Health risk assessment of organic micropollutants in greywater for potable reuse

Water Research

Volumn 72, Issue , 2015, Pages 186-198

  Etchepare, Ramiro ^a,b   van der Hoek, Jan Peter ^c,d  

^a FEDERAL UNIVERSITY OF RIO GRANDE DO SUL   (Brazil)

^b MINISTRY OF EDUCATION OF BRAZIL   (Brazil)

^c DELFT UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY   (Netherlands)

^d Waternet   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Greywater; Organic micropollutants; Potable reuse; Risk assessment; Toxicological data

Indexed keywords

HEALTH; HEALTH RISKS; RISK ASSESSMENT; RISK PERCEPTION; WASTEWATER RECLAMATION; WATER; WATER CONSERVATION; WATER TREATMENT;

DRINKING WATER STANDARDS; GREYWATER; MAXIMUM CONCENTRATIONS; ORGANIC MICRO-POLLUTANTS; POTABLE REUSE; POTENTIAL HEALTH RISKS; TOXICOLOGICAL DATA; WATER RECLAMATION PLANTS;

POTABLE WATER;

1,3 DIOXOLANE; 2 ETHYLHEXANOL; 2 HEXANONE; 2,4 DICHLOROPHENOL; 2,4,6 TRICHLOROPHENOL; ACTIVATED CARBON; BENZENE; CAMPHOR; CARVONE; CHLOROFORM; CITRIC ACID; CITRONELLOL; COUMARIN; DICHLOROMETHANE; DRINKING WATER; ETHYL PARABEN; ETHYLBENZENE; EUGENOL; ISOEUGENOL; LINALOOL; MALATHION; MENTHOL; META CRESOL; METHYL PARABEN; NAPHTHALENE; NICOTINE; ORTHO CRESOL; PENTACHLOROPHENOL; PHENOL; PHTHALIC ACID DIETHYL ESTER; ORGANIC COMPOUND; WASTE WATER; WATER POLLUTANT;

CONCENTRATION (COMPOSITION); HEALTH RISK; ORGANIC POLLUTANT; RISK ASSESSMENT; WASTEWATER; WATER CHEMISTRY; WATER POLLUTION; WATER QUALITY; WATER USE;

ADSORPTION; ARTICLE; BIOCHEMICAL OXYGEN DEMAND; CHEMICAL OXYGEN DEMAND; GENOTOXICITY; HEALTH HAZARD; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RISK ASSESSMENT; WASTE WATER MANAGEMENT; WATER POLLUTANT; WATER QUALITY; WATER SUPPLY; ANALYSIS; CHEMISTRY; HEALTH; RECYCLING; WASTE WATER;

DRINKING WATER; HEALTH; ORGANIC CHEMICALS; RECYCLING; RISK ASSESSMENT; WASTE WATER; WATER POLLUTANTS, CHEMICAL;

EID: 84926378831     PISSN: 00431354     EISSN: 18792448     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.watres.2014.10.048     Document Type: Article

References (83)

1. Ahel M., Giger W. Partitioning of alkylphenols and alkylphenol polyethoxylates between water and organic solvents. Chemosphere 1993, 26(8):1471-1478.
2. Alfiya Y., Gross A., Sklarz M., Friedler E. Reliability of on-site greywater treatment systems in Mediterranean and arid environments - a case study. Water Sci. Technol. 2013, 67(6):1389-1395.
3. Andersen H.R., Lunsbye M., Wedel H.V., Eriksson E., Ledin A. Estogenic personal care products in a greywater reuse system. Water Sci. Technol. 2007, 56(12):45-49.
4. Andersson M., Dalsgaard A. Demonstrationsprojekt med genanvendelse af gra° t spildevand fra en større gra°vandsproducent Økologisk byfornyelse og spildevandrensning Nr. 46 2004, (In Danish). Accessed April 2014. http://www2.mst.dk/Udgiv/publikationer/2004/87-7614-149-7/html/default.htm.
5. Barker S.F., O'Toole J., Sinclair M.I., Leder K., Malawaraarachchi M., Hamilton A.J. A probabilistic model of norovirus disease burden associated with greywater irrigation of home produced lettuce in Melbourne, Australia. Water Res. 2013, 47:1421-1432.
6. Boyjoo Y., Pareek V.K., Ang M. A review of greywater characteristics and treatment processes. Water Sci. Technol. 2013, 67(7):1403-1424.
7. Burrows W.D., Schmidt M.O., Carnevale R.M., Schaub S.A. Nonpotable reuse: development of health criteria and technologies for shower water recycle. Water Sci. Technol. 1991, 24(9):81-88.
8. Cramer G.M., Ford R.A., Hall R.L. Estimation of toxic hazard - a decision tree approach. Food Cosmet. Toxicol. 1978, 16:255-276.
9. Cook S., Tjandraatmadja G., Ho A., Sharma A. Definition of Decentralised Systems in the South East Queensland Context 2009, CSIRO: Water for a Healthy Country National Research Flagship. Urban Water Security Research Alliance, Technical Report No. 12. Available from:, (accessed in July 2014). http://www.urbanwateralliance.org.au/publications.html.
10. Daston G.P., Gooch J.W., Breslin W.J., Shuey D.L., Nikiforov A.I., Fico T.A. Environmental estrogens and reproductive health: a discussion of human and environmental data. Reprod. Toxicol. 2004, 11:465-481.
11. Daughton C.G., Ternes T.A. Pharmaceuticals and personal care products in the environment: agents of subtle change?. Environ. Health Perspect. 1999, 107(6):907-938.
12. Deblonde T., Cossu-Leguille C., Hartemann P. Emerging pollutants in wastewater: a review of the literature. Int. J. Hyg. Environ. Health 2011, 214:442-448.
13. Dixon A., Butler D., Fewkes A. Guidelines for greywater re-use: health issues. Water Environ. J. 1999, 13:322-326.
14. Donner E., Eriksson E., Revitt D.M., Scholes L., Holten-Lutzhof H.C., Ledin A. Presence and fate of priority substances in domestic greywater treatment and reuse systems. Sci. Total Environ. 2010, 408(12):2444-2451.
15. EC (European Commission) Council directive 98/83/EC of 3 November 1998 on the quality of water intended for human consumption. Off. J. Eur. Comm. 1998, L:1998:330:0032:0054:EN: Accessed January 2014:. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do%3Furi%BCOJ.
16. EFSA (European Food Safety Authority) Scientific opinion on exploring options for providing advice about possible human health risks based on the concept of threshold of toxicological concern (TTC). EFSA J. 2012, 10(7):2750.
17. Eriksson E., Auffarth K., Eilerse A.M., Henze M., Ledin A. Household chemicals and personal care products as sources for xenobiotic organic compounds in grey wastewater. Water SA 2003, 29:135-146.
18. Eriksson E., Auffarth K.P.S., Henze M., Ledin A. Characteristics of grey wastewater. Urban Water 2002, 4(1):85-104.
19. Eriksson E., Andersen H.R., Madsen T.S., Ledin A. Greywater pollution variability and loadings. Ecol. Eng. 2009, 35:661-669.
20. Eriksson E., Baun A., Henze M., Ledin A. Environmental risk assessment of xenobiotic organic compounds in grey wastewater. Potential and Problems Related to Reuse of Water in Households 2002, PhD thesis, Technical University of Denmark, Available online at:, (accessed in July 2014). http://www.er.dtu.dk/publications.
21. Eriksson E., Baun A., Henze M., Ledin A. Phytotoxicity of grey wastewater evaluated by toxicity tests. Urban Water J. 2006, 3(1):13-20.
22. EU (European Union) Opinion on use of the threshold of toxicological concern (TTC) approach for human safety assessment of chemical substances with focus on cosmetics and consumer products. Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS), Scientific Committee on Health and Environmental Risks (SCHER) and Scientific Committee on Emerging and Newly Identified Health Risks (SCENIHR) 2012, SCCP/1171/08.
23. EU (European Union) Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and the Council of 23 October 2000 establishing a framework for community action in the field of water policy. J. Eur. Comm. 2000, 22.12.2000, L327/1-L327/73.
24. Garland J.L., Levine L.H., Yorio N.C., Adams J.L., Cook K.L. Graywater processing in recirculating hydroponic systems: phytotoxicity, surfactant degradation, and bacterial dynamics. Water Res. 2000, 31(12):3075-3086.
25. Gerrity D., Pecson B., Trussell R.S., Trussell R.R. Potable reuse treatment trains throughout the world. J. Water Supply: Res. Technol. AQUA 2013, 62(6):321-338.
26. Hernández Leal L., Vieno N., Temmink H., Zeeman G., Buisman C.J.N. Occurrence of xenobiotics in gray water and removal in three biological treatment systems. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2010, 44:6835-6842.
27. Hernández Leal L., Temmink H., Zeeman G., Buisman C. Removal of micropollutants from aerobically treated greywater via ozone and activated carbon. Water Res. 2011, 45:2887-2896.
28. Hernández Leal L. Removal of Micropollutants from Grey Water Combining Biological and Physical/chemical Processes 2010, Thesis, Wageningen University, The Netherlands.
29. Hu J.J., Aizawa T., Magara Y. Evaluation of adsorbability of pesticides in water on powdered activated carbon using octanol-water partitioning coefficient. Water Sci. Technol. 1997, 35(7):219-226.
30. Jefferson B., Laine A., Parsons S., Stephenson T., Judd S. Technologies for domestic wastewater recycling. Urban Water 2000, 1(4):285-292.
31. Johnson S.D. The economic case for "High performance buildings". Corp. Environ. Strategy 2000, 7(4):350-361.
32. Jurado-Sánchez B., Ballesteros E., Gallego M. Occurrence of carboxylic acids in different steps of two drinking-water treatment plants using different disinfectants. Water Res. 2014, 51:186-197.
33. Kasprzyk-Hordern B., Dinsdale R.M., Guwy A.J. The removal of pharmaceuticals, personal care products, endocrine disruptors and illicit drugs during wastewater treatment and its impact on the quality of receiving waters. Water Res. 2009, 43:363-380.
34. Kroes R., Renwick A.G., Cheeseman M., Kleiner J., Mangelsdorf I., Piersma A., Schilter B., Schlatter J., van Schothorst F., Vos J.G., Würtzen G. Structure-based thresholds of toxicological concern (TTC): guidance for application to substances present at low levels in the diet. Food Chem. Toxicol. 2004, 42:65-83.
35. Larsen N.J. Demonstrationsprojekt I Fuldskala for Rensning Af Gråt Spildevand Økologisk Byfornyelse Og Spildevandsrensning 2006, [No. 59, (In Danish)]. Accessed April 2014. http://www2.mst.dk/Udgiv/publikationer/2006/87-7052-149-2/html/default.htm.
36. Ledin A., Auffarth K., Eriksson E., Smith M., Eilersen A.-M., Mikkelsen P.S., Dalsgaard A., Henze M. Udvikling Af Metode Til Karakterisering Af Gra° T Spildevand. Økologisk Byfornyelse Og Spildevandsrensning 2006, [No. 58, (In Danish)]. Accessed April 2014. http://www.mst.dk/Udgivelser/Publikationer/2006/07/87-7052-116-6.htm.
37. Lee C.O., Howe K.J., Thomson B.M. Ozone and biofiltration as an alternative to reverse osmosis for removing PPCPs and micropollutants from treated wastewater. Water Res. 2012, 46:1005-1014.
38. Leeman W.R., Krul L., Houben G.F. Reevaluation of the Munro dataset to derive more specific TTC thresholds. Regul. Toxicol. Pharmacol. 2014, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.yrtph.2014.04.015.
39. Luo Y., Guoa W., Ngo H.H., Nghiemb L.D., Hai F.I., Zhang J., Liang S., Wang X.C. A review on the occurrence of micropollutants in the aquatic environment and their fate and removal during wastewater treatment. Sci. Total Environ. 2014, 473-474:619-641.
40. Maimon A., Tal A., Friedler E., Gross A. Safe on-site reuse of greywater for irrigation - a critical review of current guidelines. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2010, 44:3213-3220.
41. Mons M.N., Heringa M.B., van Genderen J., Puijker L.M., Brand W., van Leeuwen C.J., Stoks P., van der Hoek J.P., vander Kooij D. Use of the Threshold of Toxicological Concern (TTC) approach for deriving target values for drinking water contaminants. Water Res. 2013, 47:1666-1678.
42. Munro I.C., Ford R.A., Kennepohl E., Sprenger J.G. Correlation of structural class with No-Observed-Effect Levels: a proposal for establishing a threshold of concern. Food Chem. Toxicol. 1996, 34:829-867.
43. Munro I.C., Renwick A.G., Danielewska-Nikiel B. The threshold of toxicological concern (TTC) in risk assessment. Toxicol. Lett. 2008, 180:151-156.
44. Mwenge Kahinda J., Taigbenu A.E., Boroto J.R. Domestic rainwater harvesting to improve water supply in rural South Africa. Phys. Chem. Earth 2007, 32:1050-1057.
45. Nielsen M., Pettersen T. Genanvendelse Af Gråt Spildevand På Campingpladser - Fase 2 Og 3 Økologisk Byfornyelse Og Spildevandsrensning 2005, [No. 57. Report to the Danish EPA], (In Danish). Accessed April 2014. http://www2.mst.dk/Udgiv/publikationer/2005/87-7614-899-8/html/default.htm.
46. O'Toole J., Sinclair M., Malawaraarachchi M., Hamilton A., Barker S.F., Leder K. Microbial quality assessment of household greywater. Water Res. 2012, 46:4301-4313.
47. Oron G., Adel M., Agmon V., Friedler E., Halperin R., Leshem E., Weinberg D. Greywater use in Israel and worldwide: standards and prospects. Water Res. 2014, 58:92-101.
48. Pal A., Gin K.Y.H., Lin A.Y.C., Reinhard M. Impacts of emerging organic contaminants on freshwater resources: review of recent occurrences, sources, fate and effects. Sci. Total Environ. 2010, 408:6062-6069.
49. Palmquist H., Hanaeus J. Hazardous substances in separately collected grey- and blackwater from ordinary Swedish households. Sci. Total Environ. 2005, 348:151-163.
50. Palmquist H., Hanaeus J. Organic hazardous substances in graywater from Swedish households. J. Environ. Eng. 2006, 132:901-908.
51. Pinto U., Maheshwari B.L., Grewal H.S. Effects of greywater irrigation on plant growth, water use and soil properties. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 2010, 54:429-435.
52. Pisani P., Menge J.G. Direct potable reclamation in Windhoek: a critical review of the design philosophy of new Goreangab drinking water reclamation plant. Water Sci. Technol. Water Supply 2013, 13(2):214-226.
53. Organic Pollutans in the Water Cycle - Properties, Occurrence, Analysis and Environmental Relevance of Polar Compounds 2006, 350. Wiley VCH, Germany. T. Reemtsma, M. Jekel (Eds.).
54. Revitt M., Eriksson E., Donner E. The implications of household greywater treatment and reuse for municipal wastewater flows and micropollutant loads. Water Res. 2011, 45:1549-1560.
55. Ridder de D.J., Villacorte L., Verliefde A.R.D., Verberk J.Q.J.C., Heijman S.G.J., Amy G.L., van Dijk J.C. Modeling equilibrium adsorption of organic micropollutants onto activated carbon. Water Res. 2010, 44:3077-3086.
56. Rodriguez C., Van Buynder P., Devine B., Cook A., Weinstein P. Indirect potable reuse schemes: a sustainable water supply alternative. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2009, 8(6):1174-1209.
57. Rodriguez C., Weinstein P., Cook A., Devine B., Buynder P.V. A proposed approach for the assessment of chemicals in indirect potable reuse schemes. J. Toxicol. Environ. Health Part A Curr. Issues 2007, 70(19):1654-1663.
58. Rosal R., Rodríguez A., Perdigón-Melón J.A., Petre A., García-Calvo E., Gómez M.J., Agüera A., Fernández-Alba A.R. Occurrence of emerging pollutants in urban wastewater and their removal through biological treatment followed by ozonation. Water Res. 2010, 44:578-588.
59. Santala E., Uotila J., Zaitsev G., Alasiurua R., Tikka R., Tengvall J. Microbiological greywater treatment and recycling in an apartment building. AWT98 -Advanced Wastewater Treatment, Recycling and Reuse: Milan 14-16 September 1998 1998, 319-324.
60. Schriks M., Heringa M.B., Margaretha K., Voogt P., van Wezel A. Toxicological relevance of emerging contaminants for drinking water quality. Water Res. 2010, 44:461-476.
61. Sim W., Lee J., Shin S., Song K., Oh J. Assessment of fates of estrogens in wastewater and sludge from various types of wastewater treatment plants. Chemosphere 2011, 82:1448-1453.
62. Smith E., Bani-Melhem K. Grey water characterization and treatment for reuse in an arid environment. Water Sci. Technol. 2012, 66(1):72-78.
63. Staatsblad Besluit van 23 mei 2011, houdende bepalingen inzake de productie en distributie van drinkwater en de organisatie van de openbare drinkwatervoorziening (Drinkwaterbesluit) 2011, (accessed May 2014). http://wetten.overheid.nl/BWBR0030111/geldigheidsdatum_28-05-2014.
64. Surendran S., Wheatley A.D. Grey-water reclamation for non-potable re-use. Water Environ. 1998, 12:406-413.
65. Tadkaew N., Hai F.I., McDonald J.A., Khan S.J., Nghiema L.D. Removal of trace organics by MBR treatment: the role of molecular properties. Water Res. 2011, 45:2439-2451.
66. Tchobanoglous G., Leverenz H., Nellor M.H., Crook J. Direct Potable Reuse: a Path Forward 2011, WateReuse Research and WateReuse California, Washington, DC.
67. Temmink H., Hernández Leal L., Graaf M., Zeeman G., Buisman C. Personal care products and pharmaceuticals in new sanitation concepts. Conference Proceedings International Water Week Amsterdam "Presenting Integrated Solutions for a Changing World", 2011, Amsterdam, The Netherlands 2011.
68. Tluczkiewicz I., Buist H.E., Martin M.T., Mangelsdorf I., Escher S.E. Improvement of the cramer classification for oral exposure using the database TTC RepDose - a strategy description. Regul. Toxicol. Pharmacol. 2011, 61:340-350.
69. Travis M.J., Wiel-Shafran A., Weisbrod N., Adar E., Gross A. Greywater reuse for irrigation: effect on soil properties. Sci. Total Environ. 2010, 408:2501-2508.
70. Trinh T., van den Akker B., Coleman H.M., Stuetz R.M., Le-Clech P., Khan S.J. Removal of endocrine disrupting chemicals and microbial indicators by a decentralised membrane bioreactor for water reuse. J. Water Reuse Desalin. 2012, 2(2):67-73.
71. Turner R.D.R., Will J.D., Dawes L.A., Gardner E.A., Lyons D.J. Phosphorus as a limiting factor on sustainable greywater irrigation. Sci. Total Environ. 2013, 456-457:287-298.
72. URL 1. OECD Organization of Economic Co-operation and Development. OECD Quantitative Structure-activity Relationships Project. , accessed May 2014. http://www.oecd.org/chemicalsafety/risk-assessment/theoecdqsartoolbox.htm.
73. USEPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency) 2011-Edition of the Drinking Water Standards and Health Advisories 2011, EPA 820-R-11-002, Office of Water U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC.
74. USEPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency) Guidelines for Water Reuse 2012, US Environmental Protection Agency. Office of Wastewater Management, Washington, DC.
75. van der Hoek J.P., Tenorio J., Hellinga C., Lier J.van, Wijk A.van Green village delft - integration of an autarkic water supply in a local sustainable energy system. J. Water Reuse Desalin. 2014, 4(3):154-163.
76. Van Leeuwen C.J., Vermeire T. Risk Assessment of Chemicals 2007, Springer, 978-4020-6101-1. second ed.
77. van Wezel A.P., Jager T. Comparison of two screening level risk assessment approaches for six disinfectants and pharmaceuticals. Chemosphere 2002, 47:1113-1128.
78. Verlicchi P., Galletti A., Petrovic M., Barceló D. Hospital effluents as a source of emerging pollutants: an overview of micropollutants and sustainable treatment options. J. Hydrol. 2010, 389:416-428.
79. Westerhoff P., Yoon Y., Snyder S., Wert E. Fate of endocrine-disruptor, pharmaceutical, and personal care product chemicals during simulated drinking water treatment processes. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2005, 37(17):6649-6663.
80. WHO (World Health Organization) Guidelines for Drinking-water Quality 2011, World Health Organization.
81. WHO (World Health Organization) Evaluation of certain food additives and contaminants: fifty-seventh report of the joint FAO/WHO expert committee on food additives. Jt. FAO/WHO Expert Comm. Food Addit. 2002.
82. WHO-IPCS (World Health Organization - International Programme on Chemical Safety), Mono- and Disubstituted Methyltin, Butyltin, and Octyltin Compounds, (Concise International Chemical Assessment Document; 73), First Draft Prepared by Dobson S., Howe P.D. and Floyd P., 2006, World Health Organization.
83. Zuo J., Zhao Z.Y. Green building research-current status and future agenda: a review. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 2014, 30:271-281.