Further evidence of the narcissistic personality inventory's validity problems: A meta-analytic investigation-Response to Miller, Maples, and Campbell (this issue)

Journal of Research in Personality

Volumn 45, Issue 5, 2011, Pages 408-416

  Rosenthal, Seth A ^a   Matthew Montoya, R ^b   Ridings, Leigh E ^b   Rieck, Stacey M ^b   Hooley, Jill M ^c  

^a HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF DAYTON   (United States)

^c HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Aggression; Grandiose narcissism; Meta analysis; Narcissism; Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD); Narcissistic Personality Inventory (NPI); Normal narcissism; Pathological narcissism; Psychological health; Self esteem

Indexed keywords

EID: 80052301766     PISSN: 00926566     EISSN: 10957251     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jrp.2011.06.004     Document Type: Article

References (118)

1. Ackerman R.A., Witt E.A., Donnellan M.B., Trzesniewski K.H., Robins R.W., Kashy D.A. What does the Narcissistic Personality Inventory really measure?. Assessment 2011, 18:67-87.
2. American Psychiatric Association Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders 1987, American Psychiatric Association, Washington, DC. 3rd ed., Revised.
3. American Psychiatric Association Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders 1994, American Psychiatric Association, Washington, DC. 4th ed.
4. Ames D.R., Rose P., Anderson C.P. The NPI-16 as a short measure of narcissism. Journal of Research of Personality 2006, 40:440-450.
5. Beck A.T., Ward C.H., Mendelson M., Mock J., Erbaugh J. An inventory for measuring depression. Archives of General Psychiatry 1961, 4:561-571.
6. Bosson J.K. When conscious and non-conscious self-views clash: Interpersonal and physiological correlates of discrepant implicit and explicit self-esteem. Dissertation Abstracts International: Section B: The Sciences and Engineering 2001, 61(11-B):6184-6294.
7. Bosson, J. K. (2004). [NPI-40, Rosenberg self-esteem, psychological health]. Unpublished raw data.
8. Bosson J.K. Overvalued and ashamed: Considering the roles of self-esteem and self-conscious emotions in covert narcissism. The self-conscious emotions: Theory and research 2005, Guilford, New York. 2nd ed. J.L. Tracy, R.W. Robins, J.P. Tangney (Eds.).
9. Bosson J.K., Lakey C.E., Campbell W.K., Zeigler-Hill V., Jordan C.H., Kernis M.H. Untangling the links between narcissism and self-esteem: A theoretical and empirical review. Social and Personality Psychology Compass 2008, 2/3:1415-1439.
10. Brown R.P., Budzek K., Tamborski M. On the meaning and measure of narcissism. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2009, 35:951-964.
11. Bushman, B. (2011). [NPI-40 and Rosenberg self-esteem]. Unpublished raw data.
12. Bushman B.J., Baumeister R.F. Threatened egotism, narcissism, self-esteem, and direct and displaced aggression: Does self-love or self-hate lead to violence?. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1998, 75:219-229.
13. Bushman B., Baumeister R.F., Thomaes S., Ryu E., Begeer S., West S.G. Looking again and harder, for a link between low self-esteem and aggression. Journal of Personality 2009, 77:427-446.
14. Buss A.H., Perry M. The aggression questionnaire. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1992, 63:452-459.
15. Cain N.M., Pincus A.L., Ansell E.B. Narcissism at the crossroads: Phenotypic description of pathological narcissism across clinical theory, social/personality psychology, and psychiatric diagnosis. Clinical Psychology Review 2008, 28:638-656.
16. Campbell W.K. Is narcissism really so bad?. Psychological Inquiry 2001, 12:214-216.
17. Campbell W.K., Bonacci A.M., Shelton J., Exline J.J., Bushman B.J. Psychological entitlement: Interpersonal consequences and validation of a self-report measure. Journal of Personality Assessment 2004, 83:29-45.
18. Campbell W.K., Bush C.P., Brunell A.B., Shelton J. Understanding the social costs of narcissism: The case of the tragedy of the commons. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2005, 31:1358-1368.
19. Campbell W.K., Foster C.A. Narcissism and commitment in romantic relationships: An investment model analysis. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2002, 28:484-495.
20. Cheng J.T., Tracy J.L., Henrich J. Pride, personality, and the evolutionary foundations of human social status. Evolution and Human Behavior 2010, 31:334-347.
21. Clark L.A. Schedule for Nonadaptive and Adaptive Personality (SNAP). Manual for administration, scoring, and interpretation 1993, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.
22. Clark L.A., Watson D. Constructing validity: Basic issues in objective scale development. Psychological Assessment 1995, 7:309-319.
23. Cohen J. Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences 1988, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ. 2nd ed.
24. Corry N., Merritt R.D., Mrug S., Pamp B. The factor structure of the Narcissistic Personality Inventory. Journal of Personality Assessment 2008, 90:593-600.
25. Costa P.T., McCrae R.R. Revised NEO Personality Inventory (NEO-PI-R) and NEO Five-Factor Inventory (NEO-FFI) professional manual 1992, Psychological Assessment Resources.
26. Crocker J., Canevello A. Creating and undermining social support in communal relationships: The role of compassionate and self-image goals. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2008, 95:555-575.
27. Derogatis L.R., Melisaratos N. The Brief Symptom Inventory: An introductory report. Psychological Medicine 1983, 13:595-605.
28. Dickenson K.A., Pincus A.L. Interpersonal analysis of grandiose and vulnerable narcissism. Journal of Personality Disorders 2003, 17:188-207.
29. Diener E., Emmons R.A., Larson R.J., Griffin S. The satisfaction with life scale. Journal of Personality Assessment 1985, 49:71-75.
30. Donnellan M.B., Trzesniewski K.H., Robins R.W., Moffitt T.E., Caspi A. Low self-esteem is related to aggression, antisocial behavior, and delinquency. Psychological Science 2005, 16:328-335.
31. Emmons R.A. Narcissism: Theory and measurement. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1987, 52:11-17.
32. Field A.P. Meta-analysis of correlation coefficients: A Monte Carlo comparison of fixed- and random-effects methods. Psychological Methods 2001, 6:161-180.
33. Field A.P. The problems using fixed effects models of meta-analysis on real-world data. Understanding Statistics 2003, 2:77-96.
34. First M.B., Gibbon M., Spitzer R.L., Williams J.B.W., Benjamin L.S. User's guide for the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Axis II Personality Disorders (SCID-II) 1997, American Psychiatric Press, Washington, DC.
35. Fisher R.A. Statistical methods for research workers 1928, Stechert, Oxford, England.
36. Hamilton M. A rating scale for depression. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry 1960, 23:56-62.
37. Hendin H.M., Cheek J.M. Assessing hypersensitive narcissism: A reexamination of Murray's Narcism Scale. Journal of Research in Personality 1997, 31:588-599.
38. Hedges L.V., Vevea J.L. Fixed- and random-effects models in meta-analysis. Psychological Methods 1998, 3:486-504.
39. Hills P., Argyle M. The Oxford Happiness Questionnaire: A compact scale for the measurement of psychological well-being. Personality and Individual Differences 2002, 33:1073-1082.
40. Holtzman, N. S. (2010). The evolutionary persistence of socially aversive personality traits (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Washington University, St. Louis, MO.
41. Holtzman, N. S., & Strube, M. J. (2009, February). A reliable implicit association test of narcissistic personality disorder (the NPD-IAT). Poster session presented at the meeting of the Society for Personality and Social Psychology, Tampa, FL.
42. Holtzman N.S., Vazire S., Mehl M.R. Sounds like a narcissist: Behavioral manifestations of narcissism in everyday life. Journal of Research in Personality 2010, 44:478-484.
43. Horton, R. S. (2011). [NPI-40, Rosenberg self-esteem, psychological health]. Unpublished raw data.
44. Horton R.S., Bleau G., Drwecki B. Parenting narcissus: What are the links between parenting and narcissism?. Journal of Personality 2006, 74:345-376.
45. Horvath S., Morf C.C. Narcissistic defensiveness: Hypervigilance and avoidance of worthlessness. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 2009, 45:1252-1258.
46. Horvath S., Morf C.C. To be grandiose or not to be worthless: Different routes to self-enhancement for narcissism and self-esteem. Journal of Research in Personality 2010, 44:585-592.
47. Hunter J.E., Schmidt F.L. Fixed effects vs. random effects meta-analysis models: Implications for cumulative knowledge in psychology. International Journal of Selection and Assessment 2000, 8:275-292.
48. Hyler, S. E. (1994). Personality Diagnostic Questionnaire-4. Unpublished test, NYSPI.
49. Johnson J.A. The impact of item characteristics on item and scale validity. Multivariate Behavioral Research 2004, 39:273-302.
50. Jordan, C. (2006). [NPI and Rosenberg self-esteem]. Unpublished raw data.
51. Kansi, J. (2011). [NPI-40 and Rosenberg self-esteem]. Unpublished raw data.
52. Kansi J. The Narcissistic Personality Inventory: Applicability in a Swedish population sample. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology 2003, 44:441-448.
53. Konrath, S. (2004). [NPI-40 and Rosenberg self-esteem]. Unpublished raw data.
54. Konrath, S. (2005a). [NPI-40 and Rosenberg self-esteem]. Unpublished raw data.
55. Konrath, S. (2005b). [NPI-40 and Rosenberg self-esteem]. Unpublished raw data.
56. Konrath, S. (2007). [NPI-40 and Rosenberg self-esteem]. Unpublished raw data.
57. Konrath, S. (2010). [NPI-40 and Rosenberg self-esteem]. Unpublished raw data.
58. Lakey C.E., Rose P., Campbell W.K., Goodie A.S. Probing the link between narcissism and gambling: The mediating role of judgment and decision-making. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 2008, 21:113-137.
59. Locke K.D. Aggression, narcissism, self-esteem, and the attribution of desirable and humanizing traits to self versus others. Journal of Research in Personality 2009, 43:99-102.
60. Lynam D., Hoyle R., Newman J. The perils of partialling: Cautionary tales from aggression and psychopathy. Assessment 2006, 13:328-341.
61. Lynam D.R., Widiger T.A. Using the five-factor model to represent the DSM-IV personality disorders: An expert consensus approach. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 2001, 110:401-412.
62. Maples J.L., Miller J.D., Wilson L.F., Seibert L.A., Few L.R., Zeichner A. Narcissistic personality disorder and self-esteem: An examination of differential relations with self-report and laboratory-based aggression. Journal of Research in Personality 2010, 44:559-563.
63. Maxwell K.M., Donnellan M.B., Hopwood C.J., Ackerman R.A. The two faces of narcissus? An empirical comparison of the Narcissistic Personality Inventory and the pathological narcissism inventory. Personality and Individual Differences 2011, 50:577-582.
64. Miller J.D., Campbell W.K. Comparing clinical and social-personality conceptualizations of narcissism. Journal of Personality 2008, 76:449-476.
65. Miller J.D., Campbell W.K. The case for using research on trait narcissism as a building block for understanding narcissistic personality disorder. Personality Disorders: Theory, Research, and Treatment 2010, 3:180-191.
66. Miller J.D., Campbell W.K. Addressing criticisms of the Narcissistic Personality Inventory (NPI). Handbook of narcissism and narcissistic personality disorder: Theoretical approaches, empirical findings, and treatments 2011, 146-152. Wiley, Hoboken, NJ. W.K. Campbell, J.D. Miller (Eds.).
67. Miller J.D., Campbell W.K., Pilkonis P.A. Narcissistic personality disorder: Relations with distress and functional impairment. Comprehensive Psychiatry 2007, 48:170-177.
68. Miller J.D., Campbell W.K., Pilkonis P.A., Morse J.Q. Assessment procedures for narcissistic personality disorder: A comparison of the Personality Diagnostic Questionnaire-4 and best-estimate clinical judgments. Assessment 2008, 15:483-492.
69. Miller J.D., Dir A., Gentile B., Wilson L., Pryor L.R., Campbell W.K. Searching for a vulnerable dark triad: Comparing factor 2 psychopathy, vulnerable narcissism, and borderline personality disorder. Journal of Personality 2010, 78:1529-1564.
70. Miller J.D., Gaughan E.T., Pryor L.R., Kamen C., Campbell W.K. Is research using the Narcissistic Personality Inventory relevant for understanding narcissistic personality disorder?. Journal of Research in Personality 2009, 43:482-488.
71. Miller, J. D., Hoffman, B. J., Gaughan, E. T., Gentile, B., Maples, J., & Campbell, W. K. (in press). Grandiose and vulnerable narcissism: A nomological network analysis. Journal of Personality.
72. Miller, J. D., Maples, J., & Campbell, W. K. (this issue). Comparing the construct validity of scales derived from the Narcissistic Personality Inventory: A reply to Rosenthal and Hooley (2010). Journal of Research in Personality, 45, 401-407.
73. Miller J.D., Widiger T.A., Campbell W.K. Narcissistic personality disorder and the DSM-5. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 2010, 119:640-649.
74. Morf, C. C. (2010a). [NPI-40 and Rosenberg self-esteem]. Unpublished raw data.
75. Morf, C. C. (2010b). [NPI-40 and Rosenberg self-esteem]. Unpublished raw data.
76. Morf, C. C. (2010c). [NPI-40, Rosenberg self-esteem, Buss-Perry aggression]. Unpublished raw data.
77. Morf, C. C., Horvath, S., & Zimmermann, T. D. (submitted for publication). In the mind of a male narcissist: Worthlessness primes aggression.
78. O'Shea, P. G., & Gustafson, S. B. (1999). Confirmatory item response theory: An analysis of the Narcissistic Personality Inventory. Poster presented at the 11th annual conference of the American Psychological Society, Denver, CO.
79. Okada R. Narcissism and psychological health in adolescence: A meta-analysis. Japanese Journal of Developmental Psychology 2009, 20:428-436.
80. National Research Council Combining information: Statistical issues and opportunities for research 1992, National Academy Press, Washington, DC.
81. Papps B.P., O'Carroll R.E. Extremes of self-esteem and narcissism and the experience and expression of anger and aggression. Aggressive Behavior 1998, 24:421-438.
82. Park, S. W. (2008). Personality and situational factors in judgment of responsibility (Unpublished master's thesis). University of Dayton, Dayton, OH.
83. Park S.W., Bauer J.J., Arbuckle N.B. Growth motivation attenuates the self-serving attribution. Journal of Research in Personality 2009, 43:914-917.
84. Paulhus D.L. Interpersonal and intrapsychic adaptiveness of trait selfenhancement: A mixed blessing?. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1998, 74:1197-1208.
85. Paulhus D.L. Normal narcissism: Two minimalist accounts. Psychological Inquiry 2001, 12:228-230.
86. Paulhus D.L., Robins R.W., Trzesniewski K.H., Tracy J.L. Two replicable suppressor situations in personality research. Multivariate Behavioral Research 2004, 39:303-328.
87. Pincus A.L., Ansell E.B., Pimentel C.A., Cain N.M., Wright A.G.C., Levy K.N. Initial construction and validation of the pathological narcissism inventory. Psychological Assessment 2009, 21:365-379.
88. Pincus A.L., Lukowitsky M.R. Pathological narcissism and narcissistic personality disorder. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology 2010, 6:421-446.
89. Radloff L.S. The CES-D Scale: A self-report depression scale for research in the general population. Applied Psychology Measurement 1977, 1:385-401.
90. Raine A., Dodge K., Loeber R., Gatzke-Kopp L., Lynam D., Reynolds C., et al. The Reactive-Proactive Aggression Questionnaire: Differential correlates of reactive and proactive aggression in adolescent boys. Aggressive Behavior 2006, 32:159-171.
91. Raskin R., Hall C.S. A Narcissistic Personality Inventory. Psychological Reports 1979, 45:590.
92. Raskin R., Hall C.S. The Narcissistic Personality Inventory: Alternate form reliability and further evidence of construct validity. Journal of Personality Assessment 1981, 45:159-162.
93. Raskin R., Terry H. A principal-components analysis of the Narcissistic Personality Inventory and further evidence of its construct validity. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1988, 54:890-902.
94. Reidy D.E., Foster J.D., Zeichner A. Narcissism and unprovoked aggression. Aggressive Behavior 2010, 36:414-422.
95. Rhodewalt F., Morf C.C. On self-aggrandizement and anger: A temporal analysis of narcissism and affective reactions to success and failure. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1998, 74:672-685.
96. Robins R.W., Hendin H.M., Trzesniewski K.H. Measuring global self-esteem: Construct validation of a Single-Item Measure and the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2001, 27:151-161.
97. Rose P. The happy and unhappy faces of narcissism. Personality and Individual Differences 2002, 33:379-391.
98. Rosenberg M. Society and the adolescent self-image 1965, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
99. Rosenthal S.A., Hooley J.M. Narcissism assessment in social-personality research: Does the association between narcissism and psychological health result from a confound with self-esteem?. Journal of Research in Personality 2010, 44:453-465.
100. Rosenthal S.A., Pittinsky T.L. Narcissistic leadership. The Leadership Quarterly 2006, 17:617-633.
101. Samuel, D. B. (2008). [NPI-40, Rosenberg self-esteem, psychological health]. Unpublished raw data.
102. Samuel D.B., Widiger T.A. Clinicians' personality descriptions of prototypic personality disorders. Journal of Personality Disorders 2004, 18:286-308.
103. Samuel D.B., Widiger T.A. Convergence of narcissism measures from the perspective of general personality functioning. Assessment 2008, 15:364-374.
104. Sedikides C., Rudich E.A., Gregg A.P., Kumashiro M., Rusbult C. Are normal narcissists psychologically healthy? Self-esteem matters. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2004, 87:400-416.
105. Steger M.F., Frazier P., Oishi S., Kaler M. The meaning in life questionnaire: Assessing the presence of and search for meaning in life. Journal of Counseling Psychology 2006, 53:80-93.
106. Sutin A.R., Robins R.W. Continuity and correlates of emotions and motives in self-defining memories. Journal of Personality 2005, 73:793-824.
107. Sutin A.R., Robins R.W. Phenomenology of autobiographical memories: The memory experiences questionnaire. Memory 2007, 15:390-411.
108. Tellegen A., Waller N.G. Exploring personality through test construction: Development of the Multidimensional Personality Questionnaire. Personality measures: Development and evaluation 1994, Vol. 1:133-161. JAI Press, Greenwich, CT.
109. Thomaes S., Stegge H., Bushman B.J., Olthof T., Denissen J. Development and validation of the Childhood Narcissism Scale. Journal of Personality Assessment 2008, 90:382-391.
110. Tracy J.L., Cheng J.T., Robins R.W., Trzesniewski K.H. Authentic and hubristic pride: The affective core of self-esteem and narcissism. Self and Identity 2009, 8:196-213.
111. Troisi, J. D., & Park, L. (2006). [NPI-40, Rosenberg self-esteem, aggression, psychological health]. Unpublished raw data.
112. Trzesniewski K.H., Donnellan M.B., Robins R.W. Do today's young people really think they are so extraordinary?. Psychological Science 2008, 19:181-188.
113. Twenge J.M., Campbell W.K. "Isn't it fun to get the respect we're going to deserve?" Narcissism, social rejection, and aggression. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2003, 29:261-272.
114. Twenge J.M., Konrath S., Foster J.D., Campbell W.K., Bushman B.J. Egos inflating over time: A cross-temporal meta-analysis of the Narcissistic Personality Inventory. Journal of Personality 2008, 76:875-901.
115. University of California, Davis (2010). [Psychology Department Mass Testing: NPI-40, Rosenberg self-esteem, psychological health, 2009-2010]. Unpublished raw data.
116. Wallace H.M., Baumeister R.F. The performance of narcissists rises and falls with perceived opportunity for glory. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2002, 82:819-834.
117. Wright A.G.C., Lukowitsky M.R., Pincus A.L., Conroy D.E. The higher order factor structure and gender invariance of the Pathological Narcissism Inventory. Assessment 2010, 17:467-483.
118. Yarkoni T. The abbreviation of personality, or how to measure 200 personality scales with 200 items. Journal of Research in Personality 2010, 44:180-198.