Can mindfulness be too much of a good thing? The value of a middle way

Current Opinion in Psychology

Volumn 28, Issue , 2019, Pages 159-165

  Britton, Willoughby B ^a  

^a BROWN UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ATTENTION; AWARENESS; HUMAN; INTEROCEPTION; MEDITATION; MINDFULNESS; PHYSIOLOGY;

ATTENTION; AWARENESS; EMOTIONAL REGULATION; HUMANS; INTEROCEPTION; MEDITATION; MINDFULNESS;

EID: 85060610411     PISSN: 2352250X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.copsyc.2018.12.011     Document Type: Review

References (62)

1. Grant, A.M., Schwartz, B., Too much of a good thing: the challenge and opportunity of the inverted U. Perspect Psychol Sci 6 (2011), 61–76.
2. Yerkes, R.M., Dodson, J.D., The relation of strength of stimulus to rapidity of habit-formation. J Comp Neurol Psychol 18 (1908), 459–482.
3. Pierce, J., Aguinis, H., The too-much-of-a-good-thing effect in management. J Manage 39 (2013), 313–338.
4. Brown, K.W., Ryan, R.M., The benefits of being present: mindfulness and its role in psychological well-being. J Pers Soc Psychol 84 (2003), 822–848.
5. Van Dam, N.T., van Vugt, M.K., Vago, D.R., Schmalzl, L., Saron, C.D., Olendzki, A., Meissner, T., Lazar, S.W., Kerr, C.E., Gorchov, J., et al. Mind the hype: a critical evaluation and prescriptive agenda for research on mindfulness and meditation. Perspect Psychol Sci 13 (2018), 36–61 This article is a consensus statement from 15 mindfulness researchers who are concerned that the application of mindfulness-based interventions and products is outpacing the scientific evidence base. The review highlights areas of concern and makes recommendations for how to improve the rigor of the science and the safety of the interventions.
6. Reynolds, L., Bissett, I., Porter, D., Consedine, N., A brief mindfulness intervention is associated with negative outcomes in a randomised controlled trial among chemotherapy patients. Mindfulness 8 (2017), 1291–1303 In a RCT of mindfulness training versus relaxation training for cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy, mindfulness (but not relaxation) training was associated with increased symptom distress, social avoidance and reduced quality of life. The authors caution against using MBIs during the acute stage of illness.
7. Johnson, C., Burke, C., Brinkman, S., Wade, T., Effectiveness of a school-based mindfulness program for transdiagnostic prevention in young adolescents. Behav Res Ther 81 (2016), 1–11 One of the largest school-based mindfulness randomized controlled trials (RCTs) to date, comprises of more than 300 students across five schools. Compared to normal school activities, mindfulness training resulted in increased anxiety for males, and for students of both genders with low baseline depression or weight concerns.
8. Sahdra, B., Ciarrochi, J., Parker, P., Basarkod, G., Bradshaw, E., Baer, R., Are people mindful in different ways? Disentangling the quantity and quality of mindfulness in latent profiles and exploring their links to mental health and life effectiveness. Eur J Pers 31 (2017), 347–365.
9. Lindahl, J.R., Fisher, N.E., Cooper, D.J., Rosen, R.K., Britton, W.B., The varieties of contemplative experience: a mixed-methods study of meditation-related challenges in Western Buddhists. PLoS One, 12, 2017, e0176239 TheVarieties of Contemplative Experience study is the most comprehensive study on meditation-related challenges and difficulties to date. Based on interviews with more than 100 meditation teachers and meditators, the study documents 59 categories of meditation-related experiences that are often associated with negative valence, distress, or functional impairment.
10. Lustyk, M., Chawla, N., Nolan, R., Marlatt, G., Mindfulness meditation research: issues of participant screening, safety procedures, and researcher training. Adv Mind-Body Med 24 (2009), 20–30.
11. Lomas, T., Cartwright, T., Edginton, T., Ridge, D., A qualitative summary of experiential challenges associated with meditation practice. Mindfulness, 2014, 1–13.
12. Cebolla, A., Demarzo, M., Martins, P., Soler, J., Garcia-Campayo, J., Unwanted effects: is there a negative side of meditation? A multicentre survey. PLoS One, 12, 2017, e0183137 An online survey of 342 Spanish-speaking, English-speaking, and Portuguese-speaking meditators found that 25% of respondents reported ‘unwanted effects’ (UEs) from meditation, including increased anxiety/panic (14%), pain/headaches (6%), and dissociation/depersonalization (9%). While most UEs were transitory, some UEs were long-lasting, required medical attention, and resulted in discontinuation of meditation practice.
13. Holzel, B.K., Lazar, S.W., Gard, T., Schuman-Olivier, Z., Vago, D.R., Ott, U., How does mindfulness meditation work? Proposing mechanisms of action from a conceptual and neural perspective. Perspect Psychol Sci 6 (2011), 537–559.
14. Ingram, R.E., Self-focused attention in clinical disorders: review and a conceptual model. Psychol Bull 107 (1990), 156–176.
15. Mor, N., Winquist, J., Self-focused attention and negative affect: a meta-analysis. Psychol Bull 128 (2002), 638–662.
16. Eisenlohr-Moul, T.A., Walsh, E.C., Charnigo, R.J. Jr., Lynam, D.R., Baer, R.A., The “what” and the “how” of dispositional mindfulness: using interactions among subscales of the five-facet mindfulness questionnaire to understand its relation to substance use. Assessment 19 (2012), 276–286.
17. Evans, D.R., Eisenlohr-Moul, T.A., Button, D.F., Baer, R.A., Segerstrom, S.C., Self-regulatory deficits associated with unpracticed mindfulness strategies for coping with acute pain. J Appl Soc Psychol 44 (2014), 23–30.
18. Murphy, J., Brewer, R., Catmur, C., Bird, G., Interoception and psychopathology: a developmental neuroscience perspective. Dev Cogn Neurosci 23 (2017), 45–56.
19. de Jong, M., Lazar, S.W., Hug, K., Mehling, W.E., Holzel, B.K., Sack, A.T., Peeters, F., Ashih, H., Mischoulon, D., Gard, T., Effects of mindfulness-based cognitive therapy on body awareness in patients with chronic pain and comorbid depression. Front Psychol, 7, 2016, 967.
20. Fox, K.C., Nijeboer, S., Dixon, M.L., Floman, J.L., Ellamil, M., Rumak, S.P., Sedlmeier, P., Christoff, K., Is meditation associated with altered brain structure? A systematic review and meta-analysis of morphometric neuroimaging in meditation practitioners. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 43 (2014), 48–73.
21. Fox, K.C., Dixon, M.L., Nijeboer, S., Girn, M., Floman, J.L., Lifshitz, M., Ellamil, M., Sedlmeier, P., Christoff, K., Functional neuroanatomy of meditation: a review and meta-analysis of 78 functional neuroimaging investigations. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 65 (2016), 208–228.
22. Gotink, R.A., Meijboom, R., Vernooij, M.W., Smits, M., Hunink, M.G., 8-week mindfulness based stress reduction induces brain changes similar to traditional long-term meditation practice—a systematic review. Brain Cogn 108 (2016), 32–41.
23. Etkin, A., Wager, T.D., Functional neuroimaging of anxiety: a meta-analysis of emotional processing in PTSD, social anxiety disorder, and specific phobia. Am J Psychiatry 164 (2007), 1476–1488.
24. Moeller-Bertram, T., Keltner, J., Strigo, I.A., Pain and post traumatic stress disorder—review of clinical and experimental evidence. Neuropharmacology 62 (2012), 586–597.
25. Nardo, D., Hogberg, G., Flumeri, F., Jacobsson, H., Larsson, S.A., Hallstrom, T., Pagani, M., Self-rating scales assessing subjective well-being and distress correlate with rCBF in PTSD-sensitive regions. Psychol Med 41 (2011), 2549–2561.
26. Craig, A.D., How do you feel—now? The anterior insula and human awareness. Nat Rev Neurosci 10 (2009), 59–70.
27. Martinez, E., Aira, Z., Buesa, I., Aizpurua, I., Rada, D., Azkue, J.J., Embodied pain in fibromyalgia: disturbed somatorepresentations and increased plasticity of the body schema. PLoS One, 13, 2018, e0194534.
28. Brooker, J., Julian, J., Webber, L., Chan, J., Shawyer, F., Meadows, G., Evaluation of an occupational mindfulness program for staff employed in the disability sector in Australia. Mindfulness 4 (2013), 122–136.
29. Treleaven, D.A., Trauma-Sensitive Mindfulness: Practices for Safe and Transformative Healing. 2018, Norton, New York.
30. Engert, V., Kok, B.E., Papassotiriou, I., Chrousos, G.P., Singer, T., Specific reduction in cortisol stress reactivity after social but not attention-based mental training. Sci Adv, 3, 2017, e1700495.
31. Kabat-Zinn, J., Full Catastrophe Living: Using the Wisdom of Your Body and Mind to Face Stress, Pain, and Illness. 1990, Delta, New York, NY.
32. Tang, Y.Y., Holzel, B.K., Posner, M.I., The neuroscience of mindfulness meditation. Nat Rev Neurosci 16 (2015), 213–225.
33. Sierra, M., Depersonalization: A New Look at a Neglected Syndrome. 2009, Cambridge University Press, New York.
34. Taylor, V.A., Grant, J., Daneault, V., Scavone, G., Breton, E., Roffe-Vidal, S., Courtemanche, J., Lavarenne, A.S., Beauregard, M., Impact of mindfulness on the neural responses to emotional pictures in experienced and beginner meditators. Neuroimage 57 (2011), 1524–1533.
35. Kral, T.R.A., Schuyler, B.S., Mumford, J.A., Rosenkranz, M.A., Lutz, A., Davidson, R.J., Impact of short- and long-term mindfulness meditation training on amygdala reactivity to emotional stimuli. Neuroimage 181 (2018), 301–313.
36. APA, 300.6 depersonalization/derealization disorder. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, edn 5 (DSM-V), 2013, American Psychiatric Association.
37. Crane, R.S., Brewer, J., Feldman, C., Kabat-Zinn, J., Santorelli, S., Williams, J.M., Kuyken, W., What defines mindfulness-based programs? The warp and the weft. Psychol Med 47 (2017), 990–999.
38. van der Velden, A.M., Kuyken, W., Wattar, U., Crane, C., Pallesen, K.J., Dahlgaard, J., Fjorback, L.O., Piet, J., A systematic review of mechanisms of change in mindfulness-based cognitive therapy in the treatment of recurrent major depressive disorder. Clin Psychol Rev 37 (2015), 26–39.
39. Farb, N.A., Segal, Z.V., Mayberg, H., Bean, J., McKeon, D., Fatima, Z., Anderson, A.K., Attending to the present: mindfulness meditation reveals distinct neural modes of self-reference. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci 2 (2007), 313–322.
40. Brake, C.A., Sauer-Zavala, S., Boswell, J.F., Gallagher, M.W., Farchione, T.J., Barlow, D.H., Mindfulness-based exposure strategies as a transdiagnostic mechanism of change: an exploratory alternating treatment design. Behav Ther 47 (2016), 225–238.
41. Barry, T.J., Vervliet, B., Hermans, D., An integrative review of attention biases and their contribution to treatment for anxiety disorders. Front Psychol, 6, 2015, 968.
42. McNally, R.J., Attentional bias for threat: crisis or opportunity?. Clin Psychol Rev, 2018 (in press).
43. MacLeod, C., Rutherford, E., Campbell, L., Ebsworthy, G., Holker, L., Selective attention and emotional vulnerability: assessing the causal basis of their association through the experimental manipulation of attentional bias. J Abnorm Psychol 111 (2002), 107–123.
44. Eldar, S., Ricon, T., Bar-Haim, Y., Plasticity in attention: implications for stress response in children. Behav Res Ther 46 (2008), 450–461.
45. Bonanno, G.A., Burton, C.L., Regulatory flexibility: an individual differences perspective on coping and emotion regulation. Perspect Psychol Sci 8 (2013), 591–612.
46. Kohl, A., Rief, W., Glombiewski, J.A., How effective are acceptance strategies? A meta-analytic review of experimental results. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry 43 (2012), 988–1001.
47. Troy, A.S., Shallcross, A.J., Mauss, I.B., A person-by-situation approach to emotion regulation: cognitive reappraisal can either help or hurt, depending on the context. Psychol Sci 24 (2013), 2505–2514.
48. Dunn, B.D., Billotti, D., Murphy, V., Dalgleish, T., The consequences of effortful emotion regulation when processing distressing material: a comparison of suppression and acceptance. Behav Res Ther 47 (2009), 761–773.
49. Parsons, C.E., Crane, C., Parsons, L.J., Fjorback, L.O., Kuyken, W., Home practice in mindfulness-based cognitive therapy and mindfulness-based stress reduction: a systematic review and meta-analysis of participants’ mindfulness practice and its association with outcomes. Behav Res Ther 95 (2017), 29–41.
50. Britton, W.B., Lindahl, J.R., Cahn, B.R., Davis, J.H., Goldman, R.E., Awakening is not a metaphor: the effects of Buddhist meditation practices on basic wakefulness. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1307 (2014), 64–81.
51. Britton, W.B., Haynes, P.L., Fridel, K.W., Bootzin, R.R., Polysomnographic and subjective profiles of sleep continuity before and after mindfulness-based cognitive therapy in partially remitted depression. Psychosom Med 72 (2010), 539–548.
52. Ferrarelli, F., Smith, R., Dentico, D., Riedner, B.A., Zennig, C., Benca, R.M., Lutz, A., Davidson, R.J., Tononi, G., Experienced mindfulness meditators exhibit higher parietal-occipital EEG gamma activity during NREM sleep. PLoS One, 8, 2013, e73417.
53. Lyubomirsky, S., Sheldon, K.M., Schkade, D., Pursuing happiness: the architecture of sustainable change. Rev Gen Psychol 9 (2005), 111–131.
54. Dimidjian, S., Hollon, S.D., How would we know if psychotherapy were harmful?. Am Psychol 65 (2010), 21–33.
55. Dimidjian, S., Segal, Z.V., Prospects for a clinical science of mindfulness-based intervention. Am Psychol 70 (2015), 593–620.
56. Coronado-Montoya, S., Levis, A.W., Kwakkenbos, L., Steele, R.J., Turner, E.H., Thombs, B.D., Reporting of positive results in randomized controlled trials of mindfulness-based mental health interventions. PLoS One, 11, 2016, e0153220 This review of mindfulness-based intervention RCTs found that nearly 90% of the trials reviewed reported positive results in favor of mindfulness, which the authors concluded is suggestive of reporting bias. Only 25% of studies that found negative results reported them in a straightforward way. Instead, 75% of studies ‘spun’ negative findings to appear equivocal or positive by conducting follow-up subgroup analyses, reporting pre–post changes in the MBI group only, or providing a caveat such as the dose of meditation may have been inadequate.
57. Morone, N.E., Moore, C.G., Greco, C.M., Characteristics of adults who used mindfulness meditation: United States, 2012. J Altern Complement Med 23 (2017), 545–550 Querying more than 100 000 adults as part of the 2012 U.S. National Health survey, this study represents the largest cross-sectional study to date that compares mindfulness meditators to non-meditators. The study found that mindfulness meditators had worse physical and mental health than non-meditators, including higher levels of pain, headaches, stress, depression, anxiety, insomnia and acute illness. Although cross-sectional studies cannot establish direction of causality, the authors posit that poor mental and physical health caused people to meditate, or that meditation increases awareness of symptoms. They did not consider the possibility that meditation may have a causal role in poor mental and physical health.
58. Wong, S., Chan, J., Zhang, D., Lee, E., Tsoi, K., The safety of mindfulness-based interventions: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Mindfulness, 2018 (in press) In a review of 231 RCTs of mindfulness-based interventions (MBSR or MBCT), the vast majority (84.4%) did not contain any information about measuring or monitoring adverse effects. In the remaining 15.6%, fewer adverse effects in the MBI arm were more likely to be reported when MBIs failed to outperformed controls, or when authors reported conflicts of interest. Current MBI trial harms reporting is not adequate to produce an accurate estimate of the prevalence of meditation-related harms.
59. Bent, S., Padula, A., Avins, A.L., Brief communication: better ways to question patients about adverse medical events: a randomized, controlled trial. Ann Intern Med 144 (2006), 257–261.
60. Ioannidis, J.P., Evans, S.J., Gotzsche, P.C., O'Neill, R.T., Altman, D.G., Schulz, K., Moher, D., Better reporting of harms in randomized trials: an extension of the CONSORT statement. Ann Intern Med 141 (2004), 781–788.
61. Visted, E., Vollestad, J., Nielsen, M., Nielsen, G., The impact of group-based mindfulness training on self-reported mindfulness: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Mindfulness 6 (2014), 501–522.
62. Jacobson, N.S., Roberts, L.J., Berns, S.B., McGlinchey, J.B., Methods for defining and determining the clinical significance of treatment effects: description, application, and alternatives. J Consult Clin Psychol 67 (1999), 300–307.