Pariah profession, debased discipline? An analysis of social work's low academic status and the possibilities for change

Social Work Education

Volumn 25, Issue 3, 2006, Pages 245-264

  Green, L C ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Academic Prestige; Multidisciplinarity; Professionalisation; Public Image

Indexed keywords

EID: 85055308638     PISSN: 02615479     EISSN: 14701227     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/02615470600565152     Document Type: Article

References (96)

1. Anscombe, B., 2001. ‘Not either/or but both/and: an academic/field partnership in practice’,. Australian Social Work, vol. 54 (no. 4): pp. 19–27.
2. Ayre, P., 2001. ‘Child protection and the media: lessons from the last three decades’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 31 (no. 6): pp. 887–901.
3. Barclay, P., 1982. Social Workers: Their Role and Tasks, London: Bedford Square Press.
4. Barnes, J., 2002. “ ‘Focus on the future: key messages from focus groups about the future of social work training’, ”. In Reform of Social Work Education and Training, Reform Focus Groups Summary Document
5. Basford, L., 1999. ‘Shared learning: a phenomena for celebration and a challenge to health educators’,. Nurse Education Today, vol. 19 (no. 5): pp. 345–346.
6. Batty, D., 2002a. ‘Boost for social work students’,. The Guardian, 1 October
7. Batty, D., 2002b. ‘Q&A: Mental Health Bill’,. The Guardian, 8 November
8. Batty, D., 2002c. ‘Mental Health Bill sparks human rights fears’,. The Guardian, 11 November
9. Batty, D., 2002d. ‘Unsocial services’,. The Guardian, 15 October
10. Bhaskar, R., 1978. “ ‘General introduction’, ”. In Critical Realism, Edited by: Archer, M, Bhaskar, R, Collier, A, Lawson, T, and Norrie, A. London: Routledge. in
11. Bortoli, B., 2001. ‘Sociology and the social services at the dawn of the profession’,. Studi di Sociologia, vol. 39 (no. 4): pp. 447–463.
12. Brake, M., and Bailey, R., 1980. Radical Social Work, New York: Pantheon Books.
13. Brindle, D., 2002. ‘Job centred: practical focus for social work degree’,. The Guardian, 29 May
14. Bryman, A., 2001. Social Research Methods, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
15. Cannan, C., 1994. ‘Enterprise culture, professional socialization and social work education in Britain’,. Critical Social Policy,: pp. 5–18. Winter
16. Cleminson, A., and Bradford, S., 1996. ‘Professional education: the relationship between “academic and experiential learning”’,. Journal of Vocational Education and Training, vol. 48 (no. 3): pp. 249–259.
17. Clifford, D., Burke, B., Feery, D., and Knox, C., 2002. ‘Combining key elements in training and research: developing social work assessment theory and practice in partnership’,. Social Work Education, vol. 21 (no. 1): pp. 35–48.
18. Collier, A., 1994. Critical Realism: An Introduction to Roy Bhaskar’s Philosophy, London: Verso.
19. Community Care (2002) Archive. ‘Services at a crossroads’ Community Care, 3 October. Available at http://www.community-care.co.uk/articles/article.asp?liarticleid (accessed 3 December 2002).
20. Community Care (2002) Archive. ‘Leadbetter calls for four year degree’ Community Care, 28 November. Available at: http://www.community-care.co.uk/articles/article.asp?liarticleid (accessed 3 December 2002).
21. Cook, A., Davis, J., and Vanclay, L., 2001. ‘Shared learning in practice placements for health and social work students in East London: a feasibility study’,. Journal of Interprofessional Care, vol. 15 (no. 2): pp. 185–190.
22. Cox, P., and Hardwick, L., 2002. ‘Research and critical theory: their contribution to social work education and practice’,. Social Work Education, vol. 21 (no. 1): pp. 35–49.
23. Daro, D., 2002. ‘Public perception of child sexual abuse: who is to blame?’,. Child Abuse and Neglect, vol. 26 (no. 11): pp. 1131–1133.
24. Davies, M., 1994. The Essential Social Worker, Aldershot: Arena. 3rd edn
25. Davies, M., 2003. ‘Where morality meets mess but snubs empiricism’,. The Times Higher Educational Supplement,: pp. 32 24 October
26. Department of Health (DoH) (2000) Assessing Children in Need and Their Families: Practice Guidance, Stationary Office, London. Available at: http://www.doh.gov.uk/pds/qpracticeguidance.pdf (accessed 15 April 2003).
27. Ekstein, R., 1979. ‘Professional training or professional education’,. Clinical Social Work Journal, vol. 7 (no. 2): pp. 152–158.
28. England, H., 1986. Social Work as Art, Aldershot: Gower.
29. Esdaile, S. A., and Roth, L. M., 2000. ‘Education not training: the challenge for developing professional autonomy’,. Occupational Therapy International, vol. 7 (no. 3): pp. 147–152.
30. Feyerabend, P., 1975. Against Method, London: New Left Books.
31. Fook, J., Ryan, M., and Hawkins, L., 2000. Professional Expertise: Practice, Theory and Education for Working in Uncertainty, London: Whiting and Birch.
32. Fraser, D., 2003. The Evolution of the British Welfare State, Basingstoke: Macmillan.
33. Green, L., 2001. “ ‘Children, sexual abuse and the child protection system’, ”. In Children in Society: Contemporary Theory, Policy and Practice, Edited by: Foley, P, Roche, J, and Tucker, S. Basingstoke: Palgrave/OUP. in
34. Gunther, J., 1980. “ ‘Towards a synthesis of social work and sociology’, ”. In Mid-South Sociological Association, New Orleans: (MISSA).
35. Hamilton, D., and Fauri, D., 2001. ‘Social workers’ political participation: strengthening the political confidence of social work students',. Journal of Social Work Education, vol. 37 (no. 2): pp. 321–322.
36. Harris, J., 1999. ‘State social work and social citizenship in Britain: from clientilism to consumerism’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 31 (no. 3): pp. 915–937.
37. Haynes, B. T., and White, T. W., 1999. ‘Will the “real” social work please stand up: a call to stand for professional unity’,. Social Work, vol. 44 (no. 4): pp. 385–391.
38. Houston, S., 2001. ‘Beyond social constructionism: critical realism and social work’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 31 (no. 6): pp. 845–861.
39. Howe, D., 1992. ‘Child abuse and the bureaucratisation of social work’,. Sociological Review, vol. 40 (no. 3): pp. 491–508.
40. Hugman, R., 1991. Power in the Caring Professions, Basingstoke: Macmillan.
41. Hugman, R., 2001. ‘Post welfare social work? Reconsidering post-modernism, post-Fordism and social work education’,. Social Work Education, vol. 20 (no. 3): pp. 321–332.
42. Humphrey, J. C., 2003. ‘New Labour and the regulatory reform of social care’,. Critical Social Policy, vol. 32 (no. 1): pp. 5–24.
43. Humphries, B., 2003. ‘What else counts as evidence in evidence-based social work’,. Social Work Education, vol. 22 (no. 1): pp. 81–91.
44. James, P., 2001. ‘The double edge of competency training: contradictory discourse and lived experience’,. Journal of Vocational Education and Training, vol. 53 (no. 2): pp. 301–324.
45. Jones, C., 1995. ‘Demanding social work education: an agenda for the end of the century’,. Issues in Social Work Education, vol. 15 (no. 2): pp. 3–17.
46. Jones, C., 1997. “ ‘British social work and the classless society: the failure of a profession’, ”. In Towards a Classless Society, Edited by: Jones, H, ed. London: Routledge. in
47. Jones, C., 2001. ‘Voices from the frontline: state social workers and New Labour’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 31: pp. 547–562.
48. Jordan, B., 2001. ‘Tough love: social work, social exclusion and the third way’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 31 (no. 4): pp. 527–546.
49. Jordan, B., and with Jordan, C., 2000. Social Work and the Third Way: Tough Love as Social Policy, London: Sage.
50. Kendall, L., and Harker, L., (ed.). 2002. From Welfare to Wellbeing: The Future of Social Care, London: Institute for Public Policy Research.
51. Klein, N., 2000. ‘Hand to brand combat’,. Guardian Weekend, 23 September
52. Kolevzon, M. S., and Maykranz, J., 1982. ‘Theoretical orientation and clinical practice: uniformity versus eclecticism’,. The Social Service Review, vol. 56 (no. 1): pp. 120–129.
53. Lang, D., 1987. ‘Stratification and prestige hierarchies in graduate and professional education’,. Sociological Inquiry, vol. 57: pp. 12–31. Winter
54. Layder, D., 1994. Understanding Social Theory, London: Sage.
55. Light, D., Jr. 1979. ‘Surface data and deep structure: observing the organization of professional training’,. Administrative Science Quarterly, vol. 24 (no. 4): pp. 551–559.
56. Lymbery, M., 2001. ‘Social work at the crossroads’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 31 (no. 3): pp. 369–384.
57. Lyons, K., 2000. ‘The place of research in social work education’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 30 (no. 4): pp. 433–447.
58. Mullaly, B., 1997. Structural Social Work: Ideology, Theory and Practice, Toronto, Canada: Oxford University Press.
59. Mullaly, B., 2001. ‘Confronting the politics of despair: towards the reconstruction of progressive social work in a global economy and postmodern age’,. Social Work Education, vol. 20 (no. 3): pp. 303–320.
60. Orme, J., 2001a. ‘Regulation or fragmentation? Directions for social work under New Labour’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 31 (no. 4): pp. 611–624.
61. Orme, J., 2001b. ‘Hail the arrival of social work education’,. The Guardian, 30 March
62. Orme, J., 2003. ‘ESRC recognition of research training’,. Social Work Education, vol. 22 (no. 6): pp. 611–612.
63. Outhwaite, W., 1994. Habermas: A Critical Introduction, Cambridge: Polity.
64. Parsloe, P., 2001. ‘Looking back on social work education’,. Social Work Education, vol. 20 (no. 1): pp. 9–20.
65. Parton, N., 2000. ‘Some thoughts on the relationship between theory and practice in and for social work’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 30 (no. 4): pp. 449–463.
66. Parton, N., 2001. ‘The current state of social work in UK universities: some personal reflections’,. Social Work Education, vol. 20 (no. 2): pp. 164–174.
67. Parton, N., 2003. ‘Rethinking professional practice: the contributions of social constructionism and the feminist “ethics of care”’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 33 (no. 1): pp. 1–16.
68. Payne, M., 1996. What is Professional Social Work?, Birmingham: Venture Press.
69. Polyani, M., 1967. The Tacit Dimension, New York: Anchor Books.
70. Porter, S., 1998. Social Theory and Nursing Practice, Basingstoke: Macmillan.
71. Powell, J., 2003. ‘Planning a submission for ESRC recognition’,. Social Work Education, vol. 22 (no. 6): pp. 619–623.
72. Preston-Shoot, M., 2002. ‘Editorial’,. Social Work Education, vol. 21 (no. 6): pp. 621–622.
73. Reid, W. J., 2002. ‘Knowledge for direct social work practice: an analysis of trends’,. Social Service Review,: pp. 6–33. March
74. Robson, C., 2002. Real World Research, Oxford: Blackwell. 2nd edn
75. Rosen, A., 1994. ‘Knowledge use in direct practice’,. Social Service Review, vol. 68 (no. 4): pp. 561–577.
76. Saleebey, D., 1991. ‘Technological fix: altering the consciousness of social work’,. Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare, vol. 18 (no. 4): pp. 51–67.
77. Shardlow, S., and Walliss, J., 2003. ‘Mapping comparative empirical studies of European social work’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 33: pp. 921–941.
78. Shaw, I., 2003. ‘Process and outcomes: the 2001 ESRC recognition exercise’,. Social Work Education, vol. 22 (no. 6): pp. 613–617.
79. Sheehan, R., 2003. ‘The marginalisation of children by the legal process’,. Australian Social Work, vol. 56 (no. 1): pp. 28–39. March
80. Sheldon, B., 1986. ‘Social work effectiveness experiments: review and implications’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 16: pp. 223–242.
81. Sheldon, B., 2001. ‘The validity of evidence based practice in social work: a reply to Stephen Webb’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 31: pp. 801–809.
82. Sheppard, M., Newstead, S., DiCaccavo, A., and Ryan, K., 2001. ‘Comparative hypothesis assessment and quasi triangulation as process knowledge assessment strategies in social work practice’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 31 (no. 6): pp. 863–885.
83. Shipman, M., 1988. The Limitations of Social Research, London: Longman. 3rd edn
84. Sklair, L., 1991. Sociology of the Global System, Baltimore: Harvester and John Hopkins University Press.
85. Steele, L., 2001a. ‘Are social work values under threat’,. The Guardian, 12 April
86. Steele, L., 2001b. ‘Social skills’,. The Guardian, 15 May
87. Stevenson, O., 1998. ‘It was more difficult than we thought: a reflection on fifty years of child welfare practice’,. Child and Family Social Work, vol. 3 (no. 3): pp. 153–161.
88. Sullivan, E., and Johns, R., 2002. ‘Challenging values and inspiring attitude change: creating an effective learning experience’,. Social Work Education, vol. 21 (no. 2): pp. 217–232.
89. Taylor, B. J., Dempster, M., and Donnelly, M., 2003. ‘Hidden gems: systematically searching electronic databases for research publications for social work and social care’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 33: pp. 423–439.
90. Taylor, C., and White, S., 2000. Practising Reflexivity in Health and Social Care: Making Knowledge, Cambridge: Oxford University Press.
91. Wakefield, J. C., 1996. ‘Does social work need the ecosystems perspectives? Part 2. Does the perspective save social work from incoherence?’,. Social Service Review, vol. 70 (no. 2): pp. 183–213.
92. Waters, M., 1995. Globalization, London: Routledge.
93. Webb, S. A., 2001. ‘Some considerations on the validity of evidence-based practice in social work’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 31: pp. 57–79.
94. White, S., 1997. ‘Beyond retroduction: hermeneutics, reflexivity and social work practice’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 27 (no. 7): pp. 39–53.
95. Wilding, P., 1982. Professional Power and Social Welfare, London: Routledge, Kegan and Paul.
96. Williams, J., 2001. ‘1998 Human Rights Act: social work's new benchmark’,. British Journal of Social Work, vol. 31 (no. 6): pp. 831–844.