Biophysical causality and environmental preference elicitation: Evaluating the validity of welfare analysis over intermediate outcomes

American Journal of Agricultural Economics

Volumn 99, Issue 1, 2017, Pages 163-185

  Johnston, Robert J ^a   Schultz, Eric T ^b   Segerson, Kathleen ^b   Besedin, Elena Y ^c   Ramachandran, Mahesh ^d  

^a CLARK UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CONNECTICUT   (United States)

^c ABT ASSOCIATES   (United States)

^d Water Resources Office   (United States)

Author keywords

Biophysical production; Causality; Choice experiment; Ecological indicators; Ecosystem service; River restoration; Stated preference; Valuation; Willingness to pay

Indexed keywords

BIOINDICATOR; ECOSYSTEM SERVICE; ENVIRONMENTAL ECONOMICS; ENVIRONMENTAL RESTORATION; VALUATION; WELFARE ECONOMICS; WILLINGNESS TO PAY;

RHODE ISLAND; UNITED STATES;

EID: 85014848964     PISSN: 00029092     EISSN: 14678276     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/ajae/aaw073     Document Type: Article

References (77)

1. Adamowicz, W., J. Swait, P. Boxall, J. Louviere, and M. Williams. 1997. Perceptions versus Objective Measures of Environmental Quality in Combined Revealed and Stated Preference Models of Environmental Valuation. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 32(1): 65-84.
2. Adler, M. A., and E. A. Posner. 2000. Implementing Cost-benefit Analysis When Preferences Are Distorted. The Journal of Legal Studies 29(2): 1105-47.
3. Atkinson, S. E., and T. D. Crocker. 1987. A Bayesian Approach to Assessing the Robustness of Hedonic Property Value Studies. Journal of Applied Econometrics 2(1): 27-45.
4. Bateman, I. J., R. Brouwer, S. Ferrini, M. Schaafsma, D. N. Barton, A. Dubgaard, B. Hasler, S. Hime, I. Liekens, and S. Navrud. 2011. Making Benefit Transfers Work: Deriving and Testing Principles for Value Transfers for Similar and Dissimilar Sites Using A Case Study of the Non-market Benefits of Water Quality Improvements Across Europe. Environmental and Resource Economics 50(3): 365-87.
5. Bateman, I. J., G. M. Mace, C. Fezzi, G. Atkinson, and K. Turner. 2011. Economic Analysis for Ecosystem Service Assessments. Environmental and Resource Economics 48(3): 177-218.
6. Bergstrom, J. C., J. R. Stoll, and A. Randall. 1989. Information Effects in Contingent Markets. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 71(3): 685-91.
7. Berrens, R. P., A. K. Bohara, H. C. Jenkins-Smith, C. L. Silva, and D. L. Weimer. 2004. Information and Effort in Contingent Valuation Surveys: Application to Global Climate Change Using National Internet Samples. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 47(2): 331-63.
8. Blamey, R. K., J. W. Bennett, J. J. Louviere, M. D. Morrison, and J. C. Rolfe. 2002. Attribute Causality in Environmental Choice Modeling. Environmental and Resource Economics 23(2): 167-86.
9. Boyd, J., and A. Krupnick. 2013. Using Ecological Production Theory to Define and Select Environmental Commodities for Nonmarket Valuation. Agricultural and Resource Economics Review 42(1): 1-32.
10. Boyd J., P. Ringold, A. Krupnick, R. J. Johnston, M. A. Weber, and K. Hall. 2016. Ecosystem Services Indicators: Improving the Linkage between Biophysical and Economic Analyses. International Review of Environmental and Resource Economics 8(3-4): 359-443.
11. Boyer, T., and S. Polasky. 2004. Valuing Urban Wetlands: A Review of Nonmarket Valuation Studies. Wetlands 24(4): 744-55.
12. Boyle, K. J. 2003. Contingent Valuation in Practice. In A Primer on Nonmarket Valuation, ed. P. A. Champ, K. J. Boyle, and T. C. Brown, 111-69. Norwell, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
13. Brown, T. C., J. C. Bergstrom, and J. B. Loomis. 2007. Defining, Valuing, and Providing Ecosystem Goods and Services. Natural Resources Journal 47(3): 329-76.
14. Bulte, E., S. Gerking, J. A. List, and A. de Zeeuw. 2005. The Effect of Varying the Causes of Environmental Problems on Stated WTP Values: Evidence from a Field Study. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 49(2): 330-42.
15. Burns, C. W., M. Schallenberg, and P. Verburg. 2014. Potential Use of Classical Biomanipulation to Improve Water Quality in New Zealand Lakes: A Reevaluation. New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 48(1): 127-38.
16. Carlsson, F., P. Frykblom, and C. Liljenstolpe. 2003. Valuing Wetland Attributes: An Application of Choice Experiments. Ecological Economics 47(1): 95-103.
17. Christie, M., N. Hanley, J. Warren, K. Murphy, R. Wright, and T. Hyde. 2006. Valuing the Diversity of Biodiversity. Ecological Economics 58(3): 304-17.
18. Colby, B., and P. Orr. 2005. Economic Tradeoffs in Preserving Riparian Habitat. Natural Resources Journal 45(1): 15-31.
19. Colantoni, C. S., O. A. Davis, and M. Swaminuthan. 1976. Imperfect Consumers and Welfare Comparisons of Policies Concerning Information and Regulation. The Bell Journal of Economics 7(2): 602-15.
20. Colombo, S., M. Christie, and N. Hanley. 2013. What are the Consequences of Ignoring Attributes in ChoiceExperiments Implications for Ecosystem Service Valuation. Ecological Economics 96(1): 25-36.
21. Czajkowski, M., M. Buszko-Briggs, and N. Hanley. 2009. Valuing Changes in Forest Biodiversity. Ecological Economics 68(12): 2910-17.
22. Czajkowski, M., N. Hanley, and J. LaRiviere. 2015. The Effect of Experience on Preferences: Theory and Empirics for Environmental Public Goods. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 97(1): 333-51.
23. Daly, A., S. Hess, and K. Train. 2012. Assuring Finite Moments for Willingness to Pay in Random Coefficient Models. Transportation 39(1): 19-31.
24. Dietz, T., P. C. Stern, and A. Dan. 2009. How Deliberation Affects Stated Willingness to Pay for Mitigation of Carbon Dioxide Emissions: An Experiment. Land Economics 85(2): 329-47.
25. Dillman, D. A., J. D. Smyth, and L. M. Christian. 2009. Internet, Mail and Mixed Mode Surveys: The Tailored Design Method, 3rd ed. New York: John Wiley and Sons.
26. Erkan, D. E. 2002. Strategic Plan for the Restoration of Anadromous Fishes to Rhode Island Coastal Streams. Wakefield, RI: Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management, Division of Fish andWildlife.
27. Ferrini, S., and R. Scarpa. 2007. Designs with A Priori Information for Nonmarket Valuation with Choice-experiments: A Monte Carlo Study. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 53(3): 342-63.
28. Fiebig, D. G., M. P. Keane, J. Louviere, and N. Wasi. 2010. The Generalized Multinomial Logit Model: Accounting for Scale and Coefficient Heterogeneity. Marketing Science 29(3): 393-421.
29. Glenk, K., and S. Colombo. 2013. Modelling Outcome-related Risk in Choice Experiments. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 57(4): 559-78.
30. Hattam, C., A. Böhnke-Henrichs, T. Börger, D. Burdon, M. Hadjimichael, A. Delaney, J. P. Atkins, S. Garrard, and M. C. Austen. 2015. Integrating Methods for Ecosystem Service Assessment and Valuation: Mixed Methods or Mixed Messages. Ecological Economics 120(1): 126-38.
31. Hensher, D. A., and W. H. Greene. 2003. The Mixed Logit Model: The State of Practice. Transportation 30(3): 133-76.
32. Holland, D. S., J. Sanchirico, R. J. Johnston, and D. Joglekar. 2010. Economic Analysis for Ecosystem Based Management: Applications to Marine and Coastal Environments. Washington DC: Resources for the Future Press.
33. Holmes, T. P., J. C. Bergstrom, E. Huszar, S. B. Kask, and F. Orr, III. 2004. Contingent Valuation, Net Marginal Benefits, and the Scale of Riparian Ecosystem Restoration. Ecological Economics 49(1): 19-30.
34. Hu, W., W. L. Adamowicz, and M. M. Veeman. 2006. Labeling Context and Reference Point Effects in Models of Food Attribute Demand. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 88(4): 1034-49.
35. Interis, M. G., and D. R. Petrolia. 2016. Location, Location, Habitat: How the Value of Ecosystem Services Varies across Location and by Habitat. Land Economics 92(2): 292-307.
36. Jacobsen, J. B., and B. J. Thorsen. 2010. Preferences for Site and Environmental Functions when Selecting Forthcoming National Parks. Ecological Economics 69(7): 1532-44.
37. Johnston, R. J., and J. M. Duke. 2007. Willingness to Pay for Agricultural Land Preservation and Policy Process Attributes: Does the Method Matter American Journal of Agricultural Economics 89(4): 1098-115.
38. Johnston, R. J., B. M. Holland, and L. Yao. Forthcoming. Individualized Geocoding in Stated Preference Questionnaires: Implications for Survey Design and Welfare Estimation. Land Economics 92(4): 737-59
39. Johnston, R. J., G. Magnusson, M. Mazzotta, and J. J. Opaluch. 2002. Combining Economic and Ecological Indicators to Prioritize Salt Marsh Restoration Actions. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 84(5): 1362-70.
40. Johnston, R. J., and M. Russell. 2011. An Operational Structure for Clarity in Ecosystem Service Values. Ecological Economics 70(12): 2243-9.
41. Johnston, R. J., K. Segerson, E. T. Schultz, E. Y. Besedin, and M. Ramachandran. 2011. Indices of Biotic Integrity in Stated Preference Valuation of Aquatic Ecosystem Services. Ecological Economics 70(11): 1946-56.
42. Johnston, R. J., E. T. Schultz, K. Segerson, E. Y. Besedin, and M. Ramachandran. 2012. Enhancing the Content Validity of Stated Preference Valuation: The Structure and Function of Ecological Indicators. Land Economics 88(2): 102-20.
43. -. 2013. Stated Preferences for Intermediate versus Final Ecosystem Services: Disentangling Willingness to Pay for Omitted Ecological Outcomes. Agricultural and Resource Economics Review 42(1): 98-118.
44. Johnston, R. J., S. K. Swallow, T. J. Tyrrell, and D. M. Bauer. 2003. Rural Amenity Values and Length of Residency. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 85: 1009-24.
45. Johnston, R. J., T. F. Weaver, L. A. Smith, and S. K. Swallow. 1995. Contingent Valuation Focus Groups: Insights from Ethnographic Interview Techniques. Agricultural and Resource Economics Review 24(1): 56-69.
46. Kaplowitz, M. D., F. Lupi, and J. P. Hoehn. 2004. Multiple Methods for Developing and Evaluating a Stated-choice Questionnaire to Value Wetlands. In Methods for Testing and Evaluating Survey Questionnaires, ed. S. Presser, J. M. Rothgeb, M. P. Couper, J. T. Lessler, E. Martin, J. Martin, and E. Singer, 503-24. New York: John Wiley and Sons.
47. Karr, J. R. 1981. Assessment of Biotic Integrity Using Fish Communities. Fisheries 6 (6): 21-7.
48. Kataria, M. 2009. Willingness to Pay for Environmental Improvements in Hydropower Regulated Rivers. Energy Economics 31(1): 69-76.
49. Kerr, G. N., and B. M. H. Sharp. 2008. Evaluating Off-site Environmental Mitigation using Choice Modelling. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 52(4): 381-99.
50. Kryger, J., and H. U. Riisgård. 1988. Filtration Rate Capacities in 6 Species of European Freshwater Bivalves. Oecologia 77(1): 34-8.
51. Lang, J. R., and W. H. Jones. 1979. Hedonic Property Valuation Models: Are Subjective Measures of Neighborhood Amenities Needed Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association 7(4): 451-65.
52. LaRiviere, J., M. Czajkowski, N. Hanley, M. Aanesen, J. Falk-Petersen, and D. Tinch. 2014. The Value of Familiarity: Effects of Knowledge and Objective Signals on Willingness to Pay for a Public Good. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 68(2): 376-89.
53. Layton, D. F., and G. Brown. 2000. Heterogeneous Preferences Regarding Global Climate Change. The Review of Economics and Statistics 82(4): 616-24.
54. Longo, A., A. Markandya, and M. Petrucci. 2008. The Internalization of Externalities in the Production of Electricity: Willingness to Pay for the Attributes of a Policy for Renewable Energy. Ecological Economics 67(1): 140-52.
55. McIntosh C. R., J. F. Shogren, and D. C. Finnoff. 2010. Invasive Species and Delaying the Inevitable: Valuation Evidence from a National Survey. Ecological Economics 69: 632-40.
56. Meas, T., W. Hu, M. T. Batte, T. A. Woods, and S. Ernst. 2015. Substitutes or Complements Consumer Preference for Local and Organic Food Attributes. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 97(4): 1044-71.
57. Milon, J. W., and D. Scrogin. 2006. Latent Preferences and Valuation of Wetland Ecosystem Restoration. Ecological Economics 56(2): 162-75.
58. Nedeau, E. 2003. The Amazing Alewife. Gulf of Maine Times 7 (2): Science Insights.
59. Poor, P. J., K. J. Boyle, L. O. Taylor, and R. Bouchard. 2001. Objective versus Subjective Measures of Water Clarity in Hedonic Property Value Models. Land Economics 77(4): 482-93.
60. Raithel, C. J., and R. H. Hartenstine. 2006. The Status of Freshwater Mussels in Rhode Island. Northeastern Naturalist 13(1): 103-16.
61. Rose, J. M., and M. C. J. Bliemer. 2009. Constructing Efficient Stated Choice Experimental Designs. Transport Reviews 29(5): 587-617.
62. Sandor, Z., and M. Wedel. 2001. Designing Conjoint Choice Experiments Using Managers' Prior Beliefs. Journal of Marketing Research 38(4): 430-44.
63. -. 2002. Profile Construction in Experimental Choice Designs for Mixed Logit Models. Marketing Science 21(4): 455-75.
64. Scarpa, R., and J. M. Rose. 2008. Design Efficiency for Non-market Valuation with Choice Modelling: How to Measureit, What to Report, and Why. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 52(3): 253-82.
65. Scarpa, R., M. Thiene, and K. Train. 2008. Utility in Willingness to Pay Space: A Tool to Address Confounding Random Scale Effects in Destination Choice to the Alps. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 90(4): 994-1010.
66. Schilt, C. R. 2007. Developing Fish Passage and Protection at Hydropower Dams. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 104(3): 295-325.
67. Schkade, D. A., and J. W. Payne. 1994. How People Respond to Contingent Valuation Questions: A Verbal Protocol Analysis of Willingness to Pay for an Environmental Regulation. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 26(1): 88-109.
68. Schultz, E. T., R. J. Johnston, K. Segerson, and E. Y. Besedin. 2012. Integrating Ecology and Economics for Restoration: Using Ecological Indicators in Valuation of Ecosystem Services. Restoration Ecology 20(4): 304-10.
69. Smith, D. R. 1985. Recent Range Expansion of the Freshwater Mussel Anodonta implicata and Its Relationship to Clupeid Fish Restoration in the Connecticut River System. Freshwater Invertebrate Biology 4(2): 105-8.
70. Spash, C. L., and N. Hanley. 1995. Preferences, Information and Biodiversity Preservation. Ecological Economics 12(3): 191-208.
71. Spooner, D. E., and C. C. Vaughn. 2008. A Trait-based Approach to Species' Roles in Stream Ecosystems: Climate Change, Community Structure, and Material Cycling. Oecologia 158(2): 307-17.
72. Strayer, D. L., D. C. Hunter, L. C. Smith, and C. K. Borg. 1994. Distribution, Abundance, and Roles of Freshwater Clams (Bivalvia, Unionidae) in the Freshwater Tidal Hudson River. Freshwater Biology 31(2): 239-48.
73. Thiene, M., and R. Scarpa. 2009. Deriving and Testing Efficient Estimates of WTP Distributions in Destination Choice Models. Environmental and Resource Economics 44(3): 379-95.
74. Train, K. E. 2009. Discrete Choice Methods with Simulation. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
75. Train, K., and M. Weeks. 2005. Discrete Choice Models in Preference Space and Willing-to-Pay Space. In Applications of Simulation Methods in Environmental and Resource Economics, ed. R. Scarpa and A. Alberini, 1-16. Dordrecht, Germany: Springer.
76. Vaughn, C. C., and C. C. Hakenkamp. 2001. The Functional Role of Burrowing Bivalves in Freshwater Ecosystems. Freshwater Biology 46(11): 1431-46.
77. Zhao, M., R. J. Johnston, and E. T. Schultz. 2013. What to Value and How Ecological Indicator Choices in Stated Preference Valuation. Environmental and Resource Economics 56(1): 3-25.