Communicating uncertainty in hydro-meteorological forecasts: Mission impossible?

Meteorological Applications

Volumn 17, Issue 2, 2010, Pages 223-235

  Ramos, Maria Helena ^a   Mathevet, Thibault ^b   Thielen, Jutta ^c   Pappenberger, Florian ^d  

^a CEMAGREF   (France)

^b EDF R AND D   (France)

^c JOINT RESEARCH CENTRE   (Italy)

^d EUROPEAN CENTRE FOR MEDIUM RANGE WEATHER FORECASTS   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Ensemble flood forecasts; Hydrometeorology; Uncertainty communication

Indexed keywords

DECISION MAKING; FLOOD CONTROL; FLOODS; MANAGERS; RESERVOIRS (WATER);

CIVIL PROTECTION; FLOOD FORECAST; FLOOD FORECASTING; HYDROLOGICAL FORECAST; HYDROMETEOROLOGY; OPERATIONAL FORECASTERS; RESERVOIR OPERATION; SCIENTIFIC COMMUNITY;

WEATHER FORECASTING;

DECISION MAKING; ENSEMBLE FORECASTING; FLOOD FORECASTING; FORECASTING METHOD; HYDROMETEOROLOGY; STAKEHOLDER; UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS; WARNING SYSTEM; WATER MANAGEMENT;

FRANCE;

EID: 77954172514     PISSN: 13504827     EISSN: 14698080     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/met.202     Document Type: Article

References (63)

1. Apel H, Aronica GT, Kreibich H, Thieken AH. 2009. Flood risk analyses - how detailed do we need to be? Natural Hazards 49: 79-98.
2. Apel H, Thieken AH, Merz B, Blöschl G. 2004. Flood risk assessment and associated uncertainty. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences 4: 295-308.
3. Atger F. 2001. Verification of intense precipitation forecasts from single models and ensemble prediction systems. Nonlinear Processes in Geophysics 8: 401-417.
4. Barredo JI. 2009. Normalised flood losses in Europe: 1970-2006. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences 9: 97-104.
5. Bartholmes JC, Thielen J, Ramos MH, Gentilini S. 2009. The European flood alert system EFAS - part 2: statistical skill assessment of probabilistic and deterministic operational forecasts. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 13(2): 141-153.
6. Beven KJ. 2000. Uniqueness of place and process representations in hydrological modelling. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 4(2): 203-213.
7. Beven KJ. 2006. On undermining the science? Hydrological Processes 20(14): 3141-3146.
8. Beven KJ, Smith PJ, Freer JE. 2008. So just why would a modeller choose to be incoherent? Journal of Hydrology 354(1-4): 15-32.
9. Block PJ, Souza Filho FA, Sun L, Kwon HH. 2009. A streamflow forecasting framework using multiple climate and hydrological models. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 45(4): 828-843.
10. Blöschl G. 2008. Flood warning - on the value of local information. International Journal of River Basin Management 6(1): 41-50.
11. Broad K, Leiserowitz A, Weinkle J, Steketee M. 2007. Misinterpretations of the ''Cone of Uncertainty'' in Florida during the 2004 hurricane season. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society 88(5): 651-667.
12. Buizza R, Asensio H, Balint G, Bartholmes J, Bliefernicht J, Bogner K, Chavaux F, de Roo A, Donnadille J, Ducrocq V, Edlund C, Kotroni V, Krahe P, Kunz M, Lacire K, Lelay M, Marsigli C, Milelli M, Montani A, Pappenberger F, Rabufetti D, Ramos MH, Ritter B, Schipper JW, Steiner P, Thielen-Del Pozzo J, Vincendon B. 2007. EURORISK/PREVIEW report on the technical quality, functional quality and forecast value of meteorological and hydrological forecasts. ECMWF Technical Memorandum 516, ECMWF Research Department: Shinfield Park, Reading, United Kingdom; 21 pages.
13. Changnon SA, Pielke RA, Changnon D, Sylves RT, Pulwarty R Jr. 2000. Human factors explain the increased losses from weather and climate extremes. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society 81(3): 437-442.
14. Cloke H, Pappenberger F. 2009. Ensemble flood forecasting: a review. Journal of Hydrology 375(3-4): 613-626.
15. Cŕeton-Cazanave L. 2009. Warning! The use of meteorological information during a flash-flood warning process. Advances in Science and Research 3: 99-103.
16. Demeritt D, Cloke H, Pappenberger F, Thielen J, Bartholmes J, Ramos MH. 2007. Ensemble predictions and perceptions of risk, uncertainty, and error in flood forecasting. Environmental Hazards 7(2): 115-127.
17. Dietrich J, Trepte S, Wang Y, Schumann AH, Voß F, Hesser FB, Denhard M. 2008. Combination of different types of ensembles for the adaptive simulation of probabilistic flood forecasts: hindcasts for the Mulde 2002 extreme event. Nonlinear Processes in Geophysics 15(2): 275-286.
18. Faulkner H, Parker D, Green C, Beven K. 2007. Developing a translational discourse to communicate uncertainty in flood risk between science and the practitioner. Ambio: A Journal of the Human Environment 36: 692-703.
19. Gigerenzer G, Hertwig R, van den Broek E, Fasolo B, Katsikopoulos KV. 2005. ''A 30% Chance of Rain Tomorrow'': how does the public understand probabilistic weather forecasts? Risk Analysis 25(3): 623-629.
20. Golding BW. 2009. Uncertainty propagation in a London flood simulation. Journal of Flood Risk Management 2(1): 2-15.
21. Guha-Sapir D, Hargitt D, Hoyois P. 2004. Thirty Years of Natural Disasters 1974-2003: the Numbers. Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters, UCL Presses Universitaires de Louvain: Louvain, Belgium; 190 page. http://www.emdat.net/documents/Publication/publication_2004_emdat.pdf. [Accessed April 2010].
22. Handmer J, Proudley B. 2007. Communicating uncertainty via probabilities: the case of weather forecasts. Environmental Hazards 7: 79-87.
23. Hartmann HC, Bales R, Sorooshian S. 2002. Weather, climate, and hydrologic forecasting for the US Southwest: a survey. Climate Research 21: 239-258.
24. He Y, Wetterhall F, Cloke HL, Pappenberger F, Wilson M, Freer J, McGregor G. 2009. Tracking the uncertainty in flood alerts driven by grand ensemble weather predictions. Meteorological Applications 16: 91-101.
25. Houdant B. 2004. Contribution á l'amélioration de la prévision hydrométéorologique opérationnelle. Pour l'usage des probabilités dans la communication entre acteurs [Contribution to the improvement of operational hydrometeorological forecasting. For the use of probability in the communication between actors], PhD thesis, ENGREF, EDF, Grenoble, France; 209 page (in French).
26. Jaun S, Ahrens B. 2009. Evaluation of a probabilistic hydrometeorological forecast system. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 13: 1031-1043.
27. Joslyn SL, Nadav-Greenberg L, Taing MU, Nichols RM. 2009. The effects of wording on the understanding and use of uncertainty information in a threshold forecasting decision. Applied Cognitive Psychology 23(1): 55-72.
28. Kelman I, Spence R. 2003. A flood failure flowchart for buildings. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers: Municipal Engineer 156(3): 207-214.
29. Kloprogge P, van der Sluijs J, Wardekker A. 2007. Uncertainty communication: issues and good practice. Report NWS-E-2007-199, Department of Science, Technology and Society, Utrecht University: Utrecht, The Netherlands; 64 page.
30. Knight L (ed.) 2009. World Disasters Report 2009 - Focus on Early Warning, Early Action. International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, ATAR Roto Presse: Satigny/Vernier, Switzerland; 210 page. http://www.ifrc.org. [Accessed April 2010].
31. Komma J, Reszler C, Blöschl G, Haiden T. 2007. Ensemble prediction of floods - catchment non-linearity and forecast probabilities. Natural Hazards Earth System Sciences 7: 431-444.
32. Krzysztofowicz R. 2001. The case for probabilistic forecasting in hydrology. Journal of Hydrology 249(1-4): 2-9.
33. Krzysztofowicz R. 2002. Bayesian system for probabilistic river stage forecasting. Journal of Hydrology 268(1-4): 16-40.
34. Lugiez F, Guillot P. 1960. Dix annees de previsions d'apportsa Electricite de France. IAHS-AISH Publication 51: 558-566.
35. McCarthy S, Tunstall S, Parker D, Faulkner H, Howe J. 2007. Risk communication in emergency response to a simulated extreme flood. Environmental Hazards 7(3): 179-192.
36. McMillan HK, Brasington J. 2008. End-to-end flood risk assessment: a coupled model cascade with uncertainty estimation. Water Resources Research 44(3): W03419. DOI: 10.1029/2007WR005995.
37. Mantovan P, Todini E. 2006. Hydrological forecasting uncertainty assessment: incoherence of the GLUE methodology. Journal of Hydrology 330: 368-381.
38. Mathevet T, Garavaglia F, Garçon R, Gailhard J, Paquet E. 2009. Operational hydrological ensemble forecasts in France. Recent development of the French Hydropower Company (EDF), taking into account rainfall and hydrological model uncertainties. Geophysical Research Abstracts, Vol. 11, EGU2009-10248.
39. Montanari A, Brath A. 2004. A stochastic approach for assessing the uncertainty of rainfall-runoff simulations. Water Resources Research 40: W01106. DOI: 10.1029/2003WR002540.
40. Morss RE, Demuth JL, Lazo JK. 2008. Communicating uncertainty in weather forecasts: a survey of the U.S. public. Weather and Forecasting 23: 974-991.
41. Morss RE, Wahl E. 2007. An ethical analysis of hydrometeorological prediction and decision making: the case of the 1997 red river flood. Environmental Hazards 7: 342-352.
42. Murphy AH. 1993. What is a good forecast? An essay on the nature of goodness in weather forecasting. Weather and Forecasting 8: 281-293.
43. NRC (National Research Council). 2006. Completing the Forecast: Characterizing and Communicating Uncertainty for Better Decisions Using Weather and Climate Forecasts. Committee on Estimating and Communicating Uncertainty in Weather and Climate Forecasts, National Research Council, The National Academies Press: Washington, D.C.; 124 page. www.nap.edu. [Accessed April 2010].
44. Obled C, Bontron G, Garçon R. 2002. Quantitative precipitation forecasts: a statistical adaptation of model outputs though an analogues sorting approach. Atmospheric Research 63: 303-324.
45. Olsson J, Lindström G. 2008. Evaluation and calibration of operational hydrological ensemble forecasts in Sweden. Journal of Hydrology 350: 14-24.
46. Önkal D, Goodwin P, Thomson M, Gönül S, Pollock A. 2009. The relative influence of advice from human experts and statistical methods on forecast adjustments. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 22(4): 390-409.
47. Pappenberger F, Beven KJ. 2006. Ignorance is bliss: or 7 reasons not to use uncertainty analysis. Water Resources Research 42: W05302; DOI: 10.1029/2005WR004820.
48. Pappenberger F, Beven KJ, Hunter MN, Bates PD, Gouweleeuw BT, Thielen J, de Roo APJ. 2005. Cascading model uncertainty from medium range weather forecasts (10 days) through a rainfall-runoff model to flood inundation predictions within the European Flood Forecasting System (EFFS). Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 9(4): 381-393.
49. Pitt M. 2008. The Pitt review: learning lessons from the 2007 floods. Cabinet Office, 22 Whitehall, London SW1A 2WH; 462 page. http://archive.cabinetoffice.gov.uk/. [Accessed April 2010].
50. Ramos MH, Bartholmes J, Thielen J. 2007. Development of decision support products based on ensemble weather forecasts in the European Flood Alert System. Atmospheric Science Letters 8(4): 113-119.
51. Renner M, Werner MGF, Rademacher S, Sprokkereef E. 2009. Verification of ensemble flow forecasts for the River Rhine. Journal of Hydrology 376: 463-475.
52. Romanowicz RJ, Beven KJ, Young PC. 2006. Uncertainty propagation in a sequential model for flood forecasting. IAHS-AISH Publication 303: 177-184.
53. Roulston MS, Bolton GE, Kleit AN, Sears-Collins AL. 2006. A laboratory study of the benefits of including uncertainty information in weather forecasts. Weather and Forecasting 21(1): 116-122.
54. Schaefli B, Balin Talamba D, Musy A. 2007. Quantifying hydrological modeling errors through a mixture of normal distributions. Journal of Hydrology 332: 303-315.
55. Thielen J, Bartholmes J, Ramos MH, de Roo A. 2009a. The European flood alert system - part 1: concept and development. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 13(2): 125-140.
56. Thielen J, Bogner K, Pappenberger F, Kalas M, del Medico M, de Roo A. 2009b. Monthly-, medium-, and short-range flood warning: testing the limits of predictability. Meteorological Applications 16(1): 77-90.
57. Thielen J, Ramos MH, Bartholmes J, de Roo A, Cloke H, Pappenberger F, Demeritt D. 2005. Summary report of the 1st EFAS workshop on the use of Ensemble Prediction System in flood forecasting, 21-22nd November 2005, Ispra. European Report EUR 22118 EN, European Communities: Italy; 23page. http://floods.jrc.ec.europa.eu/efas-documents. [Accessed April 2010].
58. Thirel G, Rousset-Regimbeau F, Martin E, Habets F. 2008. On the impacts of short-range meteorological forecasts for ensemble stream flow predictions. Journal of Hydrolometerology 9(6): 1301-1317.
59. Todini E. 2004. Role and treatment of uncertainty in real-time flood forecasting. Hydrological Processes 18(14): 2743-2746.
60. Wahlström M. 2009. Disaster risk reduction, climate risk management and sustainable development. WMO Bulletin 58(3): 165-174.
61. WMO (World Meteorological Organization). 2008. Guidelines on communicating forecast uncertainty. Technical document PWS-18 WMO/TD 1422; 25page. www.wmo.int. [Accessed April 2010].
62. WMO (World Meteorological Organization). 2009. Conference statement - Summary of the expert segment. World Climate Conference- 3. Geneva, 31 August - 4 September 2009, Conference statement, Summary of the Expert Segment, 41page. http://www.wmo.int/wcc3. [Accessed April 2010].
63. Zorita E, von Storch H. 1999. The analog method as a simple statistical downscaling technique: comparison with more complicated methods. Journal of Climate 12: 2474-2489.