The impacts of roads and other infrastructure on mammal and bird populations: A meta-analysis

Biological Conservation

Volumn 143, Issue 6, 2010, Pages 1307-1316

  Benítez López, Ana ^a   Alkemade, Rob ^a   Verweij, Pita A ^b  

^a PBL NETHERLANDS ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT AGENCY   (Netherlands)

^b UTRECHT UNIVERSITY   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Biodiversity loss; Bird abundance; Infrastructure; Mammal abundance; Mean species abundance; Meta analysis; Meta regression; Roads; Traffic intensity

Indexed keywords

ABUNDANCE; ANTHROPOGENIC EFFECT; BIRD; HUMAN ACTIVITY; INFRASTRUCTURAL DEVELOPMENT; INFRASTRUCTURE PLANNING; MAMMAL; META-ANALYSIS; POPULATION DECLINE; POPULATION DENSITY; ROAD TRANSPORT; SPECIES CONSERVATION;

EID: 77954819367     PISSN: 00063207     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.biocon.2010.02.009     Document Type: Review

References (119)

1. Adams L.W. Small mammal use of an interstate highway median strip. Journal of Applied Ecology 1984, 21:175-178.
2. Alkemade R., van Oorschot M., Miles L., Nellemann C., Bakkenes M., ten Brink B. GLOBIO3: a framework to investigate options for reducing global terrestrial biodiversity loss. Ecosystems 2009, 12:374-390.
3. Andrews A. Fragmentation of habitat by roads and utility corridors: a review. Australian Zoologist 1990, 26:130-141.
4. Angold P.G. The impact of a road upon adjacent heathland vegetation: effects on plant species composition. Journal of Applied Ecology 1997, 34:409-417.
5. Arnqvist G., Wooster D. Meta-analysis: synthesizing research findings in ecology and evolution. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 1995, 10:236-240.
6. Auerbach N.A., Walker M.D., Walker D.A. Effects of roadside disturbance on substrate and vegetation properties in Arctic Tundra. Ecological Applications 1997, 7:218-235.
7. Ballard W.B., Cronin M.A., Rodrigues R., Skoog R.O., Pollard R.H. Arctic fox, Alopex galopus, den densities in the Prudhoe Bay Oil Field, Alaska. Canadian Field-Naturalist 2000, 114:453-456.
8. *Ballasus H., Sossinka R. The impact of power lines on field selection and grazing intensity of wintering White-fronted- and Bean Geese Anser albifrons, A. fabalis. Journal für Ornithologie 1997, 138:215-228.
9. Barrios L., Rodriguez A. Behavioural and environmental correlates of soaring-bird mortality at on-shore wind turbines. Journal of Applied Ecology 2004, 41:72-81.
10. Barrows C.W., Allen M.F., Rotenberry J.T. Boundary processes between a desert sand dune community and an encroaching suburban landscape. Biological Conservation 2006, 131:486-494.
11. Bates, D., Maechler, M., 2009. lme4: Linear mixed-effects models using S4 classes. R package version 0.999375-31. http://CRAN.R-project.org/package=lme4.
12. *Bautista L.M., García J.T., Calmaestra R.G., Palacin C., Martín C.A., Morales M.B., Bonal R., Viñuela J. Effect of weekend road traffic on the use of space by raptors. Conservation Biology 2004, 18:726-732.
13. Boarman W.I., Sazaki M. A highway's road-effect for desert tortoises (Gopherus agasazii). Journal of Arid Environments 2005, 65:94-101.
14. Bolger D.T., Scott T.A., Rotenberry J.T. Breeding bird abundance in an urbanizing landscape in coastal Southern California. Conservation Biology 1997, 11:406-421.
15. Buskirk S. Keeping an eye on the neighbours. Science 2009, 306:238-239.
16. Cameron R.D., Reed D.J., Dau J.R., Smith W.T. Redistribution of calving caribou in response to oil field development on the Arctic Slope of Alaska. Arctic 1992, 45:338-342.
17. *Carbaugh B., Vaughan J.P., Bellis E.D., Graves H.B. Distribution and activity of white-tailed deer along an interstate highway. Journal of Wildlife Management 1975, 39:570-581.
18. *Clark W.D., Karr J.R. Effects of highways on Red-winged Blackbird and Horned Lark populations. Wilson Bulletin 1979, 81:143-145.
19. Cox D.R. The Analysis of Binary Data 1970, Methuen & Co. Ltd., London.
20. *Cronin M.A., Amstrup S.C., Durner G.M., Noel L.E., McDonald T.L., Ballard W. Caribou distribution during the post-calving period in relation to infrastructure in the Prudhoe Bay oil field, Alaska. Arctic 1998, 51:85-93.
21. Dean W.R.J., Milton S.J. The importance of roads and road verges for raptors and crows in the Succulent and Nama-Karoo, South Africa. Ostrich 2003, 74:181-186.
22. *Delgado J.D., Arévalo J.R., Fernández-Palacios J.M. Consecuencias de la fragmentación viaria: efectos de borde de las carreteras en la laurisilva y el pinar de Tenerife. Ecología Insular/Island Ecology 2004, 181-225. Asociación Española de Ecología Terrestre (AEET)-Cabildo Insular de La Palma. J.M. Fernández-Palacios, C. Morici (Eds.).
23. DerSimonian R., Laird N. Meta-analysis in clinical trials. Controlled Clinical Trials 1986, 7:177-188.
24. Develey P.F., Stouffer P.C. Effects of roads on movements by understorey birds in mixed-species flocks in Central Amazonian Brazil. Conservation Biology 2001, 15:1416-1422.
25. *Devereux C.L., Denny M.J.H., Whittingham M.J. Minimal effects of wind turbines on the distribution of wintering farmland birds. Journal of Applied Ecology 2008, 45:1689-1694.
26. Dónazar J.A., Ceballos O., Travaini A., Hiraldo F. Roadside raptor surveys in the Argentinean Patagonia. Journal of Raptor Research 1993, 27:106-110.
27. Drews C. Road kills of animals by public traffic in Mikumi National Park, Tanzania, with notes on baboon mortality. African Journal of Ecology 1995, 33:89-100.
28. Dunthorn A.A., Errington F.P. Casualties among birds along a selected road in Wiltshire. Bird Study 1964, 11:168-182.
29. Dyer S.J., O'Neill J.P., Wasel S.M., Boutin S. Avoidance of industrial development by woodland caribou. Journal of Wildlife Management 2001, 65:531-542.
30. Egger M., Davey-Smith G., Schneider M., Minder C. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple graphical test. British Medical Journal 1997, 315:629-634.
31. Evans D.R., Gates E.J. Cowbird selection of breeding areas: the role of habitat and bird species abundance. Wilson Bulletin 1997, 109:470-480.
32. Fahrig L., Rytwinski T. Effects of roads on animal abundance: an empirical review and synthesis. Ecology and Society 2009, 14:21. .
33. Fajardo I., Pividal V., Trigo M., Jimenez M. Habitat selection, activity peaks and strategies to avoid road mortality by the little owl, a new methodology on owls research. Alauda 1998, 66:49-60.
34. Forman R.T.T., Alexander L.E. Roads and their major ecological effects. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 1998, 29:207-231.
35. Forman R.T.T., Deblinger R.D. The ecological road-effect zone of Massachusetts (USA) suburban highway. Conservation Biology 2000, 14:36-46.
36. Forman R.T.T., Reineking B., Hersperger A.M. Road traffic and nearby grassland bird patterns in a suburbanizing landscape. Environmental Management 2002, 29:782-800.
37. Forman R.T.T., Sperling D., Bissonette J.A., Clevenger A.P., Cutshall C.D., Dale V.H., Fahrig L., France R., Goldman C.R., Heanue K., Jones J.A., Swanson F.J., Turrentine T., Winter T.C. Road Ecology: Science and Solutions 2003, Island Press, Washington, Covelo, London.
38. Gagnon J.W., Theimer T.C., Dodd N.L., Boe S., Schweinsburg R.E. Traffic volume alters elk distribution and highway crossings in Arizona. Journal of Wildlife Management 2007, 71:2318-2323.
39. *Gill J.A., Sutherland W.J., Watkinson A.R. A method to quantify the effects of human disturbance on animal populations. Journal of Applied Ecology 1996, 33:786-792.
40. Goosem M., Marsh H. Fragmentation of a small-mammal community by a powerline corridor through tropical rainforest. Wildlife Research 1997, 24:613-629.
41. Gullison R.E., Hardner J.J. The effects of road design and harvest intensity on forest damage caused by selective logging: empirical results and a simulation model from the Bosque Chimanes, Bolivia. Forest Ecology and Management 1993, 59:l-14.
42. Harestad A.S., Bunnel F.L. Home range and body weight-a reevaluation. Ecology 1979, 60:389-402.
43. Haskell D.G. Effects of roads on macroinvertebrate soil fauna of the Southern Appalachian Mountains. Conservation Biology 2000, 14:57-63.
44. *Hüppop V.O., Hüppop K. The influence of agriculture and road usage on the distribution of coastal bird nests on saltmarshes in Schleswig-Holstein (Germany). Die Vogelwarte 1995, 38:76-88.
45. Jaeger J.A.G., Bowman J., Brennan J., Fahrig L., Bert D., Bouchard J., Charbonneau N., Frank K., Gruber B., von Toschanowitz K.T. Predicting when animal populations are at risk from roads: an interactive model of road avoidance behavior. Ecological Modeling 2005, 185:329-348.
46. Joly K., Nellemann C., Vistnes I. A reevaluation of caribou distribution near an oilfield road on Alaska's North Slope. Wildlife Society Bulletin 2006, 34:866-869.
47. *Keller V.E. The effect of disturbance from roads on the distribution of feeding sites of geese (Anser brachyrhynchus, A. anser), wintering in North-Scotland. Ardea 1991, 79:229-232.
48. Kroodsma R.L. Effect of edge on breeding forest bird species. Wilson Bulletin 1984, 96:426-436.
49. *Kuitunen M., Rossi E., Stenroos A. Do highways influence density of land birds?. Environmental Management 1998, 22:297-302.
50. Lambertucci S.A., Speziale K.L., Rogers T.A., Morales J.M. How do roads affect the habitat use of an assemblage of scavenging raptors?. Biodiversity and Conservation 2009, 18:2063-2074.
51. *Lane S.J., Alonso J.C., Martín C.A. Habitat preferences of great bustard Otis tarda flocks in the arable steppes of central Spain: are potentially suitable areas unoccupied?. Journal of Applied Ecology 2001, 38:193-203.
52. *Larsen J.K., Madsen J. Effects of wind turbines and other physical elements on field utilization by Pink-footed Geese (Anser brachyrhynchus): a landscape perspective. Landscape Ecology 2000, 15:755-764.
53. *Laurance W.F., Croes B.M., Tchignoumba L., Lahm S.A., Alonso A., Lee M.E., Campbell P., Ondzeano C. Impacts of roads and hunting on central African rainforest mammals. Conservation Biology 2006, 20:1251-1261.
54. Lockwood J.L., McKinney M.L. Biotic Homogenization 2001, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.
55. Madsen J. Impact of disturbance on field utilization of Pink-footed Geese in West Jutland, Denmark. Biological Conservation 1985, 33:53-63.
56. Mahoney S.P., Schaefer J.A. Hydroelectric development and the disruption of migration in caribou. Biological Conservation 2002, 107:147-153.
57. *Malcolm J.R., Ray J.C. Influence of timber extraction routes on Central African small-mammal communities, forest structure and tree diversity. Conservation Biology 2000, 14:1623-1638.
58. Martínez-Abraín A. Mortalidad estacional de aves en una carretera del P.N. de l'Albufera de Valencia (E. España). Doñana, Acta Vertebrata 1994, 21:90-95.
59. Martínez-Abraín, A., Oro, D., Jiménez, J., Stewart, G., Pullin, A., 2008. What are the Impacts of Human Recreational Activity on the Distribution, Nest-occupancy Rates and Reproductive Success of Breeding Raptors? Systematic Review No. 27. Collaboration for Environmental Evidence.
60. McLellan B.N., Shackleton D.M. Grizzly bear and resource extraction industries: habitat displacement in response to seismic exploration, timber harvesting and road maintenance. Journal of Applied Ecology 1989, 26:371-380.
61. Millennium Ecosystem Assessment Ecosystems and Human Well-being: Biodiversity Synthesis 2005, Island Press, Washington, DC.
62. *Meunier F.D., Verheyden C., Jouventin P. Bird communities of highway verges: influence of adjacent habitat and roadside management. Acta Oecologica 1999, 20:1-13.
63. *Meunier F.D., Verheyden C., Jouventin P. Use of roadsides by diurnal raptors in agricultural landscapes. Biological Conservation 2000, 92:291-298.
64. Mood A.M., Graybill F.A., Boes D.C. Introduction and Theory of Statistics 1973, McGraw-Hill, Auckland. third ed.
65. Nellemann C., Cameron R.D. Effects of petroleum development on terrain preferences of calving caribou. Arctic 1996, 49:23-28.
66. Nellemann C., Vistnes I., Jordhøy P., Strand O. Winter distribution of wild reindeer in relation to powerlines, roads and resorts. Biological Conservation 2001, 101:351-360.
67. Nellemann C., Jordhøy P., Vistnes I., Strand O., Newton A. Progressive impacts of piecemeal development. Biological Conservation 2003, 113:307-317.
68. Nellemann C., Vistnes I., Ahlenius H., Rekazewicz P., Kaltenborn B.P., Magomedova M., Udovyk O., Furuhovde T. Environment and security: 2050 scenarios. Social and Environmental Impacts in the North 2003, 129-148. Kluwer Academic Publishers. R.O. Rasmussen, N.E. Koroleva (Eds.).
69. Newmark W.D., Boshe J.I., Sariko H.I., Makumbule G.K. Effects of a highway on large mammals in Mikumi National Park, Tanzania. African Journal of Ecology 1996, 34:15-31.
70. Noel L.E., Parker F.R., Cronin M.A. Caribou distribution near an oilfield road on Alaska's North Slope, 1978-2001. Wildlife Society Bulletin 2004, 32:757-771.
71. OECD OECD Guidelines Towards Environmentally Sustainable Transport 2002, OECD Publications, Paris.
72. *Oehler J.D., Litvaitis J.A. The role of spatial scale in understanding responses of medium-sized carnivores to forest fragmentation. Canadian Journal of Zoology 1996, 74:2070-2079.
73. Oehlert G.W. A note on the Delta Method. The American Statistician 1992, 46:27-29.
74. Ortega Y.K., Capen D.E. Effects of forest roads on habitat quality for Ovenbirds in a forested landscape. Auk 1999, 116:937-946.
75. Osenberg C.W., Sarnelle O., Cooper S.D., Holt R.D. Resolving ecological questions through meta-analysis: goals, metrics, and models. Ecology 1999, 80:1105-1117.
76. Parris K.M., Schneider A. Impacts of traffic noise and traffic volume on birds of roadside habitats. Ecology and Society 2009, 14:29. .
77. *Paruk J.D. Habitat utilization by bald eagles wintering along the Mississippi River. Transactions or the Illinois Academy of Science 1987, 80:333-342.
78. Peris S.J., Pescador M. Effects of traffic noise on passerine populations in Mediterranean wooded pastures. Applied Acoustics 2004, 65:357-366.
79. Pimm S.L., Russell G.H., Gittleman J.H., Brooks T.M. The future of biodiversity. Science 1995, 269:347-350.
80. Pinheiro J.C., Bates D.M. Mixed-effects Models in S and S-PLUS 2000, Springer Verlag, New York.
81. *Piper S.D., Catterall C.P. Impacts of picnic areas on bird assemblages and nest predation activity within Australian eucalypt forests. Landscape and Urban Planning 2006, 78:251-262.
82. Przybylski Z. The effects of automobile exhaust gases on the arthropods of cultivated plants, meadows and orchards. Environmental Pollution 1979, 19:157-161.
83. Pullin A.S., Stewart G.S. Guidelines for systematic review in conservation and environmental management. Conservation Biology 2006, 20:1647-1656.
84. Räty M. Effect of highway traffic on tetraonid densities. Ornis Finnica 1979, 56:169-170.
85. Reed R.A., Johnson-Barnard J., Baker W.L. Contribution of roads to forest fragmentation in the Rocky Mountains. Conservation Biology 1996, 10:1098-1106.
86. Reijnen R., Foppen R. The effects of car traffic on breeding bird populations in woodland. I. Evidence of reduced habitat quality for Willow Warblers (Phylloscopus trochilus) breeding close to a highway. Journal of Applied Ecology 1994, 31:85-94.
87. Reijnen R., Foppen R., Ter Braak C., Thissen J. The effects of car traffic on breeding bird populations in woodland. III. Reduction of density in relation to the proximity of main roads. Journal of Applied Ecology 1995, 32:187-202.
88. Reijnen R., Foppen R., Meeuwsen H. The effect of traffic on the density of breeding bird populations in Dutch agricultural grasslands. Biological Conservation 1996, 75:255-260.
89. Reijnen R., Foppen R., Veenbaas G. Disturbance by traffic as a threat to breeding birds: evaluation of the effect and considerations in planning and managing road corridors. Biodiversity and Conservation 1997, 6:567-581.
90. Rheindt F.E. The impact of roads on birds: does song frequency play a role in determining susceptibility to noise pollution?. Journal für Ornithologie 2003, 144:295-306.
91. *Rich A.C., Dobkin D.S., Niles L.J. Defining forest fragmentation by corridor width: the influence of narrow forest-dividing corridors on forest-nesting birds in southern New Jersey. Conservation Biology 1994, 8:1109-1121.
92. *Roedenbeck I.A., Voser P. Effects of roads on spatial distribution, abundance and mortality of brown hare (Lepus europaeus) in Switzerland. European Journal of Wildlife Research 2008, 54:425-437.
93. Roedenbeck I.A., Fahrig L., Findlay C.S., Houlahan J.E., Jaeger J.A.G., Klar N., Kramer-Schadt S., Van der Grift E.A. The Rauischholzhausen agenda for road ecology. Ecology and Society 2007, 12(1):11. .
94. Romin L.A., Bissonette J.A. Deer-vehicle collisions: status of state monitoring activities and mitigation efforts. Wildlife Society Bulletin 1996, 24:276-283.
95. Rosenthal R. The " file drawer problem" and tolerance for null results. Psychological Bulletin 1979, 86:638-641.
96. *Rost G.R., Bailey J.A. Distribution of mule deer and elk in relation to roads. Journal of Wildlife Management 1979, 43:634-641.
97. Sala O.E., Chapin F.S., Armesto J.J., Berlow E., Bloomfield J., Irzo R., Huber-Samwald E., Huenneke K.F., Jackson R.B., Kinzig A., Leemans R., Lodge D.M., Mooney H.A., Oesterheld M., Poff N.L., Sykes M.T., Walker B.H., Walker M., Wall D.H. Global biodiversity scenarios for the year 2100. Science 2000, 87:1770-1774.
98. Sanderson E.W., Jaiteh M., Levy M.A., Redford K.H., Wannebo A.V., Woolmer G. The Human footprint and the last of the wild. BioScience 2002, 52:891-904.
99. Santos A.M., Tabarelli M. Distance from roads and cities as a predictor of habitat loss and fragmentation in the Caatinga vegetation of Brazil. Brazilian Journal of Biology 2002, 62:897-905.
100. sCBD, MNP Cross-roads of Life on Earth-Exploring Means to Meet the 2010 Biodiversity Target. Solution-oriented Scenarios for Global Biodiversity Outlook 2. Technical Series No. 31 2007, Secretariat of the Convention on Biological Diversity, Montreal, pp. 90.
101. Shine R., Lemaster M., Wall M., Langkilde T., Mason R. Why did the snake cross the road? Effects of roads on movement and location of mates by garter snakes (Thamnophis sirtalis parietalis). Ecology and Society 2004, 9:9. .
102. Sokal R.R., Rohlf F.J. Biometry: The Principles and Practice of Statistics in Biological Research 1981, Freeman, New York. second ed.
103. Spellerberg I.F. Ecological effects of roads and traffic: a literature review. Global Ecology and Biogeography Letters 1998, 7:317-333.
104. Sweeting M.J., Sutton A.J., Lambert P. What to add to nothing? Use and avoidance of continuity corrections in meta-analysis of sparse data. Statistics in Medicine 2004, 23:1351-1375.
105. Thompson S.G., Sharp S.J. Explaining heterogeneity in meta-analysis: a comparison of methods. Statistics in Medicine 1999, 18:2693-2708.
106. *Tigas L.A., Van Vuren D.H., Sauvajot R.M. Behavioral responses of bobcats and coyotes to habitat fragmentation and corridors in an urban environment. Biological Conservation 2002, 108:299-306.
107. Trombulak S.C., Frissell C.A. Review of ecological effects of roads on terrestrial and aquatic communities. Conservation Biology 2000, 14:18-30.
108. UNEP, Nellemann, C., Kullerud, L., Vistnes, I., Forbes, B.C., Husby, E., Kofinas, G.P., Kaltenborn, B.P., Rouaud, J., Magomedova, M., Bobiwash, R., Lambrechts, C., Schei, P.J., Tveitdal, S., Grøn, O., Larsen, T.S., 2001. GLOBIO. Global Methodology for Mapping Human Impacts on the Biosphere. UNEP/DEWA/TR.01-3.
109. UNEP Global Environmental Outlook 4. Environment for Development 2007, United Nations Environmental Programme, Nairobi, Kenya.
110. Van der Zande A.N., TerKeurs W.J., van der Weijden W.J. The impact of roads on the densities of four bird species in an open field habitat-evidence of a long-distance effect. Biological Conservation 1980, 18:299-321.
111. Van Dyke F., Klein W.C. Response of elk to installation of oil wells. Journal of Mammalogy 1996, 77:1028-1041.
112. Verboom J., Alkemade R., Klijn J., Metzger M.J., Reijnen R. Combining biodiversity modeling with political and economical development scenarios for 25 countries. Ecological Economics 2007, 62:267-276.
113. Viechtbauer, W., 2009. metafor: Meta-analysis package for R. R package version 0.5-4. http://CRAN.R-project.org/package=metafor.
114. *Vistnes I., Nellemann C. Avoidance of cabins, roads, and power lines by reindeer during calving. Journal of Wildlife Management 2001, 65:915-925.
115. Vitousek P.M. Beyond global warming: ecology and global change. Ecology 1994, 75:3-15.
116. Vos C.C., Chardon J.P. Effects of habitat fragmentation and road density on the distribution pattern of the moor frog Rana arvalis. Journal of Applied Ecology 1998, 35:44-56.
117. Winzer P.J. Accuracy of error propagation exemplified with ratios of random variables. Review of Scientific Instruments 2000, 71:1447-1454.
118. Wolf F., Guevara J. Imputation of missing data in systematic reviews: so what is the standard deviation?. Cochrane 2001, 1:7.
119. Yost A.C., Wright R.G. Moose, caribou and grizzly bear distribution in relation to road traffic in Denali National Park, Alaska. Arctic 2001, 54:41-48.