Pedicle screw insertion accuracy with different assisted methods: A systematic review and meta-analysis of comparative studies

European Spine Journal

Volumn 20, Issue 6, 2011, Pages 846-859

  Tian, Nai Feng ^a   Huang, Qi Shan ^a   Zhou, Ping ^a   Zhou, Yang ^a   Wu, Rui Kai ^a   Lou, Yi ^a   Xu, Hua Zi ^a  

^a THE SECOND AFFILIATED HOSPITAL AND YUYING CHILDREN S HOSPITAL OF WENZHOU MEDICAL UNIVERSITY   (China)

Author keywords

Accuracy; Computer tomography; Fluoroscopy; Navigated spine surgery; Pedicle screw

Indexed keywords

ACCURACY; COMPUTER ASSISTED TOMOGRAPHY; FLUOROSCOPY; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS; PEDICLE SCREW; PEDICLE SCREW INSERTION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; SCOLIOSIS; SPINE SURGERY; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; THREE DIMENSION FLUOROSCOPY; TWO DIMENSION FLUOROSCOPY; BONE SCREW; COMPUTER ASSISTED SURGERY; INTERNAL FIXATOR; METHODOLOGY; RADIOGRAPHY; SPINE; SPINE FUSION;

BONE SCREWS; FLUOROSCOPY; HUMANS; INTERNAL FIXATORS; SPINAL FUSION; SPINE; SURGERY, COMPUTER-ASSISTED;

EID: 80052564997     PISSN: 09406719     EISSN: 14320932     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s00586-010-1577-5     Document Type: Review

References (61)

1. Harrington PR, Tullos HS (1969) Reduction of severe spondylolisthesis in children. South Med J 62:1-7
2. Xu R, Zhao L, Chai B et al (2009) Lateral radiological evaluation of transarticular screw placement in the lower cervical spine. Eur Spine J 18:392-397
3. Bayley E, Zia Z, Kerslake R et al (2010) Lamina-guided lateral mass screw placement in the sub-axial cervical spine. Eur Spine J 19:660-664
4. Husted DS, Yue JJ, Fairchild TA et al (2003) An extrapedicular approach to the placement of screws in the thoracic spine: an anatomic and radiographic assessment. Spine 28:2324-2330 (Pubitemid 37271327)
5. Tian NF, Xu HZ, Wang XY et al (2010) Morphometric comparisons between the pedicle and the pedicle rib unit in the immature Chinese thoracic spine: a computed tomographic assessment. Spine 35:1514-1519
6. Lo YL, Dan YF, Teo A et al (2008) The value of bilateral ipsilateral and contralateral motor evoked potential monitoring in scoliosis surgery. Eur Spine J 17:S236-S238
7. Sutter M, Eggspuehler A, Grob D et al (2007) The diagnostic value of multimodal intraoperative monitoring (MIOM) during spine surgery: a prospective study of 1,017 patients. Eur Spine J 16:S162-S170 (Pubitemid 350029512)
8. Kosmopoulos V, Schizas C (2007) Pedicle screw placement accuracy: a meta-analysis. Spine 32:E111-E120 (Pubitemid 46197463)
9. Tian NF, Xu HZ (2009) Image-guided pedicle screw insertion accuracy: a meta-analysis. Int Orthop 33:895-903
10. Nakanishi K, Tanaka M, Misawa H et al (2009) Usefulness of a navigation system in surgery for scoliosis: segmental pedicle screw fixation in the treatment. ArchOrthop Trauma Surg 129:1211-1218
11. Arand M, Schempf M, Fleiter T et al (2006) Qualitative and quantitative accuracy of CAOS in a standardized in vitro spine model. Clin Orthop Relat Res 450:118-128 (Pubitemid 44342125)
12. Fu TS, Wong CB, Tsai TT et al (2008) Pedicle screw insertion: computed tomography versus fluoroscopic image guidance. Int Orthop 32:517-521
13. Lee GY, Massicotte EM, Rampersaud YR (2007) Clinical accuracy of cervicothoracic pedicle screw placement: a comparison of the "open" lamino-foraminotomy and computer-assisted techniques. J Spinal Disord Tech 20:25-32 (Pubitemid 46220321)
14. Lekovic GP, Potts EA, Karahalios DG et al (2007) A comparison of two techniques in image-guided thoracic pedicle screw placement: a retrospective study of 37 patients and 277 pedicle screws. J Neurosurg Spine 7:393-398 (Pubitemid 47584614)
15. Gruetzner PA, Waelti H, Vock B et al (2004) Navigation using fluoro-CT technology, concept and clinical experience in a new method for intraoperative navigation. Eur J Trauma 30:161-170 (Pubitemid 38856586)
16. Nottmeier EW, Seemer W, Young PM (2009) Placement of thoracolumbar pedicle screws using three-dimensional image guidance: experience in a large patient cohort. J Neurosurg Spine 10:33-39
17. Merloz P, Troccaz J, Vouaillat H et al (2007) Fluoroscopy-based navigation system in spine surgery. Proc Inst Mech Eng [H] 221:813-820 (Pubitemid 350065077)
18. Rajasekaran S, Vidyadhara S, Ramesh P et al (2007) Randomized clinical study to compare the accuracy of navigated and nonnavigated thoracic pedicle screws in deformity correction surgeries. Spine 32:E56-E64 (Pubitemid 46105794)
19. Amiot LP, Lang K, Putzier M et al (2000) Comparative results between conventional and computer-assisted pedicle screw installation in the thoracic, lumbar, and sacral spine. Spine 25:606-614 (Pubitemid 30158220)
20. Ito H, Neo M, Yoshida M et al (2007) Efficacy of computerassisted pedicle screw insertion for cervical instability in RA patients. Rheumatol Int 27:567-574 (Pubitemid 46411892)
21. Kotani Y, Abumi K, Ito M et al (2007) Accuracy analysis of pedicle screw placement in posterior scoliosis surgery: comparison between conventional fluoroscopic and computer-assisted technique. Spine 32:1543-1550 (Pubitemid 46956151)
22. Laine T, Schlenzka D, Mäkitalo K et al (1997) Improved accuracy of pedicle screw insertion with computer-assisted surgery. A prospective clinical trial of 30 patients. Spine 22:1254-1258 (Pubitemid 27259842)
23. Laine T, Lund T, Ylikoski M et al (2000) Accuracy of pedicle screw insertion with and without computer assistance: a randomised controlled clinical study in 100 consecutive patients. Eur Spine J 9:235-240
24. Merloz P, Tonetti J, Pittet L et al (1998) Pedicle screw placement using image guided techniques. Clin Orthop Relat Res 354:39-48 (Pubitemid 28424044)
25. Richter M, Cakir B, Schmidt R (2005) Cervical pedicle screws: conventional versus computer-assisted placement of cannulated screws. Spine 30:2280-2287 (Pubitemid 41504897)
26. Sakai Y, Matsuyama Y, Nakamura H et al (2008) Segmental pedicle screwing for idiopathic scoliosis using computer-assisted surgery. J Spinal Disord Tech 21:181-186 (Pubitemid 351643476)
27. Arand M, Hartwig E, Hebold D et al (2001) Precision analysis of navigation-assisted implanted thoracic and lumbar pedicled screws. A prospective clinical study. Unfallchirurg 104:1076-1081
28. Schnake KJ, König B, Berth U et al (2004) Accuracy of CT-based navigation of pedicle screws in the thoracic spine compared with conventional technique. Unfallchirurg 107:104-112 (Pubitemid 38314162)
29. Seller K, Wild A, Urselmann L et al (2005) Prospective screw misplacement analysis after conventional and navigated pedicle screw implantation. Biomed Tech (Berl) 50:287-292
30. Huang Y, Kong R, Fang SY et al (2009) Comparison study between C-arm X-ray and 3D CT in guiding thoracolumbar pedicle screw fixation. Shandong Med J (Chin) 49:5-7
31. Li Y (2007) The study of clinical anatomy of cervical pedicle with Iso-C arm and clinical application of Iso-C navigation system. Master's Thesis, Shandong University (Chin) (5)
32. Liu YJ, Tian W, Liu B et al (2005) Accuracy of CT-based navigation of pedicle screws implantation in the cervical spine compared with X-ray fluoroscopy technique. Chin J Surg (Chin) 43:1328-1330
33. Yang YH, Ye H, Zheng J et al (2005) Application of orthopaedic guidance for pedicle screw fixation of spine. Orthop J Chin (Chin) 13:75-76
34. Xu L, Yu X, Zheng DB et al (2004) Preliminary application of spinal navigation with the intra-operative 3D-imaging modality in pedicle screw fixation. Orthop J Chin (Chin) 12:1895-1897
35. Yang LL, Chen HJ, Chen DY et al (2007) Clinical applications of computer assisted navigation technique in scoliosis surgery. Orthop J Chin (Chin) 15:1773-1776
36. Zhang DS, Yuan JT, Zheng J et al (2008) Pedicle screw placement under the guidance of computer-assisted navigation system. Chin J Min Inv Surg (Chin) 8:544-546
37. Li SG, Sheng L, Zhao H et al (2009) Computer-assisted navigation technique in the spinal pedicle screw internal fixation. J Clin Rehabil Tissue Eng Res (Chin) 13:3365-3369
38. Tian W, Liu B, Li Q et al (2003) Experience of pedicle screw fixation in the cervical spine using navigation system. J Spinal Surg (Chin) 1:15-18
39. Austin MS, Vaccaro AR, Brislin B et al (2002) Image-guided spine surgery: a cadaver study comparing conventional open laminoforaminotomy and two image-guided techniques for pedicle screw placement in posterolateral fusion and nonfusion models. Spine 27:2503-2508 (Pubitemid 35346161)
40. Choi WW, Green BA, Levi AD (2000) Computer-assisted fluoroscopic targeting system for pedicle screw insertion. Neurosurgery 47:872-878 (Pubitemid 32103663)
41. Mirza SK, Wiggins GC, Kuntz C et al (2003) Accuracy of thoracic vertebral body screw placement using standard fluoroscopy, fluoroscopic image guidance, and computed tomographic image guidance: a cadaver study. Spine 28:402-413 (Pubitemid 36232625)
42. Sagi HC, Manos R, Park SC et al (2003) Electromagnetic fieldbased image-guided spine surgery part two: results of a cadaveric study evaluating thoracic pedicle screw placement. Spine 28:E351-E354
43. Sagi HC, Manos R, Benz R et al (2003) Electromagnetic fieldbased image-guided spine surgery part one: results of a cadaveric study evaluating lumbar pedicle screw placement. Spine 28:2013-2018 (Pubitemid 37082669)
44. Assaker R, Reyns N, Vinchon M et al (2001) Transpedicular screw placement: image-guided versus lateral-view fluoroscopy: in vitro simulation. Spine 26:2160-2164 (Pubitemid 32929374)
45. Hart RA, Hansen BL, Shea M et al (2005) Pedicle screw placement in the thoracic spine: a comparison of image-guided and manual techniques in cadavers. Spine 30:E326-E331
46. John PS, James C, Antony J et al (2007) A novel computerassisted technique for pedicle screw insertion. Int J Med Robot 3:59-63 (Pubitemid 46732473)
47. Ludwig SC, Kramer DL, Balderston RA et al (2000) Placement of pedicle screws in the human cadaveric cervical spine: comparative accuracy of three techniques. Spine 25:1655-1667 (Pubitemid 30460467)
48. Ludwig SC, Kowalski JM, Edwards CC et al (2000) Cervical pedicle screws: comparative accuracy of two insertion techniques. Spine 25:2675-2681
49. Tian W, Liu YJ, Liu B et al (2006) Experimental study and clinical applications of computer assisted navigation technique in spinal surgery. Chin J Orthop (Chin) 26:671-675
50. He XS, Yang HL, Zhu RF et al (2008) Study on pedicle screw fixation of cervical spine assisted CT-based navigation system compared with the individual cervical peddle screws placement technique. Suzhou Univ J Med Sci (Chin) 28:415-417
51. Xia Q, Yan SJ, Chen TY et al (2007) Application of computerassisted fluoroscopic navigation based on the C-arm X-ray in pedicle screw fixation. Fudan Univ J Med Sci (Chin) 34:873-876
52. Lim MR, Girardi FP, Yoon SC et al (2005) Accuracy of computerized frameless stereotactic image-guided pedicle screw placement into previously fused lumbar spines. Spine 30:1793-1798 (Pubitemid 41099495)
53. Rampersaud YR, Lee KS (2007) Fluoroscopic computer-assisted pedicle screw placement through a mature fusion mass: an assessment of 24 consecutive cases with independent analysis of computed tomography and clinical data. Spine 32:217-222 (Pubitemid 46115954)
54. von Jako RA, Carrino JA, Yonemura KS et al (2009) Electromagnetic navigation for percutaneous guide-wire insertion: accuracy and efficiency compared to conventional fluoroscopic guidance. Neuroimage 47:T127-T132
55. Nakashima H, Sato K, Ando T et al (2009) Comparison of the percutaneous screw placement precision of isocentric C-arm 3-dimensional fluoroscopy- navigated pedicle screw implantation and conventional fluoroscopy method with minimally invasive surgery. J Spinal Disord Tech 22:468-472
56. Verma R, Krishan S, Haendlmayer K et al (2010) Functional outcome of computer-assisted spinal pedicle screw placement: a systematic review and meta-analysis of 23 studies including 5,992 pedicle screws. Eur Spine J 19:370-375
57. Sugano N (2003) Computer-assisted orthopedic surgery. J Orthop Sci 8:442-448 (Pubitemid 36702100)
58. Kendo D, Citak M, Hüfner T et al (2007) Current concepts and applications of computer navigation in orthopedic trauma surgery. Central Eur J Med 2:392-403 (Pubitemid 47512884)
59. Slomczykowski M, Roberto M, Schneeberger P et al (1999) Radiation dose for pedicle screw insertion. Fluoroscopic method versus computer-assisted surgery. Spine 24:975-982
60. Gebhard FT, Kraus MD, Schneider E et al (2006) Does computerassisted spine surgery reduce intraoperative radiation doses? Spine 31:2024-2027 (Pubitemid 44297785)
61. Tjardes T, Shafizadeh S, Rixen D et al (2010) Image-guided spine surgery: state of the art and future directions. Eur Spine J 19:25-45