Are low-price promises collusion guarantees? An experimental test of price matching policies

Spanish Economic Review

Volumn 9, Issue 1, 2007, Pages 59-77

  Fatas, Enrique ^a   Mañez, Juan A ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF VALENCIA   (Spain)

Author keywords

Experimental economics; Price matching guarantees

Indexed keywords

EID: 33847289318     PISSN: 14355469     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s10108-006-9012-0     Document Type: Article

References (42)

1. Arbatskaya M, Hviid M, Shaffer G (1999) Promises to match or beat rival prices. In: Baye M (ed) Advances in applied microeconomics, vol 8. JAI Press Inc, Greenwich, pp 149-171
2. Arbatskaya M, Hviid M, Shaffer G (2004) On the incidence and variety of low price guarantees. J Law Econ XLVII:307-332
3. Baye MR, Kovenock D (1994) How to sell a pickup truck: 'Beat-or-Pay' advertisements as facilitating devices. Int J Ind Organ 12:21-33
4. Belton M (1987) A model of doupoly and meeting or beating the competition. Int J Ind Organ 5:399-417
5. Benson B, Faminow ML (1988) The impact of experience on prices and profits in experimental dupoly markets. J Econ Behav Organ 9:345-365
6. Broseta B, Fatas E, Neugebauer T (2003) Asset markets and equilibrium selection in public goods games with provision points: an experimental study. Econ Inq 41(3):574-591
7. Capra M, Goeree JK, Gómez R, Holt CA (2002) Learning and noisy equilibrium behaviour in an experimental study of imperfect price competition. Int Econ Rev 43(3):613-636
8. Corts KS (1995) On the robustness of the argument that price matching is anti-competitive. Econ Lett 47:417-421
9. Corts KS (1996) On the competitive effects of price matching policies. Int J Ind Organ 15:283-299
10. Croson R, Fatas E, Neugebauer T (2005) Reciprocity, matching and conditional cooperation in two public goods games. Econ Lett 87:95-101
11. Davis DD, Holt CA (1993) Experimental economics. Princeton University Press, Princeton
12. Deck CA, Wilson B (2003) Automated pricing rules in electronic posted offer markets. Econ Inq 41(2):208-223
13. Dixit A, Nalebuff B (1991) Thinking strategically. W.W. Norten & Company, Inc., New York
14. Doyle C (1988) Different selling strategies in Bertrand oligopoly. Econ Lett 28:387-390
15. Dufwenberg M, Gneezy U (2000) Price competition and market concentration: an experimental study. Int J Ind Organ 18:7-22
16. Edlin A (1997) Do guaranteed-low price policies guarantee high prices, and can antitrust rise to the challenge? Harv Law Rev 111:528-575
17. Edlin A, Emch E (1999) The welfare losses from price-matching policies. J Ind Econ 47(2):145-167
18. Fatas E, Georgantzís N, Mañez J, Sabater G (2005) Pro-competitive price beating guarantees. Experimental evidence. Rev Ind Organ 26:115-136
19. Fatas E, Neugebauer T, Perote J (2006) Within team competition in the minimum game. Pac Econ Rev 11(2):247-270
20. Fischbacher U (1999) z-Tree: Zurich toolbox for readymade economic experiments - experimenter's manual. Working paper number. 21, Institute for Empirical Research in Economics, University of Zurich
21. Friedman JW, Hoggatt AC (1980) An experiment in non-cooperative oligopoly, Research in Experimental Economics, vol 1. supplement JAI Press, Greenwich
22. Garcia-Gallego A, Georgantzis N (2001) Multiproduct activity in an experimental differentiated oligopoly. Int J Ind Organ 19:493-518
23. Hess J, Gerstner E (1991) Price matching policies: an empirical case. Manage Decis Econ 12:305-315
24. Hviid M, Shaffer G (1994) Do low price guarantees facilitate tacit collusion? University of Michigan working paper, 94-02
25. Hviid M, Shaffer O (1999) Hassle costs: the Achilles' heel of price-matching guarantees. J Econ Manage Strat 8:489-521
26. Holt C (1995) Industrial organization: a survey of laboratory research. In: Kagel JH, Roth AE (eds) Handbook of experimental economics, Princeton University Press, Princeton
27. Jain S, Srivastava J (2000) An experimental and theoretical analysis of price-matching refund policies. J Mark Res 37:351-362
28. Kaplan T (2000) Effective price-matching: a comment. Int J Ind Organ 18:1291-1294
29. Logan J, Lutter R (1989) Guaranteed lowest prices: do they facilitate collusion? Econ Lett 31:189-192
30. Mañez JA (2006) Unbeatable value low-price guarantee: collusive mechanism or advertising strategy. J Econ Manage Strat 15:143-166
31. Milyo J, Waldfogel J (1999) The effects of price advertising on prices: evidence on the wake of 44 Liquormart. Am Econ Rev 89:1081-1096
32. Moorthy S, Winter RA (2002) Price-matching guarantees. Review of marketing science working papers, vol 2, No. 1, Article 2. http://www.bepress. com/roms/vol2/iss1/paper2
33. Plott C (1982) Industrial organization theory and experimental economics. J Econ Lit 20:1485-1527
34. Plott C (1989) An updated review of industrial organization: applications of experimental methods. In: Schmalensee R, Willig R (eds) Handbook of industrial organization, vol II. North-Holland, New York
35. Png IPL, Hirschleifer D (1987) Price discrimination through offers to match price. J Bus 60:365-383
36. Salop S (1986) Practices that (credibly) facilitate oligopoly coordination. In: Stiglitz J, Mathewson F (eds) New developments in the analysis of market structure, MIT Press, Cambridge
37. Sargent M (1993) Economics upside-down: low price guarantees as mechanism for facilitating tacit collusion. Univ PA Law Rev 141:2055-2118
38. Smith MD, Bailey J, Brynjolfsson E (1999) Understanding digital markets. In: Brynjolfsson E, Kahin B (eds) Understanding the digital economy, MIT Press, Cambridge
39. Srivastava J (2001) A consumer perspective on price matching refund policies: effect on price perceptions and search behaviour. J Consum Res 28(2):296-308
40. Srivastava J, Lurie N (2004) Price matching refund policies as signals of store price image? J Retail 80:117-128
41. Van Huyck J, Battalio R, Beil R (1990) Tacit coordination games, strategic uncertainty, and coordination failure. Am Econ Rev 80:234-248
42. Zhang J (1995) Price-matching policy and the principle of minimum differentiation. J Ind Econ 43:287-299