The group selection controversy

Journal of Evolutionary Biology

Volumn 23, Issue 1, 2010, Pages 6-19

  Leigh Jr , E G ^a  

^a SMITHSONIAN TROPICAL RESEARCH INSTITUTE   (Panama)

Author keywords

Common good; Cooperation; Fair meiosis; Green beards; Group selection; Kin selection; Levels of selection; Mutualism; Price's theorem; Superorganisms

Indexed keywords

ALTRUISM; ANIMAL; COOPERATIVE BEHAVIOR; EVOLUTIONARY BIOLOGY; GENOTYPE; GROUP SELECTION; KIN SELECTION; MUTUALISM; PHENOTYPE; RELATEDNESS;

ALTRUISM; ANIMAL; EVOLUTION; GENETIC SELECTION; GENOME; REVIEW;

ALTRUISM; ANIMALS; EVOLUTION; GENOME; SELECTION, GENETIC;

ANIMALIA;

EID: 72449156199     PISSN: 1010061X     EISSN: 14209101     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1420-9101.2009.01876.x     Document Type: Review

References (160)

1. Alexander, R.D. Borgia, G. 1978. Group selection, altruism, and the levels of organization of life. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 9 : 449 474.
2. Aoki, K. 1982. A condition for group selection to prevail over counteracting individual selection. Evolution 36 : 832 842.
3. Boehm, C. 1993. Egalitarian society and reverse dominance hierarchy. Curr. Anthropol. 34 : 227 254.
4. Boehm, C. 1997. Impact of the human egalitarian syndrome on Darwinian selection mechanics. Am. Nat. 150 : S100 S121.
5. Boehm, C. 1999. Hierarchy in the Forest: the Evolution of Egalitarian Behavior. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
6. Bonner, J.T. 2000. First Signals: The Evolution of Multicellular Development. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
7. Boomsma, J.J. 2007. Kin selection versus sexual selection: why the ends do not meet. Curr. Biol. 17 : R673 R683.
8. Bourke, A.F.G. Franks, N.R. 1995. Social Evolution in Ants. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
9. Bulmer, M.G. Taylor, P.D. 1980. Dispersal and the sex ratio. Nature 284 : 448 449.
10. Buss, L.W. 1987. The Evolution of Individuality. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
11. Charlesworth, B. Toro, M.A. 1982. Female-biased sex ratios. Nature 298 : 494.
12. Clark, A.B. 1978. Sex ratio and local resource competition in a prosimian primate. Science 201 : 163 165.
13. Clutton-Brock, T. 2002. Breeding together: kin selection and mutualism in cooperative vertebrates. Science 296 : 69 72.
14. Colwell, R.K. 1981. Group selection is implicated in female-biased sex ratios. Nature 290 : 401 404.
15. Corner, E.J.H. 1952. Wayside Trees of Malaya, 2nd edn. Government Printer, Singapore.
16. Corner, E.J.H. 1988. Wayside Trees of Malaya, 3rd edn. Malayan Nature Society, Kuala Lumpur.
17. Cosmides, L. Tooby, J. 1981. Cytoplasmic inheritance and intragenomic conflict. J. Theor. Biol. 89 : 83 129.
18. Crow, J.F. 1979. Genes that violate Mendel's rules. Sci. Am. 240 (2 134 146.
19. Crow, J.F. 1991. Why is Mendelian segregation so exact? BioEssays 13 : 305 312.
20. Crow, J.F. Aoki, K. 1982. Group selection for a polygenic behavioral trait: a differential proliferation model. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 79 : 2628 2631.
21. Crow, J.F. Aoki, K. 1984. Group selection for a polygenic behavioral trait: estimating the degree of population subdivision. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 81 : 6073 6077.
22. Darwin, C. 1859. On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection. John Murray, London.
23. Dawkins, R. 1976. The Selfish Gene. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
24. Dawkins, R. 1982. The Extended Phenotype. W. H. Freeman, New York.
25. Denny, A.J., Franks, N.R., Powell, S. Edwards, K.J. 2004. Exceptionally high levels of multiple mating in an army ant. Naturwissenschaften 91 : 396 399.
26. Dunbar, M.J. 1960. The evolution of stability in marine environments: natural selection at the level of the ecosystem. Am. Nat. 94 : 129 136.
27. Eberhard, W.G. 1980. Evolutionary consequences of intracellular organelle competition. Q. Rev. Biol. 55 : 231 249.
28. Emlen, S.T. Wrege, P.H. 1988. The role of kinship in helping decisions among white-fronted bee-eaters. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 23 : 305 315.
29. Ewens, W.J. 1989. An interpretation and proof of Fisher's fundamental theorem of natural selection. Theor. Popul. Biol. 36 : 167 180.
30. Fischer, E.A. 1980. The relationship between mating system and simultaneous hermaphroditism in the coral reef fish Hypoplectrus nigricans. Anim. Behav. 28 : 620 634.
31. Fischer, E.A. 1981. Sexual allocation in a simultaneously hermaphroditic coral reef fish. Am. Nat. 117 : 64 82.
32. Fischer, E.A. 1988. Simultaneous hermaphroditism, tit-for-tat, and the evolutionary stability of social systems. Ethol. Sociobiol. 9 : 119 136.
33. Fisher, R.A. 1930. The Genetical Theory of Natural Selection. Clarendon Press, Oxford.
34. Fisher, R.A. 1958. The Genetical Theory of Natural Selection, 2nd edn. Dover Press, New York.
35. Fletcher, J.A. Doebeli, M. 2006. How altruism evolves: assortment and synergy. J. Evol. Biol. 19 : 1389 1393.
36. Fletcher, J.A. Doebeli, M. 2009. A simple and general explanation for the evolution of altruism. Proc. R. Soc. B 276 : 13 19.
37. Fletcher, J.A. Zwick, M. 2006. Unifying the theories of inclusive fitness and reciprocal altruism. Am. Nat. 168 : 252 262.
38. Frank, S.A. 1986. Hierarchical selection theory and sex ratios. I. General solutions for structured populations. Theor. Popul. Biol. 29 : 312 342.
39. Frank, S.A. 1997. The Price equation, Fisher's fundamental theorem, kin selection, and causal analysis. Evolution 51 : 1712 1729.
40. Frank, S.A. 1998. Foundations of Social Evolution. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
41. Gadagkar, R. 1990. Evolution of eusociality: the advantage of assured fitness returns. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B 329 : 17 25.
42. Gardner, A. Grafen, A. 2009. Capturing the superorganism: a formal theory of group adaptation. J. Evol. Biol. 22 : 659 671.
43. Gardner, A., West, S.A. Barton, N.H. 2007. The relation between multilocus population genetics and social evolution theory. Am. Nat. 169 : 207 226.
44. Gilpin, M.E. 1975. Group Selection in Predator-Prey Communities. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
45. Goodnight, C.J. Stevens, L. 1997. Experimental studies of group selection: what do they tell us about group selection in nature? Am. Nat. 150 : S59 S79.
46. Grafen, A. 1985. Hamilton's rule OK. Nature 318 : 310 311.
47. Grafen, A. 2006. Optimisation of inclusive fitness. J. Theor. Biol. 238 : 541 563.
48. Haig, D. 1996. Gestational drive and the green-bearded placenta. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 93 : 6547 6551.
49. Hamilton, W.D. 1963. The evolution of altruistic behavior. Am. Nat. 97 : 354 356.
50. Hamilton, W.D. 1964a. The genetical evolution of social behavior I. J. Theor. Biol. 7 : 1 16.
51. Hamilton, W.D. 1964b. The genetical evolution of social behavior II. J. Theor. Biol. 7 : 17 51.
52. Hamilton, W.D. 1967. Extraordinary sex ratios. Science 156 : 477 488.
53. Hamilton, W.D. 1970. Selfish and spiteful behavior in an evolutionary model. Nature 228 : 1218 1220.
54. Hamilton, W.D. 1971. Selection of selfish and altruistic behaviour in some extreme models. In : Man and Beast: Comparative Social Behavior (J.F. Eisenberg W.S. Dillon, eds pp. 57 91. Smithsonian Press, Washington, DC.
55. Hamilton, W.D. 1972. Altruism and related phenomena, mainly in social insects. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 3 : 193 232.
56. Hamilton, W.D. 1975. Innate social aptitudes of man: an approach from evolutionary genetics. In : Biosocial Anthropology, ASA Studies 4 (R. Fox, ed pp. 133 153. Malaby Press, London.
57. Hamilton, W.D. 1987a. Discriminating nepotism: expectable, common, overlooked. In : Kin Recognition in Animals (D.J.C. Fletcher C.D. Michener, eds pp. 417 437. Wiley, New York.
58. Hamilton, W.D. 1987b. Kinship, recognition, disease, and intelligence: constraints of social evolution. In : Animal Societies: Theories and Facts (Y. Itô, J.L. Brown J. Kikkawa, eds pp. 81 102. Japan Scientific Societies Press, Tokyo.
59. Heinze, J., Hölldobler, B. Peeters, C. 1994. Conflict and cooperation in ant societies. Naturwissenschaften 81 : 489 497.
60. Helanterä, H. Bargum, K. 2007. Pedigree relatedness, not greenbeard genes, explains eusociality. Oikos 116 : 217 220.
61. Herre, E.A. 1985. Sex ratio adjustment in fig wasps. Science 228 : 896 898.
62. Herre, E.A. 1987. Optimality, plasticity and selective regime in fig wasp sex ratios. Nature 329 : 627 629.
63. Herre, E.A., Jandér, K.C. Machado, C.A. 2008. Evolutionary ecology of figs and their associates: recent progress and outstanding puzzles. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Evol. Syst. 39 : 439 458.
64. Hölldobler, B. Wilson, E.O. 1990. The Ants. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
65. Hölldobler, B. Wilson, E.O. 2009. The Superorganism. Norton, New York.
66. Hughes, W.O.H. Boomsma, J.J. 2004. Genetic diversity and disease resistance in leaf-cutting ant societies. Evolution 58 : 1251 1260.
67. Hughes, W.O.H. Boomsma, J.J. 2006. Does genetic diversity hinder parasite evolution in social insect colonies? J. Evol. Biol. 19 : 132 143.
68. Hughes, W.O.H., Sumner, S., Van Borm, S. Boomsma, J.J. 2003. Worker caste polymorphism has a genetic basis in Acromyrmex leaf-cutting ants. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 100 : 9394 9397.
69. Hughes, W.O.H., Oldroyd, B.P., Beekman, M. Ratnieks, F.L.W. 2008. Ancestral monogamy shows kin selection is key to the evolution of eusociality. Science 320 : 1213 1216.
70. Hunt, J.H. 2007. The Evolution of Social Wasps. Oxford University Press, New York.
71. Hurst, G.D.D. Werren, J.H. 2001. The role of selfish genetic elements in eukaryotic evolution. Nat. Genet. 2 : 597 606.
72. Keller, L. Ross, K.G. 1998. Selfish genes: a green beard in the red fire ant. Nature 394 : 973 975.
73. Kimura, M. 1983. Diffusion model of intergroup selection, with special reference to the evolution of an altruistic character. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 80 : 6317 6321.
74. Komdeur, J., Daan, S., Tinbergen, J. Mateman, C. 1997. Extreme adaptive modification in sex ratio of the Seychelles warbler's eggs. Nature 385 : 522 525.
75. Kropotkin, P. 1902. Mutual Aid: A Factor in Evolution. Heinemann, London.
76. Leigh, E.G., Jr. 1970. Sex ratio and differential mortality between the sexes. Am. Nat. 104 : 205 210.
77. Leigh, E.G., Jr. 1971. Adaptation and Diversity. Freeman Cooper, San Francisco, CA.
78. Leigh, E.G., Jr. 1977. How does selection reconcile individual advantage with the good of the group? Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 74 : 4542 4546.
79. Leigh, E.G., Jr. 1983. When does the good of the group override the advantage of the individual? Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 80 : 2985 2989.
80. Leigh, E.G., Jr. 1986. Ronald Fisher and the development of evolutionary theory. I. The role of selection. Oxf. Surv. Evol. Biol. 3 : 187 223.
81. Leigh, E.G., Jr. 1991. Genes, Bees and Ecosystems. Trends Ecol. Evol. 6 : 257 262.
82. Leigh, E.G., Jr. 1994. Do insect pests promote mutualism among tropical trees? J. Ecol. 82 : 677 680.
83. Leigh, E.G., Jr. 2000. Evolutionary biology and human altruism: a review of three books. Evolution 54 : 328 332.
84. Leigh, E.G., Jr. Rowell, T.E. 1995. The evolution of mutualism and other forms of harmony at various levels of biological organization. Écologie 26 : 131 158.
85. Leigh, E.G., Jr. Vermeij, G.J. 2002. Does natural selection organize ecosystems for the maintenance of higher productivity and diversity? Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B 357 : 709 718.
86. Leigh, E.G., Jr., Herre, E.A. Fischer, E.A. 1985. Sex allocation in animals. Experientia 41 : 1265 1275.
87. Levins, R. 1968. Evolution in Changing Environments. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
88. Lewontin, R.C. 1962. Interdeme selection controlling a polymorphism in the house mouse. Am. Nat. 96 : 65 78.
89. Lewontin, R.C. 1965. Selection in and of populations. In : Ideas in Modern Biology. Proceedings of the XVI International Congress of Zoology, Vol. 6 (J.A. Moore, ed.), pp. 299 311. Natural History Press, New York, NY.
90. Lewontin, R.C. 1970. The units of selection. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 1 : 1 18.
91. MacArthur, R.H. 1961. Population consequences of natural selection. Am. Nat. 95 : 195 199.
92. Margulis, L. 1993. Symbiosis in Cell Evolution. W. H. Freeman, New York.
93. Margulis, L. 1998. The Symbiotic Planet. Weidenfeld and Nicolson, London.
94. Martin, S.J., Beekman, M., Wossler, T.C. Ratnieks, F.L.W. 2002. Parasitic Cape honeybee workers. Apis mellifera capensis, evade policing. Nature 415 : 163 165.
95. Mattila, H.R. Seeley, T.D. 2007. Genetic diversity in honey bee colonies enhances productivity and fitness. Science 317 : 362 364.
96. Maynard Smith, J. 1964. Group selection and kin selection. Nature 201 : 1145 1147.
97. Maynard Smith, J. 1976. Group selection. Q. Rev. Biol. 51 : 277 283.
98. Maynard Smith, J. 1998. Unto others: the evolution and psychology of unselfish behavior (book review). Nature 393 : 639 640.
99. Maynard Smith, J. Szathmáry, E. 1995. The Major Transitions in Evolution. Freeman/Spektrum, Oxford.
100. Michod, R.E. Hamilton, W.D. 1980. Coefficients of relationship in sociobiology. Nature 288 : 694 697.
101. Moran, N.A., McCutcheon, J.P. Nakabachi, A. 2008. Genomics and evolution of heritable bacterial symbionts. Annu. Rev. Genet. 47 : 165 190.
102. Moran, P.A.P. 1962. The Statistical Processes of Evolutionary Theory. Clarendon Press, Oxford.
103. Murgia, C., Pritchard, J.K., Kim, S.Y., Fassatti, A. Weiss, R.A. 2006. Clonal origin and evolution of a transmissible disease. Cell 126 : 477 487.
104. Packer, C. Pusey, A.E. 1982. Cooperation and competition within coalitions of male lions: cooperation or game theory? Nature 296 : 740 742.
105. Packer, C., Gilbert, D.A., Pusey, A.E. O'Brien, S.J. 1991. A molecular genetic analysis of kinship and cooperation in African lions. Nature 351 : 562 565.
106. Packer, C., Pusey, A.E. Eberly, L.E. 2001. Egalitarianism in female African lions. Science 293 : 690 693.
107. Pearse, A.-M. Swift, K. 2006. Transmission of devil facial-tumour disease. Nature 439 : 549.
108. Price, G.R. 1970. Selection and covariance. Nature 227 : 520 521.
109. Price, G.R. 1972a. Extension of covariance selection mathematics. Ann. Hum. Genet. 35 : 485 490.
110. Price, G.R. 1972b. Fisher's 'fundamental theorem' made clear. Ann. Hum. Genet., 36 : 129 140.
111. Queller, D.C. 1985. Kinship, reciprocity and synergism in the evolution of social behavior. Nature 318 : 366 367.
112. Queller, D.C. 1989. The evolution of eusociality: reproductive head starts of workers. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 86 : 3224 3226.
113. Queller, D.C. 1992. A general model for kin selection. Evolution 46 : 376 380.
114. Queller, D.C., Ponte, E., Bozzaro, S. Strassmann, J.E. 2003. Single-gene greenbeard effects in the social amoeba Dictyostelium discoideum. Science 299 : 105 106.
115. Rankin, D.J., López-Sepulcre, A., Foster, K.R. Kokko, H. 2007. Species-level selection reduces selfishness through competitive exclusion. J. Evol. Biol. 20 : 1459 1468.
116. Ratnieks, F.L.W. 2006. The evolution of cooperation and altruism: the basic conditions are simple and well-known. J. Evol. Biol. 19 : 1413 1414.
117. Ratnieks, F.L.W. Visscher, P.K. 1989. Worker policing in the honeybee. Nature 342 : 796 798.
118. Ratnieks, F.L.W., Foster, K.R. Wenseleers, T. 2006. Conflict resolution in insect societies. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 51 : 581 608.
119. Seeley, T.D. 1995. The Wisdom of the Hive. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
120. Seeley, T.D. 1997. Honey bee colonies are group level adaptive units. Am. Nat. 150 : S22 S41.
121. Seeley, T.D. Tarpy, D.R. 2007. Queen promiscuity lowers disease within honeybee colonies. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 274 : 67 72.
122. Slatkin, M. Wade, M.J. 1978. Group selection on a quantitative character. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 75 : 3531 3534.
123. Sober, E. Wilson, D.S. 1998. Unto Others: The Evolution and Psychology of Unselfish Behavior. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
124. Sterck, E.H.M., Watts, D.P. van Schaik, C.P. 1997. The evolution of female social relationships in nonhuman primates. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 41 : 291 309.
125. Sturtevant, A.H. 1938. Essays on evolution II. On the effects of selection on social insects. Q. Rev. Biol. 13 : 74 76.
126. Szathmáry, E. Maynard Smith, J. 1995. The major evolutionary transitions. Nature 374 : 227 232.
127. Taylor, P.D. Frank, S.A. 1996. How to make a kin selection model. J. Theor. Biol. 180 : 27 37.
128. Taylor, P.D., Wild, G. Gardner, A. 2007. Direct fitness of inclusive fitness: how shall we model kin selection? J. Evol. Biol. 20 : 301 309.
129. Thorne, B.L. 1997. Evolution of eusociality in termites. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 28 : 27 54.
130. Trivers, R.L. Willard, D.E. 1973. Natural selection of parental ability to vary the sex ratio of offspring. Science 179 : 90 92.
131. Villesen, P., Murakami, T., Schultz, T.R. Boomsma, J.J. 2002. Identifying the transition between single and multiple mating of queens in fungus-growing ants. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 269 : 1541 1548.
132. Visscher, P.K. 1996. Reproductive conflict in honey bees: a stalemate of worker egg-laying and policing. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 39 : 237 244.
133. Wenseleers, T. Ratnieks, F.L.W. 2006. Enforced altruism in insect societies. Nature 444 : 50.
134. West Eberhard, M.J. 1975. The evolution of social behavior by kin selection. Q. Rev. Biol. 50 : 1 33.
135. West Eberhard, M.J. 1981. Intragroup selection and the evolution of insect societies. In : Natural Selection and Social Behavior: Recent Research and New Theory (R. Alexander D.W. Tinkle, eds pp. 3 17. Chiron Press, New York.
136. West Eberhard, M.J. 1987. Flexible strategy and social evolution. In : Animal Societies: Theories and Facts (Y. Itô, J.L. Brown J. Kikkawa, eds pp. 35 51. Japan Scientific Societies Press, Tokyo.
137. West Eberhard, M.J. 2003. Developmental Plasticity and Evolution. Oxford University Press, New York.
138. West, S.A. Herre, E.A. 1998. Stabilizing selection and variation in fig wasp sex ratios. Evolution 52 : 475 485.
139. West, S.A., Herre, E.A. Sheldon, B.C. 2000. The benefits of allocating sex. Science 290 : 288 290.
140. West, S.A., Shuker, D.M. Sheldon, B.C. 2005. Sex-ratio adjustment when relatives interact: a test of constraints on adaptation. Evolution 59 : 1211 1228.
141. West, S.A., Griffin, A.S. Gardner, A. 2007a. Social semantics: altruism, cooperation, mutualism, strong reciprocity and group selection. J. Evol. Biol. 20 : 415 432.
142. West, S.A., Griffin, A.S. Gardner, A. 2007b. Evolutionary explanations for cooperation. Curr. Biol. 17 : R661 R672.
143. West, S.A., Giffin, A.S. Gardner, A. 2008. How useful has group selection been? J. Evol. Biol. 22 : 374 385.
144. Wheeler, W.M. 1928. The Social Insects. Harcourt Brace, New York.
145. Williams, G.C. 1966. Adaptation and Natural Selection. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
146. Williams, G.C. 1979. The question of adaptive sex ratio in outcrossed vertebrates. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 205 : 567 580.
147. Williams, G.C. 1992. Natural Selection: Domains, Levels and Challenges. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
148. Wilson, E.O. 1971. The Insect Societies. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
149. Wilson, D.S. 1975. A theory of group selection. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 72 : 143 146.
150. Wilson, D.S. 1977. Structured demes and the evolution of group-advantageous traits. Am. Nat. 111 : 157 185.
151. Wilson, D.S. 1980. The Natural Selection of Populations and Communities. Benjamin/Cummings, Menlo Park, CA.
152. Wilson, D.S. Sober, E. 1989. Reviving the superorganism. J. Theor. Biol. 136 : 337 356.
153. Wright, S. 1929. Evolution in Mendelian populations. Anat. Rec. 44 : 287.
154. Wright, S. 1931. Evolution in Mendelian populations. Genetics 16 : 97 159.
155. Wright, S. 1932. The roles of mutation, inbreeding, crossbreeding and selection in evolution. Proc. Sixth Int. Congr. Genet. 1 : 356 366.
156. Wright, S. 1945. Tempo and mode in evolution: a critical review. Ecology 26 : 415 419.
157. Wright, S. 1978. The relation of livestock breeding to theories of evolution. J. Anim. Sci. 46 : 1192 1200.
158. Wynne-Edwards, V.C. 1962. Animal Dispersion in Relation to Social Behavior. Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh.
159. Wynne-Edwards, V.C. 1963. Intergroup selection in the evolution of social systems. Nature 200 : 623 626.
160. Wynne-Edwards, V.C. 1965. Self-regulating systems in populations of animals. Science 147 : 1543 1548.