Shared Decision Making in Pediatrics: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

Academic Pediatrics

Volumn 15, Issue 6, 2015, Pages 573-583

  Wyatt, Kirk D ^a,b   List, Betsy ^c   Brinkman, William B ^d   Prutsky Lopez, Gabriela ^a,e,f   Asi, Noor ^a   Erwin, Patricia ^a   Wang, Zhen ^a   Domecq Garces, Juan Pablo ^a,e,g   Montori, Victor M ^a   LeBlanc, Annie ^a  

^a MAYO CLINIC   (United States)

^b MAYO CLINIC COLLEGE OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^c CINCINNATI CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL MEDICAL CENTER   (United States)

^d UNIVERSITY OF CINCINNATI COLLEGE OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^e UNIVERSIDAD PERUANA CAYETANO HEREDIA   (Peru)

^f WAYNE STATE UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^g HENRY FORD HOSPITAL   (United States)

Author keywords

adolescent; child; child, preschool; decision aids; decision making; decision making, shared; decision support techniques; infant; infant, newborn; pediatrics

Indexed keywords

CONFLICT; DECISION MAKING; DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEM; HUMAN; KNOWLEDGE; MEDICAL DECISION MAKING; META ANALYSIS; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PATIENT SATISFACTION; PEDIATRICS; PUBLICATION; REVIEW; SHARED DECISION MAKING; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; ADOLESCENT; CHILD; DOCTOR PATIENT RELATION; HUMAN RELATION; INFANT; NEWBORN; PATIENT PARTICIPATION; PRESCHOOL CHILD;

ADOLESCENT; CHILD; CHILD, PRESCHOOL; DECISION MAKING; DECISION SUPPORT TECHNIQUES; HUMANS; INFANT; INFANT, NEWBORN; PATIENT PARTICIPATION; PEDIATRICS; PHYSICIAN-PATIENT RELATIONS; PROFESSIONAL-FAMILY RELATIONS;

EID: 84947034102     PISSN: 18762859     EISSN: 18762867     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.acap.2015.03.011     Document Type: Review

References (108)

1. A.G. Fiks, and M.E. Jimenez The promise of shared decision-making in paediatrics Acta Paediatr 99 2010 1464 1466
2. C. Charles, A. Gafni, and T. Whelan Shared decision-making in the medical encounter: what does it mean? (Or, it takes at least two to tango) Soc Sci Med 44 1997 681 692
3. C. Charles, A. Gafni, and T. Whelan Decision-making in the physician-patient encounter: revisiting the shared treatment decision-making model Soc Sci Med 49 1999 651 661
4. G. Makoul, and M.L. Clayman An integrative model of shared decision making in medical encounters Patient Educ Couns 60 2006 301 312
5. J. Gabe, G. Olumide, and M. Bury "It takes three to tango": a framework for understanding patient partnership in paediatric clinics Soc Sci Med 59 2004 1071 1079
6. W.G. Bartholome Informed consent, parental permission, and assent in pediatric practice Pediatrics 96 5 pt 1 1995 981 982
7. Informed consent, parental permission, and assent in pediatric practice. Committee on Bioethics, American Academy of Pediatrics Pediatrics 95 1995 314 317
8. Patient- and family-centered care and the pediatrician's role Pediatrics 129 2012 394 404
9. United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child Available at: http://www.ohchr.org/en/professionalinterest/pages/crc.aspx 1989 Accessed April 17, 2014
10. D. Merenstein, M. Diener-West, A. Krist, and et al. An assessment of the shared-decision model in parents of children with acute otitis media Pediatrics 116 2005 1267 1275
11. E.A. Lipstein, W.B. Brinkman, and M.T. Britto What is known about parents' treatment decisions? A narrative review of pediatric decision making Med Decis Making 32 2012 246 258
12. E.A. Lipstein, W.B. Brinkman, A.G. Fiks, and et al. An emerging field of research: challenges in pediatric decision making Med Decis Making 35 2015 403 408
13. D. Stacey, F. Legare, N.F. Col, and et al. Decision aids for people facing health treatment or screening decisions Cochrane Database Syst Rev 1 2014 CD001431
14. F. Legare, M. Labrecque, A. LeBlanc, and et al. Training family physicians in shared decision making for the use of antibiotics for acute respiratory infections: a pilot clustered randomized controlled trial Health Expect 14 suppl 1 2011 96 110
15. K.D. Wyatt, G. Prutsky Lopez, J.P. Domecq Garces, and et al. Study protocol: a systematic review of pediatric shared decision making Syst Rev 2 2013 48
16. Cochrane Collaboration. The Cochrane Collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias. Available at: http://ohg.cochrane.org/sites/ohg.cochrane.org/files/uploads/Risk%20of%20bias%20assessment%20tool.pdf. Accessed April 12, 2014.
17. Cochrane Collaboration. Suggested risk of bias criteria for EPOC reviews. Available at: http://epoc.cochrane.org/sites/epoc.cochrane.org/files/uploads/Suggested%20risk%20of%20bias%20criteria%20for%20EPOC%20reviews.pdf. Accessed April 12, 2014.
18. T. Greenhalgh, G. Robert, F. Macfarlane, and et al. Storylines of research in diffusion of innovation: a meta-narrative approach to systematic review Soc Sci Med 61 2005 417 430
19. Shared@EACH - Shared Decision Making Network. Available at: https://www.facebook.com/groups/SharedDecisionMaking/.
20. Family Decision Services. SMDM Connect. Available at: http://connect.smdm.org/groups/discussion/list/groupid/5596. Accessed April 14, 2014.
21. Services CFD. A to Z inventory of pediatric patient decision aids. Available at: http://www.cheo.on.ca/en/decisionaids. Accessed April 12, 2014.
22. M. Egger, G. Davey Smith, M. Schneider, and et al. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test BMJ 315 7109 1997 629 634
23. J. Lau, J.P. Ioannidis, N. Terrin, and et al. The case of the misleading funnel plot BMJ 333 7568 2006 597 600
24. R. DerSimonian, and N. Laird Meta-analysis in clinical trials Control Clin Trials 7 1986 177 188
25. J.P. Higgins, S.G. Thompson, J.J. Deeks, and et al. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses BMJ 327 7414 2003 557 560
26. F. Legare, M. Labrecque, A. LeBlanc, and et al. Does training family physicians in shared decision making promote optimal use of antibiotics for acute respiratory infections? Study protocol of a pilot clustered randomised controlled trial BMC Fam Pract 8 2007 65
27. A. Leblanc, F. Legare, M. Labrecque, and et al. Feasibility of a randomised trial of a continuing medical education program in shared decision-making on the use of antibiotics for acute respiratory infections in primary care: the DECISION+ pilot trial Implement Sci 6 2011 5
28. F. Legare, M. Labrecque, M. Cauchon, and et al. Training family physicians in shared decision-making to reduce the overuse of antibiotics in acute respiratory infections: a cluster randomized trial CMAJ 184 2012 E726 E734
29. F. Legare, M. Labrecque, G. Godin, and et al. Training family physicians and residents in family medicine in shared decision making to improve clinical decisions regarding the use of antibiotics for acute respiratory infections: protocol for a clustered randomized controlled trial BMC Fam Pract 12 2011 3
30. (Australia) NCfIRaS. MMR Decision Aid. Available at: http://www.ncirs.edu.au/immunisation/education/mmr-decision/index.php. Accessed December 10, 2013.
31. S. Shourie, C. Jackson, F.M. Cheater, and et al. A cluster randomised controlled trial of a web based decision aid to support parents' decisions about their child's measles mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccination Vaccine 31 2013 6003 6010
32. C. Wallace, J. Leask, and L.J. Trevena Effects of a web based decision aid on parental attitudes to MMR vaccination: a before and after study BMJ 332 7534 2006 146 149
33. C. Jackson, F.M. Cheater, R. Peacock, and et al. A feasibility study of a web based MMR decision aid to support informed decision-making by UK parents Health Educ J 69 2009 74 83
34. Widdice L, Heeman A, Leyva C, et al. Impact of an HPV vaccine decision aid on knowledge, decisional conflict, and intention to vaccinate. Paper presented at: Pediatric Academic Societies Annual Meeting; 2013; Washington, DC.
35. C. Leyva, M. Zender, K. Staun, and et al. People into practice: design of a medical decision aid with repetitive stakeholders' input Int J Design Soc 7 2013 51 63
36. A.J. Herrera, B. Cochran, A. Herrera, and et al. Parental information and circumcision in highly motivated couples with higher education Pediatrics 71 1983 233 234
37. D.B. Bailey, V. Buysse, T. Smith, and et al. The effects and perceptions of family involvement in program decisions about family-centered practices Eval Program Plan 15 1992 23 32
38. M.E. Evans, M.I. Armstrong, F. Thompson, and et al. Assessing the outcomes of parent-and provider-designed systems of care for children with emotional and behavioral disorders Psychiatr Q 65 1994 257 272
39. L.G. Yamamoto Application of informed consent principles in the emergency department evaluation of febrile children at risk for occult bacteremia Hawaii Med J 56 1997 313 317 320-312
40. L.G. Yamamoto, L.L. Young, and J.L. Roberts Informed consent and parental choice of anesthesia and sedation for the repair of small lacerations in children Am J Emerg Med 15 1997 285 289
41. R.A. Dunn, P.E. Shenouda, D.R. Martin, and et al. Videotape increases parent knowledge about poliovirus vaccines and choices of polio vaccination schedules Pediatrics 102 1998 e26
42. B. Chewning, P. Mosena, D. Wilson, and et al. Evaluation of a computerized contraceptive decision aid for adolescent patients Patient Educ Couns 38 1999 227 239
43. M.M. Mello, J.P. Burns, R.D. Truog, and et al. Decision making and satisfaction with care in the pediatric intensive care unit: findings from a controlled clinical trial Pediatr Crit Care Med 5 2004 40 47
44. C. Kline, A. Reineke, J. Auger, and et al. Effects of a unique pediatric hematology-oncology palliative care program on medical decision-making and communication between healthcare providers and families: results of a supportive care survey Progr Palliat Care 20 2012 13 18
45. University of Leeds, National Centre for Immunisation Research and Surveillance (Australia). The MMR decision aid. Available at: http://www.leedsmmr.co.uk/. Accessed December 10, 2013.
46. A.L. Wroe, N. Turner, and R.G. Owens Evaluation of a decision-making aid for parents regarding childhood immunizations Health Psychol 24 2005 539 547
47. R.M. Hays, J. Valentine, G. Haynes, and et al. The Seattle Pediatric Palliative Care Project: effects on family satisfaction and health-related quality of life J Palliat Med 9 2006 716 728
48. J.N. Baker, R. Barfield, P.S. Hinds, and et al. A process to facilitate decision making in pediatric stem cell transplantation: the individualized care planning and coordination model Biol Blood Marrow Transplant 13 2007 245 254
49. Bennett C, Drake E, Hopkins L, et al. What can you do to prevent HPV and cervical cancer? A decision aid for parents/guardians of girls in grade 8 in Ontario. Available at: http://decisionaid.ohri.ca/docs/das/HPV-vaccine.pdf. Accessed December 10, 2013.
50. N.A. Francis, C.C. Butler, K. Hood, and et al. Effect of using an interactive booklet about childhood respiratory tract infections in primary care consultations on reconsulting and antibiotic prescribing: a cluster randomised controlled trial BMJ 339 2009 b2885
51. Johnston C, Durieux-Smith A, Moran L, et al. Should my child have a second cochlear implant? A decision aid to discuss options with your health care team. Available at: http://www.cheo.on.ca/uploads/Decision%20Services/Final%20BICI%20DA%2020101108.pdf. Accessed December 10, 2013.
52. A. Karpas, M. Finkelstein, and S. Reid Parental preference for rehydration method for children in the emergency department Pediatr Emerg Care 25 2009 301 306
53. M.E. Lyon, P.A. Garvie, R. McCarter, and et al. Who will speak for me? Improving end-of-life decision-making for adolescents with HIV and their families Pediatrics 123 2009 e199 e206
54. H.C. Ossebaard, J.E. van Gemert-Pijnen, M.J. Sorbi, and et al. A study of a Dutch online decision aid for parents of children with ADHD J Telemed Telecare 16 2010 15 19
55. Healthwise Staff. Depression: should my child take medicine to treat depression? Available at: http://www.healthlinkbc.ca/kb/content/decisionpoint/ty6886.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
56. Healthwise Staff. Wisdom teeth: should I have my wisdom teeth removed? Available at: http://www.healthlinkbc.ca/kb/content/decisionpoint/aa143778.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
57. Healthwise Staff. Scoliosis: should I (or my child) have surgery? Available at: http://www.healthlinkbc.ca/kb/content/decisionpoint/aa115911.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
58. C. Jackson, F.M. Cheater, W. Harrison, and et al. Randomised cluster trial to support informed parental decision-making for the MMR vaccine BMC Public Health 11 2011 475
59. A.P. Nieboer, J.M. Cramm, B. van der Meij, and et al. Choice processes and satisfaction with care according to parents of children and young adults with intellectual disability in the Netherlands J Intellect Dev Disabil 36 2011 127 136
60. Brinkman W, Parker M, Wolski C, et al. LGG for Diarrhea. Available at: http://www.cincinnatichildrens.org/service/j/anderson-center/evidence-based-care/decision-aids/. Accessed December 10, 2013.
61. T. Connolly, and J. Reb Toward interactive, Internet-based decision aid for vaccination decisions: better information alone is not enough Vaccine 30 2012 3813 3818
62. Cosway B, Lloyd A, Owens D, et al. Glue ear. Available at: https://web.archive.org/web/20130921213626/http://www.optiongrid.org/resources/glueear-grid.pdf. Accessed September 21, 2013.
63. A.G. Fiks, S. Mayne, C.C. Hughes, and et al. Development of an instrument to measure parents' preferences and goals for the treatment of attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder Acad Pediatr 12 2012 445 455
64. A. Golnik, P. Scal, A. Wey, and et al. Autism-specific primary care medical home intervention J Autism Dev Disord 42 2012 1087 1093
65. Healthwise Staff. ADHD: should my child take medicine for ADHD? Available at: http://www.healthlinkbc.ca/kb/content/decisionpoint/aa69633.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
66. Healthwise Staff. Bed-wetting: should I do something about my child's bed-wetting? Available at: http://www.healthlinkbc.ca/kb/content/decisionpoint/aa6160.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
67. Healthwise Staff. Bed-wetting: should my child see a doctor? Available at: http://www.healthlinkbc.ca/kb/content/decisionpoint/aa6052.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
68. Healthwise Staff. Ear problems: should my child be treated for fluid buildup in the middle ear? Available at: http://www.healthlinkbc.ca/kb/content/decisionpoint/aa60386.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
69. Healthwise Staff. Umbilical hernia: should my child have surgery? Available at: http://www.healthlinkbc.ca/kb/content/decisionpoint/rt1510.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
70. Lawson M, Saarimaki A, Kryworuchko J, et al. Ottawa family decision guide. Available at: http://www.cheo.on.ca/uploads/Decision%20Services/OFDG.pdf. Accessed December 10, 2013.
71. Lloyd A, Owens D, Cording E, et al. Tonsillectomy or watchful waiting - for children under 16 years old. Available at: http://www.optiongrid.org/resources/tonsillectomy-grid.pdf. Accessed December 10, 2013.
72. P.W. Brady, W.B. Brinkman, J.M. Simmons, and et al. Oral antibiotics at discharge for children with acute osteomyelitis: a rapid cycle improvement project BMJ Qual Saf 23 2014 499 507
73. W.B. Brinkman, J. Hartl Majcher, L.M. Poling, and et al. Shared decision-making to improve attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder care Patient Educ Couns 93 2013 95 101
74. Brinkman W, Froehlich T, Sucharew H, et al. Effect of an explicit values clarification exercise on parental decision making and subsequent medication use following completion of an N-of-1 methylphenidate trial among children with ADHD. Paper presented at: International Shared Decision Making Conference; 2013; Lima, Peru.
75. Healthwise Staff. HPV: should my child get the vaccine? Available at: http://www.healthlinkbc.ca/kb/content/decisionpoint/uz2098.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
76. Healthwise Staff. Circumcision: should I keep my son's penis natural? Available at: http://www.healthlinkbc.ca/kb/content/decisionpoint/aa41834.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
77. Healthwise Staff. Acne: should I see my doctor? Available at: http://www.healthlinkbc.ca/kb/content/decisionpoint/aa37670.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
78. Healthwise Staff. Acne: should I take isotretinoin for severe acne? Available at: http://www.healthlinkbc.ca/kb/content/decisionpoint/aa37467.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
79. Healthwise Staff. Ear infection: should I give my child antibiotics? Available at: http://www.healthlinkbc.ca/kb/content/decisionpoint/te6203.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
80. Healthwise Staff. Blocked tear ducts: should my baby have a probing procedure? Available at: http://www.healthlinkbc.ca/kb/content/decisionpoint/aa170043.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
81. G.M. Westermann, F. Verheij, B. Winkens, and et al. Structured shared decision-making using dialogue and visualization: a randomized controlled trial Patient Educ Couns 90 2013 74 81
82. Autism Speaks Autism Treatment Network. Autism: should my child take medicine for challenging behavior? Available at: http://www.autismspeaks.org/sites/default/files/documents/atn/medicine-decision-aid.pdf. Accessed December 10, 2013.
83. Leesman L. Warfarin or enoxaparin? Available at: http://www.cincinnatichildrens.org/WorkArea/DownloadAsset.aspx?id=101268. Accessed April 17, 2015.
84. P. Rosati, V. Di Salvo, S. Crudo, and et al. Are parents of children hospitalized with severe community-acquired pneumonia more satisfied with care when physicians allow them to share decisions on the antibiotic route? Health Expect 2014 Apr 28 http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/hex.12197. [Epub ahead of print]
85. Simmons M. Right choice, right time: supporting young people to make evidence-based, preference-sensitive decisions about treatment for mild, moderate and severe depression. Available at: http://www.beyondblue.org.au/resources/research/research-projects/research-projects/right-choice-right-time-supporting-young-people-to-make-evidence-based-preference-sensitive-decisions-about-treatment-for-mild-moderate-and-severe-depression. Accessed December 10, 2013.
86. Winnepeg Regional Health Authority. Child tracheostomy decision guide. Available at: http://www.wrha.mb.ca/extranet/eipt/files/EIPT-023-001.pdf. Accessed April 17, 2015.
87. A.M. O'Connor Validation of a decisional conflict scale Med Decis Making 15 1995 25 30
88. G. Elwyn, H. Hutchings, A. Edwards, and et al. The OPTION scale: measuring the extent that clinicians involve patients in decision-making tasks Health Expect 8 2005 34 42
89. M.A. McCabe Involving children and adolescents in medical decision making: developmental and clinical considerations J Pediatr Psychol 21 1996 505 516
90. S. Joffe Rethink "affirmative agreement," but abandon "assent" Am J Bioeth 3 2003 9 11
91. V.A. Miller, and D. Harris Measuring children's decision-making involvement regarding chronic illness management J Pediatr Psychol 37 2012 292 306
92. C.E. Beck, K.M. Boydell, E. Stasiulis, and et al. Shared decision making in the management of children with newly diagnosed immune thrombocytopenia J Pediatr Hematol Oncol 26 2014 26
93. Calkins C, Cosway B, Cochran N, et al. Fluid in middle ear. Available at: http://optiongrid.org/resources/fluidinear-grid.pdf. Accessed December 10, 2013.
94. F. Legare, M. Guerrier, C. Nadeau, and et al. Impact of DECISION+2 on patient and physician assessment of shared decision making implementation in the context of antibiotics use for acute respiratory infections Implement Sci 8 2013 144
95. H. Tapp, L. Kuhn, T. Alkhazraji, and et al. Adapting community based participatory research (CBPR) methods to the implementation of an asthma shared decision making intervention in ambulatory practices J Asthma 24 2014 24
96. A.G. Fiks, S. Mayne, D.J. Karavite, and et al. A shared e-decision support portal for pediatric asthma J Ambul Care Manage 37 2014 120 126
97. E.M. Dewitt, E.A. Lipstein, K. Staun, and et al. A178: development of tools to facilitate shared decision making about medications for juvenile idiopathic arthritis - a project of the Pediatric Rheumatology Care and Outcomes Improvement Network Arthritis Rheum 66 suppl 11 2014 S232 S233
98. E.M. Dewitt, K. Fricke, L. Bergheger, and et al. A147: engaging patients and families in the pediatric rheumatology care and outcomes improvement network Arthritis Rheum 66 suppl 11 2014 S190
99. E. Shirley, C. Bejarano, C. Clay, and et al. Helping families make difficult choices: creation and implementation of a decision aid for neuromuscular scoliosis surgery J Pediatr Orthop 2014 Dec 30 [Epub ahead of print]
100. N. Joseph-Williams, R. Newcombe, M. Politi, and et al. Toward minimum standards for certifying patient decision aids: a modified delphi consensus process Med Decis Making 20 2013 20
101. M.A. Adams, G.J. Norman, M.F. Hovell, and et al. Reconceptualizing decisional balance in an adolescent sun protection intervention: mediating effects and theoretical interpretations Health Psychol 28 2009 217 225
102. P.J. Hollen, W.L. Hobbie, and S.M. Finley Testing the effects of a decision-making and risk-reduction program for cancer-surviving adolescents Oncol Nurs Forum 26 1999 1475 1486
103. H.S. Adelman, V.M. MacDonald, P. Nelson, and et al. Motivational readiness and the participation of children with learning and behavior problems in psychoeducational decision making J Learn Disabil 23 1990 171 176
104. H. Rhee, P.J. Hollen, M.J. Belyea, and et al. Decision-making program for rural adolescents with asthma: a pilot study J Pediatr Nurs 23 2008 439 450
105. B. Feenstra, L. Boland, M.L. Lawson, and et al. Interventions to support children's engagement in health-related decisions: a systematic review BMC Pediatr 14 2014 109
106. G. Elwyn, D. Frosch, and S. Rollnick Dual equipoise shared decision making: definitions for decision and behaviour support interventions Implement Sci 4 2009 75
107. B. Freedman Equipoise and the ethics of clinical research N Engl J Med 317 1987 141 145
108. F. Legare, M.C. Politi, R. Drolet, and et al. Training health professionals in shared decision-making: an international environmental scan Patient Educ Couns 88 2012 159 169