Accounting for privatisation in Africa? Reflections from a critical interdisciplinary perspective

Critical Perspectives on Accounting

Volumn 21, Issue 5, 2010, Pages 374-389

  Josiah, Jairos ^a,b   Burton, Bruce ^a   Gallhofer, Sonja ^a   Haslam, Jim ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF DUNDEE   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF BOTSWANA   (Botswana)

Author keywords

Accounting; Interdisciplinary perspective; Privatisation

Indexed keywords

EID: 77952745121     PISSN: 10452354     EISSN: 10959955     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cpa.2009.09.002     Document Type: Article

References (129)

1. Action Aid. Turning off the taps: donor conditionality and water privatization in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. London: Action Aid; 2009.
2. Adams S. The impact of privatization on economic growth and income inequality in sub-Saharan Africa. The Journal of Social Political and Economic Studies 2006, 31(3):295-320.
3. Adams S., Mengistu B. The political economy of privatization in sub-Saharan Africa. Social Science Quarterly 2008, 89(1):78-94.
4. Al-Obaidan A.M. Efficiency effect of privatization in the developing countries. Applied Economics 2002, 34(1):111-117.
5. Andreasson B. Privatization in sub-Saharan Africa: has it worked and what lesson can be learnt? Gothenburg: Swedish Development Advisers; 1998, Swedish Development website, retrieved August 1, 2009 from http://www.swededevelop.com/.
6. Antonio R.J. Immanent critique as the core of Critical Theory: its origins and developments in Hegel, Marx and contemporary thought. British Journal of Sociology 1981, 32(3):330-345.
7. Appiah-Kubi K. State-owned enterprises and privatisation in Ghana. The Journal of Modern African Studies 2001, 39(2):197-229.
8. Ariyo A., Jerome A. Privatization in Africa: an appraisal. World Development 1999, 27(1):201-213.
9. Arnold P.J., Cooper C. A tale of two classes: the privatisation of Medway Ports. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 1999, 10(2):127-152.
10. Banerjee S.G., Rondinelli D.A. Does foreign aid promote privatization? Empirical evidence from developing countries. World Development 2003, 31(9):1527-1548.
11. Barnes P.A., Chakravarty S.P., Haslam J. Bargaining power, dissimulation and takeovers in a rational market with asymmetric information. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 1990, 17(4):529-539.
12. Barnett S. Evidence on the fiscal and macroeconomic impact of privatisation. IMF Working Paper 2000. Washington, DC: International Monetary Fund.
13. Basu P.K. Demystifying privatization in developing countries. International Journal of Public Sector Management 1994, 7(3):44-55.
14. Bayliss K. Utility privatisation in sub-Saharan Africa: a case study of water. Journal of Modern African Studies 2003, 41(4):507-531.
15. Bennell P. Privatization in sub-Saharan Africa: progress and prospects during the 1990s. World Development 1997, 25(11):1785-1803.
16. Benson J.S. The impact of privatization on access in Tanzania. Social Science & Medicine 2001, 52(12):1903-1915.
17. Bernstein R.J. The restructuring of social and political theory 1976, Basil Blackwell, London.
18. Birdsall N., Nellis J. Winners and losers: assessing the distributional impact of privatization. World Development 2003, 31(10):1617-1633.
19. Bortolotti B., D'Souza J., Fantini M., Megginson W.L. Privatization and the sources of performance improvement in the global telecommunications industry. Telecommunications Policy 2002, 26(5-6):243-268.
20. Bös D. Privatization and development. Review of Development Economics 1997, 1(3):337-354.
21. Boubakri N., Cosset J.C. The financial and operating performance of newly privatized firms: evidence from developing countries. The Journal of Finance 1999, 53(3):1081-1110.
22. Boubakri N., Cosset J.C. Does privatisation meet the expectations in developing countries? A survey and some evidence from Africa. Journal of African Economies 2002, 11(Suppl. 1):111-140.
23. Buchanan J. The theory of public choice 1972, University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, MI.
24. Buchanan J. From private preferences to public philosophy: the development of public choice. The economics of politics 1978, 1-20. Institute of Economic Affairs, London. J. Buchanan (Ed.).
25. Budds J., McGranahan G. Are the debates on water privatization missing the point? Experiences from Africa, Asia and Latin America. Environment and Urbanization 2003, 15(2):87-114.
26. Calhoun C. Critical social theory: culture, history and the challenge of the difference 1996, Blackwell, Oxford.
27. Callon M. Some elements of a sociology of translation: domestication of the scallops and the fishermen of St Brieuc Bay. Power, action and belief: a new sociology of knowledge? 1986, 196-223. Routledge, London. J. Law (Ed.).
28. Carter C., Mueller F. The colonisation of strategy: financialisation in a post-privatisation context. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 2006, 17(8):967-985.
29. Catchpowle L., Cooper C. No escaping the financial: the economic referent in South Africa. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 1999, 10(3):317-329.
30. Chirwa E.W. Privatisation and technical efficiency: evidence from the manufacturing sector in Malawi. African Development Review 2001, 13(2):276-307.
31. Christian Aid Master or servant 2001, Christian Aid, London.
32. Christian Aid Power and poverty: world bank energy reform and poor people 2007, Christian Aid, London.
33. Cole B., Cooper C. Deskilling in the 21st century: the case of rail privatisation. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 2006, 17(5):601-625.
34. Conteh C. Reconciling public sector efficiency with equitable governance: the case of Botswana at the crossroads. CPSA Conference (with permission); 2006.
35. Cook P., Uchida Y. Privatisation and economic growth in developing countries. The Journal of Development Studies 2003, 39(6):121-154.
36. Craig J. Putting privatisation into practice: the case of Zambia Consolidated Copper Mines Limited. The Journal of Modern African Studies 2001, 39(3):389-410.
37. Craig R., Amernic J. The deployment of accounting-related rhetoric in the prelude to a privatization. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 2004, 17(1):41-58.
38. Crammer C. Privatisation and adjustment in Mozambique: a 'hospital pass'?. Journal of Southern African Studies 2001, 27(1):79-103.
39. Crompton G., Jupe R. Such a silly scheme: the privatisation of Britain's railways 1992-2002. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 2003, 14(6):617-645.
40. Cuervo A., Villalonga B. Explaining the variance in the performance effects of privatization. Academy of Management Review 2000, 25(3):581-590.
41. Cullis A, Watson C. Winners and losers: privatising the commons in Botswana. International Institute for Environment and Development Securing the Commons Series No. 9. London; 2005.
42. Due J., Temu A. Changes in employment by gender and business organization in newly privatized companies in Tanzania. Canadian Journal of Development Studies 2002, 23(2):317-333.
43. Easterly W. The elusive quest for growth 2001, The MIT Press, Cambridge MA.
44. Estache A. 2004. Emerging infrastructure policy issues in developing countries: a survey of the recent economic literature. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 3442; 2004.
45. Estes R. Publica or privatus: pro whose bono?. Advances in Public Interest Accounting 1990, 3:33-42.
46. Filipovic A. Impact of privatization on economic growth. Issues in Political Economy 2005, 14:1-22.
47. Fine B. Privatization: theory and lessons from the UK and South Africa. Seoul Journal of Economics 1997, 10(4):373-414.
48. Foster T.H., Mouly V.S. Privatisation in a developing country: insights from the Gambia. Journal of Organisational Change Management 2006, 19(2):250-265.
49. Fundanga CM, Mwaba A. Privatization of public enterprises in Zambia: an evaluation of the policies, procedures and experiences. African Development Bank: Economic Research Papers No. 35; 1997.
50. Galal A., Shirley M. Overview-does privatisation deliver: highlights from World Bank conference 1994, The World Bank, Washington DC.
51. Gallhofer S., Haslam J. The aura of accounting in the context of crisis: Germany and the First World War. Accounting, Organisations and Society 1991, 16(5/6):487-520.
52. Gallhofer S., Haslam J. Beyond accounting: the possibilities of accounting and critical accounting research. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 1997, 8(1/2):71-95.
53. Gallhofer S., Haslam J. Accounting and emancipation: some critical interventions 2003, Routledge, London.
54. Gallhofer S., Haslam J. The accounting-globalisation interrelation: an overview with some reflections on the neglected dimension of emancipatory potentiality. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 2006, 17(7):903-934.
55. Gallhofer S., Haslam J. Exploring social, political and economic dimensions of accounting in the global context: the International Accounting Standards Board and accounting disaggregation. Socio-Economic Review 2007, 5(4):633-664.
56. Geddes M. The social audit movement. Green reporting: the challenge of the nineties 1992, Chapman and Hall, London. D. Owen (Ed.).
57. Goldman M. How " Water for all!" policy became hegemonic: the power of the World Bank and its transnational policy networks. Geoforum 2007, 38(5):786-800.
58. Gray R., Owen D., Adams C. Accounting & accountability: changes and challenges in corporate social and environmental reporting 1996, FT Prentice Hall, Harlow.
59. Gray P. Private participation in infrastructure: a review of the evidence 2001, World Bank, Washington DC.
60. Greenwald B., Stiglitz J.E. Externalities in economies with imperfect information and incomplete markets. Quarterly Journal of Economics 1986, 101(2):229-264.
61. Grossman S., Stiglitz J.E. Stockholder unanimity in the making of production and financial decisions. Quarterly Journal of Economics 1980, 94(3):543-566.
62. Hanke S.H. Privatization and development 1987, Institute for Contemporary Studies Press, San Francisco CA.
63. Harte G., Owen D. Fighting de-industrialisation: the role of local government social audits. Accounting, Organizations and Society 1987, 12(2):123-141.
64. Held D. Introduction to critical theory: Horkheimer to Habermas 1980, Hutchison, London.
65. Held D., McGrew A. The great globalisation debate: an introduction. The global transformations reader 2000, Blackwell Publishers, Oxford. Held, McGrew (Eds.).
66. Hentz J.J. The two faces of privatisation: political and economic logics in transitional South Africa. The Journal of Modern African Studies 2000, 38(2):203-223.
67. Hopwood A.G. On trying to study accounting in the contexts in which it operates. Accounting, Organizations and Society 1983, 8(2/3):287-305.
68. Hopwood A.G., Miller P. Accounting as social and institutional practice 1994, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
69. How A. Critical theory 2003, Palgrave MacMillan, Basingstoke.
70. Institute for Workers Control. Upper Clyde shipbuilders: a social audit. London: IWC; 1971.
71. Institute for Workers Control. Why Imperial Typewriters must not close. London: IWC; 1975.
72. Jay M. The dialectical imagination: a history of Frankfurt School and Institute of Social Research, 1923-1950 1973, Heinemann Educational Books, London.
73. Jensen M.C., Meckling W. theory of the firm: managerial behaviour, agency costs and capital structure. Journal of Financial Economics 1976, 3(4):305-360.
74. Jerome A. Privatisation and regulation in South Africa: an evaluation. 3rd International conference on pro-poor regulation and competition: issues, policies and practices 2004.
75. Jones L., Jammal Y., Gollgur N. Impact of privatization in Cote d'Ivoire: Draft final report. Boston Institute for Developing Economies 1998, Boston University, Boston, MA.
76. Jupe R. A 'fresh start' or the 'worst of all worlds'? A critical financial analysis of the performance and regulation of Network Rail in Britain's privatised railway system. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 2009, 20(2):175-202.
77. Jupe R., Crompton G. A deficient performance: the regulation of the train operating companies in Britain's privatised railway system. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 2006, 17(8):1035-1065.
78. K'akumu O.A. Privatization of the urban water supply in Kenya: policy options for the poor. Environment and Urbanization 2004, 16(2):213-222.
79. Lehman C.R. Accounting's changing role in social conflict 1992, Marcus Weiner, New York.
80. Llewellyn S. Managing the boundary: how accounting is implicated in maintaining the organisation. Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal 1994, 7(4):4-23.
81. Margolis H. Selfishness, altruism and rationality: a theory of social choice 1982, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
82. Mason B., Talbot C. What water privatization means for Africa 2002, International Committee of the Fourth International, London.
83. Megginson W.L., Netter M.J. From state to market: a survey of empirical studies on privatization. Journal of Economic Literature 2001, 39(2):321-389.
84. Menard C., Clarke G. A transitory regime: water supply in Conakry, Guinea. Thirsting for efficiency: the economics and politics of urban water system reform 2002, 273-316. World Bank, Washington DC. M. Shirley (Ed.).
85. Mothusi B., Dipholo K. Privatisation in Botswana: the demise of a development state?. Public Administration and Development 2008, 28(3):239-249.
86. Nellis J. Privatization in Africa: what has happened? What is to be done?. Privatization: successes and failures 2008, 109-135. Columbia University Press, New York NY. G. Roland (Ed.).
87. Newcastle City Council. Newcastle upon Tyne social audit 1979-1984. Newcastle: Newcastle City Council; 1985.
88. Nwankwo S. Public-to-private organizational transition: a reconceptualisation of conventional paradigms. International Journal of Social Economics 1996, 23(7):25-38.
89. Nwankwo S., Richards D.C. Privatization-the myth of free market orthodoxy in sub-Saharan Africa. International Journal of Public Sector Management 2001, 14(2):165-180.
90. O'Connor B. Adorno's negative dialectic: philosophy and the possibility of critical rationality 2004, The MIT Press, London.
91. Okeahialam C.C., Kedslie M.J. Privatisation and the further development of accounting policy in Africa. Research in Accounting in Emerging Economies 1999, 1(Supplement):157-172.
92. Pallot J. The role of accounting in the privatisation of state trading enterprises in New Zealand. Advances in Public Interest Accounting 1998, 7:161-191.
93. Parker D., Kirkpatrick C. Privatisation in developing countries: a review of the evidence and the policy lessons. The Journal of Development Studies 2005, 41(4):513-541.
94. Perroti E.C., van Oijen P. Privatization, political risk and stock market development in emerging economies. Journal of International Money and Finance 2001, 20(1):43-69.
95. Plane P Productive efficiency of public enterprises: a macroeconomic analysis based on cross section estimates of a neo-classical production function. Applied Economics 1992, 24(8):833-844.
96. Plane P. Privatisation and economic growth: an empirical investigation from a sample of developing market economies. Applied Economics 1997, 29(2):161-178.
97. Plane P. Privatization, technical efficiency and welfare consequences: the case of the Cote d'Ivoire Electricity Company (CIE). World Development 1999, 27(2):343-360.
98. Puxty A.G. The social and organisational context of management accounting 1993, CIMA/Academic Press, London.
99. Puxty A.G. Accounting choice and a theory of crisis: the cases of post-privatisation of British Telecom and British Gas. Accounting, Organizations and Society 1997, 22(7):713-735.
100. Rahaman A.S., Everett J., Neu D. Accounting and the move to privatize water services in Africa. Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal 2007, 20(5):637-670.
101. Ramamurti R. Why haven't developing countries privatized deeper and faster?. World Development 1999, 27(1):137-155.
102. Redda BM. Post-privatisation changes in management control, firm activities and performance: the case of Eritrea-based firms. Unpublished PhD thesis: Department of Accounting, University of Groningen, Netherlands; 2007.
103. Rodriguez-Claire A. Multinationals, linkages and economic development. American Economic Review 1999, 86(4):852-873.
104. Rowthorn B., Ward J. How to run a company and run down an economy-the effects of closing down steelmaking in Corby. Cambridge Journal of Economics 1979, 3(4):327-340.
105. Saal D.S., Parker D. Productivity and price performance in the privatized water and sewerage companies of England and Wales. Journal of Regulatory Economics 2001, 20(1):61-90.
106. Sappington D., Stiglitz J.E. Privatisation, information and incentives. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 1987, 6(4):567-582.
107. Self P Government by the market? The politics of public choice 1993, Macmillan, Basingstoke.
108. Services to Community Action and Trade Unions. The Public cost of private contractors. Sheffield: SCAT; 1985.
109. Shaoul J. The power of accounting: reflecting on water privatisation. Accounting, Auditing and Accountability 1997, 10(3):382-405.
110. Shaoul J. A critical financial analysis of the performance of privatised industries: the case of the water industry in England and Wales. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 1997, 8(5):479-505.
111. Sheffield City Council. Sheffield Jobs Audit. Sheffield: Sheffield City Council; 1985.
112. Sheshinski E., López-Calva L.F. Privatization and its benefits: theory and evidence. CESifo Economic Studies 2003, 49(3):429-459.
113. Skærbæk P., Melander P. The politics of the changing forms of accounting: a field study of strategy translation in a Danish government-owned company under privatisation. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 2004, 1(1):17-40.
114. Stephen F.H., Backhaus J.G. Corporate governance and mass privatisation: a theoretical investigation of transformations in legal and economic relationships. Journal of Economic Studies 2003, 30(3/4):389-468.
115. Stiglitz J.E. Foreword. Privatization: successes and failures 2008, Columbia University Press, New York NY. G. Roland (Ed.).
116. Stittle J. Accounting for UK rail freight track charges: privatisation, politics and the pursuit of private sector vested interests. Accounting Forum 2004, 28(4):403-425.
117. Tanyi G. Designing privatization strategies in Africa-law, economics and practice 1997, Praeger Editions, New York.
118. Temu A., Due J. The success of newly privatized companies: new evidence from Tanzania. Canadian Journal of Development Studies 1998, 19(2):315-341.
119. Tinker T. Social accounting for corporations: private enterprise versus the accounting interest 1984, Manchester University Press, Manchester.
120. Transport and General Workers Union. Let's take on the takeovers. London: TGWU; 1986.
121. Tsamenyi M., Onumah J., Tetteh-Kumah E. Post privatization performance and organizational changes. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 2010, 21(5):428-442.
122. Tyrall D., Parker D. The fragmentation of a railway: a study of organizational change. Journal of Management Studies 2005, 42(3):507-537.
123. Uddin S., Hopper T. Accounting for privatisation in Bangladesh: testing the World Bank claims. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 2003, 14(7):739-774.
124. Vavrus F. Making distinctions: privatisation and the (un)educated girl on Mount Kilimanjaro, Tanzania. International Journal of Educational Development 2002, 22(5):527-547.
125. Wallsten S.J. An econometric analysis of telecom competition, privatisation, and regulation in Africa and Latin America. The Journal of Industrial Economics 2001, 49(1):1-19.
126. White S.K. The recent work of Jürgen Habermas: reason, justice and modernity 1988, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
127. World Bank Bureaucrats in business 1995, The World Bank, Washington, DC.
128. Yoder R., Borkholder P., Friesen B.D. Privatization and development: the empirical evidence. Journal of Developing Areas 1991, 25:425-434.
129. Zhang Y.F., Parker D., Kirkpatrick C. Electricity sector reform in developing countries: an econometric assessment of the effects of privatization, competition and regulation. Journal of Regulatory Economics 2008, 33(2):159-178.