An official ATS/AACN/ACCP/ESICM/SCCM policy statement: Responding to requests for potentially inappropriate treatments in intensive care units

American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine

Volumn 191, Issue 11, 2015, Pages 1318-1330

  Bosslet, Gabriel T ^a   Pope, Thaddeus M ^b   Rubenfeld, Gordon D ^b   Lo, Bernard ^b   Truog, Robert D ^b   Rushton, Cynda H ^b   Curtis, J Randall ^b   Ford, Dee W ^b   Osborne, Molly ^b   Misak, Cheryl ^b   Au, David H ^b   Azoulay, Elie ^b   Brody, Baruch ^b   Fahy, Brenda G ^b   Hall, Jesse B ^b   Kesecioglu, Jozef ^b   Kon, Alexander A ^b   Lindell, Kathleen O ^b   White, Douglas B ^b  

^a INDIANA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^b NONE

Author keywords

Conflict resolution; End of life care; Ethics committees; Futility; Shared decision making

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CONSULTATION; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HUMAN; INTENSIVE CARE UNIT; INTERPERSONAL COMMUNICATION; MEDICAL PRACTICE; MEDICAL PROFESSION; MEDICAL SOCIETY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROFESSIONALISM; INTENSIVE CARE; PRACTICE GUIDELINE; STANDARDS; UNNECESSARY PROCEDURE;

HUMANS; INTENSIVE CARE; INTENSIVE CARE UNITS; SOCIETIES, MEDICAL; UNNECESSARY PROCEDURES;

EID: 84930470895     PISSN: 1073449X     EISSN: 15354970     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1164/rccm.201505-0924ST     Document Type: Article

References (83)

1. Piers RD, Azoulay E, Ricou B, Dekeyser Ganz F, Decruyenaere J, Max A, Michalsen A, Maia PA, Owczuk R, Rubulotta F, et al.; APPROPRICUS Study Group of the Ethics Section of the ESICM. Perceptions of appropriateness of care among European and Israeli intensive care unit nurses and physicians. JAMA 2011;306:2694-2703.
2. Huynh TN, Kleerup EC, Wiley JF, Savitsky TD, Guse D, Garber BJ, Wenger NS. The frequency and cost of treatment perceived to be futile in critical care. JAMA Intern Med 2013;173:1887-1894.
3. Prendergast TJ. Resolving conflicts surrounding end-of-life care. New Horiz 1997;5:62-71.
4. Garros D, Rosychuk RJ, Cox PN. Circumstances surrounding end of life in a pediatric intensive care unit. Pediatrics 2003;112:e371.
5. Fine RL, Mayo TW. Resolution of futility by due process: early experience with the Texas Advance Directives Act. Ann Intern Med 2003;138:743-746.
6. Medical futility in end-of-life care: report of the Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs. JAMA 1999;281:937-941.
7. Consensus statement of the Society of Critical Care Medicine's Ethics Committee regarding futile and other possibly inadvisable treatments. Crit Care Med 1997;25:887-891.
8. American Thoracic Society. Withholding and withdrawing life-sustaining therapy. Ann Intern Med 1991;115:478-485.
9. Rubin SB. If we think it's futile, can't we just say no? HEC Forum 2007; 19:45-65.
10. American Medical Association. Opinion 10.01-Fundamental elements of the patient-physician relationship. 2014 [accessed 2014 Apr 22]. Available from: http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/physician-resources/medical-ethics/code-medical-ethics/opinion1001.page?
11. Norton SA, Hogan LA, Holloway RG, Temkin-Greener H, Buckley MJ, Quill TE. Proactive palliative care in the medical intensive care unit: effects on length of stay for selected high-risk patients. Crit Care Med 2007;35:1530-1535.
12. Stapleton RD, Engelberg RA, Wenrich MD, Goss CH, Curtis JR. Clinician statements and family satisfaction with family conferences in the intensive care unit. Crit Care Med 2006;34:1679-1685.
13. Selph RB, Shiang J, Engelberg R, Curtis JR, White DB. Empathy and life support decisions in intensive care units. J Gen Intern Med 2008; 23:1311-1317.
14. Schneiderman LJ, Gilmer T, Teetzel HD, Dugan DO, Blustein J, Cranford R, Briggs KB, Komatsu GI, Goodman-Crews P, Cohn F, et al. Effect of ethics consultations on nonbeneficial life-sustaining treatments in the intensive care setting: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA 2003;290:1166-1172.
15. Curtis JR, Vincent J-L. Ethics and end-of-life care for adults in the intensive care unit. Lancet 2010;376:1347-1353.
16. Curtis JR, White DB. Practical guidance for evidence-based ICU family conferences. Chest 2008;134:835-843.
17. Thompson BT, Cox PN, Antonelli M, Carlet JM, Cassell J, Hill NS, Hinds CJ, Pimentel JM, Reinhart K, Thijs LG; American Thoracic Society; European Respiratory Society; European Society of Intensive Care Medicine; Society of Critical Care Medicine; Sociètède Rèanimation de Langue Française. Challenges in end-oflife care in the ICU. Statement of the 5th International Consensus Conference in Critical Care: Brussels, Belgium, April 2003: executive summary. Crit Care Med 2004;32:1781-1784.
18. Evans LR, Boyd EA, Malvar G, Apatira L, Luce JM, Lo B, White DB. Surrogate decision-makers' perspectives on discussing prognosis in the face of uncertainty. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2009;179: 48-53.
19. Heyland DK, Tranmer J, O'Callaghan CJ, Gafni A. The seriously ill hospitalized patient: preferred role in end-of-life decision making? J Crit Care 2003;18:3-10.
20. Azoulay E, Chevret S, Leleu G, Pochard F, Barboteu M, Adrie C, Canoui P, Le Gall JR, Schlemmer B. Half the families of intensive care unit patients experience inadequate communication with physicians. Crit Care Med 2000;28:3044-3049.
21. Azoulay E, Pochard F, Chevret S, Adrie C, Annane D, Bleichner G, Bornstain C, Bouffard Y, Cohen Y, Feissel M, et al.; FAMIREA Study Group. Half the family members of intensive care unit patients do not want to share in the decision-making process: a study in 78 French intensive care units. Crit Care Med 2004;32:1832-1838.
22. White DB, Evans LR, Bautista CA, Luce JM, Lo B. Are physicians' recommendations to limit life support beneficial or burdensome? Bringing empirical data to the debate. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2009;180:320-325.
23. Rushton CH. Principled moral outrage: an antidote to moral distress? AACN Adv Crit Care 2013;24:82-89.
24. American Society for Bioethics and Humanities. Core competencies for health care ethics consultation, 2nd ed. Glenview, IL: American Society for Bioethics and Humanities; 2011.
25. Schenker Y, Crowley-Matoka M, Dohan D, Tiver GA, Arnold RM, White DB. I don't want to be the one saying 'we should just let him die': intrapersonal tensions experienced by surrogate decision makers in the ICU. J Gen Intern Med 2012;27:1657-1665.
26. Jezewski MA. Do-not-resuscitate status: conflict and culture brokering in critical care units. Heart Lung 1994;23:458-465.
27. White DB, Pope TM. The courts, futility, and the ends of medicine. JAMA 2012;307:151-152.
28. Sprung CL, Cohen SL, Sjokvist P, Baras M, Bulow HH, Hovilehto S, Ledoux D, Lippert A, Maia P, Phelan D, et al.; Ethicus Study Group. End-of-life practices in European intensive care units: the Ethicus Study. JAMA 2003;290:790-797.
29. Wunsch H, Harrison DA, Harvey S, Rowan K. End-of-life decisions: a cohort study of the withdrawal of all active treatment in intensive care units in the United Kingdom. Intensive Care Med 2005;31:823-831.
30. Garland A, Connors AF. Physicians' influence over decisions to forego life support. J Palliat Med 2007;10:1298-1305.
31. Curtis JR, Park DR, Krone MR, Pearlman RA. Use of the medical futility rationale in do-not-attempt-resuscitation orders. JAMA 1995;273: 124-128.
32. Cook DJ, Guyatt GH, Jaeschke R, Reeve J, Spanier A, King D, Molloy DW, Willan A, Streiner DL; Canadian Critical Care Trials Group. Determinants in Canadian health care workers of the decision to withdraw life support from the critically ill. JAMA 1995;273:703-708.
33. Gramelspacher GP, Zhou XH, Hanna MP, Tierney WM. Preferences of physicians and their patients for end-of-life care. J Gen Intern Med 1997;12:346-351.
34. O'Donnell H, Phillips RS, Wenger N, Teno J, Davis RB, Hamel MB. Preferences for cardiopulmonary resuscitation among patients 80 years or older: the views of patients and their physicians. J Am Med Dir Assoc 2003;4:139-144.
35. Steinhauser KE, Christakis NA, Clipp EC, McNeilly M, McIntyre L, Tulsky JA. Factors considered important at the end of life by patients, family, physicians, and other care providers. JAMA 2000; 284:2476-2482.
36. Emanuel EJ. A communal vision of care for incompetent patients. Hastings Cent Rep 1987;17:15-20.
37. Misak CJ, White DB, Truog RD. Medical futility: a new look at an old problem. Chest 2014;146:1667-1672.
38. Daniels N. Accountability for reasonableness. BMJ 2000;321:1300-1301.
39. Daniels N, Sabin J. Limits to health care: fair procedures, democratic deliberation, and the legitimacy problem for insurers. Philos Public Aff 1997;26:303-350.
40. Hampshire S. 'Justice Is Conflict.' New York Rev Books 2000;47:80.
41. Spielman B. Collective decisions about medical futility. J Law Med Ethics 1994;22:152-160. [Discussion pp. 161-162.]
42. Emanuel EJ. The ends of human life: medical ethics in a liberal polity. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press; 1991.
43. Gutmann A. Why deliberative democracy? Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 2004.
44. Pope TM. Dispute resolution mechanisms for intractable medical futility disputes. NY Law Sch Law Rev 2013;58:347-368.
45. American Academy of Pediatrics. Committee on Bioethics. Institutional ethics committees. Committee on Bioethics. Pediatrics 2001;107: 205-209.
46. Burns JP, Truog RD. Futility: a concept in evolution. Chest 2007;132: 1987-1993.
47. Pope T. Multi-institutional healthcare ethics committees: the procedurally fair internal dispute resolution mechanism. Campbell Law Rev 2009;31:257-332.
48. Mobley MJ, Rady MY, Verheijde JL, Patel B, Larson JS. The relationship between moral distress and perception of futile care in the critical care unit. Intensive Crit Care Nurs 2007;23: 256-263.
49. American Association of Critical-Care Nurses. AACN standards for establishing and sustaining healthy work environments: a journey to excellence. Am J Crit Care 2005;14:187-197.
50. Sibbald RW, Chidwick P. Best interests at end of life: a review of decisions made by the Consent and Capacity Board of Ontario. J Crit Care 2010;25:171.e1-7.
51. Schneiderman LJ, Jecker NS, Jonsen AR. Medical futility: its meaning and ethical implications. Ann Intern Med 1990;112:949-954.
52. American Medical Association Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs. Opinion 2.20-Withholding or withdrawing life-sustaining medical treatment. 1996 [accessed 2012 Jan 16]. Available from: http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/physician-resources/medical-ethics/codemedical-ethics/opinion220.page.
53. Veatch RM, Spicer CM. Futile care: physicians should not be allowed to refuse to treat. Point. Health Prog 1993;74:22-27.
54. American College of Physicians. How can our nation conserve and distribute health care resources effectively and efficiently? Philadelphia: American College of Physicians; 2011.
55. ABIM Foundation. American Board of Internal Medicine; ACP-ASIM Foundation. American College of Physicians-American Society of Internal Medicine; European Federation of Internal Medicine. Medical professionalism in the new millennium: a physician charter. Ann Intern Med 2002;136:243-246.
56. Ballard P. Summary of Maryland Health Care Decisions Act. 2014 [accessed 2015 May 4]. Available from: http://www.oag.state.md.us/Healthpol/HCDAsummary.pdf
57. Mason E. Value pluralism. In: Zalta E, editor. Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. 2011 [accessed 2015 May 7]. Available from: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/value-pluralism/
58. Howitt P, Darzi A, Yang GZ, Ashrafian H, Atun R, Barlow J, Blakemore A, Bull AM, Car J, Conteh L, et al. Technologies for global health. Lancet 2012;380:507-535.
59. Engelhardt HT Jr. Critical care: why there is no global bioethics. J Med Philos 1998;23:643-651.
60. Veatch RM. Generalization of expertise. Stud Hastings Cent 1973;1: 29-40.
61. Baum NM, Jacobson PD, Goold SD. "Listen to the people": public deliberation about social distancing measures in a pandemic. Am J Bioeth 2009;9:4-14.
62. Goold SD, Biddle AK, Klipp G, Hall CN, Danis M. Choosing Healthplans All Together: a deliberative exercise for allocating limited health care resources. J Health Polit Policy Law 2005;30:563-601.
63. Lilly CM, De Meo DL, Sonna LA, Haley KJ, Massaro AF, Wallace RF, Cody S. An intensive communication intervention for the critically ill. Am J Med 2000;109:469-475.
64. Lilly CM, Sonna LA, Haley KJ, Massaro AF. Intensive communication: four-year follow-up from a clinical practice study. Crit Care Med 2003;31:S394-S399.
65. Daly BJ, Douglas SL, O'Toole E, Gordon NH, Hejal R, Peerless J, Rowbottom J, Garland A, Lilly C, Wiencek C, et al. Effectiveness trial of an intensive communication structure for families of long-stay ICU patients. Chest 2010;138:1340-1348.
66. Scheunemann LP, McDevitt M, Carson S, Hanson LC. Randomized, controlled trials of interventions to improve communication in intensive care: a systematic review. Chest 2011;139:543-554.
67. Lautrette A, Darmon M, Megarbane B, Joly LM, Chevret S, Adrie C, Barnoud D, Bleichner G, Bruel C, Choukroun G, et al. A communication strategy and brochure for relatives of patients dying in the ICU. N Engl J Med 2007;356:469-478.
68. Davidson JE, Powers K, Hedayat KM, Tieszen M, Kon AA, Shepard E, Spuhler V, Todres ID, Levy M, Barr J, et al.; American College of Critical Care Medicine Task Force 2004-2005, Society of Critical Care Medicine. Clinical practice guidelines for support of the family in the patient-centered intensive care unit: American College of Critical Care Medicine Task Force 2004-2005. Crit Care Med 2007; 35:605-622.
69. Campbell ML, Guzman JA. Impact of a proactive approach to improve end-of-life care in a medical ICU. Chest 2003;123:266-271.
70. Campbell ML, Guzman JA. A proactive approach to improve end-of-life care in a medical intensive care unit for patients with terminal dementia. Crit Care Med 2004;32:1839-1843.
71. Kaufer M, Murphy P, Barker K, Mosenthal A. Family satisfaction following the death of a loved one in an inner city MICU. Am J Hosp Palliat Care 2008;25:318-325.
72. Azoulay E, Pochard F, Chevret S, Jourdain M, Bornstain C, Wernet A, Cattaneo I, Annane D, Brun F, Bollaert PE, et al. Impact of a family information leaflet on effectiveness of information provided to family members of intensive care unit patients: a multicenter, prospective, randomized, controlled trial. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2002;165: 438-442.
73. Peigne V, Chaize M, Falissard B, Kentish-Barnes N, Rusinova K, Megarbane B, Bele N, Cariou A, Fieux F, Garrouste-Orgeas M, et al. Important questions asked by family members of intensive care unit patients. Crit Care Med 2011;39:1365-1371.
74. Pochard F, Azoulay E, Chevret S, Lemaire F, Hubert P, Canoui P, Grassin M, Zittoun R, le Gall JR, Dhainaut JF, et al.; French FAMIREA Group. Symptoms of anxiety and depression in family members of intensive care unit patients: ethical hypothesis regarding decisionmaking capacity. Crit Care Med 2001;29:1893-1897.
75. West HF, Engelberg RA, Wenrich MD, Curtis JR. Expressions of nonabandonment during the intensive care unit family conference. J Palliat Med 2005;8:797-807.
76. Back AL, Arnold RM, Baile WF, Fryer-Edwards KA, Alexander SC, Barley GE, Gooley TA, Tulsky JA. Efficacy of communication skills training for giving bad news and discussing transitions to palliative care. Arch Intern Med 2007;167:453-460.
77. McDonagh JR, Elliott TB, Engelberg RA, Treece PD, Shannon SE, Rubenfeld GD, Patrick DL, Curtis JR. Family satisfaction with family conferences about end-of-life care in the intensive care unit: increased proportion of family speech is associated with increased satisfaction. Crit Care Med 2004;32:1484-1488.
78. Platt FW, Gaspar DL, Coulehan JL, Fox L, Adler AJ, Weston WW, Smith RC, Stewart M. "Tell me about yourself": the patient-centered interview. Ann Intern Med 2001;134:1079-1085.
79. Curtis JR, Engelberg RA, Wenrich MD, Shannon SE, Treece PD, Rubenfeld GD. Missed opportunities during family conferences about end-of-life care in the intensive care unit. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2005;171:844-849.
80. Quill TE, Arnold RM, Platt F. "I wish things were different": expressing wishes in response to loss, futility, and unrealistic hopes. Ann Intern Med 2001;135:551-555.
81. Gries CJ, Curtis JR, Wall RJ, Engelberg RA. Family member satisfaction with end-of-life decision making in the ICU. Chest 2008;133:704-712.
82. Carlet J, Thijs LG, Antonelli M, Cassell J, Cox P, Hill N, Hinds C, Pimentel JM, Reinhart K, Thompson BT. Challenges in end-of-life care in the ICU. Statement of the 5th International Consensus Conference in Critical Care: Brussels, Belgium, April 2003. Intensive Care Med 2004;30:770-784.
83. Scheunemann LP, Arnold RM, White DB. The facilitated values history: helping surrogates make authentic decisions for incapacitated patients with advanced illness. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2012;186: 480-486.