A review of solar photovoltaic levelized cost of electricity

Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews

Volumn 15, Issue 9, 2011, Pages 4470-4482

  Branker, K ^a   Pathak, M J M ^a   Pearce, J M ^a,b  

^a QUEEN S UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^b Michigan Technological University   (United States)

Author keywords

Grid parity; LCOE; Levelized cost; Photovoltaic; Solar economics

Indexed keywords

CONVENTIONAL TECHNOLOGY; ECONOMIC FEASIBILITIES; ELECTRICAL PRICE; ELECTRICITY-GENERATION TECHNOLOGY; GRID ELECTRICITY; GRID PARITY; INDUSTRY EXPERIENCE; LCOE; LEVELIZED COST OF ELECTRICITIES; NUMERICAL EXAMPLE; PHOTOVOLTAIC; SOLAR PHOTOVOLTAICS; SOLAR PVS; SPECIFIC LOCATION; STATE OF THE ART; TEST SENSITIVITY; VARIABLE RANGE;

COSTS; ELECTRIC GENERATORS; ELECTRICITY; GEOGRAPHICAL REGIONS; PHOTOVOLTAIC EFFECTS; SOLAR CONCENTRATORS; SOLAR POWER GENERATION;

SOLAR ENERGY;

EID: 81855226045     PISSN: 13640321     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.rser.2011.07.104     Document Type: Review

References (124)

1. V. Fthenakis, J.E. Mason, and K. Zweibel The technical, geographical, and economic feasibility for solar energy to supply the energy needs of the US Energy Policy 37 2009 387 399
2. B.K. Sovacool, and C. Watts Going completely renewable: is it possible (let alone desirable?) Electric J 22 2009 95 111
3. Renewable Energy Policy Network for the 21st century (REN21). Renewables 2010 global status report. Paris; 2010. p. 1-80.
4. Kirkegaard JF, Hanemann T, Weischer L, Miller M. Toward a sunny future? Global integration in the solar PV Industry, World Resources Institute (WRI) Working Paper Series; May 2010. p. 1-66.
5. J.M. Pearce Photovoltaics - a path to sustainable futures Futures 34 2002 63 674
6. R.E.H. Sims, H. Rogner, and K. Gregory Carbon emission and mitigation cost comparisons between fossil fuel, nuclear and renewable energy resources for electricity generation Energy Policy 31 2003 1315 1326 (Pubitemid 36594762)
7. International Energy Agency (IEA) Energy technology perspectives 2008: scenarios and strategies to 2050 2008 International Energy Agency, IEA/OECD Paris, France p. 1-650
8. Mints P. The 12-step solar program: towards an incentive-less future. Navigant Consulting on ElectoIQ. < http://www.electroiq.com > [accessed 19.01.2011].
9. International Energy Agency (IEA). Technology roadmap - solar photovoltaic energy; October 2010. p. 1-48.
10. G.N. Doty, D.L. McCree, J.M. Doty, and F.D. Doty Deployment prospects for proposed sustainable energy alternatives in 2020 ASME Conference Proceedings 2010, vol. 171 2010 171 182
11. Price S, Margolis R. Solar technologies market report. Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy, US Department of Energy, 2010; January 2008. p. 1-131.
12. Renewable Energy Policy Network for the 21st Century (REN21). Renewables global status report 2009 update, Paris; 2009. p. 1-32.
13. N.R. Jogleka, and E.S. Graber-Lopez A countdown towards solar power at grid parity: policy analysis based on the evolution of price-performance Proceedings of 2008 ISDSI international conference 2008 1 18
14. J. Klein Comparative costs of California Central Station electricity generation: final staff report 2010 California Energy Commission Sacramento, CA p. 1-186
15. C. Yang Reconsidering solar grid parity Energy Policy 38 2010 3270 3273
16. Energy Information Administration (EIA) International energy outlook 2010 2010 US Department of Energy USA p. 1-338
17. Denholm P, Margolis RM, Ong S, Roberts B. Break-even cost for residential photovoltaics in the United States: key drivers and sensitivities. National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) technical report; 2009. p. 1-33.
18. C. Breyer, A. Gerlach, J. Müller, H. Behacker, and A. Milner Grid-parity analysis for EU and US regions and market segments - dynamics of grid-parity and dependence on solar irradiance, local electricity prices and PV progress ratio Proceedings of 24th European photovoltaic solar energy conference 2009 4492 4500
19. S. Hegedus, and A. Luque Achievements and challenges of solar electricity from photovoltaics A. Luque, S. Hegedus, Handbook of photovoltaic science and engineering 2nd ed. 2011 John Wiley and Sons Ltd. 1 38
20. R. Pernick, and C. Wilder Utility solar assessment (USA) study reaching ten percent solar by 2025 2008 Clean Edge, Inc./Co-op. America Foundation p. 1-76 (June)
21. J. Song, R. Boas, C. Bolman, M. Farber, H. Flynn, and M. Meyers True cost of solar power: race to $1/W 2009 Photon Consulting LLC. Boston, MA
22. Brown M. Going for grid parity, BP Global - reports and publications; 12 (2005). p. 6-10. < http://www.bp.com/genericarticle.do?categoryId= 9013609&contentId=7005395 >.
23. Camstar Systems Inc. Chapter 3 - winning profits in the age of continuous innovation - taking the solar industry beyond grid parity. In: Camstar e-Book; 2010. p. 1-34.
24. Pike Research. Global solar energy outlook - solar demand dynamics, cost structures, policy factors, and competitive differentiators for suppliers: market analysis and forecasts. p. 1-67.
25. Black and Veatch Corporation Renewable energy transmission initiative phase 2B: draft report. 2010 RETI Stakeholder Steering Committee Sacramento, CA p. 1-109
26. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), Nuclear Energy Agency/International Energy Agency (OECD/IEA) Projected costs of generating electricity: 2005 update 2005 OECD Publishing Paris, France p. 1-230
27. W. Short, D. Packey, and T. Holt A manual for economic evaluation of energy efficiency and renewable energy technologies 1995 National Renewable Energy Laboratory p. 1-120 (March)
28. P.P. Singh, and S. Singh Realistic generation cost of solar photovoltaic electricity Renewable Energy 35 2010 563 569
29. Cheyney T. Chipping away at levelized costs: SunPods, Sunsonix seek lower solar LCOE in field and fabs, PV-tech.org. < http://international.pv-tech. org/chip-shots-blog/chipping-away-at-levelized-costs-sunpods-sunsonix-seek- lower-solar-lcoe175 > [accessed 1.07.2010].
30. Darling SB, You F, Veselka T, Velosa A. Assumptions and the levelized cost of energy for photovoltaics. Energy Environ Sci 2011: 7 p (Advance article).
31. SolarBuzz.com. Solar electricity global benchmark price indices, December 2010 survey results; 2010. < http://www.solarbuzz.com/SolarIndices.htm >.
32. Velosa A III. What is inside your LCOE assumptions? SEMI PV group - the grid; April 2010. < http://www.pvgroup.org/NewsArchive/ctr-036226 >.
33. Renewable Energy Policy network for the 21st century (REN21). Renewables 2007 global status report, Paris; 2008. p. 1-54.
34. Bandyopadhyay P, Groo A, Hartley M, LeBrun J, Moazed A. Renewable energy for BHP Billiton. Masters thesis, University of Michigan; 2008.
35. Grana P. Demystifying LCOE. RenewableEnergyWorld.com. < http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/rea/blog/post/2010/08/demystifying-lcoe > [accessed 18.08.2010].
36. National Energy Board (NEB). Emerging technologies in electricity generation, a market assessment report; March 2006. p. 1-113.
37. T. Walden Relative costs of electricity generation technologies 2006 Canadian Energy Research Institute, for Canadian Nuclear Association 1-8 (September)
38. R. Wiser, G. Barbose, C. Peterman, and N. Darghouth Tracking the sun - II. Installed costs of PV in the US from 1998-2008 US Department of Energy, Lawrence Livermore Berkley Laboratory 2009 p. 1-50
39. J.M. Pearce, and P.J. Harris Reducing greenhouse gas emissions by inducing energy conservation and distributed generation from elimination of electric utility customer charges Energy Policy 35 2007 6514 6525 (Pubitemid 350028966)
40. Hunt T. True cost of solar energy and other renewables: California case study, ElectoIQ/Renewable Energy Word; 13 December 2010.
41. J. Hutchinson, S. Inwood, R. James, G. Ramachandran, J. Hamel, and C. Libby Program on technology innovation: integrated generation technology options (1019539) 2009 Electric Power Research Institute Palo Alto, CA p. 1-112
42. B. Buller, and D. Eaglesham Thin film PV: the pathway to grid parity. 2009 Optics and Photonics for Advanced Energy Technology, Optical Society of America (paper ThD1)
43. R.M. Swanson Photovoltaics power up Science 324 2009 2009 891 892
44. National Energy Board (NEB). Canadian energy overview 2009 - an energy market assessment; June 2010. p. 1-52.
45. M. Munasinghe, and J.J. Warford Electricity pricing: theory and case studies. 1982 International Bank for Reconstruction and Development Washington, DC 1-395 (Technical report)
46. Natural Resource Canada (NRCan). Energy sector - about electricity; 2009. < http://www.nrcan-rncan.gc.ca/eneene/sources/eleele/abofai-eng. php#generation >.
47. National Energy Board (NEB). Energy pricing information for Canadian consumers, how Canadian markets work; 2010. < http://www.neb.gc.ca/clf-nsi/ rnrgynfmtn/prcng/lctrct/cndnmrkt-eng.html >.
48. Purchase B. Personal communication on energy policy; 2 September 2010.
49. K. Zweibel, E.M. James, and F. Vasilis A solar grand plan Sci Am 298 2008 64 73
50. S.H. Sevilgen, H.H. Erdem, B. Cetin, A.V. Akkaya, and A. Dada Effect of economic parameters on power generation expansion planning Energy Convers Manage 46 2005 1780 1789
51. Hydro-Québec. 2010 comparison of electricity prices in major north American cities; October 2010. p. 1-79.
52. Leavitt R. What the heck is a LUEC? Positive energy blog; August 2004. < http://positiveenergy.blogspot.com/2004/08/what-heck-is-luec.html >.
53. R.B. Gibson, M. Winfield, T. Markvart, K. Gaudreau, and J. Taylor An analysis of the Ontario Power Authoritys consideration of environmental sustainability in electricity system planning. Studies in Ontario electricity policy series paper no. 2 2008 University of Waterloo and York University p. 1-173
54. Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) The power to reduce CO2 emissions - the full portfolio 2007 Electric Power Research Institute Palo Alto, CA p. 1-45
55. U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). Solar energy technologies program: multi-year program plan 2007-2011. Washington, DC; 2006. p. 1-66.
56. U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). Solar energy technologies program: multi-year program plan 2008-2012. Washington, DC; 2008. p. 1-125.
57. S. Kaplan Power plants: characteristics and costs. CRS report for congress 2008 Congressional Research Service Washington, DC p. 1-108
58. Lazard Ltd. Levelised cost of energy analysis - version 3.0 2009 Lazard Ltd. New York, NY p. 1-16 (June)
59. L.M. Moore, and H.N. Post Five years of operating experience at a large, utility-scale photovoltaic generating plant Prog Photovolt: Res Appl 16 2008 249 259 (Pubitemid 351547756)
60. Oregon Government. Renewable energy - estimating the cost of generating electricity; 2007. < http://www.oregon.gov/ENERGY/RENEW/costs.shtml >.
61. G. Simons Developing cost-effective solar resources with electricity system benefits 2005 California Energy Commission p. 1-33 (Staff paper)
62. Tolley G, Jones DW. The economic future of nuclear power. Study by University of Chicago for DOE Nuclear Program; August 2004. p. 1-38.
63. Ontario Power Authority (OPA). Facilitating the development and use of renewable energy and enabling 2010 and 2025 renewable targets, in Exhibit D & E; 2008.
64. SolarBuzz. Solar photovoltaic electricity price index; 2011. < http://register.solarbuzz.com/Solarindices.htm >
65. SunPower Corporation. Levelized cost of electricity - the drivers of the levelized cost of electricity for utility-scale photovoltaics; August 2008. p. 1-27.
66. Ocampo MT. How to calculate the levelized cost of energy - a simplified approach. Energy Technology Expert; 28 April 2009. < http:// energytechnologyexpert.com/cost-of-power-generation/how-to-calculate-the- levelized-cost-of-power-or-energy/ >.
67. G. Barbose, N. Darghouth, and R. Wiser Tracking the Sun III, the installed cost of photovoltaics in the U.S. from 1998-2009 2010 US Department of Energy, Lawrence Berkley National Laboratory p. 1-54
68. Mercom Capital Group. Solar market intelligence report; 4 October 2010. p. 1-9.
69. L. Bony, S. Doig, C. Hart, E. Maurer, and S. Newman Achieving low-cost solar PV: industry workshop recommendations for near-term balance of system cost reductions 2010 Rocky Mountain Institute (RMI) p. 1-24
70. J.M. Pearce Industrial symbiosis for very large scale photovoltaic manufacturing Renewable Energy 33 2008 1101 1108
71. VLSI Research Inc. Photovoltaic cell manufacturing equipment: top-10 supplier ranking. < https://www. vlsiresearch.com/cms-pdf-upload/pdf-file- 1233694471.pdfS > [accessed 20.02.2009].
72. Heacox E. Inverter cost analysis, solar industry; July 2010. p. 28-31.
73. C. Deline, B. Marion, J. Granata, and S. Gonzalez A performance analysis of distributed power electronics in photovoltaic systems 2011 National Renewable Energy Laboratory p. 1-20 (Technical report)
74. Sparq Systems Inc. SPARQs innovative microinverter technology; 2011. < http://www.sparqsys.com/SPARQ-Technology.php >.
75. Brearley D. c-Si photovoltaic trends: design, purchasing and 2009 specs. Solar Pro Magazine; June/July 2009. p. 49-74.
76. J.H. Wohlgemuth Long term photovoltaic module reliability NCPV and solar program review meeting 2003 2003 National Research Energy Laboratory 179 183
77. A. Skoczek, T. Sample, and E.D. Dunlop The results of performance measurements of field-aged crystalline silicon photovoltaic modules Prog Photovolt: Res Appl 17 2009 227 240
78. Realini A. MTBF - PVm, mean time before failure of photovoltaic modules, final report; June 2003. p. 1-58.
79. Holladay M. Testing a thirty-year-old photovoltaic module - its time to hook up my oldest solar panel to a multimeter, Green Building Advisor.com. < http://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/blogs/dept/musings/testing-thirty-year-old- photovoltaic-module > [accessed 21.05.2010].
80. E. Dunlop, D. Halton, and H. Ossenbrink 20 years of life and more: where is the end of life of a PV module? Proceedings of IEEE photovoltaic specialists conference 2005 1593 1596 (Pubitemid 41668079)
81. A.W. Czanderna, and G.J. Jorgensen Accelerated life testing and service lifetime prediction for PV technologies in the twenty-first century 1999 National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) Golden, CO p. 1-13
82. Harrabin R. Solar panel costs set to fall, BBC News; 30 November 2009. < http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/8386460.stm >.
83. S. Leblanc, P. Roman, and C. Selkirk Project management - an engineering economics perspective 2nd custom ed. 2007 Pearson Custom Publishing (for Queens University)
84. N.M. Fraser, E.M. Jewkes, I. Bernhardt, and M. Tajima Engineering economics in Canada 3rd ed. 2006 Pearson Hall Toronto, Ontario
85. Navigant Consulting A review of PV inverter technology cost and performance projections 2006 National Renewable Energy Laboratory Golden, CO
86. D. Chianese, A. Realini, N. Cereghetti, S. Rezzonico, E. Bura, and G. Friesen Analysis of weather c-Si PV modules Proceedings of 3rd world conference on photovoltaic solar energy conversion 2003 5
87. D.L. Staebler, and C.R. Wronski Reversible conductivity changes in discharge-produced amorphous Si Appl Phys Lett 31 1977 292
88. C.R. Wronski, J.M. Pearce, J. Deng, V. Vlahos, and R.W. Collins Intrinsic and light induced gap states in a-Si:H materials and solar cells - effects of microstructure Thin Solid Films 451-452 2004 470 475
89. J.M. Pearce, J. Deng, R.W. Collins, and C.R. Wronski Light induced defect states in hydrogenated amorphous silicon centered around 1.05 and 1.2 eV from the conduction band edge Appl Phys Lett 83 2003 3725 3727
90. R. Rüther, J. del Cueto, G. Tamizh-Mani, A.A. Montenegro, S. Rummel, and A. Anderberg Performance test of amorphous silicon modules in different climates - year four: progress in understanding exposure history stabilization effects Proceedings of 33rd IEEE photovoltaic specialists conference 2008 1 5
91. C. Jardine, and K. Lane PV-COMPARE. Relative performance of photovoltaic technologies in northern and southern Europe Proceedings of PV in Europe conference 2002 1057 1060
92. K.W. Jansen, S.B. Kadam, and J.F. Groelinger The advantages of amorphous silicon photovoltaic modules in grid-tied systems Proceedings of 4th world conference on photovoltaic energy conversion 2006 2363 2366
93. K.W. Jansen, S.B. Kadam, and J.F. Groelinger The high energy yield of amorphous silicon modules in a hot coastal climate Proceedings of 21st European photovoltaic solar energy conference 2006 2535 2538
94. R. Rüther, and J. Livingstone Seasonal variations in amorphous silicon solar module outputs and thin film characteristics Sol Energy Mater Sol Cells 36 1995 29 43
95. Y. Hirata, and T. Tani Output variation of photovoltaic modules with environmental factors I - the effect of spectral solar radiation on photovoltaic module output Solar Energy 55 1995 463 468 (Pubitemid 3018565)
96. R. Gottschalg, D.G. Infield, and M.J. Kearney Experimental study of variations of the solar spectrum of relevance to thin film solar cells Sol Energy Mater Sol Cells 79 2003 527 537
97. R. Gottschalg, T.R. Betts, S.R. Williams, D. Sauter, D.G. Infield, and M.J. Kearney A critical appraisal of the factors affecting energy production from amorphous silicon photovoltaic arrays in a maritime climate Solar Energy 77 2004 909 916 (Pubitemid 39605898)
98. R. Gottschalg, T.R. Betts, D.G. Infield, and M.J. Kearney On the importance of considering the incident spectrum when measuring the outdoor performance of amorphous silicon photovoltaic devices Meas Sci Technol 15 2004 460 466 (Pubitemid 38261634)
99. R. Rüther, G. Kleiss, and K. Reiche Spectral effects on amorphous silicon solar module fill factors Sol Energy Mater Sol Cells 71 2002 375 385 (Pubitemid 34086620)
100. C.N. Jardine, T.R. Betts, R. Gottschalg, D.G. Infield, and K. Lane Influence of spectral effects on the performance of multijunction amorphous silicon cells Proceedings of photovoltaic in Europe conference 2002 4
101. M. Chegaar, and P. Mialhe Effect of atmospheric parameters on the silicon solar cells performance J Electron Devices 6 2008 173 176
102. J. Merten, and J. Andreu Clear separation of seasonal effects on the performance of amorphous silicon solar modules by outdoor I/V-measurements Sol Energy Mater Sol Cells 52 1998 11 25 (Pubitemid 128413954)
103. Andrews, R. Pearce J.M. The effects of spectral albedo on the performance of amorphous silicon photovoltaic devices, 1000 Island Energy Research Forum, November 13, 2010. < http://people.clarkson.edu/∼kvisser/TIERF/Schedule- files/Andrews.pdf >.
104. Fronius Solar Electronics. Extended warranties for Fronius PV inverters; 2010. < http://www.fronius.com/cps/rde/xbcr/SID-4BC61BC3-06170520/fronius- international/Produktinfo-Garantieverlaengerung-EN-126951-snapshot.pdf >.
105. Home Energy Solutions (HESPV). Power-One grid-tie inverters; 2011. < http://www.heshomeenergy.com/poweroneinverters.html >.
106. S. Pelland, D.W. McKenney, Y. Poissant, R. Morris, K.M. Lawrence, and K.L. Campbell The development of photovoltaic resource maps for Canada Annual conference of the solar energy society of Canada 2006
107. Brown M. Gaining on the grid, BP Global - reports and publications; 19 (2007) 14-18. < http://www.bp.com/sectiongenericarticle.do?categoryId= 9019305&contentId=7035199 >.
108. J.M. Pearce, D. Denkenberger, and H. Zielonka Accelerating applied sustainability by utilizing return on investment for energy conservation measures Int J Energy Environ Econ 17 2009 61 80
109. A.V. Banerjee, and E. Duflo The economic lives of the poor 2006 Bureau of Research and Economic Analysis USA 1-43 (Working paper no. 135)
110. C. Di Maria, S. Ferriera, and E. Lazarova Shedding light on the light bulb puzzle: the role of attitudes and perceptions in the adoption of energy efficient light bulbs Scott J Politic Econ 57 2010 48 67
111. M. Taylor Beyond technology-push and demand-pull: lessons from Californias solar policy Energy Econ 30 2008 2829 2854
112. T. Beck, A. Demirguc-Kunt, and P.M.S. Martinez Reaching out: access to and use of banking services across countries 2005 World Bank Washington
113. P.S.C. Rao, J.B. Miller, Y.D. Wang, and J.B. Byrne Energy-microfinance intervention for below poverty line households in India Energy Policy 37 2009 1694 1712
114. M. Robinson The microfinance revolution: sustainable finance for the poor 2001 World Bank Washington p. 199-215
115. Lacey S. Investors renewables growth is slower but steady. RenewableEnergyWorld.com. < http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/rea/news/ podcast/2010/07/investors-renewables-growth-is-slow-but-steady > [accessed 5.07.2010].
116. M. Goldberg Federal energy subsidies: not all technologies are created equal 2000 World Bank Washington, DC p. 1-20 (Research report no. 11, Renewable energy policy project)
117. Slavin M. The federal energy subsidy scorecard: how renewables stack up. Renewable energy world.com. < http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/rea/news/ article/2009/11/the-federal-energy-subsidy-scorecard-how-renewables-stack-up > [accessed 3.10.2009].
118. J.M. Pearce Increasing PV velocity by reinvesting the nuclear energy insurance subsidy into large scale solar photovoltaic production 34th proceedings of IEEE photovoltaic specialists conference 2009 1338 1343
119. I. Zelenika-Zovko, and J.M. Pearce Diverting indirect subsidies from the nuclear industry to the photovoltaic industry: energy and economic returns Energy Policy 39 2011 2626 2632
120. B. Chandrasekar, and T.C. Kandpal Effect of financial and fiscal incentives on the effective capital cost of solar energy technologies to the user Solar Energy 78 2005 147 156
121. K. Branker, and J.M. Pearce Financial return for government support of large-scale thin-film solar photovoltaic manufacturing in Canada Energy Policy 38 2010 4291 4303
122. D.R. Boyd, and S.J. Genuis The environmental burden of disease in Canada: respiratory disease, cardiovascular disease, cancer, and congenital affliction Environ Res 106 2008 240 249 (Pubitemid 351162975)
123. Canadian Medical Association (CMA). No breathing room - national illness costs of air pollution; August 2008. p. 1-45
124. N. Stern The economics of climate change: the Stern review 2007 Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK