The ethics of human volunteer studies involving experimental exposure to pesticides: Unanswered dilemmas

Environmental Health: A Global Access Science Source

Volumn 9, Issue 1, 2010, Pages

  London, Leslie ^a   Coggon, David ^b   Moretto, Angelo ^c,f   Westerholm, Peter ^d   Wilks, Martin F ^e   Colosio, Claudio ^c,g  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CAPE TOWN   (South Africa)

^b UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON   (United Kingdom)

^c UNIVERSITY OF MILAN   (Italy)

^d UPPSALA UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL   (Sweden)

^e UNIVERSITY OF BASEL   (Switzerland)

^f UNIVERSITY OF MILAN   (Italy)

^g SAN PAOLO HOSPITAL   (Italy)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ALDICARB; AMITRAZ; ATRAZINE; CAPTAN; CARBARIL; CHLORPYRIFOS; CIPERMETHRIN; DICHLORVOS; DIETHYLPHENYLACETAMIDE; DIMETHOATE; DIMPYLATE; ETHOPROP; FENITROTHION; FLUAZIFOP BUTYL; HERBICIDE; LINDANE; MALATHION; METHIDATHION; METHOMYL; MEVINPHOS; MOLINATE; ORGANOPHOSPHATE PESTICIDE; OXAMYL; PESTICIDE; PESTICIDE RESIDUE; PHENOL DERIVATIVE; PIPERONYL BUTOXIDE; PYRETHRIN; PYRETHROID; UNCLASSIFIED DRUG; WARFARIN;

ETHICS; EXPERIMENTAL STUDY; GUIDELINE; HEALTH RISK; LITERATURE REVIEW; OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE; PESTICIDE; PUBLIC HEALTH; RISK ASSESSMENT; RURAL POPULATION;

DOSE RESPONSE; DRUG ABSORPTION; DRUG DISTRIBUTION; DRUG EXCRETION; DRUG METABOLISM; ETHICS; EXPOSURE; FEMALE; GOVERNMENT; HUMAN; MALE; PRACTICE GUIDELINE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; RISK ASSESSMENT; TOXICITY TESTING; VOLUNTEER; ENVIRONMENTAL EXPOSURE; MEDICAL RESEARCH; RESEARCH ETHICS;

BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH; ENVIRONMENTAL EXPOSURE; ETHICS, RESEARCH; HUMANS; PESTICIDES;

EID: 77955593046     PISSN: None     EISSN: 1476069X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1186/1476-069X-9-50     Document Type: Review

References (86)

1. Ethics of pesticide testing in humans. PJ Landrigan M McCally C Oleskey, Environ Health Perspect 2003 111 750 14594642
2. Ethics of Pesticide Testing: Response. JJ McNeil J Meaklim, Environ Health Perspect 2003 111 750 14594642
3. Industry testing of toxic pesticides on human subjects concluded "no effect", despite the evidence. JB Sass HL Needleman, Environ Health Perspect 2004 112 3 150 1 14998762
4. Study Criticisms Unjustified. IS Chart A Manley SH Youngren, Environ Health Perspect 2004 112 3 151 2 10.1289/ehp.112-a151
5. Review of procedures for protecting human subjects in recent clinical studies of pesticides. G Charnley J Patterson, Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 2003 38 210 23 10.1016/S0273-2300(03)00093-X 14550761
6. Human testing of pesticides: ethical and scientific considerations. AH Lockwood, Am J Public Health 2004 94 1908 16 10.2105/AJPH.94.11.1908 15514226
7. Testing toxic compounds in human subjects: ethical standards and good science. LR Goldman JM Links, Environ Health Perspect 2004 112 458 9 15175189
8. Pesticide testing in humans: ethics and public policy. C Oleskey A Fleischman L Goldman K Hirschhorn PJ Landrigan M Lappé MF Marshall H Needleman R Rhodes M McCally, Environ Health Perspect 2004 112 914 9 10.1289/ehp.6522 15175182
9. Testing toxic pesticides in humans: health risks with no health benefits. RL Melnick J Huff, Environ Health Perspect 2004 112 459 61 15175190
10. Pesticide testing on human subjects: weighing benefits and risks. DB Resnik C Portier, Environ Health Perspect 2005 113 813 7 10.1289/ehp.7720 16002367
11. Benefits and risks of pesticide testing on humans. HL Needleman JR Reigart P Landrigan J Sass C Bearer, Environ Health Perspect 2005 113 804 5 10.1289/ehp.113-a804 16330333
12. Testing pesticides in humans: of mice and men divided by ten. S Krimsky T Simoncelli, JAMA 2007 297 2405 7 10.1001/jama.297.21.2405 17551133
13. Pesticide testing. EPA draft rules for human subjects draw fire. E Stokstad, Science 2005 309 232 10.1126/science.309.5732.232b 16002591
14. Human Experimentation: A Rule Gone Awry? A Burton, Environ Health Perspect 2006 114 6 360 A362 10.1289/ehp.114-a360 16759973
15. Food Quality Protection Act. US Congress, 1996 7 USC 136
16. Indecision over human pesticide data. A Dove, Nat Med 5 9 972 10.1038/12393 10471263
17. EPA ponders pesticide toxicity testing: considers ending moratorium on human data. M Mitka, JAMA 2003 289 535 6 10.1001/jama.289.5.535 12578466
18. US set to endorse human pesticide testing. M Wadman, Nature 2005 437 24 5 10.1038/437024a 16136104
19. Approval for pesticide toxicity testing in humans draws criticism. M Mitka, JAMA 2006 295 1237 8 10.1001/jama.295.11.1237 16537728
20. US Senate votes to ban pesticide tests on humans. M Wadman, Nat Med 2005 11 811 10.1038/nm0805-811a 16079861
21. International Ethical Guidelines for Biomedical Research Involving Human Subjects. Council for International Organizations of Medical Sciences, Geneva, CIOMS 2002
22. International code of ethics for Occupational Health Professionals. International Commission on Occupational Health, ICOH, Rome 2002 First published 1992
23. Universal Declaration on Bioethics and Human Rights. United Nations Educational, Cultural and Scientific Organisation, UNESCO, Genevan 2005
24. Helsinki Declaration. World Medical Association, 2004 http://www.wma.net/en/30publications/10policies/b3/index.html accessed on 4th December 2009
25. Protection for subjects in human research. Final rule. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Fed Regist 2006 71 24 6137 76 16502536
26. Statement of CropLife America on Pesticide Testing Involving Human Subjects. R McAllister, Environ Health Perspect 2004 112 14 154 5 10.1289/ehp.112-a154
27. Aldicarb Study Misrepresented in Human Testing Debate. A Tobia A Ayers A Blacker L Hodges N Carmichael, Environ Health Perspect 2004 112 155 6 10.1289/ehp.112-a155
28. Intentional Human Dosing Studies for EPA Regulatory Purposes: Scientific and Ethical Issues. NRC Committee on the Use of Third Party Toxicity Research, The National Academies Press, Washington 2004 http://www.nap.edu/openbook.php? isbn=0309091721
29. FAO Plant Production and Protection Paper. FAO/WHO. Pesticide residues in food - 1999. Report of the Joint Meeting of the FAO Panel of Experts on Pesticide Residues in Food and the Environment and the WHO Core Assessment Group, 1999 153
30. FAO Plant Production and Protection Paper. FAO/WHO. Pesticide residues in food - 2003. Report of the Joint Meeting of the FAO Panel of Experts on Pesticide Residues in Food and the Environment and the WHO Core Assessment Group, 2004 176
31. FAO Plant Production and Protection Paper. FAO/WHO. Pesticide residues in food - 2005. Report of the Joint Meeting of the FAO Panel of Experts on Pesticide Residues in Food and the Environment and the WHO Core Assessment Group, 2005 183
32. Chemical-specific adjustment factors for interspecies differences and human variability: guidance document for use of data in dose/concentration- response assessment. WHO, Geneva 2005 Harmonization Project Document No. 2
33. Regulation No 1107/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 1 October 2009 concerning the placing of plant protection products on the market and repealing Council Directives 79/117/EEC and 91/414/EEC. EC, Official Journal L 309 0001 0050 24/11/2009
34. Panel on plant protection products and their residues on the guidance document (GD) for the establishment of acceptable operator exposure levels (AOELs). PPR, 2006 http://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/scdocs/scdoc/345.htm
35. European Commission Health and Consumer Protection Directorate General. Draft guidance for the setting and application of acceptable operator exposure levels (AOELs). SANCO, 2006 http://ec.europa.eu/food/plant/protection/resources/ 7531-rev-10.pdf Revision 10
36. Opinion of the Scientific Committee on Plants on the draft guidance document for the setting of an acute reference dose (ARFD). :SCP Scientific Committee on Plants, 2002 http://ec.europa.eu/food/fs/sc/scp/out133-ppp-en.pdf SCP/GUIDE-ARFD/002-Final
37. Comparative metabolism of ortho-phenylphenol in mouse, rat and man. MJ Bartels DA McNett C Timchalk AL Mendrala WR Christenson GK Sangha KA Brzak SN Shabrang, Xenobiotica 1998 28 579 94 10.1080/004982598239335 9667081
38. HPLC-accelerator MS measurement of atrazine metabolites in human urine after dermal exposure. BA Buchholz E Fultz KW Haack JS Vogel SD Gilman SJ Gee BD Hammock X Hui RC Wester HI Maibach, Anal Chem 1999 71 3519 25 10.1021/ac990152g 10464479
39. Comparative in vitro-in vivo percutaneous penetration of the fungicide ortho-phenylphenol. NH Cnubben GR Elliott BC Hakkert WJ Meuling JJ van de Sandt, Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 2002 35 2 Pt 1 198 208 2002 10.1006/rtph.2001.1530 12052004
40. Initial evaluation of N,N-diethyl-m-toluamide and permethrin absorption in human volunteers under stress conditions. MJ Roy PL Kraus JA Cooper S Cherstniakova R Coll CA Seegers PA Deuster P Koslowe WA Law DS Krantz L Cantilena, Mil Med 2006 171 122 7 16578980
41. Biological monitoring for pesticide exposure - the role of human volunteer studies. MF Wilks BH Woollen JR Marsh PL Batten G Chester, Int Arch Occ Env Health 1993 65 189 S192 10.1007/BF00381338
42. The metabolism of cypermethrin in man: differences in metabolite profile following oral and dermal administration. BH Woollen JR Marsh WJD Laird JE Leeser, Xenobiotica 1992 22 983 993 10.3109/00498259209049904 1413886
43. Oral pharmacokinetics of fluazifop-butyl in human volunteers. BH Woollen TB Hart PL Batten WJD Laird DS Davies C Dollery, Human Exp Toxicol 1991 10 39 43 10.1177/096032719101000107
44. Perspiration increased human pesticide absorption following surface contact during an indoor scripted activity program. RL Williams LS Aston RI Krieger, J Expo Anal Environ Epidemiol 2004 14 129 36 10.1038/sj.jea.7500301 15014543
45. Pharmacokinetics of fluazifop-butyl in human volunteers II: Dermal dosing. JD Ramsey BH Woollen TR Auton PL Batten JE Leeser, Human Exp Toxicol 1992 11 247 254 10.1177/096032719201100402
46. The percutaneous absorption and skin distribution of lindane in man. I. In vivo studies. IP Dick PG Blain FM Williams, Hum Exp Toxicol 1997 16 645 51 10.1177/096032719701601103 9426365
47. Effect of hexaethyl tetraphosphate on cholinesterase in vitro and in vivo. KP DuBois GH Mangun, Proc Soc Exp Biol Med 1947 64 137 139 20287357
48. Safety of dimethoate insecticide. EF Edson KH Jones WA Watson, Br Med J 1967 4 5578 554 10.1136/bmj.4.5578.554-b
49. Synthetic pyrethroid insecticides: A dermatological evaluation. SA Flannigan SB Tucker MM Key CE Ross EJ Fairchild BA Grimes RB Harrist, Br J Ind Med 1985 42 363 372 4005189
50. Oral and dermal absorption of chlorpyrifos: a human volunteer study. P Griffin H Mason K Heywood J Cocker, Occup Environ Med 1999 56 10 3 10.1136/oem.56.1.10 10341740
51. Human subject experiments to estimate reentry periods for monocrotophos-treated tobacco. FE Guthrie JJ Domanski AL Chasson DE Bradway RJ Monroe, Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 1976 4 2 217 25 10.1007/BF02221025 1267489
52. Dermal exposure of human volunteers to parathion. GR Hayes Jr AJ Funckes WV Hartwell, Arch Environ Health 1964 8 829 33 14157578
53. Dermal absorption of cis-1,3-dichloropropene vapour: human experimental exposure. S Kezic AC Monster AJ Verplanke FA de Wolff, Hum Exp Toxicol 1996 15 396 9 10.1177/096032719601500506 8735463
54. Captan metabolism in humans yields two biomarkers, tetrahydrophthalimide (THPI) and thiazolidine-2-thione-4-carboxylic acid (TTCA) in urine. RI Krieger T Thongsinthusak, Drug Chem Toxicol 1993 16 207 25 10.3109/01480549309031997 8486100
55. Fenitrothion: toxicokinetics and toxicologic evaluation in human volunteers. J Meaklim J Yang O Drummer S Killalea V Staikos S Horomidis D Rutherford L Ioannides-Demos S Lim A McLean J McNeil, Environmental Health Perspectives 2003 111 3 305 308 10.1289/ehp.5726 12611659
56. Dermal absorption of chlorpyrifos in human volunteers. WJ Meuling LC Ravensberg L Roza JJ van Hemmen, Int Arch Occup Environ Health 2005 78 44 50 10.1007/s00420-004-0558-6 15627216
57. Plasma and red blood cell cholinesterase activity as indications of the threshold of incipient toxicity of ethyl-p-nitrophenyl thionobenzenephosphonate (EPN) and malathion in human beings. HC Moeller JA Rider, Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 1962 4 123 130 10.1016/0041-008X(62)90081-9 14474998
58. Dermal absorption of the phenoxy herbicide 2,4-D dimethylamine in humans: effect of DEET and anatomic site. RP Moody RC Wester JL Melendres HI Maibach, J Toxicol Environ Health 1992 36 241 50 10.1080/15287399209531635 1629935
59. Dermal absorption of the phenoxy herbicides 2,4-D, 2,4-D amine, 2,4-D isooctyl, and 2,4,5-T in rabbits, rats, rhesus monkeys, and humans: a cross-species comparison. RP Moody CA Franklin L Ritter HI Maibach, J Toxicol Environ Health 1990 29 237 45 Erratum in: J Toxicol Environ Health 1991; 32 : 107-8 10.1080/15287399009531387 2313737
60. Pharmacokinetics of picloram in male volunteers. RJ Nolan NL Freshour PE Kastl JH Saunders, Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 1984 76 264 9 10.1016/0041-008X(84) 90007-3 6495333
61. Chlorpyrifos: pharmacokinetics in human volunteers. RJ Nolan DL Rick NL Freshour JH Saunders, Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 1984 73 8 15 10.1016/0041-008X(84) 90046-2 6200956
62. Effect of exposure of human volunteers to the aerial spray of monocrotophos. RR Rao MR Marathe SD Gangoli, Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 1979 3 325 34 10.1016/0147-6513(79)90021-6 499035
63. The minimal oral toxicity level for mevinphos in man. JA Rider EJ Puletti JI Swader, Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 1975 32 97 100 10.1016/0041-008X(75)90198-2 1135882
64. Toxicological properties of the organophosphorus insecticide dimethoate. DM Sanderson EF Edson, Br J Ind Med 1964 21 52 14106136
65. The fate of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) following oral administration to man. MW Sauerhoff WH Braun GE Blau PJ Gehring, Toxicology 1977 8 3 11 10.1016/0300-483X(77)90018-X 929615
66. Absorption and mass balance of piperonyl butoxide following an 8-h dermal exposure in human volunteers. S Selim FJ Preiss KL Gabriel JH Jonkman TG Osimitz, Toxicol Lett 1999 107 207 17 10.1016/S0378-4274(99)00049-1 10414798
67. Absorption, metabolism, and excretion of N,N-diethyl-m-toluamide following dermal application to human volunteers. S Selim RE Hartnagel Jr TG Osimitz KL Gabriel GP Schoenig, Fundam Appl Toxicol 1995 25 95 100 10.1006/faat.1995.1043 7601331
68. The pharmacokinetics and metabolism of 14C/13C-labeled ortho-phenylphenol formation following dermal application to human volunteers. C Timchalk S Selim G Sangha MJ Bartels, Hum Exp Toxicol 1998 17 411 7 10.1191/096032798678909115 9756132
69. Effects on nervous function of volunteers ingesting mevinphos for one month. MM Verberk HJA Sallè Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 1977 42 351 358 10.1016/0041-008X(77)90012-6 202041
70. Incipient cholinesterase inhibition in volunteers ingesting monocrotophos of mevinphos for one month. MM Verberk, Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 1977 42 345 350 10.1016/0041-008X(77)90011-4 595013
71. Failure of indomethacin and warfarin to interact in normal human volunteers. ES Vesell GT Passananti AO Johnson, J Clin Pharmacol 1975 7 486 95 1150903
72. Percutaneous absorption of diazinon in humans. RC Wester L Sedik J Melendres F Logan HI Maibach I Russell, Food Chem Toxicol 1993 31 569 72 10.1016/0278-6915(93)90206-E 8349202
73. Human in vivo percutaneous absorption of pyrethrin and piperonyl butoxide. RC Wester DA Bucks HI Maibach, Food Chem Toxicol 1994 32 51 3 10.1016/0278-6915(84)90036-X 8132164
74. Dichlorvos: A Single Blind, Placebo Controlled, Randomized Study to Investigate the Effects of Multiple Oral Dosing on Erythrocyte Cholinesterase Inhibition in Healthy Male Volunteers. AMVAC, Newport Beach, CA:AMVAC Chemical Corporation 1997 Report No CTL/P/5392. Study No. XH6063. MRID No. 442488-01
75. A Safety and Tolerability Study of Aldicarb at Various Dose Levels in Healthy Male and Female Volunteers. PJ Wyld CE Watson WS Nimmo N Watson, Rhone-Poulenc, Lyon, France 1992 Inveresk Clinical Research Report No. 7786. MRID No. 42373-01. HED Doc No 010459. Washington, DC:U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
76. Aldicarb food poisonings in California, 1985-1988: toxicity estimates for humans. LR Goldman M Beller RJ Jackson, Arch Environ Health 45 141 147 2386419
77. Reduction of mixer-loader-applicator dermal exposure and absorption by use of protective gloves. G Chester NJ Loftus BH Woollen, Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, Eleventh Annual Meeting Arlington, VA, USA 1990 Abstract No. 199
78. Informed consent, II. Meaning and Elements. T Beauchamp RI Faden, Encyclopedia of Bioethics Thomson Gale, Stephen G. Post, 3 2004 1271 1379
79. Consent issues in human research. R Levine III, Encyclopedia of Bioethics Thomson Gale, Stephen G. Post, 3 2004 1271 1379
80. International Ethical Guidelines for Epidemiological Studies. Council for International Organizations of Medical Sciences (CIOMS), CIOMS in collaboration with World Health Organization (WHO), Geneva 2009
81. Guidelines for ethical evaluation of medical research involving human subjects - the policy and organization of research ethics in Sweden. The Swedish Medical Research Council, Swedish Medical Research Council Stockholm 1999 MRC report 2 1996
82. Behavioral alterations in adolescent and adult rats caused by a brief subtoxic exposure to chlorpyrifos during neurulation. LM Icenogle NC Christopher WP Blackwelder DP Caldwell D Qiao FJ Seidler TA Slotkin ED Levin, Neurotoxicol Teratol 2004 26 95 101 10.1016/j.ntt.2003.09.001 15001218
83. Developmental diazinon neurotoxicity in rats: later effects on emotional response. CS Roegge OA Timofeeva FJ Seidler TA Slotkin ED Levin, Brain Res Bull 2008 75 166 72 10.1016/j.brainresbull.2007.08.008 18158111
84. Neonatal exposure to low doses of diazinon: long-term effects on neural cell development and acetylcholine systems. TA Slotkin BE Bodwell ED Levin FJ Seidler, Environ Health Perspect 2008 116 340 8 10.1289/ehp.11005 18335101
85. Persistent behavioral alterations in rats neonatally exposed to low doses of the organophosphate pesticide, parathion. OA Timofeeva D Sanders K Seemann L Yang D Hermanson S Regenbogen S Agoos A Kallepalli A Rastogi D Braddy C Wells C Perraut FJ Seidler TA Slotkin ED Levin, Brain Res Bull 2008 77 6 404 11 10.1016/j.brainresbull.2008.08.019 18817854
86. Manganese neurotoxicity, a continuum of dysfunction: results from a community based study. D Mergler M Baldwin S Bélanger F Larribe A Beuter R Bowler M Panisset R Edwards A de Geoffroy MP Sassine K Hudnell, Neurotoxicology 1999 20 327 42 10385894