22. Franks, Lord (1964). British Business Schools. London: Institute of Management.
23. Gabriel, Y. (2002). 'Essai: on paragrammatic uses of organizational theory a provocation', Organization Studies, 23, pp. 133-151.
24. Grey, C. (2004). 'Reinventing business schools: the contribution of critical management education', Academy of Management Learning and Education, 3, pp. 178-186.
25. Grey, C. (2010). 'Organizing studies: publications, politics and polemic', Organization Studies, 31, pp. 677-694.
26. Higher Education Statistics Agency (1999). 'Table 2e - All HE students by subject of study, domicile and gender 1997/98'. Available at.
27. Higher Education Statistics Agency (2010). 'Table 2e - All HE students by level of study, mode of study, subject of study (#1), domicile and gender 2008/09'. Available at.
28. Ivory, C., P. Miskell, H. Shipton, A. White, K. Moeslein and A. Neely (2006). UK Business Schools: Historical Contexts and Future Scenarios: Summary Report from an EBK/AIM Management Research Forum. London: AIM Research.
29. Jarzabkowski, P. and R. Whittington (2008). 'Directions for a troubled discipline: strategy research, teaching, and practice - introduction to the dialog', Journal of Management Inquiry, 17, pp. 266-268.
30. Jepperson, R. L. (1991). 'Institutions, institutional effects, and institutionalism'. In W. W. Powell and P. J. DiMaggio (eds), The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis, pp. 143-163. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
31. Khurana, R. (2007). From Higher Aims to Hired Hands: The Social Transformation of American Business Schools and the Unfulfilled Promise of Management as a Profession. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
32. Khurana, R. and N. Nohria (2008). 'It's time to make management a true profession', Harvard Business Review, 86, pp. 70-77.
33. Mangematin, V. and C. Baden-Fuller (2008). 'Global contests in the production of business knowledge: regional centres and individual business schools', Long Range Planning, 41, pp. 117-139.
34. McGrath, R. G. (2007). 'No longer a stepchild: how the management field can come into its own', Academy of Management Journal, 50, pp. 1365-1378.
35. McKiernan, P. and S. Masrani (2007). 'The history of the British Academy of Management'. British Academy of Management.
36. McKiernan, P. and D. Wilson (2011). 'Global mimicry: putting strategic choice back on the business school agenda', British Journal of Management, 22, 457-469.
37. Mintzberg, H. (2004). Managers Not MBAs. London: Pearson Education.
38. Parsons, T. (1960). Structure and Process in Modem Societies. Glencoe, IL: Free Press.
39. Pfeffer, J. (2007). 'A modest proposal: how we might change the process and product of managerial research', Academy of Management Journal, 50, pp. 1334-1345.
40. Pfeffer, J. and C. T. Fong (2002). 'The end of business schools? Less success than meets the eye', Academy of Management Learning and Education, 1, pp. 78-95.
41. Pfeffer, J. and G. R. Salancik (1978). The External Control of Organizations: A Resource Dependence Perspective. New York: Harper and Row.
42. Pfeffer, J. and R. I. Sutton (2006). 'Evidence-based management', Harvard Business Review, 84, pp. 62-74.
43. Pfeffer, J. and R. I. Sutton (2007). 'Suppose we took evidence-based management seriously: implications for reading and writing management', Academy of Management Learning and Education, 6, pp. 153-155.
44. Podolny, J. M. (2009). 'The buck stops (and starts) at business school', Harvard Business Review, 87, pp. 62-67.
45. Porac, J. F., H. Thomas and C. Baden-Fuller (2011). 'Competitive groups as cognitive communities: the case of Scottish knitwear manufacturers revisited', Journal of Management Studies., 48, pp. 646-664.
46. Rousseau, D. M. (2006). '2005 presidential address - is there such a thing as "evidence-based management"?', Academy of Management Review, 31, pp. 256-269.
47. Rousseau, D. M. and S. McCarthy (2007). 'Educating managers from an evidence-based perspective', Academy of Management Learning and Education, 8, pp. 84-101.
48. Rynes, S. L. (2006). '"Getting on board" with AMJ: balancing quality and innovation in the review process', Academy of Management Journal, 49, pp. 1097-1102.
49. Saunders, J., V. Wong and C. Saunders (2011). 'The Research evaluation and globalization of business research', British Journal of Management, 22, 401-419.
50. Schoemaker, P. J. H. (2008). 'The future challenges of business: rethinking management education', California Management Review, 50, pp. 119-139.
51. Scott, W. R. and J. W. Meyer (1983). 'The organization of societal sectors'. In J. W. Meyer and W. R. Scott (eds), Organizational Environments: Ritual and Rationality, pp. 129-153. Beverly hills, CA: Sage.
52. Segev, E., A. Raveh and M. Farjoun (1999). 'Conceptual maps of the leading MBA programs in the United States: core courses, concentration areas, and the ranking of the school', Strategic Management Journal, 20, pp. 549-565.
53. Sillince, J. A. A. and A. D. Brown (2009). 'Multiple organizational identities and legitimacy: the rhetoric of police websites', Human Relations, 62, pp. 1829-1856.
54. Starkey, K. and S. Tempest (2009). 'From crisis to purpose', Journal of Management Development, 28, pp. 700-710.
55. Starkey, K. and N. Tiratsoo (2007). The Business School and the Bottom Line. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
56. Suchman, M. C. (1995). 'Managing legitimacy: strategic and institutional approaches', Academy of Management Review, 20, pp. 571-610.
57. The Economist (2007). 'Practically irrelevant?', Economist 28 August. Available at.
58. Thomas, H. (2007). 'Business school strategy and the metrics for success', Journal of Management Development, 26, pp. 33-42.
59. Thomas, H. and X. Li (2009). 'Mapping globally branded business schools: a strategic positioning analysis', Management Decision, 47, pp. 1420-1440.
60. Thomas, H. and A. Wilson (2009). 'An analysis of the environment and competitive dynamics of management research', Journal of Management Development, 28, pp. 668-684.
61. Tranfield, D. and K. Starkey (1998). 'The nature, social organization and promotion of management research: towards policy', British Journal of Management, 9, pp. 341-353.
62. University of Texas at Dallas (2011). 'World wide rankings - UTD top 100 business school research rankings'. Available at.
63. Van de Ven, A. H. (2007). Engaged Scholarship: a Guide for Organizational and Social Research. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
64. Van de Ven, A. and P. Johnson (2006). 'Knowledge for theory and practice', Academy of Management Review, 31, pp. 802-821.
65. Wedlin, L. (2011). 'Going global: rankings as rhetorical devices to construct an international field of management education', Management Learning, 42, pp. 199-218.
66. Wensley, R. (2009). 'Research in UK business schools or management research in the UK?', Journal of Management Development, 28, pp. 718-727.
67. Whitley, R., A. B. Thomas and J. F. Marceau (1981). Masters of Business: The Making of a New Elite? London: Tavistock.
68. Williams, A. P. O. (2010). The History of UK Business and Management Education. Bingley: Emerald.
69. Willmott, H. (1995). 'Managing the academics: commodification and control in the development of university education in the UK', Human Relations, 48, pp. 993-1027.
70. Zammuto, R. (2008). 'Accreditation and the globalization of business', Academy of Management Learning and Education, 7, pp. 256-268.
71. Zucker, L. G. (1987). 'Institutional theories of organization', Annual Review of Sociology, 13, pp. 443-464.