A direct healthcare cost analysis of the cryopreserved versus fresh transfer policy at the blastocyst stage

Reproductive BioMedicine Online

Volumn 34, Issue 1, 2017, Pages 19-26

  Papaleo, Enrico ^a   Pagliardini, Luca ^a   Vanni, Valeria Stella ^a   Delprato, Diana ^a   Rubino, Patrizia ^a   Candiani, Massimo ^a,b   Viganò, Paola ^a  

^a SAN RAFFAELE HOSPITAL   (Italy)

^b VITA SALUTE SAN RAFFAELE UNIVERSITY   (Italy)

Author keywords

Blastocyst; Cost analysis; Freeze all; IVF

Indexed keywords

ADULT; AGE; ARTICLE; BLASTOCYST; BODY MASS; CASE CONTROL STUDY; CONTROLLED STUDY; COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS; CRYOPRESERVATION; EMBRYO TRANSFER; FEMALE; HEALTH CARE COST; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HEALTH CARE SYSTEM; HUMAN; HUMAN CELL; MAJOR CLINICAL STUDY; OBSERVATIONAL STUDY; OOCYTE RETRIEVAL; PREGNANCY OUTCOME; RETROSPECTIVE STUDY; BIRTH RATE; COMPARATIVE STUDY; CYTOLOGY; ECONOMICS; IN VITRO FERTILIZATION; INFERTILITY; ITALY; OOCYTE; PREGNANCY; PREGNANCY RATE; VITRIFICATION;

ADULT; BIRTH RATE; BLASTOCYST; CASE-CONTROL STUDIES; COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS; CRYOPRESERVATION; EMBRYO TRANSFER; FEMALE; FERTILIZATION IN VITRO; HEALTH CARE COSTS; HUMANS; INFERTILITY; ITALY; OOCYTES; PREGNANCY; PREGNANCY RATE; RETROSPECTIVE STUDIES; VITRIFICATION;

EID: 85008196908     PISSN: 14726483     EISSN: 14726491     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.rbmo.2016.09.008     Document Type: Article

References (45)

1. Alpha Scientists in Reproductive Medicine, ESHRE Special Interest Group of Embryology. The Istanbul consensus workshop on embryo assessment: proceedings of an expert meeting. Journal 26 (2011), 1270–1283.
2. Barnhart, K.T., Introduction: are we ready to eliminate the transfer of fresh embryos in in vitro fertilization?. Fertil. Steril 102 (2014), 1–2.
3. Blockeel, C., Drakopoulos, P., Santos-Ribeiro, S., Polyzos, N.P., Tournaye, H., A fresh look at the freeze-all protocol: a SWOT analysis. Hum. Reprod 31 (2016), 491–497.
4. Bourgain, C., Devroey, P., The endometrium in stimulated cycles for IVF. Hum. Reprod. Update 9 (2003), 515–522.
5. Calzi, F., Papaleo, E., Rabellotti, E., Ottolina, J., Vailati, S., Vigano, P., Candiani, M., Exposure of embryos to oxygen at low concentration in a cleavage stage transfer program: reproductive outcomes in a time-series analysis. Clin. Lab 58 (2012), 997–1003.
6. Chambers, G.M., Lee, E., Hoang, V.P., Hansen, M., Bower, C., Sullivan, E.A., Hospital utilization, costs and mortality rates during the first 5 years of life: a population study of ART and non-ART singletons. Hum. Reprod 29 (2014), 601–610.
7. Check, J.H., Choe, J.K., Katsoff, D., Summers-Chase, D., Wilson, C., Controlled ovarian hyperstimulation adversely affects implantation following in vitro fertilization-embryo transfer. J. Assist. Reprod. Genet 16 (1999), 416–420.
8. Cobo, A., de los Santos, M.J., Castello, D., Gamiz, P., Campos, P., Remohi, J., Outcomes of vitrified early cleavage-stage and blastocyst-stage embryos in a cryopreservation program: evaluation of 3,150 warming cycles. Fertil. Steril 98 (2012), 1138–1146 e1131.
9. Corti, L., Papaleo, E., Pagliardini, L., Rabellotti, E., Molgora, M., La Marca, A., Vigano, P., Candiani, M., Fresh blastocyst transfer as a clinical approach to overcome the detrimental effect of progesterone elevation at hCG triggering: a strategy in the context of the Italian law. Eur. J. Obstet. Gynecol. Reprod. Biol 171 (2013), 73–77.
10. de Mouzon, J., Goossens, V., Bhattacharya, S., Castilla, J.A., Ferraretti, A.P., Korsak, V., Kupka, M., Nygren, K.G., Nyboe Andersen, A., Assisted reproductive technology in Europe, 2006: results generated from European registers by ESHRE. Hum. Reprod 25 (2010), 1851–1862.
11. Devroey, P., Bourgain, C., Macklon, N.S., Fauser, B.C., Reproductive biology and IVF: ovarian stimulation and endometrial receptivity. Trends Endocrinol. Metab 15 (2004), 84–90.
12. Devroey, P., Polyzos, N.P., Blockeel, C., An OHSS-Free Clinic by segmentation of IVF treatment. Hum. Reprod 26 (2011), 2593–2597.
13. Drakopoulos, P., Blockeel, C., Stoop, D., Camus, M., de Vos, M., Tournaye, H., Polyzos, N.P., Conventional ovarian stimulation and single embryo transfer for IVF/ICSI. How many oocytes do we need to maximize cumulative live birth rates after utilization of all fresh and frozen embryos?. Hum. Reprod 31 (2016), 370–376.
14. ESHRE Capri Workshop Group. Economic aspects of infertility care: a challenge for researchers and clinicians. Journal 30 (2015), 2243–2248.
15. Evans, J., Hannan, N.J., Edgell, T.A., Vollenhoven, B.J., Lutjen, P.J., Osianlis, T., Salamonsen, L.A., Rombauts, L.J., Fresh versus frozen embryo transfer: backing clinical decisions with scientific and clinical evidence. Hum. Reprod. Update 20 (2014), 808–821.
16. Gvakharia, M., Adamson, G.D., Implementation of an inexpensive method of vitrification and warming of human cleavage-stage embryos using cut standard straws. Fertil. Steril 95 (2011), 2552–2553.
17. Ishihara, O., Araki, R., Kuwahara, A., Itakura, A., Saito, H., Adamson, G.D., Impact of frozen-thawed single-blastocyst transfer on maternal and neonatal outcome: an analysis of 277,042 single-embryo transfer cycles from 2008 to 2010 in Japan. Fertil. Steril 101 (2014), 128–133.
18. Kato, O., Kawasaki, N., Bodri, D., Kuroda, T., Kawachiya, S., Kato, K., Takehara, Y., Neonatal outcome and birth defects in 6623 singletons born following minimal ovarian stimulation and vitrified versus fresh single embryo transfer. Eur. J. Obstet. Gynecol. Reprod. Biol 161 (2012), 46–50.
19. Li, Z., Sullivan, E.A., Chapman, M., Farquhar, C., Wang, Y.A., Risk of ectopic pregnancy lowest with transfer of single frozen blastocyst. Hum. Reprod 30 (2015), 2048–2054.
20. Maheshwari, A., Bhattacharya, S., Elective frozen replacement cycles for all: ready for prime time?. Hum. Reprod 28 (2013), 6–9.
21. Maheshwari, A., Pandey, S., Shetty, A., Hamilton, M., Bhattacharya, S., Obstetric and perinatal outcomes in singleton pregnancies resulting from the transfer of frozen thawed versus fresh embryos generated through in vitro fertilization treatment: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Fertil. Steril 98 (2012), 368–377 e361-369.
22. Nikas, G., Develioglu, O.H., Toner, J.P., Jones, H.W. Jr., Endometrial pinopodes indicate a shift in the window of receptivity in IVF cycles. Hum. Reprod 14 (1999), 787–792.
23. Ochsenkuhn, R., Arzberger, A., von Schonfeldt, V., Gallwas, J., Rogenhofer, N., Crispin, A., Thaler, C.J., Noss, U., Subtle progesterone rise on the day of human chorionic gonadotropin administration is associated with lower live birth rates in women undergoing assisted reproductive technology: a retrospective study with 2,555 fresh embryo transfers. Fertil. Steril 98 (2012), 347–354.
24. Polyzos, N.P., Sunkara, S.K., Sub-optimal responders following controlled ovarian stimulation: an overlooked group?. Hum. Reprod 30 (2015), 2005–2008.
25. Practice Committee of American Society for Reproductive Medicine and Practice Committee of Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology, Criteria for number of embryos to transfer: a committee opinion. Fertil. Steril 99 (2013), 44–46.
26. Restelli, L., Paffoni, A., Corti, L., Rabellotti, E., Mangiarini, A., Vigano, P., Somigliana, E., Papaleo, E., The strategy of group embryo culture based on pronuclear pattern on blastocyst development: a two center analysis. J. Assist. Reprod. Genet 31 (2014), 1629–1634.
27. Richter, K.S., Shipley, S.K., McVearry, I., Tucker, M.J., Widra, E.A., Cryopreserved embryo transfers suggest that endometrial receptivity may contribute to reduced success rates of later developing embryos. Fertil. Steril 86 (2006), 862–866.
28. Roque, M., Freeze-all policy: is it time for that?. J. Assist. Reprod. Genet 32 (2015), 171–176.
29. Roque, M., Lattes, K., Serra, S., Sola, I., Geber, S., Carreras, R., Checa, M.A., Fresh embryo transfer versus frozen embryo transfer in in vitro fertilization cycles: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Fertil. Steril 99 (2013), 156–162.
30. Roque, M., Valle, M., Guimaraes, F., Sampaio, M., Geber, S., Freeze-all policy: fresh vs. frozen-thawed embryo transfer. Fertil. Steril 103 (2015), 1190–1193.
31. Roy, T.K., Bradley, C.K., Bowman, M.C., McArthur, S.J., Single-embryo transfer of vitrified-warmed blastocysts yields equivalent live-birth rates and improved neonatal outcomes compared with fresh transfers. Fertil. Steril 101 (2014), 1294–1301.
32. Rubino, P., Viganò, P., Luddi, A., Piomboni, P., The ICSI procedure from past to future: a systematic review of the more controversial aspects. Hum. Reprod. Update 22 (2016), 194–227.
33. Shapiro, B.S., Daneshmand, S.T., Garner, F.C., Aguirre, M., Ross, R., Contrasting patterns in in vitro fertilization pregnancy rates among fresh autologous, fresh oocyte donor, and cryopreserved cycles with the use of day 5 or day 6 blastocysts may reflect differences in embryo-endometrium synchrony. Fertil. Steril 89 (2008), 20–26.
34. Shapiro, B.S., Daneshmand, S.T., Garner, F.C., Aguirre, M., Hudson, C., Thomas, S., Evidence of impaired endometrial receptivity after ovarian stimulation for in vitro fertilization: a prospective randomized trial comparing fresh and frozen-thawed embryo transfer in normal responders. Fertil. Steril 96 (2011), 344–348.
35. Shapiro, B.S., Daneshmand, S.T., Garner, F.C., Aguirre, M., Hudson, C., Thomas, S., Evidence of impaired endometrial receptivity after ovarian stimulation for in vitro fertilization: a prospective randomized trial comparing fresh and frozen-thawed embryo transfers in high responders. Fertil. Steril 96 (2011), 516–518.
36. Shapiro, B.S., Daneshmand, S.T., De Leon, L., Garner, F.C., Aguirre, M., Hudson, C., Frozen-thawed embryo transfer is associated with a significantly reduced incidence of ectopic pregnancy. Fertil. Steril 98 (2012), 1490–1494.
37. Shapiro, B.S., Daneshmand, S.T., Restrepo, H., Garner, F.C., Aguirre, M., Hudson, C., Matched-cohort comparison of single-embryo transfers in fresh and frozen-thawed embryo transfer cycles. Fertil. Steril 99 (2013), 389–392.
38. Shapiro, B.S., Daneshmand, S.T., Garner, F.C., Aguirre, M., Hudson, C., Clinical rationale for cryopreservation of entire embryo cohorts in lieu of fresh transfer. Fertil. Steril 102 (2014), 3–9.
39. Shapiro, B.S., Daneshmand, S.T., Garner, F.C., Aguirre, M., Hudson, C., Freeze-all can be a superior therapy to another fresh cycle in patients with prior fresh blastocyst implantation failure. Reprod. Biomed. Online 29 (2014), 286–290.
40. Sutcliffe, A.G., Ludwig, M., Outcome of assisted reproduction. Lancet 370 (2007), 351–359.
41. Tilburt, J.C., Cassel, C.K., Why the ethics of parsimonious medicine is not the ethics of rationing. JAMA 309 (2013), 773–774.
42. Ubaldi, F.M., Capalbo, A., Colamaria, S., Ferrero, S., Maggiulli, R., Vajta, G., Sapienza, F., Cimadomo, D., Giuliani, M., Gravotta, E., Vaiarelli, A., Rienzi, L., Reduction of multiple pregnancies in the advanced maternal age population after implementation of an elective single embryo transfer policy coupled with enhanced embryo selection: pre- and post-intervention study. Hum. Reprod 30 (2015), 2097–2106.
43. Venetis, C.A., Kolibianakis, E.M., Bosdou, J.K., Tarlatzis, B.C., Progesterone elevation and probability of pregnancy after IVF: a systematic review and meta-analysis of over 60 000 cycles. Hum. Reprod. Update 19 (2013), 433–457.
44. Wong, K.M., Mastenbroek, S., Repping, S., Cryopreservation of human embryos and its contribution to in vitro fertilization success rates. Fertil. Steril 102 (2014), 19–26.
45. Zhu, D., Zhang, J., Cao, S., Heng, B.C., Huang, M., Ling, X., Duan, T., Tong, G.Q., Vitrified-warmed blastocyst transfer cycles yield higher pregnancy and implantation rates compared with fresh blastocyst transfer cycles–time for a new embryo transfer strategy?. Fertil. Steril 95 (2011), 1691–1695.