Soft computing approaches to fault diagnosis for dynamic systems

European Journal of Control

Volumn 7, Issue 2-3, 2001, Pages 248-286

  Calado, J M F ^a   Korbicz, J ^b   Patan, K ^b   Patton, R J ^c   Sa Da Costa J M G ^d  

^a INSTITUTO POLITÉCNICO DE LISBOA   (Portugal)

^b UNIVERSITY OF ZIELONA GÓRA   (Poland)

^c UNIVERSITY OF HULL   (United Kingdom)

^d Instituto Superior Tecnico Institute for Mechanical Engineering   (Portugal)

Author keywords

Classification; Computational intelligence in control; Evolutionary algorithms; Fault diagnosis; FDI; Fuzzy systems; Neural networks; Soft computing methods

Indexed keywords

EID: 27644597250     PISSN: 09473580     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.3166/ejc.7.248-286     Document Type: Article

References (137)

1. Patton RJ, Frank PM, Clark RN. Issues in fault diagnosis for dynamic systems. Springer Verlag, London 2000
2. Chen J, Patton RJ. Robust model based fault diagnosis for dynamic systems. Kluwer Academic Publishers ISBN 0-7923-8411-3 1999
3. Isermann R. Fault diagnosis of machines via parameter estimation and knowledge processing - a tutorial paper. Automatica 1994; 29(4): 815-835
4. Gertler J. Fault detection and diagnosis in engineering systems. Marcel Dekker 1998
5. De Kleer J, Williams BC. Diagnosis multiple faults. Artificial Intelligence 1981; 32: 97-130
6. Shen Q, Leitch R. Fuzzy qualitative simulation. IEEE Trans Sys Man & Cybernetics 1993; SMC-23(4): 1038-1061
7. Kuipers BJ. Qualitative reasoning. MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts 1994
8. Lunze J, Schröder J. Application of qualitative observation and prediction to a neutralisation process. Proceedings of the 14th IFAC World Congress, Beijing. In: Chen H-F, Cheng D-Z, Zhang J-F (eds). Pergamon Press 2000, vol I, pp 49-54
9. Dexter AL. Fuzzy model-based fault diagnosis. IEE Proc Control Theory Appl 1995; 142(6): 545-550
10. Naidu S, Zafirou E, McAvoy TJ. Use of neural-networks for fault detection in a control system. IEEE Control Sys Magazine 1990; 10: 49-55
11. Frank PM, Kuipel N. Fuzzy Supervision and application to lean production. Int J Systems Sci 1993; 24(10): 1935-1944
12. Isermann R. Process fault detection and diagnosis methods. In: Ruokonen T (ed.). Proc. IFAC symposium SAFEPROCESS'94, Helsinki, Finland, 2, 597-612, Pergamon Press
13. Patton RJ. Robustness in model-based fault-diagnosis: The 1997 Situation, A Rev. Control, 21, 103-123, Pergamon Press
14. ∞ filtering for sensitivity optimisation of detection filters. In: Edelmayer, Bányász (eds). Proceedings of the IFAC symposium SAFEPROCESS 2000. Elsevier Press, Budapest 14-16 June 2000, pp 324-330,
15. Chen J, Patton RJ, Liu GP. Optimal residual design for fault diagnosis using multi-objective optimisation and genetic algorithms. Int J Sys Sci 1997; 27(6): 567-576
16. Fine TL. Feed-forward neural network methodology. Springer Verlag, New York 1999
17. Hunt K, Sbarbaro, Zbikowski, Gawthrop P. Neural netwoks for control systems: a survey. Automatica 1992; 28(6): 1083-1112
18. Yin CM. Application of artificial NNs to condition monitoring. PhD thesis, University of Aberdeen, 1993
19. Wang H, Brown M, Harris CJ. Fault detection for a class of unknown non-linear systems via associative memory networks. Proc I MechE J of Syst and Control Eng 1994; 208: 101-107
20. Dong D, McAvoy TJ. Non-linear principal component analysis - based on principal curves and neural networks. Computers and Chemical Engineering 1996; 20: 65-78
21. Watton J, Pham DT. An artificial NN based approach to fault diagnosis and classification of fluid power systems. J Sys & Con Eng 1997; 211(4): 307-317
22. Crowther WJ, Edge KA, Burrows CR, Atkinson RM, Woollons DJ. Fault diagnosis of a hydraulic actuator circuit using NNs: an output vector space classification approach. J Sys and Control Engineering 1998; 212(1): 57-68
23. Sharif MA, Grosvenor RI. Process plant condition monitoring and fault diagnosis. J Proc Mech Eng 1998; 212(1): 13-30
24. Kuhlmann D, Handschin E. Hoffmann W. ANN-based fault diagnosis system ready for practical application. Engineering Intelligent Systems for Electrical Engineering and Communications 1999; 7(1): 29-39
25. Weerasinghe M, Gomm JB, Williams D. Neural networks for fault diagnosis of a nuclear fuel processing plant at different operating points. Control Engineering Practice 1998; 6(2): 281-289
26. Maki Y, Loparo KA. 1998; A. neural-network approach to fault detection and diagnosis in industrial processes. IEEE Trans on Control Sys Tech 1997; 5(6): 529-541
27. Vemuri AT, Polycarpou MM. Neural-network-based robust fault diagnosis in robotic systems. IEEE Trans on Neural Networks 1997; 8(6): 1410-1420
28. Butler KL, Momoh JA, Dias LG, Sobajic DJ. An approach to power distribution fault diagnosis using a neural net based supervised clustering methodology. Engineering Intelligent Systems for Electrical Engineering & Communications 1997; 5(1): 51-57
29. Li CJ, Fan YM. Recurrent neural networks for fault diagnosis and severity assessment of a screw compressor. J Dynamic Sys Measurement & Control - Trans of the ASME 1999; 121(4): 724-729
30. Yu DL, Gomm JB, Williams D. Sensor fault diagnosis in a chemical process via RBF neural networks. Control Engineering Practice 1999; 7(1): 49-55
31. Narendra KG, Sood VK, Khorasani K, Patel R. IEEE Trans Power Sys 1998; 13(1): 77-183
32. Narendra KS. Neural networks for control: theory and practice. 'Proc of IEEE October 1996; 84(10): 1385-1406
33. Brown M, Harris CJ. The modelling abilities of the binary CMAC. IEEE Int Conf NNs, 1994b; 1335-1339
34. Ren X, Chen J. A modified NN for dynamical system identification & Control. Proceedings of the 14th World Congress of IFAC. ISBN O 08 043248 4 1999.
35. Pan M-C, Van Brussel H, Sas P. Intelligent joint fault diagnosis of industrial robots. Mech Sys & Signal Proc 1998; 12(4): 571-588
36. James Li C, Yu X. High pressure air compressor valve fault diagnosis using feedforward NNs. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing 1995; 9(5): 527-536
37. Boucherma M. Turbo-generator fault-detection and diagnosis based on artificial NNs. Ph.D Thesis, University of Sheffield, UK (no. 45-11736), 1995
38. Korbicz J, Obuchowicz A, Patan K. Network of dynamic neurons in fault detection systems. IEEE Int Conf Systems, Man & Cybernetics, San Diego, USA. October 11-14, 1998 (published on CD-ROM No.98CH36218).
39. Han Z, Frank PM. Physical parameter based FDI with NNs. In: Patton, Chen (eds). Proc. IFAC Symposium SAFEPROCESS'97, Pergamon Press, Hull, UK, pp 283-288.
40. Ficola A, Cava M La, Magnino F. An approach to fault diagnosis for non-linear dynamic systems using neural networks, In: Patton & Chen (eds), Proc. IFAC Symposium SAFEPROCESS'97, Pergamon Press, Hull, UK, pp 355-360.
41. Fuente MJ, Vega P. Neural networks applied to fault detection of a biotechnological process. Eng Applies of Artificial Intelligence 1999; 12(5): 569-584
42. Gomm JB. Adaptive NN approach to on-line learning for process fault diagnosis. Trans Inst Meas Contrl 1998; 20(3): 144-152
43. Wilson DJ. Neural networks for Multivariate SPC. PhD Thesis, Queens University Belfast, Faculty of Engineering, 1998
44. Dalmi I, Kocvacs L, Lorant I, Terstyansky G. Application of supervised and unsupervised learning methods to fault diagnosis. Proceedings of 14th World Congress of IFAC, ISBN 0 08 043248 4, 1999
45. Wang ZY, Liu YL, Griffin PJ. A combined ANN and expert system tool for transformer fault diagnosis. IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery 1998; 13(4): 1224-1229
46. Aminian M, Aminian F. Neural-network based analogcircuit fault diagnosis using the wavelet transform as pre-processor. IEEE Trans Circuits & Sys (ii)-analog and digital signal processing 2000; 47(2): 151-156
47. Pantelelis NG, Kanarachos AE, Gotzias N. Neural networks and simple models for the fault diagnosis of naval turbochargers. Mathematics and computers in Simulation 2000; 51(3-4): 387-397
48. Liu W. An extended Kalman filter and NN cascade fault diagnosis strategy for the glutamic acid fermentation process. Artificial Intelligence in Engineering 1999; 13(2): 131-140
49. Zhao JS, Chen BZ, Shen JZ. Multidimensional nonorthogonal wavelet-sigmoid basis function NN for dynamic process fault diagnosis. Computers & Chemical Engineering 1998; 23(1): 83-92
50. Zhao JS, Chen BZ, Shen JZ. A hybrid ANN-ES system for dynamic fault diagnosis of hydrocracking process. Computers & Chemical Engineering 21(SS): S929-S933
51. Ye N, Zhao B. 1997; A hybrid intelligent system for fault diagnosis of advanced manufacturing system. Int J Prod Res 1996; 34(2): 555-576
52. Maidon Y, Jervis BW, Fouillat P, Lesage S. Using artificial neural networks or Lagrange interpolation to characterize the faults in an analog circuit: an experimental study, IEEE Trans on Instr & Meas 1999; 48(5): 932-938
53. Ogg S, Lesage S, Jervis BW, Maidon Y, Zimmer T. Multiple fault diagnosis in analogue circuits using time domain response features and multi-layer perceptrons. IEE Proc Circuits Devices & Systems 1998; 145(4): 213-218
54. Mamdani E. Applications of fuzzy algorithms for control of simple dynamic plant. Proc. IEE 1994; 121: 1585-1588
55. Evsukoff A, Gentil S, Montmain J. Fuzzy reasoning in co-operation supervision systems. Control Engineering Practice 2000; 8: 389-407
56. Yang HT, Liao CC. Adaptive fuzzy diagnosis system for dissolved gas analysis of power transformers. IEEE Trans Power Del 1999; 14(4): 1342-1350
57. Lu Y, Chen TQ, Hamilton B. A fuzzy diagnostic model and its application in automotive engineering diagnosis. Applied Intelligence 1998; 9(3): 231-243.
58. Insfran AHF, da Silva APA, Lambert Torres G. Fault diagnosis using fuzzy sets. Engineering Intelligent Sys for Elec Eng. & Comms 1999; 7(4): 177-182
59. Dexter AL, Benouarets M. Model-based fault diagnosis using fuzzy matching. IEEE Trans Sys Man & Cybernet (a)-systems and humans 1997; 27(5): 673-682
60. Mechefske CK. Objective machinery fault diagnosis using fuzzy logic. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing 1998; 12(6): 855-862
61. Patton RJ, Chen J, Lopez-Toribio CJ. Fuzzy observers for non-linear dynamic systems fault diagnosis. Proc. 37th IEEE conference on decision and control 1998; 84-89
62. Kuipel N, Frank PM. A fuzzy FDI decision-making system for the support of the human operator. In: Patton, Chen (eds). Proc. IFAC Symposium SAFEPROCESS'97, Hull, UK, 721-726, Pergamon Press 1998
63. Ford N. Expert systems and artificial intelligence: an information manager's guide, London: Library Association, 1991
64. Verbruggen HB, Babuka R. Fuzzy logic control advances in applies. Word Scientific Press 1999
65. Kaymak U. Fuzzy decision-making with control applications. PhD Thesis, Delft University of Technology, PO Box 5031,2600 GA, Delft, The Netherlands, 1999
66. Bellman RE, Zadeh Lotfi A. Decision-making in a fuzzy environment. Management Science 1990 17(4): 141-164
67. Isoc D. On a new approach to build the membership functions for fuzzy models. Proc. CONTI '98, Timisoara, Romania 1998a
68. Isoc D. Identification and clustering - some approaches and evaluations. SIMSIS '98, Galati, Romania. 1998b
69. Wang LX, Mendel J. Generating fuzzy rules by learning from examples. IEEE Trans Syst, Man, Cybern 1992; 22: 1414-1427
70. Ballé P, Nells OC, Füssel D. Fault detection for nonlinear process based on local linear fuzzy models in parallel and series-parallel model, In: Patton & Chen (eds), Proc. IFAC Symposium SAFEPROCESS'97, Pergamon Press, Hull, UK, pp 1137-1142
71. Fussel D, Ballé P, Isermann R. Closed-loop fault diagnosis-based on a non-linear process model and automatic fuzzy rule generation. In: Patton & Chen (eds), Proc. IFAC Symp. Fault Detection, Supervision & Safety for Technical Processes, SAFEPROCESS'97, Sept 1997, Pergamon Press, University of Hull, UK.
72. Schneider H, Frank PM. Fuzzy logic based threshold adaptation for fault detection in robots. Proceedings of the third IEEE conference, on control applications, Glasgow, Scotland. 1994; pp 1127-1132
73. Frank PM. Advances in observer based fault diagnosis. Proceedings of international, conference on fault diagnosis: TOOLDIAG '93, Toulouse. 1993; pp 817-836
74. Frank PM. Application of fuzzy logic process supervision and fault diagnosis. Pre-prints of the IFAC symp. on fault detection, supervision & safety for technical processes, SAFEPROCESS '94, Espo, Finland 1994, pp 531-538
75. Frank PM. Analytical and qualitative model-based fault diagnosis - a survey and some new results. European J of Contr 1996; 2(1): 6-28
76. Schneider H, Frank PM. Observer-based supervision and fault detection in robots using non-linear and fuzzy-logic residual evaluation. IEEE Trans Contr Sys Techno 1996; 4(3): 274-282
77. Frank PM, Koppen-Seliger B. Fuzzy logic and neural network applications to fault diagnosis. Int J of Approximate Reasoning 1997; 16(1): 67-88
78. Linkens DA, Abbod MF. Supervisory intelligent control using fuzzy logic hierarchy. Trans Inst M C 1993; 15(3): 112-132
79. Farag WA, Quintana VH, Lambert-Torres G. A genetic-based neuro-fuzzy approach for modelling and control of dynamical systems. IEEE Trans Neural Networks 1998; 9(5):
80. Li S, Elbestawi MA. Fuzzy clustering for automated tool condition monitoring in machining, mechanical systems and signal processing, 1996; 10(5): 533-550 Academic Press
81. Altug S, Chow MY, Trussell HJ. Fuzzy inference systems implemented on neural architectures for motor fault detection and diagnosis 1999; IEEE Trans Ind Electron 1999; 46(6): 1069-1079
82. Aggarwal RK, Xuan QY, Johns AT, Li FR, Bennett A. A novel approach to fault diagnosis in multi-circuit transmission lines using fuzzy ARTmap NNs. IEEE Trans on Neural Networks 1993; 10(5): 1214-1221
83. Jota PRS, Islam SM, Wu T, Ledwich G. A class of hybrid intelligent system for fault diagnosis in electrical power systems. Neurocomputing 1998; 23(1-3): 207-224
84. Pfeufer T, Ayoubi M. Application of a hybrid neurofuzzy system to the fault diagnosis of an automotive electromechanical actuator, Fuzzy Sets & Sys 1997; 89(3): 351-360.
85. Ozyurt B, Kandel A. A hybrid hierarchical NN-fuzzy expert system approach to chemical process fault diagnosis. Fuzzy Sets & Sys 1996; 83(1): 11-25
86. Patan K, Obuchowicz A, Korbicz J. Cascade network of dynamic neurons in fault detection systems. In: Proceedings of the European control conference, ECC '99, Karlsruhe, Germany. Published on CD-ROM, 1999
87. Calado JMF. On-line fault diagnosis of industrial processes based on artificial intelligence techniques. PhD Thesis, Control Engineering Research Centre, City University, London, UK 1996
88. Jang JSR, Sun CT. Functional equivalence between radial basis function networks and fuzzy systems. IEEE Trans Neural Networks 1993; 4: 156-158
89. Lopez CJ, Patton RJ, Daley S. Takagi-Sugeno fuzzy fault tolerant control of an induction motor. Special Issue of NeuroComputing & Applications J on N-F Systems 1999
90. Wang H, Tanaka K, Griffin MF. Parallel distributed compensation of a non-linear systems by Takagi and Sugeno fuzzy models. Proc. FUZZ-IEEE/IFES '95, 531-538
91. Tanaka K, Takayuki I, Wang H. Design of fuzzy control systems. Based on Relaxed LMI Stability Conditions. Proc. 35th CDC, Kobe. 1996, pp 598-603
92. Leitch R. Engineering diagnosis: match problems to solutions, Proceedings of the international conference on fault diagnosis: TOOLDIAG '93, Toulouse. 1993, pp 837-844
93. Zhuang Z, Frank PM. Qualitative observer and its application to fault detection and isolation systems, Proc. IMechE, 1997
94. Obuchowicz, Patan K. An algorithm of evolutionary search with soft selection for training multi-layer feed-forward NNs. Proceedings of 3rd conference. NN & their applications, Kule, Poland. October. 14-18, 1997. pp 123-128
95. Obuchowicz, Korbicz J: Evolutionary search with soft selection and forced direction of mutation. Proceedings of 7th International symposium intelligent information system, Malbork, Poland. June 15-19 1998, pp 300-309
96. Patton RJ, Chen J, Liu GP. Robust fault detection of dynamic systems via genetic algorithms. Proceedings of IMechE Part I-J. of Syst. & Contr. Eng 1997; 211(5): 357-364
97. Zhou YP, Zhou BQ, Wu DX. Application of genetic algorithms to fault diagnosis in nuclear power plants. Reliability Eng & Sys Safety 2000; 67(2): 153-160
98. Wen FS, Han ZX. A refined genetic algorithm for fault section estimation in power systems using the time sequence information of circuit breakers. Electric Machines & Power Systems. 1996; 24(8): 801-815
99. Koivo HN. Artificial neural networks in fault diagnosis and control. Control Eng Practice 1994; 2: 89-101
100. Korbicz J. Neural networks and their application in fault detection and diagnosis. In: Proc. IFAC symposium. Fault Detection, Supervision and Safety for Technical Process SAFEPROCESS '97, Hull, UK, vol. 1, pp 377-382
101. Sorsa T, Koivo HN. Application of artificial neural networks in process fault diagnosis. Automatica 1993; 29: 843-849
102. Korbicz J, Patan K, Obuchowicz A. Dynamic neural networks for process modelling in fault detection and isolation systems. Intl J Applied Mathematics and Computer Science 1999; 9: 519-546
103. Narendra KS, Parthasarathy K. Identification and control of dynamic systems using neural networks. IEEE Trans on Neural Networks 1990; 1: 4-27
104. Patan K. Artificial dynamic neural networks and their application in modelling of industrial processes. PhD Thesis, Warsaw University of Technology Press, Warsaw, 2000
105. Elman JL. Finding structure in time. Cognitive Science 1990; 14: 14-211
106. Farlow SJ. (ed.). Self-organizing methods in model-line: GMDH-type algorithms, Mersel Dekker Inc, New York 1984
107. Korbicz J, Kus J. Dynamic GMDH neural networks and their application in fault detection systems. In: Proceedings. European control conference, ECC '99, Karlsruhe, Germany. Published on CD-ROM, 1999
108. Patton RJ, Korbicz J (eds). Advances in computational intelligence, Special Issue in: Intl J Applied Mathematics and Computer Science 1999; 9:
109. Kohonen T. Self-organization and associative memory. Springer-Verlag, Berlin 1984
110. Marciniak A, Korbicz J. Structure optimisation of neural network ensemble. In: Proceedings of 5th international conference on neural networks and soft computing, Zakopane, Poland. 2000, pp 100-105
111. Patan K, Korbicz J. Application of dynamic neural networks in an industrial plant In: Proceedings. IFAC symposium on fault detection, supervision and safety for technical process SAFEPROCESS '2000, Budapest, Hungary, vol. 1, pp 186-191
112. Calado JMF, Roberts PD. Fuzzy neural network applied to fault detection and diagnosis of abrupt and incipient faults. Proceedings of the InstMC/IEE/IEEE symposium on advances in fault diagnosis in process control III, York, UK. April 1996, pp 1-7
113. Chen J. Robust residual generation for model-based fault diagnosis of dynamic Systems. PhD Thesis, Department of Electronics, University of York, UK 1995
114. Calado JMF, Sá da Costa JMG. An expert system coupled with a hierarchical fuzzy neural network approach for multiple fault diagnosis. Intel J Applied Mathematics and Computer Sciences 1999; 9(3): 667-687
115. Haykin S. Neural networks: a comprehensive foundation. Macmillan College Publishing Company, Inc 1994
116. Turban E. Expert systems and applied artificial intelligence. Macmillan Publishing Company, Inc 1992
117. Calado JMF, Roberts PD. An intelligent on-line supervisory fault detection and diagnosis system. Pre-prints of the /th IFAC/IFORS/IMACS symposium on large scale systems: theory and applications, London, Elsevier Science, Vol. 2, pp 917-922
118. Clancey WJ. Heuristic classification. Artificial Intelligence 1985; 27: 289-350
119. Moor RL, Kramer MA. Expert systems in on-line process control. Chemical Control III, omer 1986, pp 839-867
120. Chitarro L, Guida G, Tasso C, Toppano E. Functional and teleogical knowledge in the multi-modeling approach for reasoning about physical systems: A case study in Diagnosis. IEEE Trans On Syst, Man and Cybernetics 1993; 23(6): 1718-1751
121. Jackson. P. Introduction to expert systems 2nd edn, Addison-Wesley 1990
122. Venkatasubramanian V, Rich SH. An object-oriented two-tier architecture for integrating compiled and deep-level knowledge for process diagnosis. Computers and Chemical Engineering 1988; 12(9/10): 903-921
123. Leitch RR, Freitag H, Shen Q, Struss P, Tornielli G. ARTIST: A methodological approach to specifying model-based diagnosis system. In: (Guida G. Stefanini A. eds). Industrial applications of knowledge based diagnosis
124. Finch FE, Kramer MA. Narrowing diagnosis focus using functional decomposition. AIChE Journal 1998; 34(1): 25-36
125. Steels L. Diagnosis with a function-fault model, applied artificial intelligence 1989; 3(2-3): 213-237
126. Zhang J, Roberts PD. Process fault diagnosis with diagnostic rules based on structural decomposition. J Process Control 1991; 1: 259-269
127. Oyeleye OO, Kramer MA. Qualitative simulation of chemical process systems: steady-state analyses. AIChE Journal 1988; 34(9): 1441-1453
128. Riedmiller M, Braun H. A direct adaptive method for faster back-propagation learning: The RPROP algorithm. Proceedings IEEE international conference on neural networks, San Francisco, CA 1993, 586-591
129. Ingham I, Dunn IJ, Heinzle S, Prenosil JE. Chemical engineering dynamics: Modelling with PC simulations. VCH 1994
130. Calado JMF, Roberts PD. Generating fault detection heuristic rules through deep and shallow knowledge of the Process. Proceedings of UKACC/IEE Int Conf on Control '96, Exeter, UK, 2-5 September 1996b Vol. 1, No. 427, pp 299-304
131. Frank PM, Koppen-Selinger B. New developments using AI in fault diagnosis. Eng Applic Artif Intell 1997; 10: 3-14
132. Witczak M, Obuchowicz A, Korbicz J. Design of nonlinear state observers using genetic programming, In: Proceedings 3rd National conference on evolutionary algorithms and global optimisation, Potok Zloty Poland 1999, pp 345-352
133. Witczak M, Korbicz J. Genetic programming based observers for non-linear systems. In: Proc 4th IFAC Symp. Fault Detection Supervision and Safety for Technical Processes, SAFEPROCESS '2000, Budapest, Hungary, vol. 2, pp 967-972
134. Michalewicz Z. Genetic Algorithms + Data Structure-s = Evolution Programs. Heidenberg: Springer Verlag, Berlin 1996
135. Obuchowicz A. Architecture optimisation of a network of dynamic neurons using the A*-algorithm. In: Proceedings 7th European congress on intelligent techniques and soft computing EUFIT '99, Aachen, Germany. CDROM, 1999
136. Koza JR. Genetic programming. Cambridge MIT: the MIT Press 1992
137. Kolesnik R, Kolesnik L, Kosinski W. Genetic operators for clustering analysis. In: Proceedings of 8th Int. Symp. on intelligent information, Ustron/ Wisla, Poland 1999; pp 203-208