Hidden in Plain Sight-Reconsidering the Use of Race Correction in Clinical Algorithms

New England Journal of Medicine

Volumn 383, Issue 9, 2020, Pages 874-882

  Vyas, Darshali A ^a   Eisenstein, Leo G ^d   Jones, David S ^b,c  

^a MASSACHUSETTS GENERAL HOSPITAL   (United States)

^b HARVARD MEDICAL SCHOOL   (United States)

^c HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^d NEW YORK UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ALGORITHM; ARTICLE; ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE; CARDIAC SURGEON; CARDIOLOGY; CLINICAL ASSESSMENT; CLINICAL DECISION MAKING; CORONARY ARTERY BYPASS GRAFT; END STAGE RENAL DISEASE; ESTIMATED GLOMERULAR FILTRATION RATE; ETHNICITY; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HEALTH DISPARITY; HEART FAILURE; HOSPITAL ADMISSION; HUMAN; KIDNEY FAILURE; KIDNEY FUNCTION; KIDNEY TRANSPLANTATION; LOW RISK PATIENT; NEPHROLITHIASIS; NEPHROLOGY; OBSTETRICS; PREDICTION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RACE DIFFERENCE; UROLOGY; VAGINAL DELIVERY; ANCESTRY GROUP; ETHNOLOGY; FEMALE; GENETICS; HEALTH CARE DISPARITY; MALE; RISK ASSESSMENT;

ALGORITHMS; CARDIOLOGY; CONTINENTAL POPULATION GROUPS; FEMALE; HEALTHCARE DISPARITIES; HUMANS; MALE; NEPHROLOGY; OBSTETRICS; RISK ASSESSMENT; UROLOGY;

EID: 85087824354     PISSN: 00284793     EISSN: 15334406     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1056/NEJMms2004740     Document Type: Article

References (46)

1. Burchard EG, Ziv E, Coyle N, et al. The importance of race and ethnic background in biomedical research and clinical practice. N Engl J Med 2003; 348: 1170-5.
2. Cooper RS, Kaufman JS, Ward R. Race and genomics. N Engl J Med 2003; 348: 1166-70.
3. Phimister EG. Medicine and the racial divide. N Engl J Med 2003; 348: 1081-2.
4. Jones DS, Dorr GM, Pollock A. Symposium: race, pharmaceuticals, and medical technology. J Law Med Ethics 2008; 36: 439-545.
5. Leroi AM. A family tree in every gene. New York Times. March 14, 2005: A21.
6. Reich D. How genetics is changing our understanding of 'race.' New York Times. March 23, 2018: SR1.
7. Social Science Research Council. Is race "real"? June 2006 (http://raceandgenomics.ssrc.org).
8. Kahn J, Nelson A, Graves JL Jr, et al. How not to talk about race and genetics. Buzzfeed News. March 30, 2018 (https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/bfopinion/race-genetics-david-reich).
9. Peterson PN, Rumsfeld JS, Liang L, et al. A validated risk score for in-hospital mortality in patients with heart failure from the American Heart Association Get with the Guidelines program. Circ Cardiovasc Qual Outcomes 2010; 3: 25-32.
10. Shahian DM, Jacobs JP, Badhwar V, et al. The Society of Thoracic Surgeons 2018 adult cardiac surgery risk models. 1. Background, design considerations, and model development. Ann Thorac Surg 2018; 105: 1411-8.
11. Levey AS, Stevens LA, Schmid CH, et al. A new equation to estimate glomerular filtration rate. Ann Intern Med 2009; 150: 604-12.
12. Rao PS, Schaubel DE, Guidinger MK, et al. A comprehensive risk quantification score for deceased donor kidneys: the kidney donor risk index. Transplantation 2009; 88: 231-6.
13. Grobman WA, Lai Y, Landon MB, et al. Development of a nomogram for prediction of vaginal birth after cesarean delivery. Obstet Gynecol 2007; 109: 806-12.
14. Landon MB, Leindecker S, Spong CY, et al. The MFMU Cesarean Registry: factors affecting the success of trial of labor after previous cesarean delivery. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2005; 193: 1016-23.
15. Moore CL, Bomann S, Daniels B, et al. Derivation and validation of a clinical prediction rule for uncomplicated ureteral stone-the STONE score: retrospective and prospective observational cohort studies. BMJ 2014; 348: g2191.
16. Wang RC, Rodriguez RM, Moghadassi M, et al. External validation of the STONE score, a clinical prediction rule for ureteral stone: an observational multi-institutional study. Ann Emerg Med 2016; 67(4): 423.e2-432.e2.
17. Shaikh N, Hoberman A, Hum SW, et al. Development and validation of a calculator for estimating the probability of urinary tract infection in young febrile children. JAMA Pediatr 2018; 172: 550-6.
18. Bowles TL, Hu C-Y, You NY, Skibber JM, Rodriguez-Bigas MA, Chang GJ. An individualized conditional survival calculator for patients with rectal cancer. Dis Colon Rectum 2013; 56: 551-9.
19. Tice JA, Miglioretti DL, Li C-S, Vachon CM, Gard CC, Kerlikowske K. Breast density and benign breast disease: risk assessment to identify women at high risk of breast cancer. J Clin Oncol 2015; 33: 3137-43.
20. Lydick E, Cook K, Turpin J, Melton M, Stine R, Byrnes C. Development and validation of a simple questionnaire to facilitate identification of women likely to have low bone density. Am J Manag Care 1998; 4: 37-48.
21. Kanis JA. Assessment of osteoporosis at the primary health care level. WHO Scientific Group technical report. Sheffield, United Kingdom: World Health Organization Collaborating Centre for Metabolic Bone Diseases, University of Sheffield, 2007.
22. Braun L. Breathing race into the machine: The surprising career of the spirometer from planation to genetics. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2014.
23. Kumar R, Seibold MA, Aldrich MC, et al. Genetic ancestry in lung-function predictions. N Engl J Med 2010; 363: 321-30.
24. Eberly LA, Richterman A, Beckett AG, et al. Identification of racial inequities in access to specialized inpatient heart failure care at an academic medical center. Circ Heart Fail 2019; 12(11): e006214.
25. Eneanya ND, Yang W, Reese PP. Reconsidering the consequences of using race to estimate kidney function. JAMA 2019; 322: 113-4.
26. Hsu J, Johansen KL, Hsu C-Y, Kaysen GA, Chertow GM. Higher serum creatinine concentrations in black patients with chronic kidney disease: beyond nutritional status and body composition. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 2008; 3: 992-7.
27. Levey AS, Tighiouart H, Titan SM, Inker LA. Estimation of glomerular filtration rate with vs without including patient race. JAMA Intern Med 2020; 180: 793-5.
28. Julian BA, Gaston RS, Brown WM, et al. Effect of replacing race with apolipoprotein L1 genotype in calculation of Kidney Donor Risk Index. Am J Transplant 2017; 17: 1540-8.
29. Cannon RM, Brock GN, Marvin MR, Slakey DP, Buell JF. The contribution of donor quality to differential graft survival in African American and Caucasian renal transplant recipients. Am J Transplant 2012; 12: 1776-83.
30. Vyas DA, Jones DS, Meadows AR, Diouf K, Nour NM, Schantz-Dunn J. Challenging the use of race in the vaginal birth after cesarean section calculator. Womens Health Issues 2019; 29: 201-4.
31. Kowalsky RH, Rondini AC, Platt SL. The case for removing race from the American Academy of Pediatrics clinical practice guideline for urinary tract infection in infants and young children with fever. JAMA Pediatr 2020; 174: 229-30.
32. Krieger N. Methods for the scientific study of discrimination and health: an ecosocial approach. Am J Public Health 2012; 102: 936-44.
33. VanderWeele TJ, Robinson WR. On the causal interpretation of race in regressions adjusting for confounding and mediating variables. Epidemiology 2014; 25: 473-84.
34. Maglo KN, Mersha TB, Martin LJ. Population genomics and the statistical values of race: an interdisciplinary perspective on the biological classification of human populations and implications for clinical genetic epidemiological research. Front Genet 2016; 7: 22.
35. American Association of Physical Anthropologists. AAPA statement on race & racism. March 27, 2019 (https://physanth.org/about/position-statements/aapa-statement-race-and-racism-2019/).
36. Obermeyer Z, Powers B, Vogeli C, Mullainathan S. Dissecting racial bias in an algorithm used to manage the health of populations. Science 2019; 366: 447-53.
37. Roberts D. Fatal invention: how science, politics, and big business re-create race in the twenty-first century. New York: New Press, 2011.
38. Yudell M, Roberts D, DeSalle R, Tishkoff S. Taking race out of human genetics. Science 2016; 351: 564-5.
39. Benjamin R. Race after technology: abolitionist tools for the new Jim code. Medford, MA: Polity, 2019.
40. Angwin J, Larson J, Mattu S, Kirchner L. Machine bias. Pro-Publica. May 23, 2016 (https://www.propublica.org/article/machine-bias-risk-assessments-in-criminal-sentencing).
41. Dieterich W, Mendoza C, Brennan T. COMPAS risk scales: demonstrating accuracy equity and predictive parity. Northpointe. July 8, 2016 (http://go.volarisgroup.com/rs/430-MBX-989/images/ProPublica-Commentary-Final-070616.pdf).
42. Kaplan JB, Bennett T. Use of race and ethnicity in biomedical publication. JAMA 2003; 289: 2709-16.
43. Morris JE, Grubbs V, Hahn M, Richmond S. Abolish racebased medicine in kidney disease and beyond. San Francisco Examiner. November 27, 2019 (https://www.sfexaminer.com/opinion/abolish-race-based-medicine-in-kidney-disease-and-beyond/).
44. UW Medicine to exclude race from calculation of eGFR (measure of kidney function). University of Washington, Department of Medicine, May 29, 2020 (https://medicine.uw.edu/news/uw-medicine-exclude-race-calculation-egfr-measure-kidney-function).
45. Tsai J. What role should race play in medicine? Scientific American. September 12, 2018 (https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/voices/what-role-should-race-play-in-medicine/).
46. Jones CP. Toward the science and practice of anti-racism: launching a national campaign against racism. Ethn Dis 2018; 28: 231-4.