Dissociating functional brain networks by decoding the between-subject variability

NeuroImage

Volumn 45, Issue 2, 2009, Pages 349-359

  Seghier, Mohamed L ^a   Price, Cathy J ^a  

^a WELLCOME TRUST CENTRE FOR NEUROIMAGING   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Across subject variability; Between subject variance; Cognitive subtractions; Default network; Functional MRI; Fuzzy clustering; Inter individual variability; Language; Networks; Second level analysis; Semantic decision

Indexed keywords

ADOLESCENT; ADULT; AGED; ALGORITHM; ARTICLE; BETWEEN SUBJECT VARIABILITY; BRAIN FUNCTION; COGNITION; COGNITIVE SUBTRACTION; FEMALE; FUNCTIONAL MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; HUMAN; HUMAN EXPERIMENT; IMAGE ANALYSIS; MALE; NERVE CELL NETWORK; NORMAL HUMAN; PRIORITY JOURNAL; TASK PERFORMANCE; VARIANCE;

ADOLESCENT; ADULT; AGED; BRAIN; COGNITION; COMPUTER SIMULATION; FEMALE; HUMANS; IMAGE INTERPRETATION, COMPUTER-ASSISTED; MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; MODELS, NEUROLOGICAL; NERVE NET; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; YOUNG ADULT;

EID: 60149087284     PISSN: 10538119     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2008.12.017     Document Type: Article

References (104)

1. Aizenstein H.J., Butters M.A., Clark K.A., Fiqurski J.L., Andrew Stenger V., Nebes R.D., Reynolds C.R., and Carter C.S. Prefrontal and striatal activation in elderly subjects during concurrent implicit and explicit sequence learning. Neurobiol. Aging 27 (2006) 741-751
2. Ashburner J., and Friston K.J. Unified segmentation. NeuroImage 26 (2005) 839-851
3. Bartels A., and Zeki S. Functional brain mapping during free viewing of natural scenes. Hum. Brain Mapp. 21 (2004) 75-85
4. Berl M.M., Balsamo L.M., Xu B., Moore E.N., Weinstein S.L., Conry J.A., Pearl P.L., Sachs B.C., Grandin C.B., Frattali C., Ritter F.J., Sato S., Theodore W.H., and Gaillard W.D. Seizure focus affects regional language networks assessed by fMRI. Neurology 65 (2005) 1604-1611
5. Bezdek J.C. Pattern Recognition with Fuzzy Objective Functions Algorithms (1981), Plenum Press, New York
6. Bezdek J.C., Hall L.O., Clark M.C., Goldgof D.B., and Clarke L.P. Medical image analysis with fuzzy models. Stat. Methods Med. Res. 6 (1997) 191-214
7. Billingsley R.L., McAndrews M.P., Crawley A.P., and Mikulis D.J. Functional MRI of phonological and semantic processing in temporal lobe epilepsy. Brain 124 (2001) 1218-1227
8. Binder J.R., Frost J.A., Hammeke T.A., Bellgowan P.S., Rao S.M., and Cox R.W. Conceptual processing during the conscious resting state. A functional MRI study. J. Cogn. Neurosci. 11 (1999) 80-95
9. Bluhm R.L., Miller J., Lanius R.A., Osuch E.A., Boksman K., Neufeld R.W., Théberge J., Schaefer B., and Williamson P. Spontaneous low-frequency fluctuations in the BOLD signal in schizophrenic patients: anomalies in the default network. Schizophr. Bull. 33 (2007) 1004-1012
10. Brandt T. How to see what you are looking for in fMRI and PET - or the crucial baseline condition. J. Neurol. 253 (2006) 551-555
11. Breckenridge J.N. Replicating cluster analysis: method, consistency, and validity. Multivar. Behav. Res. 24 (1989) 147-161
12. Bundesen C., Larsen A., Kyllingsbaek S., Paulson O.B., and Law I. Attentional effects in the visual pathways: a whole-brain PET study. Exp. Brain Res. 147 (2002) 394-406
13. Calhoun V.D., Adali T., McGinty V.B., Pekar J.J., Watson T.D., and Pearlson G.D. fMRI activation in a visual-perception task: network of areas detected using the general linear model and independent components analysis. NeuroImage 14 (2001) 1080-1088
14. Calhoun V.D., Kiehl K.A., and Pearlson G.D. Modulation of temporally coherent brain networks estimated using ICA at rest and during cognitive tasks. Hum. Brain Mapp. 29 (2008) 828-838
15. Chuang K.H., Chiu M.J., Lin C.C., and Chen J.H. Model-free functional MRI analysis using kohonen clustering neural network and fuzzy c-means. IEEE Trans. Med. Imag. 18 (1999) 1117-1128
16. Cousin E., Peyrin C., Pichat C., Lamalle L., Le Bas J.F., and Baciu M. Functional MRI approach for assessing hemispheric predominance of regions activated by a phonological and a semantic task. Eur. J. Radiol. 63 (2007) 274-285
17. Damoiseaux J.S., Rombouts S.A., Barkhof F., Scheltens P., Stam C.J., Smith S.M., and Beckmann C.F. Consistent resting-state networks across healthy subjects. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 103 (2006) 13848-13853
18. Dave R.N., and Krishnapuram R. Robust clustering methods: a united view. IEEE Trans. Fuzzy Sys. 5 (1997) 270-293
19. Davidson A.C., and Hinkley D.V. Bootstrap Methods and Their Application (1997), University Press, Cambridge
20. Depue B.E., Curran T., and Banich M.T. Prefrontal regions orchestrate suppression of emotional memories via a two-phase process. Science 317 (2007) 215-219
21. Dimitriadou E., Barth M., Windischberger C., Hornik K., and Moser E. A quantitative comparison of functional MRI cluster analysis. Artif. Intell. Med. 31 (2004) 57-71
22. Duann J.R., Jung T.P., Makeig S., and Sejnowsk T.J. Consistency of INFOMAX ICA decomposition of functional brain imaging data. 4th Inter Symp ICA Blind Signal Separation (ICA2003) (2003), Nara, Japan 289-294
23. Efron B., and Tibshirani R. An Introduction to the Bootstrap (1993), Chapman & Hall, New York
24. Fadili M.J., Ruan S., Bloyet D., and Mazoyer B. A multistep unsupervised fuzzy clustering analysis of fMRI time series. Hum. Brain Mapp. 10 (2000) 160-178
25. Fadili M.J., Ruan S., Bloyet D., and Mazoyer B. On the number of clusters and the fuzziness index for unsupervised FCA application to BOLD fMRI time series. Med. Image Anal. 5 (2001) 55-67
26. Fox M.D., Snyder A.Z., Vincent J.L., and Raichle M.E. Intrinsic fluctuations within cortical systems account for intertrial variability in human behavior. Neuron 56 (2007) 171-184
27. Fransson P. How default is the default mode of brain function? Further evidence from intrinsic BOLD signal fluctuations. Neuropsychologia 44 (2006) 2836-2845
28. Friston K.J., and Price C.J. Degeneracy and redundancy in cognitive anatomy. Trends Cogn. Sci. 7 (2003) 151-152
29. Friston K., Price C.J., Fletcher P., Moore C., Frackowiak R.S.J., and Dolan R.J. The trouble with cognitive subtraction. NeuroImage 4 (1996) 97-104
30. Gerlach C., Law I., Gade A., and Paulson O.B. Perceptual differentiation and category effects in normal object recognition: a PET study. Brain 122 (1999) 2159-2170
31. Golay X., Kollias S., Stoll G., Meier D., Valavanis A., and Boesiger P. A new correlation-based fuzzy logic clustering algorithm for fMRI. Magn. Reson. Med. 40 (1998) 249-260
32. Gomez-Laberge C.C., Adler A.A., Cameron I.I., Nguyen T.T., and Hogan M.M.J. Selection criteria for the analysis of data-driven clusters in cerebral fMRI. IEEE Trans. Biomed. Engineer. 55 (2008) 2372-2380
33. Goutte C., Toft P., Rostrup E., Nielsen F.A., and Hansen L.K. On clustering fMRI time series. NeuroImage 9 (1999) 298-310
34. Greicius M.D., Krasnow B., Reiss A.L., and Menon V. Functional connectivity in the resting brain: a network analysis of the default mode hypothesis. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 100 (2003)
35. Gu J., Cao Z., Zheng X., and Aihua C. Treatment of ill-balanced datasets of fMRI with modified fuzzy c-means method. 27th Ann Confer IEEE Eng Med Biol. Soc. (2005), Shanghai China 1411-1414 10.1109/IEMBS.2005.1616694
36. Hampson M., Peterson B.S., Skudlarski P., Gatenby J.C., and Gore J.C. Detection of functional connectivity using temporal correlations in MR images. Hum. Brain Mapp. 15 (2002) 247-262
37. Hasson U., Nir Y., Levy I., Fuhrmann G., and Malach R. Intersubject synchronization of cortical activity during natural vision. Science 303 (2004) 1634-1640
38. Hejnar M.P., Kiehl K.A., and Calhoun V.D. Interparticipant correlations: a model free fMRI analysis technique. Hum. Brain Mapp. 28 (2007) 860-867
39. Howard D., and Patterson K. The Pyramid and Palm Trees Test: A Test of Semantic Access from Words and Pictures (1992), Thames Valley Test Company, Bury St. Edmunds
40. Jaaskelainen I.P., Koskentalo K., Balk M.H., Autti T., Kauramaki J., Pomren C., and Sams M. Inter-subject synchronization of prefrontal cortex hemodynamic activity during natural viewing. Open Neuroimag. J. 2 (2008) 14-19
41. Jancke L., Loose R., Lutz K., Specht K., and Shah N.J. Cortical activations during paced finger-tapping applying visual and auditory pacing stimuli. Brain Res. Cogn. Brain Res. 10 (2000) 51-66
42. Juch H., Zimine I., Seghier M.L., Lazeyras F., and Fasel J.H.D. Anatomical variability of the lateral frontal lobe surface: implication for intersubject variability in language neuroimaging. NeuroImage 24 (2005) 504-514
43. Kharin Y. Robustness of clustering under outliers. Lect. Notes Comput. Sci. 1280 (1997) 501-511
44. Kherif F., Poline J.P., Mériaux S., Benali H., Flandin G., and Brett M. Group analysis in functional neuroimaging: selecting subjects using similarity measures. NeuroImage 20 (2003) 2197-2208
45. Kherif, F., Josse, G., Seghier, M.L., Price, C.J., in press. The main sources of inter-subject variability in neuronal activation for reading aloud. J. Cogn. Neurosci (published online 14th August 2008).
46. Kiehl K.A., Stevens M.C., Laurens K.R., Pearlson G., Calhoun V.D., and Liddle P.F. An adaptive reflexive processing model of neurocognitive function: supporting evidence from a large scale (n = 100) fMRI study of an auditory oddball task. NeuroImage 25 (2005) 899-915
47. Leski J. Towards a robust fuzzy clustering. Fuzzy Sets Sys. 137 (2003) 215-233
48. Lynch J.C., and Tian J.R. Cortico-cortical networks and cortico-subcortical loops for the higher control of eye movements. Prog. Brain Res. 151 (2005) 461-501
49. Malinen S., Hlushchuk Y., and Hari R. Towards natural stimulation in fMRI-issues of data analysis. NeuroImage 35 (2007) 131-139
50. Marsh R., Zhu H., Schultz R.T., Quackenbush G., Royal J., Skudlarski P., and Peterson B.S. A developmental fMRI study of self-regulatory control. Hum. Brain Mapp. 27 (2006) 848-863
51. McKeown M.J., Makeig S., Brown G.G., Jung T.P., Kindermann S.S., Bell A.J., and Sejnowski T.J. Analysis of fMRI data by blind separation into independent spatial components. Hum. Brain Mapp. 6 (1998) 160-188
52. Mechelli A., Friston K.J., Frackowiak R.S., and Price C.J. Structural covariance in the human cortex. J. Neurosci. 25 (2005) 8303-8310
53. Meinecke F., Ziehe A., Kawanabe M., and Muller K.R. A resampling approach to estimate the stability of one-dimensional or multidimensional independent components. IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng. 49 (2002) 1514-1525
54. Meyer-Baese A., Wismueller A., and Lange O. Comparison of two exploratory data analysis methods for fMRI: unsupervised clustering versus independent component analysis. IEEE Trans. Inf. Technol. Biomed. 8 (2004) 387-398
55. Miller M.B., and Van Horn J.D. Individual variability in brain activations associated with episodic retrieval: a role for large-scale databases. Int. J. Psychophysiol. 63 (2007) 205-213
56. Miller M.B., Van Horn J.D., Wolford G.L., Handy T.C., Valsangkar-Smyth M., Inati S., Grafton S., and Gazzaniga M.S. Extensive individual differences in brain activations associated with episodic retrieval are reliable over time. J. Cogn. Neurosci. 14 (2002) 1200-1214
57. Moller U., Ligges M., Georgiewa P., Grunling C., Kaiser W.A., Witte H., and Blanz B. How to avoid spurious cluster validation? A methodological investigation on simulated and fMRI data. NeuroImage 17 (2002) 431-446
58. Mummery C.J., Patterson K., Hodges J.R., and Price C.J. Functional neuroanatomy of the semantic system: divisible by what?. J. Cogn. Neurosci. 10 (1998) 766-777
59. Nadeau S.E., Williamson D.J., Crosson B., Gonzalez Rothi L.J., and Heilman K.M. Functional imaging: heterogeneity in task strategy and functional anatomy and the case for individual analysis. Neuropsychiatry Neuropsychol. Behav. Neurol. 11 (1998) 83-96
60. Newman S.D., Tweig D.B., and Carpenter P.A. Baseline conditions and subtractive logic in neuroimaging. Hum. Brain Mapp. 14 (2001) 228-235
61. Noppeney U., Friston K.J., and Price C.J. Degenerate neuronal systems sustaining cognitive functions. J. Anat. 205 (2004) 433-442
62. Pena J.M., Lozano J.A., and Larranaga P. An empirical comparison of four initialization methods for the K-Means algorithm. Pattern Recogn. Lett. 20 (1999) 1027-1040
63. Pinel P., Thirion B., Meriaux S., Jobert A., Serres J., Le Bihan D., Poline J.B., and Dehaene S. Fast reproducible identification and large-scale databasing of individual functional cognitive networks. BMC Neurosci. 8 (2007) 91
64. Poldrack R.A., Wagner A.D., Prull M.W., Desmond J.E., Glover G.H., and Gabrieli J.D.E. Functional specialization for semantic and phonological processing in the left inferior prefrontal cortex. NeuroImage 10 (1999) 15-35
65. Poline J.B. Contrasts and classical inference. In: Frackowiak R.S.J., Friston K.J., Frith C., Dolan R., Price C.J., Zeki S., Ashburner J., and Penny W.D. (Eds). Human Brain Function (2003), Academic Press, London
66. Price C.J., and Friston K.J. Degeneracy and cognitive anatomy. Trends Cogn. Sci. 6 (2002) 416-421
67. Price C.J., Warburton E.A., Moore C.J., Frackowiak R.S., and Friston K.J. Dynamic diaschisis: anatomically remote and context-sensitive human brain lesions. J. Cogn. Neurosci. 13 (2001) 419-429
68. Price C.J., Gorno-Tempini M.L., Graham K., Biggio N., Mechelli A., Petterson K., and Noppeney U. Normal and pathological reading: converging data from lesion and imaging studies. NeuroImage 20 (2003) 276-289
69. Pugh K.R., Shaywitz B.A., Shaywitz S.E., Constable R.T., Skudlarski P., Fulbright R.K., Bronen R.A., Shankweiler D.P., Katz L., Fletcher J.M., and Gore J.C. Cerebral organization of component processes in reading. Brain 119 (1996) 1221-1238
70. Raichle M.E., MacLeod A.M., Snyder A.Z., Powers W.J., Gusnard D.A., and Shulman G.L. A default mode of brain function. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 98 (2001) 676-682
71. Reinke K., Fernandes M., Schwindt G., O'Craven K., and Grady C.L. Functional specificity of the visual word form area: general activation for words and symbols but specific network activation for words. Brain Lang. 104 (2008) 180-189
72. Rezaee M.R., Lelieveldt B.P.F., and Reider J.H.C. A new cluster validity index for the fuzzy c-mean. Pattern Recogn. Lett. 19 (1998) 237-246
73. Ricci P.T., Zelkowicz B.J., Nebes R.D., Meltzer C.C., Mintun M.A., and Becker J.T. Functional neuroanatomy of semantic memory: recognition of semantic associations. NeuroImage 9 (1999) 88-96
74. Rombouts S.A., Barkhof F., Goekoop R., Stam C.J., and Scheltens P. Altered resting state networks in mild cognitive impairment and mild Alzheimer's disease: an fMRI study. Hum. Brain Mapp. 26 (2005) 231-239
75. Salem, S.A., Nandi, A.K., in press. Development of assessment criteria for clustering algorithms. Pattern Anal. Applic. (published online 26th January 2008). doi:10.1007/s10044-007-0099-1.
76. Salvador R., Suckling J., Coleman M.R., Pickard J.D., Menon D., and Bullmore E. Neurophysiological architecture of functional magnetic resonance images of human brain. Cereb. Cortex 15 (2005) 1332-1342
77. Sartori G., and Umilta C. How to avoid the fallacies of cognitive subtraction in brain imaging. Brain Lang. 74 (2000) 191-212
78. Schapiro M.B., Schmithorst V.J., Wilke M., Byars A.W., Strawsburg R.H., and Holland S.K. BOLD fMRI signal increases with age in selected brain regions in children. NeuroReport 15 (2004) 2575-2578
79. Schmahmann J.D., Doyen J., Toga A.W., Petrides M., and Evans A.C. MRI Atlas of The Human Cerebellum (2000), Academic Press, California-USA
80. Schmithorst V.J., Holland S.K., and Plante E. Object identification and lexical/semantic access in children: a functional magnetic resonance imaging study of word-picture matching. Hum. Brain Mapp. 28 (2007) 1060-1074
81. Seghier M.L., Lazeyras F., Pegna A.J., Annoni J.M., Zimine I., Mayer E., Michel C.M., and Khateb A. Variability of fMRI activation during a phonological and semantic language task in healthy subjects. Hum. Brain Mapp. 23 (2004) 140-155
82. Seghier M.L., Friston K.J., and Price C.J. Detecting subject-specific activations using fuzzy clustering. NeuroImage 36 (2007) 594-605
83. Seghier M.L., Lazeyras F., Pegna A.J., Annoni J.M., and Khateb A. Group analysis and the subject factor in functional magnetic resonance imaging: analysis of fifty right-handed healthy subjects in a semantic language task. Hum. Brain Mapp. 29 (2008) 461-477
84. Seghier M.L., Lee H.L., Schofield T., Ellis C.L., and Price C.J. Inter-subject variability in the use of two different neuronal networks for reading aloud familiar words. NeuroImage 42 (2008) 1226-1236
85. Shao J., and Tu D. The Jackknife and Bootstrap (1995), Springer
86. Sidtis J.J., Strother S.C., Anderson J.R., and Rottenberg D.A. Are brain functions really additive?. NeuroImage 9 (1999) 490-496
87. Smith S.M., Beckmann C.F., Ramnani N., Woolrich M.W., Bannister P.R., Jenkinson M., Matthews P.M., and McGonigle D.J. Variability in fMRI: a re-examination of inter-session differences. Hum. Brain Mapp. 24 (2005) 248-257
88. Smolders A., De Martino F., Staeren N., Scheunders P., Sijbers J., Goebel R., and Formisano E. Dissecting cognitive stages with time-resolved fMRI data: a comparison of fuzzy clustering and independent component analysis. Magn. Reson. Imaging 25 (2007) 860-868
89. Stark C.E., and Squire L.R. When zero is not zero: the problem of ambiguous baseline conditions in fMRI. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 98 (2001) 12760-12766
90. Sugiura M., Friston K.J., Willmes K., Shah N.J., Zilles K., and Fink G.R. Analysis of intersubject variability in activation: an application to the incidental episodic retrieval during recognition test. Hum. Brain Mapp. 28 (2007) 49-58
91. Sun H., Wang S., and Jiang Q. FCM-based model selection algorithms for determining the number of clusters. Pattern Recogn. 37 (2004) 2027-2037
92. Swinburn K., Porter G., and Howard D. The Comprehensive Aphasia Test (2004), Psychology Press, New York
93. Szaflarski J.P., Holland S.K., Schmithorst V.J., and Byars A.W. fMRI study of language lateralization in children and adults. Hum. Brain Mapp. 27 (2006) 202-212
94. Tootell R.B.H., Hadjikhani N.K., Mendola J.D., Marrett S., and Dale A.M. From retinotopy to recognition: fMRI in human visual cortex. Trends Cogn. Sci. 2 (1998) 174-183
95. van den Heuvel M., Mandl R., and Hulshoff Pol H. Normalized cut group clustering of resting-state fMRI data. PLoS ONE 3 (2008) e2001
96. Vandenberghe R., Price C., Wise R., Josephs O., and Frackowiak R.S.J. Functional anatomy of a common semantic system for words and pictures. Nature 383 (1996) 254-256
97. Vandenbulcke M., Peeters R., Dupont P., Van Hecke P., and Vandenberghe R. Word reading and posterior temporal dysfunction in amnestic mild cognitive impairment. Cereb. Cortex 17 (2007) 542-551
98. Wager T.D., Keller M.C., Lacey S.C., and Jonides J. Increased sensitivity in neuroimaging analyses using robust regression. NeuroImage 26 (2005) 99-113
99. Waites A.B., Briellmann R.S., Saling M.M., Abbott D.F., and Jackson G.D. Functional connectivity networks are disrupted in left temporal lobe epilepsy. Ann. Neurol. 59 (2006) 335-343
100. Wang K., Liang M., Wang L., Tian L., Zhang X., Li K., and Jiang T. Altered functional connectivity in early Alzheimer's disease: a resting-state fMRI study. Hum. Brain Mapp. 28 (2007) 967-978
101. Worsley K.J., and Friston K.J. Analysis of fMRI time-series revisited-again. NeuroImage 2 (1995) 173-181
102. Wu C.F.J. Jackknife, bootstrap and other resampling methods in regression analysis. Ann. Stat. 14 (1986) 1261-1295
103. Ylipaavalniemi J., and Vigário R. Analyzing consistency of independent components: an fMRI illustration. NeuroImage 39 (2008) 169-180
104. Zilles K., Schleicher A., Langemann C., Amunts K., Morosan P., Palomero-Gallagher N., Schormann T., Mohlberg H., Burgel U., Steinmetz H., Schlaug G., and Roland P. Quantitative analysis of sulci in the human cerebral cortex: development, regional heterogeneity, gender difference, asymmetry, intersubject variability and cortical architecture. Hum. Brain Mapp. 5 (1997) 218-221