A "fresh start" or the "worst of all worlds"? A critical financial analysis of the performance and regulation of Network Rail in Britain's privatised railway system

Critical Perspectives on Accounting

Volumn 20, Issue 2, 2009, Pages 175-204

  Jupe, Robert ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF KENT   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Corporate governance; Network Rail; Performance indicators; Railway privatisation; Regulation; Risk transfer

Indexed keywords

EID: 60849100205     PISSN: 10452354     EISSN: 10959955     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cpa.2008.05.002     Document Type: Article

References (94)

1. Alchian A.A. Some economics of property rights. Il Politico 30 (1995) 816-829
2. Averch H., and Johnson L. Behaviour of the firm under regulatory constraint. American Economic Review 52 5 (1962) 1052-1069
3. Bartle I. Britain's railway crisis: a review of the arguments in comparative perspective (2004), Centre for the Study of Regulated Industries, Bath
4. Baumol W.J., Panzar J.C., and Willig R.D. Contestable markets and the theory of industry structure (1982), Harcourt/Brace/Jovanovich, San Diago, CA
5. Beesley M., and Littlechild S. The regulation of private monopolies in the United Kingdom. Rand Journal of Economics 20 (1989) 454-472
6. Birchall J. A mutual trend: how to run rail and water in the public interest (2002), New Economics Foundation, London
7. Bishop M., and Thompson D.J. Regulatory reform and productivity growth in the UK's public utilities. Applied Economics 24 (1992) 1181-1190
8. Blair T. Speech at rail summit. February 25, 1999. Available at http://www.number-10.gov.uk/output/Page1285.asp.
9. Booz, Allen, and Hamilton. Railtrack's performance in the control period 1995-2001: final report (1999), ORR, London
10. Booz, Allen, and Hamilton. Railtrack's expenditure needs 2001-2006: report to office of the rail regulator (1999), ORR, London
11. Bradshaw W.P. The rail industry. In: Helm D., and Jenkinson T. (Eds). Competition in regulated industries (1998), Oxford University Press, Oxford 175-192
12. British Rail. Annual report and accounts 1993/94 (1994), BR, London
13. Bryer R.A. The history of accounting and the transition to capitalism in England. Part one: theory. Accounting, Organizations and Society 25 2 (2000) 131-162
14. Byers S. House of Commons debates, House of Commons Official report (Hansard). June 27, 2002, col.582.
15. Catchpowle L., Cooper C., and Wright A. Capitalism, states and accounting. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 15 8 (2004) 1037-1058
16. Clark A. Think tank lays into network rail structure. The Guardian (September 16, 2002) 2
17. Clement B. Network rail wasting billions, say train chiefs. The Independent (July 6 2006) 34
18. Cole B., and Cooper C. Deskilling in the 21st century: the case of rail privatisation. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 17 5 (2006) 601-625
19. Crompton G., and Jupe R. Such a silly scheme: the privatisation of Britain's railways 1992-2002. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 14 6 (2003) 617-645
20. Crompton G., and Jupe R. A lot of friction at the interfaces: the regulation of Britain's privatised railway system. Financial Accountability & Management 19 4 (2003) 397-418
21. Curwen P. Public enterprise: a modern approach (1986), Wheatsheaf, London
22. Department for Transport. A public-private partnership for National Air Traffic Services Limited (response), Cmnd 4702 (2000), The Stationery Office Limited, London
23. Department for Transport. The future of rail, Cmnd 6233 (2004), The Stationery Office Limited, London
24. Department for Transport. Delivering a sustainable railway, Cmnd 7176 (2007), The Stationery Office Limited, London
25. Department of Transport. New opportunities for the railways-the privatisation of BR, Cmnd 2012 (1992), HMSO, London
26. Dick B.W. Privatisation in the UK: the free market versus state control (1987), Longman, York
27. Dickson M. This sorry pantomime is no way to run a railway. Financial Times (November 17/18, 2001) 15
28. Eaglesham J. CBI launches savage attack on Treasury. Financial Times (February 27, 2008) 2
29. Editorial. Darling chained to the Rock: nationalisation of the bank is belated but correct. Financial Times (February 18, 2008) 10
30. Elliot L. Thousands of jobs to go at Northern Rock. The Guardian (February 19, 2008) 1-2
31. Flemming J., and Mayer C. The assessment: public-sector investment. Oxford Review of Economic Policy 13 4 (1997) 1-11
32. Furubotn E.G., and Pejovich S. Economics of property rights (1974), Ballinger, Cambridge, Mass
33. Giddens A. Where now for new labour? (2002), Polity Press, Cambridge
34. Glaister S. British rail privatisation: competition destroyed by politics (2004), Centre for the Study of Regulated Industries, Bath
35. Goodman J.B., and Loveman G.W. Does privatisation serve the public interest?. Harvard Business Review 69 6 (1991) 26-38
36. Gourvish T. British Rail 1974-97: from integration to privatisation (2002), Oxford University Press, Oxford
37. Grayling T. Getting back on track: reforming the ownership and regulation of Britain's railways (2001), Institute of Public Policy Research, London
38. Harris N.G., and Godward E. The privatisation of British Rail (1997), Railway Consultancy Press, London
39. Health and Safety Executive. Train derailment at Potters Bar Friday 10 May 2002: interim report. London: HSE; 2002.
40. House of Commons Select Committee on Environment, Transport and Regional Affairs. The proposed public-private partnership for National Air Traffic Services Limited, House of Commons Paper 35, Session 1999-00. London: The Stationery Office Limited; 2000.
41. House of Commons Select Committee on Environment, Transport and Regional affairs. Minutes of evidence and appendices, taken before the Transport Sub-Committee, House of Commons Paper 18-II, Session 2000-01. London: The Stationery Office Limited; 2001.
42. House of Commons Select Committee on Transport. The future of the railway, House of Commons Paper 145-I, vol. 1, Session 2003-04. London: The Stationery Office Limited; 2004.
43. House of Commons Select Committee on Public Accounts. Network Rail: making a fresh start, House of Commons Paper 556, Session 2004-05. London: The Stationery Office Limited; 2005.
44. House of Commons Select Committee on Transport. The London Underground and the public-private partnership agreements, House of Commons Paper 45, Session 2007-08. London: The Stationery Office; 2008.
45. Jackson P.M., and Price C. Privatisation and regulation: a review of the issues. In: Jackson P.M., and Price C. (Eds). Privatisation and regulation: a review of the issues (1994), Longman Group Limited, Essex 1-34
46. Jupe R. The future of rail? An evaluation of the 2004 railway industry white paper. Public Money & Management 26 3 (2005) 187-194
47. Jupe R., and Crompton G. A deficient performance: the regulation of the train operating companies in Britain's privatised railway system. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 17 8 (2006) 1035-1065
48. Kay J.A., and Thompson D.J. Privatisation: a policy in search of a rationale. The Economic Journal 96 (1986) 18-32
49. Leam D. All aboard: improving public service accountability (2002), Social Market Foundation, London
50. LEK, Halcrow, TTCI. Bottom-up review of Network Rail's business plan 2003/04-2005/06: report to Office of Rail Regulator. London: ORR; 2003.
51. Letza S., and Smallman C. In pure water there is a pleasure begrudged by none: on ownership, accountability and control in a privatised utility. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 12 1 (2001) 65-85
52. Letza S.R., Smallman C., and Sun X. Reframing privatisation: deconstructing the myth of efficiency. Policy Sciences 37 2 (2004) 159-183
53. Marsh D. Privatisation in Britain: an idea in search of a policy. Essex Papers in Politics and Government, No 72 (1990), Essex University, Essex
54. Martin S., and Parker D. Privatisation and economic performance throughout the UK business cycle. Managerial and Decision Economics 16 3 (1995) 225-237
55. Milner M. Railtrack shareholders lose court battle for compensation. The Guardian (October 15, 2005) 12
56. Mitchell W.C. Government as it is, Hobart Paper 109 (1988), Institute of Economic Affairs, London
57. Murray A. Off the rails (2001), Verso, London
58. National Audit Office. Ensuring that Railtrack maintain and renew the railway network, Paper HC 397, Session 1999-2000. London: The Stationery Office Limited; 2000.
59. National Audit Office. Network Rail: Making a fresh start, Paper HC 532, Session 2003-2004. London: The Stationery Office limited; 2004.
60. Nash C.A. Privatization and deregulation in railways: an assessment of the British approach. In: Bradshaw W.P., and Lawton Smith H. (Eds). Privatization and deregulation of transport (2000), Macmillan Press, London 159-176
61. Network Rail. Annual Report and Accounts 2002/03-2006/07. London: Network Rail; 2003-2007.
62. Network Rail. Business Plan Summary (2005), Network Rail, London
63. Network Rail. Being a member of Network Rail (2006), Network Rail, London
64. Network Rail. Business plan: delivering for our customers (2006), Network Rail, London
65. Newman C. Interview with Stephen Byers. Financial Times (October 23, 2001) 9
66. Niskanen W.A. Bureaucracy and representative government (1971), Aldine-Atherton, New York
67. Ogden S.G. Accounting for organizational performance: the construction of the customer in the privatized water industry. Accounting, Organizations and Society 22 6 (1997) 529-556
68. Office of Rail Regulator. The periodic review of Railtrack's access charges: final conclusions volume I (2000), ORR, London
69. ORR. Interim review of track access charges: draft conclusions (2003), ORR, London
70. Office of Rail Regulation. Statement on Network Rail's stewardship of the rail network 2003/04 (2004), ORR, London
71. Office of Rail Regulation. Periodic review 2008: initial assessment of Network Rail's CP4 revenue requirement and consultation on the financial framework (2005), ORR, London
72. Office of Rail Regulation. Annual Report 2005-2006 (2006), ORR, London
73. Office of Rail Regulation. Annual assessment of Network Rail 2005-2006 (2006), ORR, London
74. Office of Rail Regulation. National rail trends yearbook 2006-2007 (2007), ORR, London
75. Office of Rail Regulation. Report of ORR's investigation into engineering overruns (2008), ORR, London
76. Osborne A. Passengers have no say over pay, says rail boss. Daily Telegraph (July 22, 2004) 34
77. Osborne A. Tories demand better governance of Network Rail. Daily Telegraph Business Section (May 29, 2007) 1
78. Rahaman A.S., Everett J., and Neu D. Accounting and the move to privatize water services in Africa. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 20 5 (2007) 637-670
79. Rail Accident Investigation Branch. Train Derailment at Grayrigg, Cumbria, February 23, 2007 (2007), RAIB, Derby
80. Railtrack Group plc. Annual Report and Accounts 1995/96-2000/01. London: Railtrack; 1996-2001.
81. Shaoul J. A critical financial analysis of the performance of privatised industries: the case of the water industry in England and Wales. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 8 5 (1997) 479-505
82. Shaoul J. Critical financial analysis and accounting for shareholders. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 9 2 (1998) 235-249
83. Shaoul J. Railpolitik: the financial realities of operating Britain's national railways. Public Money & Management 24 1 (2004) 27-36
84. Shaoul J. A critical financial analysis of the Private Finance Initiative; selecting a financing method or allocating economic wealth?. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 16 4 (2005) 441-471
85. Smith R.A. High-speed railways for the UK. The Utilities Journal 6 3 (2003) 36-38
86. Strangleman T. Work identity at the end of the line? Privatisation and culture change in the UK rail industry (2004), Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke
87. Strategic Rail Authority. Towards a safer better bigger railway: annual report 2000-2001 (2001), SRA, London
88. Strategic Rail Authority (SRA). National rail trends 2003-2004 (2001), SRA, London
89. Vass P. Establishing a conceptual framework for regulated industries' accounting and accountability. Financial Accountability & Management 8 4 (1992) 299-315
90. Veblen T. Absentee Ownership (1924), George Allen & Unwin Limited, London
91. Villalonga B. Privatisation and efficiency: differentiating ownership effects from political, organisational and dynamic effects. Journal of Economic Behaviour and Organisation 42 (2000) 43-74
92. Welsby J., and Nichols A. The privatisation of Britain's railways: an inside view. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy 33 1 (1999) 55-76
93. Whitehouse L. Railtrack is dead-long live Network Rail? Nationalisation under the third way. Journal of Law and Society 30 2 (2003) 217-235
94. Wolmar C. On the wrong line: how ideology and incompetence wrecked Britain's railways (2005), Aurum Press, London