Attention bias modification for social anxiety: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Clinical Psychology Review

Volumn 40, Issue , 2015, Pages 76-90

  Heeren, Alexandre ^a   Mogoase, Cristina ^b   Philippot, Pierre ^a   McNally, Richard J ^c  

^a UNIVERSITÉ CATHOLIQUE DE LOUVAIN   (Belgium)

^b BABE BOLYAI UNIVERSITY   (Romania)

^c HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Attention bias modification; Attentional bias; Cognitive bias modification; Meta analysis; Social anxiety disorder; Speech performance; Systematic review

Indexed keywords

ATTENTIONAL BIAS; CLINICAL ASSESSMENT; DATA BASE; EFFECT SIZE; FOLLOW UP; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS; PUBLISHING; QUALITY CONTROL; QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); REVIEW; RISK FACTOR; SOCIAL PHOBIA; SPEECH ANALYSIS; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; THREAT; ADULT; ATTENTION; COGNITIVE THERAPY; FEMALE; MALE; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PHOBIC DISORDERS; PHYSIOLOGY; PROCEDURES; STATISTICS AND NUMERICAL DATA; YOUNG ADULT;

ADULT; ATTENTION; COGNITIVE THERAPY; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT (HEALTH CARE); PHOBIC DISORDERS; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC; YOUNG ADULT;

EID: 84931291800     PISSN: 02727358     EISSN: 18737811     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cpr.2015.06.001     Document Type: Review

References (99)

1. Neubauer K., von Auer M., Muray E., Petermann F., Helbig-Lang S., Gerlach A.L. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2013, 51(2):87-97.
2. Acarturk C., Cuijpers P., van Straten A., de Graaf R. Psychological treatment of social anxiety disorder: A meta-analysis. Psychological Medicine 2009, 39:241-254.
3. American Psychiatric Association Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders 2000, Author, Washington, DC, (text rev.). 4th ed.
4. Amir N., Beard C., Taylor C.T., Klumpp H., Elias J., Burns M., Chen X. Attention training in individuals with generalized social phobia: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 2009, 77:961-973.
5. Amir N., Taylor C.T., Donohue M.C. Predictors of response to an attention modification program in generalized social phobia. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 2011, 79:533-541.
6. Amir N., Weber G., Beard C., Bomyea J., Taylor C.T. The effects of a single-session attention modification program on response to a public-speaking challenge in socially anxious individuals. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 2008, 117:860-868.
7. Bagshaw S.M., McAlister F.A., Manns B.J., Ghali W.A. Acetylcysteine in the prevention of contrast-induced nephropathy: A case study of the pitfalls in the evolution of evidence. Archives of Internal Medicine 2006, 166:161-166.
8. Bar-Haim Y., Lamy D., Pergamin L., Bakermans-Kranenburg L., van IJzendoorn M.H. Threat-related attentional bias in anxious and non-anxious individuals: A meta-analytic study. Psychological Bulletin 2007, 133:1-24.
9. Beard C., Sawyer A.T., Hofmann S.G. Efficacy of attention bias modification using threat and appetitive stimuli: A meta-analytic review. Behavior Therapy 2012, 43:724-740.
10. Beard C., Weisberg R.B., Primack J. Socially anxious primary care patients' attitudes toward cognitive bias modification (CBM): A qualitative study. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy 2012, 40:618-633.
11. Benjamini Y., Hochberg Y. Controlling the false discovery rate: A practical and powerful approach to multiple testing. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society 1995, 57:289-300.
12. Berger T., Boettcher J., Caspar F. Internet-based guided self-help for several anxiety disorders: A randomized controlled trial comparing a tailored with a standardized disorder-specific approach. Psychotherapy 2014, 51:207-219.
13. Bernstein A., Zvielli A. Attention feedback awareness and control training (A-Fact): Experimental test of a novel intervention paradigm targeting attentional bias. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2014, 55:18-26.
14. Bishop S.J. Trait anxiety and impoverished prefrontal control of attention. Nature Neuroscience 2009, 12:92-98.
15. Blanco C., Schneier F.R., Schmidt A., Blanco-Jerez C.-R., Marshall R.D., Sanchez-Lacay A., Liebowitz M.R. Pharmacological treatment of social anxiety disorder: A meta-analysis. Depression & Anxiety 2003, 18:29-40.
16. Boettcher J., Berger T., Renneberg B. Internet-based attention training for social anxiety: A randomized controlled trial. Cognitive Therapy and Research 2012, 36:1-15.
17. Boettcher J., Leek L., Matson L., Holmes E.A., Browning M., MacLeod C., Andersson G., Carlbring P. Internet-based attention bias modification for social anxiety: A randomized controlled comparison of towards negative and training towards positive cues. PLoS ONE 2013, 8:e71760. 10.1371/journal.pone.0071760.
18. Borenstein M., Hedges L.V., Higgins J.P.T., Rothstein H.R. Introduction to meta-analysis 2009, John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
19. Browning M., Holmes E.A., Murphy S.E., Goodwin G.M., Harmer C.J. Lateral prefrontal cortex mediates the cognitive modification of attentional bias. Biological Psychiatry 2010, 67:919-925.
20. Brühl A.B., Delsignore A., Komossa K., Weidt S. Neuroimaging in social anxiety disorder: A meta-analytic review resulting in a new neurofunctional model. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews 2014, 47:260-280.
21. Bunnell B.E., Beidel D.C., Mesa F. A randomized trial of attention training for Generalized Social Phobia: Does attention training change social behavior?. Behavior Therapy 2013, 44:662-673.
22. Carlbring P., Apelstrand M., Sehlin H., Amir N., Rousseau A., Hofmann S.G., Andersson G. Internet-delivered attention bias modification training in individuals with social anxiety disorder - A double blind randomized controlled trial. BMC Psychiatry 2012, 12:66. 10.1186/1471-244X-12-66.
23. Clarke P.J.F., Browning M., Hammond G., Notebaert L., MacLeod C. The causal role of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in the modification of attentional bias: Evidence from transcranial direct current stimulation. Biological Psychiatry 2014, 76:946-952.
24. Clarke P.J.F., Notebaert L., MacLeod C. Absence of evidence or evidence of absence: Reflecting on therapeutic implementations of attentional bias modification. BMC Psychiatry 2014, 14:8. 10.1186/1471-244X-14-8.
25. Cohen J. Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences 1988, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ. 2nd ed.
26. Cooper H., Hedges L.V., Valentine J.C. The handbook of research synthesis and meta-analysis 2009, Russell Sage Foundation, New York, NY. 2nd ed.
27. Cristea I.A., Kok R.N., Cuijpers P. The efficacy of cognitive bias modification interventions in anxiety and depression: A meta-analysis. British Journal of Psychiatry 2015, 206:7-16.
28. Cuijpers P., van Straten A., Bolhmeijer E., Hollon S.D., Andersson G. The effect of psychotherapy for adult depression are overestimated: A meta-analysis of study quality and effect size. Psychological Medicine 2010, 40:211-223.
29. De Voogt E.L., Wiers R.W., Prins P.J.M., Salemink E. Visual search attentional bias modification reduces social phobia in adolescents. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 2014, 45:252-259.
30. Dear B.F., Sharpe L., Nicholas M.K., Refshauge K. The psychometric properties of the dot-probe paradigm when used in pain-related attentional bias research. Journal of Pain 2011, 12:1247-1254.
31. Dennis T.A., O'Toole L.J. Mental health on the go: Effects of a gamified attention-bias modification mobile application in trait-anxious. Clinical Psychological Science 2014, 25:576-590.
32. Duval S., Tweedies R. Trim and fill: A simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis. Biometrics 2000, 56:455-463.
33. Egger M., Davey Smith G., Schneider M., Minder C. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. British Medical Journal 1997, 315:629-634.
34. Emmelkamp P.M.G. Attention bias modification: The Emperor's new suit?. BMC Medicine 2012, 10:63.
35. Enock, P. M. (2015). Making an IMPACT: Designing and testing a novel attentional training game to reduce social anxiety. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Department of Psychology, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA.
36. Enock P.M., Hofmann S.G., McNally R.J. Attention bias modification treatment via smartphone to reduce social anxiety: A randomized controlled trial. Cognitive Therapy and Research 2014, 38:200-216.
37. Fanelli D. Do pressures to publish increase scientists' bias? An empirical support from US States Data. PLoS ONE 2010, 5(4):e10271. 10.1371/journal.pone.0010271.
38. Fang F.C., Steen R.G., Casadevall A.C. Misconduct accounts for the majority of retracted scientific publications. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2012, 109:17028-17033.
39. Ferguson D., Aaron S.D., Guyatt G., Herbert P. Post-randomisation exclusions: The intention to treat principle and excluding patients from analysis. British Medical Journal 2002, 325:652-654.
40. Gilboa-Schechtman E., Shachar-Lavie I. More than a face: A unified theoretical perspective on nonverbal social cue processing in social anxiety. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 2013, 7:904. 10.3389/fnhum.2013.00904.
41. Grafton B., Mackintosh B., Vujic T., MacLeod C. When ignorance is bliss: Explicit instructions and the efficacy of CBM-A for anxiety. Cognitive Therapy and Research 2014, 38:172-188.
42. Gunter R.W., Whittal M.L. Disseminations of cognitive-behavioral treatments for anxiety disorders: Overcoming barriers and improving patients access. Clinical Psychology Review 2010, 30:194-202.
43. Hakamata Y., Lissek S., Bar-Haim Y., Britton J.C., Fox N.A., Leibenluft E., Ernst M., Pine D.S. Attention bias modification treatment: A meta-analysis toward the establishment of novel treatment for anxiety. Biological Psychiatry 2010, 68:982-990.
44. Haller S.P.W., Cohen Kadosh K., Lau J.Y.F. A developmental angle to understanding the mechanisms of biased cognitions in social anxiety. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 2014, 7:846. 10.3389/fnhum.2013.00846.
45. Hallion L.S., Ruscio A.M. A meta-analysis of the effect of cognitive bias modification on anxiety and depression. Psychological Bulletin 2011, 137:940-958.
46. Hedges L.V., Olkin I. Statistical methods for meta-analysis 1985, Academic Press, Orlando, FL.
47. Heeren A., Baeken C., Vanderhasselt M.-A., Philippot P., De Raedt R. Impact of anodal and cathodal transcranial direct current stimulation over the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex during attention bias modification: An eye-tracking study. PLoS ONE 2015, 10(4):e0124182. 10.1371/journal.pone.0124182.
48. Heeren A., Lievens L., Philippot P. How does attention training work in social phobia: Disengagement from threat or reengagement to nonthreat?. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 2011, 25:1108-1115.
49. Heeren A., Maurage P., Philippot P. A Bayesian case-controls exploration of the malleability of attentional bias for threat in social phobia. International Journal of Cognitive Therapy 2013, 6:24-39.
50. Heeren A., Peschard V., Philippot P. The causal role of attentional bias to threat cues in social anxiety: A test on a cyber-ostracism task. Cognitive Therapy and Research 2012, 36:512-521.
51. Heeren A., Philippot P., Koster E.H.W. Impact of the temporal stability of preexistent attentional bias for threat on its alteration through attention bias modification. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 2015, (in press). 10.1016/j.jbtep.2014.10.012.
52. Heeren A., Reese H.E., McNally R.J., Philippot P. Attention training toward and away from treat in social phobia: Effects on behavioural, subjective, and physiological measures of anxiety. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2012, 50:30-39.
53. Clark D.M., Wells A. A cognitive model of social phobia. Social Phobia: Diagnosis, assessment, and treatment 1995, 69-93. Guilford Press, New York. R.G. Heimberg, M.R. Liebowitz, D.A. Hope, F.R. Schneier (Eds.).
54. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011]. The Cochrane Collaboration 2011, (Available from www.cochrane-handbook.org). J.P. Higgins, S. Green (Eds.).
55. Higgins J.P., Thompson S.G., Deeks J.J., Altman D.G. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. British Medical Journal 2003, 327:557-560.
56. Hirsch C.R., Clark D.M. Information-processing bias in social phobia. Clinical Psychology Review 2004, 24:799-825.
57. Ioannidis J.P.A. Effect of the statistical significance of results on the time to completion and publication of randomized efficacy trials. The Journal of the American Medical Association 1998, 279:281-286.
58. Ioannidis J.P.A. Why most discovered true associations are inflated. Epidemiology 2008, 19:640-648.
59. Jennions M.D., Moeller A.P. Relationships fade with time: A meta-analysis of temporam trends in publication in ecology and evolution. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2002, 269:43-48.
60. Jones C.R., Fazio R.H., Vasey M.W. Attentional control buffers the effect of public-speaking anxiety on performance. Social Psychological and Personality Science 2012, 3:556-561.
61. Julian K., Beard C., Schmidt N.B., Powers M.B., Smits J.A.J. Attention training to reduce attention bias and social stressor reactivity: An attempt to replicate and extend previous findings. Behaviour Research & Therapy 2012, 50:350-358.
62. Kjaergard L.L., Villumsen J., Gluud C. Reported methodologic quality and discrepancies between large and small randomized trials in meta-analyses. Annals of Internal Medicine 2001, 136:982-989.
63. Klumpp H., Amir N. Preliminary study of attention training to threat and neutral faces on anxious reactivity to a social stressor in social anxiety. Cognitive Therapy and Research 2010, 34:263-271.
64. Krimbel A. A model of the development and maintenance of generalized social phobia. Clinical Psychological Review 2008, 28:592-612.
65. Kuckertz J.M., Gildebrant E., Liliequist B., Karström P., Väppling C., Bodlund O., Stenlund T., Hoffman S.G., Andersson G., Amir N., Carlbring P. Moderation and mediation of the effect of attention training in social anxiety disorder. Behaviour Research & Therapy 2014, 53:30-40.
66. Li S.W., Tan J.Q., Qian M.Y., Liu X.H. Continual training of attentional bias in social anxiety. Behaviour Research & Therapy 2008, 46:905-912.
67. Liberati A., Altman D.G., Tetzlaff J., Mulrow C., Gotzche P.C., Ioannidis J.P.A., Clarke M., Devereaux P.J., Kleijnen J., Moher D. The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: Explanation and elaboration. PLoS Medicine 2009, 6:e1000100. 10.1371/journal.pmed.1000100.
68. Liebowitz M.R. Social phobia. Modern Problems of Pharmacopsychiatry 1987, 22:141-173.
69. Light R.J., Pillemer D.B. Summing up: The science of reviewing research 1984, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
70. Lipsey M.W., Wilson D.B. Practical meta-analysis 2001, Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA.
71. Lovell K., Richards D. Multiple access points and levels of entry (MAPLE): Ensuring choice, accessibility and equity of CBT services. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy 2000, 28:379-391.
72. MacLeod C., Clarke P.J.F. The attentional bias modification approach to anxiety intervention. Clinical Psychological Science 2015, 3:58-78.
73. MacLeod C., Mathews A. Cognitive bias modification approaches to anxiety. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology 2012, 8:189-217.
74. MacLeod C., Mathews A., Tata P. Attentional bias in emotional disorders. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 1986, 95:15-20.
75. MacLeod C., Rutherford E., Campbell L., Ebsworthy G., Holker L. Selective attention and emotional vulnerability: Assessing the causal basis of their association through the experimental manipulation of attentional bias. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 2002, 111:107-123.
76. Maurage P., Heeren A., Pesenti M. Does chocolate consumption really boost Nobel award chances? The peril of over-interpreting correlations in nutrition and health studies. The Journal of Nutrition 2013, 143:931-933.
77. McNally R.J., Enock P.M., Tsai C., Tousian M. Attention bias modification for reducing speech anxiety. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2013, 51:882-888.
78. Mogoase C., David D., Koster E.H.W. Clinical efficacy of attentional bias procedures: An updated meta-analysis. Journal of Clinical Psychology 2014, 70:1133-1157.
79. Moher D., Liberati A., Tetzlaff J., Altman D.G., the PRISMA Group Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. PLoS Medicine 2009, 6:e1000097. 10.1371/journal.pmed.1000097.
80. Moher D., Pham B., Jones A., Cook D.J., Jadad A.R., Moher M., Tugwell P., Klassen T.P. Does quality of reports of randomized trials affect estimated of intervention efficacy reported in meta-analyses. The Lancet 1998, 352:609-613.
81. Morrison A.S., Heimberg R.G. Social anxiety and social anxiety disorder. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology 2013, 9:249-274.
82. Notebaert L., Clarke P.J.F., Grafton B., MacLeod C. Validation of a novel attention bias modification task: The future may be in the cards. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2015, 65:93-100.
83. Olfson M., Guardino M., Struening E., Schneier F.R., Hellman F., Klein D.F. Barriers to the treatment of social anxiety. American Journal of Psychiatry 2000, 157:521-527.
84. Pacheco-Unguetti A.P., Acosta A., Callejas A., Lupiáñez J. Attention and anxiety: Different attentional functioning under state and trait anxiety. Psychological Science 2010, 21:298-304.
85. Price R.B., Kuckertz J.M., Siegle G., Ladouceur C., Silk J.S., Ryan N.D., Dahl R.E., Amir N. Empirical recommendations for improving the stability of the dot-probe task in clinical research. Psychological Assessment 2015, 27:365-376.
86. Rapee R.M., Heimberg R.G. A cognitive-behavioral model of anxiety in social phobia. Behaviour Research and Therapy 1997, 35:741-756.
87. Rapee R.M., MacLeod C., Carpenter L., Gaston J.E., Frei J., Peters L., Baillie A.J. Integrating cognitive bias modification into a standard cognitive behavioural treatment package for social phobia: A randomized controlled trial. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2013, 51:207-215.
88. Riley R.D., Higgins J.P.T., Deeks J.J. Interpretation of random effects meta-analyses. British Medical Journal 2011, 342:d549.
89. Schmidt N.B., Richey J.A., Buckner J.D., Timpano K.R. Attention training for generalized social anxiety disorder. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 2009, 118:5-14.
90. Schmukle S.C. Unreliability of the dot-probe task. European Journal of Personality 2005, 19:595-605.
91. Staugaard S.R. Reliability of two versions of the dot-probe task using photographic faces. Psychology Science 2009, 51:339-350.
92. Stein M.B., Stein D.J. Social anxiety disorder. The Lancet 2008, 371:1115-1125.
93. Sterne J.A.C., Becker B.J., Egger M. The funnel plot. Publication bias in meta-analysis: Prevention, assessment, and adjustments 2005, 75-98. John Willey & Sons, Ltd., Chichester. H.R. Rothstein, A.J. Sutton, M. Borenstein (Eds.).
94. Van Bockstaele B., Verschuere B., Tibboel H., De Houwer J., Crombez G., Koster E.H.W. A review of current evidence for the causal impact of attentional bias on fear and anxiety. Psychological Bulletin 2014, 140:682-721.
95. Waechter S., Nelson A.L., Wright C., Hyatt A., Oakman J. Measuring attentional bias to threat: Reliability of dot probe and eye movement indices. Cognitive Therapy and Research 2014, 38:313-333.
96. Weisberg R.B., Dyck I., Culpepper L., Keller M.B. Psychiatric treatment in primary care patients with anxiety disorders: A comparison of care received from primary care providers and psychiatrists. American Journal of Psychiatry 2007, 164:276-282.
97. Wood L., Egger M., Gluud L.L., Schulz K.F., Jüni P., Altman D.G., Gluud C., Martin R.M., Wood A.J., Sterne J.A. Empirical evidence of bias in treatment effect estimates in controlled trials with different interventions and outcomes: Meta-epidemiological study. British Medical Journal 2008, 336:601-605.
98. Yordanov Y., Dechartres A., Porcher R., Boutron I., Altman D.G., Ravaud P. Avoidable waste of research related to inadequate methods in clinical trials. BMJ 2015, 350:h809. 10.1136/bmj.h809.
99. Zvielli A., Bernstein A., Koster E.H.W. Temporal dynamics of attentional bias. Clinical Psychological Science 2015, (in press).