Recurrent failings of medical humanitarianism: intractable, ignored, or just exaggerated?

The Lancet

Volumn 390, Issue 10109, 2017, Pages 2314-2324

  Colombo, Sandro ^a   Pavignani, Enrico ^b  

^a Independent Noise Consultant   (Spain)

^b UNIVERSITY OF QUEENSLAND   (Australia)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT; HEALTH CARE; HEALTH CARE PERSONNEL; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HUMAN; MEDICAL HUMANITARIANISM; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROFESSIONALISM; REVIEW; DISASTER; ETHICS; FAILURE TO RESCUE (HEALTH CARE); FEMALE; MALE; OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH; ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT; RELIEF WORK; RISK ASSESSMENT; STATISTICS AND NUMERICAL DATA; VIOLENCE; VULNERABLE POPULATION;

DISASTERS; FAILURE TO RESCUE, HEALTH CARE; FEMALE; HEALTH PERSONNEL; HUMANS; MALE; OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH; RELIEF WORK; RISK ASSESSMENT; VIOLENCE; VULNERABLE POPULATIONS;

EID: 85020454460     PISSN: 01406736     EISSN: 1474547X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(17)31277-1     Document Type: Review

References (105)

1. de Waal, A, Famine crimes. Politics and the disaster relief industry in Africa, 1997, African Rights & the International African Institute, J Curry, and Indiana University Press, Bloomington and Indianapolis.
2. DuBois, M, Wake, C, Sturridge, S, Bennett, C, The Ebola response in West Africa exposing the politics and culture of international aid, 2015, Humanitarian Policy Group https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/odi-assets/publications-opinion-files/9903.pdf (accessed March 21, 2017).
3. Wilkinson, A, Leach, M, Briefing: ebola—myths, realities, and structural violence. Afr Aff 114 (2014), 136–148.
4. Checchi, F, Waldman, RJ, Roberts, LF, et al. World Health Organization and emergency health: if not now, when?. BMJ, 352, 2016, i469.
5. Rieff, D, A bed for the night. Humanitarianism in crisis, 2002, Vintage, London.
6. Donini, A, Maxwell, D, From face-to-face to face-to-screen: remote management, effectiveness and accountability of humanitarian action in insecure environments. Int Rev Red Cross 95 (2013), 383–413.
7. de Waal, A, The humanitarians' tragedy: escapable and inescapable cruelties. Disasters 34:suppl 2 (2010), S130–S137.
8. Donini, A, The far side: the meta functions of humanitarianism in a globalised world. Disasters 34:suppl 2 (2010), S220–S237.
9. Frank, S, Reporting disasters. Famine, aid, politics and the media, 2013, Hurst & Co, London.
10. Donini, A, Walker, P, So what?. Donini, A, (eds.) The golden fleece. Manipulation and independence in humanitarian action, 2012, Kumarian Press, Sterling.
11. Lemore, A, International assistance to Palestinians after Oslo. Political guilt, wasted money, 2008, Rutledge, Abingdon.
12. Allen, T, Life beyond the bubbles: cognitive dissonance and humanitarian impunity in Northern Uganda. Abramowitz, S, Panter-Brick, C, (eds.) Medical humanitarianism. Ethnographies of practice, 2015, University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia.
13. de Waal, A, Dollarised. Lond Rev Books 32 (2010), 38–41.
14. Slim, H, Doing the right thing: relief agencies, moral dilemmas and responsibility in political emergencies and war. Disasters 21 (1997), 244–257.
15. Anderson, MB, Do no harm. How aid can support peace or war, 1999, Lynne Rennier, Boulder.
16. Keen, D, Complex emergencies, 2008, Polity Press, Cambridge.
17. Medley, M, May awakening: South Sudan famine raises memories of 1998. African Arguments. http://africanarguments.org/2014/05/22/may-awakening-south-sudan-famine-and-parallels-with-1998-by-michael-medley/, 2014 (accessed March 15, 2017).
18. Lautze, S, Bell, W, Alinovi, L, Russo, L, Early warning, late response (again): the 2011 famine in Somalia. Glob Food Secur 1 (2012), 43–49.
19. Manning, R, Aid as a second-best solution: seven problems of effectiveness and how to tackle them. UNU-WIDER working paper no 24/2012. https://www.wider.unu.edu/publication/aid-second-best-solution (accessed May 10, 2017).
20. Whittall, J, The new humanitarian aid landscape. Case study: MSF interaction with non-traditional and emerging aid actors in Syria 2013–14. Médecins Sans Frontières. https://www.msf.org.uk/sites/uk/files/humanitarian_aid_landscape_-_syria.pdf, 2014 (accessed May 10, 2017).
21. Gordon, S, Health, conflict, stability and statebuilding: a house built on sand?. J Interv Statebuilding 7 (2013), 29–44.
22. Philips, M, Derderian, K, Health in the service of state-building in fragile and conflict affected contexts: an additional challenge in the medical-humanitarian environment. Confl Health, 9, 2015, 13.
23. Van Damme, WI, Van Lerberghe, WI, Boelaert, M, Primary health care vs. emergency medical assistance: a conceptual framework. Health Policy Plan 17 (2002), 49–60.
24. Spiegel, PB, Checchi, F, Colombo, S, Paik, E, Health-care needs of people affected by conflict: future trends and changing frameworks. Lancet 375 (2010), 341–345.
25. Dewachi, O, Skelton, M, Nguyen, V-K, et al. Changing therapeutic geographies of the Iraqi and Syrian wars. Lancet 383 (2014), 449–457.
26. Lucchi, E, Moving from the ‘why’ to the ‘how’: reflections on humanitarian response in urban settings. Disasters 36:suppl 1 (2012), S87–S104.
27. UN High Commissioner for Refugees. Cash-based interventions for health programmes in refugee settings. A review. http://www.unhcr.org/research/evalreports/568bce619/cash-based-interventions-health-programmes-refugee-settings-review.html, 2015 (accessed May 10, 2017).
28. Lucchi, E, Between war and peace: humanitarian assistance in violent urban settings. Disasters 34 (2010), 973–995.
29. Osterholm, MT, Moore, KA, Gostin, LO, Public health in the age of ebola in West Africa. JAMA Intern Med 175 (2015), 7–8.
30. Svoboda, E, Zyck, SA, Osman, D, Hashi, A, Islamic humanitarianism? The evolving role of the Organisation for Islamic Cooperation in Somalia and beyond. Humanitarian Policy Group working paper, 2015, Overseas Development Institute, London https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/odi-assets/publications-opinion-files/9457.pdf (accessed May 10, 2017).
31. The Lancet. Syria: a health crisis too great to ignore. Lancet, 388, 2016, 2.
32. Fouad, FM, Sparrow, A, Tarakji, A, et al. Health workers and the weaponisation of health care in Syria: a preliminary inquiry for The Lancet–American University of Beirut Commission on Syria. Lancet, 2017 published online March 14. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(17)30741-9.
33. Howe, K, No end in sight: a case study of humanitarian action and the Syria conflict, 2016, Kings College, The Humanitarian Policy Group at the Overseas Development Institute, and the Feinstein International Center at Tufts University http://www.alnap.org/resource/22353 (accessed May 10, 2017).
34. Collinson, S, Duffield, M, Berger, C, Felix da Costa, D, Sandstrom, K, Paradoxes of presence: risk management and aid culture in challenging environments, March, 2013, Humanitarian Policy Group https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/odi-assets/publications-opinion-files/8428.pdf (accessed May 10, 2017).
35. Brauman, R, La médicine humanitaire, 2009, Presses Universitaires de France, Paris (in French).
36. Benn, H, Awareness, understanding and response. Speech given at BBC-World service Trust/DFID conference. http://www.i-policy.org/2004/12/awareness_under.html, 2004 (accessed May 10, 2017).
37. Allen, T, Trial Justice. The international criminal court and the lord's resistance army, 2006, Zed Books, London.
38. Benthall, J, Disasters, relief and the media, 2010, Routledge, London.
39. Bailey, S, Humanitarian action, recovery and stabilisation in the Democratic Republic of Congo. 2011. Overseas Development Institute; HPG working paper. https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/odi-assets/publications-opinion-files/7239.pdf (accessed March 16, 2017).
40. Palmer, JJ, Kelly, AH, Surur, EI, Checchi, F, Jones, C, Changing landscapes, changing practice: negotiating access to sleeping sickness services in a post-conflict society. Soc Sci Med 120 (2014), 396–404.
41. Chair's Summary. Standing up for humanity: committing to action. World Humanitarian Summit; Istanbul. https://docs.unocha.org/sites/dms/Documents/Chairs Summary.pdf, May 23–24, 2016 (accessed March 16, 2017).
42. Marriage, Z, The comfort of denial: External assistance in Southern Sudan. Dev Change 37 (2006), 479–500.
43. Yates, R, Universal health care and the removal of user fees. Lancet 373 (2009), 2078–2081.
44. von Schreeb, J, Michael, M, Joint assessment of health status and health system among crisis affected populations in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) and the humanitarian health sector strategy for DRC, 2004, World Health Organization, Geneva.
45. de Ville de Goyet, C, Sarmiento, JP, Grünewald, F, Health response to the earthquake in Haiti, January, 2010, 2011, Pan-American Health Organization, Washington, DC http://new.paho.org/disasters/dmdocuments/HealthResponseHaitiEarthq.pdf (accessed March 10, 2017).
46. Farmer, P, Haiti after the earthquake, 2011, Public Affairs, New York.
47. Cooley, A, Ron, J, The NGO Scramble. Int Secur 27 (2002), 5–39.
48. Grünewald, F, Binder, A, Inter-agency real-time evaluation in Haiti: 3 months after the earthquake. https://www.unicef.org/evaluation/files/Haiti_IA_RTE_final_Eng.pdf, 2010 (accessed March 16, 2017).
49. Lynch C. Top UN aid official critiques aid efforts in confidential email. Foreign Policy, 2010.
50. Capobianco, E, Naidu, V, A decade of aid to the health sector in Somalia, 2000–2009, 2010, The World Bank http://elibrary.worldbank.org/content/book/9780821387696 (accessed March 16, 2017).
51. Bertone, MP, Samai, M, Edem-Hotah, J, Witter, S, A window of opportunity for reform in post-conflict settings? The case of Human Resources for Health policies in Sierra Leone, 2002–2012. Confl Health, 8, 2014, 11.
52. Roberts, L, A war within a war. Science 343 (2014), 1302–1305.
53. Kennedy, J, Michailidou, D, Civil war, contested sovereignty and the limits of global health partnerships: A case study of the Syrian polio outbreak in 2013. Health Policy Plan, 2017, 10.1093/heapol/czw148 published online Feb 15.
54. Slim, H, Trombetta, L, Syria crisis common context analysis, May, 2014, UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, New York https://docs.unocha.org/sites/dms/Documents/Syria%20Crisis%20Common%20Context%20Analysis_June%202014.pdf (accessed May 10, 2017).
55. del Valle, H, Healy, S, Humanitarian agencies and authoritarian states: a symbiotic relationship?. Disasters 37:suppl 2 (2013), S188–S201.
56. Dijkzeul, D, Wakenge, CI, Doing good, but looking bad? Local perceptions of two humanitarian organisations in eastern Democratic Republic of the Congo. Disasters 34 (2010), 1139–1170.
57. Parkinson, SE, Behrouzan, O, Negotiating health and life: Syrian refugees and the politics of access in Lebanon. Soc Sci Med 146 (2015), 324–331.
58. Smirl, L, Spaces of aid: how cars, compounds and hotels shape humanitarianism, 2015, Zed Books, London.
59. Duffield, M, Challenging environments: danger, resilience and the aid industry. Secur Dialogue, 43, 2012, 475.
60. James, E, The professional humanitarian and the downsides of professionalisation. Disasters 40 (2016), 185–206.
61. Mosse, D, Introduction: the anthropology of expertise and professionals in international development. Mosse, D, (eds.) Adventures in Aidland, 2011, Berghahn Books, New York.
62. Farrar, JJ, Piot, P, The Ebola emergency–immediate action, ongoing strategy. N Engl J Med 371 (2014), 1545–1546.
63. Wessells, MG, Do no harm: toward contextually appropriate psychosocial support in international emergencies. Am Psychol 64 (2009), 842–854.
64. Inter-agency Standing Committee. IASC guidelines on mental health and psychosocial support in emergency settings. Geneva. http://www.who.int/mental_health/emergencies/guidelines_iasc_mental_health_psychosocial_june_2007.pdf, 2007 (accessed May 10, 2017).
65. van Ommeren, M, Saxena, S, Saraceno, B, Mental and social health during and after acute emergencies: emerging consensus?. Bull World Health Organ 83 (2005), 71–75.
66. Tol, WA, van Ommeren, M, Evidence-based mental health and psychosocial support in humanitarian settings: gaps and opportunities. Evid Based Ment Health 15 (2012), 25–26.
67. Bracken, PJ, Giller, JE, Summerfield, D, Psychological responses to war and atrocity: the limitations of current concepts. Soc Sci Med 40 (1995), 1073–1082.
68. Riddell, R, Does foreign aid really work?, 2007, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
69. Tiller, S, Healy, S, Have we lost the ability to respond to refugee crises? The Maban response, May, 2013, Overseas Development Institute, London http://odihpn.org/magazine/have-we-lost-the-ability-to-respond-to-refugee-crises-the-maban-response/ (accessed May 10, 2017).
70. Jones, H, Taking responsibility for complexity: how implementation can achieve results in the face of complex problems. Overseas Development Institute working paper. https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/odi-assets/publications-opinion-files/6485.pdf, June, 2011 (accessed May 10, 2017).
71. Ager, A, Burnham, G, Checchi, F, et al. Strengthening the evidence base for health programming in humanitarian crises. Science 345 (2014), 1290–1292.
72. Boss, LP, Toole, MJ, Yip, R, Assessments of mortality, morbidity, and nutritional status in Somalia during the 1991–1992 famine. Recommendations for standardization of methods. JAMA 272 (1994), 371–376.
73. Spiegel, PB, Salama, P, Maloney, S, van der Veen, A, Quality of malnutrition assessment surveys conducted during famine in Ethiopia. JAMA 292 (2004), 613–618.
74. Salama, P, Collins, S, An ongoing omission: adolescent and adult malnutrition in famine situations, 1999, Field Exchange, Nairobi.
75. Michael, M, Pearson, N, Daliam, A, Inter Agency Health Evaluation. Humanitarian oasis in a parched health sector: refugees and host populations in Eastern and Southern Chad. http://www.unscn.org/layout/modules/resources/files/Humanitarian_oasis_in_a_parched_health_sector.pdf, April, 2006 (accessed March 16, 2017).
76. Roberts, L, Advances in monitoring have not translated into improvements in humanitarian health services. Prehosp Disaster Med 22 (2007), 384–389.
77. Ramalingam, B, Aid on the edge of chaos: rethinking international cooperation in a complex world, 2013, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
78. Darcy, J, Stobaugh, H, Walker, P, Maxwell, D, The use of evidence in humanitarian decision-making. ACAPS operational learning paper, 2013, Feinstein International Center, Tuft University http://www.fao.org/fileadmin/user_upload/drought/docs/t-tufts_1306_acaps_3_online.pdf (accessed March 16, 2017).
79. de Waal, A, Evidence and narratives: recounting lethal violence in Darfur, Sudan. Abramowitz, S, Panter-Brick, C, (eds.) Medical humanitarianism. Ethnographies of practice, 2015, University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia.
80. Bennett, C, Foley, M, Pantuliano, S, Sturridge, S, Time to let go. Remaking humanitarian action for the modern era, April, 2016, Overseas Development Institute, Humanitarian Policy Group http://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/resource-documents/10422.pdf (accessed March 16, 2017).
81. The Lancet. Public health impact of Rwandan refugee crisis: what happened in Goma, Zaire, in July, 1994? Goma Epidemiology Group. Lancet 345 (1995), 339–344.
82. Salama, P, Spiegel, P, Talley, L, Waldman, R, Lessons learned from complex emergencies over past decade. Lancet 364 (2004), 1801–1813.
83. Degomme, O, Guha-Sapir, D, Patterns of mortality rates in Darfur conflict. Lancet 375 (2010), 294–300.
84. Bolton, P, Bass, J, Murray, L, Lee, K, Weiss, W, McDonnell, SM, Expanding the scope of humanitarian program evaluation. Prehosp Disaster Med 22 (2007), 390–395.
85. Ssengooba, F, McPake, B, Palmer, N, Why performance-based contracting failed in Uganda. An ‘open-box’ evaluation of a complex health system intervention. Soc Sci Med 75 (2012), 377–383.
86. Fox, S, Witter, S, Wylde, E, Mafuta, E, Lievens, T, Paying health workers for performance in a fragmented, fragile state: Reflections from Katanga Province, Democratic Republic of Congo. Health Policy Plan 29 (2014), 96–105.
87. Diaz, J, Garfield, R, Iraq. Social sector watching briefs. Health and nutrition, July, 2003, UNICEF and WHO, Geneva http://apps.who.int/disasters/repo/11224.pdf (accessed March 16, 2017).
88. Autesserre, S, Dangerous tales: dominant narratives on the Congo and their unintended consequences. Afr Aff (Lond) 111 (2012), 202–222.
89. Spiegel, PB, Bennedsen, AR, Claass, J, et al. Prevalence of HIV infection in conflict-affected and displaced people in seven sub-Saharan African countries: a systematic review. Lancet 369 (2007), 2187–2195.
90. Akseer, N, Salehi, AS, Hossain, SM, et al. Achieving maternal and child health gains in Afghanistan: a countdown to 2015 country case study. Lancet Glob Health 4 (2016), e395–e413.
91. Mohamed, AH, Dalal, W, Nyoka, R, et al. Health care utilization for acute illnesses in an urban setting with a refugee population in Nairobi, Kenya: a cross-sectional survey. BMC Health Serv Res, 14, 2014, 200.
92. Carruth, L, Camel milk, amoxicillin, and a prayer: medical pluralism and medical humanitarian aid in the Somali region of Ethiopia. Soc Sci Med 120 (2014), 405–412.
93. Management Sciences for Health. MDS3: Managing access to medicines and other health technologies, 3rd edn. Chapter 15. Pharmaceutical donations. Arlington. https://www.msh.org/sites/msh.org/files/mds3-ch15-donations-mar2012.pdf, 2011 (accessed May 10, 2017).
94. Interagency Guidelines. Guidelines for medicine donations, revised. http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/44647/1/9789241501989_eng.pdf, 2010 (accessed March 16, 2017).
95. Médecins Sans Frontières. Accès aux soins, mortalité et violences en République Démocratique du Congo. Résultats de cinq enquêtes épidémiologiques: Kilwa, Inongo, Basankusu, Lubutu, Bunkeya (de mars à mai 2005). Médecins Sans Frontières, 2005.
96. Kligerman, M, Barry, M, Walmer, D, Bendavid, E, International aid and natural disasters: a pre- and post-earthquake longitudinal study of the healthcare infrastructure in Leogane, Haiti. Am J Trop Med Hyg 92 (2015), 448–453.
97. Helander, B, Getting the most out of it: nomadic health care seeking and the state in southern Somalia. Nomad People 25 (1990), 122–132.
98. Abramowitz, S, What happens when MSF leaves? Humanitarian departure and medical sovereignty in postconflict Liberia. Abramowitz, S, Panter-Brick, C, (eds.) Medical humanitarianism ethnographies of practice, 2015, University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia.
99. Hummelbrunner, R, Jones, H, A guide for planning and strategy development in the face of complexity. Overseas Development Institute; Background Note. https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/odi-assets/publications-opinion-files/8287.pdf (accessed March 16, 2017).
100. Good, BJ, DelVecchio Good, MJ, Abramowitz, S, Kleinman, A, Panter-Brick, C, Medical humanitarianism: research insights in a changing field of practice. Soc Sci Med 120 (2014), 311–316.
101. Svoboda, E, Pantuliano, S, International and local/diaspora actors in the Syria response. A diverging set of systems? Overseas Development Institute Humanitarian Policy Group working paper. https://www.odi.org/publications/8714-international-localdiaspora-actors-syria-response, 2015 (accessed March 16, 2017).
102. Walker, P, Glasser, J, Kambli, S, Climate change as a driver of humanitarian crises and response. http://fic.tufts.edu/assets/18089.TU_.Climate.pdf, June, 2012 (accessed March 16, 2017).
103. Assistance, GH, Humanitarian Assistance Report. http://www.globalhumanitarianassistance.org/report/gha2016/, 2016 (accessed March 16, 2017).
104. Davey, E, Humanitarian history in a complex world. Overseas Development Institute, Humanitarian Policy Group. Policy brief 59. https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/odi-assets/publications-opinion-files/8975.pdf, May, 2014 (accessed March 16, 2017).
105. Lewis, D, International development and the ‘perpetual present’: anthropological approaches to the re-historicization of policy. Eur J Dev Res 21 (2009), 32–46.