Closed-loop control for intensive care unit sedation

Best Practice and Research: Clinical Anaesthesiology

Volumn 23, Issue 1, 2009, Pages 95-114

  Haddad, Wassim M ^a   Bailey, James M ^b  

^a Georgia Institute of Technology   (United States)

^b Northeast Georgia Medical Center   (United States)

Author keywords

adaptive control; automated anesthesia; closed loop sedation; electroencephalography; mechanical ventilation; pharmacodynamics; pharmacokinetics

Indexed keywords

SEDATIVE AGENT;

ALGORITHM; ANESTHESIA LEVEL; CARDIOVASCULAR FUNCTION; CLINICAL DECISION MAKING; CLINICAL PHARMACOLOGY; CLINICAL PRACTICE; COMPARTMENT MODEL; CONSCIOUSNESS LEVEL; DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEM; DRUG RESEARCH; ENERGY BALANCE; FEEDBACK SYSTEM; HEALTH CARE DELIVERY; HEALTH CARE QUALITY; INTENSIVE CARE UNIT; MATHEMATICAL MODEL; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RESPIRATORY FUNCTION; REVIEW; SEDATION; SKILL; SYSTEMS THEORY;

ALGORITHMS; ANESTHESIA; DRUG THERAPY, COMPUTER-ASSISTED; FEEDBACK; HUMANS; HYPNOTICS AND SEDATIVES; INTENSIVE CARE; MODELS, BIOLOGICAL; MONITORING, INTRAOPERATIVE; NEURAL NETWORKS (COMPUTER);

EID: 61549125081     PISSN: 15216896     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.bpa.2008.07.007     Document Type: Review

References (119)

1. In: Murray R.M. (Ed). Control in an information rich World (2003), SIAM, Philadelphia, PA
2. Keener J., and Sneyd J. Mathematical physiology (1998), Springer-Verlag, New York
3. Jacquez J.A. Compartmental analysis in biology and medicine (1985), University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, MI
4. Cherruault Y. Mathematical modelling in biomedicine (1986), Reidel, Dordrecht, Holland
5. Grodins F.S. Control theory and biological systems (1963), Columbia University Press, New York
6. Riggs D.S. Control theory and physiological feedback mechanisms (1970), Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, MD
7. Bailey J.M., and Haddad W.M. Drug dosing control in clinical pharamacology: Paradigms, benefits, and challenges. Control Systems Magazine 25 (2005) 35-51
8. Absalom R., Sutcliffe N., and Kenny G.N. Closed-loop control of anesthesia using bispectral index: Performance assessment in patients undergoing major orthopedic surgery under combined general and regional anesthesia. Anesthesiology 96 1 (2002) 67-73
9. Schwilden H., Schuttler J., and Stoeckel H. Closed-loop feedback control of methohexital anesthesia by quantitative EEG analysis in humans. Anesthesiology 67 3 (1987) 341-347
10. Linkens D.A., Abbod M.F., and Peacock J.E. Clinical implementation of advanced control in anaesthesia. Transactions of the Institute of Measurement and Control 22 4 (2000) 303-330
11. Tung A., and Rosenthal M. Patients requiring sedation. Critical Care Clinics vol. 11 (1995) 791-802
12. Mazzeo J. Sedation for the mechanically ventilated patient. Critical Care Clinics 11 (1995) 937-955
13. Ostermann M.E., Keenan S.P., Seiferling R.A., and Sibbald W.J. Sedation in the intensive care unit: A systematic review. JAMA: The Journal of the American Medical Association 283 (2000) 1451-1459
14. Kress J.P., Pohlman A.S., O'Connor M.F., and Hall J.B. Daily interruption of sedative infusions in critically ill patients undergoing. The New England Journal of Medicine 342 (2000) 1471-1477
15. Strain J. Psychological reactions to acute medical illness and critical care. Critical Care Clinics 6 (1978) 39-45
16. The Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome Network. Ventilation with lower tidal volumes as compared with traditional tidal volumes for acute lung injury and the acute respiratory distress syndrome. The New England Journal of Medicine 342 (2000) 1301-1308
17. Bidani A., Tzouanakis A.E., Cardenas J.V.J., and Zwischenberger J.B. Permissive hypercapnia in acute respiratory failure. JAMA: The Journal of the American Medical Association 272 (1994) 957-962
18. Hawes D.W., Ross J.A., White D.C., and Wloch R.T. Servocontrol of closed circuit anesthesia. British Journal of Anaesthesia 54 (1982) 229-230
19. Hayes J.K., Westenkow D.R., East T.D., and Jordan W.S. Computer controlled anesthesia delivery system. Medical Instrumentation 18 (1984) 224-231
20. Westenkow D.R., and Jordan W.S. The Utah system: Computer controlled anesthesia delivery. Future Anesthesia Delivery Systems 8 (1984) 221-233
21. Ritchie R.G., Ernst E.A., Late B.L., et al. Closed-loop control of an anesthesia delivery system: Development and animal testing. IEEE Transactions on Bio-medical Engineering 34 (1987) 437-443
22. Spain J.A., Janett T.C., and Ernst E.A. The Alabama automated closed-circuit anesthesia project. Future Anesthesia Delivery Systems vol. 8 (1984) 177-183
23. Vishnoi R., and Roy R.J. Adaptive control of closed-circuit anesthesia. IEEE Transactions on Bio-medical Engineering 38 1 (1991) 39-47
24. Jee G.I., and Roy R.J. Adaptive control of multiplexed closed-circuit anesthesia. IEEE Transactions on Bio-medical Engineering 39 10 (1992) 1071-1080
25. Bickford R.G. Automatic electroencephalographic control of anesthesia (servo-anesthesia). Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology 3 (1951) 83-86
26. Hill A.V. The possible effects of the aggregation of the molecules of haemoglobin on its dissociation curves. Journal of Physics 40 (1910) 4-7
27. Schwilden H., Stoeckel H., and Schuttler J. Closed-loop feedback control of propofol anesthesia by quantitative EEG analysis in humans. British Journal of Anaesthesia 62 3 (1989) 290-296
28. Sebel P.S., Lang E., Rampil I.J., et al. A multicenter study of bispectral electroencephalogram analysis for monitoring anesthetic effect. Anesthesia and Analgesia 84 4 (1997) 891-899
29. Glass P.S., Bloom M., Kearse L., et al. Bispectral analysis measures sedation and memory effects of propofol, midazolam, isoflurane, and alfentanil in normal volunteers. Anesthesiology 86 4 (1997) 836-847
30. Struys M.M.R.F., Smet T.D., Versichelen L.F.M., et al. Comparison of closed-loop controlled administration of propofol using bispectral index as the controlled variable versus "standard practice" controlled administration. Anesthesiology 95 (2001) 6-17
31. Glass P.S.A., and Rampil I.J. Automated anesthesia: Fact or fantasy?. Anesthesiology 95 1 (2001) 1-2
32. Kenny G.N., and Mantzardis H. Closed-loop control of propofol anaesthesia. British Journal of Anaesthesia 83 2 (1999) 223-228
33. Gentilini A., Rossoni-Gerosa M., Frei C.W., et al. Modeling and closed-loop control of hypnosis by means of bispectral index (BIS) with isoflurane. IEEE Transactions on Bio-medical Engineering 48 8 (2001) 874-889
34. Simmons L.E., Riker R.R., Prato S., and Fraser G.L. Assessing sedation during intensive care unit mechanical ventilation with the bispectral index and the sedation-agitation scale. Critical Care Medicine 27 (1999) 1499-1504
35. Shapiro B.A. Bispectral index: Better information for sedation in the intensive care unit?. Critical Care Medicine 27 6 (1999) 1663-1664
36. Riess M.L., Graefe U.A., Aken H.V., and Bone H.G. Usefulness of bispectral index to assess the level of sedation in critically ill patients. Critical Care Medicine 27 12 (1999) A132
37. Nasraway S.A., Wu E.C., Kelleher R.M., et al. How reliable in the bispectral index in critically ill patients? A prospective, comparative, single-blinded observer study. Critical Care Medicine 30 7 (2002) 1483-1487
38. Nasraway S.A. The bispectral index: Expanded performance for everyday use in the intensive care unit. Critical Care Medicine 33 3 (2002) 685-687
39. Hijazi MN, Chaudhary A. The correlation between the bispectral index (bis) and motor activity assessment scale (maas) in sedated and mechanically ventilated patients, CHEST Meeting Abstracts; 2004. p. 897.
40. Johansen J.W., and Sebel P.S. Development and clinical application of electroencephalographic bispectrum monitoring. Anesthesiology 93 (2000) 1336-1340
41. Kallet R.H., Campbell A.R., Dicker R.A., et al. Effects of tidal volume on work of breathing during lung-protective ventilation in patients with acute lung injury and acute respiratory distress syndrome. Critical Care Medicine 34 1 (2006) 8-14
42. Hess D.R., and Thompson B.T. Patient-ventilator dyssynchrony during lung protective ventilation: What's a clinician to do?. Critical Care Medicine 34 1 (2006) 231-233
43. Nilsestuen J.O., and Hargett K.D. Using ventilator graphics to identify patient-ventilator asynchrony. Respiratory Care 50 2 (2005) 202-234
44. Anderson B.D.O., and Moore J.B. Optimal control: Linear quadratic methods (1990), Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey
45. Weinert C.R., Chlan L., and Gross C. Sedating critically ill patients: Factors affecting nurses' delivery of sedative therapy. American Journal of Critical Care 10 3 (2001) 156-167
46. Gelinas C., Fortier M., Viens C., et al. Pain assessment and management in critically ill intubated patients: A retroscpective study. American Journal of Critical Care 13 2 (2004) 126-135
47. Sessler C.N. Sedation scales in the ICU. Chest 126 (2004) 1727-1730
48. Jong M.M.J.D., Burnes S.M., Campbell M.L., et al. Development of the American Association of Critical-Care Nurses' sedation assessment scale for critically ill patients. American Journal of Critical Care 14 6 (2005) 531-544
49. Devlin J.W., Boleski G., Mlynarek M., et al. Motor activity assessment scale: A valid and reliable sedation scale for use with mechanically ventilated patients in an adult surgical intensive care unit. Critical Care Medicine 27 (1999) 1271-1275
50. Åström K.J., and Wittenmark B. Adaptive control (1989), Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA
51. Narendra K.S., and Annaswamy A.M. Stable adaptive systems (1989), Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
52. Ioannou P.A., and Sun J. Robust adaptive control (1996), Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ
53. Rescigno A., and Beck J.S. Compartments. In: Rosen R. (Ed). New York. Foundation of mathematical biology, ser. 5 vol. 2 (1972), Academic Press, NY 255-322
54. Mohler R.R. Biological modeling with variable compartmental structure. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 19 (1974) 922-926
55. Sandberg W. On the mathematical foundations of compartmental analysis in biology, medicine and ecology. IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems 25 (1978) 273-279
56. Brown R.F. Compartmental system analysis: State of the art. IEEE Transactions on Bio-medical Engineering 27 (1980) 1-11
57. Anderson D.H. Compartmental modeling and tracer kinetics (1983), Springer-Verlag, Berlin, New York
58. Godfrey K. Compartmental models and their applications (1983), Academic Press, New York
59. Jacquez J. Compartmental modeling. In: IFAC Proceedings Series; 1989. p. 31-37.
60. Hull C.J. How far can we go with compartmental models?. Anesthesiology 72 (1990) 399-402
61. Jacquez J.A., and Simon C.P. Qualitative theory of compartmental systems. SIAM Review 35 (1993) 43-79
62. Jacquez J.A. Modeling with compartments (1999), BioMedWare, Ann Aarbor, MI
63. Haddad W.M., and Chellaboina V. Nonlinear dynamical systems and control: A Lyapunov-based approach (2008), Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
64. Haddad W.M., and Chellaboina V. Stability and dissipativity theory for nonnegative dynamical systems: A unified analysis framework for biological and physiological systems. Nonlinear Analysis: Real World Applications 6 (2005) 35-65
65. Haddad W.M., Hayakawa T., and Bailey J.M. Adaptive control for nonnegative and compartmental dynamical systems with applications to general anesthesia. International Journal of Adaptive Control and Signal Processing 17 (2003) 209-235
66. Haddad W.M., Hayakawa T., and Bailey J.M. Adaptive control for nonlinear compartmental dynamical systems with applications to clinical pharmacology. Systems & Control Letters (2006) 62-70
67. Volyanskyy K, Haddad WM, Bailey JM. Adaptive disturbance rejection control for compartmental systems with applications to intraoperative anesthesia influenced by hemorrhage and hemodilution effects. International Journal of Adaptive Control and Signal Processing, in press.
68. Haddad W.M., Bailey J.M., Hayakawa T., and Hovakimyan N. Neural network adaptive output feedback control for intensive care uint sedation and intraoperative anesthesia. IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks 18 4 (2007) 1049-1066
69. Bailey JM, Haddad WM., Im JJ, et al. Adaptive and neural network adaptive control of depth of anesthesia during surgery. In: Proceedings of American Control Conference. Minneapolis, MN; 2006. p. 3409-3414.
70. Kazama T., Kurita T., Morita K., et al. Influence of hemorrhage on propofol pseudo-steady state concentration. Anesthesiology 97 (2002) 1156-1161
71. Haddad WM, Hayakawa T, Bailey JM. Nonlinear adaptive control for intensive care unit sedation and operating room hypnosis. In: Proceedings of American Control Conference. Denver, CO; June 2003. p. 1808-1813.
72. Volyansky K, Htaddad WM. Adaptive control for compartmental dynamical systems with disturbance rejection guarantees. In: Proceedings of American Control Conference. New York, NY; July 2007. p. 1215-1220.
73. Leonessa A, Haddad WM, Hayakawa T, Morel Y. Adaptive control for nonlinear uncertain systems with actuator amplitude and rate saturation constraints. International Journal of Adaptive Control and Signal Processing, in press.
74. Hui Q., Haddad W.M., Chellaboina V., and Hayakawa T. Adaptive control of mammillary drug delivery systems with actuator amplitude constraints and system time delays. European Journal of Control 11 (2005) 586-600
75. Haddad WM, Volyanskyy KY, Bailey JM. Neuroadaptive output feedback control for automated anesthesia with noisy EEG measurements. In: Proceedings of American Control Conference. Seattle, WA; June 2008. p. 813--818.
76. Henthorn T.K., Krejcie T.C., Niemann C.U., et al. Ketamine distribution described by a recirculatory pharmacokinetic model is not stereo-selective. Anesthesiology 91 6 (1999) 1733-1743
77. Gyori. Delay differential and integro-differential equations in biological compartment models. Systems Science 8 2-3 (1982) 167-187
78. Maeda H., Kodama S., and Konishi T. Stability theory and existence of periodic solutions of time delayed compartmental systems. Electronics and Communications in Japan 65 1 (1982) 1-8
79. Haddad W.M., and Chellaboina V. Stability and dissipativity theory for nonnegative and compartmental dynamical systems with time delay. In: Niculescu S.-I., and Gu K. (Eds). Advances in time-delay systems (2004), Springer 421-435
80. Hale K., and Verduyn lunel S.M. Introduction to functional differential equations (1993), Springer-Verlag, New York, NY
81. Niculescu S.-I. Delay effects on stability: a robust control approach (2001), Springer, New York, NY
82. Chellaboina V, Haddad WM, Ramakrishnan J, Hayakawa T. Direct adaptive control of nonnegative and compartmental dynamical systems with time delay. In: Proceedings of American Control Conference. Boston, MA; July 2004. p. 1235-1240.
83. Chellaboina V., Haddad W., Ramakrishnan J., and Hui Q. Direct adaptive control of nonnegative and compartmental systems with time delay. In: Queinnec I., Tarbouriech S., Garcia G., and Niculescu S.-I. (Eds). Biology and control theory: current challenges (2007), Springer 291-316
84. Narendra S., and Parthasarathy K. Identification and control of dynamical systems using neural networks. IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks 1 (1990) 4-27
85. Chen F.C., and Khalil H.K. Adaptive control of nonlinear systems using neural networks. International Journal of Control 55 6 (1992) 1299-1317
86. Hunt J., Sbarbaro D., Zbikowski R., and Gawthrop P.J. Neural networks for control: A survey. Automatica 28 (1992) 1083-1112
87. Lewis F.L., Yesildirek A., and Liu K. Multilayer neural-net robot controller with guaranteed tracking performance. IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks 7 2 (1996) 388-399
88. Lewis F.L., Jagannathan S., and Yesildirak A. Neural network control of robot manipulators and nonlinear systems (1999), Taylor & Francis, London, UK
89. Spooner J., Maggiore M., Ordonez R., and Passino K. Stable adaptive control and estimation for nonlinear systems: Neural and fuzzy approximator techniques (2002), John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY
90. Buell J., Jelliffe R., Kalaba R., and Sridhar R. Modern control theory and optimal drug regiments, I: The plateau effect. Mathematical Biosciences 5 (1969) 285-296
91. Buell J., Jelliffe R., Kalaba R., and Sridhar R. Modern control theory and optimal drug regiments, II: Combination therapy. Mathematical Biosciences 6 (1970) 67-74
92. Soong T.T. Pharmacokinetics with uncertainties in rate constants-II: Sensitivity analysis and optimal dosage control. Mathematical Biosciences 13 (1972) 391-396
93. Pierce J.G., and Schumitzky A. Optimal impulsive control of compartment models, I: Qualitative aspects. Journal of Optimization Theory and Application 18 (1976) 537-554
94. Kusuoka H., Kodama S., Hori M., et al. Optimal control of drug administration. Proceeding of International Conference Cybern Society 1 (1978) 63-68
95. Pierce J.G., and Schumitzky A. Optimal control of compartment models, II: Algorithm. Journal of Optimization Theory and Application 26 1 (1978) 581-599
96. Kusuoka H., Kodama S., Maeda H., et al. Optimal control in compartmental systems and its application to drug administration. Mathematical Biosciences 53 1-2 (1981) 59-77
97. Martin P., and Ahuja A.A. Optimal pharmacokinetic delivery of infused drugs: Application to the treatment of cardiac arrhythmias. Journal of Biomedical Engineering 10 4 (1988) 360-364
98. Nersesov S.G., Haddad W.M., and Chellaboina V. Optimal fixed-structure control for linear nonnegative dynamical systems. International Journal of Robust and Nonlinear Control 14 (2004) 487-511
99. Bernstein D.S., and Hyland D.C. Optimal projection approach to robust, fixed-structure control design. In: Junkins J. (Ed). Mechanics and control of space structures (1993), AIAA, Washington, D.C.
100. {infinity, incomplete} optimal static output feedback. In: Proceedings of American Control Conference. Pittsburgh, PA; 1989. p. 2506-2511.
101. Levine W.S., and Athans M. On the determination of the optimal output feedback gains for linear multivariable systems. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 15 (1970) 44-48
102. Haddad W.M., Chellaboina V., and Nersesov S.G. Impulsive and hybrid dynamical systems: Stability, dissipativity, and control (2006), Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
103. Campbell D., and Brown J. The electrical analog of the lung. British Journal of Anaesthesia 35 (1963) 684-693
104. Wald A.A., Murphy T.W., and Mazzia V.D. A theoretical study of controlled ventilation. IEEE Transactions on Bio-medical Engineering 15 (1968) 237-248
105. Epstein A., and Epstein R.A. Airway flow patterns during mechanical ventilation of infants: A mathematical model. IEEE Transactions on Bio-medical Engineering 26 (1979) 299-306
106. Barbini P. Nonlinear models of the mechanics of breathing applied to the use and design of ventilators. Journal of Biomedical Engineering 4 (1982) 294-304
107. Marini J.J., and Crooke P.S. A general mathematical model for respiratory dynamics relevant to the clinical setting. American Review of Respiratory Disease 147 (1993) 14-24
108. Hotchkiss J.R., Crooke P.S., Adams A.B., and Marini J.J. Implications of a biphasic two-compartment model of constant flow ventilation for the clinical setting. Journal of Critical Care 9 (1994) 114-123
109. Similowski T., and Bates J.H. Two-compartment modeling of respiratory system mechanics at low frequencies: Gas redistribution or tissue rheology. European Respiratory Journal 4 (1991) 353-358
110. Crooke P.S., Head J.D., and Marini J.J. A general two-compartment model for mechanical ventilation. Mathematical and Computer Modeling 24 (1996) 1-18
111. Chellaboina V, Haddad WM, Bailey JM, Li H, Limit cycle stability analysis of a multi-compartment model for a pressure-limited respirator and lung mechanics system. In Proceedings of American Control Conference. New York, NY; 2007. p. 2411-2416.
112. Chellaboina V, Haddad WM, Li H, & Bailey JM. Direct adaptive control for a multi-compartment model of a pressure-limited respirator and lung mechanics systems. In: Proceedings of IEEE Conference on Decision and Control. Cancun, Mexico; 2008.
113. Grap J., Borchers T., Munro C.L., et al. Actigraphy in the critically ill: Correlation with acitivity, agition, and sedation. American Journal of Critical Care 14 1 (2005) 52-60
114. Weinbroum A., Abraham R.B., Ezri T., and Zomer J. Wrist actigraphy in anesthesia. Journal of Clinical Anesthesia 13 (2001) 455-460
115. Chase J.G., Agogue F., Starfinger C., et al. Quantifying agitation in sedated ICU patients using digital imaging. Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine 76 2 (2004) 131-141
116. Becouze C.E., Hann J.G., Chase, and Shaw G.M. Measuring facial grimacing for quantifying patient agitation in critical care. Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine 87 2 (2007) 134-147
117. Ashraf AB, Lucey S, Cohn JF et al. The painful face: Pain expression recognition using active appearance models. In: Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Multimodal Interface. Nagoya, Japan; 2007.
118. Brahnam S., Chuang C.-F., Sexton R.S., and Shih F.Y. Machine assessment of neonatal facial expressions of acute pain. Decision Support Systems 43 (2007) 1242-1254
119. Monwar M.M., Rezaei S., and Prkachin K. Eigenimage based pain expression recongintion. International Journal of Applied Mathematics 36 2 (2007)