Punishing the "model minority": Asian-American criminal sentencing outcomes in federal district courts

Criminology

Volumn 47, Issue 4, 2009, Pages 1045-1090

  Johnson, Brian D ^a   Betsinger, Sara ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND   (United States)

Author keywords

Asians; Disparity; Ethnicity; Federal; Punishment; Race; Sentencing; Stereotypes

Indexed keywords

EID: 71949102518     PISSN: 00111384     EISSN: 17459125     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1745-9125.2009.00169.x     Document Type: Article

References (114)

1. Agresti, Alan, and Barbara Finlay. 1997. Statistical Methods for the Social Sciences. Upper Saddle River, NJ : Prentice Hall.
2. Albonetti, Celesta A. 1991. An integration of theories to explain judicial discretion. Social Problems 38 : 247 266.
3. Albonetti, Celesta A. 1997. Sentencing under the federal sentencing guidelines: Effects of defendant characteristics, guilty pleas, and departures on sentence outcomes for drug offenses, 1991-1992. Law & Society Review 31 : 789 822.
4. Albonetti, Celesta A. 2002. The joint conditioning effect of defendant's gender and ethnicity on length of imprisonment under the federal sentencing guidelines for drug trafficking-manufacturing offenders. Journal of Gender, Race, and Justice 6 : 39 60.
5. Albonetti, Celesta A. 2003. Model misspecification: Why aggregation of offenses in federal sentencing equations is problematic. Criminology 41 : 1449 1456.
6. Alvarez, Alexander, and Ronet Bachman. 1996. American Indians and sentencing disparity: An Arizona test. Journal or Criminal Justice 24 : 549 561.
7. Ancheta, Angelo. 2006. Race, Rights and the Asian American Experience, 2nd ed. Newark, NJ : Rutgers University Press.
8. Barnes, Jessica, and Claudette Bennett. 2002. The Asian Population: 2000 Census Brief. Washington, DC : U.S. Census Bureau.
9. Blalock, Hubert M. 1967. Toward a Theory of Minority-Group Relations. New York : Capricorn Books.
10. Blumstein, Alfred. 1982. On the racial disproportionality of United States' prison populations. The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 73 : 1259 1281.
11. Bridges, George S., and Robert D. Crutchfield. 1988. Law, social standing, and racial disparities in imprisonment. Social Forces 66 : 699 724.
12. Bridges, George S., and Sara Steen. 1998. Racial disparities in official assessments of juvenile offenders: Attributional stereotypes as mediating mechanisms. American Sociological Review 63 : 554 570.
13. Brown, Imogen, and Roy Hullin. 1992. A study of sentencing in the Leeds magistrates' courts: The treatment of ethnic minority and white offenders. British Journal of Criminology 32 : 41 53.
14. Bushway, Shawn D., Brian D. Johnson, and Lee Ann Slocum. 2007. Is the magic still there? The use of the Heckman Two-Step Correction for selection bias in criminology. Journal of Quantitative Criminology 23 : 151 178.
15. Bushway, Shawn D., and Anne M. Piehl. 2001. Judging judicial discretion: Legal factors and racial discrimination in sentencing. Law & Society Review 35 : 733 764.
16. Bushway, Shawn D., and Anne M. Piehl. 2007. Social science research and the legal threat to presumptive sentencing guidelines. Criminology & Public Policy 6 : 461 482.
17. Bynum, Tim. 1981. Parole decision making and Native Americans. In Race, Crime, and Criminal Justice, eds. R. L. McNeely and Carl Pope. Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage.
18. Bynum, Tim, and Raymond Paternoster. 1984. Discrimination revisited: An exploration of frontstage and backstage criminal justice decision making. Sociology and Social Research 69 : 90 108.
19. Chambliss, William J., and Robert B. Seidman. 1971. Law, Order, & Power. Reading, MA : Addison-Wesley.
20. Cheng, Cliff. 1997. Are Asian American employees a model minority or just a minority? The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science 33 : 277 290.
21. Chun, Ki-Taek. 1980. The myth of Asian American success and its educational ramifications. In The Asian American Cultural Experience, eds. Don Nakanishi and Tina Nishida. New York : Routledge.
22. Crawford, Charles, Ted Chiricos, and Gary Kleck. 1998. Race, racial threat, and sentencing of habitual offenders. Criminology 36 : 481 512. (Pubitemid 128134562)
23. Daniels, Roger. 1993. Prisoners without Trial: Japanese Americans in World War II. New York : Hill & Wang.
24. Demuth, Stephen. 2003. Racial and ethnic differences in pretrial release decisions and outcomes: A comparison of Hispanic, black, and white felony arrestees. Criminology 41 : 873 908.
25. Dixon, Jo. 1995. The organizational context of criminal sentencing. American Journal of Sociology 100 : 1157 1198.
26. Eisenstein, James, Roy B. Flemming, and Peter F. Nardulli. 1988. The Contours of Justice: Communities and Their Courts. Boston, MA : Little, Brown.
27. Engen, Rodney L., and Randy R. Gainey. 2000. Modeling the effects of legally relevant and extralegal factors under sentencing guidelines: The rules have changed. Criminology 38 : 1207 1230.
28. Engen, Rodney L., Sara Steen, and George S. Bridges. 2002. Race, crime and juvenile justice: An empirical analysis of research methods and findings. Social Problems 49 : 194 220.
29. Everett, Ronald S., and Roger A. Wojtkiewicz. 2002. Difference, disparity, and race/ethnic bias in federal sentencing. Journal of Quantitative Criminology 18 : 189 211.
30. Farrell, Ronald A., and Malcolm D. Holmes. 1991. The social and cognitive structure of legal decision-making. The Sociological Quarterly 32 : 529 542.
31. Fredrickson, George. 2003. The historical construction of race and citizenship in the United States. Paper presented to UNRISD, pp. 465 480. http://www.unrisd.org.
32. Gong Lum v. Rice. 1927. 275 U.S. 78.
33. Hacker, Andrew. 1995. Two Nations: Black and White, Separate, Hostile, Unequal. New York : Macmillan.
34. Hagan, John. 1974. Parameters of criminal prosecution: An application of path analysis to a problem of criminal justice. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology 65 : 536 544.
35. Hagan, John. 1975. The social and legal construction of criminal justice: A study of the pre-sentencing process. Social Problems 22 : 620 637.
36. Hagan, John. 1977. Criminal justice in rural and urban communities: A study of the bureaucratization of justice. Social Forces 55 : 597 612.
37. Hagan, John. 1989. Why is there so little criminal justice theory? Neglected macro and microlevel links between organization and power. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 26 : 116 135.
38. Hagan, John, and Celesta A. Albonetti. 1982. Race, class, and the perception of criminal injustice in America. American Journal of Sociology 88 : 329.
39. Hagan, John, and Kristin Bumiller. 1983. Making sense of sentencing - A review and critique of sentencing research. In Research on Sentencing: The Search for Reform, Vol. II, eds. Alfred Blumstein, Jacqueline Cohen, Susan E. Martin, and Michael H. Tonry. Washington, DC : National Academy Press.
40. Hagan, John, Ilene H. Nagel, and Celesta A. Albonetti. 1980. The differential sentencing of white-collar offenders in ten federal district courts. American Sociological Review 45 : 802 820.
41. Hartley, Richard D., Sean Maddan, and Cassia C. Spohn. 2007. Prosecutorial discretion: An examination of substantial assistance departures in federal crack-cocaine and powder-cocaine cases. Justice Quarterly 24 : 382 407.
42. Hawkins, Darnell F. 1981. Causal attribution and punishment for crime. Deviant Behavior 2 : 207 230.
43. Hawkins, Darnell F. 1987. Beyond abnormalities: Rethinking the conflict perspective on race and criminal punishment. Social Forces 65 : 719 745.
44. Heckman, James. 1976. The common structure of statistical models of truncation, sample selection and limited dependent variables and a simple estimator for such models. The Annals of Economic and Social Measurement 5 : 475 492.
45. Helms, Ronald, and David Jacobs. 2002. The political context of sentencing: An analysis of community and individual determinants. Social Forces 81 : 577 604.
46. Hobbs, Frank, and Nicole Stoops. 2002. Demographic Trends in the 20th Century. U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Special Reports, Series CENSR-4. Washington, DC : U.S. Government Printing Office.
47. Hofer, Paul J., and Kevin Blackwell. 2001. What Are We Learning from Multiple Regression Studies of Federal Sentencing Decisions? Paper presented at the American Society of Criminology meeting. San Diego, CA, November.
48. Hurh, Won Moo, and Kwang Chung Kim. 1989. The "success" image of Asian Americans: Its validity, and its practical and theoretical implications. Ethnic and Racial Studies 12 : 512 537.
49. Jang, Sung Joon. 2002. The effects of family, school, peers, and attitudes on adolescents' drug use: Do they vary with age? Justice Quarterly 19 : 97 126.
50. Johnson, Brian D. 2003. Racial and ethnic disparities in sentencing departures across modes of conviction. Criminology 41 : 449 490.
51. Johnson, Brian D. 2005. Contextual disparities in guidelines departures: Courtroom social contexts, guidelines compliance, and extralegal disparities in criminal sentencing. Criminology 43 : 761 796.
52. Johnson, Brian D. 2006. The multilevel context of criminal sentencing: Integrating judge- and county-level influences. Criminology 44 : 259 298.
53. Johnson, Brian D., Jeffery Ulmer, and John Kramer. 2008. The social context of guidelines circumvention: The case of U.S. district courts. Criminology 46 : 737 783.
54. Kautt, Paula, and Cassia Spohn. 2002. Cracking down on black drug offenders? Testing for interactions among offenders' race, drug type, and sentencing strategy in federal drug sentences. Justice Quarterly 19 : 1 35.
55. Kennedy, Randall. 1997. Race, Crime, and Law. New York : Pantheon Books.
56. Kerner Commission. 1968. Report of the National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders. Washington, DC : U.S. Government Printing Office.
57. Kleck, Gary. 1981. Racial discrimination in criminal sentencing: A critical evaluation of the evidence with additional evidence on the death penalty. American Sociological Review 46 : 783 805.
58. Klepper, Steven, Daniel S. Nagin, and Luke-Jon Tierney. 1983. Discrimination in the criminal justice system: A critical appraisal of the literature. In Research on Sentencing: The Search for Reform, Vol. 2, eds. Alfred Blumstein, Jacqueline Cohen, Susan E. Martin, and Michael H. Tonry. Washington, DC : National Academy Press.
59. Korematsu v. United States. 1944. 323 U.S. 214.
60. Kramer, John, and Darrell Steffensmeier. 1993. Race and imprisonment decisions. Sociological Quarterly 34 : 357 376.
61. Kramer, John, and Jeffery Ulmer. 2002. Downward departures for serious violent offenders: Local court "corrections" to Pennsylvania's sentencing guidelines. Criminology 40 : 897 932.
62. LaFree, Gary. 1985. Official reactions to Hispanic defendants in the Southwest. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 22 : 213 237.
63. Liska, Allen E. 1994. Modeling the conflict perspective of social control. In Inequality, Crime, and Social Control, eds. George S. Bridges and Martha A. Myers. Boulder, CO : Westview Press.
64. Lyman, Stanford. 1974. Chinese Americans. New York : Random House.
65. March, James G., and Herbert A. Simon. 1958. Organizations. New York : Wiley.
66. Martinez, Ramiro, Jr. 2002. Latino Homicide: Immigration, Violence and Community. New York : Routledge.
67. McKinnon, Jesse, and Claudette Bennett. 2005. We the People: Blacks in the United States, Census 2000 Special Report. CENSR-25. Washington, DC : Bureau of the Census.
68. McNulty, Thomas L., and Paul E. Bellair. 2003. Explaining racial and ethnic differences in serious adolescent violent behavior. Criminology 41 : 709 748.
69. Miller, Stuart C. 1969. The Unwelcome Immigrant: The American Image of the Chinese, 1785-1882. Berkeley : University of California Press.
70. Mitchell, Ojmarrh. 2005. A meta-analysis of race and sentencing research: Explaining the inconsistencies. Journal of Quantitative Criminology 21 : 439 466.
71. Mustard, David B. 2001. Racial, ethnic, and gender disparities in sentencing: Evidence from the U.S. federal courts. Journal of Law and Economics 44 : 285 314.
72. Nagel, Ilene H., and Stephen J. Schulhofer. 1992. A tale of three cities: An empirical study of charging and bargaining practices under the federal sentencing guidelines. Southern California Law Review 66 : 501 566.
73. Paek, Hye Jin, and Hemant Shah. 2003. Racial ideology, model minorities, and the "not-so-silent partner:" stereotyping of Asian Americans in U.S. magazine advertising. Howard Journal of Communication 14 : 225 243.
74. People v. Hall. 1854. 4 Cal. 399.
75. Peterson, Ruth D., and John Hagan. 1984. Changing conceptions of race: Towards an account of anomalous findings of sentencing research. American Sociological Review 49 : 56 70.
76. Piliavin, Ivan, and Scott Briar. 1964. Police encounters with juveniles. American Journal of Sociology 70 : 206 214.
77. Quinney, Richard. 1970. The Social Reality of Crime. Boston, MA : Little, Brown.
78. Ramirez, Roberto. 2004. We the People: Hispanics in the United States, Census 2000 Special Report. CENSR-18. Washington, DC : Bureau of the Census.
79. Reeves, Terrence J., and Claudette E. Bennett. 2004. We the People: Asians in the United States, Census 2000 Special Report. CENSR-17. Washington, DC : Bureau of the Census.
80. Ruth, Henry, and Kevin R. Reitz. 2003. The Challenge of Crime: Rethinking our Response. Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press.
81. Sampson, Robert J., and Janet L. Lauritsen. 1997. Racial and ethnic disparities in crime and criminal justice in the United States. Crime and Justice 21 : 311 374.
82. Sellin, Thorsten. 1935. Race prejudice in the administration of justice. American Journal of Sociology 41 : 212 217.
83. Spitzer, Steven. 1975. Toward a Marxian theory of deviance. Social Forces 22 : 638 651.
84. Spohn, Cassia. 2000. Thirty years of Sentencing Reform: The Quest for a Racially Neutral Sentencing Process. Washington, DC : National Institute of Justice.
85. Spohn, Cassia, John Gruhl, and Susan Welch. 1981-1982. The effect of race on sentencing: A re-examination of an unsettled question. Law & Society Review 16 : 71 88.
86. Spohn, Cassia, and David Holleran. 2000. The imprisonment penalty paid by young, unemployed black and Hispanic male offenders. Criminology 38 : 281 306.
87. Steen, Sara, Rodney L. Engen, and Randy R. Gainey. 2005. Images of danger and culpability: Racial stereotyping, case processing, and criminal sentencing. Criminology 43 : 435 468.
88. Steffensmeier, Darrell, and Stephen Demuth. 2000. Ethnicity and sentencing outcomes in U.S. federal courts: Who is punished more harshly? American Sociological Review 65 : 705 729.
89. Steffensmeier, Darrell, and Stephen Demuth. 2001. Ethnicity and judges' sentencing decisions: Hispanic-black-white comparisons. Criminology 39 : 145 178. (Pubitemid 33267459)
90. Steffensmeier, Darrell, Jeffery Ulmer, and John Kramer. 1998. The interaction of race, gender, and age in criminal sentencing: The punishment cost of being young, black, and male. Criminology 36 : 763 798. (Pubitemid 128156126)
91. Stephan, James J., and Jennifer C. Karberg. 2003. Census of State and Federal Correctional Facilities, 2000. Report NCJ-198272. Washington, DC : Bureau of Justice Statistics.
92. Stolzenberg, Ross M., and Daniel A. Relles. 1990. Theory testing in a world of constrained research design. Sociological Methods & Research 18 : 395 415.
93. Sudnow, David. 1965. Normal crimes: Sociological features of the penal code in a public defender office. Social Problems 12 : 255 276.
94. Thomson, Randall J., and Matthew T. Zingraff. 1981. Detecting sentencing disparity: Some problems and evidence. American Journal of Sociology 86 : 869 880.
95. Turk, Austin T. 1969. Criminality and Legal Order. Chicago, IL : Rand McNally.
96. Ulmer, Jeffery. 1997. Social Worlds of Sentencing: Court Communities under Sentencing Guidelines. Albany : State University of New York Press.
97. Ulmer, Jeffery. 2005. The localized uses of federal sentencing guidelines in four U.S. district courts: Evidence of prosecutorial order. Symbolic Interaction 28 : 255 279.
98. Ulmer, Jeffery, and Brian D. Johnson. 2004. Sentencing in context: A multilevel analysis. Criminology 42 : 137 178.
99. Uniform Crime Reports. 2005. Crime in the United States 2005. Uniform Crime Reports. Washington, DC : U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation. http://www.fbi.gov/ucr/ucr.htm.
100. United States Sentencing Commission. 2003. Sourcebook of Federal Sentencing Statistics. Washington, DC : U.S. Department of Justice.
101. United States Sentencing Commission. 2006. Final Report on the Impact of United States v. Booker on Federal Sentencing. Washington, DC : U.S. Department of Justice.
102. United States v. Booker and United States v. Fanfan. 2005. 125 S. Ct. 738.
103. Unnever, James D., Charles E. Frazier, and John C. Henretta. 1980. Race differences in criminal sentencing. Sociological Quarterly 21 : 197 205.
104. Weber, Max. 1954. On Law in Economy and Society. Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press.
105. Welch, Susan, Cassia Spohn, and John Gruhl. 1985. Convicting and sentencing differences among black, Hispanic, and white males in six localities. Justice Quarterly 2 : 67 80.
106. Wheeler, Stanton, David Weisburd, and Nancy Bode. 1982. Sentencing the white-collar offender: Rhetoric and reality. American Sociological Review 47 : 641 659.
107. Wilbanks, William. 1987. The Myth of a Racist Criminal Justice System. Monterey, CA : Brooks/Cole.
108. Wilson, William J. 1980. The Declining Significance of Race: Blacks and Changing American Institutions. Chicago, IL : University of Chicago Press.
109. Wong, William. 1994. Covering the invisible "model minority." Media Studies Journal 8 : 49 60.
110. Wooldredge, John. 2007. Neighborhood effects on felony sentencing. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 44 : 238 263.
111. Zatz, Marjorie. 1984. Race, ethnicity, and determinate sentencing: A new dimension to an old controversy. Criminology 22 : 147 171.
112. Zatz, Marjorie. 1987. The changing forms of racial/ethnic biases in sentencing. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 24 : 69 92.
113. Zatz, Marjorie. 2000. The Convergence of Race, Ethnicity, Gender and Class on Court Decision Making: Looking Toward the 21st Century. Washington, DC : National Institute of Justice.
114. Zhou, Min. 2000. Social capital in Chinatown: The role of community-based organizations and families in the adaptation of the younger generation. In Contemporary Asian America: A Multidisciplinary Reader, eds. Min Zhou and James Gatewood. New York : NYU Press.